Sunday 14 February 2021

Guilty But Let Off

Having been glued to the TV for days watching the impeachment trial saga play out, in the end I couldn't bring myself to fully listen to the utterly odious and contemptible Mitch McConnell attempt to explain for the benefit of history his lame and disgraceful reasons for not convicting Trump. In my book he gets absolutely no credit whatsoever for condemning Trump's actions in the strongest terms, whilst gutlessly refusing to do his duty in the earnest hope that others will via criminal or civil means.

Even ignoring the blatant self-interest of this most unattractive of politicians, the sheer hypocrisy of the man is breath taking for having made his decision on the baseless 'unconstitutionality' argument, a situation entirely of his own making by refusing to allow the case to begin whilst Trump was still in office. It's almost certain that he alone could have ensured a conviction by doing the right thing and thus bring enough Republican votes with him, but he's got his place in history along with his 42 colleagues and it's not going to be favourable.

The prosecution case was both thorough and convincing in stark contrast to the rambling theatricals of the Trump defence. By common agreement they were completely 'outlawyered' but of course it didn't really matter what they said as acquittal was fairly-well ensured with so many GOP senators remaining fearful of Trump and losing their comfy jobs. Hats off though to the magnificent seven who now have to cope with ferocious attacks from an emboldened former president and his army of vindicated thugs.

One of the saddest parts of this whole sorry saga will be the precedent now fully established of election mistrust and that being used by Republican states as justification for further voter suppression. Under the guise of improving election security, some 200 legislative measures are already being introduced that will have the effect of making it as hard as possible for the black vote to be cast. The GOP know they can't win in any other way and 'states rights' gives them licence to effectively be as racially discriminatory as they like. What a horrid, horrid state of affairs when one dreadful sociopathic man can be allowed to wreak such damage on a great democracy. 

So, as we prepare to go to the polls in May, armed for the first time with our own means of putting crosses on bits of paper, rather than the special short stubby pencils that allow the crosses to be rubbed out by election officials or MI5 and thus facilitate vote rigging, be thankful we don't have a federalised system and 435 ways of running elections in the UK. This from the Vox website:-    

State GOPs have already introduced dozens of bills restricting voting access in 2021

In 2020, voters turned out at the highest level in 100 years, thanks in part to expanded vote-by-mail. In response, state-level Republicans are introducing an unprecedented amount of legislation to restrict voting rights, according to a new report from the Brennan Center for Justice.

State legislators in 28 states have filed 106 bills restricting the franchise thus far in 2021 — and the overwhelming majority have come from Republicans. Compare that to last year at this time: Then, only 35 such bills had been filed in six states.

“We are seeing a backlash,” says Eliza Sweren-Becker, the report’s lead author. “Rather than going out and trying to persuade voters, we’re seeing legislators trying to shrink the electorate in order to ensure job security for themselves.”

The proposed legislation largely falls into two categories: bills that either increase the difficulties individual Americans would face absentee voting or that give officials greater leeway to shrink the voter pool. Some are attempts to roll back voting rights expansions necessitated by the pandemic; others are retreads of policies Republicans have pushed before, like expanded voter identification laws.

The passage of these laws will, essentially, depend on whether Republicans control both the statehouse and the governorship in the states in which they’ve been introduced — a reality in 18 of the 28 states. And while Sweren-Becker says their constitutionality would hinge on the way each bill is written and implemented, a lot of them have a decent chance at sticking around.

The news isn’t all bad: A whopping 406 bills have been introduced in 35 states that would expand access to voting, including permanently codifying the absentee voter policies that allowed voters in some states to cast their ballots early and remotely. Some states will consider both expansive and restrictive voting rights bills; which path the state follows will likely hinge on which party controls the legislature.

At the national level, Democrats in Congress are pushing a number of voting rights bills. Last year, the House passed the John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act, which would provide for federal oversight in states with a recent history of racial discrimination in voting laws. On Thursday, Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) reintroduced his annual Vote From Home bill with Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-OR), which would mandate universal absentee voting — or the ability to vote by mail without an excuse — for federal elections and disallow states from imposing “additional conditions or requirements on the eligibility of the individual,” save for the postmark deadline.

“Last year we saw a widespread expansion of vote-at-home access as a safe and secure way to participate during the COVID-19 pandemic,” Blumenauer said in a release. “We should continue to make voting easier, not harder.”

At each level of government, the fight over the future of how America’s democracy operates is in full effect — and states are moving quickly.

