It's almost certainly a product of advancing years that things that seemed understood and quite straightforward years ago are now an almost complete mystery. Things were so simple, but now aren't. Jobs and role boundaries have changed beyond recognition and as one agency has retreated from areas of work, another has taken it over.
I can still recall being shocked by a phone call many years ago from a police officer regarding a client of mine and their 'supervision' of them. I heard myself saying 'but that's my job' as they explained their job title under the umbrella of Integrated Offender Management.
Isn't it astonishing that during a period of austerity and substantial cuts in numbers of police officers, the police have been quietly encroaching upon areas of work that most would feel were the legitimate purview of other more appropriate agencies, such as probation. It surely cannot be unconnected that as probation has found itself increasingly side-lined and in chaos, the police have been quietly moving their tanks onto our lawns?
Of particular note is Durham Constabulary who were testing the legal boundaries some time ago with 'supervision' facilities for the injecting of heroin provided by them! Now they are flying the flag for the rehabilitation of offenders as well because, as the Chief Constable puts it, "the current criminal justice sanctions were not effective for dealing with low-level offences such as shoplifting, assault or drug possession."
It's absolutely extraordinary that as probation is being quietly strangled under the dead hand of centralised bureaucratic control, it's now the police who are able to be flexible, innovative and forward-thinking. No more 'we lock 'em up and you let 'em out'. They are the new liberal-minded social service, the 'iron fist in a velvet glove'. Why don't we just merge with them and have done with it - a 'one stop shop'? We might be better off under the Police and Crime Commissioners than bloody civil servants. This from the Guardian:-
Durham's pioneering police scheme slashes reoffending rates
Reoffending rates have been slashed in a pioneering police scheme in north-east England which experts say could lead to a transformation in how the justice system deals with violent crime.
More than 2,660 offenders who have committed offences such as burglary and assault have taken part in an experiment in which they avoid prosecution if they take part in a rehabilitation programme for issues such as mental health and substance abuse. If they complete the four-month contract with police, they walk away without a criminal conviction. If they do not, they are prosecuted in the traditional way.
The initiative by Durham constabulary is the longest-running and most advanced of its kind in England, with at least five other forces, including Surrey and Devon & Cornwall, considering the introduction of similar schemes. The first results of the trial, seen by the Guardian, found a 15-percentage point drop in reoffending after two years among those who took part in rehabilitation compared with those who did not.
Most of the 519 offenders in the first cohort of the trial had been arrested for violence, theft, drug possession or criminal damage. About half had no previous convictions but others had been arrested as many as 52 times. The results, which are part of a University of Cambridge study to be published in 2022, are the most significant indication to date of the long-term success of “deferred prosecution” programmes in England.
The findings will reopen the debate about whether such initiatives represent “soft justice”, as some critics claim, or are successful in reducing crime and cutting costs. The idea has gained traction with senior police leaders and is to be discussed by the National Police Chiefs Council later this month.
Jo Farrell, the chief constable of Durham constabulary, said the current criminal justice sanctions were not effective for dealing with low-level offences such as shoplifting, assault or drug possession. “What I’m not saying is where people commit serious offences, they won’t feel the full force of the law,” she said. “This isn’t about trying to do things on the cheap or divert people away from court or prison. It’s a cohort of people for whom this cycle will never end unless we do something different.”
Under the Durham programme, called Checkpoint, offenders spend four months with a police supervisor who helps them access support for issues including mental health, to drug or alcohol use, homelessness and communication skills. Of the 2,660 offenders involved in the trial to date, only 166 (6%) have reoffended.
The initiative also involves the victim of the crime, consulting them on the progress of the offender’s rehabilitation, although they do not get the final say on whether the offender is prosecuted. Durham police said only five victims had complained out of the 2,660 offenders who had completed the programme.
Checkpoint costs the force £480,000 a year but an internal estimate suggests that for every 1,000 offenders it saves at least £2m a year in reduced crime. A similar trial in the West Midlands, which ended in 2014, tracked 414 offenders over two years and found that the amount and severity of reoffending by those on deferred prosecutions was lower, or no worse, than those who were prosecuted. That study, by criminologists at Cambridge, has not yet been published.
Prof Lawrence Sherman of the university’s Institute of Criminology said there was mounting evidence against the prosecution of low-level offences such as theft or common assault. “It’s expensive, it rarely results in a formal punishment, victims aren’t satisfied with it. It’s generally a pretty bad way to manage low-level offences which are the highest volume offences,” he said.
Sophie Gregory, criminology course director at Birmingham City University, described the Durham findings as significant and said: “We know that around two-thirds of women and a third of men are reportedly committing crime to fund addictions, so if we can go back to that root problem and help with some tailored support long term it has got to help reduce reoffending.”
The debate about rehabilitation was reignited by the terrorist attacks in London Bridge in November and Streatham this month, both carried out by men who had been recently released after prison sentences for terrorism offences. Boris Johnson also made “law and order” a key part of his 2019 election campaign, promising among other things to prosecute within a week anyone caught with a knife.
But Farrell said such a blanket approach may not always be appropriate. “Within all offences, there’s context. You get bold statements by politicians: ‘Everybody who carries a knife must go to prison.’ Policing is based on discretion – we have a lot of discretion and a lot of autonomy,” she said. “Context is everything and the situation you’re dealing with and their background. Taking a very binary position on things strikes me as a not very intelligent way of dealing with an issue.”
Alex Mayes of the charity Victim Support said the one wish of those affected by crime was for the offender to stop offending. He added: “Where evidence shows offender management schemes to be effective at reducing reoffending, many victims of low-level offences may be open to credible and safe programmes. However, just as in the wider public, justice means different things to different victims of crime. For this reason, where these schemes are used, it is vital that all victims receive explanations as to their use, and that victims’ ongoing feedback is sought in order to inform the process.”
An attempt to help explain the mysteries and magic that are part and parcel of 'probation'.
Monday, 17 February 2020
Sunday, 16 February 2020
Pick of the Week 58
So much evidence, so many testimonies, a tragedy of errors; it should surely be a piece of piss for unions representing staff to address these issues? Staff are clearly at breaking point but too scared to stand up & say so, hence they are effectively enabling the shitshow to continue. If Probation staff blew the whistle it would all collapse, wouldn't it? That's not to blame staff.
Whistle-blowing isn't an easy thing to do. I know from experience. But does make things change. And it seem that there are plenty of staff in shit situations. I'm a union steward (not NAPO), and can assure you that staff are all encouraged to speak out by me. But you can't force folk and as you say they are scared of repercussions. Very sad but true.
*****
What's a "parole officer"? Once again the media can't even get our job title correct let alone understand what we do. I shouldn't be surprised as it's not the first time and won't be the last but when Buckland went on the Today programme to stand up this reactionary knee jerk crowd pleasing bollocks he mentioned the importance of the role of every agency by name except, you guessed it, Probation! I remain heartily sick of being ignored and undervalued for my role in protecting the public by helping people change but sadly, not surprised.
*****
The Guardian offers one perspective, and one perspective only. Never liked the paper and never will. When you deal with criminals of any calibre there is no fail safe way to ensure they will never offend again. Mix and match who you like in prisons and the results are the same. You either keep your head down, and get on with your lives or you entangle yourself further into criminality. Most will give up through age and the usual social and environmental factors, and others are so far gone they enjoy and revel in what they do, it gives them satisfaction. This is the conundrum we face, but until the CJS gets a grip on itself not much is going to change. Old lag, reformed.
*****
It will always be a battle, and wearying: the really depressing thing is that from the time I started in Probation way back in the last century, we (practitioners, academics, progressives) seem to have been losing ground. I formed a view a long while back that when UK looked to Europe for influence on its criminal justice policy, things got a bit better, and when we looked to the US, things got worse. So that wearying fight looks even more desperate now.
*****
There's always reforms and policy changes in the CJS. But they're never accompanied with any explanation of how they're intended to advance the system. They're reactionary, politically motivated and short sighted. I can totally understand why people call for longer prison sentences, and an end to automatic release at the halfway mark. It should be remembered however that under the old two thirds system that many prisoners were released on parole having served much less then half their sentence, and if released after two thirds they were not subject to supervision.
Just making sentences longer changes what? If someone's sick and admitted to hospital for a week and receives no treatment, then they're still likely to be sick when they're discharged. Simply saying that they are now going to spend two weeks in hospital without any treatment just means they stay in hospital longer, but still get discharged with the same issues. Sometimes I wonder if the CJS is a too valuable political tool for politicians to really want to fix it.
*****
It's been announced that Interserve are not bidding for UPW/Interventions in the new round of tenders. Nothing on google as of yet but it has been announced to staff. Interesting times ahead.
*****
Probation Officers are using out of date risk assessment tools to ascertain risk and in my case, release was not supported by 3 probation officers including a senior one. This was not because of any serious or imminent risk of serious harm to the public but perceived and wrongly forecast risk of psychological harm to CJS professionals. The PB saw right through it and ripped all three probation officers to shreds. I'm very pleased that one resigned as an OS in HMP Downview shortly after, stating stress.
The Parole Board told probation staff that their evidence was not credible and that they could not be believed although they had conspired, and I don't use that word lightly, with the prison psychologist to get their stories straight and song from the same hymn sheet about not recommending release. The PB deemed my recall to prison for daring to tweet about how awful NPS had become, to be unlawful and ordered immediate release.
For the most part probation officers are decent, kind and properly trained but the cuts and mass exodus has left the service broken and in tatters. Unless and until there is root and branch reform of the way probation service operates, staff will continue to be overstretched and people will be recalled unlawfully and cases seriously mismanaged. Probation workers should be subject to the same scrutiny and accountability as all other social service workers, albeit they have an overriding public protection role...It's deeply worrying that staff are not accountable for bad decisions and people pay with their lives.
*****
A lot of probation staff now rely on & hide behind the pseudo-science of 'risk assessment', a growth industry in recent times. It takes far more than correctly entering data to assess risk, but it's just that approach that seems to be where many of the errors of judgement originate. It would perhaps be unkind to call it lazy; maybe more that its as a result of not enough time, not enough experience & not enough support from management.
Above observes: "For the most part probation officers are decent, kind and properly trained but the cuts and mass exodus has left the service broken and in tatters." I think it is certainly true that those being assessed pay a higher price for errors of judgement than those doing the assessments.
The risk-averse culture of organisations avoiding taking any blame means that unless there's a compelling case to answer the organisation wins out every time, and the person who feels (or who is) 'wrongly' assessed can be deprived of their liberty, deprived of their children, deprived of their rights or, in some tragic cases, deprived of their life.
MoJ says: "Criminal behaviour is influenced by a range of individual, social and environmental factors. People tend to interpret others’ behaviour as because of the sort of person they are. We often fail to see situational, environmental or social influences. Much decision making in criminal justice needs to be informed by an assessment of whether someone poses a risk to the public....
... What makes a good risk assessment tool?
It is important that the risk assessment tools we use are theoretically sound and provide reliable and valid estimates. Criteria for approving risk assessment tools is supported by advice from MoJ’s Correctional Services Accreditation and Advice Panel (CSAAP)."
*****
Was that fake news regarding Purple Futures/Interserve not bidding, or are we still waiting for confirmation?
*****
NAPO have sent all members an email confirming it and Ian Mulholland head of Interserve Justice has also confirmed it during a conference call to staff. I look forward to a blog on it. btw, managers still cracking the whip for us to tick those boxes - I think we should all go off sick so that everything fails as I assume they will still get fined until the contract expires?
*****
The assumption must be that they will be paid handsomely until the contract expires. Cute Mulholland knows how the game is played; when he was 'on the inside' he helped Spurr et al write the rules. He knows there's no risk of being fined between now & whenever the contracts actually expire. You don't get this level of protection for knowing nothing.
*****
Pay has been a major issue throughout but the NPS deal on pay worsened the CRCs position. Seetec have set the bar now but not because of union pressure. There are TR2 issues and recruitment. That pay offer is a done deal to mirror NPS pay. About time but no backdate awards says it all the unions seem powerless.
*****
Perhaps we could be told how this was specifically negotiated. What arguments were used that persuaded the employer? What researched information was submitted. When will this result be rolled out to other areas in the CRC regardless of who owns/runs them? Looking forward to this!
*****
I think for some years now social explanations for criminal behaviour and offending have been rubbed out, and been replaced with the notion that any such behaviour is largely an innate aspect of a deviant personality. A decade of Neoliberalism governance has tapped into the older Liberalism ideology of everyone being born equal in the eyes of God, ergo all have equal opportunity to follow the right path. Not to do so is a personal choice and a demonstration of an innate leaning to'wards deviance.
I think austerity has perpetrated and embedded that notion quite dramatically. It's much easier to explain huge cuts to social institutions and support networks when criminal behaviour is explained in the context of nature rather then nurture. Indeed, I'd argue that the removal of the social Work ethos of probation, and it's privatisation can be seen as a shift in ideology towards offending being seen as an innate aspect of personality. Removal of the social Work ethos is self explanatory, but privatisation saw offenders only through the prisim of risk. Ability, social status, personal opportunity and social need never really got a look in. Why? Because criminal behaviour should be seen as innate?
I think too that the drive to digitise the CJS also pushes towards the nature not nurture argument. Algorithms are being introduced everywhere from determining whether a defendant should be granted bail, whether they'll reoffend and even to what type of prison they should be held in. When technology is being applied in this fashion it surely negates many social explanations for offending? It;s a very cold and clinical approach all about process and devoid of the human understanding and knowledge that we learn throughout our personal journeys through life.
