Friday, 5 April 2019

The Surreal World of TR

The things I do for this blog now include getting utterly drenched in Liverpool yesterday on my way to a joint event put on by Liverpool John Moores University and the Probation Journal, a sort of post mortem on 'Transforming Rehabilitation'. The star turn was Oliver Lodge of the National Audit Office and author of three out of the four NAO reports on TR to date.

Having reminded us that the NAO's job is never to question government policy, but rather examine and audit in respect of Value For (Taxpayer's) Money, a trot through the key findings of all four reports, delivered in a typical accountants' flat, unemotional tone, nevertheless was devastating in utterly demolishing this particular bit of government policy. A bit surreal really, but a situation rather neatly encapsulated by a bit of typically British understatement "not a pretty picture" he said.  There really was nothing and I mean nothing, to commend TR, according to the man from the government department whose job it is to never question government policy - well, except this:- 
'At the end of the TR contracts, the cost will be £822m less than before.' 
I had to have a long think about this figure and indeed I seem to recall that the TR architect himself, Chris Grayling, has already quoted it in defence of the TR omnishambles. Lets just ponder for one minute what this figure of underfunding has meant over the last few years:-
  • careers ruined
  • stress caused
  • sick leave increase
  • staff vacancies
  • recruitment stymied
  • reduction in training 
  • more victims
  • more crime
  • more SFOs
  • community orders not made
  • increase in recalls to prison
  • accommodation not found
  • jobs not secured
This is not a comprehensive list, but you get the idea, a situation confirmed in spades by all the other panel speakers whether academics, from NPS, from CRC or Napo. They all spoke movingly and unlike our friend Oliver from the NAO, passionately about the horror of TR and Lol Burke in particular reminded the audience that its introduction has been likened to  workplace violence. I personally know of a colleagues having been diagnosed with PTSD.

The NAO has suggested in the strongest terms that TR2 be 'paused' and are very concerned at the 'huge challenge to come'. We know the outgoing HMI says TR is 'irredeemably flawed' and the Justice Committee are very concerned. As yet there has been no response to last years 'sham' consultation, but some say we will hear in May. We could be in for another round of trauma folks.  

--oo00oo--

This letter in the Telegraph confirms the magistrates are not happy:-

Probation reform

SIR – The report by Dame Glenys Stacey, HM Chief Inspector of Probation, on the state of the probation service is extremely concerning (report, March 28), suggesting that existing provision is simply not fit for purpose.

The report highlights poor performance, dwindling confidence among magistrates in the delivery of community sentences, and the risk that people are being sent to prison when a suitable community sentence might have made this avoidable.

As the Ministry of Justice decides on its next steps in reforming the probation service, these matters must be addressed. Magistrates will not be able to impose community sentences with confidence unless they know that they can be delivered.

John Bache JP
National Chairman, Magistrates Association
London SW8


--oo00oo--

We wonder what the new HMI and current MoJ insider will make of it all:-

The Secretary of State has announced the appointment of Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Probation.

The Secretary of State has announced the appointment of Justin Russell as Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Probation for a tenure of 3 years. His appointment will commence on 1 June 2019 and run until 31 May 2022.

The appointment follows a report from the Justice Select, Committee into Justin’s suitability for the role, published on 8 March, and a public hearing with the committee held on 5 March.

Appointments and re-appointments are regulated by the Commissioner for Public Appointments, and have been made in line with the Governance Code on Public Appointments.

HM Chief Inspectorate of Probation

The Chief Inspector of Probation reports directly to Ministers, but operates independently of government and the services under its scrutiny. The Chief Inspector has a duty to ensure the inspection of probation and youth offending services in England and Wales and to provide independent scrutiny of the quality of work undertaken with individual offenders.

Justin Russell Biography

Mr Russell has spent over thirty years working on a wide range of criminal justice issues as a researcher, policy maker and major programme leader and has a long-standing interest and involvement in probation and youth justice policy. Mr Russell has also worked for the Audit Commission and Mental Health Foundation and was a non-executive Director of Turning Point from 2005 to 2011. Until recently, he was Director General for Justice Analysis and Offender Policy at the Ministry of Justice and is currently the Director General for No Deal EU Exit Planning at the Ministry of Justice.


--oo00oo--

Finally, Bob Neill writing in the Times makes clear his view that prison reform can only happen if probation is fixed:-

Time for rethink on a prisons policy that amounts to crisis management

The government’s approach to prisons in England and Wales is failing to deliver.

The prison population has nearly doubled since the early 1990s — currently standing at 82,000 — and forecasts to 2022 suggest that even more people than that will be in prison by then. This is against the backdrop of a £1.2bn black hole in the Ministry of Justice’s finances, with many prisons overcrowded and a rapidly changing prisoner demographic.

There are many people in prison with drug, alcohol and mental health problems, and prison is often not the best place for them to get help. Despite this, we use custodial sentences more than any other nation in western Europe, and we get considerably worse results in terms of turning people’s lives around and preventing reoffending.

The Commons justice committee’s wide-ranging report, published today after almost 18-months of evidence gathering, proposes a range of solutions.

David Gauke, the justice secretary, is right in his assertion that there is a strong case for abolishing short sentences of six months or less altogether — and not purely because it is an easy way of saving money or closing prisons.

The ministry has rightly focused on safety and decency in prisons, however this has come directly at the expense of rehabilitation. We heard robust evidence that poor access to rehabilitation has a cyclical impact on the degradation of regimes and on safety, which can in turn lead to violence and self-harm. There must now be a dual approach to maintain safety and decency, but also improve rehabilitation.

Without doubt, prison will always have a role in dealing with the most serious crimes and those who are a threat to society, but cutting the use of short sentences, and instead properly investing in tough and rigorous community rehabilitation services would go a long way to solving many of the problems I have described.

Almost a third of prisoners are on sentences of less than 12 months. Better access to support and opportunities for offenders would reduce repeat imprisonment, bring down the estimated £15 billion annual cost of reoffending, and start to alleviate pressure on jails.

It is time for a serious and open public debate about the criminal justice system, the role of prison and its affordability. The government has acknowledged this, but it should happen sooner rather than later so the public can understand the challenging nature of decisions around criminal justice.

No solution is straightforward, but ministers must produce a plan that shows a more joined-up approach to the way we use imprisonment and how that is linked to the rest of the criminal justice system.

At present, we waste unsustainable vast sums of public money, but also fail the thousands of people convicted of less serious offences who need support to move on from their past mistakes. It is time for a serious rethink.

Bob Neill is a Conservative MP and chairman of the justice select committee.

Thursday, 4 April 2019

Warehousing the Homeless

Just parking this here as there is no-one else to talk to: my organisation gives only slightly less of a f*ck than the government. This morning I was stressed, cramming the grubby tattered remains of a long gone family holiday into a bag: tent, sleeping bag, pillow, into a bag for client leaving prison. "Jesus! It can't be that bad" says partner. Not that I haven't bleated on, but conveying the horror of what is happening is clearly a challenge we are not meeting...
The comment above chimed with the following story I saw on the BBC website yesterday. Coming as it does on the back of hearing how Theresa May's treatment of the Windrush generation whilst at the helm at the Home Office is likely to cost us upwards of £200million, I'm beginning to think I live in a country I no longer recognise. 

