Showing posts with label RAR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label RAR. Show all posts

Sunday, 12 September 2021

Probation House Style

Probation under civil service control absolutely loves acronyms and there's a very particular management house style I have the greatest difficulty taking seriously and reconciling with the real world. Take for example the latest Insight blog :-
 
Delivering Quality Interventions in Probation: The Rehabilitation Activity Requirement (RAR)

Jason Morris and Laura Baverstock work as Senior Policy Managers within the Service Design Team in the Probation Reform Programme (PRP). In this blog, they explain the work that has been underway to uphold key commitments to increasing the availability of quality RAR interventions in Probation; make best use of evidence and evaluation; and, preserve Community Rehabilitation Company (CRC) innovation with a collaborative approach to service design.

On 26th June 2021, 21 Community Rehabilitation Companies (CRCs) were renationalised and unified with the National Probation Service (NPS) to form a new Probation Service for England and Wales. Since then, the Probation Reform Programme (PRP) has continued its work to implement probation’s Target Operating Model (TOM). The TOM provides a blueprint of how the new Probation Service will operate. As part of this effort, we’ve been working to equip Probation Practitioners and Regional Interventions Teams with quality interventions that enable the delivery of Rehabilitation Activity Requirements (RARs).

The Rehabilitation Activity Requirement

RARs form part of a Community Order or Suspended Sentence Order to set the amount and type of rehabilitation activity for people on probation. They were introduced in the Offender Rehabilitation Act (2014), as a distinct sentencing option to the ‘programme requirement’ (fulfilled through Accredited Programme completion). Prior to reunification hundreds of identifiable RAR interventions were available across the CRCs alongside many other bespoke interventions. Over recent years, room for improvement has been identified in the delivery of RARs both from the academic community and Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP).

The TOM sets out how the Probation Service will deliver RARs. A large amount of RAR activity will be commissioned from partner organisations through “Commissioned Rehabilitative Services”. The main vehicle for Probation Service-delivered RARs will be in the form of Structured Interventions and Probation Practitioner Toolkits (also referred to below simply as "toolkits"). Structured Interventions provide a set of exercises delivered primarily to groups by interventions facilitators in a set sequence. Toolkits are comprised of similar material delivered by the Probation Practitioner on a one-to-one basis as part of supervision.

Our task now is to ensure that the TOM is fully implemented to ensure consistency in the availability and quality of Structured Interventions and toolkits. This will improve confidence amongst stakeholders (including the courts) around how the Probation Service delivers RARs.

Approved Suites: Structured Interventions and Probation Practitioner Toolkits

The national Effective Interventions Panel (EIP) played a key role in the lead up to reunification, by enabling RAR interventions to be appraised against seven core principles set out by the Correctional Services Accreditation Advice Panel (principles that are distinct from those required for Accredited Programmes).

The Seven Principles used within the EIP to assess Structured Interventions and toolkits are as follows:

1. Alignment with an evidence base
2. Credible rationale for how, why and for whom the intervention will work
3. A structure that allows replication
4. A selection process that targets the intervention appropriately
5. To equip people with useful skills and ensure that no one will be disadvantaged or harmed
6. Quality assurance to ensure it is delivered as designed.
7. A commitment to research and evaluation

The EIP is made up of experts from across HMPPS. Panel sessions involve a democratic scoring process, which results in recommendations and conclusions that are fed back to developers.

HMPPS Contract Management and the PRP Service Design Team identified interventions from CRC rate cards to continue as Structured Interventions in the unified Probation Service “post contract”. In addition, the EIP sat eight times between October 2020 and January 2021 to appraise 45 Structured interventions. A total of 37 were ear marked for incorporation into an Approved Suite of Structured Interventions that would come into effect by April 2022.

The EIP also sat 10 times to appraise Probation Practitioner Toolkits between April and May 2021. During these toolkit EIP sessions, a total of 24 sets of materials were appraised and seven toolkits were provisionally approved for inclusion in an 'Approved Suite of Probation Practitioner Toolkits'.

EIP decisions were then ratified through a further governance process which approved development work to finalise the approved suites of toolkits and Structured Interventions. The overarching ambition for Probation Practitioner Toolkits was to create greater alignment across the suite to increase their potential to work as wraparound support for other interventions. In addition, several overlapping EIP-approved Structured Interventions were identified for amalgamation into single offers via workgroups comprised of staff from Regional Interventions Teams. A total of 12 Structured Interventions would account for all Structured Intervention delivery from April 2022 onwards.

The Structured Intervention workgroups offer a key opportunity to refine innovation in a stepwise fashion to Structured Interventions:

- fully adhere to EIP principles

- build on CRC innovation

- involve people on probation as co-creators

- integrate sentence management support through alignment with toolkits

Clinical and strategic oversight for Structured Interventions and toolkits will continue to be provided by the national EIP process. This governance will help establish toolkits as the vehicle for RAR delivery within the role of the Probation Practitioner; a step that aims to help put the supervisory relationship back at the heart of probation work. Furthermore, continued EIP governance will help us to work towards greater content alignment between supervision and in-house interventions (such as Structured Interventions and Accredited Programmes). This has the potential to enable interventions to combine more holistically, making the experience of probation more cohesive for people accessing a range of probation services.

Tuesday, 9 February 2021

Grand Plans

What with morale being so low and us all distracted and worn down by Covid concerns, I guess we should have been paying a bit more attention to the government's sentencing White Paper published last September. We covered Napo's initial response here we raised an eyebrow at the aim for a world class service here and other cliche's here, but maybe a close look at the whole probation chapter would be wise:- 

A Smarter Approach to Sentencing

Strengthening the way that offenders are supervised in the community requires a stronger, world-class probation service – one that keeps the public safe through effective community sentences which combine punishment with tailored programmes and treatment requirements to address specific criminogenic needs. With the support of skilled practitioners, a successful period of probation supervision can challenge and motivate offenders to address the causes of their offending. Through our reform programme, our aim is for probation practitioners to have the time, support and tools to develop productive relationships with those they supervise, to deliver interventions directly, and to place offenders with other rehabilitative services.

3. Empowering Probation 

Chapter Summary 

The probation service has for too long operated in the shadows and with the work of its dedicated professionals not sufficiently valued or understood. We want this to change. Probation services deliver more than merely the supervision of offenders. With the support of skilled practitioners, a successful period of probation supervision will see offenders challenged and motivated to address the causes of their offending: supported to find stable accommodation and employment, and to make a sustained move away from relationships, associations or addictions that will lead to reoffending. 

Effective supervision is at the heart of our plans to improve probation services. We want probation practitioners to have the time, support and tools to develop effective relationships with those they supervise, to deliver effective interventions directly, and to place offenders with other rehabilitative services. We will do this through investment and reforms to the way that probation services are delivered, alongside improvements to the powers available to probation practitioners. 

