Friday, 5 July 2019

Gauke's Swan Song

I notice that David Gauke has not only anticipated the ending of his tenure at the MoJ, he's actively encouraging it. This from the Guardian:-

Populist politicians are poisoning Britain

The justice secretary, David Gauke, has launched an impassioned attack on “populist politicians” who deceive the public by telling them what they think they want to hear. In a speech to the annual judges’ dinner in the City of London on Wednesday, Gauke, a forthright opponent of a no-deal Brexit, anticipated his imminent removal from office and contrasted the fact-finding diligence of the judiciary with his political colleagues who “pour poison into our national conversation”.

Adopting gallows humour, the Conservative MP who has survived no-confidence votes in his south-west Hertfordshire constituency, began by telling his legal audience that he was “a veteran” compared with recent justice secretaries, who have not lasted long in the job.

“Indeed, I am the first lord chancellor in a while to have served long enough to deliver two of these speeches,” Gauke said at the Mansion House dinner. “It is true that my predecessor but two, Michael Gove, made it to his second speech but he left the government one week later [in July 2016] when a new prime minister, with whom he did not see eye to eye [Theresa May], took office. How times have changed. I might only have three weeks.”

In remarks that will be viewed as a veiled attack on the Conservative leadership frontrunner Boris Johnson, the justice secretary said: “There is no doubt in my mind that the forces of populism are much stronger in this country and internationally than has been the case for some time.

“A willingness by politicians to say what they think the public want to hear, and a willingness by large parts of the public to believe what they are told by populist politicians, has led to a deterioration in our public discourse. This has contributed to a growing distrust of our institutions – whether that be parliament, the civil service, the mainstream media or the judiciary.”

A dangerous gulf is emerging, he said, between the people and the institutions that serve them. Such institutions – including the legal system and the judiciary – provide the “kind of confidence and predictability that underpins our success as a society”.

Gauke continued: “Rather than recognising the challenges of a fast-changing society require sometimes complex responses, that we live in a world of trade-offs, that easy answers are usually false answers, we have seen the rise of the simplifiers. Those grappling with complex problems are not viewed as public servants but as engaged in a conspiracy to seek to frustrate the will of the public. They are ‘enemies of the people’.”

Gauke’s jibe refers to the Daily Mail headline in 2016 attacking the judges who found in favour of only parliament having the power to trigger article 50 and the UK’s departure from the EU. He explained: “In deploying this sort of language, we go to war with truth. We pour poison into our national conversation. But language really matters in our discourse.

“Our judiciary has a reputation for intellectual rigour, careful consideration of the arguments, and a serious-minded determination to each decision based on what is right and not necessarily what is superficially popular. I am not sure that all politicians have the same reputation.”

Politics, the justice secretary said, should be about finding and embracing practical solutions to society’s problems “not as we imagine or represent it to be. We must face facts. I have made that my guiding principle in office.”

--oo00oo--

That speech in full:-
My Lord Mayor, Lord Chief Justice, ladies and gentlemen.

I would like to begin by thanking you, Lord Mayor, for your hospitality and the invitation to address such a distinguished group of colleagues tonight. When I spoke at this event last year, I did so as a relatively new Lord Chancellor… though by contrast with my immediate predecessors, I am now something of a veteran!

Indeed, I am the first Lord Chancellor in a while to have served long enough to deliver two of these speeches. It is true that my predecessor but two, Michael Gove, made it to his second speech but he left the Government one week later when a new Prime Minister, with whom he did not see eye to eye, took office. How times have changed. I might only have three weeks.

Last year I talked about the importance of the Rule of Law as the ‘bedrock of our democracy’. I made the argument that the principles it encompasses – equality under the law; access to justice; government being subject to the same law as anyone else; and a framework of law that is clear and certain – underpin and protect so many aspects of our way of life, from the liberty and rights of the individual to the strength of our economy. In a changing and uncertain world, they are principles that act as an anchor for us.

When I took my oath of office, I committed to uphold the Rule of Law and to defend your independence as the judicial branch of the State. The link between those two is inextricable, because the Rule of Law cannot exist without you as its custodians. It is an oath I have taken seriously.

I would like to express my gratitude to judges at all levels and in all jurisdictions for the work you do throughout the year – under huge scrutiny, constantly challenged by complexity – making decisions that affect the lives of so many people, and for doing so in the pursuit of the proud principles of our modern democracy. Whether it is by design or a by-product of a shift in our national debate, I think many of those principles are being put at risk and so too are the institutions that exist to protect them.

There is no doubt in my mind that the forces of populism are much stronger in this country and internationally than has been the case for some time. A willingness by politicians to say what they think the public want to hear, and a willingness by large parts of the public to believe what they are told by populist politicians, has led to a deterioration in our public discourse. This has contributed to a growing distrust of our institutions – whether that be Parliament, the civil service, the mainstream media or the judiciary.

A dangerous gulf between the people and the institutions that serve them has emerged. But the reality is that these institutions – including the legal system and the judiciary – offer us the kind of confidence and predictability that underpins our success as a society.

Our institutions have evolved over time to reflect the changing needs of our society. And that has not stopped. Our institutions are strong and effective because they continue to change organically as society demands, but not immediately in knee-jerk reactions to events in the news. Change comes with urgency sometimes, but must always be approached in a considered way to avoid negative unintended consequences.

Thus, our institutions have become guardians of our democratic ideals. They ensure that the right checks and balances exist for us and they promote the inherent sense of fairness that exists in our country. They do not work against the people, they share power in the best interests of everyone.

That view – that our institutions are not perfect, they must change to reflect society but they are beneficial and essential to our way of life – is under attack. Rather than recognising the challenges of a fast-changing society require sometimes complex responses, that we live in a world of trade-offs, that easy answers are usually false answers, we have seen the rise of the simplifiers. Those grappling with complex problems are not viewed as public servants but as engaged in a conspiracy to seek to frustrate the will of the public. They are ‘enemies of the people’.

In deploying this sort of language, we go to war with truth; we pour poison into our national conversation. But language really matters in our discourse. All of us in public life have a responsibility to use language with care and respect. Arguments that are too simplistic and partial simply allow scepticism to creep in when the full picture does inevitably become clear.

We must all have the courage to disagree on the facts and the good sense to appreciate that language can have powerful effects. That is why I deprecate the careless use of language which can undermine our admired and renowned institutions.

The confidence that is rightly placed in you is done so by virtue of your years of training and experience. Our judiciary has a reputation for intellectual rigour, careful consideration of the arguments, and a serious-minded determination to each decision based on what is right and not necessarily what is superficially popular. I am not sure that all politicians have the same reputation.

But politics should be about finding and embracing practical solutions to society’s problems, and to do that based on dealing with the world as we find it, not as we imagine or represent it to be. We must face facts. I have made that my guiding principle in office.

We have looked across the entire prison system to understand the complex problems and put a renewed focus on rehabilitation, alongside the obvious need to tackle violence, self-harm and drugs. We have carefully examined our probation system and begun an ambitious but practical process of reform.

We are following the evidence on reoffending to look at reforming short sentences and working across the criminal justice system and with Health and other departments to turn offenders’ lives around and protect the public from crime.

We must…Make decency, humanity and a focus on skills and real work make prisons launching pads for rehabilitation…Make our courts system modern and accessible to all people…Ensure that court users – whether victims, defendants or witnesses – are appropriately supported throughout the process…Face the reality of modern society and allow couples in a marriage or civil partnership to legally end their relationship and move forward with their lives without the need to demonstrate that one of them is at fault…And ensure that our common law system continues to lead the world because it puts itself at the heart of the revolution in LawTech.

Today’s world is undoubtedly changing. But the Rule of Law and our institutions, including the independent judiciary, are assets that we must cherish, even as they evolve.

Of course, we must always work to maintain that trust and confidence in our institutions. We must act with integrity, for the public good, and hold ourselves to the highest standards. But we cannot be passive. We must stand up for truth; for institutions that work in the interests of the people, not against them; for honest, respectful public debate that lays out all the options and all the consequences.