16 comments:

  1. I agree with that.
    For me, we always knew the Republicans would support him, but in having the public hearing we saw, from the House Managers, the horrendous footage of what really happened that day. Some of it was redacted as it is so horrific. Included the preparations to hang Mike Pence, one of their own, in public. Many republicans were shocked at how close they had been to witnessing deaths across the house. A bit like the Truth and Reconciliation trials in South Africa, the truth is now out there.
    The Court is not the Senate but the American public. I hope that will show up in the election results of next year, especially if Trump stands.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Just listened to a fascinating discussion on CNN that's blown me away. A Republican academic was asked about the future prospects for the party and he said there's two ways they can win in the future - the easy way or the hard way. The easy way is just carry on gerrymandering! Been doing it for years and courts allow any manner of methods to stop opponents either voting or having their votes counted. All public knowledge that they choose their voters rather than voters choose them! The hard way is to change the party so it's more electable. And this is the greatest democracy in the world?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And there lays the problems of having a written consultation. As time moves, and society develops, the intentional meaning of each amendment within that Constitution has to be revisited, reinterpreted and applied to suit the present.
      It's those with power and political influence that decide what was ment and how its interpreted in today's world.
      Instead of being a universal instrument to afford all equal rights, its become a tool for the powerful to twist and manipulate to suit their own advantage.
      A written Constitution only works if its accompanied by political integrity.
      Sadly, there's not much political integrity to be found anywhere on the planet in today's world.

      'Getafix

      Delete
  3. In my opinion, one of the major stumbling points is the autonomy of the states with their differing procedures and ways of counting.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jim, both parties gerrymander as this article explains:

    https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/nation-politics/marylands-redistricting-case-reminds-us-both-parties-gerrymander-a-lot/

    Check out a map of Maryland's congressional districts and how ridiculous they're drawn!

    Getafix, it's that written constitution that meant the election went ahead in the first place. Without it Trump would have just postponed the election due to the pandemic. After all, that's what happened here with the UK local elections.

    @17.29, it may be a stumbling block but it's a federation and that's the way it should be. The US only exists as an entity because of a federation of states. The federal government would have no power whatsoever to reduce that autonomy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for that - how very alarming and disappointing - clearly my deep dive into things American has a lot further to plunge. Greatest democracy? I think not.

      Delete
    2. JB I am no trump supporter but the outcome is a mark of institutional dynamics . Politics is dirty we don't hold anyone to account really. Boris blinders to a record death rate and he is going to win the may elections. Why because starmer is weak and considering a nationalism drive to appear more electable to flag waving idiots sorry patriots. We have elected leader to act as they please until election day. They do as they please too look at Napo a completely incompetant useless general sell out come do a deal members won't notice secretary gets away with it so why not the bigger boys. It's the structures the same in all offices the managers fiddle or shaft staff around no ordinary person gets a fair day.

      Delete
    3. Does anyone know if there is a mechanism for holding a recall vote for the NAPO General Secretary?

      Delete
  5. I have to say that I am in no doubt that, on the whole, human decency & the principle of the impeachment won through. It didn't need a guilty verdict - in fact that outcome might have been counterproductive, overshadowed the merits of the house managers' presentation & led to the martyrdom of trump.

    A number of contributors have been discussing US politics on this blog. Jim & others - including me - have been glued to US tv channels. The world has been watching this and the house managers knew that, hence they kept their cool & allowed their humanity to be on public display - unlike the petulant foul-mouthed ambulance chasers. I trust they were paid well.

    team trump has been made toxic, not least by the post-trial ramblings of cowardly lion mitch mcconnell, and there are now numerous criminal as well as civil matters being considered including a civil case by those who lost loved ones on 6 Jan, those who were injured & traumatised on 6 Jan.

    It might also open actions by by institutions who were affected e.g. the District of Columbia & the national park service who issued the amended permit for 6 Jan which explicitly stated: "This permit does not authorize a march from the Ellipse."

    Fox News claim the permit has a clause which allows for a march. It doesn't. trump specifically told the mob to march down pennsylvania avenue, that he would march with them, and they would go to the capitol together.

    Fox is referring to a line in the permit which says that some participants may leave to attend rallies at the capitol ... BUT the very specific Additional Condition states explicitly:

    "This permit authorizes the use of the Ellipse southwest quadrant, west of the vista site line and south of the tree lighting site starting on Saturday, January 2 at 6:30 am until Wednesday, January 8, 2021 at 7:30 pm. This permit does not authorize a march from the Ellipse."

    NPS Permit 21-0278 dated 5 Jan 2021.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Shapeshifter-in-Chief speaks out about "kerfuffle"

    "I think the clear message that we get from the proceedings in America is that, after all the toings and froings and all the kerfuffle, American democracy is strong," he said.

    "And the American constitution is strong and robust. And we're delighted now, I'm very delighted, to have a good relationship with the White House, which is an important part of any UK prime minister's mission.

    "I've had some good conversations already with President Biden, fantastic conversations about the way he sees things."

    ReplyDelete
  7. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/lindsey-graham-impeach-kamala-harris-b1802201.html%3famp

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anybody know if probation workers are to be offered the vaccine?

