Saturday, 11 May 2019

Privatisation On The Wane

As speculation grows as to exactly what the MoJ has up its sleeve in order to fix the probation omnishambles, I've been pointed in the direction of this article on the Public Finance website from February regarding the whole vexed topic of privatisation post-Carillion:- 

Coming home: local government insourcing

The collapse of contracting giant Carillion one year ago sent shockwaves through both the private and public sectors. It was Britain’s second largest construction company, and its liquidation has been named as the “largest ever in the UK”. Creaking under the weight of £1.5bn in debts, Carillion’s demise, according to the National Audit Office, cost the public purse £148m as it picked up 420 abandoned public service contracts – in organisations ranging from schools and hospitals to prisons and the armed forces.

At the policy level, the Carillion story led to a thorough interrogation of the outsourcing model. Outsourcing had grown in popularity since being kickstarted in the 1980s by then prime minister Margaret Thatcher, when local authorities were effectively forced to open inhouse services to the private sector to cut costs. From 2010, outsourcing was championed enthusiastically by Cabinet Office minister Francis Maude, whose Open Public Services white paper set out plans for a diverse marketplace for public services.

What a difference five or six years can make. MPs on the works and pensions, business, and public administration committees all made some trenchant comments. “The failure of Carillion reflects long-term failures of government understanding about the design, letting and management of contracts and outsourcing,” said the public administration committee in its report last summer.

The Carillion crisis gave opponents of outsourcing ammunition to launch a full-scale attack, and the government has had to shift position. Current Cabinet Office minister David Lidington has reaffirmed the government’s commitment to outsourcing, but intends to bring in a raft of new regulations to improve transparency and secure social value. A ‘living wills’ pilot is testing contingency arrangements in the event of another Carillion-style collapse.

Despite this, the debate rumbles on, especially with ongoing concerns over another large government contractor, Interserve. This company’s troubles also became evident at the start of last year and it has been battling to stay afloat ever since. In December, it was seeking a second rescue deal as it struggled with £500m of debt.

Interserve has so far survived, with the government allowing it to continue to bid for public contracts, confident that it is not in the same dire financial situation as Carillion. But it will surely have spooked a local authority sector that looks like it was already starting to have second thoughts about outsourcing, as PF reported in March last year.

We highlighted Southwark council, which saved £4.35m after bringing its customer services back inhouse in 2013. Now, an exclusive PF investigation via freedom of information requests shines a light on council outsourcing over the past five financial years. It reveals a dramatic slowdown in the amount of money local authorities have been spending. Carillion’s collapse happened towards the end of the period that PF examined: was it the nail in the coffin for local government outsourcing?

FOI responses from 60 councils across England show a stark tailing off in the value of outsourced contracts. Where there was a 39% increase in the value of contracts between 2013-14 and 2014-15, this had almost flattened to just 1.6% between 2016-17 and 2017-18, with much smaller rises in the intervening years.

The most common services outsourced over the five-year period were waste management (17% of respondents), facilities maintenance and management (17%) and leisure services management (13%). A range of contracts were signed over the five-year period, from snow clearing to waste management to stray dog kennelling.

There were fewer similarities in the services councils chose to insource during that time, with authorities bringing back inhouse everything from cleaning services to highways maintenance to IT services. PF analysis finds examples of councils that have made considerable savings by bringing services back inhouse. East Riding of Yorkshire Council is one of the councils that put a figure on how much insourcing had saved it. The local authority has reduced costs by £2m since 2013 after bringing back inhouse services like staff training, occupational health, payroll, IT and print and design. The council did not respond to questions from PF on why it made these decisions.

Derby City Council has also saved more than £1m in the past two years after bringing highways maintenance – a contract previously held by Carillion – back under council control. David Kinsey, head of highways, says: “We were confident we could run things more efficiently.” He points out this was not because the council was unhappy with the service provided by the contractor. “It would be easy for me to sit here and say it was all because of the big bad contractor, but, actually, when we reflect on it, there were questions to be asked about whether we were writing the right contracts and whether we managed them effectively.”

Notably, not all contracts brought back under council control have been successful. Maidstone Borough Council brought a cafeteria within council property back inhouse at a cost of £220,000 between 2016 and 2018, but subsequently decided to re-outsource the management. Laurence Tricker, programme and projects manager at Maidstone, explains: “The decision was made based on a period of trading by the council during which losses were made. Since being contracted out, the cafĂ© provides rental income and we have reduced our overall management costs.”

The membership organisation the Association for Public Service Excellence surveyed 208 senior local government officers in 2017, before the Carillion collapse. It found that 73% had or were in the process of considering insourcing a service, with 45% having already completed the process. APSE’s head of communications, Mo Baines, says it was austerity that had driven “an increased need for efficiencies and improvements to service quality”. She adds: “While major contract failures like the collapse of Carillion have focused minds, its contribution to the volume of insourcing in local government is of less significance than those contracts already being insourced by local councils.”

Mayor of Hackney Philip Glanville says his council has been on a 10-year journey to bring services back inhouse. “There has not been an example that I am aware of where we have brought something inhouse and it has not cost us less to deliver that service,” he tells PF. “We have seen that at almost every step you get a more coordinated response, save money, create better services and improve terms and conditions for the workforce.” Between 2010 and 2014, the council brought back inhouse its recycling services, saving £600,000. It also took back control of its housing management service, reducing its costs by £300,000.

Matt Dykes, senior policy officer at the TUC, believes outsourcing has had its day. “There has been a growing trend for taking services back inhouse,” he explains. “Someone might suggest that we have reached peak outsourcing – there’s not much else now that can be externalised, and councils are down to core services only.” Colin Haslam, professor of accounting and finance at Queen Mary University of London, agrees that local authority outsourcing has reached its peak. Many councils had already started the process of “remunicipalisation” as he calls it – the localised provision of services.

Haslam believes the Carillion collapse is likely to mean more local authorities will bring services back inhouse, because of “an increasing risk in relation to the large corporate outsourcers, like Capita, Serco, G4S and Carillion”. Outsourcing commentator John Tizard also agrees that Carillion’s legacy is likely to be muted local authority interest in outsourcing. “There have been some very high-profile failures in outsourcing, which has made many in the public sector – not least local government – question [its] usefulness.”

Tizard tells PF that the backslide in outsourcing is partly because of the lack of financial flexibility the model offers. “In a period of tightening budgets, austerity and uncertainty, it is increasingly recognised that long-term contracts, which lock up sizable parts of your budget, further reduce financial flexibility and consequently the ability to protect frontline services that are not outsourced,” he explains.

A survey by the New Local Government Network from October last year suggests that Carillion has “dented public confidence in partnership arrangements”. NLGN’s poll of nearly 200 council leaders found that 39% wanted to outsource less over the next two years, compared with 15% who were looking to outsource more.

Jessica Studdert, deputy director of NLGN, echoes Tizard. “To cope with financial and demand pressures, councils are increasingly finding they need more flexibility and direct control over services – outsourced contracts tend to be long-term and can be unresponsive to changing circumstances,” she tells PF.

With no sign of financial pressures on councils easing, it could be easy to see why long-term and costly contracts with third parties would appear less attractive. It is not just the local government sector’s views on outsourcing that might have been damaged over the past year. Haslam claims private providers have become “increasingly defensive about taking on any further contracts, and are even handing them back”. Private contractors often view government contracts as too “onerous”, pushing them into loss-making positions, he suggests.

Tizard agrees that the private sector, too, is re-evaluating its position in a post-Carillion world. “The likelihood is that they will increase their risk premium in their charges – I think many contractors will now be looking for a better return and therefore higher charges,” he predicts.

Kerry Hallard, chief executive of the Global Sourcing Association, an industry group, believes local government outsourcing should continue and that Carillion’s failure was not a result of this method of service provision. “Carillion wasn’t an outsourcing failure. Carillion was a corporate governance failure,” she tells PF.