Inside Harlow's office block 'human warehouse' housing

"It is very scary," says mother-of-four Melanie Smith, sitting on the sofa which doubles as her bed, a few feet from the oven and sink of her one-room studio. Pressed close to her couch is one of the two beds that fill the rest of her flat and upon which her two sons eat, play and sleep. Ms Smith is one of hundreds of residents placed at Terminus House in Harlow by councils in and around London, often many miles from everything and everybody they once knew.

The former office block - the Essex town's tallest building - is one of hundreds up and down England which have been turned into housing without ever needing planning permission. Its owner, Caridon Property, claims it delivers a "good service" at the 14-storey 1960s office block - and that it does all it can to keep people safe. But since the building was resurrected as a housing complex in April 2018, crime has soared.

Police figures show that in the first 10 months after people moved in, crime within Terminus House itself rose by 45%, and within that part of the town centre (within a 500m radius) by nearly 20% - to more than 500 incidents - compared with the previous 10 months. More than 100 incidents involved violence or sex crimes. Incidents included anti-social behaviour, burglary, criminal damage and arson. There has also been at least one drugs raid.

Harlow's district commander Ch Insp Matt Cornish said: "I am absolutely convinced that Terminus House being at that site is a contributing factor in the increase in crime and anti-social behaviour we are having." And some occupants told the BBC that living at Terminus House, which is also home to 25 people recently released from prison, is frightening.

Ms Smith was placed there in April 2018. "There's no room," she said. "They have to eat, drink and sleep in their beds. There's no room to move about. It is not good for them. It is ridiculous really." She said it was not safe for her children to go downstairs, even during the day, because of drug users who are "out of it". "It is very scary. You don't know who is outside the door," she said. "Any arguments that happen, it is always, constantly, outside the door. Often you hear them banging against the door where they are fighting. The wall next to me - I had to clean the blood off it two weeks ago. You don't want them [the children] going down there - I don't want them thinking this is normal."

Down the corridor lives Kylie Yiangou, a single mother of a three-year-old boy, who was placed at Terminus by Epping Council. "It is a nightmare. It is mentally draining. They shouldn't have sold this place as a dream. I don't care if people want to sit in a room and overdose. But not next to my son. One minute they are laughing. The next minute they are fighting. The minute he says 'mummy I'm scared' I just lose my temper and have to go outside and literally drag men out of the hallway. And to be honest, I am homeless - how can I turn round and say I don't want that? I am homeless. How can I turn something down?"


Planning permission?
  • Under a change to Permitted Development rights in 2013, developers became able to turn offices into residential premises without planning permission
  • Unless there are demonstrable concerns about issues such as flooding or contamination, local councils have no control over such developments
  • More than 1,000 homes in Harlow have been created from office block conversions
  • The Local Government Association said in January 2019 that half of all new homes being created in Harlow are from office block conversions
Terminus House is covered by nearly 100 high definition CCTV cameras. "We just want to make sure that all the areas are covered," says Paul Jackson, regional manager at Caridon Property, which owns and runs the building. We do have some people that are vulnerable and it makes them feel safe. And should there be any incidents then they are covered and the police can use our system. I think we offer a good service. The property we have is like a stepping stone for most people. We have people from all different backgrounds. Most of them will be on a lower income. We offer a service that can help people out, people that are vulnerable. Councils come to us, they want to use our property and people are usually here for anything between two months and a couple of years. There's a need and we try and supply the need."

He confirmed there had been a police raid which involved a search for drugs adding: "I am aware there are drugs being taken in the property and we work closely with the police to try and resolve that. Like any other block of flats I'm sure there are situations and issues. But on a day-to-day basis everyone we see seems to be getting on OK."

While Terminus House sits at the centre of Harlow, other office blocks on the outskirts have also been given over to new housing. Greenway House, which is run by another company, sits to the far western outskirts of the town. Its flats are larger, the corridors wider and it has a play area for children, albeit a makeshift one in a fenced-off section of the car park. No residents who spoke with BBC voiced concerns about crime or their personal safety. What they did complain of, however, was their sense of isolation.

Channon Manley, housed at Greenway by Enfield Council in north London, described it as "an island with nothing". "The only thing around us is warehousing and business centres," she said. The closest shop is a 40-minute walk away and it takes an hour to walk into the centre of town."

With nearly half of new housing in Harlow being forged from old office blocks, the welfare of children living there has become a growing concern. One Caridon worker told the BBC some children at Templefields House, to the north eastern edge of the town, had found themselves referred to as "office block kids". Bernadette Miele, head teacher at Tanny's Dell Primary, said incoming pupils from Templefields were "presenting with social concerns" and needed additional support from her staff.

Danny Purton, portfolio holder for the environment at Harlow Council, compared the use of office blocks for homes to "human warehousing". "While they are here, we try and make them as welcome as possible," he said. "They are moving here because they are being off-rolled from London, where these people cannot afford the price of housing. In Harlow, the business model works for these landlords. But they shouldn't be here - they should be back with the communities they have come from and where the services are." 

He said many families lived in "complete isolation". "The problem is the location and it is completely inappropriate for families to live in an industrial setting. There are no facilities for the children to play, to meet other children and to have any sort of child's life at all."

Wednesday, 3 April 2019

Great Leadership, But Poor Output?

"No matter how good a senior leadership team is, it is the effectiveness of case management that makes the difference to people’s lives." The Dame persists with her 'senior leadership good, workforce bad' mantra. It's as if there's no link between mgmt & practice. Twitter
There's clearly a bit of a theme developing in these HMI reports. Here's a press release about the latest, but to be honest, I'm completely bewildered. Maybe it's time to give a few of these 'brilliant' managers a caseload and see how they fair?  

Cheshire and Greater Manchester CRC - Reflective organisation capable of addressing weakness in protecting victims.

Strong leadership and hard work by staff have yet to translate into effective work to protect victims from harm, inspectors found in the Cheshire and Greater Manchester Community Rehabilitation Company (CRC).

Publishing the fourth report in 2018-19 on a CRC owned by the Purple Futures group, Dame Glenys Stacey, HM Chief Inspector of Probation, said it was not surprising to find themes similar to those identified in previous reports.

However, Dame Glenys added: “It is disappointing to learn that so little has improved since our last visit in 2016.

“The CRC’s operating model and organisation structure have been designed to enhance opportunities for rehabilitation and to reduce reoffending… However, despite an ongoing campaign by senior leaders to keep the profile of public protection high, they have been unable to embed a culture that recognises and responds effectively to the need to keep people safe from harm.” Weaknesses in work to protect children were particularly highlighted.

Inspectors assessed that the “risk of harm to others was underestimated in too many cases” and that “the quality of planning was variable; plans lacked important detail, especially about how the CRC would keep people safe.”

Resourcing restraints beyond the CRC’s control had led to structural and policy changes. CRC leaders remained positive and worked hard to introduce and embed change, and drive improvement. “However, many practitioners feel overwhelmed by the pace of change and unable to meet the demands of the CRC’s expectations. There is a growing divide between the strategic aspirations of the CRC and the reality of practice. We have seen this in other Purple Futures CRCs,” Dame Glenys said.

The report noted that staff managed “heavy and complex workloads within an environment of constant change”. Staffing levels have reduced by a quarter since 2014 and some teams across the large and complex CRC were managing “far too many” cases.

Some supervised cases “beyond their competence and without the necessary support”. Some were ill-equipped to handle cases involving complex child safeguarding issues and work to address domestic abuse by men was inadequate. Inspectors found that some were “extremely distressed” by their workloads.

