--oo00oo--
Well, perhaps this finally puts to bed the suggestion that concerns about probation workloads are simply a minority of disillusioned staff moaning.
Over 70% turnout in both Napo ballots, with 87.4% of valid votes cast on the workload question supporting action short of a strike. That’s a considerable expression of concern from a workforce that has spent years being told about transformation, efficiency, resilience and the importance of public protection.
And now, from 23 November, PPs are being asked to do something that really shouldn’t be considered extraordinary. Work their contracted hours.
I imagine HMPPS has been busy preparing its Gold Command contingency arrangements for industrial action. Entirely understandable, of course. Public protection responsibilities don’t disappear during an industrial dispute. But I do wonder how much attention and resource is being devoted to managing the consequences of staff working their contracted hours, compared with addressing why the service has become so dependent upon people working beyond them in the first place. Because if working to contracted hours creates an operational crisis, surely the crisis existed long before the industrial action began?
HMPPS has already acknowledged that the Probation Service is unsustainable. Yet individual PPs remain responsible for managing complex risks, meeting statutory deadlines, responding to emergencies and making defensible decisions within workloads that frequently exceed the time realistically available.
So what happens when that additional goodwill is no longer there? Who determines which work takes priority? Who takes responsibility for the tasks that cannot reasonably be completed? And how will individual PPs be protected from being held accountable for failures arising from organisational capacity rather than their own professional decisions?
These are not simply questions for Napo members. They are questions for those responsible for directing, resourcing and overseeing the Probation Service.
For years, professional commitment has helped bridge the gap between what the organisation demands and what its staffing capacity can realistically deliver. But commitment should never be mistaken for an unlimited resource. And perhaps that’s what makes this ballot result so significant. Thousands of staff have now formally expressed their unwillingness to continue accepting the conditions under which they’re expected to deliver probation. We talk endlessly about resilience, but resilience cannot mean expecting individuals to absorb organisational failure indefinitely.
HMPPS may well have contingency plans for the industrial action beginning on 23 November. But where is the contingency plan for a Probation Service that can no longer rely on the unpaid labour and goodwill of its workforce to keep it functioning? Because you can prepare for industrial action. You can't contingency plan your way out of the underlying reasons people voted for it.
*****
Regarding UNISON, I do find the different positions taken by the unions concerning, particularly at a time when probation desperately needs a collective voice.
I can understand why some colleagues might regard 5% as an offer worth accepting, especially given the financial pressures many are experiencing. Equally, I understand Napo’s concerns about the longer term implications for pay progression and the failure to adequately address the erosion of probation pay.
But what troubles me is the division this risks creating within an already fragmented workforce. We’ve seen enough of that throughout probation’s recent history, particularly during TR. Colleagues who were once part of the same profession found themselves divided by organisational structures and decisions they had little control over. We should be extremely cautious about allowing another divide to develop between staff represented by different unions.
Ultimately, Napo and UNISON members are working within the same service, facing many of the same excessive workloads, staffing shortages, professional responsibilities and pressures.
Those difficulties don’t disappear because one union recommends accepting a pay offer while another rejects it. And perhaps that is the bigger issue. Pay cannot be considered entirely separately from workloads, retention and the increasing demands placed upon PPs. What does a 5% increase actually achieve in the longer term if the working conditions driving experienced colleagues out of the profession remain largely unchanged?
I respect the democratic decisions made by members of both unions, but I would hope their leaderships can continue working together on the issues that unite their members rather than allowing their different negotiating positions to become another source of division. Because the employer remains the same, the pressures remain the same, and the need for a properly resourced, professionally valued Probation Service remains exactly the same.
The last thing probation needs is another situation where those doing the work become divided while the underlying problems remain unresolved.
*****
I remember when I first started out in work, on a paid YTS, if anyone remembers those! Someone from one of the major unions came along and explained why paying £1.50 a week in subscriptions was worthwhile. By the end of the talk, we realised he wasn’t just some union representative; he was the General Secretary. We all signed up, got involved and participated. We felt part of something. Even through my student year I maintained union membership of one form or another.