The nature/nurture argument is age old. I personally believe both play a part. We're all a little different to each other. Our genes determine parts of the way we are. That's nature's loaded gun. But I think it's nurture and our social position and understanding that inevitably decides if, when where or how we pull the trigger on that gun. All humans exhibit behavioural traits. Surely those that exhibit behaviour deemed unacceptable to society should not be seen as irredeemably flawed by nature?
*****
Counter-terrorism POs already exist, I think they are on the same pay as other POs. Not sure that they get much additional training. They don't supervise all TACT offenders either. I wonder what impact doubling the numbers will have, given the chronic shortage of POs. Will other POs take the strain. Given the increasing lack of diversity amongst POs, I also wonder how this client group responds to supervision by staff from different backgrounds and with different values.
*****
I'm no longer employed in Probation. Last week I spoke with an ex-colleague who is still employed by NPS. They told me the staff group in the area are battered & bruised, tired, frightened: "If you don't make waves you get left alone. No-one has the time or emotional space to fight. We're under-staffed, under-resourced & overwhelmed. Its head down, do the best you can & hope nothing goes wrong because there's no support from management & you're under a bus before you can blink. I'm ashamed that my passive compliance gives the green light to NPS, but that's how it is as a PO these days."
Jim - I reckon you're right on the money with your observation: "I'm rapidly gaining the impression that probation service staff must have been sufficiently cowed, purged, bullied and silenced under the dead-hand of civil service bureaucracy and central command and control by HMPPS."
*****
With respect, if you're paid to do a job then your employer has a right to expect you to do as you're told. People who create waves won't get far in any company or organisation, be it HSBC, Tesco, NPS or wherever. Some staff seem to want to undermine their employer at every opportunity yet are happy to bank their salary every month. My message to anybody who dislikes the NPS so much that they want to 'fight' is that they need to leave and not let the door hit them on their way out. Go and do a job that makes them less unhappy.
*****
The prison system is just a reflection of a broken society. It won't be fixed as long as it's seen as being separate from society, it's part of our social structure, and solving the prison crisis requires major change both sides of the gate. When someone is sent to prison, effectively the state take control of that persons life. They have some responsibility by taking that control, not just to that person in prison, but to the wider society as well. Yet the time in prison has no direction, no pathway to take that ownership of life back. It's just a dangerous and destructive ordeal.
Then ownership is passed on upon release to probation services. It's clear just by the comments on this blog over the years that probation services are no longer in any position to assist someone to reach a place where they're in a position to take that ownership back with the prospect of any real success. In fact the only thing that a prisoner has ownership of is responsibility for the offence they've been sent to prison for in the first place. I think it's right that someone who commits an offence should take responsibility for it, but when the state take ownership of that life they too need to take responsibility for what they do with it.
Sending someone to prison today isn't too far removed from fostering a damaged juvenile with alcoholic chaotic parents. It's not going to bring anything else but more problems. People who lose ownership of life need a route of getting it back any many need help in achieving that. There's a desperate need for penal reform, but much of what's needed to achieve that lays far beyond the institution gates.
*****
Having read today's blog & some of the posted comments I think it really IS all over now. So it looks like the truly nasty amoral political class have finally succeeded in their efforts to eliminate the remnants of what was a free-thinking, independent, humanitarian vocational profession by slicing & dicing, ducking & diving, slipping public money into the greasy palms of unscrupulous profiteers, and getting HMPPS to tailor a bespoke political straight-jacket for the NPS, i.e. the Civil Service.
If you build it, they will come: "My message to anybody who dislikes the NPS so much that they want to 'fight' is that they need to leave... if you're paid to do a job then your employer has a right to expect you to do as you're told." If I were to write the book it would be entitled "When Advise, Assist & Befriend became J.F.D.I."
*****
What have we come to? We are trained to challenge, confront and change offending (and offensive behaviour) but are we expected to simply bow, scrape and tug our forelocks to those who claim to be in control but who have driven the ship onto the rocks. Sometimes I despair.
*****
Totally agree and on both points. We are treated like disposable robots now, numbers and god forbid we display the very skills they incorporated in training. We are professionals in a so called career with degrees and [not] those without experience and responsible decision making. Why should we then simply shut up and follow mis management and organisational bullying and accept the stress and blame culture they place on us. Are we not supposed to be honest and fair people by nature of wanting to do a job working with others.
*****
I think you are missing the point; people ARE doing a job they love, they are devoted to it and want so much to do it well. But the sheer weight of work they know is meaningless and irrelevant is what makes them unhappy - they express themselves, as any good employee should do - they say "this isn't right - can we suggest change" and are told NO YOU MUST DO IT THIS WAY.
Nobody, at least not myself, is suggesting that an assessment is not required, followed by a meaningful risk management plan and a good sentence plan; I don't think most people suggest that these plans shouldn't be amended when required. But it's the sheer weight of bureaucracy which is towing them down.
The focus is ALWAYS on the OASYS filling out every box meticulously using prescribed guidance under which people fear getting "Requires Improvement" (even though most do), the ARMS, the Delius risk registers, using "CRISSA format" in every single Delius entry, filling out "HETE" data.....NONE of this has any meaning to the service user, and people know this - the focus is never on what goes on in the probation room, what have you achieved with this person and how did you achieve it or if not why not?
It makes people sick and yet you say "with respect, do what your employer says, or just LEAVE".... comments like yours create the culture of fear people say they are working in. Your comments have incensed me, but would love to hear your reply.
*****
Excellent post. From your knowledge of the current model you clearly know how the system operates and what the emphasis is placed on. I've done thirty years in the service and stayed in offender management throughout, as Jim's article says the estate is not up to the job, the one size fits all approach simply doesn't work. What hasn't been mentioned is the fact that other Justice agencies are also failing, the police and Courts are under resourced and this has a knock on effect on what we can do as well.
*****
You think oasys and ndelius is bad try using mysis and msat. Didn't work for 3 days last week. No-one knows what they are doing on it. Very little information and doesn't make sense the rest of the country and NPS are using different systems.
*****
Did I just read correctly...YET ANOTHER OASYS QA??? Have they not realised that the first three iterations have been complete FAILURES - they demoralise staff and as pointed out, chain staff filling out irrelevant information into boxes, after boxes after boxes! I've seen some wonderful sentence plans lately, and yet, according to OASYS QA cannot technically score "GOOD" if the "assessor" and "offender" comments boxes have not been completed with a few sentences of crap. CAN THESE EPF PEOPLE NOT HEAR US - IT IS OASYS that needs changing, NOT the people using it - perhaps if we got rid of the EPF team, and all the salaries that go into paying them to churn out tools, the money can go into creating an OASYS which works? Or better still....just write assessments on a Word for Windows document generated through delius, like ARMS is.
In a climate where the NPS has just been told in no uncertain terms by the HMIP that it's not working well, in a climate where staff are leaving in droves (perhaps created by the climate of fear generated through incessant focus on spending hours and hours updating OASYS in such meticulous terms), in a climate where there are hundreds of vacancies, when will NPS understand that THEY need to change not the staff working for it?
*****
As for Omic as a PO being given jobs that that prison don't have the resources to cover and told that we work for HMPPS now. God knows what it will be like when we come under the line management of the Governor. They set Oasys targets and supervision targets that there is not enough time to meet because we are expected to deliver for example Court documents to offenders appealing their convictions. Cover a large amount of admin tasks, but our stationery, etc. Oh and the prison does not promote diversity as it claims nor understand we are on more flexible working patterns. Horrid but apparently less stressful than our counterparts in community offices. It sounds horrendous out there.
*****
I'm a bit confused. YHCOSA preventing hundreds of victims? I don't think so. Sorry but this CEO's exaggerations do nothing for the repute of Circles. COSA is a great idea in theory, but Probation rightly found it intolerably expensive. In my experience the concept of Circles works best in church and faith communities....where the volunteers come from the congregations and most likely know the core member and effectively cost nothing....the unfortunate thing about CoSA was that the volunteers were often flaky and fickle, only applying to get something on their pyschology student CVs,And like most charities this CEO seems to have struggled with credibility with funders and the more general vagaries of funding.
*****
Meanwhile in the grim reality of Civil Service, a whole morning spent on "briefings for staff" with no mention of anything other than processes and targets. New processes and handy guides, etc etc. I am looking forward to the day when a New Process, with Handy Guide including Flowcharts, Quality Assurance Grid, and mandatory e-learning will be issued to guide me in the decision as to whether I need to go for a pee.
*****
Yep, that will be next and like call centres timed on how long we go to the loo etc via our computer log ons. You can't even easily search anything in equip nor do we have the time to muck about reading the mass of instructions they spout.
*****
Lost in the QAGmire. Motto for NPS - "Sorry we missed you. Maybe not as sorry as the victims of your SFO but never mind..."
After the official whitewash, denials, deflections & ritual sacrifice of expendable PO/PSO staff, above rightly highlights the introduction of a whole series of 'new processes', the Civil Service's 'grown-up' version of comics down your pants when you're called to see the headmaster for a jolly good thrashing.
*****
Have to love the tone. It's all a process of perpetual progress and continual improvements. It's exciting times! It should however be a much more apologetic tone, "we've made such a total f*** up, we're now scratching our heads wondering how to put things back together again. That would be honest at least.
Personally I think this new design is being tailored to eventually hand the reigns of probation services over to the regional PCCs. The local sheriff will decide what goes on in this town folks! For me however, it seems all about making the model look good. For sure there's objectives, but very little meat on the bone about why and how this model will achieve them. Maybe I just need things spelling out a bit more then most, but I want to hear "by doing this we are going to achieve x, y, and z." By not doing this it will allow us to achieve d, e and f." Architect's don't just design good looking buildings, they have to make them safe and functional too! More detail please.
Whistle-blowing isn't an easy thing to do. I know from experience. But does make things change. And it seem that there are plenty of staff in shit situations. I'm a union steward (not NAPO), and can assure you that staff are all encouraged to speak out by me. But you can't force folk and as you say they are scared of repercussions. Very sad but true.
*****
What's a "parole officer"? Once again the media can't even get our job title correct let alone understand what we do. I shouldn't be surprised as it's not the first time and won't be the last but when Buckland went on the Today programme to stand up this reactionary knee jerk crowd pleasing bollocks he mentioned the importance of the role of every agency by name except, you guessed it, Probation! I remain heartily sick of being ignored and undervalued for my role in protecting the public by helping people change but sadly, not surprised.
*****
The Guardian offers one perspective, and one perspective only. Never liked the paper and never will. When you deal with criminals of any calibre there is no fail safe way to ensure they will never offend again. Mix and match who you like in prisons and the results are the same. You either keep your head down, and get on with your lives or you entangle yourself further into criminality. Most will give up through age and the usual social and environmental factors, and others are so far gone they enjoy and revel in what they do, it gives them satisfaction. This is the conundrum we face, but until the CJS gets a grip on itself not much is going to change. Old lag, reformed.
*****
It will always be a battle, and wearying: the really depressing thing is that from the time I started in Probation way back in the last century, we (practitioners, academics, progressives) seem to have been losing ground. I formed a view a long while back that when UK looked to Europe for influence on its criminal justice policy, things got a bit better, and when we looked to the US, things got worse. So that wearying fight looks even more desperate now.
*****
There's always reforms and policy changes in the CJS. But they're never accompanied with any explanation of how they're intended to advance the system. They're reactionary, politically motivated and short sighted. I can totally understand why people call for longer prison sentences, and an end to automatic release at the halfway mark. It should be remembered however that under the old two thirds system that many prisoners were released on parole having served much less then half their sentence, and if released after two thirds they were not subject to supervision.
Just making sentences longer changes what? If someone's sick and admitted to hospital for a week and receives no treatment, then they're still likely to be sick when they're discharged. Simply saying that they are now going to spend two weeks in hospital without any treatment just means they stay in hospital longer, but still get discharged with the same issues. Sometimes I wonder if the CJS is a too valuable political tool for politicians to really want to fix it.
*****
It's been announced that Interserve are not bidding for UPW/Interventions in the new round of tenders. Nothing on google as of yet but it has been announced to staff. Interesting times ahead.
*****
Probation Officers are using out of date risk assessment tools to ascertain risk and in my case, release was not supported by 3 probation officers including a senior one. This was not because of any serious or imminent risk of serious harm to the public but perceived and wrongly forecast risk of psychological harm to CJS professionals. The PB saw right through it and ripped all three probation officers to shreds. I'm very pleased that one resigned as an OS in HMP Downview shortly after, stating stress.
The Parole Board told probation staff that their evidence was not credible and that they could not be believed although they had conspired, and I don't use that word lightly, with the prison psychologist to get their stories straight and song from the same hymn sheet about not recommending release. The PB deemed my recall to prison for daring to tweet about how awful NPS had become, to be unlawful and ordered immediate release.
For the most part probation officers are decent, kind and properly trained but the cuts and mass exodus has left the service broken and in tatters. Unless and until there is root and branch reform of the way probation service operates, staff will continue to be overstretched and people will be recalled unlawfully and cases seriously mismanaged. Probation workers should be subject to the same scrutiny and accountability as all other social service workers, albeit they have an overriding public protection role...It's deeply worrying that staff are not accountable for bad decisions and people pay with their lives.
*****
A lot of probation staff now rely on & hide behind the pseudo-science of 'risk assessment', a growth industry in recent times. It takes far more than correctly entering data to assess risk, but it's just that approach that seems to be where many of the errors of judgement originate. It would perhaps be unkind to call it lazy; maybe more that its as a result of not enough time, not enough experience & not enough support from management.
