Friday, 20 November 2026

Lets Reward Failure!

Whilst probation staff prepare for industrial action over a fair pay deal, we are reminded just how crap MoJ and HMPPS are, but astonishingly reward themselves for being crap! This from the Daily Mail:-

Top officials at the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) shared a bonus pot of up to £100,000 between them despite the prisoner early release chaos and crippling courts backlog. The department's latest annual accounts, published on Tuesday, revealed a swathe of 'performance-related' payments were made to senior staff in the last financial year. A total of eight mandarins received bonuses of between £5,000 and £20,000 in 2025/26, according to the document.

During those 12 months, the MoJ oversaw the early release of tens of thousands of prisoners in a bid to ease overcrowding in jails. Meanwhile, the backlog of Crown Court cases stood at more than 80,000.

The MoJ's annual accounts also revealed total departmental losses of more than £66million in the financial year. The losses included £38.5million in 'constructive losses', £22.5million in 'administrative write-offs', and £3.8million in 'fruitless payments'.

The 'constructive losses' from the prison capacity programme were said to have primarily arisen 'from the write-off of construction costs'. These were 'incurred on projects at existing prison sites that were subsequently descoped'.

MoJ figures published last month revealed that 43,610 prisoners were released after serving just 40 per cent of their sentence in the 12 months to April this year. This was under an initial Government scheme to free up prison spaces in order to ease the overcrowding crisis in jails.

Amy Rees was paid a bonus of between £10,000 and £15,000 in 2025/26 for her work as head of HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS), according to the latest MoJ accounts. This was related to 'performance in the previous financial year, which was paid out in the current financial year', the document stated. Ms Rees left the role in April 2025 to become the MoJ's interim permanent secretary. She is now chief executive of Homes England.

Other top MoJ staff to receive bonuses in the last financial year included James McEwen, the permanent successor to Ms Rees at HMPPS, and Nick Goodwin, who was boss of HM Courts and Tribunals Service until August this year.

Campaigners called for the MoJ to end bonus payments to senior staff until the prisons crisis was solved. John O'Connell, chief executive of the TaxPayers' Alliance, said: 'These MoJ mandarins should not be taking home bonuses while convicts walk free.'The prisons system is falling apart and bosses should not expect any performance pay, at least until they have delivered the extra places and improved efficiency that ministers have promised.'This Whitehall-wide culture of rewarding shoddy performance needs to stop.'

A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: 'We are pulling every lever to fix the justice system - building 14,000 new prison spaces, addressing the Crown Court backlog and boosting victim support funding to record levels. 'The salaries of senior civil servants are in line with civil service guidelines, which balance affordability and the need to attract high calibre people to deliver quality services that represent true value to the taxpayer.'

--oo00oo--

From Future Positive:-

"Top officials at the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) shared a bonus pot reaching £100,000 during a financial year marked by widespread challenges in the justice system. According to the MoJ's recently published annual accounts for 2025/26, eight senior officials received performance-related payments ranging from £5,000 to £20,000.

This bonus scheme was in place while the department managed the early release of over 43,600 prisoners, who served only 40% of their sentences, in a government effort to reduce jail overcrowding. Meanwhile, the Crown Court faced a backlog exceeding 80,000 cases, contributing to systemic pressure.

The accounts also disclosed departmental losses surpassing £66 million, including £38.5 million in construction write-offs linked to prison capacity projects that were later halted. £22.5 million was recorded as administrative write-offs and £3.8 million as fruitless payments.

Amy Rees, who served as head of HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) before becoming interim permanent secretary, received between £10,000 and £15,000 as a bonus related to previous year performance. Other recipients included James McEwen, who succeeded Ms. Rees at HMPPS, and Nick Goodwin, former head of HM Courts and Tribunals Service.

The bonus awards have drawn criticism from campaigners and watchdogs. John O'Connell of the TaxPayers' Alliance stated, "These MoJ mandarins should not be taking home bonuses while convicts walk free." He called for the suspension of such payments until improvements in prison capacity and court efficiency are realized.

A Ministry of Justice spokesperson emphasized ongoing efforts to address justice system challenges, including plans to build 14,000 new prison spaces and tackle the court backlog, and said senior civil servant salaries align with guidelines balancing affordability with attracting talent to serve the public effectively."

--oo00oo--

Dame Antonia Romeo DCB, Permanent Secretary (to 13 April 2025) - Accrued pension and related lump sum at pension age as at 31 March 2026 = £65-70,000 plus a lump sum of £145-150,000

Phil Copple, Interim Chief Executive, HMPPS (from 14 April 2025 to 12 October 2025) - £85-90,000 plus a lump sum of £210-215,000

Contracted probation services costs for the year 2025/26 = £93,854 ,000 (yup, £93.8million)

Amy Rees, Director General, Chief Executive, HMPPS to 13 April 2025) and Interim Permanent Secretary (from 14 April 2025 to 30 June 2025) - salary paid £45-50,000 + £14,000 benefits + £10-15,000 bonus

James McEwen, Chief Operating Officer (to 12 October 2025), Director General and Chief Executive Officer, HMPPS (from 13 October 2025) - salary paid £175-180,000 + £5-10,000 bonus + £77,000 pension benefit

Amy Holmes, Interim Director General, Service Delivery Transformation (from 17 March 2025 to 28 September 2025) and Interim Chief Operating Officer from 13 October 2025 to 31 March 2026) - salary paid £135-140,000 + £15-20,000 bonus + £134,000 pension benefit

Megan Lee-Devlin, Director General, Service Delivery Transformation (to 28 September 2025) and Director General, Justice Services and Transformation (from 29 September 2025) - salary paid £185-190,000 + £5-10,000 bonus + £73,000 pension benefit

Ross Gribbin, Director General, Policy – Prisons, Offenders and International Justice (from 16 November 2023 to 9 December 2025) - salary paid £105-110,000 + £10-15,000 bonus + £52,000 pension benefit

Thursday, 19 November 2026

A Blast From the Past

Gosh, it's been a long time since Nacro featured on these pages! Maybe those with very long memories or are simply curious might like to pop Nacro in the search box and be taken back to almost the very origins of the blog, 2010 and The Dog that Doesn't Bark. Clearly some readers have long memories:-

"Nacro have developed a massively over-inflated sense of their own importance following their association with sodexo & the McDowells episode. Remember that?

"McDowell led Nacro as Chief Executive from 2009 to 2014 before taking up the independent post of Chief Inspector of Probation in February 2014... In late 2014, the Ministry of Justice privatised regional probation services, awarding six of the 21 contracts to a partnership between outsourcing firm Sodexo Justice Services and McDowell's former employer, Nacro... McDowell's wife, Janine McDowell, worked as a senior manager and deputy managing director at Sodexo Justice Services... While McDowell declared his wife's role to the Ministry of Justice upon his appointment, the connection was omitted during his pre-appointment scrutiny hearing before the House of Commons Justice Select Committee"

So, having revisited the saga of Nacro getting into bed with Sodexo, a prison and probation operator and the TR Omnishambles, I thought I'd ask the genie in the bottle "Has Nacro gone soft on campaigning?" Genie said:-

Whether Nacro has "gone soft" on campaigning depends on how its current strategy is compared against its historical roots and peer organisations. While critics have previously accused the charity of softening its stance due to its heavy reliance on government service-delivery contracts, Nacro maintains a structured policy and campaigning arm focused on pragmatic, incremental reform.

Why Critics Have Accused Nacro of "Going Soft"

Service Delivery vs. Radical Reform. Historically, Nacro was closely associated with outspoken penal reform. Over the past two decades, it evolved into a major provider of government-commissioned housing, education, and resettlement services. In a 2009 profile in The Guardian, Harry Fletcher of the National Association of Probation Officers explicitly accused Nacro of having "gone soft" due to its apparent silence on major penal reform compared to pure campaigning bodies like the Howard League for Penal Reform and the Prison Reform Trust.

Contractural Constraints. Because Nacro bids for and delivers substantial public sector contracts across England and Wales, critics within the voluntary sector have long noted the tension between acting as a government contractor and publicly opposing government justice policy. At the time, Nacro's leadership acknowledged it could "do better" on speaking out, while emphasising that frontline service delivery and cross-sector cooperation were its primary priorities.