Hallard expresses disdain for the “anti-outsourcing rhetoric” that followed Carillion’s liquidation, including government comments. “There’s no positive communication that comes from government, it is just obsessed with kicking rather than applauding its service providers,” she says. But Hallard concedes that outsourcing is not always effective and that there is scope for change. “Outsourcing shouldn’t be focused just on driving out cost any more – that’s old school,” she claims. Instead, she believes greater efforts should be made to bring SMEs into the fold, with fewer contracts going to the small number of big players.

In Hackney, Glanville agrees there needs to be greater consideration of SMEs in the government’s portfolio of contractors. “Too often, big companies are going through the motions and delivering poor-quality services,” he tells PF.

Walter Akers, partner at consultancy RSM UK, explains why local authorities might prefer larger contractors: “There is a bias towards larger organisations, because they score better on risk and in the procurement process because they’ve got scale, they’ve got strong balance sheets – they’ve got experience.” He also believes Carillion should be a wake-up call for councils when entering into contracts with large private organisations. “Councils think they can continue operating the way they always have after they’ve signed these big commercial deals, and experience shows they can’t. That’s where they end up spending more money longer term than if they kept services inhouse,” he tells PF. Councils should be more savvy in their contract management, he explains.

Akers also points out that, often, local authorities outsource a service to a large organisation that does not necessarily have better skills. “Why was Carillion – primarily a construction firm – running libraries and providing school meals? It’s like going to an Italian restaurant and ordering a curry,” he suggests.

At the TUC, Dykes predicts that more council insourcing is to come. “It won’t change quickly, because you have had 30 years of this mindset and culture, and there will be long-term contracts that may be very difficult to get out of,” he says. “But things are changing already.”

Tizard tells PF: “The current Conservative government has said it sees outsourcing as the principal model for service delivery, but local government is perhaps more sophisticated, and local authorities led by Tories and Labour are all questioning outsourcing,” he says.

PF’s FOI research shows that 60 councils in 2017-18 still contracted out £588m of services. But Studdert says confidence in outsourcing has been shaken and notes a declining appetite among councils. She adds: “That doesn’t mean an end to the role of the private sector in public provision altogether. It means that future partnerships need to be much more clearly built around the overriding imperative to drive deep social impact with public spend. If partnerships are built on a greater sense of shared endeavour and long-term value creation, this should recognise the innate strengths of each and absolute clarity of roles.”

Back to the source

Margaret Thatcher started an increase in public sector outsourcing when she brought in compulsory competitive tendering in 1980. This effectively forced local authorities to open up inhouse services to private competition in an effort to cut costs. It was initially introduced for construction, maintenance and highways work by the 1980 Local Government, Planning and Land Act.

The policy was subsequently repackaged under New Labour. After winning the 1997 election, Tony Blair’s government replaced CCT with best value, forcing councils to look at outsourcing services, although the policy was also intended to consider quality alongside cost. Further outsourcing was encouraged in the 2011 Open Public Services white paper introduced by the coalition government. This suggested that public services should be open to a range of providers – public, private and third sector – with control decentralised to the lowest possible level.

Friday, 10 May 2019

Ducks Form Row

It certainly took some time, but the inevitability of a humiliating admission that TR was an unmitigated disaster of gigantic proportions and that TR2 hasn't a hope in hell of being sold to anyone as a bright new future, has at last dawned on the MoJ and its political masters. Of course it won't be spun like that because taxpayers pay for a huge team of enthusiastic young spin doctors who as we speak are developing the positive narrative that will accompany news of probation reunification. And it's started with this in today's Times:- 

State may take back control of probation service

David Gauke, the justice secretary, is preparing to renationalise probation after a partial privatisation by Chris Grayling that a watchdog branded “irredeemably flawed”. Under the proposals the supervision of tens of thousands of offenders will be taken over by the state-run probation service. Private sector companies will provide treatment programmes and other help to criminals.

In March Dame Glenys Stacey, chief inspector of probation, said the system was “irredeemably flawed” and that the public would be safer if core supervision work were managed by the state. A final decision has yet to be made on moving the supervision of medium and low-risk offenders back into state hands but it is the option favoured by Mr Gauke. “It couldn’t be any worse that what has been going on,” one probation service source said.

--oo00oo--

Of course this has been on the cards for some time with the MoJ spin department having fallen silent some time ago. But we've been reading the runes; the ducks are forming up in rows and the celestial bodies are coming into alignment. The stage is set; it just needs to be packaged as an exciting, bright new future and the politicians have to save face, obviously. There has to be a role for the private sector because Tories believe in privatisation, even though it doesn't work. There has to be a role for the third sector because that gives the impression that the Tories aren't the nasty party and believe in the value of 'charity'. Of course there is the small matter of them having been royally shafted by TR, but that letter the other day ordering a 'bung' makes clear the political dimension to all this:- 
"I intend to put in place a more stable and resilient probation system, which works effectively to protect the public and tackle reoffending. In that context, there is clearly value in maintaining a diverse and varied market of providers able to address the complex needs of individuals in the probation system. Organisations such as these will be key in the future market for probation services; if our failure to stand behind them results in their departure from the market, this could make it difficult for our reformed service to properly do its job from inception."      
In order to save face it looks clear that the private sector will probably be rewarded with hugely-expanded tagging contracts, together with programmes and UPW along the Welsh model. The MoJ will champion the fact that they listened to the evidence from the 'sham' consultation; they heeded the stern words from Bob Neill and took on board the damning reports from the PAC and NAO. Just about everyone can claim success for this outcome; the unions, academics; campaigning groups; this blog even, but it's only a first step. It won't be like it was before and we simply must shake free of HMPPS command and control. But that's for another day folks. In the mean time, lets remind ouselves why TR2 had to be strangled at birth. This from last week:-   

PAC raises concerns over rehabilitation services and wider impacts of failing to support offenders on release from prison.

Report summary

In its haste to rush through its reforms at breakneck speed the Ministry of Justice not only failed to deliver its ‘rehabilitation revolution’ but left probation services underfunded, fragile, and lacking the confidence of the courts.

The Ministry’s attempt to stabilise the contracts, and its decision to terminate them in December 2020 - 14 months early - will cost the taxpayer an additional £467 million.

There has been no noticeable improvement in the support offered to offenders since these reforms were first implemented, and they have failed to reduce reoffending by as much as expected, with the average number of reoffences committed by each reoffender actually increasing.

Through the Gate (TTG) services have failed to provide appropriate support for those released from prison. In some cases, offenders have been provided with tents and left with no fixed address on release from prison. This will ultimately cost the taxpayer more as costs are shunted elsewhere in the system.


Chair's comments

“Despite warnings from this Committee and the National Audit Office over the past three years, the Ministry of Justice has failed to bring about the promised revolution in rehabilitation. Rather than deliver the savings hoped for at the start of the programme, the Ministry’s attempts to address the failures in the reforms have cost the taxpayer an additional £467 million while failing to achieve the anticipated improvements in reoffending behaviour.

“Over-optimistic initial forecasts left the Ministry of Justice fighting fires of their own making since the programme’s inception.

“The Cabinet Office, HM Treasury and the Major Projects Review Group share responsibility for these failures by providing insufficient challenge at the early stages of the project and allowing it to proceed too quickly with insufficient safeguards or testing.

“The way offenders are treated on their release from prison has a significant impact on how they re-integrate into society – the failures of this programme have left offenders unsupported leading to further costs to taxpayers in dealing with both reoffending and supporting individuals failed by the rehabilitation system.

“The Ministry of Justice must demonstrate that it has learnt lessons and be more assertive in addressing the failures of design, delivery and financial planning.”