And we must reject the idea that experience and evidence mean nothing. If we fail to do so then we will end up applying hopeless solutions to imagined problems. What we need is to relentlessly focus on reality and pragmatic change that really gets results. That is what I will continue to stand for both in my role as Lord Chancellor and after. Ministers and governments may change but our belief in the Rule of Law and the necessity to seek the truth must endure.

Ladies and Gentlemen, thank you for listening. I would like to invite you to rise for a toast to the health of our kind and generous hosts this evening… to the Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress.


David Gauke MP

--oo00oo--

Meanwhile, there are signals from the MoJ that the ambitious timetable for designing probation TR2 might be in trouble:-  

We have taken the decision to postpone a small number of our market engagement events. Since launching our response to the ‘strengthening probation, improving confidence’ public consultation we have held over 20 engagement events, with providers, the market and other key partners. As a result, we have taken the decision to summarise the feedback received so far, and refine our approach so that we are able to make future sessions as constructive and productive as possible. We will re-schedule our planned engagement activity.

The MoJ is cancelling the Innovation Partner Service Design Market Engagement event taking place on the 8th July. This is due to the need to undertake further work on the scope of the additional services for the Innovation partner contracts. The event on the 8th July will now be replaced by a Innovation Partner market engagement event on Payment and Performance frameworks.

Thursday, 4 July 2019

Napo at Work in the South West 26

As always, thanks to the reader for forwarding the following:-

SSW Branch AGM Report 2018 -19

Reporting on the most significant year since the flawed TR fiasco started we have seen the end of the single worst failure of privatisation. We cheered at the end of the Working Links occupation. Sadly, however, immediately replaced by the Seetec contractor instead of placing DDC into a potential Govco arrangement, only missing out by a few months or so under specific contract terms. The new contractors appear to manage with the same ideologies only wrapped up in a lot of self–praise as their way in pretending to be good for the area. Not quite Panto season but “oh no they aint.” A rotten start day 1 with attacks on terms and conditions from an agenda that continues to suppress members’ wages and avoid fair workloads or genuinely seek any resolutions. To protect members from the excessive pressures. Napo and combined unions will be exploring what actions we should take as workloads and a pay dispute continue. What a great start they have failed to make.

In June 18 we saw the report on the Debentures at Companies House that really signalled the beginning of the aggressive financial battles going on behind the scenes of Working Links and their owner the Aurelius’ group. Hardly surprising as the region had recently received another government bail out of 4 million that disappeared. It started the speculation trail that NAPO reported on and kept a watching brief, all the signs of a company in distress started to get worse, holding onto staff expenses and general non payments of bills. CP vans stuck at the roadsides without any recovery insurance, vehicles without road tax or fuel cards refused at payments, a decline in standards from the public services we were once proud of and under private ownership could never see performance anywhere near what we once were.

In July 18 we heard of the announcements to cut the contracts 2 years earlier than planned. The Government failures all too obvious as violent crime went up, repeat offending climbing and the abysmal performance of split probation all too painfully commented upon by the PAC. The contractors’ time was shortened but their failures in delivering was the real reason. Ironically they still do not appear to appreciate it is the way they chose to manage that has accelerated the demise of TR. Napo SSW had already predicted the end was likely. We have a great team able to work cohesively and have seen so much decline it cannot bottom out much further. Our team have campaigned on many fronts to help accelerate the end of TR.

Napo SSW is pleased to report that we have made efforts and continue to do so to see the contracts ended early. We have led on many campaign fronts

  • The regional dispute
  • The Parliamentary evidence
  • Plymouth Council motion
  • Campaign of role protections.
  • Non variations on our contracts roles and terms.
  • Collation of the catalogue of secrets public risk issues failures and collusions of the Working links way.
  • Non compliance with lawful requirements in relation to health and safety vehicles and a range continued failings.
and we will continue to do so.

This excerpt from the July branch report fits nicely as this remains the position under the new contractor Seetec. The name over the door may well have changed but the same old tune is playing. The announcement of the Wales case management return to NPS a year earlier was also introduced at the same time.

By November 2018 having been very busy myself in a serious personalised dispute with the NAPO Chairs et al which resulted in our victory at the Certifications Officer on all four counts of the complaint. I thank Dave Rogan and my team who, as usual work tirelessly and supportively for the benefit of the SSW branch. It was a bleak period having such inappropriate leadership in the Union but you don’t really get what you think you vote for.

The winter saw some major developments with the parliamentary committee recommendations coming through with an order to the MOJ which reinstates 1-1 case work minimum service contacts . It was not as though Working Links did not have enough financial trouble, they were now told to deliver the requirements without any more cash. Their` usual high squeak whining “we need more money” directed at the MOJ was going to fall on deaf ears. They scurried around suggesting the requirements did not actually require a full 30 minutes 1-1 time. In panic their pathetic approach to reconcile 1-1 requirements after they had removed most of the staffing was an impossible task. Still there is no agreed workload calculations or proper running of the process agreed with the Unions. The passing across of the staff from the ridiculous call centre model to now deliver a new role was just another Working Links fiasco. While the call centre signs were still on the walls in offices the call centres are effectively now as dead as the Monty Python Parrott.

By December 18 and through to March so much was going on. I was reporting that the flurry of legal arguments being played out at Companies House made it fairly clear that Working Links will be gone in less than a few months. I was hoping weeks at the time but now with hindsight wish they had survived another few months so that our contract remaining period would have gone to a Govco than the extending our aggravations with another clutch on for cash company. More expensive unskilled and non vocational management is just part of the same TR mess that has continued to ooze its journey while we are all too polite in pointing out just how failed it is and needs arresting now. Aurelius sold Working Links to a debt company and announcing the news on their website. Whilst MOJ were caught napping again, denying the claims, yet the news was out. They looked weak for their efforts and throughout the year we have seen their game change with a massive overhaul of MOJ key players. Let’s hope the new team deliver ideas that really save probation staff by putting Probation Officers back into public service where they are genuinely needed and required, whilst saving fortunes by dismissing the remaining structure in the form of privatised management companies.

In the same period the HMIP report was being finalised and kept a closely guarded secret. That was a clear signal to brace up as it was to be as bad as it could get in my experience. Napo have no sympathy for some of the most senior management and Working Links directors. None of these people are with us anymore. They had led the way to what has become the worst HMIP report ever. Delivered by an appalling operating model, the ongoing dispute on the pay deal for staff. Where were the contract managers? What were they being paid for?

By February the game was up Working Links, finally succumbing to their plight and their grip on the contract going to the insolvency court. Handing back the keys we were pleased to hear. We in NAPO had some air punching and celebrations at the end of the Working Links Directorships. They could no longer continue their plan to impose redundancies which they could never fund given the protections of the collective agreement held tightly as a protected agreement for the DDC area. They were gone and Seetec rock up with a load of promises and still no real delivery. Same old same old.

As the news was announced those old call centre signs and the Working Links logos were reportedly savagely stripped from the walls in an act of frustration, anger and relief that saw some staff get some satisfaction for being able to pull down the signs of oppressive management and the end of an aggressive structure that failed from the get go. Good riddance Links and the nature of your management style leaves a nasty stain on all the staff they stole money, terms and entitlements from. The final consequence for the publication in March of the worst HMIP report on record saw the end of the career of the Chief Officer. Without his endorsement and complete loyalty to the Working Links fiasco they could not have done so much damage. His end was fitting amazingly he was alone in paying the price for his collective failures.

The recent few months have seen the Unions messed around by Seetec with only 3 meetings the first of which was irrelevant no more than a hello get together and the remaining two about terms and pay. The Seetec approach is disorganised. They are playing the delay game. The CEO only turning into a meeting on the basis of the excuses and cancellations have to dry up at some point. No decent offer on pay despite a well delivered presentation on the unions’ claim by the NAPO General Secretary. The Seetec group did not even have the courage to face the union side to tell us and even though I doubt they have any authority, they just focus on issues that will do working relations more damage than venture into taking any constructive way forwards as we have seen with no progress on moratoriums and staff protections. This year will be even more complex and with the end game in sight just over the next year we hope to see a change of political direction and all bets are off. We hope in any case to see the campaign won in complete removal of the wasted money on unnecessary pay and now superfluous contractors who should be looking elsewhere for finance instead of stripping government’s contracts and making the probation services fail. Nothing more saddening.