Fast forward to probation. I changed my union affiliation to one of the main probation unions, but apart from the very early days, I never really felt involved. There was little opportunity to participate. I regularly challenged the status quo and the employer, applied to become a union rep, but as far as the local branch was concerned, my face didn’t fit, and they made it crystal clear.
At the same time, probation was going downhill, union communication was abysmal and local representation wasn’t particularly great either. Anyone remember the Napo forum? We had some brilliant conversations and debates on there until it was shut down. That’s around the time I found this blog. When I needed representation, getting the union on board was a chore. Phone calls were passed around, emails went unanswered, delays for representation were endless and, in the end, I did most of the work myself. When I challenged them about this, I was treated as the enemy. The irony is that when I eventually spoke directly to the General Secretary, the very person others seemed so keen to criticise, he was the one who actually listened and helped.
Despite all this, I lived through two periods of industrial action I can remember. The first time, I didn’t join the strike. How could I stand alongside the same union clique of members and branch reps who I knew had been actively stabbing me in the back? The second time, during TR, I had moved to a better location. I joined the protests, stood around a burning oil drum (until the fire brigade came and outed the fire) and marched through the streets with placards.
Following TR, probation unions failed, disappeared or fundamentally changed. I left that union and joined another, partly to ensure I had access to representation should I need it in the future. When I eventually needed representation, I specifically requested an external rep. They were excellent. I still did a lot of the work myself, but one thing they did exceptionally well was to listen and to represent me. No delays in responding, no avoiding calls, no telling me how busy they were, and no fudging, dishonesty or side deals with management. There is a trade-off. I don’t feel as up to date with probation-specific communications, I no longer get to attend specialist AGMs and I probably won’t be involved in future strike action. But I’m still active in my own way. I still encourage people to join a union, even the union I previously had to leave for my own sanity and safety, hoping it’s changed for the better.
So please, don’t shut people out and withhold information because they’re not attending your union meetings or standing on your picket line. Don’t make assumptions based on whether we’re Gen X, Gen Y, millennials, Black, White, gay, straight, or anything else. There’s already too much of that coming from the ivory tower. Unions should be demonstrating a better way, not reproducing the same divisions. You don’t know everyone’s journey, what they’ve experienced or why they’ve made the choices they have. Instead of asking why someone isn’t standing alongside you, perhaps ask what needs to change to make them want to. Collective strength is built by bringing people together, not pushing people away.
Probation Officer
*****
I find the comments about QDOs and PTAs rather disappointing, particularly given the wider discussion we’ve been having about professional development, the loss of experience and the need to support newly qualified POs.
We cannot spend one day lamenting the erosion of professional expertise and the lack of meaningful development, then spend the next suggesting that those working in roles intended to support quality and learning should simply be returned to frontline caseloads. That’s not to say every role is effective, every appointment is appropriate or that the balance between operational and non-operational staffing shouldn’t be scrutinised. Of course it should.
But surely the question is whether those roles are delivering meaningful support, strengthening professional judgement and improving the quality of probation practice? A well-supported PO is not a luxury. Neither is good quality training, reflective practice or professional development. And let’s not forget that the people occupying these roles did not design the staffing model, determine the pay offer or create the workload crisis.
We’ve spent considerable time discussing how divided probation has become. Yet here we are, dividing ourselves again into those supposedly doing the ‘real work’ and those who apparently aren’t. Perhaps we should direct more of our scrutiny towards the decisions that have left the service so overstretched, rather than assuming colleagues in different roles are somehow responsible for the conditions we’re all working under.
Because if we’re serious about renewing probation, we need to value the people delivering supervision and the people helping them develop the knowledge and skills to deliver it well. Those should be complementary responsibilities, not competing ones.
*****
The UK Government has defended a pay offer to probation workers which has been rejected and sparked a threat of strikes. Members of Napo have voted in favour of industrial action over pay as well as their workloads. In a statement, the union confirmed: “We will be calling on our members in Probation England and Wales to commence a campaign of Industrial Action on Monday 23 November.”