Partnership working: We want to ensure that there is improved strategic delivery and local partnership working. A refreshed joint policing and probation strategy for IOM will be published by the end of 2020. 

Improving the service to victims and the wider community: Community sentences should also be seen to be served in the community and should be actively benefiting the community within which they are being served. We want to make sure that, in particular, there is a greater community voice in determining how Unpaid Work schemes should be focussed to bring about the most benefit. 

Increasing the powers of probation practitioners: We plan to consider the strong arguments for varying the responsibilities and powers available to probation practitioners to enable them to act swiftly and responsively on their professional judgement, to make sure we have a strong and responsive probation service that is delivering reductions in reoffending. 

Introduction

189  Strengthening the way that offenders are supervised in the community requires a stronger, world-class probation service – one that keeps the public safe through the effective supervision of offenders in the community, by delivering programmes and other interventions to address criminogenic needs, and by bringing together a wide range of statutory agencies and private and voluntary organisations to provide rehabilitation and support. 

190  In strengthening probation we want to ensure that services are effective and give confidence to judges, magistrates and the public, and that are structured in a way that supports local partnership working and is responsive to the needs of local areas.

Unifying probation supervision 

191  In May 2019, we announced that when Community Rehabilitation Company (CRC) contracts came to an end, all sentence management responsibilities for low-, medium-, and high-risk offenders would be held by the National Probation Service (NPS). This means that from June 2021, the NPS will be responsible for the effective delivery of community sentences, licences and other forms of post-sentence management by ensuring offenders are properly supervised, requirements are coordinated and delivered, risks are managed and enforcement action taken after any breach, including recall to custody. This will sit alongside and complement the existing NPS responsibility for providing advice to courts ahead of sentencing on the most suitable type of sentence for the offender. NPS Wales unified their offender management services in December 2019, and the learning from that process is helping to shape the future design for England. In March 2020 we published a detailed vision for the probation structures in the Draft Target Operating Model for the Future of Probation Services. 

192  In June 2020 we announced changes in this model in response to the experience of COVID-19. Under our revised approach to probation reform, Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes and Structured Interventions will no longer be contracted out but will instead be delivered by the NPS directly. We consider that bringing these services into the NPS in addition to sentence management will put us in the best possible position to respond to any further disruption caused by COVID-19 and enable a smoother recovery out of exceptional delivery arrangements we have had to put in place. Advice to court will continue to be a core duty of the NPS with increased focus on quality of assessment and pre-sentence reports. The NPS will build on the existing enhanced through the gate services with a new resettlement model which improves links with prisons, enhances pre-release planning by probation practitioners and provides increased focus on short term sentences. 

193  The revised model puts us in the best place to be able to deliver these ambitions. It will facilitate more strategic and integrated probation supervision through fostering close collaboration with strategic partners including local courts and Police and Crime Commissioners.

194  Our approach for all services for Day 1 of the new model will be to move existing CRC staff and delivery models into the NPS with minimal disruption with ongoing work thereafter to embed and improve service delivery. The transition to a level of service as envisaged by the Draft Target Operating Model for probation is likely to take time given the backlogs to Unpaid Work and Accredited Programmes created by exceptional delivery arrangements as well as a likely spike in court orders once jury trials resume. This would be the case regardless of which organisation delivery sat with, but we consider that bringing this work in-house gives us greater flexibility to deal with this. 

Structural and organisational changes to probation 

The National Probation Service (NPS) will be responsible for managing all offenders on a community order or licence following their release from prison in England and Wales. 

The NPS will continue to deliver those services reserved to the public sector such as advice to court. From June 2021, the NPS will also deliver offenders’ Unpaid Work and behavioural change programmes in England and Wales. 

The voluntary and private sectors will play an enhanced role in the probation system, running services such as education, employment, and accommodation commissioned through the Probation Services Dynamic Framework. 

There will be 12 probation areas across England and Wales, introducing 11 new probation areas in England, with existing arrangements remaining unchanged in Wales. 

In England, each area will be overseen by a new dedicated regional director who will provide strategic leadership and be responsible for the overall delivery and commissioning of probation services. 

The regional directors, along with the NPS Director in Wales, will work closely to ensure an effective, unified approach from the pre-sentence stage in court through to supervision in the community. 

We will take action to strengthen the standing of the probation workforce and also make changes that support continuous professional development. 

Benefits of the future model for probation 

195  In developing the future model for probation, we want to ensure that services are effective and provided in a way that judges, magistrates and the public have confidence in, and are structured in a way that supports local partnership working and is responsive to the needs of local areas. 

196  Unifying sentence management under the NPS should have a positive impact on the judiciary’s faith in probation’s ability to deliver, as we know sentencers have expressed greater confidence in the NPS, with whom they have a more direct relationship than CRCs. There will be a single organisation responsible for providing advice to court and delivering the sentence, and we anticipate that this will result in benefits in the preparation of pre-sentence reports (PSRs). 

197  Additionally, it will mean greater central control over the quality of services and enable greater clarity around minimum standards. It will also mean that there will be one probation voice in local partnership arrangements. 

198  The creation of a Dynamic Framework for resettlement and rehabilitative interventions will enable more local commissioning and support the direct participation of smaller voluntary sector and specialist organisations in the delivery of these interventions, something that has not been consistently achieved under the current model. This will help services to be more locally responsive and provide more ready access to services that better address individual needs, particularly vulnerable offenders and those with complex needs. 

Partnership working 

199  Across the system, we want to ensure that there is improved strategic delivery and local partnership working. In creating 11 new probation regions across England, alongside the existing area in Wales, we have sought to achieve the right balance between the potential for efficiencies across the probation system and arrangements that are closer to other criminal justice system structures and which can facilitate partnership working.

200  In England, each of the NPS divisions will be overseen by a Regional Probation Director who will provide strategic leadership and be responsible for the overall delivery and commissioning of probation services. In Wales, the Executive Director for HMPPS already has responsibility for all probation services and prisons, and this will remain unchanged. These leaders will have clear responsibility for strengthening engagement in local and regional partnerships. 

201  This will ensure there is greater transparency around probation performance, that services are responsive to local priorities, and opportunities are taken to co-commission those services that are key to reducing reoffending with partners such as Police and Crime Commissioners (PCCs), local authorities and health commissioners. 

202  We want to support probation providers to work with local partners to develop innovative services that respond to offenders’ needs. There are already schemes in some areas, and in future we would like to see arrangements develop in other areas. The plans set out in our response to the probation consultation for Regional Directors to have funding reserved for innovative, cross-cutting approaches, will support this.