The news coming this spring that the contracts for case management will also be ceased has left Seetec holding the can for a CRC in a mess without them implementing an immediate action plan to deal with the serious HMIP report. In the short to mid term they will have very little left or the support from staff (our members) as the contract continues to decline on a daily basis.

In relation to the DDC area’s SSW branch our struggle will continue no matter what. We are committed to NAPOs reunification campaign having achieved most of what we set out to do. We just have to make the case for interventions and CP and when we win that battle too we can all look inwardly and start the real repair process to put probation back at the top of its game like we were once enabled to do.

It is a tough time right now to be a trade unionist and the last few years have taken some effort. This SSW branch despite the attacks received and some rubbish or pathetic commentary on social media from those who really know little. This branch has prevented mass additional dismissals with the protections we have fought for in our collective agreements. With the knowledge and efforts of the executive this area would been a much worse place for staff than we currently suffer. For that energy strength and unity and as a team it is important to recognise the Stirling efforts of the NAPO SSW branch members. Each and every member of the Executive standing their ground, protecting terms and investing personal time in the union’s work.

As Chair of the SSW my personal thanks go to our team, my respects and our members extended this also. This branch has maintained our position consistently and will continue to do so just so long as our NAPO members require us and whatever that takes. The future is looking better and we also thank the PAC and NAO report for having the foresight to drive through what’s required to try and fix probation. Top of the team the General Secretary’s level and the pan unions group. Together we are stronger and together we will do our best to ensure the scourge of TR is finally extinguished.

Dino Peros 

NAPO SSW Branch Chair 

Wednesday, 3 July 2019

Latest From Napo 190

From the most recent edition of Napo News Online:-

The ‘Mixed Market’ and the lessons from the Serco UPW Fiasco

Whilst Napo members will welcome the Government U-turn which will see the transfer of Offender Management work to the NPS England and Wales by April 2021, the evidence against leaving Intervention services to the vagaries of the market are writ large in the failure of the last experiment.

On the 6th February 2014 Chris Grayling, then Secretary of State for Justice, announced to Parliament that he intended to terminate Serco’s Community Payback (London) contract by the end of that year. This followed an earlier award to SERCO of the entire Unpaid Work Service in 2012 with the intention that it should deliver this until at least the autumn of 2016.

The decision came after compelling evidence that Serco’s approach to delivering this critically important intervention regime had been a mixture of disorganisation and financial ineptitude. The flaws in service delivery were also graphically exposed in a BBC2 ‘Newsnight’ feature involving ‘whistle-blowing’ Napo members. They told of serious failings in the contract and embarrassing examples of community service projects not being properly supervised due to staff shortages, along with serious inaccuracies in the reporting of offenders who had failed to turn up at their appointments. By now, none of this came as a surprise to Napo members who were well aware of the Serious Fraud Office investigation involving SERCO, where allegations of ‘tagging the dead’ to falsely record the numbers and names of people wearing an electronic tag were in need of some answers.

In March 2013 Napo wrote to Michael Spurr following Chris Grayling’s statement to the Justice Select Committee that the Serco contract had produced savings of 40% since its commencement. Napo demanded to know how this figure was arrived at. We also asked for a costing of the work carried out prior to the transfer on legal and consultancy advice and the time spent by NOMS and then London Probation staff time in drawing up the bid. Michael Spurr’s reply was that the 40% figure was a re-working of the often repeated MoJ claim that the contract was to save the taxpayer £25 million (37%) over the life of the four-year contract, and that he could not reply to our questions on costing due to ‘commercial confidentiality’.

In the May/June 2013 edition of Napo News, Pat Waterman then Greater London branch chair and Sarah Friday Napo National Official co-authored an article: ‘Lessons learnt from the part privatisation of London Community Payback’ in which they highlighted the scale of job losses. Pat wrote: “Over 300 LPT staff were transferred to Serco on 30 October. However, no sooner was the ink dry on the trade union recognition agreement when Serco announced its plans to make 99 redundancies by way of a severance scheme”, adding: “The scale of the job losses arising from the privatisation of London CP is one of the most devastating things about it, with nearly 200 jobs being cut from a pre-privatisation total of around 550 (including about 100 casuals)”. In addition to the above job cuts in June 2013 Serco made a subsequent round of 10 redundancies – this time to managerial grades (senior and field managers).

In December 2013, Napo General Secretary Ian Lawrence, commented on the Serco decision to withdraw from the MoJ competition to become a primary provider of probation services, (due to the SFO investigations into their activities as well as another outsourcing giant G4S). Ian said: “Despite their clear transgressions, both companies may still be allowed to work with other potential suppliers to support the Governments’ objective of achieving a diverse market in Probation”, adding that: “We will now be using this as further evidence to parliamentarians that both companies have proved themselves to be unfit for purpose in terms of their contracts within the justice sector”.

The pressure was mounting, and by the end of 2014, the 129 full time equivalent staff had been subject to a messy transfer from SERCO into the newly created London CRC (Community Rehabilitation Company). The MoJ claimed that this move would assist the national Transforming Rehabilitation programme, but most commentators believed it was because the Government wanted to downplay the news of abject failure, especially as the announcement appeared as a footnote in a wider MoJ announcement.

Exposing the myth of the ‘mixed – market’

Clocks forward to the present; where it appears that this Government has not only failed to heed the lessons of the past, but seems intent on repeating them. The mantra that there is still a market for Interventions and Programmes in the face of all empirical evidence to the contrary is pushing credulity to its absolute limits.

The past failures of Serco, along with those of a vast majority of CRCs (that’s the companies not our members who have worked damn hard to keep them afloat) as evidenced in reports by the Chief Inspector for Probation, the National Audit Office and two parliamentary select committees, have not exactly concentrated the minds of people who ought to know better in number 102 Parliament Street.

It seems that money is no object when it comes to presenting Interventions as some sort of second-rate accoutrement to a client’s contact with probation. In the face of what we know to be an extremely sceptical response to new contracts by current CRC owners, the MoJ spin machine has gone into overdrive. The GOV.UK portal regularly spewing out unintelligible material extolling the so-called benefits of a probation mixed-market to would be purchasers. Some have confided to Napo that the prospect has about the same allure as the ‘snake oil’ once peddled by travelling Wild West salespeople.

Anyone can see that whatever wheels Grayling thought were on his TR bandwagon came off a long time ago. Even before he embarked on his gargantuan personal disaster he could have seen, (but chose not to) that the London Serco CP experiment was its X-rated prequel. The privatisation of London Community payback (just like TR) was a scandalous waste of public money, it seriously impacted on public safety and, in the view of the Probation trade unions, is still in breach of an International Labour Organisation convention on forced labour.

Napo will simply not settle for the significant victory that we secured on 16th May, and we have wasted no time in doubling our campaigning efforts to fix probation. Our ultimate objective is to see all probation work under public control with not-for-profit third sector partners providing the additional assistance that worked so well for clients and the taxpaying public before the TR disaster divided a once gold standard service.

Ian Lawrence and Sarah Friday

Tuesday, 2 July 2019

Time For a National Probation Agency

As many readers will be aware, Russell Webster has produced three succinct blog posts regarding the MoJ's plans for a redesigned probation service. Following the last in the series I notice from Facebook that David Raho has continued to make the case for a different direction of travel and one that undoubtedly would find widespread support within the profession:- 

Russell Webster on redesigning probation

I know I’ve said it before but the thinking is now finally edging at glacial speed towards the realisation that what is really required is not for the CRCs to be assimilated into the NPS (like The Borg on Star Trek) but rather the establishment of a brand new service built around the infrastructure and best bits of all probation providers that is both tied into local services and one step removed from direct government interference and Stalinist centralisation. Probation is not a civil service and when Grayling made it one it was another of his failings as it does not sit well with what we are and what we do. We are public servants not civil servants.