Evidence of Active Campaigning
Despite those criticisms, Nacro's campaigning hub demonstrates ongoing policy advocacy rather than an abandonment of campaigning. Under its 2025–2028 Strategy, Nacro lists "Campaigning for change for the people we support" as one of its five core priorities. Recent activity includes:

Targeted Legislative and Policy Wins. Nacro has focused on specific, achievable operational changes in prisons and resettlement. It cites successes in ending Friday prison releases, securing a commitment to 12 weeks of transitional housing for prison leavers, raising the prison discharge grant from £46 to £82.39, and achieving a 20% reduction in public prison phone call costs alongside a £1/week prison wage increase in 2025.

Lived-Experience Advocacy. Through initiatives like its Justice ExChange and Truth About Youth reports, Nacro uses service-user testimony to lobby policymakers on physical healthcare in prisons, post-release mortality rates, and youth disengagement from post-16 education.

Public Policy Briefings.
 In late 2026, Nacro actively challenged government policy on prison capacity—calling for a focus on reducing probation recalls—and criticised gaps in post-16 education and supported housing funding.

Summary
Rather than stopping campaigning altogether, Nacro operates differently from pure pressure groups. Organisations like the Howard League focus exclusively on legal and systemic advocacy without holding government service contracts, allowing them to take a more confrontational stance. Nacro uses its position as a large frontline service provider to push for practical, evidence-based adjustments within the justice, housing, and education systems.

--oo00oo--

Basically Nacro have popped up due to a degree of excitement surrounding their latest report  from The Better Futures Project and based on responses from service users. It's always good to get the views and experiences from this group and the findings are not surprising to many probation staff:-

Conclusion 

As the provisions of the Sentencing Act come into force, a strong and effective Probation Service becomes ever more critical, as are the services in the community which support rehabilitation. 

To build a justice system for the future, the services that support people in the community – both the Probation Service and the voluntary sector organisations that provide vital support – need to have the funding and the resource to do the job well. This report highlights positive examples of probation officers providing high-quality support and creating relationships to help people build their lives and move away from offending. But it also highlights examples where the challenges the Probation Service has faced over many years have led to poor levels of trust and support. The identification of what is important and the qualities and strengths of a good probation officer brings real opportunities to learn and develop. Ultimately, the ability to build productive and supportive relationships is key. 

The purpose of sharing the views of people with lived experience in this report is not to develop a list of recommendations, but to ensure that the experiences of those who have been under probation supervision are shared, heard and taken into account. However, at a time of significant change as the Sentencing Act come into effect, there are emerging themes highlighted that require greater focus. Strengthening the role and effectiveness of the Probation Service will ultimately increase peoples’ chances of turning their lives around, moving away from crime, and reducing reoffending:

Fulfilling the dual role of probation through effective rehabilitation: The most effective way to protect the public is to support effective rehabilitation, enabling people leaving custody to build a stable life and contribute to society. If the focus on public protection and the management of risk takes precedence over rehabilitation, or becomes the sole focus, rehabilitation can be undermined and lasting change can then be limited. 

Recruitment and training of probation staff: The feedback from people who have been supervised by the Probation Service and the qualities they believe to be key in probation officers should directly inform recruitment and training. These include honesty; listening and people skills; empathy and a caring non-judgmental attitude. 

Lower risk doesn’t equal lower need: As probation supervision changes to prioritise those who present the highest risk, those with a wide range of needs, such as mental health, substance misuse and housing must not be overlooked. Those who represent less immediate or severe risk to the public are often people caught in the revolving door of offending, or at risk of their offending becoming prolific if they aren’t able to access support. 

Recall: The huge increase in the use of recall has clearly impacted the relationships people have with their probation officers. The framework to support decisions to recall needs to support effective decision-making and be fair and proportionate, balancing public protection with the impact on the rehabilitation of the individual.

Pre-sentence reports: The capacity of probation to prepare high-quality pre-sentence reports in conjunction with each individual is essential. This will ensure that sentencing decisions are well-informed, as well as considering how to best to support rehabilitation and reducing reoffending.

Probation in prisons: Effective transitions from prison to community are only possible if supported by smooth handovers between prison and community probation officers, ensuring sharing of information and release plans with licence conditions that are informed by previous engagement and supportive of growth. 

Employing people with lived experience in both probation and the voluntary sector: The insight and experiences of people with lived experience are invaluable to creating a diverse and knowledgeable workforce that can best support people on probation. To make this a reality there must be a greater focus on mentoring roles, overcoming current barriers of vetting, stigma and lack of relevant work experience.

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Upstream or Downstream 2

So, on the day Alan Milburn publlishes a plan for getting young people into productive society, thus proving once again how spending money upstream rather than downstream is a very sensible idea indeed, the government refuses to apply the same logic to criminal justice. The answer remains "1,300 new officers and £700million" for an utterly broken system.  

--oo00oo--

Well, perhaps this finally puts to bed the suggestion that concerns about probation workloads are simply a minority of disillusioned staff moaning.

Over 70% turnout in both Napo ballots, with 87.4% of valid votes cast on the workload question supporting action short of a strike. That’s a considerable expression of concern from a workforce that has spent years being told about transformation, efficiency, resilience and the importance of public protection.

And now, from 23 November, PPs are being asked to do something that really shouldn’t be considered extraordinary. Work their contracted hours.

I imagine HMPPS has been busy preparing its Gold Command contingency arrangements for industrial action. Entirely understandable, of course. Public protection responsibilities don’t disappear during an industrial dispute. But I do wonder how much attention and resource is being devoted to managing the consequences of staff working their contracted hours, compared with addressing why the service has become so dependent upon people working beyond them in the first place. Because if working to contracted hours creates an operational crisis, surely the crisis existed long before the industrial action began?

HMPPS has already acknowledged that the Probation Service is unsustainable. Yet individual PPs remain responsible for managing complex risks, meeting statutory deadlines, responding to emergencies and making defensible decisions within workloads that frequently exceed the time realistically available.

So what happens when that additional goodwill is no longer there? Who determines which work takes priority? Who takes responsibility for the tasks that cannot reasonably be completed? And how will individual PPs be protected from being held accountable for failures arising from organisational capacity rather than their own professional decisions?

These are not simply questions for Napo members. They are questions for those responsible for directing, resourcing and overseeing the Probation Service.

For years, professional commitment has helped bridge the gap between what the organisation demands and what its staffing capacity can realistically deliver. But commitment should never be mistaken for an unlimited resource. And perhaps that’s what makes this ballot result so significant. Thousands of staff have now formally expressed their unwillingness to continue accepting the conditions under which they’re expected to deliver probation. We talk endlessly about resilience, but resilience cannot mean expecting individuals to absorb organisational failure indefinitely.

HMPPS may well have contingency plans for the industrial action beginning on 23 November. But where is the contingency plan for a Probation Service that can no longer rely on the unpaid labour and goodwill of its workforce to keep it functioning? Because you can prepare for industrial action. You can't contingency plan your way out of the underlying reasons people voted for it.

*****
Regarding UNISON, I do find the different positions taken by the unions concerning, particularly at a time when probation desperately needs a collective voice.

I can understand why some colleagues might regard 5% as an offer worth accepting, especially given the financial pressures many are experiencing. Equally, I understand Napo’s concerns about the longer term implications for pay progression and the failure to adequately address the erosion of probation pay.

But what troubles me is the division this risks creating within an already fragmented workforce. We’ve seen enough of that throughout probation’s recent history, particularly during TR. Colleagues who were once part of the same profession found themselves divided by organisational structures and decisions they had little control over. We should be extremely cautious about allowing another divide to develop between staff represented by different unions.

Ultimately, Napo and UNISON members are working within the same service, facing many of the same excessive workloads, staffing shortages, professional responsibilities and pressures.

Those difficulties don’t disappear because one union recommends accepting a pay offer while another rejects it. And perhaps that is the bigger issue. Pay cannot be considered entirely separately from workloads, retention and the increasing demands placed upon PPs. What does a 5% increase actually achieve in the longer term if the working conditions driving experienced colleagues out of the profession remain largely unchanged?

