Thursday 26 September 2019

We Are On a Dangerous Road

Following the humiliating defeat in the Supreme Court on Tuesday, our Prime Minister had no choice but to cut his US trip short and return straight home to face a packed House of Commons. The spectacle millions of us witnessed was truly shocking and without doubt has demonstrated he is an unfit person to hold public office. 

In reckless behaviour that apes that of the current US President, Boris Johnson has clearly decided to follow the advice of his special advisor and career psychopath Dominic Cummings and set the People against Parliament. His appalling choice of language and dog-whistle rhetoric was specifically designed to incite anger and the ugliest forms of civil unrest within our population, knowing full well that it will be enthusiastically fuelled by the right-wing press and internet trolls. I don't think I've ever been so alarmed or appalled by any other politician in my lifetime and that includes Enoch Powell.

I suspect this Twitter thread from Jonathan Lis of British Influence will resonate with many this morning:-      

"I don’t think any of us who witnessed what happened in the House of Commons today, whether in person or on TV, will ever forget it. I think the genuine, inhuman, toxic horror of it will remain etched in my mind for the rest of my life. This sounds shrill or hysterical. It is not. Something died tonight that will never come back. Something of our decency, our love, our care for one another, not as political opponents but as human beings, trying to do what’s best for the people we care about.

This transcends Brexit. I don’t care if you voted leave or remain. It even, in fact, transcends prorogation. This was a festival of gleeful cruelty orchestrated by a political leader so removed from humanity that he was prepared to barrack and assail the friends of a murdered MP. Make no mistake. We’ve witnessed the first steps of a very deliberate revolution. This is the end of civility. End of playing by the rules. End of giving a fuck about anyone or anything beyond the nationalist prize you think will unlock the glory you couldn’t begin to deserve.

This is Trump’s Britain in ways we can only begin to compute. Language has no more limits. People have no more value. The aggressive, heartless contempt starts here and people have every right to be scared. These moments are as dangerous as any we’ve found in the last 80 years. We expect it from Johnson. The total unadulterated sociopathic malice was ‘priced in’ by his Tory enablers who denied what was in front of them and looked the other way. It’s the rest of the Tories who shame and devastate us. They saw, they listened, and finally they applauded.

If you value democracy, if you value civility, if you value basic fucking decency to your fellow human beings, now is the time to fight for it. We will get over prorogation. We will, somehow, get over Brexit. But unless we fight hard, fight now, we may not get over this."

--oo00oo--

This from Buzzfeed News:-

Female MPs Accused Boris Johnson Of Putting Their Lives In Danger After A Furious Brexit Debate In Parliament

Boris Johnson received widespread condemnation from across the House of Commons on Wednesday night and was accused of putting politicians’ lives in danger, after he claimed that delivering Brexit was “the best way to honour the memory” of the murdered MP Jo Cox.

Amid furious scenes in parliament — with some MPs walking out of the chamber in protest and others left in tears — the prime minister shocked the Commons by responding to a plea from Labour MP Paula Sherriff to moderate his language in the wake of death threats to politicians by saying “humbug”.

In astonishing exchanges across the House, Sherriff told Johnson: “We stand here under the shield of our departed friend with many of us in this place subject to death threats and abuse every single day. “And let me tell the prime minister that they often quote his words — “Surrender Act”, “betrayal”, “traitor” — and I for one am sick of it. We must moderate our language and it has to come from the prime minister first.”

To cries of “shame” from opposition MPs, Johnson replied: “I have never heard such humbug in all my life.”

Several Labour MPs left the Commons chamber in protest at Johnson’s description of legislation passed by MPs aimed at preventing a no-deal Brexit as a “Surrender Act”. Despite the criticism the prime minister doubled down on his language by calling it the “Capitulation Act” and the “Humiliation Act”.

In an emotive intervention, Labour’s Tracy Brabin, who took over as MP for Batley and Spen after Cox was killed a week before the EU referendum, asked Johnson: “As the woman who has taken over the seat left by our dear friend Jo Cox, can I ask him, in all honesty, as a human being, please, please will he going forward moderate his language so we will all feel secure going about our jobs.”

The PM replied that “the best way to honour the memory of Jo Cox and indeed the best way to bring this country together would be, I think, to get Brexit done”. Cox campaigned vocally for Remain before she was shot and stabbed to death by a far-right terrorist in the final days of the referendum campaign.