Above observes: "For the most part probation officers are decent, kind and properly trained but the cuts and mass exodus has left the service broken and in tatters." I think it is certainly true that those being assessed pay a higher price for errors of judgement than those doing the assessments.
The risk-averse culture of organisations avoiding taking any blame means that unless there's a compelling case to answer the organisation wins out every time, and the person who feels (or who is) 'wrongly' assessed can be deprived of their liberty, deprived of their children, deprived of their rights or, in some tragic cases, deprived of their life.
MoJ says: "Criminal behaviour is influenced by a range of individual, social and environmental factors. People tend to interpret others’ behaviour as because of the sort of person they are. We often fail to see situational, environmental or social influences. Much decision making in criminal justice needs to be informed by an assessment of whether someone poses a risk to the public....
... What makes a good risk assessment tool?
It is important that the risk assessment tools we use are theoretically sound and provide reliable and valid estimates. Criteria for approving risk assessment tools is supported by advice from MoJ’s Correctional Services Accreditation and Advice Panel (CSAAP)."
*****
Was that fake news regarding Purple Futures/Interserve not bidding, or are we still waiting for confirmation?
*****
NAPO have sent all members an email confirming it and Ian Mulholland head of Interserve Justice has also confirmed it during a conference call to staff. I look forward to a blog on it. btw, managers still cracking the whip for us to tick those boxes - I think we should all go off sick so that everything fails as I assume they will still get fined until the contract expires?
*****
The assumption must be that they will be paid handsomely until the contract expires. Cute Mulholland knows how the game is played; when he was 'on the inside' he helped Spurr et al write the rules. He knows there's no risk of being fined between now & whenever the contracts actually expire. You don't get this level of protection for knowing nothing.
*****
Pay has been a major issue throughout but the NPS deal on pay worsened the CRCs position. Seetec have set the bar now but not because of union pressure. There are TR2 issues and recruitment. That pay offer is a done deal to mirror NPS pay. About time but no backdate awards says it all the unions seem powerless.
*****
Perhaps we could be told how this was specifically negotiated. What arguments were used that persuaded the employer? What researched information was submitted. When will this result be rolled out to other areas in the CRC regardless of who owns/runs them? Looking forward to this!
*****
I think for some years now social explanations for criminal behaviour and offending have been rubbed out, and been replaced with the notion that any such behaviour is largely an innate aspect of a deviant personality. A decade of Neoliberalism governance has tapped into the older Liberalism ideology of everyone being born equal in the eyes of God, ergo all have equal opportunity to follow the right path. Not to do so is a personal choice and a demonstration of an innate leaning to'wards deviance.
I think austerity has perpetrated and embedded that notion quite dramatically. It's much easier to explain huge cuts to social institutions and support networks when criminal behaviour is explained in the context of nature rather then nurture. Indeed, I'd argue that the removal of the social Work ethos of probation, and it's privatisation can be seen as a shift in ideology towards offending being seen as an innate aspect of personality. Removal of the social Work ethos is self explanatory, but privatisation saw offenders only through the prisim of risk. Ability, social status, personal opportunity and social need never really got a look in. Why? Because criminal behaviour should be seen as innate?
I think too that the drive to digitise the CJS also pushes towards the nature not nurture argument. Algorithms are being introduced everywhere from determining whether a defendant should be granted bail, whether they'll reoffend and even to what type of prison they should be held in. When technology is being applied in this fashion it surely negates many social explanations for offending? It;s a very cold and clinical approach all about process and devoid of the human understanding and knowledge that we learn throughout our personal journeys through life.
The nature/nurture argument is age old. I personally believe both play a part. We're all a little different to each other. Our genes determine parts of the way we are. That's nature's loaded gun. But I think it's nurture and our social position and understanding that inevitably decides if, when where or how we pull the trigger on that gun. All humans exhibit behavioural traits. Surely those that exhibit behaviour deemed unacceptable to society should not be seen as irredeemably flawed by nature?
*****
Counter-terrorism POs already exist, I think they are on the same pay as other POs. Not sure that they get much additional training. They don't supervise all TACT offenders either. I wonder what impact doubling the numbers will have, given the chronic shortage of POs. Will other POs take the strain. Given the increasing lack of diversity amongst POs, I also wonder how this client group responds to supervision by staff from different backgrounds and with different values.
*****
I'm no longer employed in Probation. Last week I spoke with an ex-colleague who is still employed by NPS. They told me the staff group in the area are battered & bruised, tired, frightened: "If you don't make waves you get left alone. No-one has the time or emotional space to fight. We're under-staffed, under-resourced & overwhelmed. Its head down, do the best you can & hope nothing goes wrong because there's no support from management & you're under a bus before you can blink. I'm ashamed that my passive compliance gives the green light to NPS, but that's how it is as a PO these days."
Jim - I reckon you're right on the money with your observation: "I'm rapidly gaining the impression that probation service staff must have been sufficiently cowed, purged, bullied and silenced under the dead-hand of civil service bureaucracy and central command and control by HMPPS."
*****
With respect, if you're paid to do a job then your employer has a right to expect you to do as you're told. People who create waves won't get far in any company or organisation, be it HSBC, Tesco, NPS or wherever. Some staff seem to want to undermine their employer at every opportunity yet are happy to bank their salary every month. My message to anybody who dislikes the NPS so much that they want to 'fight' is that they need to leave and not let the door hit them on their way out. Go and do a job that makes them less unhappy.
*****
The prison system is just a reflection of a broken society. It won't be fixed as long as it's seen as being separate from society, it's part of our social structure, and solving the prison crisis requires major change both sides of the gate. When someone is sent to prison, effectively the state take control of that persons life. They have some responsibility by taking that control, not just to that person in prison, but to the wider society as well. Yet the time in prison has no direction, no pathway to take that ownership of life back. It's just a dangerous and destructive ordeal.
Then ownership is passed on upon release to probation services. It's clear just by the comments on this blog over the years that probation services are no longer in any position to assist someone to reach a place where they're in a position to take that ownership back with the prospect of any real success. In fact the only thing that a prisoner has ownership of is responsibility for the offence they've been sent to prison for in the first place. I think it's right that someone who commits an offence should take responsibility for it, but when the state take ownership of that life they too need to take responsibility for what they do with it.
Sending someone to prison today isn't too far removed from fostering a damaged juvenile with alcoholic chaotic parents. It's not going to bring anything else but more problems. People who lose ownership of life need a route of getting it back any many need help in achieving that. There's a desperate need for penal reform, but much of what's needed to achieve that lays far beyond the institution gates.
*****
Having read today's blog & some of the posted comments I think it really IS all over now. So it looks like the truly nasty amoral political class have finally succeeded in their efforts to eliminate the remnants of what was a free-thinking, independent, humanitarian vocational profession by slicing & dicing, ducking & diving, slipping public money into the greasy palms of unscrupulous profiteers, and getting HMPPS to tailor a bespoke political straight-jacket for the NPS, i.e. the Civil Service.
If you build it, they will come: "My message to anybody who dislikes the NPS so much that they want to 'fight' is that they need to leave... if you're paid to do a job then your employer has a right to expect you to do as you're told." If I were to write the book it would be entitled "When Advise, Assist & Befriend became J.F.D.I."
*****
What have we come to? We are trained to challenge, confront and change offending (and offensive behaviour) but are we expected to simply bow, scrape and tug our forelocks to those who claim to be in control but who have driven the ship onto the rocks. Sometimes I despair.
*****
Totally agree and on both points. We are treated like disposable robots now, numbers and god forbid we display the very skills they incorporated in training. We are professionals in a so called career with degrees and [not] those without experience and responsible decision making. Why should we then simply shut up and follow mis management and organisational bullying and accept the stress and blame culture they place on us. Are we not supposed to be honest and fair people by nature of wanting to do a job working with others.
*****
I think you are missing the point; people ARE doing a job they love, they are devoted to it and want so much to do it well. But the sheer weight of work they know is meaningless and irrelevant is what makes them unhappy - they express themselves, as any good employee should do - they say "this isn't right - can we suggest change" and are told NO YOU MUST DO IT THIS WAY.
Nobody, at least not myself, is suggesting that an assessment is not required, followed by a meaningful risk management plan and a good sentence plan; I don't think most people suggest that these plans shouldn't be amended when required. But it's the sheer weight of bureaucracy which is towing them down.
The focus is ALWAYS on the OASYS filling out every box meticulously using prescribed guidance under which people fear getting "Requires Improvement" (even though most do), the ARMS, the Delius risk registers, using "CRISSA format" in every single Delius entry, filling out "HETE" data.....NONE of this has any meaning to the service user, and people know this - the focus is never on what goes on in the probation room, what have you achieved with this person and how did you achieve it or if not why not?
It makes people sick and yet you say "with respect, do what your employer says, or just LEAVE".... comments like yours create the culture of fear people say they are working in. Your comments have incensed me, but would love to hear your reply.
*****
Excellent post. From your knowledge of the current model you clearly know how the system operates and what the emphasis is placed on. I've done thirty years in the service and stayed in offender management throughout, as Jim's article says the estate is not up to the job, the one size fits all approach simply doesn't work. What hasn't been mentioned is the fact that other Justice agencies are also failing, the police and Courts are under resourced and this has a knock on effect on what we can do as well.
*****
You think oasys and ndelius is bad try using mysis and msat. Didn't work for 3 days last week. No-one knows what they are doing on it. Very little information and doesn't make sense the rest of the country and NPS are using different systems.
*****
Did I just read correctly...YET ANOTHER OASYS QA??? Have they not realised that the first three iterations have been complete FAILURES - they demoralise staff and as pointed out, chain staff filling out irrelevant information into boxes, after boxes after boxes! I've seen some wonderful sentence plans lately, and yet, according to OASYS QA cannot technically score "GOOD" if the "assessor" and "offender" comments boxes have not been completed with a few sentences of crap. CAN THESE EPF PEOPLE NOT HEAR US - IT IS OASYS that needs changing, NOT the people using it - perhaps if we got rid of the EPF team, and all the salaries that go into paying them to churn out tools, the money can go into creating an OASYS which works? Or better still....just write assessments on a Word for Windows document generated through delius, like ARMS is.
In a climate where the NPS has just been told in no uncertain terms by the HMIP that it's not working well, in a climate where staff are leaving in droves (perhaps created by the climate of fear generated through incessant focus on spending hours and hours updating OASYS in such meticulous terms), in a climate where there are hundreds of vacancies, when will NPS understand that THEY need to change not the staff working for it?
*****
As for Omic as a PO being given jobs that that prison don't have the resources to cover and told that we work for HMPPS now. God knows what it will be like when we come under the line management of the Governor. They set Oasys targets and supervision targets that there is not enough time to meet because we are expected to deliver for example Court documents to offenders appealing their convictions. Cover a large amount of admin tasks, but our stationery, etc. Oh and the prison does not promote diversity as it claims nor understand we are on more flexible working patterns. Horrid but apparently less stressful than our counterparts in community offices. It sounds horrendous out there.
*****
I'm a bit confused. YHCOSA preventing hundreds of victims? I don't think so. Sorry but this CEO's exaggerations do nothing for the repute of Circles. COSA is a great idea in theory, but Probation rightly found it intolerably expensive. In my experience the concept of Circles works best in church and faith communities....where the volunteers come from the congregations and most likely know the core member and effectively cost nothing....the unfortunate thing about CoSA was that the volunteers were often flaky and fickle, only applying to get something on their pyschology student CVs,And like most charities this CEO seems to have struggled with credibility with funders and the more general vagaries of funding.
*****
Meanwhile in the grim reality of Civil Service, a whole morning spent on "briefings for staff" with no mention of anything other than processes and targets. New processes and handy guides, etc etc. I am looking forward to the day when a New Process, with Handy Guide including Flowcharts, Quality Assurance Grid, and mandatory e-learning will be issued to guide me in the decision as to whether I need to go for a pee.
*****
Yep, that will be next and like call centres timed on how long we go to the loo etc via our computer log ons. You can't even easily search anything in equip nor do we have the time to muck about reading the mass of instructions they spout.
*****
Lost in the QAGmire. Motto for NPS - "Sorry we missed you. Maybe not as sorry as the victims of your SFO but never mind..."
After the official whitewash, denials, deflections & ritual sacrifice of expendable PO/PSO staff, above rightly highlights the introduction of a whole series of 'new processes', the Civil Service's 'grown-up' version of comics down your pants when you're called to see the headmaster for a jolly good thrashing.
*****
Have to love the tone. It's all a process of perpetual progress and continual improvements. It's exciting times! It should however be a much more apologetic tone, "we've made such a total f*** up, we're now scratching our heads wondering how to put things back together again. That would be honest at least.
Personally I think this new design is being tailored to eventually hand the reigns of probation services over to the regional PCCs. The local sheriff will decide what goes on in this town folks! For me however, it seems all about making the model look good. For sure there's objectives, but very little meat on the bone about why and how this model will achieve them. Maybe I just need things spelling out a bit more then most, but I want to hear "by doing this we are going to achieve x, y, and z." By not doing this it will allow us to achieve d, e and f." Architect's don't just design good looking buildings, they have to make them safe and functional too! More detail please.
Labels:
CRC,
Criminal Justice System,
HMPPS,
Interserve,
NAPO,
NPS,
OASys,
OMIC,
Parole,
Parole Board,
Prison,
Probation,
SEETEC
Saturday, 15 February 2020
Command and Control 2
I notice the following was published by Clinks yesterday:-
Following the tragic incidents at Fishmongers Hall in November 2019, HMP Whitemoor in January 2020 and in Streatham in February 2020, Her Majesty's Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) put in place a number of restrictions on people in the criminal justice system and on their staff’s attendance at events.