Probation regions in a brand new National Probation Agency (NPA) need to have some autonomy from central control to respond to local need but be able to use revamped shared services providing HR and administrative services to free up practitioners as much as possible without unduly reducing their professional autonomy.

It is vitally important that we do not lose the innovations that have been mostly developed in the CRCs as unlike the MoJs plans they have now been tested in the field and are being developed further through practitioner feedback. Time-saving innovations and advances that work reasonably well and that are helpful need to be developed further then scaled up and rolled out service-wide. The MoJ's blueprint is blatantly wrong when it says that it is sticking with Delius and Oasys as better solutions are required and better solutions are now potentially available. However, decisions have to be made now and plans made and actions taken expeditiously to prevent further delays down the line. Going backwards as suggested by the MoJ does not increase stability, by sticking with the devils you know from the 1990s, but rather denies the opportunity to move forward to better things that can be improved more easily and that are fit for the 21st century and the technologies that we are familiar with and would want to use to make our job easier.

There is certainly a place for private contractors under the probation umbrella in a reunified service and it would be naive to believe otherwise. Grayling clearly got it wrong but those of us who knew where the trusts were heading know that CP in London was an example of what Trusts were planning to do on a wider scale just as NHS Trusts contract out service provision to private providers. What the Serco CP experience in London was able to prove was that little or no money can be made from CP as public sector probation were actually able to run it fairly efficiently as it shared resources and did not have to provide separate HR and financial services. Serco slimmed CP in London down to the very minimum and retained staff by paying them more than their equivalents back in the Trust. The unions did not object to employers paying increases over and above what was expected particularly as these increases would be preserved in a staff transfer.

Government plans to reunite probation casework certainly does not mean sending private companies and contractors packing. It makes sense that some key services are provided in-house and some might be contracted out eg IT, HR, financial, facilities management, H&S if it is cost effective to do so. There are also parcels of work that could be provided by others working under the probation umbrella. I for one want to see the trend towards greater integration of electronic monitoring into offender management take place although the private sector will need to be involved to provide technical services. The important thing is to get the best people doing the jobs they are best qualified to do at a reasonable cost to taxpayers. This is how modern organisations function.

Where TR went badly wrong was to go too far by dividing the service and splitting the service users according to a relatively arbitrary assessment of risk at point of sentence. Whereas tweaking and expanding the Trusts and giving them commissioning powers would have been sufficient. Whilst core services should by default be provided by the public sector - for some very good reasons - many colleagues across probation may wish to have the choice to work for private providers provided that they are adequately resourced to do what they are being asked to do. For efficiency, private companies would need to provide specialist services on longer contracts subject to oversight by the new NPA, not the MoJ (who have a fairly poor record). Also, no one should be penalised or prevented from moving between employers whether moving from public to private or to the voluntary sector if they are doing the same sort of work. In order to facilitate this it would be necessary to have some form of universally recognised competency-based accreditation system

Funding to the 3rd sector who had been in partnership with Trusts fell by approximately 50% following TR and we sometimes wonder why former partners and friends are somewhat less motivated to help out than previously. In a new organisation, the 3rd sector needs to play a bigger role in service provision with long term funding contracts again subject to oversight by the new NPA.


David Raho

--oo00oo--

I work for a CRC but also have over a decade of NPS experience. I like elements of our IT System Omnia as its case management and risk and needs assessment together. You don’t have to keep logging into different systems all the time. With all the good will in the world it’s a challenge to keep looking at oasys when you are time pressured. However, I prefer oasys as a risk assessment tool. If we improved parts of omnia it would be a good alternative to delius and Oasys.

*****
I’d put a bet on Serco increasing pay for CP is a one off in the private world. It’s highly likely keeping private providers will create a two tier system, with public sector staff seeing pay rises whilst the poorer cousins in CRCs sit by and watch colleagues celebrate. Oh wait, that’s already happened. I predict it only getting worse with the pay gap widening and career opportunities being stunted for us left out here in the private sphere. Just a thought!

*****
Serco had their reasons and remember they were keen to repair their image and engage in corporate renewal under a new MD who was happy to get shot of CP as soon as TR was announced. Some staff decided to stay with Serco. Private companies however often do pay more than the public sector for similar work although they tend to pay managers more and like to reward individual high performers with bonuses rather than agree to blanket increases irrespective of performance. There is quite a lot of data that indicates that probation pay fell way behind other similar professions when it was fully in the public sector I remember the pay hikes of the 1980s when we fell behind social workers and as we had a shared qualification people were jumping ship. I have heard estimates of between £6-9000 as about the sum required that would bring a mid career PO up to where they should be in terms of earnings. This gradual fall in probation earnings relative to other professions has been due to a number of factors.

The recent NPS pay settlement was almost unprecedented in the public sector and probably one of the biggest increases in the public sector in recent times although some benefiting from it still had issues with it. CRCs have probably not been able to deliver the rewards they thought they might have been able to because they have been strapped for cash due to a dodgy PbR system etc. On the other hand the NPS just gets more cash from the treasury. It is well known that had it had to operate within the same financial restrictions as the CRCs it would have gone bust at about the 18 month stage. The difference being that despite stories of amusing notes left by departing ministers the government cannot go bust and must keep paying the wages. Meanwhile some CRCs were struggling to keep the lights on. An FOI request to the NPS would probably confirm their financial status. Things like career development and innovation are expensive but some has taken place in the CRCs and I have certainly seen some people now enjoying positions that they could not have dreamt of occupying in public sector probation where there was widespread stagnation and lack of opportunities as well as some good stuff. I think there are more opportunities in the CRCs and a bit more movement of staff around. There are also some more commercially orientated training and job opportunities. It’s a bit swings and roundabouts. 

However not all CRCs are the same and created equal. Over in the NPS some people have failed to gain any benefit from being part of a national service for instance being able to in theory transfer anywhere in England and Wales. Try it. There are also people who have left the NPS after repeated attempts to advance or gain promotion and then joined the CRC where they have been promoted quickly and offered pretty good training and opportunities. Pay is something that needs to be sorted out either through negotiations (preferred) or further action. 
David Raho

******
You make a very valid point. Indeed I came from a private sector company in fostering social work into Probation. However I think the split (#2) has created the unique position that many of us find ourselves literally sat next to those who are again looking at security of tenure in the public sector as well as a pay rise while Interventions/CP (many qualified PSOs amongst us) face uncertainty. At least when we were dumped in the CRCs it was a sense of team work as we’re ‘all in it together’. Despite this post I’m not money focused! I came back to the public sector as a vocational career move. But it offered security. There are things the private sector does better, but making profit from Human misfortune isn’t one of them. And we all have choices so as my loyalty to this profession has been totally obliterated for the second time I now feel able to apply for other jobs as personally there’s no vocation left worth fighting for. Sorry for the whinge but I have found this group to be heavily dominated by OMs mainly in the NPS so I’d like to appeal to you all not to forget your friends who were once your equals who share your office - we are currently uncomfortable and very concerned for the future. Thank you.

******
Well said. I am proud to be a PO in London CRC and really proud of my colleagues who have kept professionalism alive and probation's unique identity strong. Indeed I’m having a T-shirt made with the slogan ‘In this one the probation is strong’ with a picture of Yoda. I am very conscious of the professional dimension to our situation and we must keep fighting for our identity every day. Unfortunately I am also aware of the bizarre phenomenon of a minority of influential NPS colleagues organising themselves to protect the NPS against change to their way of working when case management is reunified. There is a odd compromise suggestion to silo CRC staff within the NPS to protect them from the NPS and the NPS from being exposed to more advanced business processes IT etc. Whilst this might mean the former CRC operating in the more or less freed up way the have been used to there is however no doubt that this would not last long. The slow moving but creativity crushing and bureaucratically suffocating mass that is the MoJ HMPPS NPS bloc will, like a large shapeless globulous entity of enormous bulk and weight, bear down upon CRC staff wiping out their will to live let alone work and who will find resistance is futile as the Empire can launch salvos of directives and instructions day and night against the Resistance safe in the knowledge they have the former CRCs staff penned in and unable to move. 

