I need to say a big thank you to the many readers and contributors who were kind enough to remark on the work of the blog as the news broke. This is very much appreciated and the sheer numbers confirm that, although despised and derided in certain quarters, there is still a role for an independent discussion and information platform that facilitates anonymity and informed debate. Just for the record, there were 4500 hits on Wednesday; 6000 on Thursday and 3300 yesterday, thus confirming that especially in times of crisis, this remains a significant 'go-to' place for information and hence a role in helping to shape the narrative.
It does feel like a victory, but I think we all know much misery is to come as the reunification takes effect and most of probation disappears behind the secretive closed doors of HMPPS with its love of bureaucracy and command and control culture. The fight must continue to break free from this outfit and regain our independence. In the meantime there are many questions that spring to mind, not least what will happen to the volunteers that the CRC's recruited, many of whom are former or current clients? NPS have never seen a role for such people of course as the concept doesn't fit their mindset. What's the position going to be with ViSOR vetting too?
--oo00oo--
It's not a reversal though is it? Spare a thought for the teams in programmes, UPW, drug and alcohol treatment, housing, finance benefit and debt support, partner link workers etc. Who all signed up to work for a probation service and will now be farmed off cheaply to the charity sector, and will be hugely anxious this morning about their jobs.
*****
This is absolutely not a reversal - this is the centralised bureaucracy swallowing up more staff, and moving probation further away from its local roots.
This is absolutely not a reversal - this is the centralised bureaucracy swallowing up more staff, and moving probation further away from its local roots.
*****
It's the people in interventions these days who do more of the traditional probation work, the programmes facilitators, UPW supervisors etc spend more time building relationships and working with service users than officers are enabled to under all the recording requirements.
It's the people in interventions these days who do more of the traditional probation work, the programmes facilitators, UPW supervisors etc spend more time building relationships and working with service users than officers are enabled to under all the recording requirements.
*****
Whilst unions and reformers and politicians celebrate, claim victory and make the headlines, some who's strived tirelessly might not even get a mention. You might just have to buy your own pint to celebrate Jim, but there's no doubt at all you deserve it! But.. Someone needs to keep a close eye on what the privateers do between now and the end date because their only mission now will be to strip every penny out that they can before they go.
Whilst unions and reformers and politicians celebrate, claim victory and make the headlines, some who's strived tirelessly might not even get a mention. You might just have to buy your own pint to celebrate Jim, but there's no doubt at all you deserve it! But.. Someone needs to keep a close eye on what the privateers do between now and the end date because their only mission now will be to strip every penny out that they can before they go.
*****
Today's announcement is neither a broad-spectrum antibiotic nor a panacea of any kind, its merely an acknowledgement of the diagnosis.
Today's announcement is neither a broad-spectrum antibiotic nor a panacea of any kind, its merely an acknowledgement of the diagnosis.
*****
As the waters of privatisation receded, the destruction TR has caused will be laid bare in its totality. It will be a long and difficult fix structurally, IT nightmares, relocations and reassignments and upheaval everywhere. The damage caused to the workforce could be even more difficult to heal, the wounds as you say have indeed become infected. But today is a good day nevertheless. However long the journey back takes, it can begin knowing it's a step in the right direction.
As the waters of privatisation receded, the destruction TR has caused will be laid bare in its totality. It will be a long and difficult fix structurally, IT nightmares, relocations and reassignments and upheaval everywhere. The damage caused to the workforce could be even more difficult to heal, the wounds as you say have indeed become infected. But today is a good day nevertheless. However long the journey back takes, it can begin knowing it's a step in the right direction.
*****
Too true. A victory but a hollow victory for the casualties along the way. And there will still be much turbulence ahead. Will all CRC staff be TUPE'd back to the NPS? I think not - the NPS won't require some staff and I'm sure the contracts offered could well be less favourable than those currently enjoyed by the long term staff. So concerns about job losses,futures will still be there.