The recent incidents, in particular the one that took place at Fishmonger’s Hall, affected many individuals and organisations in our sector. The loss of life was also a loss of two individuals’ passion and belief in the potential in everyone and in the power of working together to help people to change. But this passion and belief lives on within our sector and we are therefore concerned that any response to these events from either the criminal justice system or our own sector, must be proportionate and not undermine access to services that support desistance and enable people to improve their lives. We are talking to HMPPS to help minimise the impact of these restrictions while also keeping people safe.
The restrictions imposed by HMPPS
1. Temporary suspension of Release on Temporary Licence (ROTL) for the purpose of attending public events celebrating offender achievements, and a corresponding suspension of permitting offenders on licence from attending such events.
2. Any such events hosted by HMPPS in a public setting, with planned attendance by prisoners on ROTL or offenders on licence, should not go ahead until further notice.
3. In cases where such an event in a public setting is hosted by a partner organisation, the decision about whether to cancel is for that organisation. However, where events do take place, HMPPS staff should not attend.
4. Internal HMPPS events within prison establishments may go ahead, subject to local risk assessment.
It is possible for Prison Group Directors or Probation Divisional Directors to request permission for events/event attendances to go ahead, by exception, by making a request of their Executive Director, who will liaise with the Joint Extremism Unit ahead of a recommendation going to the relevant Director-General.
Clinks understands that these restrictions are based upon intelligence and assessments by the Security, Order and Counter Terrorism Directorate and the Joint Extremism Unit. HMPPS’ purpose is to reduce the risk of further incidents as far as possible and to keep people safe. We are, however, concerned to ensure that they do not limit access to rehabilitative opportunities across a wide range of people within the criminal justice system or have implications which present a challenge to the sector’s commitment to involve experts by experience in the design and delivery of services. In particular, we are concerned that under these restrictions it is unclear what constitutes “public events celebrating offender achievements” and that this may impact a wide range of criminal justice voluntary sector activities, even if not the intention. We know from discussions with members and partners that there is a lack of knowledge of the restrictions and what may be required of organisations. Furthermore, there is confusion as to how these restrictions may be interpreted, reports of inconsistencies in interpretation and concern as to the longer-term impact if they remain in place for much longer.
We have raised these concerns with HMPPS and are in ongoing discussions with them to pass on feedback from our sector, help them to understand the impact of the restrictions and limit that impact wherever possible. We understand the restrictions will be reviewed in March and we will keep the sector updated with regards to this. Both I and Richard Nicholls, Clinks’ Head of Operations and a member of the Reducing Reoffending Third Sector Advisory Group (RR3), are meeting with the Director General in the next weeks to discuss concerns and seek further clarity.
HMPPS has assured us that they are absolutely committed to supporting rehabilitative activity in our sector and working with organisations facing barriers to their work in this period when restrictions remain in place. Colleagues at HMPPS understand that the restrictions articulated above can’t account for every eventuality so they are happy to receive queries and referrals about events from the sector. If you have questions or concerns about how these restrictions might affect your activities please contact directorgeneralprisons@justice.gov.uk or directorgeneralprobation@justice.gov.uk.
If you have concerns or questions you can also get in touch with us. Richard.nicholls@clinks.org is leading on issues around working safely in the sector and is the best first point of contact.
1. Temporary suspension of Release on Temporary Licence (ROTL) for the purpose of attending public events celebrating offender achievements, and a corresponding suspension of permitting offenders on licence from attending such events.
2. Any such events hosted by HMPPS in a public setting, with planned attendance by prisoners on ROTL or offenders on licence, should not go ahead until further notice.
3. In cases where such an event in a public setting is hosted by a partner organisation, the decision about whether to cancel is for that organisation. However, where events do take place, HMPPS staff should not attend.
4. Internal HMPPS events within prison establishments may go ahead, subject to local risk assessment.
It is possible for Prison Group Directors or Probation Divisional Directors to request permission for events/event attendances to go ahead, by exception, by making a request of their Executive Director, who will liaise with the Joint Extremism Unit ahead of a recommendation going to the relevant Director-General.
Clinks understands that these restrictions are based upon intelligence and assessments by the Security, Order and Counter Terrorism Directorate and the Joint Extremism Unit. HMPPS’ purpose is to reduce the risk of further incidents as far as possible and to keep people safe. We are, however, concerned to ensure that they do not limit access to rehabilitative opportunities across a wide range of people within the criminal justice system or have implications which present a challenge to the sector’s commitment to involve experts by experience in the design and delivery of services. In particular, we are concerned that under these restrictions it is unclear what constitutes “public events celebrating offender achievements” and that this may impact a wide range of criminal justice voluntary sector activities, even if not the intention. We know from discussions with members and partners that there is a lack of knowledge of the restrictions and what may be required of organisations. Furthermore, there is confusion as to how these restrictions may be interpreted, reports of inconsistencies in interpretation and concern as to the longer-term impact if they remain in place for much longer.
We have raised these concerns with HMPPS and are in ongoing discussions with them to pass on feedback from our sector, help them to understand the impact of the restrictions and limit that impact wherever possible. We understand the restrictions will be reviewed in March and we will keep the sector updated with regards to this. Both I and Richard Nicholls, Clinks’ Head of Operations and a member of the Reducing Reoffending Third Sector Advisory Group (RR3), are meeting with the Director General in the next weeks to discuss concerns and seek further clarity.
HMPPS has assured us that they are absolutely committed to supporting rehabilitative activity in our sector and working with organisations facing barriers to their work in this period when restrictions remain in place. Colleagues at HMPPS understand that the restrictions articulated above can’t account for every eventuality so they are happy to receive queries and referrals about events from the sector. If you have questions or concerns about how these restrictions might affect your activities please contact directorgeneralprisons@justice.gov.uk or directorgeneralprobation@justice.gov.uk.
If you have concerns or questions you can also get in touch with us. Richard.nicholls@clinks.org is leading on issues around working safely in the sector and is the best first point of contact.
Anne Fox
CEO Clinks
Friday, 14 February 2020
Command and Control
There was a time of course when notions of 'command and control' would have been complete anathema to any Probation Officer worth their salt, but they just love it at HMPPS HQ and it's coming soon to a CRC near you:-
Probation Change Bulletin - Issue 4
Welcome to the first edition of our bulletin in 2020, keeping you up to date with the progress of the probation reform programme. Due to restrictions imposed during the general election campaign at the end of last year, we were unable to publish updates in November and December. Rest assured, work has been continuing at speed and the programme remains busy.
I look forward to providing further updates as we continue to make progress this year. If you have any questions or would like to contact the programme team please email: strengthening.probation@justice.gov.uk
2. Reflecting on 2019
2019 was a year of great progress for the probation reform programme. We started by listening to the outcome of the consultation (which received over 450 responses) on how we best strengthen probation before announcing the unified model in May. We then started to deliver on the model through the transfer of offender management staff from the Community Rehabilitation Company (‘CRC’) Wales to the National Probation Service (‘NPS’) Wales in December (see below).
The last three months of the year also marked some key milestones which I’d like to share with you. These included:
2.1 Launching Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service (‘HMPPS’) Strategy
The strategy, launched in November 2019, outlines the outcomes that everyone within HMPPS is focused on achieving. HMPPS is central to achieving three of the Ministry of Justice’s overall objectives:
- Decent and safe prisons
- Public protection
- Reduced reoffending
2.2 Launching the probation delivery partner competition
The first phase of expressing an interest in the delivery partner competitions and the launch of the competitions has started. Probation delivery partners are the organisations that will deliver Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes and other Structured Interventions to the regions. There will be one probation delivery partner in each of the 12 new probation regions in England and Wales.
We very much hope that current organisations will express an interest in these competitions, but understand that sometimes this might not be the case. Regardless, there will be no impact on the quality of probation services that are provided to offenders, staff and stakeholders during the transition.
2.3 Appointing the regional probation directors
The programme continues to make great progress towards the launch of the unified model next Spring. that goal. I’m delighted that we have appointed the new team of 12 National Probation Service Regional Directors for England and Wales (11 for England and one for Wales). These new senior leaders are from a range of backgrounds and all have great experience of probation, both in the NPS and CRCs.
As they start to build their own regional teams, they will be working closely with the programme to implement change, develop best practice and lead probation services in their region. This is in line with our blueprint, published last June, with further details included in our draft Target Operating Model, which we plan to publish towards the end of February.
We were determined to appoint the right people to these important roles. The process was rigorous with a number of individuals involved, including Police and Crime Commissioners who sat on interview panels. The regional probation directors are:
Ian Barrow, Wales
Andrea Bennett, North West
Chris Edwards , Greater Manchester
Bronwen Elphick, North East
Lynda Marginson, Yorkshire and Humberside
Sarah Chand, West Midlands
Martin Davies, East Midlands
Steve Johnson-Proctor, East of England
Kilvinder Vigurs, London
Angela Cossins, South West
Gabriel Amahwe, South Central
Mary Pilgrim, Kent, Surrey and Sussex
2.4 Wales transition to the NPS unified model
The transition process in Wales has gone well and I’d like to express my thanks to everyone who has been involved. On 2nd December 2019, just over 300 staff in Wales moved over to the partially unified model for the probation service.
The transition has been a major achievement and a review of staff working needs, in terms of environment and IT resources, will ensure they are given the best support in their important and challenging roles. There are a number of lessons we can usefully learn, especially given that the scale and complexity for transition in England will be different.
2.5 Increased focus areas
Like any complex reform programme, there are inevitably a few areas that have taken longer to move forward with than we had hoped. One of these is the design of our Dynamic Framework. Our initial approach was to hold central competitions for each of the 12 regions. Following feedback from key stakeholders we have paused the launch and are adjusting our approach to ensure it’s more regionally tailored to what already exists.
NPS deputy directors are currently completing a gap analysis with their local partnerships to support this work. We have set up a new board to help our resettlement model align more closely with prisons, while the design work for a unified offender management system in the NPS is in its early stages and we’re keen to make quick progress on this soon.
3. Looking ahead to 2020
When we announced plans for the new probation model last May, we said that transition would occur in Spring 2021 and we have now settled on a specific date. Management of low- and medium-risk offenders will pass from CRCs to HM Prison and Probation Service in June 2021, allowing time to implement these complex changes safely. Therefore 2020 will be another busy year of engagement with staff and stakeholders and finalising the Target Operating Model.
Over the next few months, we will launch the first stage of the competition to appoint providers to the Dynamic Framework (smaller, more specialist local providers of pathway provision). From April we will begin the process of shifting the NPS from its current formation of seven divisions to 12 regions.
By the end of the year we will have completed that process and appointed all partner organisations that will support NPS regions in the future. Further details can be found in other areas of this bulletin. We will also commit to continuing to consult, engage and inform staff and stakeholders as well as with our trade unions on the progress in the programme.
3.1 The launch of the workforce programme
In January, HMPPS launched a five-year probation workforce programme. This is a parallel programme to the reform programme with a purpose to ensure the new unified service has the right staff in the right places at the right time, bringing together all the probation workforce areas currently sitting in different parts of HMPPS and the Ministry of Justice.
A key focus is to make sure all recruitment is diverse and inclusive, staffing level requirements are met, staff have the right qualifications, learning opportunities and professional career development plans and, overall, making sure our HR polices are fit for purpose. Ian Barrow, previously probation delivery director for the National Probation Service in Wales, has been appointed interim director for the probation workforce programme.
The programme, which sits alongside the probation reform programme, will be launching its workforce strategy towards the end of February. It will ensure that, as CRCs are integrated into the new unified model, there is a clear focus on supporting probation colleagues as they carry out new and challenging roles.
Amy Rees, Director General for Probation and Wales, said: “We made a commitment in the recent HMPPS Strategy and the People Plan that a strong workforce was an absolute priority for us to achieve our aims in the agency and in probation…I do not underestimate the scale of what lies ahead but we have a real opportunity here: to shape the direction for our probation workforce and create a lasting legacy for our valued staff.”
3.2 Publication of the draft Target Operating Model
Final work is being done on the interim Target Operating Model, which will be published in the next few weeks. This important document outlines how probation will be run from 2021, the structure of the future NPS and the processes that we are implementing. This follows the operating blueprint, published last June.
While there is still a huge amount of work to be done, gaps in design areas and many questions that still need answering, the Target Operating Model, clearly demonstrates the commitment of HMPPS to continue to drive the reform programme forward at pace to deliver for the public, probation staff and individuals under probation supervision.
3.3 Assistant Chief Officer events
Two engagement events with NPS and CRCs and the programme have recently taken place to refine the delivery structures for the 12 new regions and agree on the processes for staff transfer from CRCs to the NPS.
We anticipate the Probation Delivery Unit structures for regions will be announced shortly.
Thursday, 13 February 2020
Latest from Napo 200
From Napo news online last week:-
Napo meets with Justice Minister
Napo, alongside colleagues from our sister unions, met with Justice Minister Lucy Frazer this week. The meeting was overshadowed by the terrible incident in South London last Sunday, and it became quickly evident from the flurry of activity going on in MoJ HQ that we would have less time with the Minister than is usual.
Nevertheless, the delegation which included Napo General Secretary Ian Lawrence and National Vice-Chair Ikki Bhogal, was able to effectively engage with the Minister on a range of important issues on behalf of our members working in the NPS and CRC’s. Here we left Ms Frazer in no doubt that if Probation was already in need of a serious increase in funding to allow it to reach the standards expected of it, the Manifesto commitments of this Government in respect of the criminal justice system and the well documented events over recent weeks, made that even more of an imperative.
