Saturday, 21 March 2020

Latest From Napo 203

The following was published late yesterday and although not my main blogpost today, in view of widespread concern within the whole probation world, the content is clearly important and therefore will be of widespread interest:-

To: all Napo members in Cafcass, NPS, PbNI and the CRC estate

Dear Member

Combatting C19 - Napo members show courage and resilience as Exceptional Delivery Model is implemented

I thought I would base the contents of this week’s mail out around the key issues that I reported on to your National Executive Committee yesterday. This was an extraordinary meeting, in what are extraordinary times; as it was conducted entirely remotely by teleconference. It worked pretty well all things considered, and I extend our appreciation to NEC members for their patience and discipline as we debated issues of serious importance to our members (another mail out will follow early next week about what was discussed) Unfortunately, this and other means of remote communication, will provide the main means of support for our activities as we all go about our business in the uncertain weeks and months ahead.

As I write, the horrendous live news feeds from the desperately overwhelmed Italian health service, and news of another 39 deaths today in the UK, provides further warning (as if it were needed) that we and our families are in the midst of a global Pandemic that presents a real and present danger to millions of people irrespective of age and social standing. Napo has been doing, is doing, and will continue to do, absolutely everything we can to work with your employers to enact the necessary measures demanded by the social distancing policy that was announced by the Prime Minister this week. As you would expect we will lead by example within our sphere of influence.

Our work, and the considerable achievements over the space of a few days to try and reduce risk to staff and service users would not have been anywhere near as effective without the support of our members, who have been providing important real time information that has enabled us to engage early with senior leaders and, where needs be, to take a robust approach where we believe that action has been slow to happen. Much has been done, but there remains a lot more still to do.

In a week that has seen unprecedented partnership between the Government, the Official Opposition, TUC and Employers representatives, it’s only right that I express appreciation to senior HMPPS leaders for their willingness to listen and respond to your concerns as best they can especially following our demands that prioritisation be given to the suspension of Interventions and Programmes across the CRCs. Things are tough enough as it is, and the climate is not helped by endless media speculation about possible further initiatives by the Government. That said, we can be pretty confident that next week will see the announcement of major steps across the Criminal Justice and Family Court systems that will fundamentally change the way in which the majority of our members undertake their work. If and when that happens the Napo Officers and myself will issue further news to you as early as we possibly can

Here are some of the other actions we have been involved in nationally alongside our sister unions this week :


  • Strategic meetings and regular contact as and when required, with the Director General and Executive Director of Probation around the developing Exceptional Delivery Model (EDM) which provides the structure for emergency measures across Probation and Prisons. See the following LINK to the Official advice from Government about key Workers and the closure of educational establishments
  • Establishing links which give Union H&S leads early previews of intended instructions to be issued under the EDM
  • Similar contact by your Officials and National Officers with Cafcass Leaders, CRC owners and Senior Management Teams on contingency planning and steps to reduce face to face contact
  • Discussions about the launch of an additional hours remuneration package in NPS to support the EDM (more about our views on this next week)
  • Further representations about the need to suspend the NPS sickness absence management scheme, and all face to face hearings.
  • Work with cross party politicians and the media on the developing situation across Prisons and Probation
  • Fielding the many and quite understandable questions from members
Keeping Napo functioning during the crisis

The Officer Group have moved swiftly to authorise me to enact emergency measures to protect your employees at Falcon Road in respect of risk mitigation and business continuity.

Essentially, all Napo staff are now working remotely (save for a designated team who will attend HQ on a rota system for care and maintenance purposes). This means that we will generally be asking members who need to contact HQ directly to use the voicemail telephone number and Info@napo.org.uk e-mail address. Both sources will be monitored daily and the team will seek to contact you at the earliest opportunity I will arrange for further details to be issued to your Branch Representatives. Meanwhile, the normal link arrangements with Officers and Officials via phone and e-mail continue as normal.

The officers and NEC also agreed that all face to face contact between members seeking assistance or who may be called to attend a hearing and Napo staff or any Napo representative must be conducted remotely until further notice.

All Napo events between now and early June are also cancelled and a decision will be made on the scheduled June NEC at a later date.

Ian Lawrence
General Secretary on behalf of the Napo Officers and Napo Staff Group

20th March 2020

Friday, 20 March 2020

Beware of Bullshit

Lets start by answering a question about 'key' workers. The government have issued guidance for schools and can be found here:-

Coronavirus (COVID-19): maintaining educational provision

If your work is critical to the COVID-19 response, or you work in one of the critical sectors listed below, and you cannot keep your child safe at home then your children will be prioritised for education provision:

Public safety and national security

This includes police and support staff, Ministry of Defence civilians, contractor and armed forces personnel (those critical to the delivery of key defence and national security outputs and essential to the response to the COVID-19 pandemic), fire and rescue service employees (including support staff), National Crime Agency staff, those maintaining border security, prison and probation staff and other national security roles, including those overseas.


--oo00oo--

We all know the internet is a wonderful thing that is rapidly changing the lives of us all, but it also has a dark side that enables bullshit, rumour and misinformation to take hold. Anyone who watched the BBC tv documentary the other night 'Taking Control : The Dominic Cummings Story' will be left in no doubt as to how politicians are now able to manipulate information, tell lies and win elections with seeming consummate ease. 

There's already evidence that the same is happening in relation to the current crisis with fake news about the Army heading to London on the M6, conspiracy theories about the origin, nature and purpose of COVID-19 and how it can be dealt with and treated. There is misinformation everywhere such as our prime minister saying he's confident 'We can turn the tide' on coranavirus in 12 weeks. It's just bullshit of course, something we all know he's an expert in. In light of this I don't want to pass over the following article from the Guardian on Wednesday:-         

Scientists have been sounding the alarm on coronavirus for months. Why did Britain fail to act?

On 24 January, Chinese doctors and scientists reported the first description of a new disease caused by a novel coronavirus. They described how a strange series of cases of pneumonia had presented in December in Wuhan, a city of 11 million people and the capital of Hubei province. At that time, 800 cases of the new disease had been confirmed. The virus had already been exported to Thailand, Japan and South Korea.

Most of the 41 people described in this first report, published in the Lancet, presented with non-specific symptoms of fever and cough. More than half had difficulties in breathing. But most worryingly of all, a third of these patients had such a severe illness that they had to be admitted to an intensive care unit. Most developed a critical complication of their viral pneumonia – acute respiratory distress syndrome. Half died.

The Chinese scientists pulled no punches. “The number of deaths is rising quickly,” they wrote. The provision of personal protective equipment for health workers was strongly recommended. Testing for the virus should be done immediately a diagnosis was suspected. They concluded that the mortality rate was high. And they urged careful surveillance of this new virus in view of its “pandemic potential”.

That was in January. Why did it take the UK government eight weeks to recognise the seriousness of what we now call Covid-19?

In 2003, Chinese officials were heavily criticised for keeping the dangers of a new viral disease, severe acute respiratory syndrome (Sars), secret. By 2020, a new generation of Chinese scientists had learned their lesson. Under immense pressure, as the epidemic exploded around them, they took time to write up their findings in a foreign language and seek publication in a medical journal thousands of miles away. Their rapid and rigorous work was an urgent warning to the world. We owe those scientists enormous thanks.