Too true. A victory but a hollow victory for the casualties along the way. And there will still be much turbulence ahead. Will all CRC staff be TUPE'd back to the NPS? I think not - the NPS won't require some staff and I'm sure the contracts offered could well be less favourable than those currently enjoyed by the long term staff. So concerns about job losses,futures will still be there.
*****
No I think the golden share is the key here the equalities of terms is a paramount position anyone going into the NPS will be on equitable terms has to be no two tier. Right to be concerned though that's what the fight coming is about.
No I think the golden share is the key here the equalities of terms is a paramount position anyone going into the NPS will be on equitable terms has to be no two tier. Right to be concerned though that's what the fight coming is about.
*****
There is no TUPE arrangement as the Offender Management Act made us exempt. There is a staff transfer scheme. This will still protect pay and conditions but it does allow the NPS to cherry pick who they want from the CRC and discard the rest after they have reviewed ‘roles and responsibilities’. It’s far from over. I can’t feel jubilant when my colleagues jobs are at risk.
There is no TUPE arrangement as the Offender Management Act made us exempt. There is a staff transfer scheme. This will still protect pay and conditions but it does allow the NPS to cherry pick who they want from the CRC and discard the rest after they have reviewed ‘roles and responsibilities’. It’s far from over. I can’t feel jubilant when my colleagues jobs are at risk.
*****
Spare a thought for those in interventions, who are probably feeling undervalued and very anxious this morning.
Spare a thought for those in interventions, who are probably feeling undervalued and very anxious this morning.
*****
Here we go again. The tattered fag packet used to record Tory probation policy has been dusted off and put back to use. Another headlong rush to design and implement a new system which, will almost inevitably result in more fuck ups. Let's just remember what fuck ups actually mean. Lost careers, more harm caused to our communities; I could go on. It's beholden on us to try to mitigate these as much as we can and make the very best of what is coming to preserve best practice and achieve better outcomes. More working extra hours, more stress through uncertainty; I could go on again. So thanks Jim and all of us who've argued and fought to get to this stage. Good luck to all of us who'll have to get through it. We will because that's what we do but it shan't be easy. The battle is won today but the war to ensure that Probation returns to a sensible locally managed and integral part of the CJS continues. Stay committed my wonderful colleagues and stay safe.
Here we go again. The tattered fag packet used to record Tory probation policy has been dusted off and put back to use. Another headlong rush to design and implement a new system which, will almost inevitably result in more fuck ups. Let's just remember what fuck ups actually mean. Lost careers, more harm caused to our communities; I could go on. It's beholden on us to try to mitigate these as much as we can and make the very best of what is coming to preserve best practice and achieve better outcomes. More working extra hours, more stress through uncertainty; I could go on again. So thanks Jim and all of us who've argued and fought to get to this stage. Good luck to all of us who'll have to get through it. We will because that's what we do but it shan't be easy. The battle is won today but the war to ensure that Probation returns to a sensible locally managed and integral part of the CJS continues. Stay committed my wonderful colleagues and stay safe.
*****
Two cheers for today’s news! As with everything else, the devil will be in the detail. Let us remember that the NPS is not a haven of tranquility. The silence from our ‘leaders’ over the last five years has been deafening and these are the people who will assume that they are taking control of the re- formulated service. A new broom is very much a necessity. We have another disaster looming with OMiC which once again delivers a two tier system between state and private prisons, seemingly with the support of the unions, and staff being ordered into prisons while the government is making noises about strengthening community sentences. Huge thanks to you Jim, the voice of sanity in the wilderness. A victory yes, and something to build upon, but by no means the end of the war. Anyway, let’s enjoy today, restore our energies and prepare for what is to come.
Two cheers for today’s news! As with everything else, the devil will be in the detail. Let us remember that the NPS is not a haven of tranquility. The silence from our ‘leaders’ over the last five years has been deafening and these are the people who will assume that they are taking control of the re- formulated service. A new broom is very much a necessity. We have another disaster looming with OMiC which once again delivers a two tier system between state and private prisons, seemingly with the support of the unions, and staff being ordered into prisons while the government is making noises about strengthening community sentences. Huge thanks to you Jim, the voice of sanity in the wilderness. A victory yes, and something to build upon, but by no means the end of the war. Anyway, let’s enjoy today, restore our energies and prepare for what is to come.