As I have previously suggested the only viable solution is to form a new non pseudo civil service organisation removed from direct government control and operational interference or in fact too much freedom lest we go the other way and where we leave our former affiliations at the door and take up a new fresh unified identity where open mindedness and learning are the watch words and do what research informs us is the most effective way to ensure those we work with are rehabilitated and stay rehabilitated. Leave punishment to others and behaviourist nonsense to others who want to be involved in such things. Our business is rehabilitation and resettlement and we should be given the freedom and resources to go about our work with a minimum amount of interference from the centre - a bit like the Home Office back in the 1980s. It should be the probation services choice whether to commission services from the private or 3rd sector not the government who know little about what works (look at their record). Taking back control of the probation service and making it more accountable to the local communities it serves should be a top priority. When we are back together employment law protections should enable those doing the same job to be paid the same or employers would face legal action. A lot of problems can be solved at a stroke but many others require compromise and understanding and a liberal dose of vision. Vision is unfortunately a thing in short supply. David Raho

******
Open mindedness and learning would be the watch words. I’d like to shake your hand and buy you a pint for that last message. I have numerous NPS old friends who do tell me it’s no bed of roses. Let’s just pray/hope that things all come out in the wash eventually... I still like the Irish/Scottish model but I’m sure if we asked their officers they’d shed some light on the state of their own services too.

Monday, 1 July 2019

A Reader's Question

"A probation service in the North East of England has been commended for its strong leadership and the innovative way it supports individuals to move away from further offending... HM Inspectorate of Probation conducted a routine inspection of the North East Division of the NPS... Chief Inspector of Probation Justin Russell said: “Leaders in the North East Division of the NPS have a clear vision and strategy to deliver a quality service, and this has been communicated well to staff and key stakeholders."

However...

"... the Division is not always able to achieve this ambition because... There is a lack of qualified probation officers across England and Wales, and inspectors found... Restrictions to local recruitment have further hampered efforts to place newly qualified officers in the offices where they are most needed... The Division needs to take a more robust approach to risk management in order to keep potential and actual victims safe. In a third of inspected cases, the risk assessments did not contain enough information about who might be at risk of harm from the individual under supervision and the exact nature of that risk. For example, some assessments overlooked victims of previous offences.”

Please, Please, PLEASE can someone tell me how & why HMIP continue to praise "strong leadership" when they then clearly & explicitly identify that 30% or more of the work is shit, that people are left at risk & that there aren't enough staff to do the work because of local recruitment policies. HOW THE FUCK IS that commensurate with the alleged 'STRONG LEADERSHIP'?

It's Trumpism gone viral. It seems to be a contractual obligation that HMIP praise probation leaders, irrespective of the actualite. Maybe it's the quality of the lunches? The comfy-ness of the hotel rooms? The quantity of management speak that short-circuits the inspectors' objectivity? Or simply the cosy, rosy feelings brought on by familiar faces?

Anon

Thursday, 27 June 2019

NPS Staffing Crisis

The new Chief Inspector of Probation published a fairly positive report on NPS in the North East yesterday, but once again it highlighted the staffing crisis largely brought about by TR:-

North East probation service delivering innovative work, despite heavy workloads

A probation service in the North East of England has been commended for its strong leadership and the innovative way it supports individuals to move away from further offending. The North East Division of the National Probation Service (NPS) supervises almost 19,000 high-risk offenders across a large area that stretches from the Scottish border to The Wash in Lincolnshire.

HM Inspectorate of Probation conducted a routine inspection of the North East Division of the NPS and looked at 10 aspects of its work. The Inspectorate has given the Division an overall ‘Good’ rating, its second-highest mark.

Chief Inspector of Probation Justin Russell said: “Leaders in the North East Division of the NPS have a clear vision and strategy to deliver a quality service, and this has been communicated well to staff and key stakeholders. However, the Division is not always able to achieve this ambition because of staff shortages and high workloads.”

There is a lack of qualified probation officers across England and Wales, and inspectors found significant shortages across this Division too. Restrictions to local recruitment have further hampered efforts to place newly qualified officers in the offices where they are most needed.

Mr Russell said: “Despite staff shortages and some heavy workloads, staff across the Division take the time to develop professional relationships with the individuals under their supervision. If individuals missed appointments or broke the rules of their orders, staff did excellent work to engage individuals again and get them back on track.”

Inspectors found the Division offers a comprehensive range of services to individuals to support their rehabilitation. Pioneering initiatives include ‘Project Beta’, a collaboration between HM Prison and Probation Service, Durham County Council and Darlington Borough Council. The project works with individuals who are leaving prisons across the North East to help ensure they enter stable accommodation on release to provide a foundation for beginning a life free from crime. Inspectors also noted a network of community hubs in Cleveland has supported women to move away from crime and reoffending.

The Division has also been proactive in addressing gaps in its services. Probation staff wanted to strengthen their work with sexual offenders so set up additional training and a library of resources. Staff can now work with this complex and challenging group of offenders with greater expertise and confidence.

Work with victims of serious crime was found to be of a good standard. The Division runs a statutory scheme that provides victims with updates on the perpetrator’s sentence and gives them an opportunity to contribute their views on release plans. Contact with victims was timely and supportive in nearly nine out of 10 inspected cases, and victims received clear communications throughout the course of the sentence. However, inspectors found a small number of victims were not contacted about the scheme; the Inspectorate is now encouraging the Division to make sure all eligible victims are approached.

Inspectors found the overall quality of work with individuals under supervision was generally good, but some aspects require improvement.

Mr Russell said: “The Division needs to take a more robust approach to risk management in order to keep potential and actual victims safe. In a third of inspected cases, the risk assessments did not contain enough information about who might be at risk of harm from the individual under supervision and the exact nature of that risk. For example, some assessments overlooked victims of previous offences.”

The Inspectorate has made seven recommendations to improve the quality of the Division’s work.

Mr Russell added: “There is much to commend in the innovative and proactive leadership of the North East division of the NPS. Taking the opportunity to learn from this inspection will enable the division to further improve its service delivery.”

--oo00oo--

A few weeks ago a question on Facebook sought to address the staffing problem and the responses might prove enlightening, not just to the MoJ as they beaver away in earnest on the new probation model, but also to those currently contemplating a career in this line of work:-

What would it take to convince you to return to probation or retain you as a member of frontline probation staff if you are thinking of rejoining or leaving? If you are temping what would encourage you to move from temping to permanent work? 

A parking space would be a start.

Ditto.

I would want more pay and manageable caseload but that's a pipe dream.

I was recently tempted back to a permanent PO post from agency, as they’ve agreed to give me extended leave (unpaid), to enable me to maintain flexibility to xxxxxx each year. I feel very lucky - have yet to see how the reduced income will impact though!

I’d like that. To spend more time xxxxxxxxx.


Definitely. Ill health and the privatisation made me re-evaluate life’s priorities .. go for what makes you happy and live your best life. x

Yes time to re-evaluate definitely.


Reduced stress helps! X

Yes. I get told by friends that stress can kill even. 
I’m XX. If I early retired this year I’d only get £XX a year pension. I’m looking into flexible retirement. I’m XX this year and no matter what pension is - at 60 I’m going to early retire.

I agree totally .. my plan is to retire early and move to Xxxxxxxx full-time, where the cost of living is much lower. xx

More official recognition, less of a blame culture and less aggressive intervention into private life - needing to seek managerial permission before needing to do virtually anything outside of work, excessive vetting, social media embargoes etc.

More manageable workloads. No more weekly emails saying this that or the other is missing or out of date. Not having to wait two months for an OHA. 
More facilities time for reps. A less draconian absence management policy.

To be honest nothing would tempt me to move from agency to permanent. I work part time- take a month off Xxxxxx and Xxxxxxx, as well as other shorter bits of leave - have a degree of independence and autonomy - which also allows me to work in different places. I’m mortgage free so have few financial commitments and retire in 2021! For others I would suggest a robust WMT, flexible hours and technology to work from home - parity re conditions - parking - reopening offices - ongoing training!

I forgot about the WMT- not fit for purpose.


I forgot about the no bullying!