But medical and scientific advisers to the UK government ignored their warnings. For unknown reasons they waited. And watched.

The scientists advising ministers seemed to believe that this new virus could be treated much like influenza. Graham Medley, one of the government’s expert scientific advisers, was disarmingly explicit. In an interview on Newsnight last week, he explained the UK’s approach: to allow a controlled epidemic of large numbers of people, which would generate “herd immunity”. Our scientists recommended “a situation where the majority of the population are immune to the infection. And the only way of developing that, in the absence of a vaccine, is for the majority of the population to become infected.”

Medley suggested that, “ideally”, we might need “a nice big epidemic” among the less vulnerable. “What we are going to have to try and do,” he said, was to “manage this acquisition of herd immunity and minimise the exposure of people who are vulnerable.” Sir Patrick Vallance, the government’s chief scientific adviser, suggested that the target was to infect 60% of the UK’s population.

After weeks of inaction, the government announced a sudden U-turn on Monday, declaring that new modelling by scientists at Imperial College had convinced them to change their initial plans. Many journalists, led by the BBC, reported that “the science had changed” and so the government had responded accordingly. But this interpretation of events is wrong. The science has been the same since January. What changed is that government advisers at last understood what had really taken place in China.

Indeed, it didn’t need this week’s predictions by Imperial College scientists to estimate the impact of the government’s complacent approach. Any numerate school student could make the calculation. With a mortality of 1% among 60% of a population of some 66 million people, the UK could expect almost 400,000 deaths. The huge wave of critically ill patients that would result from this strategy would quickly overwhelm the NHS.

The UK’s best scientists have known since that first report from China that Covid-19 was a lethal illness. Yet they did too little, too late.

The virus quickly made its way to Europe. Italy was the first European country to suffer huge human losses. On 12 March, two Italian researchers, Andrea Remuzzi and Giuseppe Remuzzi, set out the lessons of their tragic experience. Italy’s health service simply could not cope. They did not have the capacity of intensive care beds to deal with the scale of infection and its consequences. They predicted that by mid-April their health system would be overwhelmed. The mortality of patients with severe infection was high. A fifth of health workers were becoming infected, and some were dying.

They described the situation in Italy as an unmanageable catastrophe. They wrote: “These considerations might also apply to other European countries that could have similar numbers of patients infected and similar needs regarding intensive care admissions.” And yet the UK continued with its strategy of encouraging the epidemic and the goal of herd immunity.

Something has gone badly wrong in the way the UK has handled Covid-19. I know Chris Whitty, the chief medical officer, and Patrick Vallance. I have the utmost respect for both. They have had the services of some of the most talented researchers in the world to draw on. But somehow there was a collective failure among politicians and perhaps even government experts to recognise the signals that Chinese and Italian scientists were sending. We had the opportunity and the time to learn from the experience of other countries. For reasons that are not entirely clear, the UK missed those signals. We missed those opportunities.

In due time, there must be a reckoning. I sat with the director general of the World Health Organization, Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, in Geneva in February. He was in despair. Tedros had been criticised for not calling a public health emergency of international concern sooner. But when he did and when he asked for the modest sum of $675m to help the WHO combat the growing global pandemic his pleas were ignored.

The UK is now taking the right actions to defeat this new epidemic. But we have lost valuable time. There will be deaths that were preventable. The system failed. I don’t know why. But, when we have suppressed this epidemic, when life returns to some semblance of normality, difficult questions will have to be asked and answered. Because we can’t afford to fail again. We may not have a second chance.

Richard Horton is a doctor and edits the Lancet

Thursday, 19 March 2020

Information Vacuum

Funny thing. Have you noticed how all the Twitter accounts belonging to NPS senior managers seem to have fallen silent recently? None of the usual inconsequential upbeat puff just at the very moment staff are worried sick, desperate for information and in need of leadership. 

The question being asked repeatedly on social media platforms now is 'are probation staff key workers or not? This is important because with schools now closing tomorrow, many probation staff with children have some urgent decisions to make regarding childcare, just as the suspicion grows that the MoJ will be considering significant emergency release of low risk prisoners next week. Staff are getting increasingly angry at being kept in the dark and  many Napo members are feeling similarly disenchanted following the latest extraordinary mailout from HQ:-

Dear Colleagues,

C19 – Napo in communication with NPS, CRC, HMPPS and Cafcass senior leaders

As you would expect, Napo is currently engaged with senior leaders across the above employers to ascertain their advice in response to yesterday’s Government statement on Social Distancing in the campaign to combat the Coronavirus.

Clearly this has caused concern amongst our membership and that of our sister unions, with whom we are also in regular communication. Our members valuable work within Probation and Cafcass involves a proportionately higher requirement for face to face contact with clients than just about any other profession. We wanted to let you know that we acknowledge your concerns, and that the Napo team are working flat out at the moment in analysing information and we will issue any additional advice to members once we are in a position to do so. The Napo leadership team are also in regular discussion with the General Secretary to ensure that everything is being done to ensure business continuity for Napo HQ.

Whilst we fully appreciate that members have a range of legitimate questions we must ask that you refrain from sending e-mail or making telephone calls into Napo HQ as this is taking up valuable time as we seek to secure answers.

Yours in solidarity

Ian

Ian Lawrence General Secretary     
Siobhan Foreman National Vice-Chair

--oo00oo--

Business meetings are now to be held via Skype but we still have to sit in groups of up to 10 men, often elderly, delivering Horizon, which is still to be run until MoJ says different. No real cleaning of offices, pubs are wiping door handles etc continuously, no wipes to wipe down desks and phones in interview rooms, no separate bins to “use it, bin it, kill it”, no soap in kitchen, no alcohol rich sanitiser etc and now no pay increase, but “business as usual”.

Those in the highest risk categories should be self isolating and following the guidance. I am almost certain that there will be a significantly reduced office presence, probably with those who have less concern re: particular vulnerabilities either themselves or in their immediate families taking a lead role in enabling offices to remain operational, because that's what we do. Locally we have had offers from those already home working to take on additional report writing etc, to support those who are taking on more of the office cover. 


News from NE. Actually heard that they have cancelled all their local training so it just felt like one place was taking action and not others. Agree that is so unpredictable and unclear how to progress. I’m half expecting several of my delegates not to turn up this week but feels like we will know more by Friday.

That advice came out this afternoon about face to face training etc. I think today's announcement will trigger a fairly rapid avalanche of guidance, where I'd imagine all events like that will be suspended while social distancing is the advice.

Interserve have cancelled UPW and programmes with immediate effect for 48 hours this afternoon, think it may be to check legality re sentences.

Hopefully something will come out tomorrow, but for the moment, it's a case of keep calm and carry on working. We are already being advised to bring laptops home every night  along with phones, so in the case of a short notice lockdown we can at least attempt to work from home.