*****
Do we now worry about redundancies, pay parity, terms & conditions?
Do we now worry about redundancies, pay parity, terms & conditions?
*****
In a nutshell, yes. This isn't a joyous occasion.
In a nutshell, yes. This isn't a joyous occasion.
*****
There will certainly be some need for the a transfer process in both directions but lets see if the privateers pull out they will never deliver decent CP or Programmes. NPS already do its own intervention work in SOTP and less reliant for DV in CRCs as they are crap. Lone tutors large groups and massive attrition why pay for that off the failed rate card? New contracts will be a waste of money and they may want to reconsider re badging interventions as probation plus and attach it back to public services proper sharing the same infrastructure and sentence compliance will reduce risks and better the confidence of the whole organisation. No more pandering to failing private companies. I think many will want to see appropriate exit procedures agreements as was before with TR1 but these will need to be enforceable this time round lets hope the unions have learnt a lesson.
There will certainly be some need for the a transfer process in both directions but lets see if the privateers pull out they will never deliver decent CP or Programmes. NPS already do its own intervention work in SOTP and less reliant for DV in CRCs as they are crap. Lone tutors large groups and massive attrition why pay for that off the failed rate card? New contracts will be a waste of money and they may want to reconsider re badging interventions as probation plus and attach it back to public services proper sharing the same infrastructure and sentence compliance will reduce risks and better the confidence of the whole organisation. No more pandering to failing private companies. I think many will want to see appropriate exit procedures agreements as was before with TR1 but these will need to be enforceable this time round lets hope the unions have learnt a lesson.
*****
Big thanks to Jim, and contributors to the blog, Napo, Unison, Dame Glenys, Frances Crook, Russell Webster & many many more. But...... Gauke said on TV this morning that "the widespread reform of Probation Services was necessary in 2014". No, David, it was not. Do NOT mistake today's news as any sort of victory. As many posts on here are suggesting, its merely a political strategy for something equally or more divisive & damaging. TR was not such a stealthy process - hindsight shows it was openly discussed but either missed or dismissed. Do not make the same mistake with Gauke's reforms.
*****
Lets hope there is a redundancy package for those of us that have now been shafted twice.
Lets hope there is a redundancy package for those of us that have now been shafted twice.
*****
I'm currently with the NPS and after 5 years felt like I needed a change in terms of the role, type of caseload etc. I decided to apply and have been offered a position with the CRC. With today's news I'm unsure where to progress with my career
I'm currently with the NPS and after 5 years felt like I needed a change in terms of the role, type of caseload etc. I decided to apply and have been offered a position with the CRC. With today's news I'm unsure where to progress with my career
*****
Please remove Probation from the Civil Service as I did not sign up to the code of conduct when I joined NPS. I have take the comments within the documents 'We want to turn Probation back into a profession on a par with teachers and Social Worker's.' Are they having a laugh? Same people that have shafted our pay, terms and conditions over the last 10 years. Afraid I might not be around long enough to find out.
Please remove Probation from the Civil Service as I did not sign up to the code of conduct when I joined NPS. I have take the comments within the documents 'We want to turn Probation back into a profession on a par with teachers and Social Worker's.' Are they having a laugh? Same people that have shafted our pay, terms and conditions over the last 10 years. Afraid I might not be around long enough to find out.
*****
I so hope voluntary redundancy is offered. I've had enough!
*****
If we haven't seen any "innovative" approaches to reoffending (as opposed to innovative ways of cutting staff without paying the going rate) in the last 4-5 years, isn't that a fairly good signal that there aren't really any left to discover?
If we haven't seen any "innovative" approaches to reoffending (as opposed to innovative ways of cutting staff without paying the going rate) in the last 4-5 years, isn't that a fairly good signal that there aren't really any left to discover?