203  We also want to re-focus how law enforcement partners work together to supervise offenders in the community, through strategic arrangements such as Integrated Offender Management (IOM). IOM enables the police and probation to jointly provide an enhanced supervision of priority offenders identified in local areas in line with the government’s crime reduction and reducing reoffending plans. We will publish a refreshed joint policing and probation strategy for IOM by the end of 2020. 

204  Community sentences should also be seen to be served in the community and should be actively benefiting the community within which they are being served. We want to make sure that, in particular, there is a greater community voice in determining how Unpaid Work schemes should be focussed to bring about the most benefit. This is why we are introducing a statutory duty for probation to consult a range of voices when designing and delivering Unpaid Work placements and schemes. Further detail on the design of Unpaid Work under the new model for probation is available in the ‘Supervising Offenders in the Community’ chapter of this paper. 

Probation Workforce Programme 

205  In January 2020, the Probation Workforce Programme was launched to ensure the wider changes happening in probation go hand-in-hand with positive changes for our workforce. Our staff are integral to the successful operation of the NPS model, and we need to ensure we have a motivated and professional workforce that can deliver for the probation service.

206  The Workforce Programme will seek to address the significant shortfall of trained probation officers in the system by focusing on four key workstreams: capacity and efficiency, capability, pay rewards and policies, and infrastructure. This will ultimately ensure that we have the right number of people with the right capabilities and appropriate support to deliver a strong and effective service both now and in the future. The workforce strategy was launched in July 2020 and we have already started recruiting new probation staff. This strategy set out our commitment to increase recruitment of probation staff this year and have a minimum of 1000 new probation practitioners in training by January 2021. Our ambition is to make sure probation officers have manageable and varied caseloads and are encouraged specialisms. As part of this work, we will explore options to improve the professionalisation of the probation officer and probation support officer role. 

Trusting probation staff to take action 

207  We want to make sure that probation practitioners have the necessary powers to be able to properly supervise offenders in the community, in particular, that they are able to act quickly and responsively to behaviour that needs to be addressed without necessarily needing to return to the courts. 

208  A core function of the probation service is to supervise offenders in the community. That is, to require an offender to attend an appointment so the probation practitioner responsible for their sentence can identify existing or emerging needs and risks, and either provide interventions directly or refer them to other organisations. For offenders released from custody, this kind of supervision is built into the duration of their licence. 

209  In contrast, not all Community Orders or Suspended Sentence Orders provide for this general supervision power for the length of the order. Unless an Order contains a Rehabilitation Activity Requirement (RAR), legislation as currently framed explicitly provides for supervision only in connection with the requirements imposed by the order. While offenders are under a general duty to keep in touch with their Responsible Officer in accordance with such instructions they may be given from time to time, the legislation does not clarify what ‘keeping in touch’ means and if it includes attending probation supervision appointments. 

210  In practice, this means that a probation practitioner who may wish to supervise offenders who have completed all of their requirements (but whose Order has not expired), do not currently have legislative cover to do so unless the Order contains a RAR. Also, practitioners who may wish to supervise offenders for reasons unconnected to the requirements of the Order do not currently have legislative cover to do so. 

211  We believe there is an important role for the Court in setting out the requirement(s) an offender should undertake as part of their community order at the point of sentencing. And the priority of the probation service must always be to support the purpose of the Order and the administration of justice. However, we also believe there is merit in probation staff having sufficient flexibility within their prescribed duties and responsibilities to respond to the unique journey of each offender as they progress through their sentence. Supervision unconnected to requirements, carried out after the completion of requirements, may be warranted for two reasons. First, the Responsible Officer may feel that supervision is necessary to address issues that either arise post-sentencing and are not strictly related to the original requirements, or after requirements are complete and remain outstanding. Second, the Responsible Officer may also feel supervision is necessary if there is reason to believe that the offender’s level of risk to the public has increased. 

212  We will therefore legislate to give probation practitioners greater flexibility to take appropriate action where they have concerns about an offender’s rehabilitative needs or risk to the public. In practice, this would empower Responsible Officers to compel offenders to attend supervision appointments and, where appropriate, participate in rehabilitative activities for the length of a Community Order or Suspended Sentence (either through supervision sessions or onwards referral to other organisations). 

213  Alongside this change, we plan to consider the arguments for varying the responsibilities and powers available to probation practitioners to enable them to act swiftly and responsively on their professional judgement. We want to take the opportunity provided by the Probation Reform programme to bring about greater change. 

214  It is currently possible for courts to bring community sentences to a conclusion before the original end date if the individual has sufficiently fulfilled the order’s requirements. Where offenders breach their order, there is a process where Responsible Officers can give warnings before taking enforcement proposals to court. 

215  We recognise that swift breach action where individuals fail to comply with a requirement of the court’s order is central in securing public confidence in community sentences, as well as having the potential to further influence and change offender behaviour. Effective use of community sentences relies on the relationship between the probation practitioner and the offender; we therefore need to ensure that probation has the right mechanisms, tools and powers to support and enhance this relationship. 

216  Other jurisdictions will mark progress made by offenders with events recognising the positive changes they have made. In England and Wales, we have seen examples of offender achievements being recognised with letters or certificates. For individuals who have experienced difficult relationships with the state, for example through the education system or the care system, it may be the first time anyone in authority has ever acknowledged progress. 

217  In view of this, as well as the potential to harness the improvements to the probation service brought about by reform, we will further explore the options and their implications. There is a spectrum through which we could consider giving probation practitioners a range of more immediate options before taking an order back to court: 

• ‘Administrative’ variation of existing requirements to respond to an offender’s changes in circumstances. We are pursuing this policy via the powers to vary timings of curfews, outlined in this paper. 

• Flexible enforcement of court-imposed requirements, that would allow the Responsible Officer to adjust and vary these requirements to encourage and influence changes in offender behaviour. Under this model, we would consider whether the sentencer (at sentencing) should specify the minimum and maximum number of hours to be completed at the discretion of the offender manager.

• Imposition of new requirements for non-compliance/breach. 

218  Options under this spectrum could mark a distinct change in the way in which probation supervise offenders in the community. We believe that enhanced powers could afford probation staff greater flexibility to respond to offenders’ needs in a way that reflects their professionalism and expertise. 

219  However, within this policy, it is vital that the flexibility afforded to probation is consistent with the court’s original sentence. Due to the importance of the relationship between the courts and probation, we will explore these options with relevant key stakeholders to decide on the most appropriate and effective powers to potentially introduce. 

Conclusion 

220  In order for community supervision to work effectively, it needs to be accompanied by a robust probation service, to fulfil the key aims of protecting the public while also providing support for offenders who wish to turn their lives around. 

221  This chapter has reiterated plans for the National Probation Service. By strengthening probation in this way, we want to ensure that services are effective for those who require them and give the public confidence in the system.