Not being in contact with people! Keeping your distance avoiding social contact and staying vigilant! Well we are vigilant. Anyone who rings in saying they can’t attend we are giving them the advice we were given but when people walk into the office to be seen - seen they will be - so how is that being in line with what was said tonight! It’s bizarre and rightly or wrongly direction is needed. I’m happy to go to work every day and will cover for colleges who can’t but if advice from the top is keep your distance what else is there to do!

I am waiting for further guidance tomorrow. I am confident those at the centre of probation are working very hard to work out the guidance for all staff. I will continue to work with staff on the front line for the time being whilst not in a risk group etc. In these times it is our public sectors which are leaned on most. I wish the guidance today was a bit clearer but it’s not so will wait for further interpretation.

I am expecting the usual updating email tomorrow. I would expect any group activities to be stopped & an increase in telephone reporting. Many staff members will need to self isolate. I will see what the advice to us says. I worry for predictable increase in domestic violence as well as people getting really ill or worse.

The guidance received late this afternoon was not at all specific. Basically staff & SUs with symptoms should not come into the office & we should also follow NHS guidance on who should self isolate. Other than that it is business as usual here!

I think the situation is very complex and not a simple choice. I agree there should be policy & resources about limitting the risks for frontline staff. I am not going to comment on the guidance which came out this afternoon. Where is the line between being vulnerable enough to self isolate for staff & service users? If you have mild asthma do you self isolate, possibly for weeks / months. You could end your isolation and then catch it anyway. 


We are equivalent to an emergency service, especially in regard to high risk & very high risk cases. With this there are responsibilities not involved in other employment. There should, however, be specific clear guidelines from our employer stating when staff & SUs should not come into the office. This is an evolving situation and who know what exactly will happen.  We are getting no support at all. The civil service have not got a clue what we do and the lack of practical guidance to front line staff just highlights this. 

All the yes managers don't offer any support because they just refer to what is coming out centrally. We are expected to sit in tiny rooms no more than 9ft by 9ft to deliver interventions only feet from someone with no ventilation in the room for up to an hour. The highest risk of contracting Covid 19. We are not prioritising who should report, we are asking over 70s to still report, even though the government are saying they should isolate and getting nothing from the centre about what really affects us. We have no hand sanitizers no protective equipment, absolutely nothing. Staff are having to provide it themselves. It's absolutely shameful.

Wednesday, 18 March 2020

Whatever It Takes

Not sure how to put into words what's going on, but will try. It seems that pretty much everything we once understood and experienced is now out of the window as the world goes on a war footing, but unusually without any guns being fired. Well, I say that, but as we Brits extraordinarily clear the shops of toilet rolls, in the US they are buying guns at an unprecedented rate. It appears to be mostly the Chinese community responding to fears stoked by their dreadful racist President choosing to disgracefully brand Cov-19 as a 'Chinese' virus. 

Staying with the US for a moment, I find it astonishing that Trump has seamlessly moved from calling it all the latest 'Democratic hoax', to becoming a sudden convert to socialism with a plan to just send everyone a cheque! Of course he's up for re-election and possibly thinks it's a good wheeze to just buy votes with a trillion tax dollars, like he tried to buy the entire supply of vaccine being developed in Germany. This whole unprecedented event was always likely to bring out the best and worst in people.  

Incredible isn't it, but money is suddenly no problem after all. There is indeed something called a money tree and we learn from the Chancellor that if £350 billion isn't enough, then 'it's whatever it takes'. But as the Guardian points out, it's going to take a lot more to fend off disaster and protect our whole economy. Did you notice Boris is beginning to look a little tired? It seems the reality of being top dog has finally hit home and he's having to put in a full day's work. I wonder how much use Dominic Cummings is nowadays? Was the fleeting irresponsible notion of 'herd immunity' his handiwork given past published views on eugenics?      

Everything in life is changing at a rapid rate and no one can be sure where it's taking us and for how long. In trying to get my head around things, I keep returning to the realisation that this global event is uniting the world in a way that politics alone never has and probably never could. The virus knows no political boundaries and every nation, democratic or totalitarian, has to take very similar action to protect its citizens, preserve its political structures and maintain economic activity. 

It's not just capitalism and globalisation under threat, but every shade of government. At this extraordinary moment in time when the whole world faces a shared threat, surely there's scope to re-order things in an unprecedented way for the better of us all and the planet?  This editorial in the FT at the weekend gave an early steer as to what is required and might be possible:-       

Now is the time for a global fiscal response to coronavirus

The first duty of governments is to safeguard their citizens’ survival and physical security. The second is to protect their material wellbeing. The coronavirus epidemic threatens both. Governments have been slow to rise to the challenge. 


It is now clear that the virus poses a potentially catastrophic public health risk, which can only be addressed by extraordinary distancing measures that inhibit large parts of economic activity. The task is to implement those measures — most western governments now are, if sometimes trailing the private sector’s initiatives — while minimising the economic harm. 

Money must not be a hindrance to health services’ ability to do everything possible to control the epidemic and treat the ill. To worry about public finances in such a moment is both perverse and counterproductive: spending too little is a greater threat to prosperity than spending too much. 

Beyond that, the economic damage is multiplied by the repercussions from the initial disruption. Workers who lose their jobs and businesses that run out of cash cut back on their purchases, making more workers and companies lose their livelihoods in turn.

Governments should spare no expense and waste no time to minimise such knock-on effects from temporary hits to cash flows and incomes. Generous loans, guarantees and income support programmes should be put in place. They must also be designed for sectors where self-employment, freelance, gig or project work is common, such as the creative industries. 

The drop in inflation expectations shows that the demand contraction is even more drastic than the supply disruption. Strong macroeconomic stimulus is warranted. Central banks have stepped up to the plate. The Bank of England’s textbook policy response combines general stimulus, targeted liquidity support, and an easing of regulatory requirements. The Federal Reserve pumped hundreds of billions of dollars into a stressed market. The European Central Bank fell short of a rate cut, but crafted a strong package of bond purchases and incentives for banks to uphold their business lending. 

That package was, however, badly undermined when ECB president Christine Lagarde seemed to dismiss the need to contain the sort of disparity in governments’ borrowing costs that almost brought the euro down in 2011-12. She later clarified but the damage was done: Italian yields soared. The ECB must now state it would welcome a eurozone rescue programme for Italy with few strings attached, so as to activate the emergency bond-buying programme set up in the last crisis — and stand ready to buy Italian bonds unilaterally if markets derail Rome’s spending on coronavirus. 

Until the ECB shows it has Italy’s back, that role falls to EU partners. The signs are positive. Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission president, has put EU budget money on the table and been vocal that Italy and others should spend as much as they need on the health crisis. Even Berlin has expressed similar views. The commission has promised not to let fiscal and competition rules get in the way, and should now ask member states to activate a general escape clause. 

But not all governments have shown the required determination. The US has still to put in place a proper public health response, let alone a sufficient fiscal programme. There is nothing like the global economic co-ordination achieved in 2008-9, though the need for co-ordinated stimulus is just as great. When EU finance ministers meet this week, they should not waste their chance to provide it.