Workload, by which I mean LESS assessments. OASys tells us nothing that we do not know in advance. What EXACTLY is SARA for? Why ARMS? Still more pay, lets get back what we lost since 2012. Less counting things, more time with people. If we have to be civil servants how about non contributory pension and retirement at 60?

My thoughts exactly. Don't forget VISOR! Another useless tool we don't need, we don't want!

Yeah, that too.

Oh and RSR! Fill out this form that tells us that serious re-offending is very rare. Well ain't that a surprise!

I’m a temp and no price to go permanent would be enough. X

I have been banging the ViSOR drum for years! Hopefully this will be the end of it once and for all.

Totally agree about SARA. Utterly pointless. 

Fingers crossed but I doubt it as it's about us doing the police's work for them, same as for the ARMS!

I never look at it

I have seen it and the bulk of the info on there is supplied by us anyway! It’s completely unnecessary and even if it was imperative, access should have been granted without vetting. I cannot explain how much upset and concern this caused amongst some of my colleagues.


I don’t look at SARA.

They are ALL pointless. OASYs takes hours. OGRS takes five minutes. Scores are always very close. Do an OGRS. Ask a question covering all the areas in OASYs Use those as the basis of a sentence plan done via the web. SORTED.

It seems to be widely agreed that SARA is useless.

Agree.

Is temping much more money?

Not really when you take in to account no annual leave or sickness pay. However, I prefer the autonomy - the feeling that if I’m unhappy there is a plethora of other jobs in the sector. I also think you have more authority when it comes to flexible working - I do condensed hours with Xxxxxxx’s off. I have done 2 spells permanent and 2 spells temping. I really would not consider permanent work again.

The RSR is not significantly different in what it looks at than what you get from an OGRS. The only time it is ever different is for sex offenders, when it increases the numbers.

My take from Court work. Can we ditch the EPF? Unless the person is out of area, this is a waste of time. If people are from out of area, let us just call it an Accredited Programme and the other area can figure out which, according to what they have. Could we get rid of RAR? Not an effective way of supervising anyone. It can result in someone receiving a minimal service even if their circumstances change and mean they need more support. The considerations when doing a report on someone should focus on *if* they need Probation intervention and what sort would help the most. There is no such thing as a catch-all, one-size-for-all intervention.


SARA? Well, it helps you remember what areas can be relevant to domestic abuse and its causes, but the practitioner is still the one deciding the risk.


What’s EPF?

Effective Proposal Framework, which must be done before doing the proposal on your reports, including before delivering any stand down reports.


Pay according to years experience and holidays to match. I know that’s not fair on permanent staff but it’s what I would push for on an individual basis. Anything less - no thanks. Temping has saved my mental health and enabled me to continue to work as an OM. At the end of the day, I’ve been able to carry on working on the job I love and serve the community.

My mental health is certainly suffering. I’m stressed re workload. Not fit for purpose WMT and how we are all being treated. And made to feel we are to blame for being stressed and not being able to manage that.


Nonsense emphasis on ‘resilience’.


Left for YOT - not sure anything would tempt me back, especially not as YOT matched my NPS salary and to return would put me back on bottom of NPS scale. Had forgotten what being appreciated for work effort was like as not had that for years in probation.


Sounds like you are much happier.

Well if a lot changed maybe you could be swayed.

Odd. As a seconded PO in Xxxxxxxx YOT l was treated with contempt. As were all the staff. So happy to have a way back.

This is second time in YOT as had previous secondment to different YOT. Welcomed and valued by both. Current YOT has just taken on ex-probation officers with others having been seconded to that YOT.


So how about career progression? Training etc. Those who are PSOs would you like to train to be a PO with no loss of pay or maybe a bit on top? How about the creation of Senior Practitioner posts on the same points as SPOs? Management training for POs? Transfer without penalty? If we don’t ask we won’t get.

Some good ideas there, especially the Sr Practitioner posts.


I’m a big supporter of SP roles as we are not all cut out or want to be managers but certainly know our onions. I also think that not developing the PSO role to enable movement is a travesty.

I’d rather stick pins in my eyes than be a manager. But senior practitioner role sounds an excellent idea.

All social workers have senior practitioners posts and when I started as a P.O. the only route in was with a social work qualification.


Yes all of the above! We need more emphasis on progression through OM skills not management. So if u have done a counselling course - that ought to lead somewhere rather than nowhere. I’m not interested in management, I see that as a separate career. Or, make managers carry a caseload to make it more integrated.

It’s so so sad we won’t be able to do a stint in programmes now. I want group work skills! I want skills in rehabilitation. I want to be coached in rehab skills and have people actually interested in how I work in supervision. I know how to risk manage, but the real practise improvement - no one seems to care.

Sorry to rant - but when inspectors look at our cases they care what happens in sessions. Managers don’t really. We all know that that is the point of our work. Practitioners have to scrabble around digging up old worksheets from 20 years ago to actual
ly structure their sessions. We ought to have ready access to these as well as a comprehensive partnerships directory which is updated on a six monthly basis in every office. Also: every new case needs to be brought before a weekly allocation meeting so they can get partnership appointments booked in from the word go. I know this is not strictly speaking about career progression but I’m just putting an idea out.

Trouble is, all of this gets in the way of doing assessments.

I'd say that as far as I’m aware it does in the NPS but in London CRC and TV there is at least, in recent times, a genuine concern about trying to improve quality at the coal face after most staff made clear their dissatisfaction with command and control targets obsessed approaches. I’d have liked the sort of innovation now being rolled out to have happened sooner but contract times have been shortened and reliable systems take time to develop and roll out. However, I really don’t want the good progress in certain areas - particularly in advances in tools and technologies - to be lost as progress has been hard won and involved many dedicated practitioners. Some of the best stuff has just started to gain some traction not least due to a change in senior management direction but also it is evident that the green shoots of what we might want are evident and mostly welcomed and I’m relatively hard to convince. I would like NPS colleagues to benefit from the best of what has been developed and available. There is an opportunity to improve things across the board.

What both NPS and CRC desperately need are well trained staff both PSOs, POs, SPO and hopefully SPs and certainly something suitably creative in respect of PSOs who all need to feel positive about their employers, leaders, and newly motivated to do the job they were trained to do in the way that is best not directed by faceless bureaucrats.

As a PSO I’d have appreciated the opportunity to train as a PO - as did many highly qualified PSOs in my region - but when we were told we’d have to pay for our own ‘top up’ modules none of us had odd 2 grand to spare.


Exactly. Many would do it but not at their own expense.


I’m doing it now at my own expense but gaining the modules via an Xxxxxxx from Xxxxxxx Uni, hence a huge student loan. At least this way I’ll get a Masters at which point I’ll walk out of Probation. I think what was so difficult for us CRC PSOs was the knowledge that NPS PSOs don’t face the same financial penalty. I really must leave this group - I sound like a moaning old git, and I’m not! I’m very peaceful but this second kick in the teeth for programmes has just destroyed my love for this job.

You don’t sound like that. I’m really angry about it.

My CRC has management training, CPD, innovation, opportunity to have input in how the organisation ran, Associate Tutors roles for operational staff who wanted a chance to deliver programmes and brush up on rehabilitation skills and CA's who wanted skills and experience to apply for operations roles, to lead or work on projects ..... I hope these innovations don't get lost in the move and that the new NPS takes forward all of the positives from both current NPS and CRCs. However, Programmes Rule!

Easier application process rather than civil service competencies that bear no resemblance to the actual job!!


So true. Excellent point.

Better pay, free parking and flexible working and I would consider coming back

Better pay, flexible working including working from home at times and free parking, plus team building.


Easier application process.

As PSO with ten plus years experience it’s frustrating that you have to have a degree to firstly apply for PQUiP. It seems that experience and consistent good/outstanding appraisals doesn’t mean much!


Less hours.

Competent and trained management without a bias of who you are mates with. Work progression routes and personal development. Investment in staff.

Generic case loads like there was back in circa 2003-2007 so there's a mixture of different types of cases - makes the job more emotionally/mentally sustainable.