Conclusions and recommendations

The breakneck speed with which the Ministry introduced the Transforming Rehabilitation reforms created an unacceptable level of risk that was not sufficiently challenged by the safeguards intended to protect the taxpayer. Transforming Rehabilitation was an ambitious programme that contained inherent risks, including combining a ‘black box approach’, using payment by results to incentivise innovation, with extending statutory supervision to offenders sentenced to less than 12 months. The Ministry failed to conduct adequate pilots or to learn sufficiently from similar programmes elsewhere and tied the reforms to a timescale that was undeliverable from the outset. It suffered from optimism bias and gambled on the promises of innovation and it is unacceptable that so many unnecessary risks were taken with taxpayers’ money. The Ministry acknowledges that it implemented its reforms at breakneck speed in order to procure contracts before the 2015 general election. In its haste, it failed to get enough commercial input into its plans. Responding to the problems with these contracts will cost the taxpayer an additional £467 million. Despite the risks involved, the checks and balances for major projects designed to protect the taxpayer, including HM Treasury and the Major Projects Review Group, gave the programme the green light and failed to provide effective challenge.

Recommendation: The Ministry, Cabinet Office and HM Treasury, should write to us by the end of June 2019 to set out what has been done to strengthen the approval and challenge processes both within the Ministry and at the centre of government in response to failed programmes such as this.

The Ministry has created an underfunded and fragile probation market and we are not confident in its ability to cope with further provider failure. In September 2016 we warned about CRCs’ increasing dependence on payment by results and the risks to the financial sustainability of CRCs. The Ministry failed to realise that a payment by results model was not appropriate for probation or that reoffending was not a good measure of performance for CRCs. Its system relied on volumes of work which did not materialise, meaning that CRCs were unable to cover the cost of basic probation services let alone invest in innovation. At the outset, the Ministry modelled a 2% reduction in volumes of work but, two years into the programme, volumes were between 16% and 48% lower than anticipated. In February 2019, Working Links and the three CRCs it owned went into administration, requiring the Ministry to transfer these services to Kent, Surrey and Sussex CRC. The Ministry was confident that it or another provider would be able to step in if other suppliers fail, but it is constrained by a cap which means that no provider can own 25% of the market, and the NPS is already dealing with intolerable workloads. Interserve, the owner of five CRCs, went into administration on 15 March and it is unclear what impact this will have on the future of these contracts.

Recommendation: The Ministry should write to the Committee, by the end of June 2019, providing details of its contingency arrangements in the event of further provider failure, and explaining what it is doing to manage this risk as its contracts proceed to termination in December 2020. The Ministry should also provide the Committee with an outline of how it managed the impact of both Working Links and Interserve collapsing into administration.

The Ministry will not make sustained progress with reducing reoffending until it can provide the support offenders desperately need on leaving prison, including securing stable accommodation. The reforms failed to reduce reoffending by as much as expected and, from 2011 to March 2017, the average number of reoffences committed by each reoffender actually increased by 22%. The number of offenders recalled to prison increased by 47% from January 2015 to September 2018 and the Ministry acknowledges that it is a long way from getting post-sentence supervision right. The Ministry’s Through the Gate (TTG) model has not provided the services it promised and an estimated 2,961 prisoners did not receive TTG services in 2018. Prisons have been releasing prisoners without settled accommodation, with some prisoners having been provided with tents instead. The Ministry does not know how many prisoners have settled accommodation after they leave prison. The cross government Reducing Reoffending Board has met two or three times in its first year but there is little concrete evidence of what it has achieved so far.

Recommendation: The Ministry, working with the Reducing Reoffending Board should report back to this Committee, by the end of June 2019, setting out a cross-government strategy to reduce reoffending, and how it will measure whether this is working.

The Ministry failed to involve voluntary sector organisations in delivering probation services on the scale it promised. We warned in both September 2016 and March 2018 that the Ministry was not doing enough to involve the voluntary sector in efforts to improve rehabilitation services. As at October 2018, just 11% of voluntary sector organisations (VSOs) working in the sector provide services to CRCs, and probation trusts spent less than 3% of their budgets on voluntary and third sector provision. VSOs were frozen out of bidding because they were unable to provide the onerous Parent Company Guarantees required to tender for the contracts. The voluntary sector has also become less involved in providing TTG services, resulting in the loss of better-quality specialist services, that had been provided at no cost to the taxpayer. Currently provision of specialist services on mental health, employment and substance abuse is poor and not tailored to offenders’ needs. The Ministry acknowledges that VSO involvement is patchy and it intends to design its new system to have greater input from VSOs.

Recommendation: When it announces its new approach, the Ministry should write to the Committee to clearly explain what role it expects VSOs to play in the probation system, and what it will do to ensure this role is being fulfilled successfully. The Ministry should also outline how it intends to improve its provision of specialist services and how it will tailor these services to the specific requirements of those in need of support.

The Ministry’s decision to split the probation service has let down offenders and those working in the justice system. The split of probation services between the NPS and CRCs introduced many new points of contact between different parts of the probation system and with the wider justice system, which create friction and require effort and resource to manage. The reforms split the role of probation services in court, so the NPS provides all advice to courts in a pre-sentence report, while CRCs do not attend court. These arrangements undermine sentencers’ confidence in CRCs which, in turn, is partly responsible for the declining use of community sentences – even though community sentences generally lead to better outcomes for offenders. The Ministry failed to anticipate that changes in sentencing practice would increase caseloads for the NPS. As at September 2018 the caseload split between CRCs and the NPS was 59:41 against an original assumption of 64:36. Combined with severe staffing shortages, this has resulted in intolerable workloads for the NPS. Delays to the Ministry’s ICT gateway to provide a link between CRCs and HMPPS have cost the taxpayer £23 million in compensation to CRCs and only two CRCs are currently using the gateway.

Recommendation: If it persists with this flawed structure, the Ministry should urgently spell out how such a separation of probation service can work effectively and what it will do to address the failings with the current system.

If the Ministry does not put into practice the lessons from its failed reform programme it is in danger of repeating the same mistakes again. In July 2018, the Ministry announced that it will terminate its CRC contracts, 14 months early, in December 2020. It has consulted on the future of probation services and plans to procure second-generation contracts in April 2019. It does not yet have a blueprint for its new system. The Ministry has stated that the NAO’s report has provided it with a clear framework of things it must do differently in its new system, and that there was not a single lesson in the report it would not take on board. Despite this, the Ministry has not allowed any more time for its procurement of new contracts than it did last time, although it is working on contingencies that may give it some more time. The Ministry is unable to say whether it will conduct pilots of the new system, conceding that it ‘might’ for some areas.

Recommendation: When it announces its new plans, the Ministry should write to this Committee spelling out exactly how its plans to address the failings set out by this Committee and the NAO, and how it will avoid the same mistakes happening again.

Thursday, 9 May 2019

A Bung for Third Sector

We can but hope that the days of the probation privateers are numbered, but in the meantime I notice that the Justice Secretary has had to direct the Permanent Secretary to cough-up some more cash in the wake of the Working Links collapse as a 'goodwill'  gesture:-

Sir Richard Heaton 
Permanent Secretary 
102 Petty France 
London SW1H 9AJ

8 May 2019

Dear Richard, 

Working Links 

Thank you for your letter of 8 May about the proposal to provide financial support to the Permitted Subcontractors who face losses following the collapse of Working Links and its Community Rehabilitation Companies (CRCs). I am grateful for the scrutiny and advice that you and other officials in the Department have given me on this complex matter. 

I recognise the issues that this course of action causes for you as the Principal Accounting Officer and for the Chief Executive of HMPPS. However, as you set out in your letter to me, there are issues that weigh in my decision to an extent that you are not able to accommodate. 

In particular, I have listened carefully to the arguments put forward by these organisations that the Government has a moral ‘duty of care’ (though we do not, I accept, owe a legal duty of care) to make good these losses. In making that claim, these organisations stress the unique circumstances of this first-generation probation outsourcing, the comfort given by my predecessors about how the Government would steward this market, their status as ‘Permitted Subcontractors’ in our contract structure, and the extent to which these organisations were delivering frontline statutory services on behalf of Government. 

I intend to put in place a more stable and resilient probation system, which works effectively to protect the public and tackle reoffending. In that context, there is clearly value in maintaining a diverse and varied market of providers able to address the complex needs of individuals in the probation system. Organisations such as these will be key in the future market for probation services; if our failure to stand behind them results in their departure from the market, this could make it difficult for our reformed service to properly do its job from inception. 