--oo00oo--

It strikes me that we have the opportunity to actually do something about tax havens and agree a way to remove vast wealth from the likes of the Bransons of this world, or Russian oligarchs and Chinese billionaires. Maybe we could all agree a way of getting the likes of Amazon, Google, Facebook and Uber to pay any f*cking tax? With the world's aircraft fleet virtually grounded and travel everywhere reduced, suddenly discussions regarding that other worldwide threat of climate change could take a whole different trajectory?

--oo00oo--

With news that jury trials likely to last more than three days are being suspended, I suspect the Human Rights Blog is going to be worth following over the coming days and here's a taster, including how the Coronavirus has got the Prime Minister of Israel out of a spot of bother:-  

Quarantine measures are not the only legal sphere in which the impact of Covid-19 is being felt. The Guardian reported that cleaners at a hospital in Lewisham walked out over pay, however tensions were heightened because of the risk posed by the disease. Employers have a responsibility to protect employees under health and safety legislation from dangers in respect of the work they do, yet personal protective equipment in hospitals is in short supply. The outbreak raises the question of what steps are reasonable for employers to take to protect their workers. S 100(1)(d) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 establishes that where an employee is dismissed for leaving work or refusing to return in circumstances where the employee reasonably believed there to be a serious and imminent danger, it will constitute unfair dismissal. Will a doctor, or a nurse, be in breach of their contract if they refuse to work? Is a higher standard expected of those individuals than say, a hospital cleaner, or a waiter in a restaurant?

It may be that ultimately, whilst employment law confers protection on such individuals, their own professional regulators do not. It is not hard to imagine the General Medical or Nursing and Midwifery Councils holding their members to a higher standard than that required by their employment contracts, and deeming those who have fallen below it to have brought the profession into disrepute. Many members of the public might consider such an approach to be quite reasonable. Yet could such an analysis extend to other professions with similar regulators? Would a teacher who felt keeping schools open in an epidemic was unreasonable and refused to teach be subject to disciplinary proceedings? Or a lawyer who refused to attend a public hearing?

In particular, the impact on criminal justice may be significant. Israel has already suspended criminal trials, which is presumably convenient given the Prime Minister was due to attend one tomorrow on charges of fraud, breach of trust and bribery. Similarly, the Australian state of Victoria has suspended all jury trials due to the risk of transmission during the process of empanelling jurors. Should the virus begin to spread in British jails, the head of the Prison Officer’s Association has stated that prisoners may need to be released early.

How the UK’s already stretched criminal justice system will accommodate this in the context of widespread anticipated absences due to illness amongst court staff, judges and lawyers remains to be seen. If trials are delayed, concerns must exist around custody time limits and prolonged periods of detention without charge. Similarly, how can an individual’s right to justice delivered at a public hearing under the ECHR be maintained at a time when the rest of society is taking measures to prevent the movement and mixing of individuals?

As with speculation concerning the public health response, a lot of this is conjecture. The outbreak may worsen, or it may settle down. What seems likely however is that the next few months will bring numerous challenges, and the fleet footed responses required will likely require a radical departure from previous norms.

Tuesday, 17 March 2020

Latest From Napo 202

"On another front. What's happening about the increment next month? Unison are saying that the Treasury are refusing to fund it as predicted by me and many others when the pay deal was announced. NAPO are saying it's a payroll administrative issue and will be resolved. Apparently payroll can't handle giving everyone a rise. I know SSCL are shit but really? Has that clown Lawrence sold us down the river again? I fervently hope not but my cynisim is based on bitter experience."
JTU11-20 March 2020 

NPS CAN’T PAY YOUR 2020 INCREMENT ON TIME 

The NPS has confirmed today that it will not be able to pay your 2020 increment on time in April. This is seriously bad news. Napo, UNISON and GMB/SCOOP were made aware of this potential problem earlier this year. We tried to head it off by: 
  • Lobbying Sonia Flynn, Chief Probation Officer NPS, and Amy Rees, Director General for Probation HMPPS 
  • Meeting with the Prisons and Probation Minister Lucy Frazer on 4 February after writing to her to raise our grave concerns over the possible delay in your pay 
  • Drafting our 2020 pay claim to emphasize the need for NPS to pay the 2020 pay increment on time Despite these efforts, it is extremely worrying that the NPS has failed to get the necessary sign off from the Treasury to pay you your increment on time this year. 
WHY THE NPS SHOULD PAY UP ON TIME 

There are a number of compelling reasons why the NPS should pay your increment on time:

1. When members voted to accept the 2018 two year pay modernisation offer, there was a commitment in the offer from the NPS to pay the 2020 increment on time. The offer set out: 
‘On 1 April 2020 eligible NPS staff below the maximum that have met the required timeframes to progress will … progress by one pay point in their revised pay band with no link to the CBPPF (competency based framework)’ 

2. The NPS told the unions that it had costed the increments going forward from the end of the two year pay deal, and that these were factored into their discussions with the Treasury. 

3. The recently published HMIP report into its ‘Inspection of NPS Central Functions’ (January 2020) paints a sorry picture of the impact of Transforming Rehabilitation on the NPS workforce. The criticisms of the Inspectorate reflect very badly on the way in which the NPS has been managed over the last 5 years. The last thing that the NPS needed was to fail to pay staff their increments on time. 

TIME FOR INVESTMENT IN THE NPS WORKFORCE 

You come to work for the NPS every day. You deliver your best in the most trying circumstances possible. You and your colleagues are not to blame for the state in which the NPS now finds itself. 

The unions have made direct representations to the Director General for Probation and to the Prisons and Probation Minister that the action plan set out for NPS in the recent HMIP report will require serious and sustained funding over the course of the next Comprehensive Spending Review. 

The unions have emphasized that this funding must include significant investment in the NPS workforce and its pay and conditions. Instead we have a situation which feels like NPS employees are continuing to pay the cost of the failure of Transforming Rehabilitation. 

The unions have made it clear to the NPS and to HMPPS that the target operating model for the new ‘Unified Probation Model’, following the transfer of CRC staff into the NPS next year, will not succeed unless there is proper investment in the workforce. This means better pay, as well as more staff, lower workloads and office refurbishment. 

With today’s announcement, the NPS has made the worst possible start to this. The unions will continue to press for NPS to step up to its responsibilities. Our members deserve better! 

Next steps 

As members would expect we have already made high level representations and are demanding an early opportunity to discuss the situation. We absolutely understand that this news will cause anger and frustration among members, and the unions will keep you up to date with more news as and when it becomes available.

--oo00oo--
"No real discussion or meaningful advice from the CRCs, the NPS, or the ministry - should we suspend groups? Office appointments? Any and all face to face contact? Enforcement? After all are we really going to breach or recall people for following government advice?... No doubt there will be no clear guidance any time soon so I guess it's going to be up to us. I wonder who'll be first to say 'fuck this - they may not care about any of our safety but I do' and lead the first walk out?" 
A casual glance at the 'secret' Facebook group, especially over the last few hours, confirms there is widespread concern and alarm over the lack of any firm direction from NPS or MoJ regarding safety of those staff still engaged in direct contact with clients. Groupwork and UPW has not been cancelled, there appears to be a widespread absence of hand sanitising products and staff with serious underlying health conditions are getting desperate for guidance. Those working within the prison estate apparently have no access to laptops so home working does not look possible. The silence from management, and to be frank Napo, is beginning to cause serious unrest in the ranks.