Dame Glenys added: “No matter how good a senior leadership team is, it is the effectiveness of case management that makes the difference to people’s lives. Currently, despite pockets of careful, competent practice, there is too much variation in the quality of case management. The CRC needs to do far more to protect victims and the public and to make sure the individuals with whom it works change their offending behaviour.”
More positively, though, inspectors found the CRC’s work to supervise Unpaid Work Orders imposed by courts to be good, though its ‘Through the Gate’ services for those leaving prison were inadequate.

Inspectors, moreover, had confidence in the leadership and staff to address weaknesses. The report noted: “The CRC has a strong leadership team that demonstrates its commitment to quality probation services, its staff and other stakeholders. The ongoing investment with partners, providers and other stakeholders has helped create effective initiatives and interventions. The quality assurance framework provides a fully comprehensive system for driving improvements in policy and practice.”

Overall, Dame Glenys added:

“This is a hard-working, reflective organisation and I have every confidence that leaders will respond positively to this report to improve service provision.”

Another Broadside for MoJ

Despite government being all-but paralysed because of Brexit and the entire Cabinet held 'hostage' for an unprecedented eight hours at 10 Downing Street, and denied access to their mobile phone, life goes on and the MoJ get another kicking, this time from Bob Neil and the Justice Committee:-  

Prisons crisis: Government’s current approach inefficient, ineffective and unsustainable

The Government’s current approach to prison funding to accommodate growing population forecasts is inefficient, ineffective, and unsustainable in the medium or long-term, says the Justice Committee in a major new report published today.

Read the report summary
Read the full report: Prison population 2022: planning for the future

Reporting on a wide-ranging 18-month inquiry, the Committee agrees with Justice Secretary David Gauke that there is a very strong case for abolishing sentences of six months or less altogether. Re-offending costs an estimated £15 billion a year; the report recommends that there must be a focus on investing services to reduce this, thus cutting crime and reducing the overall size of the prison population - which is increased through repeat imprisonment.

Over the past 25 years, the prison population for England and Wales has almost doubled in size - from 44,246 in 1993 to 82,384 in December 2018. Capacity has not kept pace with demand and many prisons are now overcrowded. The inquiry heard how staffing shortages and other disruptions have severely undermined the delivery of rehabilitative services in prisons, including education, mental health treatment, substance misuse treatment and offending behaviour programmes. The Committee concluded that this creates immeasurable wasted costs.

The nature of the prison population is rapidly changing: a higher proportion of offenders are in prison for serious violent or sexual offences. The average age is rising and many prisoners have mental health problems. All these factors and others make the current cohort of prisoners extremely challenging.

The report argues that the Government’s focus on addressing safety and decency in prisons has come at the expense of rehabilitation. The Ministry of Justice needs to refocus its efforts to enable a dual approach to maintain both safety and decency, as well as improve rehabilitation.

Chair's comments

Chair of the Justice Committee, Bob Neill MP, said:

“The Ministry of Justice and Treasury are guilty of a crisis management approach to prisons that has been failing for the past five years. Throwing money at the prison system to tackle multiple issues takes funding away from external rehabilitative programmes that could stem or reverse many of the problems.

“Proper investment in rehabilitation services would really work. Better access to support and opportunities for offenders would reduce repeat imprisonment, save money, and start to alleviate pressures on jails.

“Poor access to rehabilitation while in prison creates boredom and frustration, with a cyclical impact on the degradation of regimes and safety.

“We need a serious open public debate about the criminal justice system, the role of prison and its affordability. We are pleased that the Justice Secretary and Prisons Minister have acknowledged this but regardless of the political climate it cannot just be a long-term aspiration.

There must be greater transparency so that everyone can understand the true costs and challenging nature of decisions which need to be made about public spending on prisons and other aspects of criminal justice. This should form the first step of the Justice Secretary’s ‘National conversation’. These issues cannot be hidden behind the prison gates any longer.”

Key conclusions and recommendations

Today’s report makes conclusions and recommendations in a range of areas. These include:

The MoJ’s approach to managing the prison population and its financial sustainability;
  • There should be an overarching strategy for reoffending and a clear vision for what prisons will look like in the future. The Ministry of Justice’s rehabilitative strategies should each be underpinned by clear governance arrangements, action plans, timetables and resources.
  • The Government’s existing approach to prison reform is not sufficient to resolve major structural deficits to provision to reduce crime. There is an urgent need for significant additional resources for cross-departmental provision to reduce reoffending. This would save the Ministry money in the long-term and would reduce the cost to society of reoffending in the long-term.
  • The Treasury must now be able to recognise the wider implications of the decision not to invest in the prison and probation systems in recent years. It should take this into account in the 2020 to 2025 Spending Review exercise which should be broadened to encompass a more systematic approach to managing the £15bn a year costs of reoffending.
The current and projected prison population;
  • The prison population has become increasingly challenging in nature, with prisoners often having complex health and social needs. Many have learning disabilities or mental health conditions, such as psychosis, that make it difficult to cope with the criminal justice system and places an additional burden on the prison service to manage their needs.
  • Understanding the reasons for ethnic and racial disproportionality and seeking to reduce it must form part of a longer-term strategy for ensuring the sustainability of the prison population. The Ministry must monitor and take seriously the trend of racial and ethnic disparity in the prison population.
Explaining the growth in the prison population;
  • The rise in prison population has resulted from a greater proportion of those convicted being given a custodial sentence and from custodial sentences becoming longer. This has been driven by a complex set of factors, including more minor offending being diverted from the courts.
  • The Committee recommends that when changes to sentencing legislation are being debated in Parliament, the Ministry considers what more it might do to make Parliamentarians aware of the likely impact on exceedingly constrained resources.
Getting the basics right, including strong incentives for prisoners to reform;
  • There is a grave and worsening situation in the safety of prisons, despite recent advances in effort and resources.
  • Prisons are not currently maximising opportunities for rehabilitation. Regimes need to be reported upon in a meaningful way to enable monitoring of their operations, which are key to rehabilitation.
  • For IPP prisoners, the aim of the system should be that most are safely managed back into communities at the earliest opportunity. As part of its review of sentencing, the Ministry should consult on legislative solutions to both release and recall of indeterminate sentenced prisoners to bring about sentencing certainty.
  • Whilst progress made on the Prison Estates Transformation Programme is welcome, the new-for-old strategy is not working as intended. The Committee recommends that as part of its Justice 2030 project, the Ministry develops a realistic, properly costed, long-term estate strategy that enables it to meet the needs of an ever-changing prison population.
Cross-departmental working to tackle reoffending.
  • The Committee supports the Government’s approach to the abolition of short, ineffective prison sentences. The Committee repeats the recommendation of its Transforming Rehabilitation report that the Government should introduce presumption against short custodial sentences and believes. In addition to their welcome move towards avoiding the use of sentences under six months, they should model the effects of abolishing sentences of fewer than 12 months.
  • The Judiciary is entitled to expect that, in addition to being punished, those who are subject to probation supervision have good quality interventions and an opportunity to move on with their lives. The Government should as a medium-term priority, consider the value of judicial monitoring in its effort to improve sentencer confidence.