Against this backdrop, I have concluded that in these particular circumstances, as they relate to the collapse of Working Links and their CRCs, it is reasonable for Government to protect Permitted Subcontractors from the losses they have incurred. I direct you to process these payments once the scale of their exposure is verified. 

You rightly draw to my attention the risks of repercussion from providing this support, specifically in acting outside of the Department’s Managing Public Money obligations, and potentially setting expectations that we would act in the same way if presented with a similar scenario in the future.

To mitigate this risk, you and I have agreed that we will remind Directors in other CRCs and their supply chain of the responsibilities set out in their contracts, and their duties to ensure appropriate financial controls and risk management approaches are in place within their organisations. 

I am absolutely clear that this is a unique response to a unique and specific set of circumstances. There should be no expectation that I would agree to replicate this approach in future.

RT HON DAVID GAUKE MP

Wednesday, 8 May 2019

Lib Dem Apology Required

I see that the Liberal Democrats are consulting on probation and prison reforms. I don't know about anyone else, but given their wholehearted support for destroying the probation service with TR whilst part of the coalition government, I'd expect an acknowledgement and apology first. 

Background 

This consultation paper is presented as the first stage in the development of new Liberal Democrat policy in relation to the rehabilitation of offenders. It does not represent agreed party policy. It is designed to stimulate debate and discussion within the party and outside. Based on the response generated and the deliberations of the spokespeople, a full policy paper will be drawn up and presented to Conference for debate. 

The paper has been drawn up by Jonathan Marks, Liberal Democrat Lords Spokesperson for Justice, and Mike German, Spokesperson for Rehabilitation and Probation. They are both prepared to speak on the paper to outside bodies and to discussion meetings organised within the party. 

Comments on the paper, and requests for speakers, should be addressed to: Lord German, Liberal Democrats, 8-10 Great George St, London, SW1P 3AE Email: mike.german@libdems.org.uk 

Comments should reach us as soon as possible and no later than Friday 3rd May 2019. Further copies of this paper can be found online at www.libdems.org.uk/policy_papers

1. Introduction 

1.1 The primary purpose of the penal system should be to prevent crime by successfully rehabilitating offenders, so they do not go on to commit further crimes in the future. Prisons are necessary to protect the public from serious and dangerous offenders, but the main focus of the criminal justice system must be on stopping re-offending. 

1.2 That objective requires offenders to be given appropriate sentences; prisons to provide for rehabilitation, recovery, learning and work, with suitable treatment, education and work available to all prisoners; and services in both prison and the community to help turn people away from crime, including housing, education and training, healthcare and treatment for addiction. 

1.3 Britain’s current penal system falls far short of that standard. Prisons are overcrowded and understaffed; prisoners spend too much time locked in their cells, unable to engage in productive activity or receive rehabilitative services; and rates of violence, drug use, self-harm and suicide are far too high and rising. 

1.4 ‘Through the Gate’ resettlement services and supervision of offenders are failing badly. In particular, the Community Rehabilitation Companies responsible for low- and medium-risk offenders have failed to achieve reductions in re-offending rates, largely because the Government has underfunded and mismanaged the ‘payment-byresults’ contracts. The Ministry of Justice has been forced to end these contracts early. 

1.5 The provision of services in the community is also inadequate. Many former offenders are not able to find work, and the financial support they receive is often not enough to cover even basic necessities. Far too many prisoners become homeless upon release from prison. Physical and mental health care and addiction treatment are often inconsistent and insufficient. 

1.6 As a result, re-offending rates remain far too high. 30% of offenders are convicted of committing at least one new offence within a year of leaving custody or receiving a non-custodial sentence, a Spring Conference 2019 reprimand or a warning. For under-18s, the rate is even higher, at 40%. These rates have remained essentially unchanged for more than a decade. 

1.7 The Liberal Democrats believe that we must significantly reduce the prison population, which is the largest in Western Europe, including by making greater use of tough, effective community sentences – especially in place of short prison sentences, which have proved particularly ineffective – and ending the imprisonment of people for drug possession for personal use. 

1.8 We must also radically transform prisons themselves: building rehabilitation and recovery into their design, dramatically improving conditions and ensuring more time is spent in purposeful activity. That includes meaningful work, education and training, and access to good leisure and sports facilities. Prisoners should have access to IT and digital skills training. 

1.9 However, tackling re-offending requires a more radical approach to penal reform. At the heart of the problem is a lack of coordination and continuity of services. We therefore propose a radically new, holistic approach to rehabilitation, spanning sentencing, prisons and community supervision and including a full range of rehabilitative services. 

1.10 We would give responsibility to local co-ordinating bodies to ensure the proper supervision of each offender and ex-offender in their area. These bodies would commission the services they need for rehabilitation, both in prison and in the community. 

1.11 The Government must also think differently about the costs and benefits of rehabilitation. Improving staffing and conditions in prisons, the quality of supervision in the community and the provision of services will all require significant investment. However, against this must be set against the huge societal and financial benefits of reducing reoffending – including less crime and therefore fewer victims of crime, fewer people in prison, and more people in work. The current budgetary process does not account for these savings to the public purse. 

1.12 In this paper, we set out our proposal for a new system of coordinating the work of all bodies in the public, private and voluntary sectors which have either a responsibility for rehabilitating offenders or simply a willingness to help former offenders turn their lives around. We also detail the myriad of problems that blight our prison and probation services and set out a number of further proposals to address them. We will consult on these proposals with both party members and external stakeholders before presenting a final policy paper to Conference.

2. A new holistic approach 

2.1 The core of our proposal is a new model centred on individual offenders and their rehabilitative needs. 

2.2 Local public bodies would be given responsibility for coordinating all services for an offender, from the point of sentencing all the way through prison or any community sentence and post-sentence supervision. 

2.3 These new co-ordinating bodies would be funded directly by the Ministry of Justice and charged with commissioning services from a range of providers depending on the needs of the offender. 

2.4 But central direction from the Ministry of Justice cannot possibly deal with the many different essential services needed for individual offenders. Services have to be provided locally and they should therefore be co-ordinated by a local body which can build strong relationships with providers in their area. 

2.5 In order to prevent a postcode lottery from developing, the Ministry of Justice would set a national policy framework and local bodies would be accountable to it. 

2.6 Each co-ordinating body would have a mandate to ensure that courts, prison governors, probation services, police forces, local authorities, housing associations, the Department for Work & Pensions, the National Health Service, providers of treatment for addiction and third-sector providers all work closely together to co-ordinate and provide all the services an individual offender might need to rebuild a life free from crime. 

2.7 This would enable the third sector to strengthen its role in supporting the work of rehabilitation – one of the aims of Transforming Rehabilitation, the Coalition Government’s 2013 white paper. There are many good examples of successful third-sector organisations who are making a real difference in offenders’ lives. Our proposal would provide sufficient funding for these organisations to scale up their services.

2.8 We would also want to see private sector employers willing to provide training and employment to former offenders in close contact with the co-ordinating bodies. There are increasing numbers of employers who are dedicated to giving former offenders training and employment and their role in rehabilitation is extremely important. 

2.9 These co-ordinating bodies should be low-cost operations, based in the offices of other services with relatively small staffs, diverted from other parts of the justice system if possible. 

2.10 There are a number of forms that these new bodies could take. They could be run directly by the Ministry of Justice, by local authorities or as independent organisations. They could include representatives of local service providers or be completely independent. 

2.11 There is also the related question of what geographical area each body should serve. One option would be for each upper- or single tier local authority to have one, but 174 of these bodies seems excessive. Other options include one for each of the 43 police force areas; one for each of the 21 Community Rehabilitation Companies; or one for each of the 11 proposed probation regions.

5. Probation 

5.1 Under Section 2 of the Offender Rehabilitation Act 2014, anyone leaving prison after a sentence of more than a day but less than two years is subject to a mandatory supervision period of at least 12 months. The Act specifies that “The purpose of the supervision period is the rehabilitation of the offender.” 