Monday, 16 March 2020

Chickens Coming Home to Roost

It's becoming fairly obvious that the world is now a very different place as every nation, institution and living person has to come to terms with the long-overdue pandemic that recognises no man-made borders. One minute we thought the greatest threat was man-made climate change, still inexplicably deniable by some, but coronavirus changes that in the short term and in a bizarre and novel way becomes something that uniquely unites mankind. 

I don't know about others, but I'm finding it hard to feel the same about much else at the present time and a blog on some esoteric aspect of human endevour on a tiny bit of a huge planet seems so - well, pointless. Like everything else at the moment, I don't know what's going to happen or how I'm going to feel, but this piece in the Times today serves to highlight how this world-wide emergency is certainly going to shine a very harsh light on our domestic politics and policies over the last few years. I have an overwhelming sense that an awful lot of chickens are going to come home to roost in the coming months. 

Chief constable weeps under strain of severe budget cuts

A chief constable broke down and wept as he described the weight of responsibility of running a force struggling to keep the public safe amid severe budget cuts.

Gareth Morgan, the head of Staffordshire police, said that he had found it hard to decide how to best serve the public with diminishing resources. A police officer with 32 years of service, he told the BBC: “We’ve had difficult choices to make about where you prioritise the limited resources that you’ve got.

“My job is to try and balance those competing needs. With what I’ve got, where can I get the best return to keep the public as safe as I can? And that’s a continual challenge and I feel that very powerfully with the staff.” He then said, “I need a minute”, before bowing his head and wiping away tears.

Mr Morgan, 53, continued: “And it is hard when you’re trying to get that balance right. It does weigh heavily on you in terms of ‘was that the right choice? Is this the right direction to go in?’ But when I’m not here, and people are off doing this stuff, 24/7, looking after people, and I live here, I’m part of the community, they’re doing it on our behalf, and I feel I’m responsible.”

According to the Staffordshire Police Federation, which represents rank and file officers, the force has seen a drop of 30 per cent in their workforce over the past ten years, from 2,400 to 1,670, while grappling with rising and increasingly complex caseloads.

Sudesh Amman, the terrorist who launched a knife attack in Streatham, London in February, was from the area, as were his former associates. Staffordshire has also experienced a growth in serious organised violence linked to “county lines” — drugs transported from cities into provincial towns — and cyber-enabled offences.

Mr Morgan is on secondment to the College of Policing at present. He spoke to the broadcaster for a new series, Cops Like Us, which is scheduled to begin tomorrow on BBC Two.

About a year ago Mr Morgan attracted controversy for wrongly sacking a PC for drink-driving when she drove 500 yards down a country road to flee an abusive partner as he slept. Speaking to The Times, he explained: “Not every day is total bedlam, but there are many days where it’s hard and it takes its toll emotionally and physically. You’re constantly weighing up, ‘is this right for the public? And how will it be for the staff?’

“At times we’ve been stretched, and we’re not always able to do the job we want to do for the public.” He said that his views were largely shared among other chief constables.

Mr Morgan, a father of two who lives in north Staffordshire, said that he had shifted a number of officers from a response role into neighbourhood policing and investigations in an attempt to prevent crimes from happening rather than only reacting to them.

“Some of those decisions have been tough,” he said. “It takes its toll on me. I think we should be open about taking difficult decisions and their effects.”

Last year Boris Johnson announced that police forces would receive 20,000 extra officers.

Mr Morgan said that while that was “very welcome . . . those increases don’t come anywhere near the reductions [we had before austerity] and it’ll take us a long time to get back to where we were.”

--oo00oo--

Cops Like Us

Series 1 Episode 1 of 3

Following officers from Staffordshire’s overstretched police force as they talk candidly about the frustrations of being on the beat in one of the UK’s most deprived cities - Stoke-on-Trent. In recent years, Staffordshire police have lost more than a quarter of their officers due to budget cuts. Filmed over six months, this series follows emergency response teams trying to combat a backlog of cases and a rise in gang culture, hate crime and domestic violence. Searingly honest interviews from the chief constable and his team reveal how they manage their limited resources and how they feel about the decisions they have to make.

The city of Stoke-on-Trent is made up of six small towns. It is known as ‘the potteries’ – a nod towards the world-famous pottery manufacture that once thrived there. Pottery made in Stoke-on-Trent was once shipped all over the world for use in the finest restaurants. But in the 1980s, much of the manufacturing closed down, many pot banks were shut and workers laid off. Although the employment rate in Stoke is now on the rise, it is a city still struggling with the loss of its iconic industry.

In recent years, Stoke City Council has reduced mental health and welfare services. More and more people are finding themselves in crisis – and ultimately at the end of 999 calls to the police. The police officers have also seen the numbers of suicide attempts they attend rise. It used to be a handful a year - now, it is a regular occurrence.

Staffordshire Police were not immune to the UK-wide cuts, and they have lost 594 response officers. Some police stations have been sold off, and many are now closed to the public. The number of support staff, from administration workers to cleaners, has also been reduced. But the Staffordshire Police officers are a resilient bunch – and despite the challenging circumstances, they work hard to keep the population safe in the face of a variety of crimes. No two 999 calls are ever the same, and it takes grit and a sense of humour to police the community.

The officers also have to deal with both the immediate impact and after-effects of crime in the areas they serve. After a stabbing in the suburb of Norton, one of the biggest jobs the police and local councillors face is reassuring the nervous community back to a sense of normality.

With reduced numbers the new norm, Staffordshire Police are looking to use their limited resources in ever more efficient ways. They are planning on moving the response team out of their run-down base at Hanley Police station and into the fire station across the road – fully aware that they will need to change their habits when they move into the immaculately-kept fire station.

Stoke-on-Trent, and the police force who serve it, is in a time of transition. This series explores the highs and lows of working in one of the most demanding and challenging jobs in the UK.

Saturday, 14 March 2020

Prisons and Coronavirus

There has been a rumour for days that coronavirus has already entered the prison estate and this from a lawyer seen on Twitter at 5.00pm yesterday would seem to lend it some credence:- 
"Went to see client in cells today. He refused to come out, passed me a note: cellmate has corona, I don't want to infect you. Cell staff confirmed prison said he has suspected corona or TB. Why was he put in a van and brought to court to spread it?!"
This from the Independent earlier in the week highlighted concerns:-
  
Coronavirus ‘would spread like wildfire’ if outbreak hit UK prisons, experts warn

As coronavirus takes hold across the UK, it is looking increasingly likely that many of us will be forced into some degree of self-isolation. With England’s deputy chief medical officer admitting the UK will see “many thousands of people” contract the disease, trying to avoid crowded spaces and have limited contact with other people sounds like a good idea.