Johnson’s words were condemned by Cox’s husband Brendan on Twitter:
Feel a bit sick at Jo’s name being used in this way. The best way to honour Jo is for all of us (no matter our views) to stand up for what we believe in, passionately and with determination. But never to demonise the other side and always hold onto what we have in common.
In response to another question from the Labour MP Anna McMorrin about the abuse politicians were receiving on social media, Johnson warned that it would not stop until Brexit was delivered. If McMorrin thought “that storm on Twitter is going to abate, she’s got another thing coming,” the PM said.

Johnson was also criticised by Conservative MP Jeremy Lefroy, who said: “With freedom of speech comes responsibility, and sometimes that responsibility means not saying what one might like to say — words like surrender, betrayal, treason”.

Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson said: “The Prime Minister tonight proved he is totally unfit for office. To suggest the best way to honour Jo Cox, an MP who was murdered for what she believed in, was to pass his Brexit deal was sickening.”

As the debate raged in the Commons, BuzzFeed News spoke to several MPs who expressed their horror at the prime minister’s language. Sherriff revealed the level of abuse she and other colleagues have received in recent months: “I’ve had swastikas left outside my office. And I know now as a result of that, I might not be able to go home this weekend, stay in my own house. We’ve had MPs have to move addresses, stay in hotels, there’s a lot that goes on that we don’t necessarily talk about.”

Alison McGovern, a close friend of Cox, said: “It is devastating that our Prime Minister cannot realise the consequences of his words. They have real life effect. This isn't a game, and he should listen when people express grief and distress at what he says.”

Earlier this year, BuzzFeed News revealed the specialist police unit set up to investigate crimes against MPs has received 558 complaints since its inception and has seen a huge increase in reports in the last 12 months.

Scottish National Party MP Alison Thewliss called for Johnson to resign, saying his behaviour was: "Absolutely despicable. And what makes it worse is it's deliberate. He's doing this deliberately to wind people up, to get people out on the streets. It's irresponsible and it's dangerous, and it's got to stop. He's got to go."

Labour’s Rosie Duffield said: “He is inciting violence, implying to [women] MPs repeatedly that if we vote his way, we will all be safe. His answer to Anna McMorrin sounded like an outright threat. I had written a question about Kent but when he upset so many of my colleagues, I felt compelled to call him out. This is what real privilege looks like.”

12 comments:

  1. Johnson appears to me to be someone who's "blagged" their way through life as a method of achieving his own ends, never really understanding or caring that his actions or behaviour may have profound consequences for others. He has no moral compass, no integrity and I think no conscience. Given he's the leader of a political party increasingly being shaped by far right ideology, it is a very frightening era of political history in the making.
    However, aside from what was seen in Parliament yesterday, aside from the lies, deceit the manipulation of parliamentary process, Johnson leads a government that is quite prepared to throw the Northern Ireland peace process under a bus in pursuit of their own ideological utopia.
    For many now the 'troubles' are something that happened a long time ago, a vague memory of something that happened somewhere else, yesterday's news, and that's why the contentious 'backstop' is always only considered in terms of trade and the movement of goods between the EU and UK. The political tensions that exist in NI (and are fastly growing) get little mention or consideration.
    However the threat of the troubles returning in NI is very, very real if the UK exit the EU with no protection for the Good Friday Agreement. It is utterly shameful for any government to act with such ambivalence towards the prospect of a return to those terrible times.
    I would urge Parliamentarians to watch the fascinating BBC4 documentary series "The Troubles, a Secret History" and remind themselves just how devastating those troubles were.
    Politics should be about solutions and protections and substance, not just rethoric and bluster.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0008c4b

    'Getafix

    ReplyDelete
  2. https://www-bbc-co-uk.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/amp/uk-politics-49834726?amp_js_v=a2&amp_gsa=1#referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com&amp_tf=From%20%251%24s&ampshare=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.co.uk%2Fnews%2Famp%2Fuk-politics-49834726%23referrer%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fwww.google.com%26amp_tf%3DFrom%2520%25251%2524s

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Laura Kuenssberg BBC Political editor:-

      "I'm not sure that we can look the nation in the eye and say that was a good day."