5.2 We support the mandatory supervision of offenders after their release from prison. As set out in Section 3, we also believe that greater use should be made of tough community-based sentences involving supervision, as an alternative to prison. But they must be made to work effectively – and that means the deployment of additional resources. 

5.3 Since 2015, probation provision has been split between the National Probation Service (NPS), which is responsible for supervising ‘high-risk’ offenders, and 21 Community Rehabilitation Companies (CRCs), which have responsibility for ‘low- and medium-risk’ offenders. 

5.4 The NPS is generally performing reasonably well, although staff shortages mean that probation officers often have to contend with very high workloads and are therefore not able to give offenders the attention they need. Officers are subjected to considerable stress, which has markedly sapped morale in the service. 

5.5 The CRCs, on the other hand, are failing badly and have come nowhere near meeting their objectives. Inspections have revealed a range of problems, including: 
  • “Insufficient contact, a lack of meaningful contact and poor continuity of contact with those under probation supervision”, with many CRCs supervising individuals by telephone only. This can make it impossible for CRCs to enforce probation requirements properly.
  • “Insufficient purposeful activity”, with more than one in ten offenders receiving no purposeful activity at all.
  • “Very poor Through the Gate services,” with one in ten people released from prison without a roof over their heads. 
  • A lack of services to meet individuals’ needs, with people sometimes left waiting many months for services or not receiving them at all. 
5.6 Based on these inspections, HM Inspectorate of Probation has concluded that: “there has been little innovative work to reduce reoffending, voluntary sector involvement in probation services is ever diminishing and resettlement services provided to prisoners before release are poor.” 

5.7 Trade unions warn that morale of probation officers, in both the NPS and CRCs, is at an “all-time low”. We believe that probation officers perform an important public duty and must be properly recognised and supported in their work. We are concerned that low morale will make it harder both to retain experienced officers and to recruit new ones. 

5.8 In 2018, the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee found that “the extent of involvement of the third sector in delivering probations services has been woeful” – partly because of the underfunding of CRC contracts, and partly because “many third-sector organisations are withdrawing from probation services because the support they provided is now part of government probation supervision”.  

5.9 The Justice Select Committee found that “CRC performance in reducing reoffending, particularly the number of times an offender reoffends, has been disappointing” and concluded that “we do not think that the payment by results mechanism provides sufficient incentives to providers to reduce reoffending”. 

5.10 The Committee also highlighted problems resulting from the split of probationers between the NPS and CRCs based on risk, including “co-ordination challenges” and the fact that “the risk of harm an individual poses can change over time”. The Howard League for Penal Reform argues that the “two-tier system” created by this split “is the central flaw corrupting the whole edifice” and that it should be reintegrated into a single service. 

5.11 In July to September 2018, the Ministry of Justice consulted on proposals to end the current CRC contracts early (in 2020 rather than 2022); replace the current system of 21 CRCs and seven NPS districts with 11 probation regions; and introduce a requirement that offenders are seen face-to-face at least once a month during the first year of supervision. The Government has not yet announced the outcome of this consultation. 

5.12 Reforms to the current system of CRCs – including ending the existing contracts early and putting new contracts in place on better terms – are clearly necessary. However, we do not believe these will go nearly far enough to address the major problems in probation. 

5.13 Our proposal of local bodies with responsibility for all of an offender’s probation and rehabilitative services would solve the “coordination challenges” identified by the Justice Select Committee. Local commissioning would enable a proper multi-agency approach, including public, private and third-sector providers. 

5.14 The imposition and enforcement of supervision requirements plays an important role in rehabilitation. However, relatively minor breaches of licence requirements too often result in offenders being returned to prison, damaging their prospects for rehabilitation and contributing to the problems of prison overcrowding. 

5.15 The number of people recalled to custody has increased in recent years. 22,542 people were returned to custody after licence recall in 2018, compared to 19,662 in 2015.53 At the end of 2018, there were 6,965 people in prison on recall – an 18% increase since May 2015.  The majority of these are recalled for licence breaches alone, not for having committed new offences. 

5.16 The improvements to rehabilitation services we are proposing will help to reduce the number of people facing recall. However, we also believe that probation services and the courts should be encouraged or required to take a more graduated approach to sanctioning people for breaching their licence conditions, returning them to prison only as a last resort.

Monday, 6 May 2019

Rory Gets Out of Jail Free

I've said it before and I'll say it again. Politics is as much about being lucky as anything and Gavin Williamson getting the chop was the perfect opportunity to get Rory Stewart out of a tricky situation at the MoJ. 

Despite him being highly regarded in many quarters, it's certainly the view taken by the POA, together with some sceptical prison reformers. It was also the day after the Joseph McCann story broke with the MoJ admitting he may have been mistakenly released from prison. At the time of writing, although McCann has been apprehended, by any measure the circumstances look shocking and may well prove to be yet another factor in potential candidates for the ministerial vacancy proving difficult to strong-arm. This from the Independent last week:- 

Rory Stewart ‘given get out of jail free card’ on prison pledge, say campaigners

Rory Stewart‘s removal from his role as prisons minister has “given him a get out of jail free card” on his pledge to improve the prison system, justice campaigners have claimed. A cabinet reshuffle sparked by the firing of defence secretary Gavin Williamson over a national security leak saw Theresa May appoint Mr Stewart as secretary for international development – widely seen as a promotion.

As prisons minister, a role he served in from January 2018, he vowed to resign if he failed to reduce the levels of violence and drug use in jails selected for the 10 Prisons Project, a £10m campaign announced in August 2018 to tackle “acute” issues in 10 of the most challenging jails. Criminologists and prison officers said it marked a continuation of the “ministerial merry-go-round” at the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) which was “destabilising” for the sector. Campaigners said Mr Stewart had forged a good relationship with them and made “positive” pledges, but these now risked “disappearing into a black hole”.

A MoJ spokesperson told The Independent that progress on the 10 Prisons Project would continue regardless of who replaced Mr Stewart. But campaigners worried that it would suffer the same fate as the “six reform prisons” project, which Michael Gove set up as justice secretary but was shelved after he was sacked in 2016.

Mark Fairhurst, national chairman of the Prison Officers’ Association (POA), said: 


“Rory Stewart has been given a get out of jail free card.” 

He added: “The pledges [Mr Stewart] made and the way he engaged with us and listened to us were positive, but the question is what happens now? This is the problem. You forge a good working relationship with these ministers, and you start to make progress, because certainly the things he’s implemented are things that we’ve been calling for years. But then all of a sudden, just as you’re moving forward, they get replaced or promoted. So then you’ve got to do the same thing with somebody different, and you can only hope that they have the same engagement with the trade unions, respect what we say and act upon what we say like he’s done. Unfortunately this new prisons minister, whoever he or she may be, will not have time to settle in because this is an emergency – we are still in crisis. Safety is a massive issue. We’re getting staff with their throats slashed and getting their heads stamped on.”

Mr Fairhurst said that while Mr Stewart was making progress, the 10 Prison Project was not on track to succeed, and that his ministerial move would allow him to “get out of jail free” on the pledges. “We all know that it will fail,” he added. “I think people in power knew what was coming and needed to protect him.”

Stirling University criminologist Dr Hannah Graham said: “The ministerial merry-go-round in justice in recent years is destabilising. It hasn’t offered probation, courts and prisons practitioners the consistent stability and support they need. At a time when painfully high numbers of people are dying on probation and in prisons, accountable and morally courageous ministerial leadership is so very needed.”

Peter Dawson, director of the Prison Reform Trust, said there would be a “good deal of regret” at the loss of Mr Stewart, but that it was “safe to assume” that his replacement would not commit to resigning if the 10 Prison Project doesn’t deliver. Indeed, the 10 may well disappear into the same black hole as the ‘six reform prisons’ that Michael Gove set up as justice secretary before moving on,” he added.