Initially, staff will still work their contracted hours but will not undertake any overtime. Members have also voted in favour of strikes, but no walkout dates have been confirmed yet."
- Here's the mendacious MoJ's less than original take on events:
"The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal.
A spokesman said: “Probation staff do a vital job protecting the public, which is why we have put a strong offer on the table giving every worker a further 5% pay rise, which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade alongside record investment ... We’re also recruiting an additional 1,300 officers to significantly cut workloads."
“While we are disappointed that some have voted against this competitive deal, it will not change our first responsibility of protecting the public and we have robust contingency plans in place to ensure offenders are still subject to the same rigorous supervision."
___________________________________________________
Hansard, Feb 2025: "Probation is currently in a multi-year pay deal covering the period 1 April 2022 to 31 March 2025. This pay deal has provided certainty in pay increases throughout the period while securing necessary reforms to the pay structure helping to resolve some longstanding pay issues."
ghost in't' machine says:
Cumulative Pay vs. Cost of Living: According to probation trade unions (Napo, UNISON, and GMB/SCOOP), the cumulative nominal rise in probation staff pay points between 2010 and 2024 was roughly 11%, while RPI/cost-of-living metrics rose by over 81.2% over the same period, leaving real-terms pay significantly behind
Austerity and Pay Freezes (2010s): Following the 2010 general election, public sector pay freezes and 1% public sector pay caps severely suppressed annual increments across the Probation Service for much of the decade.
The 2022–2024 Multi-Year Deal: A previous multi-year framework yielded low annual increases (such as 3.2% in 2023 and 4.5% in 2024) that lagged behind high inflation peaks
The 2025 Settlement (6% Award): Following union campaigns, rejections of initial government offers (such as an earlier 4% proposal), and ballot threats for industrial action, HMPPS and the government finalized a 6% increase across all pay points and cash allowances, backdated to April 1, 2025
Current Pay Framework (Post-2025)
• PQiP: £28,064 nationally
• PSO, Band 3: £28,064 – £33,549.
• Band 4: £37,238 – £44,520
• Band 5: £46,746 – £48,760
Let's have a look at those MoJ words again:
"The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal." - aye, 2/3 = most; so well done unison & gmb for shafting your colleagues. However pisspoor napo have been over the last two decades, at least their members have managed to make a stand this time.
"giving every worker a further 5% pay rise" - annual pay deals are just that; they will always be "a further" whatever, its not special treatment or a generous donation.
"which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade" - yep, because there's been fuck all for over a decade
MP pay rise history since 2010
April 2010 – March 2011: £65,73
May 2015 – March 2016: £74,000 (+10.3%)
April 2022 – March 2023: £84,144 (+2.7%)
April 2023 – March 2024: £86,584 (+2.9%)
April 2024 – March 2025: £91,346 (+5.5%)
April 2025 – March 2026: £93,904 (+2.8%)
April 2026 onward: £98,599 (+5.0%)
MPs: Overall ~42% increase since 2010
vs
Probation Band 4 (max): ~24% increase since 2010
*****
I find it quite sad to read that we apparently haven’t done anything professional in decades. Really? I agree that probation has been increasingly deprofessionalised over the years, but that doesn’t mean the people doing the job have somehow stopped being professionals.
We’re still making difficult decisions about risk, safeguarding and public protection every day, often with ridiculous workloads and nowhere near enough time to do the job as we’d like to.
That's what frustrates me. We’ve become so bogged down in processes, targets and prescribed ways of working that sometimes I wonder when we’re actually supposed to do probation. What happened to just sitting down and having a conversation with someone? Getting to know them, being curious, even a bit nosey! Picking up on something that doesn’t quite add up or noticing a change because you know the person well enough to recognise it. You can’t always put that into a structured intervention or tick a box to demonstrate it happened, but it’s often where the really important work takes place.
After all these years, I still believe in probation and the difference good practitioners can make. I just wish we were given the time and trusted to do it. Maybe the problem isn’t that we’ve stopped being professional. It’s that the organisation has increasingly stopped allowing us to practise like professionals.
Well, perhaps this finally puts to bed the suggestion that concerns about probation workloads are simply a minority of disillusioned staff moaning.
Over 70% turnout in both Napo ballots, with 87.4% of valid votes cast on the workload question supporting action short of a strike. That’s a considerable expression of concern from a workforce that has spent years being told about transformation, efficiency, resilience and the importance of public protection.
And now, from 23 November, PPs are being asked to do something that really shouldn’t be considered extraordinary. Work their contracted hours.
I imagine HMPPS has been busy preparing its Gold Command contingency arrangements for industrial action. Entirely understandable, of course. Public protection responsibilities don’t disappear during an industrial dispute. But I do wonder how much attention and resource is being devoted to managing the consequences of staff working their contracted hours, compared with addressing why the service has become so dependent upon people working beyond them in the first place. Because if working to contracted hours creates an operational crisis, surely the crisis existed long before the industrial action began?
HMPPS has already acknowledged that the Probation Service is unsustainable. Yet individual PPs remain responsible for managing complex risks, meeting statutory deadlines, responding to emergencies and making defensible decisions within workloads that frequently exceed the time realistically available.
So what happens when that additional goodwill is no longer there? Who determines which work takes priority? Who takes responsibility for the tasks that cannot reasonably be completed? And how will individual PPs be protected from being held accountable for failures arising from organisational capacity rather than their own professional decisions?
These are not simply questions for Napo members. They are questions for those responsible for directing, resourcing and overseeing the Probation Service.
For years, professional commitment has helped bridge the gap between what the organisation demands and what its staffing capacity can realistically deliver. But commitment should never be mistaken for an unlimited resource. And perhaps that’s what makes this ballot result so significant. Thousands of staff have now formally expressed their unwillingness to continue accepting the conditions under which they’re expected to deliver probation. We talk endlessly about resilience, but resilience cannot mean expecting individuals to absorb organisational failure indefinitely.
HMPPS may well have contingency plans for the industrial action beginning on 23 November. But where is the contingency plan for a Probation Service that can no longer rely on the unpaid labour and goodwill of its workforce to keep it functioning? Because you can prepare for industrial action. You can't contingency plan your way out of the underlying reasons people voted for it.
*****
Regarding UNISON, I do find the different positions taken by the unions concerning, particularly at a time when probation desperately needs a collective voice.
I can understand why some colleagues might regard 5% as an offer worth accepting, especially given the financial pressures many are experiencing. Equally, I understand Napo’s concerns about the longer term implications for pay progression and the failure to adequately address the erosion of probation pay.
But what troubles me is the division this risks creating within an already fragmented workforce. We’ve seen enough of that throughout probation’s recent history, particularly during TR. Colleagues who were once part of the same profession found themselves divided by organisational structures and decisions they had little control over. We should be extremely cautious about allowing another divide to develop between staff represented by different unions.
Ultimately, Napo and UNISON members are working within the same service, facing many of the same excessive workloads, staffing shortages, professional responsibilities and pressures.
Those difficulties don’t disappear because one union recommends accepting a pay offer while another rejects it. And perhaps that is the bigger issue. Pay cannot be considered entirely separately from workloads, retention and the increasing demands placed upon PPs. What does a 5% increase actually achieve in the longer term if the working conditions driving experienced colleagues out of the profession remain largely unchanged?
I respect the democratic decisions made by members of both unions, but I would hope their leaderships can continue working together on the issues that unite their members rather than allowing their different negotiating positions to become another source of division. Because the employer remains the same, the pressures remain the same, and the need for a properly resourced, professionally valued Probation Service remains exactly the same.
The last thing probation needs is another situation where those doing the work become divided while the underlying problems remain unresolved.
*****
I remember when I first started out in work, on a paid YTS, if anyone remembers those! Someone from one of the major unions came along and explained why paying £1.50 a week in subscriptions was worthwhile. By the end of the talk, we realised he wasn’t just some union representative; he was the General Secretary. We all signed up, got involved and participated. We felt part of something. Even through my student year I maintained union membership of one form or another.