Tuesday, 23 June 2020

Latest On TOM

HMPPS have just published an update to the Draft Target Operating Model for probation services in England and Wales and as you peruse the following highlights, have in mind the following observation from the Prison Reform Trust:-
"The role of central government in probation in recent years has been entirely destructive. Whether that continues to be the case will depend on whether the ministry has the humility and good sense to devolve power to a local level. That rarely comes naturally to central governments of any persuasion. It’s too early to tell how this one will behave.”
3. Further detail on changes 

NPS delivery of Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes and Structures Interventions 

3.1. Under our revised approach to probation reform, Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes and Structured Interventions will no longer be contracted out to Probation Delivery Partners but will instead be delivered by the NPS directly. We consider that bringing these services into the NPS will put us in the best possible position to respond to any further disruption caused by COVID-19 and enable a smoother recovery out of exceptional delivery arrangements we have had to put in place. These services have been delivered by probation services in the past and as such, we have confidence in our ability to deliver these again. 

3.2. Our approach for all these services for Day 1 will be to move existing CRC staff and delivery models into the NPS with the minimum disruption with ongoing work thereafter to embed and improve service delivery. The transition to a level of service as envisaged by the draft Target Operating Model is likely to take time given the backlogs to Unpaid Work and Accredited Programme created by exceptional delivery arrangements as well as a likely spike in court orders once jury trials resume. This would be the case regardless of which organisation delivery sat with but we consider that bringing this work in-house gives us greater flexibility to deal with this. 

Unpaid Work 

3.3. The design intentions for Unpaid Work are primarily to address the issues with current delivery and to improve quality and sentencer confidence. Effective Unpaid Work placements are crucial in contributing to the Government’s manifesto commitment to toughen community sentences. 

3.4. We plan to achieve this through a focus on the following areas: 
  • Quality of assessments; 
  • Interface with Sentence Management; 
  • Sufficient quality placements with increased focus on education, training and employment (ETE); 
  • Local engagement and delivery; 
  • Effective administration and recording.
3.5. As detailed in the draft Target Operating Model, the current requirement to commence work within 7 business days does not provide sufficient time to assess and place appropriately and allowing 10 business days for the completion of the Unpaid Work assessment form will enable a full risk and needs assessment. We had envisaged that this would then be shared with the Probation Delivery Partner to match to an appropriate placement and that within 10 days, the Probation Delivery Partner would deliver a full Unpaid Work induction and instruction to attend a first work session. 

3.6. As the revised model removes the interface between the NPS and Unpaid Work, it provides a new benefit for single requirement orders compared to the previous model as these can continue to be managed by Unpaid Work teams. This will facilitate efficient delivery of orders primarily focussed on ensuring Unpaid Work hours are completed and the removal of the interface will speed up the process, enabling the starts timescale to be reduced from 20 to 15 business days. The Unpaid Work assessment form completed by the Probation Practitioner will be incorporated into OASys and so there is no proposed change to the completion of this. 

3.7. It remains a priority to increase the level and scope of work placements available to meet the requirements of the Court. Female service users will be offered a choice not to be placed in all male work environments and appropriate placements will be sought in the local community to meet diverse needs. Sufficient placements and some flexibility alongside other strategies will avoid short notice cancellation of work placements. It will be the responsibility of the Unpaid Work team to review all active cases at the 6 and 9-month stages of the Unpaid Work requirement to ensure all hours are completed within the 12-month period prescribed by the Court and to flag with Probation Practitioners where appropriate action is needed. 

3.8. Whilst the main pathway to address ETE needs remains with the Rehabilitation Activity Requirement as a specific element of the sentence, considerable potential remains within the Unpaid Work requirement for on the job training and skills development that can support future employment opportunities. A feature that defines a ‘good quality’ placement is one that can utilise the 20% allowance for ETE activities for those eligible and as outlined in the draft Target Operating Model we plan a renewed focus on placements providing ETE. Under the revised model we intend to review ETE provision that CRCs have in place currently and how we might continue effective arrangements as well as seeking additional opportunities to secure improved ETE. 

3.9. We will retain our commitment to limit travel time to Unpaid Work placements to a maximum of 90 minutes each way, of which a maximum of 60 minutes each way can be spent under supervision and credited against the sentence of the Court. CRCs are not always achieving this currently so further investment will be required in Placement Coordinators to source placements locally, undertaking local engagement and ensuring sufficient transport solutions. There are currently systems in place so that local people and community organisations can identify work projects for Unpaid Work teams to complete and these will need to be strengthened under the revised model, requiring Unpaid Work teams to actively seek the views of local people and organisations when adopting new Unpaid Work projects.

3.10. We recognise that we will also need to review logistics of Unpaid Work delivery including consideration of CRC estates and assets that we might need to meet locality requirements and how we capture relevant data on placements and scheduling from CRC systems and record this going forward. We will also need to consider how we manage administrative support for which there is not a uniform model under CRC contracts. 

Accredited Programmes and Structured Interventions 

3.11. Accredited Programmes are the intervention of choice for HMPPS, as they are supported by a robust evidence base. The NPS currently deliver specific Accredited Programmes (e.g. for sex offenders) which will ease the transfer of other Accredited Programmes to the NPS as there is already expertise in this area and we anticipate that there will be eligible staff for transfer with similar expertise. By bringing these under a single organisation we will also benefit from synergies in delivery of these programmes. 

3.12. Eligibility and suitability checks will continue to be undertaken by the NPS to ensure those meeting the criteria get the opportunity to attend an Accredited Programme. Delivery of the Thinking Skills Programme (TSP) and Building Better Relationships (BBR) Programme in all regions can be achieved by the NPS. In the short term other Accredited Programmes addressing needs such as Resolve and Building Skills for Recovery which are currently being delivered in some locations can continue, subject to review of the delivery suite by the Regional Probation Director to ensure local needs are met. Design intentions to meet equality requirements and timely completions can also be met through our revised approach and will be supported by the recently approved flexible delivery model, which allows for remote and one to one delivery to meet specific needs. 

3.13. We stated in the draft Target Operating Model that the maximum time that an individual would be expected to travel to attend an Accredited Programme or Structured Intervention would be 90 minutes each way. To achieve this under the revised model we will need to secure suitable local accommodation that meets Correctional Services Accreditation and Advice Panel requirements. 

3.14. Further scoping of the CRC and NPS estates is required to understand whether this can be met through existing provisions as well as a review of those arrangements put in place by CRCs that will need to continue (e.g. providing drivers to transport individuals to interventions because of public transport challenges). As with Unpaid Work, we will also need to ensure we have appropriate systems and processes in place to provide a record of the delivery of interventions which can be quality assured. 

Staff transfers and regional structures 

3.15. - 3.16. We expect that CRC staff who deliver Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes and Rehabilitation Activity Requirements in the three need areas which will become Structured Interventions will be assigned to transfer to the NPS, which will mean many more staff coming into the NPS than under the previous model. There will be some staff in mixed roles which are part Sentence Management and part interventions where decisions on role allocation will need to be made.