--oo00oo--

Writing on Facebook, Napo Vice Chair David Raho offers some observations:-

"This is something that could well impact on future probation either way. He is smart and gets the issues quickly and certainly realised very early on that TR1 was a huge mistake although he has persisted longer than some others of influence in the know with the idea that, despite the growing mountain of evidence questioning this, that there is a substantial role for private probation in delivering probation services than the sort of reduced involvement such as that seen in Wales. My enduring impression of him (gained from a wide variety of sources) has been of a man that at least appears willing to listen and to hear different points of view. He has also been more willing than others to look into, and appear to consider, other realistic possibilities rather than simply ploughing on regardless with the same old same old. Listening is one thing, hearing is another, doing what needs to be done is something a bit more challenging.

Let us not forget that in August 2018 he challenged us to judge him on his record over the next 12 months. This at least shows a bit of gumption. In fact, he said that he would step down if matters in prison had not improved. We should judge him on how things have been going since that offer. I am hoping his successor will come to the right conclusions about TR1 and do the right thing re: TR2.

How did he do?

Perhaps in probation, we will know in a couple of weeks time and either give him a thumbs up for a reasonable effort or a Grayling Award for failure in public office. It’s a key role. Let’s just remind ourselves of what it involves. Specific responsibilities include:

Prison operations, reform and industrial relations
Probation services and reform industrial relations
Sentencing (including out of court disposals)
Public protections (including Parole Board, IPPs and Serious Further Offences)
Foreign National Offenders
Extremism
Electronic Monitoring
Supporting the Secretary of State on departmental finances and transparency

Whoever is appointed has a tough brief in troubled times."
David Raho goes on to say:-

"We live in interesting and chaotic times where it is considered considerable progress and a major concession for the unions to actually be invited to meet in the same room as ministers rather than junior staff. They are still not consistently invited to the higher level meetings where the decisions are made yet - not even Labour did this in recent times.

It is POA action that is feared by government because of public sympathy re: physical risk to PO’s and immediate public safety as they could paralyse the system and force the government into an embarrassing situation where they would be forced to bring the army in. The POA are traditionally far more militant than Napo and their actions are sometimes also used instrumentally by prison governors to achieve their aims to increase resources. The POA have much greater membership density across most of the prison estate than Napo has across probation. They do however concede that they did not resist privatisation enough when it was occurring under New Labour. By way of contrast Napo’s influence is now and historically achieved through rational and persistent argument scratching away at the underbelly of the CJS in recent times utilising modern communication skills to get the message across - sometimes it comes together well and the message gets through to change the narrative slightly. That is what has happened recently with a little help from our friends some of whom operate across the political spectrum.

Potential collective strength, though a noble and honourable aspiration, would only become a reality following a massive and unprecedented increase in union membership followed by the political transformation of staff (the majority of those working in probation are small c conservative) and radical mass epiphanic changes of attitude and motivation across probation from a general position of reluctant acceptance and apathy to solid unified rejection and activism ie unlikely but not impossible.

We will no doubt be able to judge his contribution with greater accuracy shortly. He has certainly made some of the right noises and at present his main contribution is to apparently take into consideration information from others that Graylings team for example did not. This has caused concern to private providers of probation services who believe they have been assured further contracts and for unions and reformers to dare to hope that the government will perform a dramatic u-turn. However, we are wise to be sceptical as actions do very much speak louder than words and until decisive action by government to sort out the mess follows from words then no one can have any faith in what is said.

Faith is a very relative term. I have little faith in politicians to act rationally taking into consideration relevant evidence but I’m prepared to be surprised. ‘Perhaps in probation we will know in a couple of weeks time and either give him a thumbs up for a reasonable effort or a Grayling Award for failure in public office.‘


David Raho

(Published with author's permission)

Saturday, 4 May 2019

A Completely Inappropriate Marriage

Posting late-afternoon on a Bank Holiday weekend was not part of my plan, but a story and tweet earlier today from Skynews:-

'Taskforce to tackle corrupt prison and probation officers'

has made me see red! It perfectly serves to remind me why we should never have been part of HMPPS. This new taskforce is aimed at prison officers, but sloppy journalism at Sky news just lumps us all in together. 

I decided not to run the following rather-more nuanced article from the Guardian dated 29th April, but upon reflection I should have and especially as the likelihood of a 'reunification' of probation under HMPPS is increasingly on the cards. It may be a necessary and pragmatic first step, but we must seek divorce from this completely inappropriate marriage with HM Prison Service as soon as possible!     

More than 2,500 prison staff disciplined in five years, MoJ figures show

Exclusive: FOI data reveals scale of problem, ahead of launch of counter-corruption unit to tackle offences including bringing drugs into prisons

More than 2,500 prison staff have been subject to disciplinary action in the last five years, including for relationships with inmates, assaulting prisoners and racism, the Guardian can reveal, as the government prepares to launch a unit to tackle corruption in jails. A total of 2,666 prison staff in England and Wales were subject to disciplinary action between mid-2013 and mid-2018, according to data released by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) under the Freedom of Information Act.

The most common reason for disciplinary action was breach of security, which can include bringing drugs and mobile phones into prisons, with 960 workers subject to this charge. Other charges included assault or unnecessary use of force against prisoners, for which 204 staff were disciplined, inappropriate relationships with a prisoner (64), racial harassment (19) and trafficking (28). There was also action over abusive language, sexual harassment and being unfit for work due to drink or drugs.

It is understood the Ministry of Justice will soon launch a counter-corruption unit (CCU) as the department battles with a fractious prison estate overcome with drugs, violence and poor mental health among inmates. The formation of a counter-corruption unit was announced in the Government’s Prison Drugs strategy, which was published earlier this month.

The most recent figures show that in the year to March 2018 the number of incidents in which drugs were found in prisons increased to 13,119, up 23% from 10,666 in the previous 12 months. The number of mobile phone and sim card discoveries increased by 15% in the same period: there were a total of 10,643 incidents where mobile phones were found and 4,729 incidents where sim cards were found.

A lack of experienced prison officers has been blamed in part for the difficulties faced by the service. As of 31 December 2018, there were 22,722 prison officers in bands three to five, considered to be key operational grade in public-sector prisons, of whom 42% had less than three years’ experience.

In its response, the Ministry of Justice said: “The vast majority of prison officers and other staff carry out their duties to the high standards the public rightly expect, but the small minority who fall short of those standards are held to account. Allegations of inappropriate behaviour, though rare, are taken extremely seriously and are immediately investigated. We do not hesitate to take action where there is evidence of misconduct.”

The data released to the Guardian shows the prison service launched 6,597 investigations into misconduct between mid-2013 and mid-2018, including 2,270 into breaches of security, 718 into assault or unnecessary use of force against a prisoner and 174 into inappropriate relationships with prisoners. A total of 567 officers were sacked in the same period, including 84 for breach of security, 68 for assault or unnecessary use of force against a prisoner and 39 for an inappropriate relationship with a prisoner.

The MoJ started to build its new counter-corruption unit last year after a root-and-branch review of how to tackle corruption within the prison service. It had hoped to launch in February but was delayed. The counter-corruption strategy has four pillars that mirror the Home Office’s counter-terrorism approach: protect, prevent, pursue and prepare. The unit will prioritise “pursue” by providing support to prisons and probation to progress intelligence reports. The unit will have a small national team and larger regional teams.

Last year, the MoJ advertised for a head of the unit. It was expected the unit head would lead a team of 26 staff spread across the country. In January, a prison officer, Jade Hicks, 35, was jailed after smuggling cannabis for an inmate she had befriended. Hicks, from Hemsworth near Pontefract, West Yorkshire, met the man when she worked at HMP Leeds.

In a separate case, Gemma Farr, from Draycott, Derbyshire, who worked in a prisoner rehabilitation role at HMP Dovegate in Staffordshire, was jailed for delivering contraband to prisoners. Last year, Iain Cocks, a prison officer who had a sexual relationship with an inmate, was jailed for four years. Cocks, 51, had a relationship with the female prisoner for nearly two years at HMP New Hall near Wakefield, where his wife was also working at the time. Cocks, from Barnsley, South Yorkshire, had consensual sex with the inmate in a cell and a laundry room.