The discussions focussed on three key areas namely: Pay and the problems around the non-delivery of the pay protection agreements on E3, the ramifications of the latest report by the Chief Inspector for Probation and the Governments policy on privatisation. Here, the unions again urged a rethink on the re-marketisation of Interventions and Programmes and demanded the cessation of the failing contracts for the provision of double waking night cover in Approved Premises.
On pay, we made strong representations to the Minister and Amy Rees Director General of Probation, that unless serious action was taken to improve funding then there was no chance that it would be possible to re-stabilise the service which is still in recovery mode from the disasters of the Transforming Rehabilitation Programme, or incentivise new recruits to see Probation as a worthy career that paid its staff a decent wage.
The Minister responded positively, in that it was clear that serious dialogue is going on inside HMPPS and with the Treasury on a number of priorities and it was acknowledged that the Governments plans for more police officers, more prison places and longer sentencing would need an increase in probation practitioners as well as the resources to support them.
Ms Frazer agreed to formally respond to the unions joint letter that had been sent in advance of the meeting and welcomed the publication of the correspondence. It is hoped to meet again once decisions have been made around the Governments ongoing Comprehensive Spending Review.
Napo meets with Justice Minister
Napo, alongside colleagues from our sister unions, met with Justice Minister Lucy Frazer this week. The meeting was overshadowed by the terrible incident in South London last Sunday, and it became quickly evident from the flurry of activity going on in MoJ HQ that we would have less time with the Minister than is usual.
Nevertheless, the delegation which included Napo General Secretary Ian Lawrence and National Vice-Chair Ikki Bhogal, was able to effectively engage with the Minister on a range of important issues on behalf of our members working in the NPS and CRC’s. Here we left Ms Frazer in no doubt that if Probation was already in need of a serious increase in funding to allow it to reach the standards expected of it, the Manifesto commitments of this Government in respect of the criminal justice system and the well documented events over recent weeks, made that even more of an imperative.
The discussions focussed on three key areas namely: Pay and the problems around the non-delivery of the pay protection agreements on E3, the ramifications of the latest report by the Chief Inspector for Probation and the Governments policy on privatisation. Here, the unions again urged a rethink on the re-marketisation of Interventions and Programmes and demanded the cessation of the failing contracts for the provision of double waking night cover in Approved Premises.
On pay, we made strong representations to the Minister and Amy Rees Director General of Probation, that unless serious action was taken to improve funding then there was no chance that it would be possible to re-stabilise the service which is still in recovery mode from the disasters of the Transforming Rehabilitation Programme, or incentivise new recruits to see Probation as a worthy career that paid its staff a decent wage.
The Minister responded positively, in that it was clear that serious dialogue is going on inside HMPPS and with the Treasury on a number of priorities and it was acknowledged that the Governments plans for more police officers, more prison places and longer sentencing would need an increase in probation practitioners as well as the resources to support them.
Ms Frazer agreed to formally respond to the unions joint letter that had been sent in advance of the meeting and welcomed the publication of the correspondence. It is hoped to meet again once decisions have been made around the Governments ongoing Comprehensive Spending Review.
Labels:
Approved Premises,
E3,
HMPPS,
MoJ,
NAPO,
NPS,
privatisation,
Probation
Tuesday, 11 February 2020
TR According to Chris Grayling
I notice the Institute for Government have published an interview with Chris Grayling about his time as Minister for Justice and hence responsible for the omnishambles that was TR:-
Tim Durrant (TD): You worked in a number of roles in the shadow cabinet before the 2010 election. Did they inform your time in government?
CG: Yeah, basically the jobs I did in government and the jobs I did in opposition married up almost totally. I was in the Home Office rather than in justice, but basically the jobs I’ve done in government have been the jobs I did in opposition, so there’s been a very close correlation. In none of them have I turned up as a total stranger.
Nick Davies [ND]: In September 2012, you became secretary of state for justice and lord chancellor. Can you talk us through the appointment process, the conversation you had with the prime minister, whether it was something you were expecting?
CG: I thought it was quite a good possibility because there was a lot of commonality with the reforms I’d been talking about [at DWP]. The coalition agreement envisaged a fairly similar approach in employment and in the rehabilitation of offenders. I had not been involved in shaping the justice piece in opposition, but I had been involved in shaping the work and pensions piece in opposition, so there was an obvious correlation between the work I’d been doing in DWP and the work David Cameron asked me to do in justice. And David Cameron gave the standard, you know, “come along, see the prime minister,” and he said, “I’d like you to go to justice.” He gave me two instructions, he said, “firstly, I want you to deliver the rehabilitation revolution commitment in the coalition agreement,” because his view was that it hadn’t really been delivered. Both the Conservative manifesto and the coalition agreement envisaged a significant outsourcing of the rehabilitation of offenders. And he also said, “I want you to get rid of the soft justice narrative,” which had been quite visible in the previous couple of years.
ND: What lessons did you take from overseeing the work programme to the implementation of TR [transforming rehabilitation]?
CG: I think the big difference between the two, both big reforms, both requiring a little bit of tweaking once they got up and running, is that in the case of the DWP, the team who had set up the work programme were still there. Whereas in 2015, pretty much everybody who had been involved in the transforming rehabilitation programme left. The ministers all left, the senior officials all left, and it did not get the tweaking and fine-tuning that it needed. In both cases, in the case of the DWP and the MoJ [Ministry of Justice], the statisticians got their numbers wrong. They misjudged the number of referrals that the third-party contractors would get. In the case of the DWP, they were able to make early adjustments to the contracting structure to make sure that wasn’t an issue, and by the time the programme finished, an analysis in 2016 said it had outperformed the expectations of the department based on previous programmes, and at a lower cost than previous programmes. With transforming rehabilitation, from what I could see, they sat there like rabbits in the headlights, saying: “Well, I don’t quite know what we do about this.” The referrals were much lower than expected to the outsourced companies, whose business models then were fatally weakened from the start, and they didn’t make the adjustments they needed to make earlier on.
ND: Knowing what you know now, is there anything that you would do differently to avoid some of those problems?
CG: Yeah. I think, with hindsight, it’s an interesting problem. Arriving halfway through a parliament with a mandate to deliver major reform sets you, to some extent, a timetable. You might think two years and nine months was more than enough to deliver reforms, and in most worlds it would be. But the public sector moves pretty slowly and there’s huge amounts of process involved. I would probably have done it in stages, I wouldn’t have just done one pilot in one part of the country. Because for transforming rehabilitation there had been a pilot in Peterborough of outsourcing the support of offenders to the private and voluntary sectors, which had a measurable impact on the level of re-offending. But I’d probably have done it in two or three stages.
ND: What was the advice from the civil service like on the programme?
CG: Oh, they were very hard working on it. There is a myth floating around that the civil service advised against it, which is not true. The civil service, at all stages, was very, very engaged in delivering it.
ND: More generally, what are the key challenges entailed by taking the step up from minister of state to secretary of state, and what was the support like for you from the civil service when you moved up?
CG: Pretty good. I think the key difference is you suddenly take on financial responsibility in a way that you don’t necessarily as minister of state. The financial position at the Ministry of Justice was very challenging. We had to take out something like a third of the budget over a three-year period. That was implementing reforms that Ken Clarke [the previous secretary of state for justice] had legislated for but not done, so most of the cuts in legal aid had been legislated for before I arrived but came into force on my watch. So, the budget pressures were enormous. Actually, one of the great hidden facts about probation is that the probation reforms insulated the probation service from what would have been significant budget cuts, because we were looking to expand the remit of the probation service to incorporate all the short-sentence prisoners. The Treasury did not insist on significant cuts in the way they did with the prison service, legal aid and the courts. So, I think the dominant feature of my time as secretary of state for justice was huge budget pressures. One of the great ironies, which wasn’t spotted at the time, was that because Michael Gove [Grayling’s successor as secretary of state for justice] was due to be George Osborne’s campaign manager in his leadership bid, when Michael took over as secretary of state the department’s budget went up by £500m, which took away a lot of the budget pressures we’d been dealing with in the last 12 months.
ND: Given those pressures, what was your approach like in managing a team of ministers and how did you go about identifying priorities for the department and the team?
CG: Well, the first thing I did was decide to not privatise the prisons. What I inherited from Ken Clarke was a rolling programme of prison privatisation but, looking at the plan, it was very clear to me that whilst it theoretically delivered savings, those didn’t arrive until the mid-2020s, which wasn’t a lot of use for us back then. I had bids from the private sector, but I also had a counterbid from the in-house team, from prison governors and prison unions, to run the prison service according to a different template. They took what they saw as best practice from across the estate and applied it to the prisons that were in line for privatisation, saying: “We can deliver for you.” The savings were smaller, but they were more immediate. So, the decision I took was to stop the privatisation process of the prisons but to say to the governors, “what I need you to do is to put in place the benchmarking that you’re talking about for these prisons more broadly across the estate, because that’s the only way I can meet the financial targets without really driving aggressive privatisation,” which I didn’t think was right.
ND: You mentioned the injection of cash the department received under Michael Gove. Can you describe what relations were like between you and Number 10, and the Treasury, during the time you were at MoJ?
CG: Generally, pretty good. Probation reform, as far as Number 10 and the Cabinet Office were concerned, was a priority. I mean, Nick Clegg described it in one cabinet meeting as one of the most important reforms the coalition was doing. This was a fairly fundamental part of the coalition agreement, the rehabilitation revolution, and so Number 10 was always very keen and positive about it. The Treasury was fine and helpful but process; everything takes a very long time.
TD: What would your advice be for ministers dealing with those two parts of government, the Treasury and Number 10?
CG: Try and remain friendly with everyone. I don’t believe great bust-ups in Whitehall help. Understand where they’re coming from, have good relations with the other ministers. Although it does annoy the civil service sometimes when ministers phone each other up and agree things without the civil service being present! But just maintain good relations all around, would be my best advice.
TD: You mentioned earlier you’d visited a large proportion of the prison estate. What can you take from those visits as a minister, how does it inform your decision making in Whitehall?
CG: Well, what it does is it shows you the reality of life on the ground. For example, you are always dealing with accusations that the prison estate is overcrowded. I mean, in all the briefs I’ve had there’s usually a relentless attack from the left, who want the world to look very different. If you’ve done a walk around the prisons to see what it’s like and you’re told the prisons are hideously overcrowded, well yes, it is true that we did not provide a single cell for every prisoner, but it would have been impossible to do so. So, the question is, are we putting people in completely inhuman conditions, given these are prisons? And most of the estate was, in my judgement, sufficiently okay to be justifiable. Some of the older estate improved very little. In fact, I closed more prisons than any other justice secretary has ever done, or home secretary has ever done, and some of the ones I closed were a problem. There was one on the Isle of Wight in particular that I went around and thought: “I’m glad I’ve closed this because it’s not fit for use as a prison.”
Tim Durrant (TD): You worked in a number of roles in the shadow cabinet before the 2010 election. Did they inform your time in government?
CG: Yeah, basically the jobs I did in government and the jobs I did in opposition married up almost totally. I was in the Home Office rather than in justice, but basically the jobs I’ve done in government have been the jobs I did in opposition, so there’s been a very close correlation. In none of them have I turned up as a total stranger.
Nick Davies [ND]: In September 2012, you became secretary of state for justice and lord chancellor. Can you talk us through the appointment process, the conversation you had with the prime minister, whether it was something you were expecting?
CG: I thought it was quite a good possibility because there was a lot of commonality with the reforms I’d been talking about [at DWP]. The coalition agreement envisaged a fairly similar approach in employment and in the rehabilitation of offenders. I had not been involved in shaping the justice piece in opposition, but I had been involved in shaping the work and pensions piece in opposition, so there was an obvious correlation between the work I’d been doing in DWP and the work David Cameron asked me to do in justice. And David Cameron gave the standard, you know, “come along, see the prime minister,” and he said, “I’d like you to go to justice.” He gave me two instructions, he said, “firstly, I want you to deliver the rehabilitation revolution commitment in the coalition agreement,” because his view was that it hadn’t really been delivered. Both the Conservative manifesto and the coalition agreement envisaged a significant outsourcing of the rehabilitation of offenders. And he also said, “I want you to get rid of the soft justice narrative,” which had been quite visible in the previous couple of years.
ND: What lessons did you take from overseeing the work programme to the implementation of TR [transforming rehabilitation]?
CG: I think the big difference between the two, both big reforms, both requiring a little bit of tweaking once they got up and running, is that in the case of the DWP, the team who had set up the work programme were still there. Whereas in 2015, pretty much everybody who had been involved in the transforming rehabilitation programme left. The ministers all left, the senior officials all left, and it did not get the tweaking and fine-tuning that it needed. In both cases, in the case of the DWP and the MoJ [Ministry of Justice], the statisticians got their numbers wrong. They misjudged the number of referrals that the third-party contractors would get. In the case of the DWP, they were able to make early adjustments to the contracting structure to make sure that wasn’t an issue, and by the time the programme finished, an analysis in 2016 said it had outperformed the expectations of the department based on previous programmes, and at a lower cost than previous programmes. With transforming rehabilitation, from what I could see, they sat there like rabbits in the headlights, saying: “Well, I don’t quite know what we do about this.” The referrals were much lower than expected to the outsourced companies, whose business models then were fatally weakened from the start, and they didn’t make the adjustments they needed to make earlier on.
ND: Knowing what you know now, is there anything that you would do differently to avoid some of those problems?
CG: Yeah. I think, with hindsight, it’s an interesting problem. Arriving halfway through a parliament with a mandate to deliver major reform sets you, to some extent, a timetable. You might think two years and nine months was more than enough to deliver reforms, and in most worlds it would be. But the public sector moves pretty slowly and there’s huge amounts of process involved. I would probably have done it in stages, I wouldn’t have just done one pilot in one part of the country. Because for transforming rehabilitation there had been a pilot in Peterborough of outsourcing the support of offenders to the private and voluntary sectors, which had a measurable impact on the level of re-offending. But I’d probably have done it in two or three stages.
ND: What was the advice from the civil service like on the programme?
CG: Oh, they were very hard working on it. There is a myth floating around that the civil service advised against it, which is not true. The civil service, at all stages, was very, very engaged in delivering it.
ND: More generally, what are the key challenges entailed by taking the step up from minister of state to secretary of state, and what was the support like for you from the civil service when you moved up?
CG: Pretty good. I think the key difference is you suddenly take on financial responsibility in a way that you don’t necessarily as minister of state. The financial position at the Ministry of Justice was very challenging. We had to take out something like a third of the budget over a three-year period. That was implementing reforms that Ken Clarke [the previous secretary of state for justice] had legislated for but not done, so most of the cuts in legal aid had been legislated for before I arrived but came into force on my watch. So, the budget pressures were enormous. Actually, one of the great hidden facts about probation is that the probation reforms insulated the probation service from what would have been significant budget cuts, because we were looking to expand the remit of the probation service to incorporate all the short-sentence prisoners. The Treasury did not insist on significant cuts in the way they did with the prison service, legal aid and the courts. So, I think the dominant feature of my time as secretary of state for justice was huge budget pressures. One of the great ironies, which wasn’t spotted at the time, was that because Michael Gove [Grayling’s successor as secretary of state for justice] was due to be George Osborne’s campaign manager in his leadership bid, when Michael took over as secretary of state the department’s budget went up by £500m, which took away a lot of the budget pressures we’d been dealing with in the last 12 months.
ND: Given those pressures, what was your approach like in managing a team of ministers and how did you go about identifying priorities for the department and the team?
CG: Well, the first thing I did was decide to not privatise the prisons. What I inherited from Ken Clarke was a rolling programme of prison privatisation but, looking at the plan, it was very clear to me that whilst it theoretically delivered savings, those didn’t arrive until the mid-2020s, which wasn’t a lot of use for us back then. I had bids from the private sector, but I also had a counterbid from the in-house team, from prison governors and prison unions, to run the prison service according to a different template. They took what they saw as best practice from across the estate and applied it to the prisons that were in line for privatisation, saying: “We can deliver for you.” The savings were smaller, but they were more immediate. So, the decision I took was to stop the privatisation process of the prisons but to say to the governors, “what I need you to do is to put in place the benchmarking that you’re talking about for these prisons more broadly across the estate, because that’s the only way I can meet the financial targets without really driving aggressive privatisation,” which I didn’t think was right.
ND: You mentioned the injection of cash the department received under Michael Gove. Can you describe what relations were like between you and Number 10, and the Treasury, during the time you were at MoJ?
CG: Generally, pretty good. Probation reform, as far as Number 10 and the Cabinet Office were concerned, was a priority. I mean, Nick Clegg described it in one cabinet meeting as one of the most important reforms the coalition was doing. This was a fairly fundamental part of the coalition agreement, the rehabilitation revolution, and so Number 10 was always very keen and positive about it. The Treasury was fine and helpful but process; everything takes a very long time.
TD: What would your advice be for ministers dealing with those two parts of government, the Treasury and Number 10?
CG: Try and remain friendly with everyone. I don’t believe great bust-ups in Whitehall help. Understand where they’re coming from, have good relations with the other ministers. Although it does annoy the civil service sometimes when ministers phone each other up and agree things without the civil service being present! But just maintain good relations all around, would be my best advice.
TD: You mentioned earlier you’d visited a large proportion of the prison estate. What can you take from those visits as a minister, how does it inform your decision making in Whitehall?
CG: Well, what it does is it shows you the reality of life on the ground. For example, you are always dealing with accusations that the prison estate is overcrowded. I mean, in all the briefs I’ve had there’s usually a relentless attack from the left, who want the world to look very different. If you’ve done a walk around the prisons to see what it’s like and you’re told the prisons are hideously overcrowded, well yes, it is true that we did not provide a single cell for every prisoner, but it would have been impossible to do so. So, the question is, are we putting people in completely inhuman conditions, given these are prisons? And most of the estate was, in my judgement, sufficiently okay to be justifiable. Some of the older estate improved very little. In fact, I closed more prisons than any other justice secretary has ever done, or home secretary has ever done, and some of the ones I closed were a problem. There was one on the Isle of Wight in particular that I went around and thought: “I’m glad I’ve closed this because it’s not fit for use as a prison.”
Monday, 10 February 2020
Sad Result of a Bad Decision
We've talked about Circles of Support and Accountability before and the incredulous decision by NPS/MoJ to cease funding it. It was all tied-up with the TR omnishambles and in my view is yet further evidence of why probation should return to being a stand-alone service, funded nationally but organised locally. Here, on the Clinks website, is the back story to the complete closure of a once brilliant concept and successful initiative in the North of England:-
The end of the road - lessons and reflections from a charity preventing sexual harm
In this guest blog Tammy Banks, former CEO of re:shape, talks openly about the recently closed charity and what led to its demise. She discusses the rising need for the charity’s services – preventing sexual harm – the commitment of its workforce, and the challenges of the funding environment.
I have recently closed down a charity doing excellent work because statutory services are in disarray. re:shape was an organisation that used volunteers to prevent sexual harm, working with hundreds of volunteers across Yorkshire, Humberside, Lincolnshire, Cumbria and Lancashire. It was a community project which transformed people’s lives and prevented people becoming victims.
re:shape worked positively with people who were a risk of causing sexual harm or who had already caused harm. They had been through the criminal justice system and were released back into the community, but were still assessed as being a risk. I saw a rapid rise in the demand for the service over the six years I was CEO. Our referrers were the National Probation Service, the police, prisons, local authority, NHS, charity projects, religious communities, parents and even individuals themselves. Volunteers gave thousands of hours every year to the charity. Interventions were independently proven to prevent further offences by nearly 80%.
I joined the organisation just as Transforming Rehabilitation was being implemented. My brief was to survive the year (or two) it would take to embed the new way of working. We scrimped and scraped by with charitable funding plugging the gaps, whilst statutory funders tried to get systems in place. We navigated complex statutory relationships where we often knew things about their internal workings before they did; where senior managers, the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) and other commissioners hadn’t told their operational staff about the internal changes they were making.
At the same time as this was happening, the country – and the world – appeared to be waking up to some of the realities of sexual abuse. The media was helpful in some cases by breaking down stereotypes and highlighting the abuse that was happening in organisations, the collusion and the fact that it generally isn’t the stereotype of old men in parks abusing children. #Metoo happened. Other high profile cases stunned the country and we suddenly saw another rise in the people wanting to access our services. Amazingly, we also received enquiry after enquiry from people wanting to volunteer. We built an army of trained, informed people, dedicated to preventing sexual harm and working towards no more victims locally.
The incongruence is almost laughable! People’s needs were increasing, understanding of our services was increasing, while funding was decreasing. Applications to our usual funders who have been so supportive in the past were met with sad and resigned no’s. They said things like, “your work should be funded by statutory services, we’ve subsidised it for 10 years already”, and “There are other charities that need our money and we need to distribute our limited funds fairly.”
At the same time, we were being asked by statutory funders to develop more flexible services – to amend our approach to work with more people – giving us small amounts of money here and there. Probation started looking into national commissioning for us and other intervention providers because the work was so valued. There is nothing else like it and it works – it prevents victims.
We continued developing, increased our impact and grew the most amazing, professional, skilled and dedicated staff team and hundreds of volunteers. The difference we were making was tangible. It was real, it was preventing victims. Then we received the news: there would be no national funding. The MoJ had made its decision and the decision was final. We received a letter saying they recognise the importance of the services we were offering but that they had re-routed the money elsewhere. We were asked to apply locally and to go on the Community Rehabilitation Company rate cards.
This meant four more complex organisations to engage with and months and months of inconsistent messaging and processes. All the time, during this uncertainty, fantastic staff and volunteers were still delivering interventions, working with some of the riskiest people in the community, helping people transform their lives, being part of the change and making a difference – working collaboratively towards the mission of no more victims.
We literally tried everything to survive: fundraising, small grants, large grants, local commissioning and national commissioning. At every juncture there was hope and we continued in hope, whilst watching our reserve funds dwindle away.
A couple of years on and the momentum that was built around truly preventing sexual abuse has nearly silenced. The media isn’t bothered anymore as Brexit has taken over. People’s heads are turned and they’re focused on other situations which are also very concerning. The probation service is going through reform again. Perhaps they’ve realised Transforming Rehabilitation was a mistake. Perhaps they’ve listened to all the dedicated frontline probation professionals who proclaimed that these radical reforms were devastating, and who shouted it from the rooftops six years ago.
Of course, sexual abuse continues. It’s an unfortunate fact that instances are rising and rising fast. Convictions are lower than ever before and the talk of culture change, abuse of power and standing together is growing weaker by the day. If we look at the situation from a cold monetary perspective, the current situation isn’t good for the public purse. Sexual abuse impacts everywhere: the victims, their families, the local communities, NHS services, courts, police, prison, social care, mental health services… and let’s not forget that trauma can impact a family’s ability to thrive for generations.
I look at the criminal justice system in absolute despair. Operational professionals in the system are under immense pressure. They’re trying their best whilst the whole system works against them. I’ve watched good service after good service close these last few years. Services that absolutely change people’s lives, prevent abuse and champion change… and now it’s us. I’m watching colleagues and friends in the sector near collapse and good people leaving through fear for their own mental health. What are we going to be left with?
As a country, I’m so worried about the future. I’m holding on tight to the fact that, in the last ten years, our dedicated volunteers have done amazing things. They’ve absolutely prevented hundreds and hundreds of victims and I’m sure that their training and experiences will have had an impact on their values and understanding. I think this is true of many partner agencies that we have worked with and trained too. I’m pleased to say that a selection of our services will be continuing under the umbrella of other organisations, but unfortunately many areas, including all of Yorkshire, will have no service available.
I am truly thankful to the wonderful trustees, who gave up their time and used their skills and expertise for further impact. Quakers gave us our beginning and our principles and, over the years, this has led every single decision towards our aim of ‘No more victims’.
We are at the end of the road now. We will be putting all our intellectual property as a free download from March at www.re-shape.org.uk. Please take and utilise what you wish. I hope it continues to help prevent sexual harm in the future.
Tammy is on Twitter at @tammybanksy, on LinkedIn, and can be contacted by email at Tammy@tayetraining.org.uk.
Tammy Banks
Re:shape (formerly YHLCOSA)
The end of the road - lessons and reflections from a charity preventing sexual harm
In this guest blog Tammy Banks, former CEO of re:shape, talks openly about the recently closed charity and what led to its demise. She discusses the rising need for the charity’s services – preventing sexual harm – the commitment of its workforce, and the challenges of the funding environment.
I have recently closed down a charity doing excellent work because statutory services are in disarray. re:shape was an organisation that used volunteers to prevent sexual harm, working with hundreds of volunteers across Yorkshire, Humberside, Lincolnshire, Cumbria and Lancashire. It was a community project which transformed people’s lives and prevented people becoming victims.
re:shape worked positively with people who were a risk of causing sexual harm or who had already caused harm. They had been through the criminal justice system and were released back into the community, but were still assessed as being a risk. I saw a rapid rise in the demand for the service over the six years I was CEO. Our referrers were the National Probation Service, the police, prisons, local authority, NHS, charity projects, religious communities, parents and even individuals themselves. Volunteers gave thousands of hours every year to the charity. Interventions were independently proven to prevent further offences by nearly 80%.
I joined the organisation just as Transforming Rehabilitation was being implemented. My brief was to survive the year (or two) it would take to embed the new way of working. We scrimped and scraped by with charitable funding plugging the gaps, whilst statutory funders tried to get systems in place. We navigated complex statutory relationships where we often knew things about their internal workings before they did; where senior managers, the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) and other commissioners hadn’t told their operational staff about the internal changes they were making.
At the same time as this was happening, the country – and the world – appeared to be waking up to some of the realities of sexual abuse. The media was helpful in some cases by breaking down stereotypes and highlighting the abuse that was happening in organisations, the collusion and the fact that it generally isn’t the stereotype of old men in parks abusing children. #Metoo happened. Other high profile cases stunned the country and we suddenly saw another rise in the people wanting to access our services. Amazingly, we also received enquiry after enquiry from people wanting to volunteer. We built an army of trained, informed people, dedicated to preventing sexual harm and working towards no more victims locally.
The incongruence is almost laughable! People’s needs were increasing, understanding of our services was increasing, while funding was decreasing. Applications to our usual funders who have been so supportive in the past were met with sad and resigned no’s. They said things like, “your work should be funded by statutory services, we’ve subsidised it for 10 years already”, and “There are other charities that need our money and we need to distribute our limited funds fairly.”
At the same time, we were being asked by statutory funders to develop more flexible services – to amend our approach to work with more people – giving us small amounts of money here and there. Probation started looking into national commissioning for us and other intervention providers because the work was so valued. There is nothing else like it and it works – it prevents victims.
We continued developing, increased our impact and grew the most amazing, professional, skilled and dedicated staff team and hundreds of volunteers. The difference we were making was tangible. It was real, it was preventing victims. Then we received the news: there would be no national funding. The MoJ had made its decision and the decision was final. We received a letter saying they recognise the importance of the services we were offering but that they had re-routed the money elsewhere. We were asked to apply locally and to go on the Community Rehabilitation Company rate cards.
This meant four more complex organisations to engage with and months and months of inconsistent messaging and processes. All the time, during this uncertainty, fantastic staff and volunteers were still delivering interventions, working with some of the riskiest people in the community, helping people transform their lives, being part of the change and making a difference – working collaboratively towards the mission of no more victims.
We literally tried everything to survive: fundraising, small grants, large grants, local commissioning and national commissioning. At every juncture there was hope and we continued in hope, whilst watching our reserve funds dwindle away.
A couple of years on and the momentum that was built around truly preventing sexual abuse has nearly silenced. The media isn’t bothered anymore as Brexit has taken over. People’s heads are turned and they’re focused on other situations which are also very concerning. The probation service is going through reform again. Perhaps they’ve realised Transforming Rehabilitation was a mistake. Perhaps they’ve listened to all the dedicated frontline probation professionals who proclaimed that these radical reforms were devastating, and who shouted it from the rooftops six years ago.
Of course, sexual abuse continues. It’s an unfortunate fact that instances are rising and rising fast. Convictions are lower than ever before and the talk of culture change, abuse of power and standing together is growing weaker by the day. If we look at the situation from a cold monetary perspective, the current situation isn’t good for the public purse. Sexual abuse impacts everywhere: the victims, their families, the local communities, NHS services, courts, police, prison, social care, mental health services… and let’s not forget that trauma can impact a family’s ability to thrive for generations.
I look at the criminal justice system in absolute despair. Operational professionals in the system are under immense pressure. They’re trying their best whilst the whole system works against them. I’ve watched good service after good service close these last few years. Services that absolutely change people’s lives, prevent abuse and champion change… and now it’s us. I’m watching colleagues and friends in the sector near collapse and good people leaving through fear for their own mental health. What are we going to be left with?
As a country, I’m so worried about the future. I’m holding on tight to the fact that, in the last ten years, our dedicated volunteers have done amazing things. They’ve absolutely prevented hundreds and hundreds of victims and I’m sure that their training and experiences will have had an impact on their values and understanding. I think this is true of many partner agencies that we have worked with and trained too. I’m pleased to say that a selection of our services will be continuing under the umbrella of other organisations, but unfortunately many areas, including all of Yorkshire, will have no service available.
I am truly thankful to the wonderful trustees, who gave up their time and used their skills and expertise for further impact. Quakers gave us our beginning and our principles and, over the years, this has led every single decision towards our aim of ‘No more victims’.
We are at the end of the road now. We will be putting all our intellectual property as a free download from March at www.re-shape.org.uk. Please take and utilise what you wish. I hope it continues to help prevent sexual harm in the future.
Tammy is on Twitter at @tammybanksy, on LinkedIn, and can be contacted by email at Tammy@tayetraining.org.uk.
Re:shape (formerly YHLCOSA)
Saturday, 8 February 2020
The Power of Discussion and Debate
Blimey, yet another official report highlighting in some shocking detail the terrible state of our prisons and the very poor management by HMPPS, this time from the National Audit Office:-
Improving the prison estate
This report examines the condition and capacity of HM Prison and Probation Service's prison estate.
Background to the report
Since 2015, against a backdrop of worsening living conditions for prisoners, HMPPS (Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service) has changed the way in which it maintains prisons and launched a programme to improve the condition and suitability of prison accommodation. It opted to contract out facilities management, create 10,000 new-for-old prison places and change its estate to better meet the needs of prisoners.
Content and scope of the report
This report examines how HMPPS handled these changes and what it achieved. It:
HMPPS has committed to providing a safe, secure and decent prison estate, but its plans to achieve this are failing. It has not been able to provide enough prison places, in the right type of prisons, and at the right time, to meet demand. The Prison Estate Transformation Programme’s plans to create up to 10,000 new prison places to replace ageing, ineffective prisons proved undeliverable and outsourcing prison facilities management has not delivered expected efficiencies. If successful, these initiatives could have made a difference, but as it stands the prison estate is not meeting the needs of prisoners or those working in the prison system. It represents poor value for money.
HMPPS is taking welcome steps to improve its understanding of the condition of the prison estate, and now better understands the significant gap between its ambitions and the available resources. Learning lessons from its experience in delivering the programme will be crucial as it responds to the government’s new commitment to create 10,000 new prison places. But HMPPS must resist a reactive approach and put its long-term plans on a secure footing. Achieving value for money will ultimately depend on HMPPS working with the Ministry and HM Treasury to develop a long-term, deliverable strategy that will provide a prison estate that is fit for purpose.
National Audit Office report on improving the prison estate
Commenting on the findings of today’s (7 February) National Audit Office report on improving the prison estate, Peter Dawson, director of the Prison Reform Trust said:
“This startlingly frank report says that the government is failing to provide safe, secure and decent prisons. It describes in forensic detail how a succession of plans have disintegrated almost as soon as they have been announced, resulting in a failure to build new prisons, or close old ones, or maintain the current prison estate in a useable condition. To cap it all, there is no plan in place for the future.
“Scarcely a week passes without another high profile announcement of longer sentences or delayed release dates, despite the absence of any evidence that more imprisonment does anything to deter or reduce crime. This report exposes the recklessness of that approach, sending people to a prison system that shames us as a country, and all too often serves only to entrench the behaviour it is supposed to change.”
Meanwhile the National Audit Office has found the government has so far only increased prison places by 200, despite a pledge in 2016 to deliver 10,000 places over four years. The NAO's report said the building programme was delayed because of disagreements about funding. It found 3,000 places were still under construction.
There are currently more than 83,000 people locked up - and the number is forecast to increase. The report said analysis by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) showed that from October 2022, demand for prison places could begin to outstrip supply, as an increase in police officer numbers potentially leads to more offenders being caught. Further pressures are expected because of sentencing reforms, with the most serious offenders spending longer periods behind bars. The NAO report also criticised prison conditions, with poor safety reaching "record levels" and "huge maintenance backlogs".
Ministers have announced a new £2.5bn prison building programme but the NAO said no timetable has been set and the 10,000 places which they have again promised may not be enough to keep up with the expected rise in the prison population. The Ministry of Justice said it recognised the need to invest in maintenance and safety and pledged to spend an additional £256m to carry out improvements over the coming year.
--oo00oo--
So, yet more confirmation of a pretty grim picture of very poor management by HMPPS, of which probation is of course part and regular readers will be aware I'm strongly of the opinion that if this vital public service is to survive and be useful, it must break free of the dead hand of civil service control and return to being independently run.
I want to end this post by making an important point and it concerns the degree of traction that probation practitioners can still exert despite official attempts to stifle discussion and debate within NPS. The following is from an email I received yesterday from the NAO and I hope they will not mind my quoting from it:-
"Dear Mr Brown,
The National Audit Office has today published a report on Improving the Prison Estate which we hope will be of interest to your subscribers. You can find a link to our report here: https://www.nao.org.uk/report/improving-the-prison-estate/
We have found your blog to be an excellent source of information on developments in probation and prisons sectors, particularly in terms of canvassing a broad range of perspectives from practitioners on the ground.
You may be interested to know that previous discussion threads on your blog helped to inform our approach to data collection and fieldwork for our value for money study on Transforming Rehabilitation: Progress Review which we published in March last year. This, combined with insights from our focus groups with probation officers, culminated in Figure 4 of the report which examined workload rates across different National Probation Service sub-regions."
Improving the prison estate
This report examines the condition and capacity of HM Prison and Probation Service's prison estate.
Background to the report
Since 2015, against a backdrop of worsening living conditions for prisoners, HMPPS (Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service) has changed the way in which it maintains prisons and launched a programme to improve the condition and suitability of prison accommodation. It opted to contract out facilities management, create 10,000 new-for-old prison places and change its estate to better meet the needs of prisoners.
Content and scope of the report
This report examines how HMPPS handled these changes and what it achieved. It:
- sets out the condition of the estate and the capacity within prisons to accommodate the prison population;
- examines HMPPS’s approach to managing the maintenance of its prisons; and
- assesses HMPPS’s performance in transforming its estate by building new prisons, selling unsuitable prisons and reorganising prison places.
HMPPS has committed to providing a safe, secure and decent prison estate, but its plans to achieve this are failing. It has not been able to provide enough prison places, in the right type of prisons, and at the right time, to meet demand. The Prison Estate Transformation Programme’s plans to create up to 10,000 new prison places to replace ageing, ineffective prisons proved undeliverable and outsourcing prison facilities management has not delivered expected efficiencies. If successful, these initiatives could have made a difference, but as it stands the prison estate is not meeting the needs of prisoners or those working in the prison system. It represents poor value for money.
HMPPS is taking welcome steps to improve its understanding of the condition of the prison estate, and now better understands the significant gap between its ambitions and the available resources. Learning lessons from its experience in delivering the programme will be crucial as it responds to the government’s new commitment to create 10,000 new prison places. But HMPPS must resist a reactive approach and put its long-term plans on a secure footing. Achieving value for money will ultimately depend on HMPPS working with the Ministry and HM Treasury to develop a long-term, deliverable strategy that will provide a prison estate that is fit for purpose.
--oo00oo--
This from the Guardian:-
Two in five prisons in poor condition, watchdog finds
Report says a backlog of major repairs will cost £916m as safety breaches reach a record high
The government is failing in its efforts to improve prison conditions, with record levels of safety breaches and “huge” backlogs in repairs, Whitehall’s spending watchdog has found. The National Audit Office said plans to “provide and maintain safe, secure and decent prisons” had not been carried out.
A report released on Friday found that safety in two out of every five inspected prisons were rated as poor or “not sufficiently good”, with recorded problems at an all-time high. Over the last decade, the Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) has taken 1,730 cells permanently out of use and it expects to lose another 500 places every year because of the poor conditions of the remaining estate, the NAO said.
In the next three years, 41% of prisons need major repair or replacement work. There is currently a backlog of repairs that will cost £916m to fix, according to the report. The prison population in December was around 82,300, equating to 98% of its capacity.
The report comes as ministers aim to pass emergency legislation to block the automatic early release of convicted terror offenders, which is likely to put further pressure on the prison system. The move follows three attacks in recent months by men convicted of terror offences, including the stabbing on Sunday of two people in Streatham, south London.
Responding to the report, Meg Hillier, chair of the public accounts committee, said the ministry had failed once more to oversee outsourcing firms or get to grips with management of a crumbling estate.
“As with probation reforms, the ministry has not got outsourcing right. Provider performance has been poor and planned savings failed to materialise. The ministry is on course to deliver just a third of previously promised places. The government say they want people to serve more time, but soon the prison population could exceed capacity. As the Streatham attack highlighted, the Prison and Probation Service urgently needs a long-term plan to improve our prisons and will need the funding to do this.”
In 2015, HMPPS outsourced management of prison facilities to Amey and Carillion, expecting to achieve savings of £79m, but had an inaccurate and incomplete understanding of the condition of the assets, the report said. “Due diligence was not sufficiently robust and HMPPS severely underestimated the demand for reactive maintenance work arising from vandalism and failing assets.” HMPPS expected to pay providers £17.7m for variable costs by 2018-19 – the fourth year of the contracts – but has paid £160.4m, according to the latest findings.
The government has “struggled to create new prison places”, with only 206 built and 3,360 under construction out of 10,000 new for old places it committed to create in 2016. “The main reason behind these failures was the delays in agreeing and receiving funding to build new prisons. This meant construction work began later than planned,” the report said.
It recommended that HMPPS develop a long-term strategy on condition standards and minimum levels of investment. Gareth Davies, head of the NAO, said: “The government has recently committed to creating 10,000 new prison places and needs to learn lessons from its recent experiences.”
The Ministry of Justice said it “recognised” the need to invest in maintenance and safety and pledged to spend £256m more to carry out improvements over the coming year. A spokeswoman said: “We will always have enough prison places to keep offenders behind bars, and the government’s £2.5bn investment will create 10,000 modern places, on top of the two new jails already being built.”
This from the Guardian:-
Two in five prisons in poor condition, watchdog finds
Report says a backlog of major repairs will cost £916m as safety breaches reach a record high
The government is failing in its efforts to improve prison conditions, with record levels of safety breaches and “huge” backlogs in repairs, Whitehall’s spending watchdog has found. The National Audit Office said plans to “provide and maintain safe, secure and decent prisons” had not been carried out.
A report released on Friday found that safety in two out of every five inspected prisons were rated as poor or “not sufficiently good”, with recorded problems at an all-time high. Over the last decade, the Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) has taken 1,730 cells permanently out of use and it expects to lose another 500 places every year because of the poor conditions of the remaining estate, the NAO said.
In the next three years, 41% of prisons need major repair or replacement work. There is currently a backlog of repairs that will cost £916m to fix, according to the report. The prison population in December was around 82,300, equating to 98% of its capacity.
The report comes as ministers aim to pass emergency legislation to block the automatic early release of convicted terror offenders, which is likely to put further pressure on the prison system. The move follows three attacks in recent months by men convicted of terror offences, including the stabbing on Sunday of two people in Streatham, south London.
Responding to the report, Meg Hillier, chair of the public accounts committee, said the ministry had failed once more to oversee outsourcing firms or get to grips with management of a crumbling estate.
“As with probation reforms, the ministry has not got outsourcing right. Provider performance has been poor and planned savings failed to materialise. The ministry is on course to deliver just a third of previously promised places. The government say they want people to serve more time, but soon the prison population could exceed capacity. As the Streatham attack highlighted, the Prison and Probation Service urgently needs a long-term plan to improve our prisons and will need the funding to do this.”