Guaranteed pay increase every year. And the money owed from the pay freeze. Not too much to ask is it?!

Unfortunately the reality of modern day NPS is not conducive to such cosy discussions. Any such suggestions are usually ignored. Civil Service if that is what is coming is not a panacea. It is very much top down command and control. There is little scope for discussion mostly because purse strings are held tightly at the very top.

For a friend of mine who wanted to get into general office admin work (band 2) they laughed at the wages and told me not for that - would rather stay doing retail on 45 hours a week and get 15k more per year.

For me the only thing would be to put wages up by at least 15% (I know it's gotta be a followed process) but I will be honest I have had enough of it. The only reason I'm still here is the pay cheque at the end of the month. And yes I am looking elsewhere. There are lots of issues and not enough solutions.


Essential car user allowance.

A welfare support system that supported people rather than punish them. 
Services that I could refer people into. Quality housing, drug and mental health support that is not so cash strapped that most "Assessments" come down to "how do we deny this poor bastard any help". 

Less, no sorry, NO obsession with public safety. There is a part of the Criminal Justice system which should prioritise the good that a person can do rather than the bad which they have. Where better than the Probation Service.


An obsession with getting alongside people rather than alongside a computer to fill in another assessment. 
Some distance from the Prison Service and the Justice Ministry to allow us space to breath and be the Service we were and can be again.

Some or all of that would mean that I could enjoy my last 10 years in the service, rather than spend every birthday trying to calculate if I can survive THIS year on a reduced pension or do I have to stick it out longer. Not a lot to ask is it?


Less targets and being allowed to get on with the job and doing the work that matters, work with clients.


Being able to work from home is a huge bonus. Flexible working. Having fabulous colleagues and managers.

I am glad that senior managers are finally starting to recognise these issues. They never seemed too bothered about retaining staff, which has had a catastrophic effect. Hopefully they are realising that their methods of control and direction are not working, and that there should be more ‘carrot’ than ‘stick’! For me they need to offer more creative and flexible working options, we have the IT to support that now. They need to look at particular offices or areas that struggle to recruit and retain and consider the issues and how to encourage people to want to work there. A senior practitioner role is an excellent idea, otherwise there are limited career progression opportunities for those not interested in management. Make improvements to OASys/all the assessments that we have to do, to avoid constant duplication of information. The focus should be on working with people, having the time to do meaningful work with them instead of prioritising ‘targets’.

The way it used to be. Working with a smile on your face. Reduced blame culture manageable time frames. Having your own secretary who felt valued and personal to you and colleagues. Parking - enough staff to share the workload - managers who were not guided by performance targets - professional autonomy - and overall respect from employers - but from what I hear that’s going to be a hard one to achieve when it all gets lumped back together. When I heard the news I sort of did a little flip. But as this goes on and I hear the rumblings from the jungle commonly known as the ministry of magic! Well I’m not filled with enthusiasm and glee.


I left in 2016. After the split there seemed to be a move to reduce everything to the 'quickest' or 'most efficient' way of doing things to the point where the value in doing them at all was lost. We used to stand up for ourselves - if a Court asked for a PSR on a DV case with an unrealistic turnaround then (if we knew a thorough risk assessment couldn't be done in that time) we as professionals would say no and we'd be backed up in doing so. I think we need a clear culture of who we are and what we do and we need senior officers to also know that too and who will stick up for the service when needed (I'm still saying we even 3 years after leaving!). I think probation is going to need to prove itself - be clear about its values and what it stands for and what as a profession it offers - before many would go back. That will take time.

Also, having left, you soon realise quite how bad the pay and career progression is in probation. It's a fairly flat structure with not many opportunities. I left as a PO and would need to go back in as well above SPO grade to make it worth my while. It was never about the money, but the jobs you guys do, you deserve more that's for sure.

Wednesday, 26 June 2019

Prisons Cause Crime

Now here's a surreal story. According to the BBC, Humberside police don't want one of the MoJ's super prisons on their patch because they say it will increase crime in their area:-

Full Sutton 'super prison': Police object to plans

Artist's impression of plans for Full Sutton new prison

Police have objected to plans for a new "super prison", fearing it would increase violent crime within the jail and raise demands on the force. Planning permission has been approved by East Riding Council for a £91m Category C jail near an existing high-security prison in Full Sutton. But Ch Supt Phil Ward from Humberside Police said the prison would create an estimated 250 more crimes each year.

The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) said it had carried out impact assessments. It said in a statement: "We commissioned all the appropriate impact assessments required for the planning process using the standard methodologies. "These included traffic, environmental, and public service impact reports which have been submitted to the local authority."

Ch Supt Ward said: "Comparisons with similar sized Category B prisons to that proposed in the planning application show recorded criminal offences to be circa 250 per year, the majority of which (circa 150) are recorded violence offences. "These offences require investigation which will place significant additional demand on Humberside Police."

The MOJ said they were not aware of any evidence that shows the risk of crime increases around areas with prisons in them. As well as a rise in crime, however, Ch Supt Ward also cited concerns over the impact on the community and transport network. He added that the village of Full Sutton "already suffers from significant non-village traffic flow due to the current prison facility" and "insufficient public transport to mitigate the anticipated traffic flow increase".

The existing prison - HMP Full Sutton - is a maximum security prison for men in Category A and Category B. It has a capacity of about 150 male inmates. The new facility proposed by the MoJ would house 1,440 inmates. Category C prisons are training and resettlement prisons, which allow inmates the opportunity to integrate back into the community on release.

Objections have also been received from more than 100 members of the public and protests have been held over the plans. Dozens of people gathered to protest in March, saying the area would be unable to cope with the extra traffic and it would make the area less desirable.

Tuesday, 25 June 2019

A Thought Piece

As we reflect on the passing of Paul Senior, I notice this tweet from the British Journal of Community Justice:- 
"The BJCJ is saddened to hear the news of Paul Senior's passing over the weekend. As a founding member of the Journal, his contribution has been wide and long-lasting. In tribute, we are featuring a special back issue of the journal. It was the last one that Paul edited."
The link to the issue can be found here and in light of the current discussion regarding the future shape of probation, I've selected the following:- 

Tragedy and Farce in Organisational Upheavals for Probation: What Next?

Is this an unlikely scenario, circa 2011? Government hiring a consultant in organisational and personnel management and challenging them to:

“Map out a way of changing the entire organisational matrix of probation. This is your brief:
  • Undo the governance arrangements completely and create a bifurcated and multiple ownership model using a range of companies with no experience of running probation services
  • As it worked so badly in 2001 when 17 chiefs were retired at a stroke losing the leadership skills of a service at a time when a new national organisation was created, repeat this tragedy as farce in 2014 so aim at, at least, 13 CEOs leaving the Trusts as the new organisations are created thus decimating leadership
  • Create new arrangements which will downgrade the skills of its workforce, create confusion over what is required to be a probation practitioner and then squeeze funds to the extent that redundancy, low morale and sickness escalates and the core of probation, its workers, are decimated, set against each other and disillusioned.”
And yet this is just what has unfolded in the most farcical episode in probations' rich, if turbulent, history of organisational change. The changes initiated by Transforming Rehabilitation (TR) are maybe more disruptive than previous changes but there have been plenty of changes since the steady state of 1970s and 1980s. For most of the last forty years, probation has been a local public service managed via a variety of Probation Committees (magistrates initially as the employers) and then Boards with a changing relationship with its courts, local authorities, the region and the centre. At one time the local authority also contributed to part of its budget, though the extent of local oversight was limited as direction has always come from the centre. This gathered pace when probation was projected ‘centre stage’ in the early 1990s and a more managed service was required. Boards became more diversified to include representatives from business and finance and the occasional academic. 

However, the funding requirements, controlled by the centre, ensured increasing compliance to central direction, ultimately increasing such control so that a National Probation Service was created in 2001. It was an opportunity for influence and recognition for the distinctive work of the probation service but which ultimately failed. A closer relationship with a more dominant partner, the prison service, a succession of lack lustre national leaderships plus a submissive attitude to the demands of government saw probation drift from its core ideals to a weak and divided organisational arrangement lacking rationale, connectedness and a sense of direction. The 2001 version of the NPS did not last and another organisational shift brought Probation Trusts, increased local engagement through Local Criminal Justice Boards and Community Safety Partnerships, regional bodies and enhanced working partnerships with the police and with the third sector. As we reached 2012 the Trusts were regarded, by the government's own measures, as in good health and had become the first public organisation to be awarded the ultimate business kitemark, the British Quality Foundation’s 2011 Gold Medal for Excellence Award.

Now just four years later we have governance models which are predicated on survival and ensuring the new Community Rehabilitation Companies at least break even. Many of the CEOs who started the CRCs before ownership was transferred to a strange band of catering, workfare, cleaning and security companies have now gone or been superseded by senior managers from the owners. There is no continuity between the different providers and less and less organic links with the new National Probation Service despite originally sharing buildings and having a common IT language. Now many models prevail and communication has become difficult.

Leadership is a difficult issue to get right. Too often the balance between management and leadership is blurred. In 2001 there was a strong move to centralise probation policy and practice and make all local areas dance to a new choreography (National Probation Service, 2001). For the new director faced with a brain drain of 17 Chiefs, amongst which were some of its most innovative thinkers and leaders, an administrative model prevailed and the new chiefs were managers working on behalf of a target-driven centre. This did not work well and as successive central leaders failed to resist the prisonisation of probation local leaders began to emerge. The new Trusts arrived with a younger, more female dominated leadership of the 35 Trusts which through its representative organ, the Probation Chiefs Association (PCA), began to drive forward a new agenda. Evidence showed it was performing well and innovating around such issues as Integrated Offender Management (IOM), domestic violence, sex offenders, accredited programmes, desistance agendas, the Offender Engagement Programme, etc. PCA as a fledging organisation, was beginning to assert itself and give a voice, often a female voice, to the views of its leadership in ways which approached the earlier more vocal ACOP in the recent past. Even if you took the ultimate government measure of success, reducing re offending, it was demonstrable on MoJ's own statistics that being on probation in the Trusts did help reduce reoffending (MoJ Analytical Services, 2013). During the early TR debates, this leadership was visible and articulated its dismay at the dismantling of the successful Trust arrangements. However, the corporate silencing which was imposed by the MoJ quietened that voice to a whisper and it felt that at that moment the leadership lost its power to influence the changes. Indeed many faced with the uncomfortable job of making TR work either resigned or were quietly invited to do so. Once again the leadership was decimated and as the new arrangements emerged, it did so with a much less experienced set of individuals, nervous about their futures whether as a result of their civil servant status in the NPS or the insecurity of their future in the new CRCs. The voice of that new leadership has been largely silent.

Ironically the review of research initiated by the MoJ (MoJ Analytical Services, 2013) which drew on the good practice highlighted above suggested the following four characteristics should be at the centre of the new organisational arrangements:

• Skilled, trained practitioners;
• Well-sequenced, holistic approaches;
• Services and interventions delivered in a joined-up, integrated manner;
• Need for high quality services. (Senior, 2013)

I posed this question rhetorically in a blog concerning these aspirations in 2013:

’High quality services? Where can we possibly find a public service with top quality kite mark awards, reductions of up to 10 per cent in reoffending from community orders, a highly trained and motivated staff group, delivering integrated holistic services in cooperation with voluntary and private providers? Is this why we are seeking new providers? Wait, these criteria are met by an organisation in existence – probation trusts. So it makes sense to rip them in two, give it to providers with aspirations but little track record.’ (Senior, 2013)

If the farce of diminishing the leadership was enough to impact on probation, it is a further tragedy that the organisational changes have wrought an existential crisis at the heart of the probation profession. This is discussed elsewhere in this volume (see Worrall et al.) which interrogates the impact on the occupational culture; here it is sufficient to note the warnings from voices rising above the parapet to reveal a sorry tale of the disestablishment of the Probation ideal. It can be summarised emotionally as confrontational, demoralising and divisive. In practical terms the status of probation officer has been diminished, particularly but not exclusively, in the CRCs; colleagues have been set against each other as they work for different organisations; communications have been made more complex and IT systems have proliferated without positive interconnected outcomes. At the time of writing, redundancies, sometimes as much as 40 per cent, are likely to be implemented! Training arrangements within the CRCs are undermined and practice is often being devolved to PSO equivalents in both NPS through E3 (NPS, 2016) and in the various models of the CRCs. There are, nevertheless, examples of good practice across the country, maybe in spite of rather than because of the arrangements. The future of probation as a profession is threatened by these changes yet skilled, trained practitioners were at the heart of the research evidence quoted above (MoJ Analytical Services, 2013). One voice picked at random from Twitter sums up the crisis:
'#probation fast becoming a concept, not an institution/public service NPS enforcement and CRCs failed business.' (@sadSPO, 5th March 2016)
140 characters says it all. The profession is under threat.

So, above are insights into the changes, below are some of the fears and hopes expressed at the conversation in Kendal.

Fears
• Commodification of emotional labour (see Knight et al. in this volume);
• Individualist, oppressive, competitive environments;
• Silos will be created with no common language to ease communication;
• Individual CRCs will be amalgamated for the needs of efficiency thus breaking local links even more;
• Loss of expertise/local community links following abolition of trusts. Where is the link with courts in CRCs?;
• Management becomes procedural not professional;
• Commercial imperatives are prioritised at the expense of best practice;
• The mantra becomes low cost service for maximum profit;
• Workforce no longer expects to stay in probation for life - short term work then move on;
• New managerialism defines training, then practice, of managers.

Hopes
• Freed of National Standards this will release the creative potential of CRCs;
• Mobilising the creativity of people to manage change; historically probation staff are resilient;
• Will become more outward looking, the profession of probation expanding to include not just direct probation staff but all working in community rehabilitation and community justice including third tier organisations;
• Creative new way of managing in the changed structure;
• Strong confident leaders who can communicate the meaning and purpose of probation to the public and politicians;
• Strong occupational cultures regardless of diverse organisational contexts buttressed by an independent voice for the profession, the Probation Institute.

The future of a recognisable probation institution is at risk given the organisational changes, arguably more invasive than previous attempts. Bifurcation of delivery means that integration of services for the individual service user is threatened. The deskilling of qualified Probation staff is a product of where an individual was placed in the reorganisation and not any assessment of their skills and knowledge. This threatens the professional confidence, independence and creative potential of probation staff, an integral part of delivering the always difficult role of probation. The need for effective leadership is compromised by the bifurcated arrangements. Perhaps it is prescient to speculate that when further organisational changes arrive, they may well seek to undo some of the consequences of this farcical and tragic organisational transformation.

Paul Senior 
15/03/2016

Saturday, 22 June 2019

Professor Paul Senior



Very sad to hear that Paul Senior's long battle with illness ended earlier today and I've been asked to publish the following tribute:-

I’m writing to you to find out how to get a blog entry onto your On Probation feed about the death this morning of Professor Paul Senior. You will know that through the TR debacle, while many Chief Officers (and others) were silenced, Paul stood, often alone, as a loud, irritating and critical voice, risking the future of his department at Sheffield Hallam. I am glad he lasted long enough to see his stance wholly vindicated (but not yet long enough to see Grayling get some comeuppance).

Paul was associated with probation from the 1970s. He was initially a probation officer in Doncaster, then a Training Officer in South Yorkshire Probation, before joining Sheffield Hallam University full-time in the 1980s. He became the first ever Professor of Probation Studies. He has trained thousands of probation officers, through the various manifestations of probation qualifying training, conducted and written many probation-related research projects, hosted the CJ Portal at Sheffield Hallam and was, until last year, the elected Chair of the Probation Institute. One of his fortes was to range across the seminars and workshops of a conference and deliver a succinct and accurate summary as the final speaker. He did this for NAPO trainees conferences for years on end. I suspect that there’s barely a probation officer in the country who is not acquainted with Paul himself, his work and his influence.

He died peacefully, with his children, Joe and Hannah, at his side, after a courageous 6-year battle with cancer.

Thanks.

Tony Grapes