In December, two prison officers were jailed for assaulting a 17-year-old inmate at Wetherby young offender institution in 2016. Mark Burnett was sentenced to 15 months and Daniel Scott to 10 months. The teenager was being escorted through a corridor when Burnett shut the door to the exercise yard and said: “Do you think it’s funny to assault a prison officer?” Burnett, 50, who had been a prison officer for nearly 20 years, then punched the teenager in the face, and his colleague Scott, 28, also hit the inmate.

Peter Dawson, the director of the Prison Reform Trust and a former prison governor, said misconduct among prison staff was “massively” damaging.

“Staff bringing drugs in is probably the easiest way of bringing a large quantity of drugs into a prison,” he said. “The more you tighten up other forms of getting drugs in, the more pressure staff will come under and the more they will look like the obvious way to achieve it. Prisoners generally if asked this question will say of course staff are involved and will probably identify corruption as one of the main routes of getting drugs into prison. It’s relatively low-risk, it’s relatively low-cost and you can bring in large amounts.”

He added: “Prisoners rely on staff to be honest in many ways. A corrupt member of staff is damaging because they will feed an alternative source of authority in the prison, they end up working for the prisoner, not the governor. Most prisoners don’t want that, they want the authorities to be in control. It’s massively damaging. It [corruption] is difficult to tackle. In terms of a new unit, we would welcome more attention on this. Corrupt staff are very dangerous to their colleagues as well as everyone else. Historically, the Prison Service has been reluctant to grasp this particular nettle.”

Friday, 3 May 2019

Only Sensible Option is Reunification

Oh look! Another report highlighting the Probation Omnishambles. This in the Guardian:-

Grayling probation changes 'took unacceptable risks' with public money

Overhaul left sector in worse state than before and taxpayer with £467m bill, MPs report.


Chris Grayling’s widely derided changes to the supervision of a quarter of a million offenders in the community were rushed through at breakneck speed, taking “unacceptable risks” with taxpayers’ money, a spending watchdog has said. In yet another damning report on Grayling’s so-called Transforming Rehabilitation strategy introduced when he was justice secretary, MPs on the public accounts committee (PAC) said the overhaul had left the probation sector in a worse position than before.

The changes failed to achieve expected reductions in reoffending and left services underfunded, fragile and lacking the confidence of the courts, the MPs said in a report. Action taken to tackle the problems will cost £467m, the report said, adding: “Inexcusably, probation services have been left in a worse position than they were in before the ministry embarked on its reforms.”

Probation services deal with more than 250,000 offenders in England and Wales, including those preparing to leave jail, former prisoners living in the community and people serving community or suspended sentences. The sector was overhauled in 2014 by Grayling, who ignored significant warnings from within the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) and broke up 35 existing probation trusts, replacing them with a public-sector service dealing with high-risk offenders and 21 privately run community rehabilitation companies (CRC) that manage low- to medium-risk offenders.

The MoJ plans to end the existing CRC contracts early, in December 2020. Under the proposed new system, 10 probation regions would be created in England, with each containing an National Probation Service (NPS) division and a CRC. In Wales, the NPS would assume responsibility for the management of all offenders.

The PAC chairwoman, Meg Hillier, said: 

“Despite warnings from this committee and the National Audit Office over the past three years, the Ministry of Justice has failed to bring about the promised revolution in rehabilitation. Rather than deliver the savings hoped for at the start of the programme, the ministry’s attempts to address the failures in the reforms have cost the taxpayer an additional £467m while failing to achieve the anticipated improvements in reoffending behaviour. Over-optimistic initial forecasts left the Ministry of Justice fighting fires of their own making since the programme’s inception.”

The committee claimed the MoJ failed to conduct adequate pilot schemes or to learn sufficiently from similar programmes elsewhere, accusing the department of suffering from “optimism bias”. The PAC report said: “It is unacceptable that so many unnecessary risks were taken with taxpayers’ money.”

The changes failed to reduce reoffending by as much as expected, continued the report, citing figures that showed the average number of reoffences per offender increased by 22% between 2011 and March 2017. The report also noted that the number of offenders recalled to prison for breaching their licence conditions went up by 47% from January 2015 to September 2018.

While the government says the rise reflects the extension of statutory supervision to offenders sentenced to less than 12 months, the committee said the MoJ “acknowledged that it had not got post-sentence supervision right”. The PAC joins the chief inspector of probation, the cross-party justice committee and the National Association of Probation Officers in heavily criticising Grayling’s changes. 

Richard Burgon, the shadow justice secretary, said: 

“Chris Grayling’s disastrous decision to privatise probation has been a costly failure that has left our communities less safe. The Tories must show that they have learnt the lessons of this failure and drop their ideologically driven plans to sign yet more private probation contracts. Labour has made it clear that in government we will return probation to the public sector, where it can focus on keeping the public safe – not lining the pockets of failing private companies.”

--oo00oo--

On the day Rory Stewart decided to move on to pastures new and confirms that his hat is in  the ring for Tory Party leader, I hear that Napo have been given a 'heads-up' regarding MoJ thinking in advance of appointment of yet another Prison and Probation minister:-

Napo Official Briefing on Future of Probation as at 2nd May 2019

We have established that the MOJ has informed the market that it is looking at all options for probation going forward. This includes the possibility of rolling out the Wales model everywhere. However, nothing has been decided at this point and we will have to wait for a statement by Ministers and their formal response to the consultation paper that we now expect to be published in the middle of May.

Over the last few days, we have seen some irresponsible and poorly informed communications from one of the largest private providers and we are reliant on members keeping us informed of any statements being sent out by CRCs as the MOJ seemingly has no central [control] over what their contractors say to staff.

We understand from the MOJ that the market has given a mixed response to the various options under consideration (as listed below) including some saying that they are not interested in any future contractual arrangements other than TR Mark 2.

In the meantime, Napo Officers and Officials will continue to engage with CRCs on issues such as pay and operational/ collective bargaining matters on a business as usual basis. We will also be drawing up transition papers to highlight the pros and cons of each potential option for the future provision of services and will be priming our contacts in the press and political circles.

What are the options?

1. TR Mark 2. This would see new contract package areas being drawn up to match the intended 10 divisions of the NPS. These CPAs would then be sold off in a similar way to TR. Our 8 reasons to reunify Probation give you an outline of the key issues that we are asking members to raise with MP’s but also more local concerns. I.e. DTV CRC will not exist if TR Mk2 goes ahead yet it is the only mutual and certainly not the worst performing CRC.

2. Welsh model. Clearly, this would be a massive step in the right direction for our campaign to reunify probation. It is not without its pitfalls such as the so far untested transition risks and could be seen as leaving behind comrades in Interventions and Programmes, but it would at least give us good grounds for pushing our campaign for full reunification, as well as giving us an opportunity to press again for pay parity. It is estimated that between 250-300 staff will move into the NPS Wales from KSS CRC when the transfer of Offender Management work is completed by December this year.

3. Total reunification - private sector. If we get a new Prime Minister and/or Justice Secretary then there is a real risk that they would seek to privatise the whole of Probation. While this is the least likely option, we must factor it into our planning. Our main objective would be to highlight the failure of CRC’s to deliver the most basic of probation services and lobby politicians on the basis that private providers simply cannot be trusted to hold high and very high risk cases.

4. Total reunification - public. Clearly, this is the major objective of our campaign and one we will continue to fight for. The Wales model (if it were to be the preferred option for Government) would give us a real head start, but we can still hold some hope on the possibility of the Minister accepting that a total rethink is the best option. However, any reunification would still require us to push for the NPS to have local accountability and budgets as well as our claim that Probation should be removed from the civil service and given back its former independence.

We had anticipated that a decision would have emerged by now but it is clear that more analysis is being undertaken and yesterday’s announcement that Rory Stewart has been promoted to the Cabinet has obviously also been a factor in the delay. We currently await news of his successor.

Wednesday, 1 May 2019

How To Fix Our Prisons

Entitled 'Control, Order, Hope' the Centre for Social Justice has been busy preparing a manifesto for prison safety and reform. There are 59 recommendations, which I do not intend to cover here, but the following gives a flavour of the thinking, puts matters into political context and makes clear that there can be no reduction in the prison population until the probation omnishambles is sorted out.  