Tuesday, 2 April 2019

Prison and a Moral Panic

No doubt due to a paywall, I don't think we covered this article By David Gauke and Shaun Bailey from the Times back on 19th February, but it comes via this extraordinary website. I must admit I knew nothing of the Tory candidate for London Mayor until seeing him mentioned here:- 

Prison is a dead end for many offenders and we need to avoid it

What do we want from our justice system? To some people this is a pretty straightforward question. Our courts and prisons should be there, first and foremost, to mete out strong punishment to offenders, providing justice for individuals and communities affected by their egregious, criminal behaviour. For those who espouse this “hard” justice approach, lengthy jail sentences are typically the answer — and those long custodial sentences deter further crime.

Although this answer is seemingly simple, its fundamental problem is that our penal policy is clearly not working. Between 1993 and 2008 our prison population nearly doubled, rising from 45,000 to 83,000 — about the level now.

Much of this increase is driven by higher sentences for serious sexual and violent offences — and so it should be. Prison will always be the correct place for serious offenders and this government has been right to insist on tougher sentences for certain violent and sexual crimes.

However, across the board, and for all kinds of different crimes — many non-violent — prison sentences have crept up. In fact, when it comes to the length of prison sentences we are taking a more punitive approach than at any point during Margaret Thatcher’s premiership.

The trouble with this is that reoffending rates, particularly for certain types of crime and criminal, have remained stubbornly high. It is clear that the use of custody can only be part of the solution. Indeed, there is very compelling evidence that sending people to prison for a short time does not serve society well. It does not reduce crime.

Youth workers too often see the devastating impact of an overly prison-focused approach. There are young, naive, petty criminals entering prison with a GCSE and leaving with a PhD in criminality. There are also those who lead such troubled lives that prison is only one short stop in the revolving door of addiction, theft and the criminal justice system.

Then of course there are those who need mental health support more than prison, whose chaotic lives are further destabilised by being locked up for a few months or weeks as they lose their benefits, housing, employment and sometimes even their families.

Tellingly, almost two thirds of offenders sentenced to less than 12 months in prison go on to reoffend in the first year after release. This is almost double the reoffending rate of those given community or suspended sentences.

A policy approach purely focused on more and more imprisonment is one that does not serve the interests of society, and wastes taxpayers’ money. In the 21st century we should not be thinking in terms of what is “hard” or “soft”. We should be having a conversation about what works — “smart” justice that delivers empirically the best possible outcomes for society.

That is why we shouldn’t treat prison as a holding pen for society’s problems. If someone commits a serious crime it should be met with serious time. But for more minor offences we should look to keep many people, especially our young people, away from prison plugged into their communities instead. We need to keep them close to jobs and opportunity and use their brush with the law to show them a better path.

Tougher community sentences can help provide a solution. We need a community-based regime that can impose greater restrictions on people’s lifestyles and stricter requirements in terms of accessing treatment and support. And critically, these sentences must be enforced. For example, we have the option to use a GPS tag on an offender, meaning we can track them and provide greater reassurance for victims.

Ultimately we must boost our probation service to help deliver safe, effective and enforceable community sentences. We need to think more imaginatively about what punishments work in the modern world — ones that are punitive, for a purpose, and that make us all safer by reducing reoffending. If we follow the evidence, we will ultimately deliver for the public by making them safer.

David Gauke and Shaun Bailey

--oo00oo--

This is all very interesting, coming as it does during a new moral panic over knife crime with Theresa May finding time to chair a high-powered meeting at 10 Downing Street right in the middle of the Brexit crisis and suggesting an extraordinary new role for teachers. This from Reuters:-

May holds knife-crime summit with teachers ordered to identify violent youths

Prime Minister Theresa May held a special meeting on tackling Britain’s soaring knife-crime rate on Monday after the government announced new plans that could make teachers and health workers responsible for tackling violent behaviour. The meeting with experts in youth violence in May’s Downing Street office comes after a spate of high-profile deaths sparked a debate in Britain over whether a nationwide decline in the number of police officers is behind a rise in stabbings.

Over the weekend, four people were stabbed in what police said were unprovoked attacks in London. At least 48 people in Britain have been stabbed to death since the start of the year. The new proposals could see teachers, nurses and police officers held to account if they fail to spot warning signs of violent crime among young people.


“In recent months we’ve seen appalling number of young lives cut short or devastated by serious violence crime including a number of horrifying incidents this weekend,” May said. “In many cases the perpetrators of these crimes are as young as their victims and this is something that has to be of deep concern to us all.”

There were 285 fatal stabbings in England and Wales in 2018, the highest level since records began more than 70 years ago, officials statistics showed last month. Police say the surge in knife crime in a country where guns are hard to obtain has been driven by several factors, including rivalries between drug gangs, cuts to youth services and provocations on social media.

However, the government’s new approach faced opposition from some union officials and lawmakers. “Neither the blame for or the solution to violent crime can be laid at the door of schools or front-line hospital staff,” said Mary Bousted, who works at the National Education Union. "Schools already have strong safeguarding practices in place and staff will be alerted to any issues of concern. The problem is what happens after issues of concern have been identified.”

The Conservative lawmaker Jacob Rees-Mogg questioned the value of the summit. “I’ve never been convinced that summits solve anything very much, what you need is action,” he said on LBC radio.

--oo00oo--

Why is it that Tories, and our former Home Secretary in particular, never seem to understand that decimation of youth provision just might have consequences? In fact just like breaking up the Probation Service or privatising prisons such as HMP Birmingham that then have to be salvaged by the public sector? This on BBC website:- 

A crisis-hit prison is being taken back into public ownership after the private company running it had its contract terminated.

Security firm G4S was awarded a 15-year contract to run HMP Birmingham in 2011. In August 2018, Peter Clarke, the chief inspector of prisons, said the jail had fallen into a "state of crisis" and was the worst he had come across. The Prison Service took it over, initially for six months, in August and will now run it permanently.

Prisons Minister Rory Stewart said the prison had "made good progress" since being taken back under public control, but needed "stability and continuity". G4S said HMP Birmingham faced "exceptional challenges", including "high levels of prisoner violence towards staff and fellow prisoners". It said it was "in the best interests of staff and the company" that control transferred to Her Majesty's Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) .

In 2011, the government gave two estimates for the annual value of the contract to run HMP Birmingham - £21.1m to £31.2m. It is the second time in three years that G4S has lost a major public sector contract. It was forced to transfer the management of Medway Secure Training Centre to the government in 2016, after secret BBC filming showed staff allegedly mistreating children held there.


The company continues to operate four other jails, Altcourse, Oakwood, Parc and Rye Hill, as well as two immigration removal centres near Gatwick Airport - Brook House and Tinsley House. HMP Birmingham will formally be returned to the public sector in July with staff automatically moving across.

The Prison Officers Association (POA) said the prison "should never have been privatised in the first place". POA general secretary Steve Gillan said its members had campaigned hard to bring HMP Birmingham back under public control. "We will continue to campaign to get all prisons under public control where they rightfully belong," he said.

Although there have been some improvements at HMP Birmingham, conditions at the jail are believed to remain extremely difficult with very high levels of violence. Inspectors are due to return shortly to assess what progress has been made.


Roger Swindells, chairman of HMP Birmingham's Independent Monitoring Board, which conducts regular visits to the jail, said transferring it back to the public sector was "good news. I'm pleased there's some clear direction," he said. "It takes away the uncertainty - prisoners and staff have lived under a cloud for the past seven months."