*****
Imagine if this had happened in a large company, listed on the London Stock Market. A director forces through a major organisational change without a clear rationale, against all advice from experts and without testing it first. Brooking no opposition, he goes on to push the reforms through at an unrealistically fast pace, with the deliberate intention of making them harder to reverse later. The outcome for the company is exactly as predicted... the reforms don’t work, there are numerous and serious customer complaints, the company loses credibility, and a very large amount of money.
The director responsible would almost certainly lose his job. If this didn’t happen before the next shareholder AGM, it would happen very soon after. So why are the consequences not the same in government as in business?
For me, the big story is more than simply a botched privatisation. It’s about the personalities involved and the lack of checks and balances. Surely, as UK PLC’s director responsible for the criminal justice system, Grayling’s role should have been to ask probing questions, to test assumptions, to heed advice, to operate on facts and to insist on a cautious, reversible approach. He did none of this, and so in my opinion he is not fit to hold a senior position within the government. But it looks as though he will get away without even having to explain or apologise. This is plain wrong.
*****
Renationalisation is great, but just announcing it won't make it happen. There's a lot of things to change, and I'd suggest there's not a lot of time left until the current contracts expire to implement all that needs to be done. I'd like to see the MoJ being pushed to make a statement on how they plan to go about renationalisation, what's the process, and what impacts there's likely to be on things like OMIC.A botched privatisation followed by a botched renationalisation wouldn't be in anyone's interest.
Imagine if this had happened in a large company, listed on the London Stock Market. A director forces through a major organisational change without a clear rationale, against all advice from experts and without testing it first. Brooking no opposition, he goes on to push the reforms through at an unrealistically fast pace, with the deliberate intention of making them harder to reverse later. The outcome for the company is exactly as predicted... the reforms don’t work, there are numerous and serious customer complaints, the company loses credibility, and a very large amount of money.
The director responsible would almost certainly lose his job. If this didn’t happen before the next shareholder AGM, it would happen very soon after. So why are the consequences not the same in government as in business?
For me, the big story is more than simply a botched privatisation. It’s about the personalities involved and the lack of checks and balances. Surely, as UK PLC’s director responsible for the criminal justice system, Grayling’s role should have been to ask probing questions, to test assumptions, to heed advice, to operate on facts and to insist on a cautious, reversible approach. He did none of this, and so in my opinion he is not fit to hold a senior position within the government. But it looks as though he will get away without even having to explain or apologise. This is plain wrong.
*****
Renationalisation is great, but just announcing it won't make it happen. There's a lot of things to change, and I'd suggest there's not a lot of time left until the current contracts expire to implement all that needs to be done. I'd like to see the MoJ being pushed to make a statement on how they plan to go about renationalisation, what's the process, and what impacts there's likely to be on things like OMIC.A botched privatisation followed by a botched renationalisation wouldn't be in anyone's interest.
*****
Managing a medium sized homeless charity we would sooner p*** glass than work with the MOJ.
Managing a medium sized homeless charity we would sooner p*** glass than work with the MOJ.
*****
It's been an expensive victory: the money wasted by Grayling, and the probation culture and infrastructure torn apart. If there is a positive, it's that outsourcing has its practical limits. Privatisation can make things worse. I know all this was known at the time and anyone with knowledge and experience of the criminal justice system told Grayling he was making a big mistake – but you can't reason with ideological fundamentalists who are 'irredeemably flawed'. I hope that in the future, when the probation culture is reimagined and reconstituted, it will have more backbone than it showed in the years leading up to TR, when it was in thrall to managerialism and all that jazz. Few come out of this mess with any credit, but I would say the probation inspectorate under Glenys Stacey told the truth to power and On Probation Blog kept the flame alive.
It's been an expensive victory: the money wasted by Grayling, and the probation culture and infrastructure torn apart. If there is a positive, it's that outsourcing has its practical limits. Privatisation can make things worse. I know all this was known at the time and anyone with knowledge and experience of the criminal justice system told Grayling he was making a big mistake – but you can't reason with ideological fundamentalists who are 'irredeemably flawed'. I hope that in the future, when the probation culture is reimagined and reconstituted, it will have more backbone than it showed in the years leading up to TR, when it was in thrall to managerialism and all that jazz. Few come out of this mess with any credit, but I would say the probation inspectorate under Glenys Stacey told the truth to power and On Probation Blog kept the flame alive.
*****
Everything that has been going on with probation, all the unneeded stress that is unrelated to the core values of rehabilitation, and all the political crap that goes with it, is what has now lead to me resigning. No one higher up the food chain actually seems to care about the clients, I've stuck it out for long enough purely for the sake of the clients, but not, I've had enough and will be leaving my dream job behind me. I may come back, but I highly doubt it.
Everything that has been going on with probation, all the unneeded stress that is unrelated to the core values of rehabilitation, and all the political crap that goes with it, is what has now lead to me resigning. No one higher up the food chain actually seems to care about the clients, I've stuck it out for long enough purely for the sake of the clients, but not, I've had enough and will be leaving my dream job behind me. I may come back, but I highly doubt it.
*****
Will staff be made redundant in CRCs? 'It is too early to confirm the impact on CRC staff.
The changes we have announced today are about strengthening probation services and supporting staff. Retaining the skills and knowledge of probation professionals within the system is a key priority for the department. However, we are aware of skills gap within the service which we will be addressing in the near future. We are in the process of gathering data on all those delivering services for or on behalf of CRCs to make sure we fully understand the roles and remits. This will inform our future planning.'
While everyone is celebrating just remember it could be tougher getting back into the new model then it was when we were all kicked out of it..... good luck to all, it's going to be a very stressful time. The Staff from the CRC's aren't all going to make it, at the end of the day both NPS and CRC staff have worked hard but CRC's are the underdogs in all of this so don't open that champagne bottle yet, not until you have that contract in your hands if that is where your future lies.
Will staff be made redundant in CRCs? 'It is too early to confirm the impact on CRC staff.
The changes we have announced today are about strengthening probation services and supporting staff. Retaining the skills and knowledge of probation professionals within the system is a key priority for the department. However, we are aware of skills gap within the service which we will be addressing in the near future. We are in the process of gathering data on all those delivering services for or on behalf of CRCs to make sure we fully understand the roles and remits. This will inform our future planning.'
While everyone is celebrating just remember it could be tougher getting back into the new model then it was when we were all kicked out of it..... good luck to all, it's going to be a very stressful time. The Staff from the CRC's aren't all going to make it, at the end of the day both NPS and CRC staff have worked hard but CRC's are the underdogs in all of this so don't open that champagne bottle yet, not until you have that contract in your hands if that is where your future lies.
*****
My view is that HR, Admin and IT are in the trouble zone. Frontline staff are likely ok but any specialist roles you may have been promoted to are likely worth zero. The SMT will, as always, make sure they are well looked after. SPOs may find it difficult to correlate a suitable transfer. I'm happy to be corrected if anyone has other views though.
My view is that HR, Admin and IT are in the trouble zone. Frontline staff are likely ok but any specialist roles you may have been promoted to are likely worth zero. The SMT will, as always, make sure they are well looked after. SPOs may find it difficult to correlate a suitable transfer. I'm happy to be corrected if anyone has other views though.
*****
I'm not sure even all CRC offender management staff in positions in the CRC are a done deal. NPS already has too many PSOs and not enough work for them, continues to recruit trainee POs and there is no hold on current SPO recruitment in the NPS either. It will all come down to the figures of what is needed. I suspect only a % of those CRC staff are likely to move into NPS, probably not all.
I'm not sure even all CRC offender management staff in positions in the CRC are a done deal. NPS already has too many PSOs and not enough work for them, continues to recruit trainee POs and there is no hold on current SPO recruitment in the NPS either. It will all come down to the figures of what is needed. I suspect only a % of those CRC staff are likely to move into NPS, probably not all.