3.17. To oversee and deliver this work we will need to have dedicated teams within the regional structure. Further work is required to determine roles and structures within these but we anticipate that there will be a new regional senior leadership role to oversee teams focused on Unpaid Work and Interventions. For Unpaid Work, we will need to consider arrangements for delivery of ETE and peer mentors, which in some instances may be sub-contracted under current CRC contracts. Similarly, for the delivery of the BBR programme, we will need to consider arrangements for the Partner Link Worker role which some CRCs currently sub-contract. Revised approach to Dynamic Framework 

3.18. To support preparation of procurement activity, our development of the Dynamic Framework design had progressed since publication of the draft Target Operating Model. Under the previous model we had planned to let over 200 contracts at PCC level for rehabilitation and resettlement support for Day 1 in the following need areas: 
  • Accommodation; 
  • Education, Training & Employment and Finance, Benefits & Debt; 
  • Dependency and recovery; 
  • Personal wellbeing; 
  • Women’s services; 
  • Services for young adults in Wales. 
3.19. Delivery expertise of much rehabilitation and resettlement support sits in the market as these services have not routinely been delivered by probation in the past. We consider that the Dynamic Framework continues to be the most appropriate mechanism to secure this. This is because it establishes the foundation for future procurement of these services locally and enables delivery of specific and consistent requirements. 

3.20. We recognise though that the impact of COVID-19 on many organisations’ ability to bid along with our own internal capacity to run the competitions, evaluate them and support mobilisation means that we need to revise the scope of what we can procure via the Dynamic Framework for June 2021. 

3.21. - 3.22. To balance the need to reduce the complexity of our initial call-off plans with ensuring sufficient specialist services are still in place for Day 1, we have revisited whether alternatives are available in the short-term to avoid the need for call-off competitions across some categories of need for Day 1. For instance, for some of the original intended Day 1 scope, there are existing alternative sources of provision that Regional Probation Directors are better linked into, and can commission or co-commission directly. 

3.23. Our decision on what to continue to procure for Day 1 has been informed by the following considerations: 
  • Where statutory or alternative provision is weakest; 
  • Ease of delivery in-house (including opportunity for co-commissioning by regional teams, staff skill-set and physical delivery capability – e.g. whether premises are required); 
  • Current usage – both levels and how it is delivered; 
  • Extent of need (e.g. is there a specific pre-release resettlement requirement as well as post-release rehabilitative need). 
3.24. For Day 1 we have also considered where it might be appropriate to procure services at a regional level rather than at a PCC level, thereby reducing the number of lots and making delivery for June 2021 more viable. A regional approach does not preclude local delivery. We intend to discuss with Regional Probation Directors the geographical footprint required in their regions for effective service delivery and how we can facilitate this (e.g. co-location with probation offices), as well as considering locality and responsiveness of services in our evaluation of bids. 

3.25. We will open qualification for all categories of need under the Dynamic Framework, even if some are no longer in scope for our initial phase of Day 1 procurement activity. This is important, as our ambition for a wide range of service needs to be able to be met via the Dynamic Framework remains. 

Impacts on staff 

3.26. Supporting staff through this process is critical to its successful transition and delivery. Our approach remains to work closely with Trade Unions, current employers and staff to support the transition and minimise impacts on people’s roles. Whilst we need to do a more detailed review, using updated data returns from CRCs around specific staff impacts of the new model, changes in respect of Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes and Structured Interventions mean we envisage that staff currently delivering equivalent services under CRCs will be assigned to transfer to the NPS. This provides certainty for a significant group of staff that would otherwise have been reliant on outcomes of the Probation Delivery Partner competition to inform what would happen to them. 

3.27. As outlined in the draft Target Operating Model, we will protect staff terms and conditions following transfer and most new staff compulsorily transferring into the NPS will be eligible to join the local government pension scheme post transfer. The exception is those who retain eligibility to participate in the civil service pension scheme. 

3.28. The practicalities of bringing an increased volume of staff from an increased number of employers into the NPS will necessitate renewed Trade Union negotiations and longer lead in times for enabling activity such as payroll build and testing and vetting. It is also likely to mean that we will need to focus on getting fundamental requirements in place for Day 1 and implement further changes such as restructuring post transfer. As part of the transition we will ensure that those staff moving into the NPS are fully orientated and supported. 

3.29. The establishment of a separate workforce programme, working in close collaboration with probation reform, to develop and build our workforce is in recognition that our people are our most valued asset. We acknowledge the likely increase in training needs created by this change and remain committed to identifying and addressing learning, development and experience gaps for our staff. 

3.30. We recognise the anxiety that staff will be feeling around change to this new system and want to be able to support them through it. This includes providing stimulating work that motivates and engages staff. We want to build a positive work environment that attracts, retains and develops skilled people and champions positive behaviours and practices. We intend to publish our Workforce Strategy shortly, which will set out intentions in more detail and ensure that wider changes happening in probation go hand-in-hand with positive changes for our workforce.

4. Next Steps
 

4.1. We will very quickly reprofile the probation reform programme to reflect the revised model. This will include reprioritising resource to those areas that will support a smooth transition and reviewing key milestones to June 2021 and beyond to ensure successful implementation and embedding of the changes. 

4.2. We intend to publish an updated version of the Target Operating Model for the future of probation services early in 2021 to provide further detail on the new system, informed by the changes that we have announced as well as the opportunities presented by new ways of working that we have had to introduce as a result of COVID-19. 

4.3. We will develop a revised illustration of the changes to support engagement with colleagues and stakeholders to promote awareness and participation in the future changes. 

4.4. We will continue to work with senior leaders within NPS and CRCs to explicitly address the culture(s) we currently have and what we are aiming for in the future. This work will be inclusive and recognise the diversity of our workforce and delivery. 

4.5. We will continue to engage closely with stakeholders and partners across the criminal justice system in developing our plans.

Saturday, 23 March 2019

Just What The Dr Ordered

Before Dame Glenys departs, she thinks she knows what the patient needs:- 

Dame Glenys Stacey, HM Chief Inspector of Probation 
Inside Government, Offender Management 2019 
London, 19 March 2019 

Re-imagining probation services to face the challenges of the future 

Good afternoon, and thank you for inviting me back (I was here last year). And thank you so much for asking me to speak on the theme of re-imagining probation services. Who can resist the opportunity to flex the imagination! 

Let me start by reminding you that many members of the public are but vaguely aware of probation, and what it does, but good quality probation services matter. More than a quarter of a million people are under probation supervision each year. If all these services were delivered well, there would be less reoffending and fewer people being returned repeatedly to prison. The prison population would reduce, and there would also be fewer people living on the streets, fewer people begging, and fewer confused and lonely children, with a smaller number taken into care. Men, women and children currently afraid of assault could lead happier, safer lives. These things matter to us all. 