Fast forward to probation. I changed my union affiliation to one of the main probation unions, but apart from the very early days, I never really felt involved. There was little opportunity to participate. I regularly challenged the status quo and the employer, applied to become a union rep, but as far as the local branch was concerned, my face didn’t fit, and they made it crystal clear.
At the same time, probation was going downhill, union communication was abysmal and local representation wasn’t particularly great either. Anyone remember the Napo forum? We had some brilliant conversations and debates on there until it was shut down. That’s around the time I found this blog. When I needed representation, getting the union on board was a chore. Phone calls were passed around, emails went unanswered, delays for representation were endless and, in the end, I did most of the work myself. When I challenged them about this, I was treated as the enemy. The irony is that when I eventually spoke directly to the General Secretary, the very person others seemed so keen to criticise, he was the one who actually listened and helped.
Despite all this, I lived through two periods of industrial action I can remember. The first time, I didn’t join the strike. How could I stand alongside the same union clique of members and branch reps who I knew had been actively stabbing me in the back? The second time, during TR, I had moved to a better location. I joined the protests, stood around a burning oil drum (until the fire brigade came and outed the fire) and marched through the streets with placards.
Following TR, probation unions failed, disappeared or fundamentally changed. I left that union and joined another, partly to ensure I had access to representation should I need it in the future. When I eventually needed representation, I specifically requested an external rep. They were excellent. I still did a lot of the work myself, but one thing they did exceptionally well was to listen and to represent me. No delays in responding, no avoiding calls, no telling me how busy they were, and no fudging, dishonesty or side deals with management. There is a trade-off. I don’t feel as up to date with probation-specific communications, I no longer get to attend specialist AGMs and I probably won’t be involved in future strike action. But I’m still active in my own way. I still encourage people to join a union, even the union I previously had to leave for my own sanity and safety, hoping it’s changed for the better.
So please, don’t shut people out and withhold information because they’re not attending your union meetings or standing on your picket line. Don’t make assumptions based on whether we’re Gen X, Gen Y, millennials, Black, White, gay, straight, or anything else. There’s already too much of that coming from the ivory tower. Unions should be demonstrating a better way, not reproducing the same divisions. You don’t know everyone’s journey, what they’ve experienced or why they’ve made the choices they have. Instead of asking why someone isn’t standing alongside you, perhaps ask what needs to change to make them want to. Collective strength is built by bringing people together, not pushing people away.
Probation Officer
*****
I find the comments about QDOs and PTAs rather disappointing, particularly given the wider discussion we’ve been having about professional development, the loss of experience and the need to support newly qualified POs.
We cannot spend one day lamenting the erosion of professional expertise and the lack of meaningful development, then spend the next suggesting that those working in roles intended to support quality and learning should simply be returned to frontline caseloads. That’s not to say every role is effective, every appointment is appropriate or that the balance between operational and non-operational staffing shouldn’t be scrutinised. Of course it should.
But surely the question is whether those roles are delivering meaningful support, strengthening professional judgement and improving the quality of probation practice? A well-supported PO is not a luxury. Neither is good quality training, reflective practice or professional development. And let’s not forget that the people occupying these roles did not design the staffing model, determine the pay offer or create the workload crisis.
We’ve spent considerable time discussing how divided probation has become. Yet here we are, dividing ourselves again into those supposedly doing the ‘real work’ and those who apparently aren’t. Perhaps we should direct more of our scrutiny towards the decisions that have left the service so overstretched, rather than assuming colleagues in different roles are somehow responsible for the conditions we’re all working under.
Because if we’re serious about renewing probation, we need to value the people delivering supervision and the people helping them develop the knowledge and skills to deliver it well. Those should be complementary responsibilities, not competing ones.
*****
The UK Government has defended a pay offer to probation workers which has been rejected and sparked a threat of strikes. Members of Napo have voted in favour of industrial action over pay as well as their workloads. In a statement, the union confirmed: “We will be calling on our members in Probation England and Wales to commence a campaign of Industrial Action on Monday 23 November.”