This isn't an option in prisons, where thousands of inmates exist in cells accommodating more people than they are designed to hold. For prisoners and staff alike, the outbreak poses a bigger threat than to those in the community. Some jails suffer from conditions that could create a “perfect storm” for spreading disease - infamously poor hygiene, constant movement of prisoners in and out and notoriously cramped conditions.

The Howard League for Penal Reform, a leading prisons charity, has written to the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) demanding a statement on precautions being taken to protect people in prison, and thereby the wider population, from coronavirus – warning that “unhygienic” prisons where even soap is frequently impossible to obtain – could be a “centre for spreading the virus into the community”.

“I am surprised that there appears to have been no statement from the MoJ as to the precautions being taken,” states the letter, signed by chief executive Frances Crook. Ms Crook wrote that infectious diseases “flourish” in conditions of overcrowding, poor ventilation, filth and in populations with compromised health. She added: “Should anyone enter a prison already infected with coronavirus it would spread and multiply like wildfire inside the establishment and in the community.”

Poor hygiene in jails, where many inmates are unable to shower once a day or wash their hands with soap, is a considerable concern for attempts to prevent spread of the disease, but prisons face a further problem in providing adequate treatment if people do show symptoms.

A recent report by the Nuffield Trust think tank showed prisoners in Britain frequently had hospital appointments cancelled and received less healthcare than the general public, with as many as four in 10 hospital appointments made for a prisoner cancelled or missed in 2017-18 – largely due to a lack of prison staff available to transport and guard prisoners while at hospital. If people in jail begin to show symptoms, there are questions about how they will access the necessary healthcare.

“Healthcare in prisons is often far worse than it is in the community, and prisoners can struggle to attend hospital appointments due to staffing shortages," said Aidan Shilson-Thomas, criminal justice researcher at the Reform think tank, describing the threat of coronavirus in prisons as a "perfect storm". He added: "With a growing number of older prisoners and many having underlying health conditions, it is vital that resources are made available so prisons can offer the same quality of care that members of the public would receive.”

Aside from low hygiene and below-par health facilities, campaigners warn that already low staffing levels in jails – with the total cumulative length of service among prison officers having plummeted by a quarter since 2010 – could cause further problems.

A secret Ministry of Justice blueprint is reported to lay out plans for thousands of low-risk prisoners to be released early if the coronavirus outbreak creates a shortage of staff in jails. According to the Sunday Times, ministers don't support the plans, but concerns are growing that a dwindling prison workforce would be unable to provide basic necessities, such as food and security, for the UK’s 84,000 prisoners.

Another measure is to reduce movement in and out of jails by banning family visits, but the consequences of such a move have proven devastating elsewhere. In Italy, at least six prisoners died on Sunday, reportedly after overdosing on methadone during a protest against a ban on family visits, aimed at restricting the spread of coronavirus. Riots are said to have broken out in 27 Italian prisons after all visits were suspended and inmates were told they could only speak to visitors on the phone or via Skype.

“Ministers and governors are stuck between a rock and a hard place,” said Mr Shilson-Thomas on the UK prison response. “With a lot of people coming and going from some prisons it seems very likely that the virus will enter prisons unless very strict measures are adopted for all visitors and new arrivals. But limiting prisoners' social time and family visits would be very disruptive.”

Regardless of whether visits are banned, self-isolating prisoners will likely be near-impossible in most overcrowded establishments, with many inmates living two-to-a-cell already.

A prison service spokesperson said: “We have robust contingency plans in place based on the latest advice from Public Health England. Basic hygiene is a key part of tackling coronavirus. Handwashing facilities are available in all prisons and we have worked closely with suppliers to ensure adequate supply of soap and cleaning materials. We have the ability to deploy staff flexibly and will prioritise the safety of officers, prisoners and visitors while ensuring minimal possible disruption to normal regimes.” 

--oo00oo--

The demanded MoJ statement was quickly forthcoming on Thursday:-

Coronavirus (COVID-19) prison preparedness: Lucy Frazer statement

Lucy Frazer said:

"The Government is doing everything it can to combat the COVID-19 outbreak, based on the very latest scientific and medical advice. This includes in our prisons, where we are working closely with Public Health England, the NHS and the Department of Health and Social Care to manage the challenges we face.

The safety and wellbeing of staff, prisoners and visitors is paramount and at the heart of our approach.

Prisons have existing, well-developed policies and procedures in place to manage outbreaks of infectious diseases. This means prisons are well prepared to take immediate action whenever cases or suspected cases are identified, including isolating individuals where necessary.

Basic hygiene is a key part of tackling the virus and good practice is being promoted on posters throughout the estate. Handwashing facilities are available to all prisoners – not just in cells but other shared areas such as education blocks and kitchens. Staff and visitors also have access to handwashing facilities and we have worked closely with suppliers to ensure adequate supply of soap and cleaning materials.

We understand that prisoners and their loved ones might be concerned about the situation. But we can assure them that we will continue to operate normal regimes, with the minimum disruption, for as long as we can. This will include visits to prisoners but, in line with Public Health advice for the general public, we urge any friend or family member not to come to a prison for visit if they have any symptoms associated with COVID-19 - a fever or new, persistent cough. We are also looking into ways to keep prisoners in close contact with their families in all eventualities, and will share further information as and when necessary.

We have procedures agreed with our public health colleagues for protecting staff in the workplace but, like any member of the community, some prison staff may need to self-isolate in line with public health advice, or may become infected. We are taking steps to boost staff availability and so enable us to look after prisoners properly and minimise the impacts on prison regimes of staff absences.

There is a huge amount of work taking place, and I want to thank all those who have been striving tirelessly to make sure we are ready to do all we can to respond over the coming weeks."

--oo00oo--

From BBC website:-

Coranavirus: Emergency plan for prisons in England and Wales

The government is drawing up emergency plans to avoid disruption in England's prisons, with unions saying prison officers face "unprecedented" challenges. Prison staff will be offered bonuses to cover shortages - and staff could be redeployed to cover front line services. A number of inmates died during unrest at several Italian prisons last week after visits were suspended.

The Prison Officers Association has compared conditions in England's prisons to those found on cruise ships and the Prison Governors Association has said cases of the virus are inevitable. BBC News has seen advice issued to prisons, which says inmates who had contact with a known coronavirus patient should be isolated in single accommodation.

It is understood plans being drawn in up in Whitehall involve communicating regularly with inmates, making sure they can contact their families and providing extra materials - like books and magazines - to those isolating to try to avoid boredom. The possibility of designating other buildings as prisons to cope with pressures has not been ruled out.

Senior figures do not believe large numbers of prisoners will have to be released to cope with any strain. There is, however, significant concern about the impact on older prisoners with underlying health issues. Ministers are thought to have not ruled out releasing vulnerable inmates most at risk, but the instinct in government is that they should serve their sentences.

Friday, 13 March 2020

Latest From Napo 201

Most of the latest Napo mailout was concerned with Coronavirus matters, apart from this:-

SEETEC Pay Deal - Napo negotiators raise the stakes 


Last week, members of the three Probation Unions voted to accept a significantly important pay offer from Seetec, the owner of the Kent Surrey and Sussex CRC which incorporates the former CRC areas of Wales, Bristol, Gloucester, Somerset and Wiltshire, and Devon Dorset and Cornwall. 