But probation is not working as it should. Overall, it is not delivering well enough for some of the most troubled and troublesome people in society today, when they and the wider public deserve better. 

Both the National Probation Service (NPS) and Community Rehabilitation Companies (CRCs) are failing to meet some of their performance targets, although the NPS is doing better. These targets are generally task-based, however – a sentence plan must be drawn up within fifteen days of first meeting, in each case, for example. What is much more concerning, to my mind, is that although there will be exceptions, the probation work of CRCs is generally not good enough. It is not of the right quality overall. 

As we at HMI Probation inspect, we rate divisions of the NPS and each CRC on a fourpoint rating scale: Outstanding, Good, Requiring Improvement, Inadequate. In the ten CRCs inspected over the last year, we have rated the implementation and delivery of core probation supervision as Requiring Improvement in two CRCs and Inadequate (the lowest possible rating) in the remaining eight. 

Now, here we are at the Royal College of Physicians. It seems to me that we may need their help. 

I have been asked to reimagine probation services. Last summer, the Justice Secretary made the bold decision to terminate contracts with CRCs two years earlier than planned. They will now come to an end in December 2020. The question on all our minds is this: what comes next? 

Let me put myself in the role of probation’s physician. Let me poke, and test, and identify some its most worrying symptoms - some immediately visible and some not - and then prescribe some medicine, or even surgery. 

First, it is as plain as the nose on the patient’s face that the patient is not a strong as it should be. It is under-nourished. It has a shortage of qualified probation professionals. There is now a national shortage, particularly in the ranks of those doing much of the more complex casework (Probation Officers). 

This ailment will take time to sort I am afraid. There is no instant tonic. We need a national workforce strategy to make things better, over time. The Ministry of Justice has made a similar diagnosis and intends to develop the strategy, but it will not be straightforward, with the number of different employers and models across probation. This medicine will come at a cost, and might be difficult to administer. 

And I suggest there is an underlying weakness in the patient here as well. The profession is not protected by the usual bulwarks of other established professions (such as the profession of physicians). 

Established professions generally require individuals who are in practice to be registered as members of the profession – in effect, certifying that they meet entry requirements for the profession. Almost all professions require members to undertake ongoing training (continual professional development) and that members are subject to self-regulation. Under those self-regulation arrangements, members can face Fitness to Practice proceedings if they have acted unethically or incompetently, with debarment for the most serious negligence or misconduct. 

The probation profession and the general public are not protected by these specific requirements. 

Probation professionals are not obliged to register with anyone, and are not under any profession-wide requirement to keep their knowledge and skills up to date. In recent months we have reported on notable shortcomings in the skills and knowledge of professionals supervising sexual offenders, and perpetrators of domestic abuse, both sizeable areas of work for probation services. We know from our inspections that probation professionals struggle to carve out time for training and development. 

Probation professionals are not subject to a common code of ethics. Such a code would be an important protection for all people under probation supervision, but codes of ethics also protect members of professions from commercial or other pressures in their employment, as immutable lines are drawn. 

I have to advise the patient that the impacts of commerce, and contracts that treat probation as a transactional business can mean that professional ethics can buckle under such pressures, and the evidence we have is that this has happened to some extent. 

In our inspection of Dorset, Devon and Cornwall CRC we found cases with no sentence plan at all, or where sentence plans had been prepared without meeting with the individual. We also found the assessment of the risk of serious harm to the public seriously compromised, because of commercial pressures. 

A remedy is certainly needed, and here the Ministry of Justice prescription is slightly different to mine. It has proposed the development of a national professional register, with plans to house it under the auspices of the NPS. I think it inappropriate for a major employer of the profession, or a government agency to be responsible for certification and registration of the profession. Instead, such responsibilities generally lie with an independent body. 

The Ministry of Justice has also proposed to more clearly specify the training, skills and competencies that staff will require for different roles. While welcome, this does not provide the assurance inherent in other professions’ requirements for Continuing Professional Development. Like other professionals, probation staff need to keep up to date with developments.

And I prescribe more medicine: a meaningful code of ethics, and an effective professional body for the profession. It could make such a difference for the profession and for the wider public. 

We have diagnosed that immediate issue, but what else is plain to the physician, in studying this patient? What is plain is that it is not getting enough exercise. There will be exceptions, but in general, not enough meaningful activity is taking place in cases supervised by CRCs. The patient is not doing what we know to be good for it! It is not working in accordance with the evidence base for rehabilitation anywhere near enough. 

In the day to day work of probation professionals, there has been a notable and extremely regrettable drift away from the evidence base for effective probation services. So why has the patient become so lazy, seemingly, when it knows this is not healthy? 

Things are not what they seem. The patient is active, is busy, but driven to focus on the wrong things sometimes. 

The physician might reflect that Rehabilitation Activity Requirements are ordered largely by default and can be largely ineffective, in practice, and also that recognised cognitive behavioural programmes (Accredited Programmes) and treatment orders are not being ordered or delivered enough. 

What is more, in the current model for probation services, the critical relationship between the individual under probation supervision and the probation worker is not sufficiently protected and as a result, core probation supervision itself has been allowed to coast. This has undermined the place of evidence-based and evidence-led practice. 

And CRCs are understandably focused on meeting those transaction-based targets I mentioned earlier. They are kept very busy, doing that. Many are running to keep still. Running on the treadmill. 

Refreshingly, some CRCs are self-medicating. They are developing evidence-led approaches, and some are taking a further step and evaluating those new approaches. The established national mechanism for evaluation of new approaches – Accreditation – is not being used, however, and promising developments are not being promulgated across the service as a whole. The way the service is now configured inhibits that to a large extent. 

It is so important that probation work is evidence-based and evidence-led, and that the evidence base grows over time, and yet we have seen a move away from it in recent years.

 To cure this ailment, surgery will be required, I fear. The Ministry of Justice must make sure that in the future arrangements for the provision of probation services, there are enough probation professionals able to have sufficient regard to the evidence base for effective rehabilitative probation services, and able to deliver in accordance with the evidence base.

As the physician of course, I only have a limited time with this patient. Our appointment is coming to an end shortly, but I just have time to consider one more problem. This patient cannot live better, probation cannot deliver well enough without the help of others in the community. 

Our aggregated data shows for example that for individuals leaving prison, accommodation is the most pressing issue, followed by the need for help with finance, benefits and debt, with similar issues prevalent for individuals under probation supervision in the community. 

We expect every effort in individual cases of course, but national, strategic solutions are needed. Those without a place to live are notably more likely to reoffend and to be sentenced to custodial sentences. Speedier payment of benefits when an individual leaves prison would be more likely to sustain an individual’s motivation to turn away from crime, and reduce the prospect of individuals stealing, to sustain themselves. 