I respect the democratic decisions made by members of both unions, but I would hope their leaderships can continue working together on the issues that unite their members rather than allowing their different negotiating positions to become another source of division. Because the employer remains the same, the pressures remain the same, and the need for a properly resourced, professionally valued Probation Service remains exactly the same.

The last thing probation needs is another situation where those doing the work become divided while the underlying problems remain unresolved.

*****
I remember when I first started out in work, on a paid YTS, if anyone remembers those! Someone from one of the major unions came along and explained why paying £1.50 a week in subscriptions was worthwhile. By the end of the talk, we realised he wasn’t just some union representative; he was the General Secretary. We all signed up, got involved and participated. We felt part of something. Even through my student year I maintained union membership of one form or another.

Fast forward to probation. I changed my union affiliation to one of the main probation unions, but apart from the very early days, I never really felt involved. There was little opportunity to participate. I regularly challenged the status quo and the employer, applied to become a union rep, but as far as the local branch was concerned, my face didn’t fit, and they made it crystal clear.

At the same time, probation was going downhill, union communication was abysmal and local representation wasn’t particularly great either. Anyone remember the Napo forum? We had some brilliant conversations and debates on there until it was shut down. That’s around the time I found this blog. When I needed representation, getting the union on board was a chore. Phone calls were passed around, emails went unanswered, delays for representation were endless and, in the end, I did most of the work myself. When I challenged them about this, I was treated as the enemy. The irony is that when I eventually spoke directly to the General Secretary, the very person others seemed so keen to criticise, he was the one who actually listened and helped.

Despite all this, I lived through two periods of industrial action I can remember. The first time, I didn’t join the strike. How could I stand alongside the same union clique of members and branch reps who I knew had been actively stabbing me in the back? The second time, during TR, I had moved to a better location. I joined the protests, stood around a burning oil drum (until the fire brigade came and outed the fire) and marched through the streets with placards.

Following TR, probation unions failed, disappeared or fundamentally changed. I left that union and joined another, partly to ensure I had access to representation should I need it in the future. When I eventually needed representation, I specifically requested an external rep. They were excellent. I still did a lot of the work myself, but one thing they did exceptionally well was to listen and to represent me. No delays in responding, no avoiding calls, no telling me how busy they were, and no fudging, dishonesty or side deals with management. There is a trade-off. I don’t feel as up to date with probation-specific communications, I no longer get to attend specialist AGMs and I probably won’t be involved in future strike action. But I’m still active in my own way. I still encourage people to join a union, even the union I previously had to leave for my own sanity and safety, hoping it’s changed for the better.

So please, don’t shut people out and withhold information because they’re not attending your union meetings or standing on your picket line. Don’t make assumptions based on whether we’re Gen X, Gen Y, millennials, Black, White, gay, straight, or anything else. There’s already too much of that coming from the ivory tower. Unions should be demonstrating a better way, not reproducing the same divisions. You don’t know everyone’s journey, what they’ve experienced or why they’ve made the choices they have. Instead of asking why someone isn’t standing alongside you, perhaps ask what needs to change to make them want to. Collective strength is built by bringing people together, not pushing people away.

Probation Officer

*****
I find the comments about QDOs and PTAs rather disappointing, particularly given the wider discussion we’ve been having about professional development, the loss of experience and the need to support newly qualified POs.

We cannot spend one day lamenting the erosion of professional expertise and the lack of meaningful development, then spend the next suggesting that those working in roles intended to support quality and learning should simply be returned to frontline caseloads. That’s not to say every role is effective, every appointment is appropriate or that the balance between operational and non-operational staffing shouldn’t be scrutinised. Of course it should.

But surely the question is whether those roles are delivering meaningful support, strengthening professional judgement and improving the quality of probation practice? A well-supported PO is not a luxury. Neither is good quality training, reflective practice or professional development. And let’s not forget that the people occupying these roles did not design the staffing model, determine the pay offer or create the workload crisis.

We’ve spent considerable time discussing how divided probation has become. Yet here we are, dividing ourselves again into those supposedly doing the ‘real work’ and those who apparently aren’t. Perhaps we should direct more of our scrutiny towards the decisions that have left the service so overstretched, rather than assuming colleagues in different roles are somehow responsible for the conditions we’re all working under.

Because if we’re serious about renewing probation, we need to value the people delivering supervision and the people helping them develop the knowledge and skills to deliver it well. Those should be complementary responsibilities, not competing ones.

*****
The UK Government has defended a pay offer to probation workers which has been rejected and sparked a threat of strikes. Members of Napo have voted in favour of industrial action over pay as well as their workloads. In a statement, the union confirmed: “We will be calling on our members in Probation England and Wales to commence a campaign of Industrial Action on Monday 23 November.”

Initially, staff will still work their contracted hours but will not undertake any overtime. Members have also voted in favour of strikes, but no walkout dates have been confirmed yet."

- Here's the mendacious MoJ's less than original take on events:

"The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal.

A spokesman said: “Probation staff do a vital job protecting the public, which is why we have put a strong offer on the table giving every worker a further 5% pay rise, which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade alongside record investment ... We’re also recruiting an additional 1,300 officers to significantly cut workloads."

“While we are disappointed that some have voted against this competitive deal, it will not change our first responsibility of protecting the public and we have robust contingency plans in place to ensure offenders are still subject to the same rigorous supervision."
___________________________________________________
Hansard, Feb 2025: "Probation is currently in a multi-year pay deal covering the period 1 April 2022 to 31 March 2025. This pay deal has provided certainty in pay increases throughout the period while securing necessary reforms to the pay structure helping to resolve some longstanding pay issues."

ghost in't' machine says:

Cumulative Pay vs. Cost of Living: According to probation trade unions (Napo, UNISON, and GMB/SCOOP), the cumulative nominal rise in probation staff pay points between 2010 and 2024 was roughly 11%, while RPI/cost-of-living metrics rose by over 81.2% over the same period, leaving real-terms pay significantly behind

Austerity and Pay Freezes (2010s): Following the 2010 general election, public sector pay freezes and 1% public sector pay caps severely suppressed annual increments across the Probation Service for much of the decade.

The 2022–2024 Multi-Year Deal: A previous multi-year framework yielded low annual increases (such as 3.2% in 2023 and 4.5% in 2024) that lagged behind high inflation peaks

The 2025 Settlement (6% Award): Following union campaigns, rejections of initial government offers (such as an earlier 4% proposal), and ballot threats for industrial action, HMPPS and the government finalized a 6% increase across all pay points and cash allowances, backdated to April 1, 2025

Current Pay Framework (Post-2025)

• PQiP: £28,064 nationally
• PSO, Band 3: £28,064 – £33,549.
• Band 4: £37,238 – £44,520
• Band 5: £46,746 – £48,760

Let's have a look at those MoJ words again:

"The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal." - aye, 2/3 = most; so well done unison & gmb for shafting your colleagues. However pisspoor napo have been over the last two decades, at least their members have managed to make a stand this time.

"giving every worker a further 5% pay rise" - annual pay deals are just that; they will always be "a further" whatever, its not special treatment or a generous donation.

"which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade" - yep, because there's been fuck all for over a decade

MP pay rise history since 2010
April 2010 – March 2011: £65,73
May 2015 – March 2016: £74,000 (+10.3%)
April 2022 – March 2023: £84,144 (+2.7%)
April 2023 – March 2024: £86,584 (+2.9%)
April 2024 – March 2025: £91,346 (+5.5%)
April 2025 – March 2026: £93,904 (+2.8%)
April 2026 onward: £98,599 (+5.0%)

MPs: Overall ~42% increase since 2010
vs
Probation Band 4 (max): ~24% increase since 2010

*****
I find it quite sad to read that we apparently haven’t done anything professional in decades. Really? I agree that probation has been increasingly deprofessionalised over the years, but that doesn’t mean the people doing the job have somehow stopped being professionals.

We’re still making difficult decisions about risk, safeguarding and public protection every day, often with ridiculous workloads and nowhere near enough time to do the job as we’d like to.

That's what frustrates me. We’ve become so bogged down in processes, targets and prescribed ways of working that sometimes I wonder when we’re actually supposed to do probation. What happened to just sitting down and having a conversation with someone? Getting to know them, being curious, even a bit nosey! Picking up on something that doesn’t quite add up or noticing a change because you know the person well enough to recognise it. You can’t always put that into a structured intervention or tick a box to demonstrate it happened, but it’s often where the really important work takes place.

After all these years, I still believe in probation and the difference good practitioners can make. I just wish we were given the time and trusted to do it. Maybe the problem isn’t that we’ve stopped being professional. It’s that the organisation has increasingly stopped allowing us to practise like professionals.

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Probation Must be Devolved by Default!


For those who are really keen, you can read the full monty speech here, but I've picked out what I think are the key bits. 1) Andy Burnham is keen on devolution 2) Civil servants haven't a bloody clue how to run a successful probation service 3) There is zero chance of "pride and trust" being restored under HMPPS control 4) Before Dame Antonia got to it, the Probation Service was already a gold winning "genuinely world class organisation". We demand probation is devolved now and out of the bloody civil service!  

"The Prime Minister has set an ambitious objective for his Government, to deliver good growth in every part of the UK – including through devolution by default. The Civil Service’s job is to deliver the Government’s agenda. That puts devolution by default at the heart of our work.

It will require a fundamental rewiring of the way the state works, and a major shift in powers and resources from Westminster to communities and regions. And a more collaborative approach, ensuring policy made in Westminster helps the communities that most need it.

This new approach to give power to communities will be a central part of the Prime Minister’s 10 year plan. It represents a radical change to central government - genuinely devolving power, not just delegating it.

---//---
The Future Civil Service programme has three central principles:
  • Delivery,
  • Innovation and Productivity, and
  • Pride and Trust.
---//---
The Review into the Organisation, Performance and Transformation of the Permanent Civil Service - which began in July and will report to the Prime Minister before next summer - will set out a vision for the future of the Civil Service for the decades ahead, as a genuinely world class organisation serving the duly elected government of the day, with relentless focus and determination.

It will follow the Prime Minister’s 10 year plan to rewire the state by putting devolution by default and power to communities at the heart of our future operating model.

The Review will confront the tough questions:
  • Whether current departmental structures remain optimal in an era of cross-cutting delivery?
  • What AI and devolution by default mean for Civil Service boundaries, and accountability?
  • And how to build the capabilities needed for the future, at national, regional and local level? What will this require of us?
 A change programme of this size demands imagination, determination, and visible leadership.

It is being led by the Permanent Secretaries, and we are asking all leaders across the Civil Service to demonstrate energetic and positive leadership, showing passion for high performance, grounded in the highest standards to motivate and support their teams as we transform the Service.

---//---
Thank you very much."
Dame Antonia Romeo

--oo00oo--

Note - "Devolution is the transfer of power, responsibility, and decision-making from a central government to regional, national, or local authorities."

Monday, 9 November 2026

Something of the Night

We seem to be on a roll in exploring all aspects of why the probation service has gone from gold standard to utterly broken with news of the upcoming free webinar by the Social Work Network next February:-   

“Probation work is not a branch of social work”: Post-1995 probation, social work and the making of separate professions

Professor Mark Drakeford | Professor Anne Worrall | Professor Gwen Robinson | Professor Aidan Worsley | Russell Webster | Dr Caroline J. Bald (Chair)

Baroness Blatch’s wording in the House of Lords on 5 December 1995, when she defended the removal of the social work qualification requirement and described probation as “a discipline in its own right”.

What happened when probation and social work ceased to share a professional route – and what does that history mean now?

In 1995, the Home Office removed the requirement for probation officers in England and Wales to hold a social work qualification and began the process of separating probation education from social work education. The change marked an important point in the development of two increasingly distinct professions. It was also strongly contested: of 493 responses to the consultation on the proposed changes, only 11 supported the proposals in full.

Thirty years on, this Social Work History Network webinar brings together people whose professional and academic lives span that period of change. Some trained at a time when movement between social work and probation was still relatively commonplace; others have researched what happened to probation and social work - their workforce and professional identity afterwards.

Using personal experience, historical research and contemporary perspectives, the panel will consider what was gained and what may have been lost when the professions moved apart. In particular, we will explore education and professional formation; workforce identity, mobility and resilience; the changing place of qualified and paraprofessional staff; and what professional boundaries mean for the people who encounter both social work and criminal justice systems.

The discussion will also look forward. At a time of renewed interest in probation professionalisation and regulation, what can this history tell us about professional identity, education and the relationship between social work and probation today?

There will be time for discussion and questions from the audience.

--oo00oo--

Why was the social work requirement removed from probation? Thank you AI:-

In 1995, the UK Home Office removed the requirement for probation officers in England and Wales to hold a social work qualification (such as the Diploma in Social Work).

Official Reasons for the Change
  • Widening Recruitment: A 1994 Civil Service review and subsequent Home Office arguments suggested that ending the social work mandate would help broaden and diversify the field of recruitment to bring in people with different backgrounds.
  • Redefining Probation as a Justice Discipline: The government and then-Home Secretary argued that "probation work is not a branch of social work" and viewed probation as a distinct discipline in its own right—moving away from a welfare-focused model to a more enforcement- and compliance-oriented judicial function.
  • Service-Led Training: The policy shifted qualifying education away from independent universities/social work programs and put training directly under the control of the probation service itself (leading to the introduction of the Diploma in Probation Studies in 1997).
Opposition and Controversy

The decision was heavily contested at the time—out of nearly 500 responses to the government consultation, only a small fraction supported it. Critics, practitioners, and academics argued that severing the link would narrow the training's focus and produce a more rigid system rather than fostering critical-thinking, anti-oppressive practice.

--oo00oo--

Now, who was Home Secretary in 1994/5? Why Michael Howard of course, remember him? The famous "prison works" quote comes from Conservative Home Secretary Michael Howard, who first delivered it at the Conservative Party Conference in October 1993.

The Full Quote
"Prison works. It ensures that we are protected from murderers, muggers and rapists – and it makes many who are tempted to commit crime think twice ... This may mean that more people will go to prison. I do not flinch from that. We shall no longer judge the success of our system of justice by a fall in our prison population." 

Oh look, this bollocks is still current in the Tory Party:-

Prison Works: Building a stronger, fairer justice system

In a major speech, the Shadow Justice Secretary, Nick Timothy MP CBE sets out why prison works and why Britain needs much more of it. Too many violent and repeat offenders avoid custody, and those who are jailed are held in a crumbling Victorian estate. The speech will make the case for a radical expansion of capacity through new, purpose-built prisons, a reset of the relationship between the MoJ and HMPPS, and greater independence for governors, all aimed at a system that keeps the public safe. Westminster 24th November 2026.

--oo00oo--

While we're at it, thanks to AI, lets remind ourselves of other stand-out moments of Howards time at the Home Office:-

In October 1995, then-Home Secretary Michael Howard sacked Derek Lewis, the Director General of HM Prison Service, following a series of high-profile prison escapes. The dismissal sparked a major constitutional row over ministerial responsibility and led to a landmark High Court settlement and one of British television's most famous political interviews.

Background and Dismissal

The Escapes: The crisis was triggered by high-security breakouts, most notably the escape of three inmates from Parkhurst Prison on the Isle of Wight in January 1995 and an earlier breakout from Whitemoor Prison.
The Learmont Report: Howard commissioned an independent inquiry led by General Sir John Learmont. Published in October 1995, the report criticised management failures across the Prison Service from top to bottom.
The Sacking: On the day the report was released, Howard demanded Lewis's resignation. When Lewis refused to step down, Howard dismissed him.

Political and Legal Fallout

Policy vs. Operations: HM Prison Service had recently been established as an executive agency. Howard maintained that he was responsible for overall policy, while Lewis held sole responsibility for day-to-day operations. Critics and opposition MPs argued Howard was using this distinction as a political shield to avoid resigning himself.
Wrongful Dismissal Settlement: Lewis sued the Home Office for breach of contract and wrongful dismissal, arguing Howard had repeatedly interfered in operational matters. In March 1996, the Home Office reached an out-of-court High Court settlement, agreeing to pay Lewis £125,000 (one year's salary) plus additional pension and bonus compensation.
Newsnight Interview: During the 1997 Conservative leadership contest, BBC presenter Jeremy Paxman repeatedly asked Howard whether he had threatened to overrule Lewis over the removal of Parkhurst's governor, John Marriott. Howard evaded giving a direct yes-or-no answer to the exact same question 12 times, creating a defining moment in British political broadcasting.
Subsequent Revelations: Former Prisons Minister Ann Widdecombe publicly clashed with Howard in 1997 over his handling of the affair, famously remarking that he had "something of the night" about him. In 2005, Home Office documents released under the Freedom of Information Act showed that while Howard had privately inquired about his power to overrule Lewis, he accepted civil service advice against doing so and issued no formal instruction.
 

--oo00oo--

Finally, it's worth re-visiting this blog post by Rob Allen from 2013:-

Twenty Year Stretch: Michael Howard and the Legacy of Punishment

"Howard’s legacy was longer lasting however. By provoking political adversaries to oppose his reforms, he pushed his shadow Tony Blair and New Labour as a whole into a repressive approach to penal policy. Prison numbers have continued to rise ever since 1993.

More disturbing perhaps was Howard’s shamelessly populist approach to law and order- most notoriously in his attempts to increase the tariff for the juvenile killers of James Bulger, later described by a senior judge as “ institutionalised vengeance ... [by] a politician playing to the gallery”. In respect of his sentencing policy the Lord Chief Justice told the House of Lords that “Never in the history of our criminal law have such far reaching proposals been put forward on the strength of such flimsy and dubious evidence.” Indeed the most recent review of evidence by the Ministry of Justice has found that “to date there has been no clear consensus from criminologists and commentators about whether there is an incapacitation effect at all, and if so, its scale.”

Howard’s treatment of the probation service was equally cavalier, removing the requirement for university based social work training and threatening the very existence of the service. When he left office recruitment had almost dried up and it was left to Jack Straw to introduce a new scheme of professional training as an urgent priority."

Rob Allen

Sunday, 8 November 2026

Sunday Reflections

I gave a talk last week to U3A. I've given loads of talks about probation over the years, never scripted, but rather shaped by my current mood, the prevailing situation and an assessment of how and why it's all gone wrong. I obviously have a pop at all the main political party's for their respective part in the demise of a once well-respected public service and profession, along with the part played by Tory rags like the Daily Mail. They were a particularly sparky bunch last Wednesday with two 'biting back'. "Why are you being so negative?" and "We can't afford to spend on all that old stuff". There's absolutely nothing positive to say about the situation and there's loadsamoney to spend downstream on yet more bloody places to lock everyone up.

--oo00oo--

If you listened to Charlie Taylor giving the Longford lecture you will notice his utterly damning verdict on HMPPS and MoJ ability to organise the proverbial piss-up in a brewey, so is it any surprise what's happened to probation under their command and control? Examples of how probation is now part of the problem abound on here regularly:-

Ten years ago, frontline, I had a youngish man due for release. I went to see him in advance, he was very nervous, he had all the "right" motivations, get a job, stay clean, stay out of trouble. But he had nowhere to go to, no accommodation on release. I chatted, we got to know each other. Time marched on. I referred to housing, I asked around, nada. I lost sleep over this one. For weeks. It seemed so horrible and frightening for him, and it was my duty to advise and assist. In the end a colleague - time served PSO - put me on to a local landlord he knew and we got it sorted. The accommodation was so dodgy I persuaded the housing authority to regard him as homeless. I persuaded my lad to stick with it. Two things from this. A. It was a relationship. I cared about him, deeply. B. The solution was local, boots on the ground. Nothing nothing about the way Probation is now enables any of this..

*****
“an all-White, all-female panel” … as are most of our management and senior management teams!

*****
• Trainees (PQiP): The incoming pipeline is heavily skewed, with 79% being female.
• Frontline Staff (Non-Managerial): Women represent 75.8% of the workforce.
• Middle Management: Women represent 74.3% of the workforce.
• Senior Leadership: Women represent 67.8% of the workforce.
• The Baseline Ethnicity: Roughly 80.8% of the entire service identifies as white.

*****
So the upshot of this is that probation is probably the least diverse it has ever been while parroting on about diversity till the cows come home……….practice what you preach senior leaders……

--oo00oo--

Then I notice this today on Twitter:-

"Dame Antonia Romeo, Cabinet Secretary and Head of the Civil Service - the most powerful unelected official in Britain - has been given her targets for the year. Not a single one of them has a number in them, let alone one that goes up; but they do nonetheless make for interesting reading. The targets were published at 5:23pm on Bonfire Night, with the public looking up at the sky, and with the mainstream press practising the same studious indifference to Britain's real centre of governing power as they always have. 

They call for the Cabinet Secretary to "visibly lead the Civil Service with clarity, energy and passion". She is to "champion a culture of curiosity" and "build trust in the state". And - the biggest of all the tells - she is to protect "the interests of former governments and Ministers". It's a set of targets too soft even for a junior account manager at a small recruitment firm. And this is the most noble and important public service position in the country we're talking about. The Cab Sec should be held to the highest, steepest standards, and an almost impossible standard of quality and competence obliged of them. Not even Prime Ministers enjoy the same means to serve their country as the Cabinet Secretary does. 

But this may be in Romeo's interests. Let's look at the positions she held before. For four years she ran the Ministry of Justice. In 2021, her first year there, it was given £5.2 billion to build 20,000 prison places. By September 2024 it had built 6,518. The cost is now put at up to £10.1 billion, and the finish line has been moved to 2031. When the cell places ran out, 26,456 prisoners were let out early in under seven months, every one of them on her watch. She then went to the Home Office, and from there to the top job. She now chairs the committee that decides who runs every department of state, and none of it has ever been put to you. A perfect trajectory of upward failure. And that's the arrangement. Ministers come and go and carry the blame. The officials who watched sleepily while the institution degraded and fell apart go up a floor with a pay bump, a pension increase, and a knight- or damehood earmarked for them.

Progress would abolish the post of Cabinet Secretary on our first day in office. Its powers go to a Chief of Staff of ministerial rank, picked by the Prime Minister, known to the public, answerable to Parliament, and sackable at an hour's notice if they should fall under the standard of performance the public demands. Any government project that runs 20% over budget or a year late puts the official responsible in front of a select committee and costs them their bonus, and if the failure is theirs, they face disciplinary proceedings. (And, to address the issue on this one's side, we would build 100,000 new prison places and end early release, so that no sentence a judge hands down is ever again cut short by a shortage of cells). Clarity, energy and passion are fine things to bring to a job. Under Progress, whoever runs the machine will bring a number as well, and answer for it if they should miss it."

--oo00oo--

So, who the fuck are 'Progress'? AI again:-

Progress for Britain (officially registered as Progress) has no formal organizational links with Reform UK and positions itself as a distinct rival party. While there are minor overlaps in media platforms used by its founder, the two organisations operate completely separately. 

Key Details on Progress for Britain

Independent Registration: According to the Electoral Commission, Progress (registration ID PP18166) was authorised as an independent political party in Great Britain on 28 October 2025. Its registered officers are Maxi Gorynski (Leader and Nominating Officer) and Sebastian Steele (Treasurer). 

Stance on Reform UK: Progress for Britain markets itself as a movement "beyond left and right" aimed at the "politically homeless". When publicly introducing the party on X (formerly Twitter) on 15 April 2026, Treasurer Sebastian Steele explicitly dismissed Reform UK as a viable option, stating: "We can all see the Greens and Reform aren't serious choices. Progress is the answer."

Media Overlap: Party founder Maxi Gorynski has appeared on GB News and contributed articles to publications such as Spiked and The Reformer Scotland—a Scottish publication that also features contributors from Reform UK. However, this reflects overlapping media commentary rather than a political or organisational affiliation. 

(Note: Progress for Britain is also completely separate from Progress, the long-running centre-left pressure group and think tank affiliated with the Labour Party.) 

--oo00oo--

So, what's this outfits policy on criminal justice?

Crime & Justice. Zero tolerance, maximum deterrence. Open justice and public accountability for every court in the land. Unified judicial services to clear the backlog. Institutional corruption investigated and prosecuted. The rape gangs pursued without political interference. Police returned to the streets and freed from paperwork. One law for all – no parallel legal systems, no cultural exemptions. Victims’ rights that mean something. Knife crime, drug markets, cybercrime, and terrorism met with the full force of a state that has decided to take crime seriously.

Oh dear. Not much sign of an enlightened approach here then.

Saturday, 7 November 2026

Longford Lecture 2026

Lets start this off by having a bloody good moan about Google, the bastards that own Blogger. It used to be very simple to embed a YouTube video, now it isn't and especially resizing for mobile phone use. Here's the explanation:-

Google is not actively investing in Blogger, though the platform has not been officially shut down. 

Current Status of Blogger

Maintenance Mode: Google keeps Blogger active and hosted for free, but it receives very few major feature updates, design overhauls, or modern integrations. 

Lack of New Features: Users and publishers note a near-total absence of modern platform development, leaving it far behind competitors like WordPress, Medium, or Substack. 

Niche Use Only: It survives mostly as a legacy or simple free tool for hobbyists, personal journals, and basic text archiving rather than modern content creators or brands.

Platform Criticism: Many digital publishers and SEO analysts point out that Google's broader algorithmic shifts (such as helpful content and core updates) have made traditional un-optimized free blogging harder to monetize or rank effectively.

Here's HM Chief Inspector of Prisons Charlie Taylor talking a lot of sense (from 27 minutes in):-

'Wasting Time: Missed Opportunities for Change'

Saturday, 31 October 2026

System That Still Works

This made me reflect on the journey we've been on and why it's all gone so wrong:-

Probation caseloads:
2002 191,400
2003 199,200
2004 209,500
2005 224,100
2006 235,000
2007 242,700
2008 243,400

And all that with nowhere near as many staff 'onboarded' & trained 'at pace', the earliest version of crams, no embedded oasys 'til 2004, PSRs, Lifers, coffee &/or fag breaks, team meetings, annual leave, travel & subsistence, prison visits, home visits AND continuous professional development. Tell that t' young 'uns of today an' they won't believe yer.

I asked AI what it was like being a Probation Officer in the past?

Being a probation officer was defined by a strong ethos of "advise, assist, and befriend," offering far more personal autonomy and face-to-face social work focus than today's heavily bureaucratized systems

Autonomy and Offices: Officers typically had their own private offices, personal filing cabinets, and dictaphones for transcribing case notes with the help of dedicated clerical staff.

The Ethos of Friendship & Support: Supervision leaned heavily into social work, building long-term personal bonds with clients. Officers often went above and beyond their formal remit—helping clients find jobs, managing local clothing stores, or using office befriending and emergency funds (often small cash allowances up to £10) for food or housing. 

Court and Fieldwork: Working the courts (Magistrates' and County Courts) was a central, hands-on duty. Fieldwork was heavily "patch-based," meaning officers regularly ran weekly reporting centers and drop-ins away from the main office, sometimes supported by local volunteers. 

Resources & Tools: Technology was just beginning to shift: electric typewriters, early photocopiers, and fax machines were just arriving, and records relied heavily on physical card indexes and micro-cassettes. 

Broader Culture: While the job offered high professional independence and a sense of community impact, institutional environments like prisons—where officers also spent time—could be gritty, rough, and subject to the social tensions of the era.

This led me to reflect on a key aspect of probation in the past - it was of course not a sentence. This then led me to this:- “Advise, assist and befriend”: Client Perspectives on Probation from the 1980s to Present-day, a paper about probation in the Irish Republic, which in turn drew my attention to this:-

The Criminal Justice (Community Sanctions) Bill 2014 is a piece of Irish legislation designed to update the Probation of Offenders Act 1907, broaden community-based sanctions, and reform alternative sentencing. But it has never been enacted, so the 1907 Act remains in force. So I wondered if that still meant probation was not a sentence in Ireland. Here's what AI says:-

In Ireland, a standard probation order is historically and philosophically structured as an alternative to a sentence, rather than a sentence itself. The primary reasons Ireland maintains this distinction are rooted in its foundational legislation, judicial philosophy, and the unique legal benefits of the non-conviction framework.

1. The Legal Framework: The 1907 Act
The primary legal basis for probation in Ireland remains the Probation of Offenders Act 1907. Under Section 1 of this Act, when a court decides to use a probation order, it explicitly chooses to do so "in lieu of imposing a sentence of imprisonment"

The Mechanism: The court binds the offender over on a recognizance (a legal promise) to be of good behavior and to return to court for sentencing only if they fail to comply with the probation terms

The Logic: Because the individual is being given a chance to avoid punishment, the law views the probation period as a deferral of sentencing, not the execution of a sentence.

2. The Benefit of Avoided Convictions
In the Irish District Court, if a judge finds that the facts of a minor offense are proven but chooses to issue a probation order, they do not proceed to a formal conviction.

By keeping probation structured as a pre-sentencing alternative, Irish law allows individuals—particularly first-time or minor offenders—to avoid a permanent criminal record. This preserves their employment prospects, travel opportunities, and social reintegration. 

3. Clear Separation of Non-Custodial Sanctions
Irish criminal justice relies on a distinct hierarchy of non-custodial options:

Alternatives to Sentencing: Conditional dismissals and probation orders under the 1907 Act (which avoid a recorded conviction in the District Court).

Sentences Served in the Community: Community Service Orders (CSOs), fines, and suspended sentences.

Because Community Service Orders (introduced via the Criminal Justice Act 1983) and fully suspended sentences already serve as distinct, formal "community sentences", there has been less legislative pressure to redefine the traditional 1907 probation order.


So, AI confirms that, unlike other parts of the former United Kingdom, Eire chose to stick to a bloody system that works:-

The statutory foundation for probation and conditional discharge in Ireland remains largely based on the Probation of Offenders Act 1907, though it operates alongside modern criminal justice legislation.

Core Legislation: The 1907 Act is still in force and active in the Republic of Ireland (unlike in England, Wales, or Scotland, where it was repealed by later mid-century acts). It is maintained and updated in administrative consolidations by the Law Reform Commission.

How It Works: Under the Act, judges can dismiss a proven charge or place an offender on a probation or conditional discharge order based on factors like character, age, health, or the trivial nature of the offence. In the District Court, a dismissal under Section 1(1) of the Act means the charge is proven, yet no criminal conviction is recorded (though a record of the dismissal is kept).

Conditions: The individual must agree to be of good behaviour, avoid further crimes, and follow any specific directions (such as addiction treatment or training courses).

Consequences of a Breach: If the person breaks the conditions of the order within the set period, they can be brought back before the court and dealt with (which may lead to a conviction or sentence for the original offence).


Friday, 30 October 2026

How's Tagging Going?

Electronic monitoring in practice: The police response to electronically monitored bail conditions and the use of electronic monitoring on community sentences and post-release licences

Foreword
Electronic monitoring is playing an increasingly prominent role across the criminal justice system. Over recent years, technological advances, legislative reform and changing operational pressures have all contributed to a substantial expansion in its use. In the year to June 2026, the total number of individuals subject to electronic monitoring grew by over 2,300, to 27,847. Electronic monitoring is now expected to support a wide range of objectives, including public protection, victim safety, rehabilitation, and compliance. Against a backdrop of significant prison overcrowding, electronic monitoring is increasingly being relied upon as an alternative to custody. The introduction of the Sentencing Act 2026 is expected to accelerate this trend further, increasing both the number of people subject to monitoring and the demands placed on those responsible for delivering and responding to it.

This report brings together the findings from two strands of inspection fieldwork: the police response to breaches of electronically monitored bail conditions, and the use of electronic monitoring on community sentences and post-release licences. While they focus on different parts of the criminal justice system, both strands consider whether the governance, systems, processes and partnership arrangements supporting electronic monitoring are sufficiently mature and resilient to keep pace with its growing use.

Our inspection of the police response to breaches of electronically monitored bail conditions found dedicated officers and staff working hard to respond to a substantial and increasing demand. Yet national guidance was limited, and systems and processes in different fieldwork forces varied considerably. In the cases we examined, alleged breaches of electronically monitored bail conditions did not consistently lead to structured consideration of risk to victims, witnesses or the wider public. Poor record-keeping, information-gathering and analysis made it difficult for forces to understand either the demand generated by electronic monitoring or the effectiveness of their response.

For probation, electronic monitoring has expanded the range of tools available to support public protection and risk management. Regional electronic monitoring teams have improved oversight, strengthened governance and brought greater expertise to the management of increasingly complex monitoring arrangements. However, expansion has brought complexity. Across the Probation Service, practitioners are required to navigate a growing range of monitoring technologies, operating models and communication channels. While many recognise the potential value of electronic monitoring, it is not always fully integrated into supervision or rehabilitative work. We found examples of monitoring data being underused and practitioners receiving large volumes of information without always having the confidence or capacity to make best use of it. Many of the challenges identified in our 2022 inspection of electronic monitoring remain evident today.

A particular concern is that, despite significant investment in data systems and management information, achieving a reliable picture of electronic monitoring activity still requires substantial manual effort. On 30 June 2026, there were 5,043 individuals who should have been subject to electronic monitoring but were not being monitored.

Understanding who is subject to EM, who remains unassigned with the necessary equipment, and the reasons for this, often relies on the reconciliation of multiple datasets and validation exercises. As electronic monitoring continues to expand, the need for a single, trusted and accessible source of information becomes increasingly important for management of the caseload and public confidence.

Most concerningly, both inspection strands identified risks arising from fragmented information-sharing arrangements. Whether between probation and the Electronic Monitoring Service (EMS), police and courts, or across different information systems, the absence of clear, timely and reliable information frequently undermined confidence in monitoring arrangements.

Our probation inspection findings also raise important questions about fairness and equality. While national policy recognises that electronic monitoring should be applied equitably, we are yet to see mature arrangements for understanding disproportionality across protected characteristics. As the use of electronic monitoring grows, it will become increasingly important for criminal justice agencies to understand not only who is being monitored, but whether its use and outcomes differ for particular groups.

At its best, electronic monitoring offers opportunities to strengthen public protection, improve victim safety and support more effective supervision and monitoring in the community. These tools have the potential to be guard-rails, steering people away from the wrong choices. However, technology alone cannot deliver these outcomes. Success depends on the quality of the supporting systems, partnerships, governance and professional practice that sit around it.

As electronic monitoring assumes a more prominent role within the criminal justice system, the focus must shift from expanding its use to ensuring it is delivered consistently, effectively and in ways that achieve the intended benefits for victims, communities and those subject to monitoring. This report identifies examples of encouraging practice, but the 30 recommendations it makes also draw attention to the scale of progress required across the system. It highlights areas where much more improvement is required if electronic monitoring is to become the credible, effective and integrated tool that policymakers, practitioners and the public expect it to be.

Martin Jones CBE
HM Chief Inspector of Probation

Michelle Skeer OBE QPM
His Majesty’s Inspector of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services


Probation service leadership, policy and strategy
Since the 2022 HM Inspectorate of Probation thematic inspection, His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) has invested significantly in the governance and oversight of EM within the Probation Service. Regional EM teams are now established in all probation regions and provide better scrutiny of cases that have not been assigned relevant EM equipment, improved oversight of violations and more support for practitioners in navigating an increasingly complex EM landscape. National leadership has also strengthened through the introduction of a new operating framework and management information products. Together, these developments have improved oversight of installation performance, enforcement activity and individuals who are not being electronically monitored as planned, with senior leaders demonstrating a stronger understanding of operational performance than was evident in our previous inspection. The availability of management information has improved considerably. However, as with policing, a recurring concern was the absence of a single, trusted source of information.

Significant manual effort remains necessary to reconcile multiple datasets and establish key operational facts, including who is currently being monitored, who is not being monitored, and why monitoring has not yet started.

The policy framework underpinning EM is comprehensive. The Electronic Monitoring Operational Framework establishes clear principles about proportionality, purpose, credibility, integration and fairness. However, many frontline practitioners were unfamiliar with some of these principles and there was little evidence that they routinely informed day-to-day decision-making.

Arrangements for understanding outcomes were less developed than those for understanding activity. In the Probation Service, leaders could generally describe performance on installations, violations, enforcement activity, monitoring volumes and breach notifications but were less able to demonstrate whether EM was contributing to reductions in reoffending, improved public protection outcomes, enhanced victim safety or better rehabilitation. We also found limited ability to understand disproportionality. While some analysis had been undertaken for specific programmes, comprehensive assurance regarding the use or impact of EM across the full range of protected characteristics was lacking.

Pre-sentence and pre-release work
Information-sharing arrangements to support decisions about EM have improved since our previous inspection. Practitioners now routinely seek police information before recommending electronically monitored curfews, which helps them to identify domestic abuse and other safeguarding concerns that may affect the suitability of a proposed address. However, the quality and completeness of information provided by police forces varied considerably. In some cases, limited information, restricted timescales for disclosure or the absence of key details reduced practitioners’ ability to make fully informed decisions and, at times, created a false sense of assurance about the suitability of curfew arrangements.

The quality of pre-sentence advice to courts was mixed. Practitioners were generally able to identify a clear purpose for EM and recommendations were usually proportionate to the seriousness of the offence. However, reports did not consistently demonstrate how EM would contribute to rehabilitation, reduce offending or work alongside other proposed requirements. Assessment of an individual’s personal circumstances, diversity needs and capacity to comply with monitoring arrangements was often insufficient. Courts imposed the recommended EM requirement in most cases, although we found examples where EM was imposed despite practitioners identifying outstanding safeguarding concerns or assessing it as unsuitable.

Sentencers were particularly positive about alcohol abstinence and monitoring requirements, describing them as a credible intervention that provided objective evidence of compliance. Beyond alcohol monitoring, however, stakeholders reported that courts continue to associate EM primarily with curfews and are often less familiar with the wider range of technologies available. While practitioners and sentencers recognised the potential value of GPS monitoring and exclusion zones, confidence in their use was variable, particularly in relation to eligibility criteria, operational requirements and practical application.

Pre-release planning was inconsistent and often gave insufficient attention to the role EM was intended to play in managing risk, protecting victims and supporting rehabilitation. While practitioners had generally considered information on safeguarding and domestic abuse, there was less evidence that they had analysed the suitability, impact and purpose of EM, or explained monitoring requirements effectively to individuals before release. Information-sharing between prisons, probation and monitoring providers was inconsistent, contributing to delays, confusion and difficulties with implementation.

The strongest practice involved early planning, effective multi-agency communication and clear discussions with individuals about the purpose and expectations of EM. However, these examples were not widespread. Too often, planning focused on the practical arrangements for imposing EM rather than how monitoring would contribute to wider sentence objectives, public protection and successful resettlement. As a result, the potential for EM to make a meaningful contribution to rehabilitation, desistance and risk management was not consistently realised.

Electronic monitoring in probation service delivery
The quality of probation practice in relation to EM was mixed and showed limited improvement since our 2022 inspection. Practitioners generally identified relevant risks, needs and personal circumstances, but too often failed to analyse how EM would contribute to reducing reoffending, managing risk, protecting victims or supporting desistance. EM was frequently treated as a stand-alone requirement rather than an integrated part of sentence management, with insufficient consideration given to motivation, ability, readiness to comply, diversity needs and personal circumstances.

Weaknesses identified in initial assessments were often carried through into planning and delivery. Too often, plans did not consistently explain how EM would support rehabilitation, public protection or wider sentence objectives. Contingency planning was particularly weak, and opportunities to involve individuals, family members and partner agencies in supporting successful compliance were frequently missed.

The delivery of EM was also hindered by operational challenges. Delays in fitting monitoring equipment remained common, communication with providers was inconsistent, and practitioners frequently reported difficulties accessing, interpreting and using monitoring information. GPS trail monitoring and exclusion zones were widely regarded as valuable public protection tools, yet both were underused. Often, practitioners were more focused on getting tags fitted than using the information they provided.

Information-sharing and multi-agency working during sentence delivery were inconsistent. Opportunities to use EM to support safeguarding, victim protection and risk management were often missed, while management oversight was effective in fewer than one-third of the inspected cases. The sharing of information about electronic monitoring requirements with victims was inconsistent, limiting assurance that victims were being kept appropriately informed. Regions had introduced specialist EM teams, and some were piloting auto-enforcement models that improved oversight and timeliness. However, these approaches raised questions about practitioners’ ownership of EM and the extent to which EM was integrated within wider case management activity.