Foreword

The discourse on prison reform very often excludes the people who work face-to-face with prisoners in our criminal justice system. Front line prison staff are our greatest asset in the fight to bring safety and opportunity back to a prison system disfigured by years of underinvestment and poor leadership. All too often this vital role is rendered invisible by those who fail to understand or acknowledge the profoundly important duty they carry out.

Our addiction to cheap custody has entrenched the instability and extreme violence that makes it all but impossible for prisons to do the job we pay our taxes for. An obsession with managerialism and pious abstractions has done nothing to make English and Welsh prisons the engines of human transformation they could be. Many other countries manage to model this positive vision, and we should be no different. 

Prisons don’t have to be inherently harmful. Destruction of the spirit, all too common across the system, is not inevitable and it is not unfixable. It simply takes leadership, will and proper resources. Those who actually work in our prisons can do the rest. 

This is a manifesto to get our violently disordered prisons back on their feet again. It deliberately avoids the tired rhetoric of a criminal justice ‘commentariat’ who too often confuse prisoner advocacy with public safety and are sometimes shamefully silent on the security and welfare of the men and women who work our prison landings. 

We have been practical and straightforward about the changes needed now, to make prisons safe places capable of doing more than delaying the offending of the people inside them. It builds on the work already started by Prisons Minister Rory Stewart, one of the most intellectually and morally engaged holders of that post for many years. 

Prisons manage human failure. Our aim is to put forward ideas that will help make custody productive – where confident and skilled staff can assist people in their care to break away from criminality and realise their potential. But without the foundation of security, order and control, no amount of warm words on hope and progress will make a jot of difference. In my experience at all levels of prison management and leadership, where you have well supported staff who feel valued, have dignity, have agency – anything is possible. 

Order and control is emphatically not a recipe for state oppression as our detractors will inevitably suggest. It is in fact, as anyone who has ever walked a prison landing knows, the starting point of a journey to legitimacy and ambition for our citizens in prison. This manifesto, building on previous CSJ work on practical prison reform, describes that journey in detail.

There are big questions to answer about who we send to prison and the price we are willing to pay for it as a society. In the meantime, 82,000 prisoners, most of whom will be released back into the community and 23,000 uniformed staff who want to help keep them there deserve our respect and our help to succeed. 

That key relationship and what it could achieve is at the heart of this work. 
 
Ian Acheson
Former prison Governor who led the landmark 2016 independent government review of violent extremism in prisons.

Executive summary


Our prisons are in a terrible state. This has not come about overnight. For decades our prisons and the public have been let down, just as those working and living in them, have been failed. The most recent failings have been driven by a reduction in the number of prison officers working in our prisons, but longer-term failings have included a defeatist attitude towards tackling drugs and addiction, and a failure to keep the prison estate up-to-date and fit-for-purpose. 

Some of these failings can be pinned at the feet of particular governments, but the reality is that for decades politicians have failed to grasp the importance of ensuring that our prisons are adequately resourced. Our prison leaders need to be supported to and held accountable for creating safe regimes that move people away from crime, with employment and work-readiness too often being seen as an optional extra or else delivered in an ineffective fashion. 

For several years running, the CSJ's Criminal Justice Award has gone to organisations working tirelessly to help prisoners turn their backs on crime with a focus on employment. This year, Tempus Novo, created by two former prison officers, demonstrates what can be achieved, and at the same time, the latest evidence emerging from Norway, points to the power of work and employment to fight crime. But the power of work and employment as a route out of crime is undermined when our prisons are in crisis. 

If there is one resounding message that this and future governments must take on board, it is that control, order, and hope must be restored to our prisons. This means tackling the drugs, ending the violence, and supporting staff. For in prisons awash with drugs, brutality and disempowered prison officers, there can be precious little prospect of offenders turning their lives around. In fact, quite the opposite, with prisoners accelerated into addiction, violence, and worse criminal behaviour. 

Finally, the answer to our prisons crisis is not simply to send fewer people to prison. Our own polling of UK adults found that while some (19 per cent) said the Government should send fewer people to prison to reduce overcrowding and improve staffing levels, the vast majority (70 per cent) said the Government should build more prison spaces and recruit more prison officers to reduce overcrowding and improve staffing levels. 

In the absence of effective community sentences in which the public and sentencers have confidence, and at a time when probation services are failing, we should not be surprised by this result and nor should we dismiss it.

But it is about more than resources, for the fundamental solution is to restore control, order, and hope to our jails – and to accompany this with a plan of action that delivers meaningful and, where appropriate, new intensive community sentences that help change behaviour, deliver punishment, and cut crime. 

This paper focuses on how we can restore control, order, and hope to our prisons. We outline a total of 59 recommendations, but prioritise the following for consideration by this and future governments with a determination to ensure that our prison, and wider criminal justice system, works for victims, the public, and those who work in it, by keeping them safe and helping reduce, rather than generate crime.

Conclusion

The need to restore control, order, and hope in our prisons has never been greater. 

Since 2015 it is clear that Government has sought to reverse some of the poor decisions that placed prisoners and staff alike in intolerable and unacceptable conditions. The last four Justice Secretaries have all tried to repair the damage. Michael Gove’s radical reforms were supplanted by Liz Truss’s focus on getting additional staff back on our dangerous prison landings. David Lidington’s decent efforts to beef up the powers of the prisons inspectorate, have been replaced by David Gauke and Rory Stewart’s welcome focus on the basics of order, control and decency. 

The ideas contained in this manifesto, big and small, are supportive of restoring discipline and purpose in our disordered jails. The families of prison officers and prisoners alike have every right to expect that their loved ones are safe while inside custody and return to them no worse than they entered. Society pays the price for the failure of the prison system – broken staff, broken lives, lost potential. 

Citizens have every right to expect that scarce resources are properly spent breaking the cycle of offending and reoffending that destroys lives and communities and creates further victims. It means ensuring that our prisons are model societies, not simply warehouses run by those who carry on their criminal lifestyles through violence and intimidation. Our prisons can and must be much more than a Hobbesian state of nature. 

The failure of any state – least of all a modern democratic one – to act decisively in this situation is an affront to morality and an indictment of basic competence. For many who end up in our prisons – and for the victims beyond the prison wall – the state has already let them down, whether through failing to protect rights to life or property, or through the failure to tackle the social breakdown that sits behind so much of the crime in Britain today. 

Nobody with a commitment to social justice, tackling poverty, or protecting the vulnerable should seek to oppose the restoration of control, order, and hope in our prisons. 

Nor should anyone with such a commitment support artificial and unsustainable reductions in the prison population. Calls to ease the pressure on our prisons by reducing overcrowding and improving staffing levels through such reductions in the prison population are not popular, with 70 per cent of the public preferring to build more prison spaces and recruit more prison staff.

At the same time, scrapping short prison sentences, while popular with 70 per cent of MPs in Westminster, is less so with the public. Our polling found that while 17 per cent support the Government reducing the use of short prison sentences “immediately”, more than half (53 per cent) said “only when it has the new more effective community sentences in place”, and almost 1 in 4 (23 per cent) said “never”. 

The challenge ahead, and upon which the Prisons Minister has embarked, is significant. To truly restore control, order, and hope will require a long-term sustained plan across our prisons – but also that builds genuine public and sentencer confidence in new and more effective community sentences. 

The absence of control, order, and hope is the presence of despair. We must make prisons places of transformation and this relies first and foremost on them being safe for all inside on either side of the bars. Ministers must seize the moment to empower the new Prison Service Chief Executive with the tools and support to get control back, restore order, and then create hope and purpose. 

Ministers must arm this new leader with the tools and expect the visible leadership that is so desperately needed to reverse the tragic and avoidable disintegration of a once proud organisation. Brutality, despair and violence in prisons is not inevitable. It is not unfixable. Our manifesto is a bold call to arms in aid of a public service and public servants desperate for change. We must act now. Lives depend on it.