Monday, 1 April 2019

Latest From Napo 187

Here we have selected highlights from Friday's Napo News Update by Ian Lawrence, General Secretary and Katie Lomas, National Chair:-

Napo is maintaining regular contact with Bob Neil Chair of the Justice Select Committee and there is a real push to bring as many cross party MP’s on board with our campaign to reunify probation and bring it back into public ownership. Branches have been sent postcards for members to send out to their local MP’s outlining 8 reasons to reunify probation and to highlight a specific local issue. NEC reps are being asked to go back to branches to ensure that this is happening and to actively get members on board to send out invites. Napo is organising a parliamentary drop in and a meeting for CRC representatives for 1st May at Westminster and branches will be able to send representatives to talk to MP’s and to encourage their own MP’s to attend.

RRP: Staffordshire West Midlands and Derby, Leicestershire, Nottinghamshire & Rutland CRC’s


Pay talks have not yet started with RRP but a joint claim with UNISON is being submitted. RRP has set up a Strategic Group Forum which is designed to enable RRP to engage with unions to discuss organisational matters that help to create a positive and inclusive environment. One of the issues that Napo will be raising will be a clear need for diversity training within the organisation following a number of incidents and racial stereotyping and cultural appropriation.

Workloads and a target driven working environment continue to be the biggest issues for members in both CRC’s. However, there is a growing issue of client engagement and local partnership agencies following RRP’s decision to reduce their estates and to bring the majority of Black Country work into Wolverhampton. Napo will be raising this at future JNCC’s. Recruitment is also likely to be an issue particularly in Birmingham following a mass exodus of staff to the NPS in a recent recruitment exercise.

WWM CRC: Warwickshire West Mercia

HMIP are due to carry out an inspection of this CRC at the end of March. It is clear that WWM CRC are anxious about this as they have been briefing staff to accentuate the positive work that they have been undertaking. The CRC is actively recruiting Probation Officers. Some staff are due to leave following a recruitment drive by the NPS and a skills gap is becoming more evident. The CRC is initiating a recruitment drive and Pay talks are due to start shortly.

Kent Surrey and Sussex CRC

The original KSS CRC contract has now been extended to include the CRC areas formerly managed by Working Links and new collective bargaining arrangements will shortly be discussed alongside the opening of pay negotiations.The unions priorities are to see the establishment of pay parity across the newly expanded KSS area, urgent remedial action on Workloads and immediate steps to improve the safety agenda for staff and clients and a change in approach from the disrespect that our members have suffered from their previous employer.

Interserve CRCs

All proceedings with Interserve Justice have been dominated by the dire financial situation of Interserve, their parent company. The company’s plans to de-leverage their debt were rejected by shareholders and early assurances were secured by the probation unions around job security and wages irrespective of the long term future of the CRC’s. This work has involved engagement with the TUC, the Labour front bench team and correspondence with Ministers. In other developments the Chief Inspector for Probation has published a report on the HLNY CRC which was was given a “required improvement” rating.

Sodexo CRCs

On workloads Napo has been engaging with the employer to address the ongoing issues across the six Sodexo CRCs. The unions were on the brink of registering a collective dispute but since then substantial steps have been taken to trial a new Workload Measurement Tool and further talks are scheduled.
Engagement on pay continues with Sodexo and at the time of writing Napo are examining the latest HMIP report giving the South Yorkshire CRC a rating as requiring improvement. Napo are also challenging the situation regarding the intention of Sodexo and other CRC owners to allow the appointment of Probation Officers who do not have the requisite qualifications. Further news on this issue which is being pursued nationally will follow

Durham Tees Valley CRC

HMIP inspected the CRC in November 2018. The overall assessment by the Inspectors was that the service “requires improvement”. Napo continues to press senior HMPPS management that whatever the future structure of probation there must be a role for the ‘mutual’ sector with appropriate resourcing being made available.

MTC – London and Thames Valley

MTC have re-stated their wish to expand their “market share” in probation following the withdrawal of AMEY from their partnership. Operationally, Thames Valley CRC has recently had its latest HMIP inspection outcome published. This was ‘requiring improvement’. There are recognised challenges in Thames Valley recruiting and retaining staff. There is already direct competition between the NPS and CRC with rumours of various incentives being investigated by Napo Reps. Workloads are very high in the CRC. In London, there are similar challenges around workload, recruitment and retention and professional delivery in any new contract.

Pay negotiations for the 2019 round are due to formally start shortly with the presentation of the joint Napo/Unison CRC claim. MTC have stated they want to pay similar rates to the NPS and progress people through their grade in a reasonable time but this will be dependent upon the terms of any new contracts – stating that doing so on the current terms would mean them losing money on the contracts.


NPS Updates

ViSOR news: Members may have seen the communication from Sonia Crozier this week detailing that there is an issue with the technological side of ViSOR so training is cancelled. We have been told that the ViSOR project will not stop but you can be assured that we will continue to make clear our position that the use of ViSOR as a secondary reporting system will place unnecessary additional workload at a time when our members are already struggling to cope.

Clarification on standing in elections: Members in most NPS roles at band 1-6 are classified as “politically free” in terms of the Civil Service Code restrictions on political activity. This means that members in these roles can stand for election to Council and Parish Council roles. If you plan to do this you should inform your line manager of your intention and of course of the outcome of the election. Election as a Member of Parliament is different. Members in these bands can be selected as a Prospective Parliamentary Candidate but at the point a General Election is officially called would have to resign as Civil Servants cannot be elected as a member of parliament. Anyone resigning for this reason and then failing to be elected as an MP would be immediately reinstated on the same terms. If you have a query about this please contact Katie Lomas.

OMiC update: We continue to meet with members of the HMPPS OMiC team. Members will know that Napo continue to make known our objection to the OMiC model. We welcome the keyworking element and believe that this will be an important and helpful addition to the prison regime but the case management model is fundamentally flawed because it builds in inconsistency in the crucial worker:client relationship at the most vulnerable points in the sentence. We also have concerns about the move to give offender management of around 30% of NPS custody cases to prison staff. This is not to suggest that those prison staff are not capable of offender management but if they are expected to do it they must be properly trained and have suitable experience of community OM work so that they understand how to manage risk in the community rather than in custody.

We continue to discuss the issues around workloads for people working in custody. We have asked for more information about the resourcing model and will share more updates when we have this. Finally we continue to discuss the issue of newly qualified probation officers (NQOs) being placed in a prison as their first qualified role. We have asked that the principles we are assured NPS are using be firmed up into a policy to ensure they cannot be varied when workload pressures bite. As a reminder to members the principles are that an NQO will only be placed in a prison where there is an established team of experienced officers and never in a situation where there are already other NQOs or a team new to prison work. Napo maintain that prison is not a suitable first placement for an NQO because most prison teams are small teams where it is difficult to offer the protected caseload and access to a variety of working styles and learning and support opportunities that NQOs need immediately after qualifying.

SSCL (Shared Services Connected Limited) overpayments

The NEC considered the position relating to the “over-payment” problems in the NPS. A separate briefing will follow for branches and negotiations continue with the NPS Pay team. Essentially, NPS HR say they are under pressure to recover all overpayments as a matter of principle. This has been delegated to SSCL. The majority of cases so far identified relate to previous payroll errors from SSCL, especially relating to the 2017 SOP (Single Operating Platform) updates; and disproportionately impact those who were on sick pay, maternity pay or who had otherwise changed their pay in that period. Having had to struggle to make sense of their pay and pension contributions for many months between 2017-18, and thinking these had finally been resolved, some members are now being chased for consequent alleged overpayments - arising from SSCL failing to properly apply the correct sick pay or maternity pay calculations.