Reviewing activity was a significant weakness. Formal review of the effectiveness and impact of EM was often absent, with limited consideration of whether monitoring had achieved its intended purpose, contributed to behavioural change or remained necessary and proportionate. Preparation for the end of monitoring was particularly poor, which reduced the opportunities to sustain progress or adapt risk management arrangements once EM had ended.

Overall, we found that EM was too often delivered as an administrative requirement focused on compliance rather than as an active intervention capable of supporting rehabilitation, reducing reoffending and strengthening public protection.

Thursday, 29 October 2026

Housing in Prison via Recall

So am I reading this correctly?

"Through the National Plan to End Homelessness, the Government has given a commitment to halving the proportion of prison leavers released homeless...

we simply cannot commit to end homelessness for prison leavers...the problem is simply too hard to deal with...so under our commitment to end homelessness by the end of this parliament we need to be very clear: we will not be ending homelessness for people on probation, just halving the current problem...probation officers have the skills and abilities to manage vulnerable and difficult people who are likely to reoffend due to destitution...these people can just be recalled and housed in prison instead, even though we've also committed to reducing prison numbers by releasing them homeless only for them to fill up the prison spaces again within a matter of weeks"

I mocked the government's "commitment to end homelessness" because when it comes to people released from prison that commitment apparently doesn't involve "ending homelesness" at all, but halving the current numbers of people released homeless. I said in that post this leaves Probation to manage extremely vulnerable people in destitute situations where "housing in prison via recall" ultimately becomes sadly the better option.

Ok lets be clear here. This from AI:-

The text is a satirical or critical paraphrase of UK government policy rather than a direct, verbatim quote from a specific named official.

Context of the Claims

Official Policy Stance: Under the National Plan to End Homelessness, the UK Labour government (led by the Prime Minister and ministers in the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and Ministry of Justice) has committed to halving the proportion of prison leavers released into homelessness (to 'no fixed abode') by the end of the Parliament (around 2029). 

The Controversy: Critics, social justice charities (such as Nacro), and opposition MPs have pointed out that thousands of prisoners are still being released without accommodation, leading to recent media reports and parliamentary clashes over issues like early release schemes, housing shortages, and even reports of probation services or local offices resorting to extreme stopgaps like issuing tents. 

The Quote's Origin: The passage you provided exaggerates or caricatures the government's official target—which is explicitly framed as halving prison leaver homelessness rather than eradicating it entirely—and turns it into a cynical internal monologue representing what critics claim the policy amounts to in practice (i.e., failing to house people, relying on recall to prison, and cycling individuals back through the justice system).

Lord Farmer (Con) nailed it in July this year:-

To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the effectiveness of partnership working between prisons and local housing authorities in preventing homelessness and rough sleeping among prisoners released early.

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who are here today to debate an issue that could get lost amidst the penal populism informing much of the response to the next waves of early release following the Sentencing Act 2026.

Why do I refer to penal populism? Crime must be punished, and I completely understand the concerns of many victims about early release. However, the public vengefulness politicians court to achieve popularity, notably by demanding ever-longer custodial sentences, has led to ever-longer sentences, clogged up our prisons and contributed to the need for these great swathes of early release. The inflation in custodial sentence length between 2010 and 2025 was 45%.

In their book, The Honest Politician’s Guide to Prisons and Probation, criminologists King and Willmott reveal just how many ex-Justice Secretaries, from both main parties, regret “playing to the gallery” as
“tough law and order figures”,
as my noble friend Lord Clarke of Nottingham, who was Home Secretary following the 1992 general election, described his successors. This response was driven by the understandable outcry following the Jamie Bulger killing in early 1993 by two other children. Instead of acknowledging the need to challenge inadequate parenting and manage expectations about what a criminal justice system can do, the Home Secretary who followed my noble friend Lord Clarke kickstarted the still ongoing competition between the two main parties as to who could be toughest on crime.

My response to the arms race that penal populism generates and has filled our prisons with is that, like the nuclear arms race, we simply cannot afford the price tag, either in sheer cash terms of £60,000 to £65,000 per prisoner per annum, or the squandering of human potential. Those sentenced for sexual offences—over one-fifth of prisoners—are treated as unreservedly heinous despite considerable variability in seriousness and the hypersexualisation of society. We want to lock them up and throw away the key, but the vast majority will leave prison. They and we need their genuine rehabilitation. Many have lost their families, livelihoods and homes. Only about one-third move into settled accommodation post release, compared to the average of around 45%.

More generally, imprisonment itself renders offenders homeless when tenancies lapse, mortgages are not paid or family circumstances mean they cannot return home. Despite a continuing duty of care, far too many are released homeless. Also, rehabilitation without a proper roof is almost impossible, and the statistics bear this out: their proven reoffending rate of 76% is more than double the 36.4% of those who reoffend after being released into settled accommodation. Can the Minister confirm whether the Government have assessed how many of those released early are likely to return to prison, whether through recalls for breaching licence conditions or reoffending?

This is a far grislier question, but have they assessed how many are likely to die? Leaving prison homeless is a major risk factor for death shortly after release. Last month, a Guardian investigation reported record numbers of deaths within two weeks of release in 2025—a 28% rise since 2021. Similarly, the charity Nacro found that more than one person dies every day in the year after leaving prison, and last year one in every 144 people released died within that period, more than three times the rate in 2015. In 40% of cases, drugs are a factor and homelessness interacts fatally with that: there is no structure, support or healthcare.

Inside Time, the prisoners’ newspaper—which I know the Minister reads, as do I—says that:
“An estimated 6,000 prisoners will be released earlier than planned from English and Welsh jails in 10 monthly tranches, starting on 2 September”. 
So it is very concerning that HM Inspectorate of Prisons told the Commons Public Accounts Committee in November 2024 that, at some prisons, the limited housing stock available for those released had been
“overwhelmed by early release schemes”.
Although the Government have responded to Written Questions by saying that local authorities collaborate effectively with the Prison Service to reduce homelessness, Ministry of Justice data shows that almost 13,000 people left prison homeless or as rough sleepers in the year to April 2025—a 39% rise from the previous year. Similarly, the Government’s A National Plan to End Homelessness states that this
“could have been prevented had better coordination and planning been in place”.
The duty to refer in the Homelessness Reduction Act 2017 was designed to facilitate this, and almost half of all “duty to refer” referrals are from criminal justice system organisations. Almost 10 years on from that Act, I welcome the implicit recognition in the proposed new duty to collaborate that it is not working as it should for ex-prisoners. Will the Minister explain how the new duty to collaborate will achieve the level of change required and whether it will be introduced in time to meet September’s heightened need for housing? What incentives, or even sanctions where necessary, will be put in place to ensure better joint working, not least in the interests of rehabilitation?

Prison capacity has been such an emergency issue, but the time has surely come for this to come into much sharper focus as a slower-burn way of reducing our prison population and the criminal justice budget. Reoffending costs us all £18 billion a year. Releasing prisoners into homelessness, especially rough sleeping, single-handedly undermines any previous and future rehabilitation activity. Without accommodation, they cannot seek work and restructure their lives.

Collaboration with local housing authorities is essential for rehabilitation. Some are far more effective than others at finding accommodation for ex-prisoners, even in areas of very pressured housing markets. The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman reports that many London boroughs compare badly with statistical neighbours where housing is concerned. In 2025, the London Assembly housing committee flagged inconsistent practice across London boroughs with weak co-ordination between prisons, probation and borough housing teams; prisons not consistently complying with the duty to refer; and late referrals from prisons contributing greatly to uncertainty.

I return to the plan to end homelessness. This Government have committed, by the end of this Parliament, to a 50% reduction in homelessness among people on their first night out of prison and an increase in the number of prison leavers in settled accommodation three months post release and thereafter. To conclude, I ask the Minister to outline how prisons and probation will deliver their responsibilities under the plan to embed local partnerships, collocation and pre-release planning.

--oo00oo--

It will be recalled that not long after this debate the cobbler resigned shortly before the new Prime Minister declared in Downing Street that his mission was to "end rough sleeping". As the Guardian reports, the sum committed is now some £900million, but prison releases are proving that for many it's actually "housing in prison via recall".