The pay deal represents a major breakthrough in Napo’s campaign to see parity of pay between our members working in the NPS and those employed by a CRC. The offer that was accepted by members sees the realignment of all salary bands to the 2019 NPS Pay Banding. Where this results in less than a 3% increase for an employee, Seetec will apply an unconsolidated payment for the percentage differential. The resulting pay increases will be included in the April pay run. Acceptance of this offer brings an end to the current pay dispute. 

Significance of the deal 

This move by SEETEC is a clear statement of intent about their future aspirations in terms of securing new Probation Provider contracts with the MoJ from June next year. Napo National Officials and our local reps from the above areas are commended for the way in which they engaged with Seetec and for presenting powerful arguments about the need to invest in staff if this employer wishes to stand any chance of securing new contractual arrangements going forward.

While Napo remains implacably opposed to the re-marketisation of Intervention and Programme services, it is our job to engage with all employers to try and secure the best that we can on behalf of our members. The impact of this pay deal has already seen a number of staff from neighbouring CRC’s take up employment opportunities with Seetec, which sends a strong signal to other CRC owners that’s its time they raised their game too. 


Look out for more news on CRC pay once current negotiations in DTV CRC and Sodexo are concluded. It is expected that pay claims to the NPS and other CRC’s will be submitted by the unions very soon. 

Siobhan Foreman For Napo Officer Group
Ian Lawrence General Secretary 

11th March 2020

Thursday, 12 March 2020

An Old Chestnut

It's interesting to see that once again we've returned to that very old chestnut of what the hell do we call people required to have involvement with the probation service? Those of us with considerable experience under our belt have never had an issue with 'client', unlike those in authority above us of course. We've seen 'cases' come and go, tried 'service user', dabbled with 'offender' or possibly even 'former offender', but in utterly typical civil service style it looks like settling on “person subject to probation services”. This from Inside Time:-

Former prisoners no longer “Offenders”

People on probation are no longer to be called “offenders”. Probation chiefs said they wanted to “reset the language” and use a term that would “resonate” with those under supervision.

Instead of being known as an offender, anyone under supervision will be referred to as a “person subject to probation services”. The change reflects the fact that people on probation are expected to have stopped committing crimes. It will affect ex-prisoners on licence and people given community sentences for low-level crimes.

As part of the reform, the term “Offender Manager” will be replaced with “Probation Practitioner”, while “Offender Management” will become “Sentence Management”.

HM Prison and Probation Service announced the new terminology as part of a blueprint for the future of probation, published in March. The report, called “A Draft Target Operating Model for the Future of Probation Services in England and Wales”, sets out how the Government will reverse its failed part-privatisation and reunite probation as a single national service.

It states: “We are using this document as an opportunity to reset some of the language in the probation system so that we can build an inclusive culture which staff from both Community Rehabilitation Companies and the National Probation Service can relate to; utilising terminology that resonates with stakeholders, and best reflects the intentions behind the new model and the benefits that we are seeking to achieve.

“In describing the new probation system, this document will, as far as possible, use individual/individual subject to probation services/person, Probation Practitioner and Sentence Management to denote the formerly-used terms Offender, Offender Manager/Responsible Officer and Offender Management.”

The changes only affect probation, not prisons, so the Offender Management in Custody programme will keep its name.

--oo00oo--

I'm going to use this as an excuse to revisit something from 27th October 2013:-

What About Clients?

I suspect there's a danger in all this TR omnishambles to sometimes forget how things are for our clients. By the way I use the description deliberately and regular readers will appreciate I remain rather old-fashioned with regard to such matters, for instance having never abandoned the title probation officer in favour of 'offender manager'.

On this topic, it amused me greatly to read a twitter exchange recently with a manager castigating someone for referring to a 'hostel', rather than 'Approved Premises'. They were told in no uncertain terms that "the Salvation Army does hostels - we do Approved Premises!" It's all so arcane and pointless - as the expression goes, 'if it walks like a duck; quacks like a duck, it probably is a duck', in my humble opinion.

Anyway, I digress. There is absolutely no getting away from the fact that life for most of our clients has become considerably more difficult during this period of austerity. They are suffering the triple whammy of benefit cuts, rising prices for food and utilities and a stagnating employment market. Whether it's the bedroom tax, Atos health assessments, Job Centre harassment or crap minimum wage jobs, it's basically a shit situation and getting worse all the time for this group.

Now I know that this is true for lots of people, but for many of our clients this all comes on top of probably an unhappy and troubled childhood, failure by state education, poor health, an addiction to either drink or drugs and a criminal record. Despite what might be said to the contrary, the climate has become ever less tolerant for our clients, a situation encouraged by many of our politicians wishing to garner votes by pandering to the populist notion of the distinction between the deserving and undeserving within society.

Have you any idea how difficult it is for a person coming out of prison with literacy and numeracy problems and only the £46 made famous by Chris Grayling and you can't sign on for benefits until you've provided a CV at the Job Centre? Claims have to be made online, not in person any more and appointments arranged via phone when you haven't got one. After several weeks living on thin air and you are lucky enough to have got your benefits sorted, it can only be paid via a bank account you haven't got and often proves difficult to get. And the payments are moving from fortnightly to monthly, a move almost deliberately designed to make it impossible for our clients to budget.

If you had a drink or drug problem and used to get Sickness Benefit, that's no longer available due to the Atos work assessment tests and the Job Centre or Work Programme provider will want to see evidence of jobs applied for on a regular basis, or daily attendance will be required. Fail any more than a couple of appointments due to certain chaotic aspects of your life, learning disability or mental health problems and your benefit will be 'sanctioned', ultimately for periods up to 3 years.

Despite all the rhetoric and supposed aspirations contained in the TR omnishambles, I think most people can readily see how the system of 'welfare reforms' is creating a perfect environment whereby rehabilitation is made as difficult as possible and how many clients will simply give up and resign themselves to a return to prison. Others are sadly going to take more drastic action and the arrival of the Samaritans in Job Centres will eventually see them appearing in probation offices I fear.

It's precisely this troubled group within society that the Probation Service was set up to deal with over 100 years ago. It's never been easy, but all those outfits who are at this moment considering whether to bid for our work or not, you must understand that the government is making the task that much more difficult year on year. The task of encouraging a person to change their thinking and behaviour is hardly being assisted by current government policies bearing down most heavily on those most disadvantaged within society.

The fact that, despite this, the probation service has been able to demonstrate reductions in reoffending rates for those under our supervision in recent years is nothing short of amazing and a testimony to our skill, dedication and resourcefulness. I refuse to accept that putting the work out to tender by the lowest bidder will help the situation one jot. Life for our clientele is about to get a whole lot worse and potential bidders hoping to gain from a Payment by Results contract had better understand this. 'Transforming Rehabilitation' it will not be. Scandalously, I hear the 'project' has cost £60 million already.

Despite all the odds outlined, even those clients that obtain work are facing impossible challenges and it's not encouraging news from the Social Mobility and Child Poverty Commission as reported here:-

For millions of families, work no longer pays enough to provide a route out of poverty, the government's social mobility tsar is expected to warn. A report headed up by one-time Labour minister Alan Milburn will highlight stagnating incomes and rising prices. He is due to call on employers to do more to support low-paid families earning less than a living wage.
Real-terms incomes have stagnated since 2003 but prices are continuing to rise, the commission will point out, meaning employment may not enable a low-income family to escape poverty. The report is likely to suggest that, in the current economic climate, it is unrealistic to expect the government to continue topping up low pay using working tax credits. It is thought the commission may argue that employers need to do more - paying higher minimum wages and offering better training and career development.

Wednesday, 11 March 2020

NPS and Disability

"On a different note I'd urge anyone with a disability who works for HMPPS NPS to watch the Panorama documentary on DWP. It virtually mirrors issues faced in our role for many. That is government departments or agencies not following legislation and representing thenselves as disability confident when how they operate is anything but. Apologies Jim but such an important issue it will get noticed if on your blog and colleagues facing such problems may get comfort in knowing they are not alone in doing so."

The Million Pound Disability Payout

The Department for Work and Pensions is meant to help disabled people get back into work. In this programme, reporter Richard Butchins discovers that it has lost more employment tribunals for disability discrimination than any other employer in Britain. He investigates why the DWP has paid its own employees nearly a million pounds of public money in both tribunal pay-outs and out-of-court settlements.


From the BBC website:-

DWP says it is 'shocked' by its own disability tribunal record

The Department for Work and Pensions has lost more employment tribunals for disability discrimination than any other employer in Britain since 2016. BBC Panorama found the DWP lost 17 of 134 claims of discrimination against its own disabled workers from 2016-19. And it paid out at least £950,000 in both tribunal payments and out-of-court settlements in that time.

The DWP said it was "shocked" by the data but was reviewing its processes to ensure all staff were treated fairly. It is the government department that is responsible for supporting people with disabilities into employment. Of its 80,000 members of staff, 11,000 identify as disabled.

Panorama analysed the publicly available data on the online Employment Tribunal decisions database up until December 2019. It reveals that the DWP had more cases in total and more cases which it lost than any other employer. A comparison with the five employers who had the largest number of disability discrimination cases also showed that the DWP had more cases and more tribunal defeats in proportion to its total number of employees.

Karen Jackson, a leading disability discrimination lawyer, said: "There is a horrible irony that the organisation that is designed to look after the more vulnerable members of our society is constantly falling foul of the Equality Act around disability. To me, that can only suggest that there is something quite fundamentally, systemically wrong within the culture of the organisation."

Barrie Caulcutt, 57, was awarded £26,000 after he took the DWP to an employment tribunal and a judge ruled he had been discriminated against because of his disability. He worked in the finance department at the DWP for 30 years and suffers from a serious panic and anxiety disorder that can trigger life-threatening asthma attacks. But he was not able to manage his condition after being moved into a different job role.

"I basically told them I couldn't do the job I was doing, because of my disabilities. I provided evidence from my GP," Mr Caulcutt said. "Their own occupational health service told them that unless they moved me from the environment I was working in, it would be of detriment to my health."

As part of his new role, Mr Caulcutt was told to attend a training session in a small room. He said said he could not attend because he suffered from panic attacks but was told he would be disciplined if he failed to show up. Mr Caulcutt said that during the course he had an "overwhelming feeling" that he had to leave the room.

"I just collapsed to the floor. I realised then that it was an asthma attack. I'm not a religious person, but I was praying. I was praying. Please, God, don't make me die. Don't make me die now," he said. "And the next thing I was in the back of an ambulance and they were rushing me to hospital." Despite knowing Mr Caulcutt had been admitted to hospital, the next day his managers called him to ask where he was. During the tribunal, the judge described his treatment as "wholly inexcusable".

The DWP has lost 12.5% percent of its employment tribunal cases for disability between 2016 and 2019. On average over this period 3% of disability discrimination claims were lost by employers. One the biggest payouts made by the DWP for disability discrimination was awarded to former benefits worker, Charlotte. Charlotte suffers from serious health problems, including depression, and was sacked by the DWP for taking too much sick leave. She said her colleagues were often "dismissive" and "quite nasty" when discussing state benefits claimants and she felt they had the same attitude towards her.

"I think that me being disabled, I kind of felt like if I had time off, people thought I was lying or faking it or I wasn't really ill, and that was kind of a culture," she said. At Charlotte's employment tribunal, the judge found she had been unfairly dismissed and discriminated against by the DWP.

From 2016 to 2019 the DWP paid out at least £953,315 to DWP employees with disabilities as a result of losing employment tribunals, or because they settled out of court. Freedom of Information requests reveal that between April 2017 and June 2019 the department settled 45 claims out of court, at a cost of £713,000. The remaining £240,000 was awarded to people who had won their employment tribunals.

A spokesperson for the Department for Work and Pensions said: "We are shocked that, when presented in this way, the data shows us in this light." The department said it ensured staff had formal and informal routes to raise any concerns and that cases brought against it came from fewer than 2% of staff with disabilities - although it acknowledged the figure was "still too high".

"Fair and respectful treatment is a right and we do not tolerate discrimination in any form," the spokesperson said. The DWP said it had improved how it managed absence and resolved complaints, as well as introducting 1,600 mental health first aiders, adding: "We know there is always more we can do. We have instigated a review of our processes and actions following tribunal cases, to ensure all our employees are treated fairly and with respect."

--oo00oo--

Seen on Facebook last November:-

Just something for those staff currently working in CRCs in particular to be aware of. Prior to the sifting process in TR1 employers became quite interested in identifying disabled staff and also ensuring that HR records contained accurate equalities and diversity data. We were told this would help us in the future so most of us complied in order to improve the data captured believing this was a good thing. Discrimination was always denied at the time but there were many people who for instance happened to be disabled but were sifted into an organisation they did not choose and who they subsequently discovered was not particularly interested in supporting them.

Apparently coincidentally many HR records were lost by some probation Trusts and or organisations that staff were transferred to and have never been subsequently been found.

Obviously you would hope that staff were not sifted according to their status as AT users etc however there were definitely suspicions at the time that this was a factor despite many statements that protected characteristics would be respected and reasonable adjustments made for those requiring them.

Even at this early stage I have had some reports that some organisations may want to cherry pick their staff that may lead to discrimination against those staff they may view as less productive or a good fit with their future plans. For many this could eventually result in being paid less and having less job security.

I would like every employer involved in TR2 to state publicly that they will not involve themselves in any discriminatory practice involving the sorting of staff according to arbitrary categorisation of status as desirable or undesirable to be employed in their organisation such as the fact that they are disabled or in need of assistive technology. I have heard no mention of this so far but clearly a lot of staff who remain employed are nervous that they will once again face difficulties.

All probation staff whoever they work or compelled to work for due to circumstances beyond their control deserve to be paid and treated fairly and equally. If you find any evidence of this kind of thing then please let your union rep know, Not a member of a union? Join now.