    When COVID-19 began we worked in offices because probation were ‘essential key workers’ and a ‘critical service’. Information was drip-fed to us on a need-to-know basis.

    Our senior leaders got £1500 monthly bonuses working from home, because WE (not them) kept offices open as ‘essential key workers’ and a ‘critical service’. We got zilch. Despite long hours we couldn’t fast-track supermarket queues and the clapping wasn’t for us.

    We got no Personal Protective Equipment as we weren’t a ‘priority’ service. Months later, after colleagues died, we got basic Personal protective Equipment as ‘essential key workers’ and a ‘critical service’.

    We were ‘essential key workers’ and a ‘critical service’, but weren’t in the “pay rises for doctors, police and more in the public sector” announced in July 2020, “with teachers and doctors seeing the largest rise at 3.1% and 2.8% respectively recognising their efforts on the frontline during the battle against COVID-19. Police and prison officers will both have a 2.5% rise in pay”.

    In September 2020 as civil servants we were “strongly encouraged" back into offices through rota systems, because it was “hugely beneficial" because we were ‘essential key workers’ and a ‘critical service’. We still had no direction and the @NPsBirmingham Bronze Commander had gone silent!

    March 2021 marks a year since the first lockdown. Probation is longer named on the list of “essential to the running of the justice system”, while our colleagues are still dying from COVID-19. Information is still drip-fed to us on a need-to-know basis. Whisperings that prison officers (the big P in HMPpS) are being offered the vaccine and the @NPSLDN_Director knows “the science”!

    If we are ‘essential key workers’ and a ‘critical service’ then we should be offered regular testing and priority vaccination. The ‘withdrawn’ Independent report
    Priority groups for coronavirus (COVID-19) vaccination agreed:

    “The committee is currently of the view that the key focus for the second phase of vaccination could be on further preventing hospitalisation.

    Vaccination of those at increased risk of exposure to SARS-CoV-2 due to their occupation could also be a priority in the next phase. This could include:
    * first responders
    * the military
    * those involved in the justice system
    * teachers
    * transport workers
    * public servants essential to the pandemic response.”

    https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/priority-groups-for-coronavirus-covid-19-vaccination-advice-from-the-jcvi-2-december-2020/priority-groups-for-coronavirus-covid-19-vaccination-advice-from-the-jcvi-2-december-2020#vaccine-priority-groups-advice-on-2-december-2020

    Petition 12,089 signatures

    Make prison staff top priority as key workers to recieve the covid 19 vaccine

    https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/567308

    Ps. Could have been a guest blog. Too busy recovering from Trump news.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks despite everything - much appreciated.

      Delete
  9. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.walesonline.co.uk/news/uk-news/court-staff-england-wales-balloted-19838911.amp

    ReplyDelete
  10. history of the age of austerity - worth a listen on R4

    "Its ten years since George Osborne revealed the biggest cuts to government spending since the Second World War. Now, in this post Covid world, the government faces a new, far bigger challenge as it tries to shore up a plunging economy.

    In this four-part series, Paul Johnson, Director of the Institute of Fiscal Studies, examines a decade of austerity to ask why it happened, did it need to happen, what were the effects and what next? He talks to some of the leading players in the drama such as Alistair Darling, former Chief Secretary to the Treasury Nick Macpherson, former minister David Gauke and former policy adviser to Nick Clegg, Polly Mackenzie as well as some of those directly affected.

    The first programme looks at the origins of a decade austerity, its roots in the 2008 banking crisis and the key spending reviews of 2010 and 2015 which delivered huge cuts to many government departments. The second programme looks at the impact on austerity on the Justice Department and local government. The third on the welfare system and education and the final programme looks at how austerity has hit the NHS and what economic options the current Chancellor Rishi Sunak faces dealing with a government deficit estimated to be £300bn.

    Helping Paul Johnson is financial blogger Iona Bain who asks how austerity has affected her generation of millennials and how the Covid crisis is going to affect the fortunes of those in currently in their twenties and thirties."

    ReplyDelete
  11. Who do we believe?

    1. UK minister Nadhim Zahawi claimed on Tuesday that the quarantine rollout had "gone smoothly" in England.


    2. Hotel quarantine rollout in England 'an absolute joke', says border official - Border Force sources say staff given less than three hours to digest guidance on new checks

    Or...

    1. All those arriving into Scotland directly from outside the Common Travel Area must pay to isolate for 10 days in a quarantine hotel.

    2. If they arrive at airports and ferry terminals elsewhere, then travel to Scotland on public transport, they don't have to quarantine in a hotel & can self-isolate at home.

    As usual, nothing makes sense!

    Fly from a 'red list' country to Dublin then take a flight to London, Edinburgh, Cardiff - no quarantine required; or fly to Heathrow then catch a bus or train to Scotland to evade their more stringent rules.

    Despite the usual weasel words there is NO border control in the UK. Incompetent as ever.

    ReplyDelete