Gosh, it's been a long time since Nacro featured on these pages! Maybe those with very long memories or are simply curious might like to pop Nacro in the search box and be taken back to almost the very origins of the blog, 2010 and The Dog that Doesn't Bark. Clearly some readers have long memories:-
"Nacro have developed a massively over-inflated sense of their own importance following their association with sodexo & the McDowells episode. Remember that?"McDowell led Nacro as Chief Executive from 2009 to 2014 before taking up the independent post of Chief Inspector of Probation in February 2014... In late 2014, the Ministry of Justice privatised regional probation services, awarding six of the 21 contracts to a partnership between outsourcing firm Sodexo Justice Services and McDowell's former employer, Nacro... McDowell's wife, Janine McDowell, worked as a senior manager and deputy managing director at Sodexo Justice Services... While McDowell declared his wife's role to the Ministry of Justice upon his appointment, the connection was omitted during his pre-appointment scrutiny hearing before the House of Commons Justice Select Committee"
So, having revisited the saga of Nacro getting into bed with Sodexo, a prison and probation operator and the TR Omnishambles, I thought I'd ask the genie in the bottle "Has Nacro gone soft on campaigning?" Genie said:-
Whether Nacro has "gone soft" on campaigning depends on how its current strategy is compared against its historical roots and peer organisations. While critics have previously accused the charity of softening its stance due to its heavy reliance on government service-delivery contracts, Nacro maintains a structured policy and campaigning arm focused on pragmatic, incremental reform.Why Critics Have Accused Nacro of "Going Soft"
Service Delivery vs. Radical Reform. Historically, Nacro was closely associated with outspoken penal reform. Over the past two decades, it evolved into a major provider of government-commissioned housing, education, and resettlement services. In a 2009 profile in The Guardian, Harry Fletcher of the National Association of Probation Officers explicitly accused Nacro of having "gone soft" due to its apparent silence on major penal reform compared to pure campaigning bodies like the Howard League for Penal Reform and the Prison Reform Trust.
Contractural Constraints. Because Nacro bids for and delivers substantial public sector contracts across England and Wales, critics within the voluntary sector have long noted the tension between acting as a government contractor and publicly opposing government justice policy. At the time, Nacro's leadership acknowledged it could "do better" on speaking out, while emphasising that frontline service delivery and cross-sector cooperation were its primary priorities.
Evidence of Active Campaigning
Despite those criticisms, Nacro's campaigning hub demonstrates ongoing policy advocacy rather than an abandonment of campaigning. Under its 2025–2028 Strategy, Nacro lists "Campaigning for change for the people we support" as one of its five core priorities. Recent activity includes:
Targeted Legislative and Policy Wins. Nacro has focused on specific, achievable operational changes in prisons and resettlement. It cites successes in ending Friday prison releases, securing a commitment to 12 weeks of transitional housing for prison leavers, raising the prison discharge grant from £46 to £82.39, and achieving a 20% reduction in public prison phone call costs alongside a £1/week prison wage increase in 2025.
Lived-Experience Advocacy. Through initiatives like its Justice ExChange and Truth About Youth reports, Nacro uses service-user testimony to lobby policymakers on physical healthcare in prisons, post-release mortality rates, and youth disengagement from post-16 education.
Public Policy Briefings. In late 2026, Nacro actively challenged government policy on prison capacity—calling for a focus on reducing probation recalls—and criticised gaps in post-16 education and supported housing funding.
Summary
Rather than stopping campaigning altogether, Nacro operates differently from pure pressure groups. Organisations like the Howard League focus exclusively on legal and systemic advocacy without holding government service contracts, allowing them to take a more confrontational stance. Nacro uses its position as a large frontline service provider to push for practical, evidence-based adjustments within the justice, housing, and education systems.
--oo00oo--
Basically Nacro have popped up due to a degree of excitement surrounding their latest report from The Better Futures Project and based on responses from service users. It's always good to get the views and experiences from this group and the findings are not surprising to many probation staff:-
As the provisions of the Sentencing Act come into force, a strong and effective Probation Service becomes ever more critical, as are the services in the community which support rehabilitation.
To build a justice system for the future, the services that support people in the community – both the Probation Service and the voluntary sector organisations that provide vital support – need to have the funding and the resource to do the job well. This report highlights positive examples of probation officers providing high-quality support and creating relationships to help people build their lives and move away from offending. But it also highlights examples where the challenges the Probation Service has faced over many years have led to poor levels of trust and support. The identification of what is important and the qualities and strengths of a good probation officer brings real opportunities to learn and develop. Ultimately, the ability to build productive and supportive relationships is key.
The purpose of sharing the views of people with lived experience in this report is not to develop a list of recommendations, but to ensure that the experiences of those who have been under probation supervision are shared, heard and taken into account. However, at a time of significant change as the Sentencing Act come into effect, there are emerging themes highlighted that require greater focus. Strengthening the role and effectiveness of the Probation Service will ultimately increase peoples’ chances of turning their lives around, moving away from crime, and reducing reoffending:
Fulfilling the dual role of probation through effective rehabilitation: The most effective way to protect the public is to support effective rehabilitation, enabling people leaving custody to build a stable life and contribute to society. If the focus on public protection and the management of risk takes precedence over rehabilitation, or becomes the sole focus, rehabilitation can be undermined and lasting change can then be limited.
Fulfilling the dual role of probation through effective rehabilitation: The most effective way to protect the public is to support effective rehabilitation, enabling people leaving custody to build a stable life and contribute to society. If the focus on public protection and the management of risk takes precedence over rehabilitation, or becomes the sole focus, rehabilitation can be undermined and lasting change can then be limited.
Recruitment and training of probation staff: The feedback from people who have been supervised by the Probation Service and the qualities they believe to be key in probation officers should directly inform recruitment and training. These include honesty; listening and people skills; empathy and a caring non-judgmental attitude.
Lower risk doesn’t equal lower need: As probation supervision changes to prioritise those who present the highest risk, those with a wide range of needs, such as mental health, substance misuse and housing must not be overlooked. Those who represent less immediate or severe risk to the public are often people caught in the revolving door of offending, or at risk of their offending becoming prolific if they aren’t able to access support.
Recall: The huge increase in the use of recall has clearly impacted the relationships people have with their probation officers. The framework to support decisions to recall needs to support effective decision-making and be fair and proportionate, balancing public protection with the impact on the rehabilitation of the individual.
Pre-sentence reports: The capacity of probation to prepare high-quality pre-sentence reports in conjunction with each individual is essential. This will ensure that sentencing decisions are well-informed, as well as considering how to best to support rehabilitation and reducing reoffending.
Probation in prisons: Effective transitions from prison to community are only possible if supported by smooth handovers between prison and community probation officers, ensuring sharing of information and release plans with licence conditions that are informed by previous engagement and supportive of growth.
Pre-sentence reports: The capacity of probation to prepare high-quality pre-sentence reports in conjunction with each individual is essential. This will ensure that sentencing decisions are well-informed, as well as considering how to best to support rehabilitation and reducing reoffending.
Probation in prisons: Effective transitions from prison to community are only possible if supported by smooth handovers between prison and community probation officers, ensuring sharing of information and release plans with licence conditions that are informed by previous engagement and supportive of growth.
Employing people with lived experience in both probation and the voluntary sector: The insight and experiences of people with lived experience are invaluable to creating a diverse and knowledgeable workforce that can best support people on probation. To make this a reality there must be a greater focus on mentoring roles, overcoming current barriers of vetting, stigma and lack of relevant work experience.
No comments:
Post a Comment