      That's how a Conservative MP has described the torrid scenes in the Commons in the last 24 hours. Did the prime minister alight on the frustration of many members of the public who may feel that Parliament has simply failed to keep the promise it made to carry out their wishes expressed in the referendum - yes.

      Did Boris Johnson confirm his determination to push on with keeping the vow he made to take the UK out of the EU at the end of next month - yes. But did the scenes in Parliament suggest that his determination tips into a potentially destructive disdain - yes, to that too.

      Boris Johnson's decision has long been clear - he would seek to use everything within his grasp to stick to the Brexit deadline he set. If that meant knocking some plaster off the ceiling, rattling some cages in a fractious and perhaps failing Parliament, so be it.

      It is not as if, his allies argue, this Parliament has any measurable or reliable level of support from the public at large. Their calculation is that swathes of voters, whatever they chose in 2016, have simply had enough of MPs' inability to decide.

      After three years of political strife, following a clear, if narrow, result in the referendum, it is of course the case there are plenty of voters who blame politicians collectively for the mess we all witness.

      So, as Boris Johnson and Number 10 have been obviously doing since taking office, Parliament's failure is a political target.

      Whatever you think of that interpretation, for most of tonight's debate, this still relatively new prime minister was combatively, precisely on his chosen message. Accordingly, he decided to stir his benches with rancour rather than make any effort to soothe nerves on all sides, let alone show remorse for his defeat.

      Yet, even for a politician whose tactics include provocation, it is worth asking if he went too far. Outrage is a common currency these days, but MPs' jaws dropped as he ramped up the rhetoric in responses to questions - suggesting first that it was "humbug" for a Labour MP to demand he temper his language, to try to protect MPs' safety.

      Then, he went on to say that the appropriate legacy for the MP who was murdered during the referendum, Jo Cox, was for MPs to complete the Brexit process. No surprise that Labour MPs howled in protest, some left the Commons in disbelief. And there may be few Tory MPs willing, as the day goes on, to defend how far he went.

      The cabinet minister Nicky Morgan too, who expressed her concern on Twitter, is not the only Tory MP who was unhappy at what happened. There is pushback from the other side, of course.

      One minister said, in sadness rather than anger, that Labour was deploying "double standards" after several years of calling the Leave side "racists and criminals". There should be no surprise there was reaction like this.

      Others in government believe that we are seeing the raw conflict that had to play out, the fight Theresa May delayed but couldn't make disappear. And, rightly or wrongly, politics moves so fast in this era, it's impossible to tell if tonight's cries of horror in SW1 will fade fast to nothing, or indeed, how far they have reached beyond Westminster's bubble.

      Delete
    2. As ever, forgive but note the caveat that the situation is ever shifting and could transform within days. For now, though, it is almost impossible to imagine this group of politicians being able to agree on much. The attitude Boris Johnson displayed has made the divisions more stark.

      And in the unlikely event this prime minister strikes a deal, it seems harder in this moment to imagine that he'd have more than a handful of Labour MPs on side.

      And if you were hoping that, eventually, our politicians were moving towards a way of working together, Parliament tonight was a place of fear and loathing, not a place of debate and discussion that could provide a solution for us all.

      Delete
    3. Nick Boles MP

      @NickBoles
      I had planned to abstain on today’s motion for a short recess during the Conservative Party conference. I’m not sure if it’s the effect he intended but after the PM’s behaviour yesterday I think it is crucial that he be held to account at PMQs next Wed. So I will vote against.

      Delete
    4. MPs have just voted and Parliament will NOT be adjourned for the Tory party conference.

      Delete
  3. The Sun website 4:20pm:-

    A MAN has been arrested for trying to break into the office of Labour MP Jess Phillips while screaming “fascist”. Ms Phillips said terrified staff were forced to lock themselves into constituency base in Birmingham this afternoon.

    Ms Phillips, who represents Birmingham Yardley, said the culprit was also “slapping the windows” as he tried to force his way into the building, LBC reports. The attack comes after the Ms Phillips ordered Boris Johnson to apologise for comments he made about murdered MP Jo Cox during angry clashes in the House of Commons last night. Ms Philips also told the chamber how she received regular death threats from members of the public.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What the Prime Minister - presumably does not realise in the way that experienced probation and social workers probably do, is that whilst he might be able to turn up the vocal attack, yet not become physically violent - there are plenty of others amongst our clientele and prospective clientele - who lack a capacity for discernment & reflection & do get fired up by this violent language & thus may even do actual damage & cause real physical fear- and possibly also when apprehended experience considerable sanctions in courts whilst some in parliament continue mouthing their rancour and being driven home in ministerial cars - avoiding the streets where ordinary folk gather.

      Delete
  4. Sky news.

    Labour's Jess Phillips has said a man has been arrested at her constituency office after "smacking the windows" and "shouting fascist".

    The Birmingham Yardley MP said her staff had to be locked into the office during the incident, but are OK.

    Ms Phillips said she was "not going to leap to blame Boris Johnson" but added that "we all need to be better" and the prime minister needs to "choose instead of trying to divide... to lead".

    She also said that the phones in her London office have had to be temporarily disconnected as too many people were calling up and shouting "betrayal" and "traitor".

    It comes amid anger at Mr Johnson after he said that the "best way" to honour murdered MP Jo Cox was to "get Brexit done".

    Ms Phillips, who criticised the PM's comments in the Commons, tweeted on Wednesday: "I'm not scared of an election, I am scared I might be hurt or killed".

    She also said she had received an "anonymous letter" to her constituency office which read: "It was rather prophetic that Boris Johnson should say: 'I would rather be found dead in a ditch.'

    "That is what will happen to those who do not deliver Brexit."

    Ms Phillips said: "@10DowningStreet might think we are "humbugs" about his words but they are literally being used in death threats against me."



    ReplyDelete
  5. https://amp-theguardian-com.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/amp.theguardian.com/politics/live/2019/sep/26/boris-johnsons-brexit-rhetoric-condemned-as-mps-tell-of-death-threats-politics-live?amp_js_v=a2&amp_gsa=1&usqp=mq331AQCKAE%3D#aoh=15695285135651&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com&amp_tf=From%20%251%24s&ampshare=https%3A%2F%2Famp.theguardian.com%2Fpolitics%2Flive%2F2019%2Fsep%2F26%2Fboris-johnsons-brexit-rhetoric-condemned-as-mps-tell-of-death-threats-politics-live%23aoh%3D15695285135651%26referrer%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fwww.google.com%26amp_tf%3DFrom%2520%25251%2524s

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Boris Johnson may use the privy council to bypass the legal requirement on him to seek a three-month Brexit delay if he cannot get a deal, the former prime minister John Major has suggested.

      In a speech to the Centre for European Reform thinktank this evening, Major plans to say:

      My fear is that the government will seek to bypass statute law, by passing an order of council to suspend the [Benn] Act until after 31 October.

      It is important to note that an order of council can be passed by privy councillors – that is government ministers – without involving HM the Queen.

      I should warn the prime minister that – if this route is taken – it will be in flagrant defiance of parliament and utterly disrespectful to the supreme court.

      It would be a piece of political chicanery that no one should ever forgive or forget.

      Major is referring to the difference between an order in council, which needs the approval of the monarch, and an order of council, which does not.

      Johnson has repeatedly made the apparently contradictory claims that he will, at once, abide by the law and refuse to ask for a delay.

      Delete
  6. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0008p3n

    Try ~ 49 mins in onwards...

    At around 52:20 regarding the threats made towards Anna Soubry: - "I don't think they were proper death threats, its just people letting off steam"

    For me, that's what Johnson & co are after with their vile Trumpian strategy - to minimise the real risks & dangers, to belittle those who feel threatened, to dilute reality.

    Some will remember the outpourings of rage & despair at Johnny Rotten & The Sex Pistols on Bill Grundy in 1976 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LtHPhVhJ7Rs

    Now listen to Alexei Sayle on R4 at 6.30pm - https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0008p3v

    You'll lose count of the number of 'twats', 'bastards' etc.

    You're all trained aren't you? Remember the various theories about offending behaviour, e.g. pushing the boundaries, stepping over the line, escalating behaviour?

    Parliament has changed & it can't go back.

    Meanwhile Johnson is thriving - even his sister doesn't recognise the man at the dispatch box (R4 World At One today, about 17 mins in - https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0008p36

    ReplyDelete