Legal advice has been sought and we are tracking the position, whilst also seeking to continue constructive negotiations with the HMPPS. We are advising members impacted to automatically appeal on the grounds that they cannot trust the calculations from SSCL, contacted them and were told it was now ok and settled, etc. We are especially troubled by members who have retired between 2017 and now, who will have neither any access to an appeal or means of paying alleged overpayments without adjustments to their pension.

The NEC have given authority for Napo to enter a formal dispute if this is not resolved to our satisfaction urgently. Members are to be asked to submit details if they have unresolved issues around overpayments so please look out for more news.

Approved Premises (AP) Double Waking night cover (DWNC) and rota issues

The DWNC continues to be problematic with varied performance from the two providers OCS and Sodexo. HMPPS is now charging the providers for all failures (backdated to the start of contract) including a fines and the actual cost to HMPPS of the cover arrangements. In effect this means that the providers could be in a position where their charges and fines paid to HMPPS are in excess of the income they are receiving. Following a visit to the North West by Katie Lomas, Ian Lawrence and Sarah Friday, our members working in APs are being encouraged to use the official health and safety reporting systems to log any incidents or near misses relating to their work including incidents caused by the DWNC contractors failing to cover a shift or sending inappropriate staff. This includes reporting work related stress caused by the situation.

The AP rota that was supposed to be a model rota changed has caused serious difficulties, not least because the rota makes work life balance almost impossible and does not allow for flexible working arrangements. We have secured an agreement to review the rota starting this month (March) with reference to staff feedback and the HSE guidance on shift work.

The “Professional development" agenda

Napo support the efforts being made to offer professional development to staff and to develop the licence to practice and register but we have strongly objected to the description currently being used by the centre of “Professionalisation”. This suggests that our members are not professionals and it is frankly insulting. We have encouraged HMPPS to reflect on this term and to change it. We still await proper engagement on this important subject but a positive development was the announcement of a series of sessions to be delivered as part of Learning at Work Week in May. There will be around 70 events which will be face to face or virtual events delivered on a regional basis with workshops on a variety of topics.

We have asked for acknowledgement that most NPS frontline staff will struggle to access events when workloads are unacceptably high and have suggested that this is used as a basis for a programme of events to be made available on a rolling basis to ensure it is not just tokenistic but an integral part of our members working lives.

Professional issues remain a focus and a concern across all probation providers. Any reforms to probation going forward need to address these concerns and attract broad stakeholder support from the Magistrates Association to Howard League. Napo will be at the centre of those discussions with both the MOJ and CRCs.


Training for Napo reps - off to a great start!

The new Napo education programme has started to be rolled out and the first branch has received its training starting with module 1. A number of branches now have dates in the diary for starting the programme and the NEC heard that it is hoped that by the end of the year all branches will have started the Education Programme. The training package covers three modules: Module 1 covers how Napo works, our values, what roles you can choose to do and what support is available, the legal rights and protections that come with being an accredited local Napo representative, and how the branch can work to link collective local negotiations to campaigns. Module 2 covers representing individuals and provides the skills and knowledge on how to help resolve individual employment issues (Module 2 is optional for anyone who completes Module 1) and finally Module 3 will cover collectively developing a new Branch Development Plan and an individual plan.

Diversity

Women in Napo Conference: we now have around 70 women registered at the time of writing and more potentially to come. Securing facility time to assist attendance from the NPS has encouraged some CRCs to also offer paid time off for attendance and, as always, the event is a great way to inspire and activate women members.

February was LGBT History Month. To mark this occasion Napo joined together with PiPP (Pride in Prison and Probation) and probation employers to run a series of roadshows across the country. The aim of the roadshows was to provide an opportunity to raise awareness of LGBT issues for both staff and service users. The roadshows proved to be a great success and we have identified key issues that have come out from the workshops that we will now work towards addressing and reflect on how we can encourage employers to take action on LGBT issues.

Diversity: Napo worked closely with Sodexo on delivering our LGBT Roadshows. Nick Hall the Director of the Northern CRCs and Alex Osler Director for Essex CRC spoke at our event in Newcastle and London respectively. Northumbria CRC also paid for securing Newcastle Football ground to launch Napo’s LGBT Roadshows in Newcastle.

Lammy Recommendations: Napo and UNISON have written a letter to the Probation Minister Rory Stewart. The letter sets out our concerns about the lack of reach of the Lammy Review’s Recommendations (into outcomes for BAME individuals in the Criminal Justice System) and read across specifically for probation. We are awaiting a response from the Minster to our joint union letter.

Black Members’ Survey: There was a low take up for our survey soliciting the views of Black Members. We have been working with RISE and ABPO to explore ways to increase the response rate. Additionally, we have a date in the diary to meet with the Ministry of Justice so that we can increase the response rate amongst the staff group.


Health and Safety

Napo attended the UCU working group ‘Safety in Prisons’ meeting in January. This meeting of UCU and RCN, BMA, GMB. UNISON, POA, PCS and Unite unions – all with members who work in prisons have been meeting since last summer.

We have been working on a joint policy statement for the alliance, entitled “Safe Inside Unions in Prison Alliance’” This document outlines our intentions and a number of action points, including H&S systems for all staff, effective communication with unions on risk assessments and safe systems of work, tackling violence in prisons and the targeting of women, preventing exposure to Spice and adequate levels of prison officers.

We have also developed a survey to go to the joint unions prison based members in to find out about their experiences of working in the prison environment.

Sunday, 31 March 2019

Where Is The Evidence?

I notice Penelope Gibbs continues to be concerned about 'remote' supervision. This from LinkedIn:-  

Playing with fire – the risks of evidence free probation practice

The Chief Inspector of Probation this week expressed clearly what everyone involved thinks – that the model of privatised probation does not and cannot work. This model was never piloted or tested in any way. Equally many of the new practices CRCs (privatised probation companies) have adopted have never been tested either. 


The Chief Inspector has always been critical of the use of “remote” supervision – supervising and keeping in contact with clients by telephone rather than face to face. “A relationship needs to be formed, but up to 40% of individuals under supervision in some CRCs have been supervised by telephone only, usually following an initial meeting and assessment”. (I think the Chief Inspector is implying that some clients are never at any point seen face to face by their probation worker). In some CRCs the majority of the workers have no probation qualifications.

With, but particularly without, qualifications, probation supervision is difficult to do well. More than one academic study has pointed to “trust and strong communication” as pivotal to the worker-client relationship. It makes sense that replacing face to face meetings with telephone contact may affect trust and strong communication. But we do not know what the effects are because there is no reliable research: “there is no evidence to suggest that supervision by telephone alone is effective”. The only extensive research on the success of online/telephone consultations has been in health settings where some studies on some conditions suggest some successful outcomes. But criminal justice is very different to health, particularly because probation consultations are compulsory. So we don’t know what we don’t know.

At least the Probation Inspectorate has established that there is no good research on telephone probation supervision. There has been no review of international research in relation to other interactions which the probation service has been forced to do online. Now many “meetings” for pre-sentence reports, risk assessments of those in prison and parole hearings are done on video rather than face to face. But there is no research that I know of on the impact of having these interactions on video.

Probation practice has been profoundly changed by the impetus to communicate with clients on the telephone/on video. My understanding is that probation practitioners would always prefer to talk to clients face to face but that pressure of workloads and the demands of court reform stop them doing so.