The patient cannot resolve these issues alone. Instead, the prescription is for the government. Its national Reducing Reoffending Board should consider how sufficient accommodation can be provided for those without a home, and how to speed up initial benefits payments (without clawback) for those released from custody and without a means to live. 

Accommodation and a means to live are so important, but the patient needs other services to be available locally as well. Under the government’s 2014 Transforming Rehabilitation initiative, CRCs became responsible for contracting specialist services (such as advice on managing debt) for individuals under probation supervision from those able to provide them, so that they are available for individuals CRCs supervise and for the NPS as well. Our inspection evidence shows there is an insufficient range of these specialist services overall.

CRCs contracts allow CRCs to decide what to offer by way of specialist services. We have found staff in NPS divisions (and even CRC staff themselves) are often unaware of the services on offer. More commonly however, we have found NPS staff and leaders reluctant to purchase services from CRCs, because of concerns about the quality of services to be provided, or whether they represent value for money, or because of an instinctive reluctance to pay for services. In addition, there is an enduring cultural dimension: professional probation staff do not see themselves as purchasers, and most do not want to be. 

Surgery is needed here. In designing the future arrangements for probation services, government should make sure that a good range of specialist services are available to meet need, and that the specialist service sector is nurtured and maintained. 

It is time for our appointment to end, but I do offer the patient a bit of philosophical advice, to conclude our consultation. Like so many of us, this patient wants things beyond its grasp, and not in its gift. It has been encouraged to aim for greatness rather than focus on the day to day. 

Let me explain. All probation professionals aspire to reduce reoffending, and quite right too. But CRCs are rewarded for statistically significant reductions in the reoffending of individuals they have supervised. 

Reoffending has reduced slightly in recent years, but the number of offences committed by those who do reoffend has increased. Some CRCs have received extra money as a result, others not. 

While changes in the rate of proven reoffending have been used as a strategic measure of the success of individual probation providers, I argue that changes in reoffending rates are not sufficiently and directly attributable to their work. Although evidence-based and evidence-led probation work can reduce reoffending, factors such as an individual’s maturity, or police priorities influence the reoffending rate as well. We know for example that in recent years, the criminal justice focus has moved more towards serious crime, crimes that attract long prison sentences. 

I think the patient needs to think again about its goals, and focus on living better day to day. The Ministry of Justice needs to encourage the patient in that way. More immediate measures of the quality of probation services (for example, our inspection findings and ratings) are more telling of the health of the patient – and the patient is more likely to play its part in reducing reoffending if it delivers good quality work, day in day out. 

In conclusion, I have singled out some of the most distressing symptoms for the patient, and suggested remedies, but in many ways I have looked at individual symptoms rather than their cause, and of course the focus on individual symptoms may be at a cost to the overall health of the patient. 

Let us not forget: this patient has so many attractive features. It has a strong ethos, with good leaders and committed staff capable of delivering first class probation service that can make a real difference to the most troubled in society, and to society as a whole. It has a reason to live! But is has been so ground down in recent years, and its future health remains at risk. 

The physician can prescribe some immediate medication to alleviate some of the obvious symptoms of ill-heath, but he should also take several steps back, look at the patient in the round, and consider whether a more radical treatment programme is needed. I think it is, don’t you? 

Thank you. Thank you for listening. 

Dame Glenys Stacey

Saturday, 9 February 2019

Let's Have a RAR Day

With the MoJ publishing revised guidance, now seems as good a time as any to consider what those mysterious 'RAR days' are all about:-  

1. What is the rehabilitation activity requirement?

This guidance is to explain what the rehabilitation activity requirement (known as ‘RAR’) is and how it should be used. This guidance has been produced by the Ministry of Justice probation policy team.

The RAR is one of the requirements that can be included within a community order or suspended sentence order. The main purpose is to secure someone’s rehabilitation, restoring service users to a purposeful life in which they do not reoffend.

The RAR was introduced in 2014 under the Offender Rehabilitation Act to allow providers of probation services greater flexibility to decide on the best ways to rehabilitate individuals. Community rehabilitation companies (CRCs) were encouraged to access a diverse range of rehabilitation providers from the private, voluntary and social sectors.

The RAR replaces what would previously have been undertaken as part of both the supervision and specified activity requirements. What would have previously been known as ‘supervision’ is now split between RAR interventions and offender management activity by the responsible officer (RO). The RO oversees progress of the order and develops a close, trusting relationship with the individual to support them in successfully completing the requirements they’re subject to.

The RO plans with the service user how to use the ‘RAR days’ allocated by the court and which activities to take part in to help their rehabilitation, tailored to their specific needs.


2. RAR in sentencing

The court can decide to include a RAR as part of a community order or a suspended sentence order. They do not have to include a RAR. A RAR should be proposed when the person has clear rehabilitative needs, when appropriate activities are available and where these needs cannot be met by an accredited programme or a treatment requirement.

To assist sentencers, National Probation Service (NPS) court officers should make clear proposals that specifically identify the rehabilitative needs to be addressed and the number of days needed to do so.

Where needs can be met by an accredited programme or treatment requirement, this is the preferred intervention. This is because accredited programmes are evidence based and should achieve improved outcomes if provided to the right people in the right way. A RAR should only be allocated alongside an accredited programme if it can address additional rehabilitative activities that are not addressed by the programme. The RO can offer additional appointments to secure compliance and help maintain motivation.

Treatment requirements are delivered in partnership with locally commissioned substance misuse or mental health treatment services. These partnerships bring together the resources and skills to help those with mental health and substance misuse difficulties. Consent is required for all treatment requirements.

Drug rehabilitation requirements (DRRs) can be given when the court is satisfied that the service user is dependent on or misuses drugs, and that treatment is likely to help and is available.

Alcohol treatment requirements (ATRs) can be given when the court is satisfied that a service user is dependent on alcohol and that treatment is likely to help and is available. The service user’s dependency on alcohol does not have to have caused or contributed to the offence for which they’ve been convicted.

Mental health treatment requirements (MHTRs) can be given where the court is satisfied that an offender has a mental health condition that’s treatable either in a community setting or as an outpatient in a non-secure setting. MHTRs can be used for any mental health issue, including personality disorders, and the treatment offered can cover a wide range of interventions from therapy for depression and anxiety through to secondary and psychiatric care.

3. Assessing rehabilitative needs


A RAR could be used to address someone’s needs in the following areas:

  • accommodation
  • education, training and employment
  • relationships
  • lifestyle and associates
  • non-dependent alcohol misuse (ATRs are intended for those who are alcohol dependent and DRRs for those who misuse illegal drugs)
  • emotional management (MHTRs are intended for all diagnosed mental health conditions, apart from those that require a hospital or guardianship order)
  • attitudes, thinking and behaviour
  • finance, benefits and debt
These are the needs that evidence shows either predict reoffending if they are not met, or if they are addressed will contribute to the stability people need to be able to deal with other significant issues.