Initially, staff will still work their contracted hours but will not undertake any overtime. Members have also voted in favour of strikes, but no walkout dates have been confirmed yet."
- Here's the mendacious MoJ's less than original take on events:
"The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal.
A spokesman said: “Probation staff do a vital job protecting the public, which is why we have put a strong offer on the table giving every worker a further 5% pay rise, which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade alongside record investment ... We’re also recruiting an additional 1,300 officers to significantly cut workloads."
“While we are disappointed that some have voted against this competitive deal, it will not change our first responsibility of protecting the public and we have robust contingency plans in place to ensure offenders are still subject to the same rigorous supervision."
___________________________________________________
Hansard, Feb 2025: "Probation is currently in a multi-year pay deal covering the period 1 April 2022 to 31 March 2025. This pay deal has provided certainty in pay increases throughout the period while securing necessary reforms to the pay structure helping to resolve some longstanding pay issues."
ghost in't' machine says:
Cumulative Pay vs. Cost of Living: According to probation trade unions (Napo, UNISON, and GMB/SCOOP), the cumulative nominal rise in probation staff pay points between 2010 and 2024 was roughly 11%, while RPI/cost-of-living metrics rose by over 81.2% over the same period, leaving real-terms pay significantly behind
Austerity and Pay Freezes (2010s): Following the 2010 general election, public sector pay freezes and 1% public sector pay caps severely suppressed annual increments across the Probation Service for much of the decade.
The 2022–2024 Multi-Year Deal: A previous multi-year framework yielded low annual increases (such as 3.2% in 2023 and 4.5% in 2024) that lagged behind high inflation peaks
The 2025 Settlement (6% Award): Following union campaigns, rejections of initial government offers (such as an earlier 4% proposal), and ballot threats for industrial action, HMPPS and the government finalized a 6% increase across all pay points and cash allowances, backdated to April 1, 2025
Current Pay Framework (Post-2025)
• PQiP: £28,064 nationally
• PSO, Band 3: £28,064 – £33,549.
• Band 4: £37,238 – £44,520
• Band 5: £46,746 – £48,760
Let's have a look at those MoJ words again:
"The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal." - aye, 2/3 = most; so well done unison & gmb for shafting your colleagues. However pisspoor napo have been over the last two decades, at least their members have managed to make a stand this time.
"giving every worker a further 5% pay rise" - annual pay deals are just that; they will always be "a further" whatever, its not special treatment or a generous donation.
"which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade" - yep, because there's been fuck all for over a decade
MP pay rise history since 2010
April 2010 – March 2011: £65,73
May 2015 – March 2016: £74,000 (+10.3%)
April 2022 – March 2023: £84,144 (+2.7%)
April 2023 – March 2024: £86,584 (+2.9%)
April 2024 – March 2025: £91,346 (+5.5%)
April 2025 – March 2026: £93,904 (+2.8%)
April 2026 onward: £98,599 (+5.0%)
MPs: Overall ~42% increase since 2010
vs
Probation Band 4 (max): ~24% increase since 2010
*****
I find it quite sad to read that we apparently haven’t done anything professional in decades. Really? I agree that probation has been increasingly deprofessionalised over the years, but that doesn’t mean the people doing the job have somehow stopped being professionals.
We’re still making difficult decisions about risk, safeguarding and public protection every day, often with ridiculous workloads and nowhere near enough time to do the job as we’d like to.
That's what frustrates me. We’ve become so bogged down in processes, targets and prescribed ways of working that sometimes I wonder when we’re actually supposed to do probation. What happened to just sitting down and having a conversation with someone? Getting to know them, being curious, even a bit nosey! Picking up on something that doesn’t quite add up or noticing a change because you know the person well enough to recognise it. You can’t always put that into a structured intervention or tick a box to demonstrate it happened, but it’s often where the really important work takes place.
After all these years, I still believe in probation and the difference good practitioners can make. I just wish we were given the time and trusted to do it. Maybe the problem isn’t that we’ve stopped being professional. It’s that the organisation has increasingly stopped allowing us to practise like professionals.
No comments:
Post a Comment