We are playing with fire. If we don’t know what effect telephone and video interactions have on the probation-client relationship, should we be allowing these to become the default?

Penelope Gibbs 
Director of Transform Justice 
Visiting Fellow, Kellogg College, University of Oxford

Saturday, 30 March 2019

Another Pesky Million!

Well, another milestone rapidly approaches with the blog due to sail past the six millionth 'hit' some time today. It's taken us 15 months to clock up this million, whereas the last only took just over 12, a fact that neatly confirms what this graph and my instinct tells me, namely that interest is steadily waning, but has picked up a bit since TR2 came over the horizon. What is still quite evident is that every time probation hits the news, this blog becomes the go-to-place:- 

Graph of Blogger page views

But to be honest, I'm really not sure where things go from here. Some time ago the blog became dedicated to a fight for the soul and survival of something that I feel was worthwhile, honourable and just plain 'right'. It's been a big part of my life ever since I first set foot in a probation office and felt immediately 'at home'. It seems to me we've won all the arguments; garnered all the evidence; recruited all the malcontents; identified the humbug; called-out the hypocrisy and recorded the time-line, but despite all our efforts, are we really any nearer to recovering much of our profession?

Despite recent confirmation that TR is officially dead, many of us remain to be convinced that TR2 can be prevented, but even if it is, do we really want to become re-united under Civil Service command and control? I think not.




"End of an era....NPS saying fond farewell to Michael Spurr, who has spent his career promoting the best of prison and probation. Thank you Michael."  Kilvinder Twitter 29/03/19
 
Understandably, many good people can only have so much energy for fighting and the inherent negativity can be draining and not at all healthy for anyone in the long term, myself included. Not surprisingly many people have 'moved on', a fact that is not lost on those in government, MoJ or the privateers and other 'chancers' determined to never admit that TR was a total fucking disaster and simply carry on regardless. I sense the inevitability of a steady decline for the blog. I've already written regarding a noticeable drop-off in the quality and quantity of contributions, a situation unlikely to improve I suspect. 

As many are aware, other social media platforms are available, which is just as well given that the heavily-moderated Napo members 'Forum' died a death some time ago, either through deliberate act or simple carelessness. Facebook has become the new platform of choice for many, especially the notoriously 'secret' group with an impressive 2,200 members, including some contributing Napo staff. 

Despite the description and as is often highlighted, this group cannot be regarded as 'secret' and it must be assumed employers and others read it. Despite this, many people are signed-in under real identities and the discussion is often informative, thought-provoking and lively, just such a shame that it is neither public nor secret, but sort of 'semi private'. A bit like Freemasonry, it must irritate some potential members if they fail to find a way of gaining access. Just as there are potential issues posting on such a site, there are also pros and cons with anonymous contributing, as on the blog. 'You pays your money and takes your choice' as they say.   

Starting this blog was the easiest thing in the world. Although inordinately time-consuming and on occasions stressful, it's also been a great privilege and mostly enormous fun, but I know full well that deciding how it ends and when is going to be one of the hardest decisions I will ever have to make, but not just yet some will be relieved to hear. I think there is still a bit more mileage left before I'm willing to give up and concede defeat, but dear reader, to a large extent it depends on you, your continued interest and most important of all, your  contributions! 

Thanks for making the blog what it continues to be - the go-to-place for probation.        

A Dichotomy

Lets start with a question:-
"Re SYCRC inspection report. It is confusing, commented here before, how leadership is rated outstanding and yet every aspect of case supervision is rated as inadequate or requiring improvement. Can someone explain why this keeps being the case in inspection reports? It does not seem to add up, what am I missing?"
From the inspection report:-

"The CRC has found it difficult to recruit and train qualified staff and has made the decision to deliver the Professional Qualification in Probation (PQiP) in-house, and now has 11 staff progressing through the programme."

"A minority of operational staff (16.7 full-time equivalent) are qualified probation officers. The majority of responsible officers are probation service officers, many are new to this role and some have progressed from support roles. The CRC has put in place extensive development programmes, with varying degrees of effectiveness. Emphasis has been put on performance management and quality assurance, with a dedicated team of operational assurance staff taking a leading role in supporting the quality of practice through a variety of assurance and development processes. Data from the cases examined suggests that these processes have not had the full impact intended, as the CRC has yet to audit cases against the HMI Probation standards for the quality of supervision."

"Dynamic senior leadership has driven forward change at a fast pace, supported by an effective performance management system. The organisation has made great progress in improving performance and is now meeting or exceeding all key contractual performance targets."

"Most operational staff are unqualified and require more extensive training in assessing and managing risk of harm to others." 

"Most staff have seen at least one change of manager in the past year, for a variety of reasons. Greater stability is required to make staff supervision and development more consistent and effective."

"There are too many instances where individuals under supervision experience frequent changes of supervisor, which adversely affects their engagement with services and the consistency of service delivery."

"The assessment of risk of harm to others is not good enough, and deficiencies in identifying relevant information on file, or which can be obtained from other statutory partners, result in inadequate planning and provision of interventions to keep others safe."

"Skills in analysing factors linked to offending and the effective management of risk of harm to others are not well enough understood by all practitioners."


Here's yesterday's press release:-

South Yorkshire CRC - Beginning to address problems arising from shortage of qualified probation officers

South Yorkshire Community Rehabilitation Company (CRC) was found by inspectors to have weak case supervision, with some inadequate aspects and a lack of qualified probation staff.

However, though the inspection in November and December rated the Sodexo-owned CRC as ‘Requires Improvement’ inspectors also found an outstanding leadership team which was driving improvements.

Dame Glenys Stacey, HM Chief Inspector of Probation, said: “The CRC is making significant changes to its operating model. Individuals will no longer be subject to telephone-only supervision, and leaders have taken swift action – following our findings in Sodexo’s Northumbria CRC – to improve the important work of assessing each individual subject to probation supervision.”

The rate and frequency of reoffending by people under supervision in the CRC area was found to be comparatively high. In response, Dame Glenys said, “senior leaders are working with partner agencies on a laudable initiative to prioritise resources to those who are most frequently arrested.”

The CRC, she added, “must be sure to take the right steps in these and other cases.” More accredited programmes were needed, along with interventions to improve individuals’ accommodation and employment prospects.

Inspectors identified inexperienced staff as a problem in case supervision work. The number of qualified probation officers had fallen considerably since Sodexo took ownership of the CRC in 2015.

Dame Glenys said: “Alarmingly, although individual workloads are not generally excessive, the large majority of probation staff here are not qualified, and many are not sufficiently experienced at managing risk of harm to others.

“The CRC is training staff to achieve the Professional Qualification in Probation (PQiP), and putting substantial effort into quality management but, at present, the skills gaps are reflected in the poor quality of assessment and planning work with individuals.”

The report noted that weak assessments, leading to poor planning, “often resulted in insufficient attention being given to the likelihood of individuals posing a risk of harm to others. This was made worse when information from domestic violence units or children’s social care services had not been obtained, or when contact levels had been too low to monitor individuals effectively.”

However, Dame Glenys added that more recent assessments had shown improvement. Inspectors found the CRC had recently introduced a more comprehensive assessment model.

Overall, Dame Glenys said:

“Unpaid work delivery in this CRC is good, but urgent improvements are needed to the rest of its work, and in probation supervision overall. There have been too many changes of practitioners for individuals under supervision, and those practitioners have also experienced changes in line managers. That needs to stop now, so far as possible, and leaders must concentrate on improving the skills base, and with it the quality of work delivered.”