In 2015, HMPPS outsourced management of prison facilities to Amey and Carillion, expecting to achieve savings of £79m, but had an inaccurate and incomplete understanding of the condition of the assets, the report said. “Due diligence was not sufficiently robust and HMPPS severely underestimated the demand for reactive maintenance work arising from vandalism and failing assets.” HMPPS expected to pay providers £17.7m for variable costs by 2018-19 – the fourth year of the contracts – but has paid £160.4m, according to the latest findings.
The government has “struggled to create new prison places”, with only 206 built and 3,360 under construction out of 10,000 new for old places it committed to create in 2016. “The main reason behind these failures was the delays in agreeing and receiving funding to build new prisons. This meant construction work began later than planned,” the report said.
It recommended that HMPPS develop a long-term strategy on condition standards and minimum levels of investment. Gareth Davies, head of the NAO, said: “The government has recently committed to creating 10,000 new prison places and needs to learn lessons from its recent experiences.”
The Ministry of Justice said it “recognised” the need to invest in maintenance and safety and pledged to spend £256m more to carry out improvements over the coming year. A spokeswoman said: “We will always have enough prison places to keep offenders behind bars, and the government’s £2.5bn investment will create 10,000 modern places, on top of the two new jails already being built.”
--oo00oo--
National Audit Office report on improving the prison estate
Commenting on the findings of today’s (7 February) National Audit Office report on improving the prison estate, Peter Dawson, director of the Prison Reform Trust said:
“This startlingly frank report says that the government is failing to provide safe, secure and decent prisons. It describes in forensic detail how a succession of plans have disintegrated almost as soon as they have been announced, resulting in a failure to build new prisons, or close old ones, or maintain the current prison estate in a useable condition. To cap it all, there is no plan in place for the future.
“Scarcely a week passes without another high profile announcement of longer sentences or delayed release dates, despite the absence of any evidence that more imprisonment does anything to deter or reduce crime. This report exposes the recklessness of that approach, sending people to a prison system that shames us as a country, and all too often serves only to entrench the behaviour it is supposed to change.”
There are currently more than 83,000 people locked up - and the number is forecast to increase. The report said analysis by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) showed that from October 2022, demand for prison places could begin to outstrip supply, as an increase in police officer numbers potentially leads to more offenders being caught. Further pressures are expected because of sentencing reforms, with the most serious offenders spending longer periods behind bars. The NAO report also criticised prison conditions, with poor safety reaching "record levels" and "huge maintenance backlogs".
Ministers have announced a new £2.5bn prison building programme but the NAO said no timetable has been set and the 10,000 places which they have again promised may not be enough to keep up with the expected rise in the prison population. The Ministry of Justice said it recognised the need to invest in maintenance and safety and pledged to spend an additional £256m to carry out improvements over the coming year.
--oo00oo--
So, yet more confirmation of a pretty grim picture of very poor management by HMPPS, of which probation is of course part and regular readers will be aware I'm strongly of the opinion that if this vital public service is to survive and be useful, it must break free of the dead hand of civil service control and return to being independently run.
I want to end this post by making an important point and it concerns the degree of traction that probation practitioners can still exert despite official attempts to stifle discussion and debate within NPS. The following is from an email I received yesterday from the NAO and I hope they will not mind my quoting from it:-
"Dear Mr Brown,
The National Audit Office has today published a report on Improving the Prison Estate which we hope will be of interest to your subscribers. You can find a link to our report here: https://www.nao.org.uk/report/improving-the-prison-estate/
We have found your blog to be an excellent source of information on developments in probation and prisons sectors, particularly in terms of canvassing a broad range of perspectives from practitioners on the ground.
You may be interested to know that previous discussion threads on your blog helped to inform our approach to data collection and fieldwork for our value for money study on Transforming Rehabilitation: Progress Review which we published in March last year. This, combined with insights from our focus groups with probation officers, culminated in Figure 4 of the report which examined workload rates across different National Probation Service sub-regions."
Readers will recall it was that NAO report that put the final nail in the coffin marked TR and as discussed here.
Friday, 7 February 2020
A Picture Worth a Thousand Words
On the very day I suggest that it really is all over and 'probation' as many of us know it has been strangled under NPS civil service command and control, Twitter and the NPS heirarchy delivers us the following tweet complete with photo. What exactly are poor over-worked and stressed-out staff supposed to draw from such a message? Inspiration?
We all know OASys was the best way yet invented by man to both waste as much time as possible to absolutely no useful end, and in the process drive the poor bloody author to lose the will to live. It pretty much destroyed the skill inherent in report-writing and effectively chains probation staff to their data input desks for 70% of their time. While we're at it, note how, in a Service dominated by young female practitioners, it's suited men poring over the bloody forms as well.

Exploring the new OASys quality assurance framework at OMiC workshop in Worle today.
*****
Jim - I reckon you're right on the money with your observation: "I'm rapidly gaining the impression that probation service staff must have been sufficiently cowed, purged, bullied and silenced under the dead-hand of civil service bureaucracy and central command and control by HMPPS."
*****
Jim - having read today's blog & some of the posted comments I think it really IS all over now. So it looks like the truly nasty amoral political class have finally succeeded in their efforts to eliminate the remnants of what was a free-thinking, independent, humanitarian vocational profession by slicing & dicing, ducking & diving, slipping public money into the greasy palms of unscrupulous profiteers, and getting HMPPS to tailor a bespoke political straight-jacket for the NPS, i.e. the Civil Service.
If you build it, they will come: "My message to anybody who dislikes the NPS so much that they want to 'fight' is that they need to leave... if you're paid to do a job then your employer has a right to expect you to do as you're told." If I were to write the book it would be entitled "When Advise, Assist & Befriend became J.F.D.I."
*****
We are trained to challenge, confront and change offending (and offensive behaviour) but are we expected to simply bow, scrape and tug our forelocks to those who claim to be in control but who have driven the ship onto the rocks. Sometimes I despair.
*****
Totally agree and on both points. We are treated like disposable robots now, numbers and god forbid we display the very skills they incorporated in training. We are professionals in a so called career with degrees and [not] those without experience and responsible decision making. Why should we then simply shut up and follow mis-management and organisational bullying and accept the stress and blame culture they place on us? Are we not supposed to be honest and fair people by nature of wanting to do a job working with others?
We all know OASys was the best way yet invented by man to both waste as much time as possible to absolutely no useful end, and in the process drive the poor bloody author to lose the will to live. It pretty much destroyed the skill inherent in report-writing and effectively chains probation staff to their data input desks for 70% of their time. While we're at it, note how, in a Service dominated by young female practitioners, it's suited men poring over the bloody forms as well.
Exploring the new OASys quality assurance framework at OMiC workshop in Worle today.
*****
Jim - I reckon you're right on the money with your observation: "I'm rapidly gaining the impression that probation service staff must have been sufficiently cowed, purged, bullied and silenced under the dead-hand of civil service bureaucracy and central command and control by HMPPS."
*****
Jim - having read today's blog & some of the posted comments I think it really IS all over now. So it looks like the truly nasty amoral political class have finally succeeded in their efforts to eliminate the remnants of what was a free-thinking, independent, humanitarian vocational profession by slicing & dicing, ducking & diving, slipping public money into the greasy palms of unscrupulous profiteers, and getting HMPPS to tailor a bespoke political straight-jacket for the NPS, i.e. the Civil Service.
If you build it, they will come: "My message to anybody who dislikes the NPS so much that they want to 'fight' is that they need to leave... if you're paid to do a job then your employer has a right to expect you to do as you're told." If I were to write the book it would be entitled "When Advise, Assist & Befriend became J.F.D.I."
*****
We are trained to challenge, confront and change offending (and offensive behaviour) but are we expected to simply bow, scrape and tug our forelocks to those who claim to be in control but who have driven the ship onto the rocks. Sometimes I despair.
*****
Totally agree and on both points. We are treated like disposable robots now, numbers and god forbid we display the very skills they incorporated in training. We are professionals in a so called career with degrees and [not] those without experience and responsible decision making. Why should we then simply shut up and follow mis-management and organisational bullying and accept the stress and blame culture they place on us? Are we not supposed to be honest and fair people by nature of wanting to do a job working with others?
Thursday, 6 February 2020
Is It Really All Over?
Given the ongoing and worsening crisis in our prisons, largely brought about by Chris Grayling who of course was also responsible for wrecking the former gold-standard Probation Service, I'm surprised there hasn't been greater mention of the Offender Management in Custody (OMiC) project of late? I'm rapidly gaining the impression that probation service staff must have been sufficiently cowed, purged, bullied and silenced under the dead-hand of civil service bureaucracy and central command and control by HMPPS.
Lets be clear about this. Distinguished former governor and academic John Podmore, writing in the Daily Telegraph has this to say about HMPPS, of which Probation is now part:-
--oo00oo--
Our outdated prisons have descended into mayhem. Here's how we can turn things aroundLets be clear about this. Distinguished former governor and academic John Podmore, writing in the Daily Telegraph has this to say about HMPPS, of which Probation is now part:-
"But it is a closed world of secretive accreditation and no evaluation, led by people who have only ever worked in the prison service. Outside specialists in counter terrorism, Islamic fundamentalism, drug treatment, sex offender treatment, psychiatric and psychological therapy are eschewed - and heaven forbid we involve ex-prisoners or terrorists offenders who have turned their lives around and have a valuable contribution to make. Similarly, those with law enforcement skills and competencies are also detached from efforts to combat serious organised crime in prison and the corruption that underpins it.
Prison service culture is one of insularity and defensiveness - and very little visible leadership. Despite a burgeoning bureaucracy, ministers either micro-manage ineffectively, or accept platitudes from officials instead of holding them to account. This cannot continue."The Probation Service should never have been part of this outfit; its culture and ethos is completely different, so are we to understand the absence of a clarion call for separation and re-establishment of a distinctive probation identity is over? Have NPS staff really accepted all the trappings and Blue Light discount card nonsense that goes with this dysfunctional and inappropriate outfit and are happy with it?
--oo00oo--
Our prison and probation services have sadly become chaotic institutions which succeed only in making people worse.
During their incarcerations, prisoners acquire drug habits, experience radicalisation and deteriorating mental health. Serious organised crime is seriously well organised behind prison walls and "imprisonment as a means of incapacitation" has become a myth perpetuated by politicians. If we measured the crime rates inside prisons, we would surely categorise them as crime hotspots in their own right.
There is good work and there are dedicated professionals in our jails but we are asking the impossible of them in the current set-up. Former Secretary of State for Justice, Chris Grayling gets some well-deserved blame for the chaos but the problems have run deeper for over a decade.
The establishment of a Ministry of Justice under New Labour was a logical step but it failed because of poor leadership and, latterly swingeing financial cuts on everything from legal aid to prison officers. We have tried to get a criminal Justice System on the cheap and it has failed.
The system is crying out for more funding, some of which has been forthcoming, and yet the signs are that it will be poorly targeted: Titan jails in the middle of nowhere rather than resettlement prisons in communities; 20,000 police officers but no youth workers. We lock up too many people for ever-longer periods and as they deteriorate they either fail the tests of the Parole Board for release or are quickly recalled to prison when they return to the chaos they left behind. But of the 85,000 people in prison, who really needs to be there? We should lock up those we are afraid of, not who we are mad at.
The prison system is predicated on the Mountbatten Report of 1966, following the escape of Great Train Robbers, Ronnie Biggs and Charlie Wilson and the spy, George Blake. The configuration of the prison estate with its categories A to D has changed little since, while the prison population has become ever more complex. We have a system designed for white, adult men but required to look after those with poor mental health, addictions, the elderly, serious organised criminals, TV licence non-payers, abused women and disturbed children.
Within the mayhem is poor care, ineffective treatment and financial waste. For the difficult, damaged, chaotic and disordered we need to look for community solutions and deal with them in local prisons where the emphasis is on social inclusion not security, and which is run by managers with experience in health, social care, employment and education rather than career civil servants. This group is the majority of those we incarcerate, probably two-thirds.
The remaining 30,000, those posing a real threat to the community need a separate system with secure containment and interventions. Prison is an opportunity to intervene and while there will always be a few who won’t change we should ensure they do not infect or harm others, staff or prisoners, inside or out. Such a ‘Federal’ or ‘National’ prison estate needs no new buildings, our existing eight High Secure prisons are an appropriate starting point for the most serious offenders.
What we do in such jails needs careful thought and planning, research and evaluation. For now the prison and probation service has its own treatment industry delivering a range of programmes inside and out ranging from de-radicalisation and sex-offender treatment through to anger management.
But it is a closed world of secretive accreditation and no evaluation, led by people who have only ever worked in the prison service. Outside specialists in counter terrorism, Islamic fundamentalism, drug treatment, sex offender treatment, psychiatric and psychological therapy are eschewed - and heaven forbid we involve ex-prisoners or terrorists offenders who have turned their lives around and have a valuable contribution to make. Similarly, those with law enforcement skills and competencies are also detached from efforts to combat serious organised crime in prison and the corruption that underpins it.
Prison service culture is one of insularity and defensiveness - and very little visible leadership. Despite a burgeoning bureaucracy, ministers either micro-manage ineffectively, or accept platitudes from officials instead of holding them to account. This cannot continue.
The prison service has built its own walls to resist the winds of change, it’s time we built windmills.
John Podmore is professor of Applied Social Sciences at the University of Durham. He is a former governor of Belmarsh, Swaleside and Brixton prisons.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)