In general, the more of these needs the person has, the greater their risk of reoffending. The NPS advises the court in a pre-sentence report on an appropriate maximum number of RAR activity days that might be needed and why. The court cannot set what specific rehabilitation activities should be done.

The court specifies the maximum number of RAR days that someone can be instructed to participate in activities. The number of RAR days allocated should take into account the complexity and severity of someone’s needs and their risk of reoffending. The RAR is not designed to be used as a punishment.

There’s no maximum number of RAR days but the ‘offender group reconviction scale’ (OGRS) score, based on age, gender and criminal history, should be the main guide to the number of days proposed. This is because there’s a clear link between the OGRS score and the number of rehabilitative needs. Longer RARs should be reserved for those with a higher risk of reoffending as they will have the most needs to address.

OGRS score  Average number of needs  RAR intensity  Guideline number of RAR days
0 to 24%        2.4                                                                          n/a
25 to 49%      3.2                                      Low intensity          RAR 1 to 15 days
50 to 74%      4.4                                      Medium intensity    RAR 15 to 25 days
75 to 90%      4.4                                      High intensity         RAR 25 to 60 days
Over 90%      6.2                                      High intensity         RAR 25 to 60 days

People with an OGRS score of less than 25% present a low likelihood of reoffending and are unlikely to benefit from rehabilitative interventions. It should only be in exceptional circumstances that they’re identified as needing a RAR. There would need to be clear indication of dynamic risk factors linked to an increased risk of reoffending.

In relation to identifying the rehabilitative needs of sex offenders, OGRS is not a good predictor of sexual reoffending. The factors most strongly predictive of sexual offending include: unusual sexual interests, attitudes that support sexual offending, poor emotional relationships with adults and a lack of self-management. The NPS court officer needs to assess if any of these factors exist and should be addressed by RAR interventions. If they’re eligible for an accredited programme, that should be the intervention of choice. It may be necessary to propose more RAR days if other stabilisation needs are identified.

The pre-sentence report should provide enough information about someone’s needs for the court to understand what their RAR is likely to focus on and why this should contribute to their rehabilitation.

People under probation supervision frequently have a wide range of needs. The important task is to identify the needs that, for that person, need addressing to reduce their risk of reoffending.

4. RAR in sentence planning

After sentencing, the assigned RO completes an initial assessment and, with the service user, decides on the interventions that will be done within the RAR, how they’ll be delivered, how often the person attends and what outcomes they’re aiming to achieve. This forms part of the ‘sentence plan’. It’s important to focus on the needs that are predictive of reoffending.

A RAR ‘day’ does not mean continuous activity throughout a whole day. All activities need to be enforceable. The activities that count as 1 day could include:

  • individual face-to-face planned and structured sessions designed to address identified needs
  • a planned activity with a third-party provider
  • 2 or more separate planned activities or sessions in the same day
If someone’s circumstances change in the course of the order, the RO can amend the number and type of activities to ensure they continue to meet the person’s needs. However, the number of RAR days cannot exceed that proposed by the court.

The sentence given by the court states the maximum number of RAR days that someone can be instructed to attend. If the RO believes that the agreed outcomes have been achieved through a lower number of RAR days than specified by the court, or through an alternative method, this needs to be recorded on Delius (the probation case management system) with the reasons explained.

5. What counts as a RAR activity

A RAR activity must be a pre-planned, structured intervention to address someone’s identified need to support their rehabilitation. The RO and the service user should agree the desired outcomes ahead of the activities, so that progress can be tracked.

Probation providers will have different interventions they can offer as part of a RAR to address the needs that are strongly predictive of reoffending. These are likely to include activities in the areas of:

  • accommodation
  • education, training and employment
  • relationships
  • lifestyle and associates
  • non-dependent alcohol misuse (ATRs are intended for those who are alcohol dependent and DRRs for those who misuse illegal drugs)
  • emotional management (MHTRs are intended for all diagnosed mental health conditions)
  • attitudes, thinking and behaviour
  • finance, benefits and debt
  • specific interventions for women
This is not a full list. Other activities could be included as a RAR as long as it’s planned, structured, clearly meets rehabilitative needs and there’s a rationale as to why it should work.

The activity could be as part of a group or could be individual ‘face-to-face’. An activity is usually delivered by a third party on behalf of the RO, but could be by the RO themselves if there’s no existing intervention available.

The RO must also undertake additional offender management activities, which include motivation, promoting and sustaining hope, supporting compliance, enforcement, public protection and overseeing the overall direction and sequencing of activities in the order. These appointments do not count as RAR days and the RO can offer as many of these as they feel are necessary during the course of the order. There will also be other unstructured discussions between the RO and the service user to support them in addressing their identified needs. These discussions are crucial to the building of a positive relationship with the service user, but do not count as RAR days.

6. Selecting RAR activities

The RO needs to understand the person’s needs that lie behind the offence and select an existing intervention to addresses these. If no suitable activity exists then they must record this on Delius (the probation case management system) with the reasons explained.

Examples of activities could include:

  • programmes designed to address specific issues such as emotional management
  • enforceable appointments with a specialist organisation to help achieve outcomes relating to housing or financial needs
  • working with a mentor, for example to attend college, go to the library or help prepare a CV
  • structured sessions with a RO, third sector provider or in-house specialist to help improve an individual’s ability to solve problems, make good decisions or access and maintain engagement with other services
7. Delivering RAR activities

RAR activities can be delivered by a sub-contracted provider (where there are arrangements to monitor attendance, as these are legally enforceable), an in-house specialist or by the RO. When the RO is delivering RAR interventions, this should be recorded as such, as it’s distinct from their offender management activity. The RO should ensure the service user is engaging with the process and making progress.

All appointments instructed by the RO, whether delivered by the RO or other RAR provider, are enforceable.

The RO should be assessing whether the person’s needs are being met through the planned interventions and making changes if appropriate. The provider of the RAR activity should be reporting back on attendance, progress and suggested next steps.

The service user cannot be instructed to attend more RAR days than those given in their sentence. The RAR days do not necessarily need to be spaced out for the duration of the sentence, they can be completed whenever is most appropriate.

After completing the RAR activities to address the risk of reoffending, the RO can signpost the service user to further support if needed.

The outcome of the RAR intervention needs to be recorded on Delius. This should reflect whether the desired outcomes that were agreed as part of the initial sentence plan have been achieved. The RO needs to confirm that this counts as the completion of the RAR. If fewer days have been completed, the RO needs to record the rationale for taking this decision, a description of the progress that’s been made and the outcome achieved.