Friday, 29 March 2019

Prison - More or Less?

Now that TR has been officially pronounced dead and a plan B is emerging as an alternative to TR2, this piece by Richard Garside sheds some light on what's happening on the prison front.

Ending the prisons whack-a-mole

The UK government’s decision, earlier this year, to scrap plans to build a new prison at Port Talbot, south Wales, was an important victory in the battle against prison expansion. “Welsh communities are still quite reluctant to build new prisons”, Rory Stewart, the prisons minister, told the House of Commons Welsh Affairs Committee in January. On future prison builds, he added:

We do not want to repeat the experience of Port Talbot where we decided to go somewhere and suddenly found there was a strong community objection to it.
The local MP, Stephen Kinnock, was “very strongly opposed” to building the prison, Stewart acknowledged. The Assembly Member, David Rees, was among a number of local politicians who likewise opposed the plans. Speaking in a debate in Parliament in September 2017, the Plaid Cymru home affairs spokesperson, Liz Saville Roberts, had said: “Port Talbot has been through some tough times of late, but the answer is unequivocally not to turn Wales’ industrial powerhouse into a penal colony on an industrial scale”.

Having previously supported the plans, the Welsh Government changed its mind. “I do not believe it is in the interests either of the Welsh Government or people in Wales, to see further prison development in Wales”, the Cabinet Secretary for Local Government and Public Services, Alun Davies, announced in April 2018.

The combination of local campaign, and opposition by elected politicians, was probably decisive. Without the local campaign against the prison, the elected politicians in Wales could well have swung the other way. The local campaign would also probably not have succeeded without political support.

Despite this success, the underlying dynamic continues to favour prison growth. Ministers speak vaguely of reducing the prison population, while pursuing policies that in the here-and-now fuel further growth. None of the main political parties question the resort to imprisonment, nor show any serious interest in reversing the growth of recent decades. Indeed, they appear content to see further expansion.

The proposed prison in Port Talbot was but part of bigger plan — announced in the 2016 White Paper, Prison Safety and Reform — to build 10,000 new prison places at an estimated cost of £1.3 billion. A new prison in Yorkshire was announced by the then Justice Secretary, Liz Truss, in March 2017, along with the redevelopment of several other prison sites.

While local activism and electoral politics combined in south Wales to scupper the government’s plans, this will not necessarily be the case elsewhere. Speaking of other potential prison sites, Rory Stewart told the Welsh Affairs Committee that “we are looking for communities that see the point of it, want to engage with us and would welcome our investment”. Those communities badly hit by recession and austerity would make for the obvious recipients of such apparent largesse. The potential for local coalitions of community activists, politicians and business in favour of new prisons should not be discounted.

Until we can change the national policy agenda from prison expansion to prison closure, campaigns against new prisons face being caught up in an endless game of prisons whack-a-mole. As one new prison is stopped — in this case Port Talbot — others pop up: Glen Parva and Wellingborough, for instance. As anyone who has played that game knows, there is only ever one winner: the moles. Winning the game means stopping the game: replacing the incessant movement towards prison growth with an unceasing drive towards prison closure.

While the government plans for prison growth, there are tantalising signs of a potential consensus on the need for the system to shrink. The current Justice Secretary for England and Wales, David Gauke, recently stated that prison “doesn’t work, and indeed, makes us less safe”. Last year, he told The Times that he “would like [the prison population]… to fall”.

In 2016, the former chief inspector of prisons, Lord Ramsbotham, told the BBC that 30 per cent of those currently in prison in England and Wales — some 25,000 people — did not need to be there and should be released. The Conservative chair of the House of Commons Justice Committee, Bob Neill, said that “ we should be looking to start reducing the prison population straight away”.

A jointly-authored letter, published in The Times in December 2016, called for the government to pursue policies to reduce the prison population “to the levels it was under Margaret Thatcher. That would mean eventually reducing prison numbers to about 45,000”. The three signatories had previously served in government as deputy prime minister (Nick Clegg), justice secretary and home secretary (Ken Clarke), and home secretary (Jacqui Smith).

These interventions point to the potential for a broad-based consensus on the need to close prisons. But it is a potential consensus only, lacking in the concrete capacity to act; to pursue the changes needed to make the consensus a reality. This political inertia, this stuckness, was well expressed by Rory Stewart last year, during an appearance before the House of Commons Justice Committee.

“We can do one of two things: we either… gamble everything on being able to reduce the prison population; or we can do what I would be tempted to do, which is to say that I do not feel, I am afraid, even though ideally the prison population will go down, that that is very likely to happen, because I am not sure that there is the will among the public or Parliament to take the kind of measures to reduce that population.”
With the desirable policy of shrinking the system seemingly unattainable, ministers and civil servants pursue the seemingly attainable, but undesirable, policy of prison growth. Unsurprisingly, this feeds a pessimism about the political process, and the capacity for it to deliver meaningful change.

One response to the apparent incapacity of formal politics to deliver meaningful change has been the development of new activist groups pressing explicitly prison abolitionist demands. These include the Empty Cages Collective, Community Action on Prison Expansion (which emerged out of the Empty Cages Collective), and the Incarcerated Workers Organising Committee. These groups are, to quote from David Scott’s recent book, Against Imprisonment, “generally very small in number and most members are known to each other prior to the formation of the specific abolitionist organisations”.

Eschewing any meaningful engagement with mainstream political debates, these groups have focused on local activism and direct action. On International Women’s Day earlier this month, for instance, they mounted a protest at the Ministry of Justice, alongside other groups including Bent Bars, Sister not Cis-ter, Sisters Uncut, and Women’s Strike Assembly.

The abolition of women’s prisons was, however, only incidental to the main purpose of the protest. Working under the banner of the ‘Trans Liberation Assembly’, their main demand was for trans women prisoners — those male-born prisoners who identify as women — to be held in women’s prisons.

A number of these same groups also played an active role in shutting down a planned conference on prison abolition, because one of the conference organisers was deemed not to hold the ‘correct’ line on the nature of transgender identities.

The obvious irony of supposedly abolitionist organisations seeking to shut down a conference on prison abolitionism is a symptom of a wider problem. If allegiance to a particular, and highly contested, stance in relation to identity politics forms the basis for entry to the prison abolitionist fold, the movement is likely to remain small, insignificant, riven by dogmatism.

Prison abolitionist activism, at least as practised by such groups, therefore faces the opposite problem to that faced by mainstream politics. In the case of mainstream politics, the potential for a broad-based consensus to close prisons is hampered by a political inertia, an inability to act on that potential consensus. In the case of abolitionist activism, the undoubted willingness to act is hampered by the enforcement of group-think far too narrow and intolerant to enable a broad-based abolitionist movement for change to emerge.

If we are to end the prisons whack-a-mole, the potential, broad-based consensus for shrinking, rather than expanding the system, needs to be combined with the capacity to act decisively to deliver on this consensus. This will require stamina and staying power, rather than speed and drama: what the authors of A Presumption Against Imprisonment describe as an “inevitably slow and arduous process of changing public and political thinking about the use of imprisonment”.

Delivering on this potential will require a combination of the parliamentary and the extra-parliamentary: work through the formal political channels, connected with on-the-ground collaborative activity and mobilisation, grounded in inclusive values.

Richard Garside
Director of the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies