Thursday, 23 January 2020

Remembering Harry Fletcher

Alan Travis writing in the Guardian:-

Harry Fletcher obituary

Former assistant general secretary of the probation officers’ union Napo who was pivotal in changing the laws on stalking and on coercive control

Harry Fletcher

Harry Fletcher, who has died aged 72 of a heart attack, was a doughty fighter for victims’ rights, a public voice for probation, and a successful campaigner who played a leading role in changing the laws on stalking and domestic abuse.

For almost three decades he was the assistant general secretary of a small union, the National Association of Probation Officers (Napo), but from that obscure office he became a familiar figure on British news bulletins and around Westminster.

For generations of politicians and journalists Harry was a fount of knowledge about what was going on behind the scenes in the criminal justice system. He was also the source of a sustained series of leaks and disclosures that caused serious trouble for both Labour and Conservative ministers, and was often used as an unofficial back door to the Home Office and Ministry of Justice (MoJ).

As the Guardian’s home affairs editor from 1992 to 2018, I ran news stories based on some of Harry’s leaks, most notably in 2013 about the MoJ’s internal “risk register” for the part-privatisation of the probation service, which the then justice secretary, Chris Grayling, had refused to publish. It warned that there was a “more than 80% risk” that privatisation would lead to “an unacceptable drop in operational performance” and would probably trigger “delivery failures and reputational damage” – a warning that has unfortunately been more than vindicated.

As a qualified social worker, Harry’s focus on domestic violence followed years of hearing probation officers voice concern that it was being under-reported, and that victims were being intimidated into silence by their partners. The key to the success of many of his campaigns was his use of the personal experiences of such victims, often compiled in anonymised dossiers.

It was a similar log of personal experiences that helped to secure official recognition in 2009 of the problem of army veterans ending up in prison after leaving the forces. Harry organised an unofficial count, through Napo branches, of the number of ex-army personnel in jail, and the figures obliged the Ministry of Defence and the MoJ not only to recognise the problem but to provide greater support for those leaving the forces. It is now standard practice to keep an official count along the lines he established.

Harry was born in Burnage, Manchester, the son of Jeffrey Fletcher, a departmental manager at Dunlop, and his wife, Jemima (nee Campbell), a personnel officer at Littlewoods. He went to Layburn secondary modern school and then Manchester grammar school before taking a degree at the University of East Anglia and qualifying as a social worker at Bristol University in 1974.

After a period as a social worker in Waltham Forest, east London, he joined the National Council for One Parent Families in 1977, learning his campaigning skills there before joining Napo in 1984. He served the union for 29 years until 2013, when he left to work as a political consultant on stalking, domestic abuse and digital abuse, becoming an adviser to Plaid Cymru on such matters in 2016.

Over the years, Harry built up a wide network of contacts in parliament and the media, feeding them detailed research that documented the impact of criminal justice policy on individuals. His sustained supply of leaks was fuelled by a nose for a story that was as strong as any journalist’s, and he had a fierce commitment to protecting his sources.

He was also exceptionally good in the public arena. In many high profile and notorious criminal cases, including those highlighting failings by the police, courts and prison and probation services, he was able to explain to the public in straightforward language exactly what had gone wrong and why, long before any bland official inquiry report had been produced.

His expertise was much in demand, including, in recent years, by the scriptwriters of the Public Enemies television series about probation officers. On one occasion he took the scriptwriting team to visit a hostel and a probation office after they had been refused access by the MoJ. As recently as December 2019 he was interviewed by major broadcasters and newspapers to provide background on the London Bridge terrorist attack.

He is survived by his partner, Kate Gilbert, his sons, George and William, and a grandson, Orly.

Harry Jeffrey Fletcher, criminal justice campaigner, born 27 January 1947; died 8 January 2020


--oo00oo--

The Directors of the Probation Institute are greatly saddened to learn of the death of Harry Fletcher on 8th January. Harry had been in regular contact with us about TR and Probation Reforms – most recently just before Christmas.

Many of us have worked with Harry over many years and would like to pay tribute to his immense energy and commitment to a fairer justice system, working at several different levels. For us above all Harry was Assistant General Secretary of Napo from 1984 to 2013. This long period of work for Napo saw massive changes in Probation, advances in practice and values, support for victims, increasing workloads and pressures, restructuring, all of which Harry promoted and defended. Organising large rallies at Westminster Hall, Parliamentary Questions and lobbying, particularly in the successful campaign to influence the incoming Labour Government in 1997. Harry was strongly opposed to Transforming Rehabilitation. He was pleased to see the integration plans in 2019 but understood the real reservations and in an advisory role was seeking to influence the Secretary of State over continuing issues with the new model.

Harry was always available and interested in what you had to say – he was diligent in turning over stones, finding out the detail, and in speaking out openly and clearly about his findings. You could always spot when Harry was behind an investigation. It’s hard to think of anyone who can quickly replicate his knowledge of justice combined with investigation and reporting skills – but it’s very important that principled journalists try hard to follow in his footsteps.

We would like to pass our deepest sympathies to Kate, William and George in your loss and extend our very warm appreciation of a colleague and friend.

Helen Schofield
Probation Institute January 2020.


--oo00oo--

Friend and colleague Mike Guifoyle shares some memories:-

My first real professional contact with Harry was at the York AGM 1998 when I made my maiden speech moving the National Campaigning Committee (NNC) motion on renationalising private prisons. Although Harry drafted the text with his usual rhetorical flair, I tweaked it and after the motion was unanimously carried, he winked suggesting that the additions seemed to work. It later merited a headline on the BBC ceefax page! Indeed Judy McNight (GS) cornered me at the evening social to congratulate both of us for making the headlines! 

Thereafter with subsequent AGM's and NCC meetings Harry would be the indomitable presence and guiding influence in shaping Napo's approach to campaigning and with his hard won and ever present media savvy public profile was the go-to official fronting for the union. His able tenacity in doing so merited a commendable tag line in certain Napo circles as 'Harry the Dog' (no relation to a certain Cold Blow Lane terrace legend!) given Harry's fond attachment to Arsenal FC.

I did however succeed (he was perhaps at times a touch too possessive of sharing his much cherished parliamentary and media sources!) in making it onto a Channel 4 news item with Harry on the perennial topic of resources, public safety and front line morale. To his lasting credit he did arrange for NCC members to attend a media training day and I was often a call away from some of the bigger media stories to beset the probation service over this period. 

In particular I recall the frantic behind the scenes information gathering that was needed to respond to harshly critical governmental and media pressures in light of the tragic Hanson and White SFO furore in London that resulted in the eventual resignation of the CPO David Scott. From memory Harry offered DS some fraternal advice on getting through this embroglio in the men's urinal!

He had a fund of well garnered anecdotes on the foibles and failings of political and departmental officials, amusingly batting off on one occasion Jack Straw's off-handed and trademark ill-tempered media observations on 'Napo's dinosaur union officials' with a knowing smile.

He had more moles it appeared in the corridors of power than George Smiley! And his fearlessly obdurate manner did send a proverbial shiver down the spine of many a jaded Home Office/Justice Department mandarin (particularly when Private Eye ran the story). I admired his challenging mien, his dogged and prickly commitment, hard work and easy fluency when in front of the camera. 

I recall Harry deftly coaxing Lord David Ramsbotham at one criminal justice event on his pending HoL speech on the 'future of the Probation Service' and edging into a heated conversation with the former disgraced MP and Penal Reformer Jonathan Aitken at another such event, shortly after his release from open prison, who Harry was effortlessly enlisting for Napo's campaign on resisting the incipient privatisation of the probation service. 

His parliamentary briefings and well rehearsed PQ's were unfailingly comprehensive and direct to the point at issue. Oftentimes he would break off during committee meetings chirping with hand on phone, 'I need to speak to Neil (Gerrard) MP and John (McDonnell) MP whose enduring commitment to probation as a public service was instrumental in holding the union's line during the embattled legislative campaign prior to the introduction of Noms in 2004. 

On another occasion when sharing a bibulous Balti evening with the formidably combative former POA General Secretary Brian Caton, he averred 'Harry is the lifeblood of probation and one of the best and most trusted trade union defenders of keeping probation a public service I have yet met'. 

Harry told a story from the New Labour years that I recall with relish, speaking to a die hard old socialist MP who admired Napo's well briefed arguments at the time of the OMA 2007. It captures well the continuing malign potency of a market driven privatising ideology over the need for an evidence-informed public policy agenda evinced in Harry's well researched briefing papers. The MP gruffly stated 'Harry you have all the arguments, you have all the evidence, you have all the friends you need in the party, but you are ****** because they refuse to listen and that's why you need to continue campaigning!

A doughty campaigner, a relentless newshound, a wry and incisive observer on the shifting dynamics of parliamentary and political shenanigans over many years, an evanescent presence at Napo AGM's (another breaking news story meant he was often called out of the room) and a committed and loyal Napo member and official who courted the media at a time when employers and probation chiefs were being politically eviscerated, in a way that encouraged dialogue and debate to continue, who held himself accountable to the membership and never knowingly baulked at telling those in power that Napo mattered and was still a force to be reckoned with. 

He will be sorely missed and will I believe retain a significant and abiding presence in Napo's collective memory and be fondly remembered as an integral part in what for many who knew him best represented what a determinedly and proud public sector union could achieve against the odds as well as promoting and celebrating a much admired professional association, tattered it maybe from the demands of keeping the probation flame alive, but on whose behalf in his campaigning he gave his best endeavours over many memorable years. RIP Harry.

Wednesday, 22 January 2020

It's All Been Said Before

In amongst all the recent nonsense being talked about lie-detectors, I note the right-leaning Reform think tank has taken the opportunity afforded by a new right-leaning Tory government to say something about our failing prison system. 

Of particular interest to us in probation is what they have to say regarding the numbers of people we are sending to prison and why it would be sensible to reduce this. Of course it's all been said many times before and likely to fall on deaf right-wing ears, but lets give it a look anyway:-

The Prison System 
Priorities for Investment

About 

Reform is established as the leading Westminster think tank for public service reform. We are dedicated to achieving better and smarter public services. Our mission is to set out ideas that will improve public services for all and deliver value for money. We work on core sectors such as health and social care, education, home affairs and justice, and work and pensions. Our work also covers issues that cut across these sectors, including public service design and delivery and digital public services. We are determinedly independent and strictly non-party in our approach. Reform is a registered charity, the Reform Research Trust, charity no.1103739. This publication is the property of the Reform Research Trust. The arguments and any errors that remain are the authors’ and the authors’ alone. 

About Reform Policy 

Reform Policy are in-depth research reports focusing on a specific challenge facing public services. They provide a detailed and evidence-based examination of the issues and put forward implementable recommendations to government, public sector bodies and other key stakeholders to help deliver better public services for all.

Recommendation 1: The Ministry of Justice should launch a consultation on the use of custodial sentences and consider the impact of implementing a ban on, or presumption against, short custodial sentences. It should also consider how to make magistrates more willing to use and improve their understanding of a community sentence, as they are less expensive than prison sentences and, on average, more effective at reducing reoffending. 

Recommendation 2: The Ministry of Justice should develop a strategy for future prison closures which considers various factors such as their location, efficiency and effectiveness or whether they would be too difficult to replace. This will help the Government to create a more fit-for-purpose estate. 

Recommendation 3: The Ministry of Justice should devolve a portion of the facilities management budget to prison governors. This could allow for minor maintenance problems to be addressed more quickly by local provision. 

Recommendation 4: The Government should fund the Ministry of Justice £900 million to address the growing maintenance backlog in prisons, to improve standards of decency and safety. 

Recommendation 5: The Government should ensure that the Ministry of Justice receives additional annual funding to sustain new and improved prison security measures, so that prisons can continue to disrupt the supply of contraband in the long term. 

Recommendation 6: Her Majesty’s Treasury should ensure that Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service has enough funding to close the pay gap between Closed and Fair & Sustainable pay grades by 2027, to end the two-tier pay system for Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service staff.

Introduction

In 2016 the Government published a landmark White Paper, ‘Prison Safety and Reform’, which promised to deliver much-needed changes to the prison system.  It committed to address poor safety for staff and prisoners, high levels of assaults, the poor condition of the estate, poor retention in the workforce, and ultimately poor outcomes for reoffending. 

Since the Government laid out its plans for “the biggest overhaul of our prisons in a generation” progress has been poor in several key areas: 
  • Prisoner-on-prisoner and prisoner-on-staff assaults have increased by 30 per cent since 2016.  
  • Incidents of prisoners self-harming have increased by 65 per cent since 2016.  
  • The leaving rate for Band 3-5 staff – operational prison officers – has increased by 32 per cent since 2016. 
  • In the 12 months to March 2019, 17 per cent of drug tests on prisoners were positive. 
  • Nearly £529 million intended for spending on the prison estate has been diverted to spending on the day-to-day running of prisons since 2016. 
Significant resource pressures on prisons are likely to have held back the progress of reforms. The White Paper promised prisons the “resources, authority and tools” to address these challenges, but real-terms resource spending on prisons fell in 2016-17 and 2017-18. Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) has highlighted that “reduced resources, both in terms of staff and investment [has] made it extremely difficult” to run prisons.

Increasing spending is an opportunity to make progress – if targeted effectively. In 2018- 19, Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service’s (HMPPS) resource budget rose by 4 per cent in real terms to over £3.9 billion. Several further commitments have been made: £2.5 billion for 10,000 additional prison places, £100 million for enhanced security, and £156 million for maintenance. To make the most of this increased spend the Government should focus on four priorities: more effective sentencing policies, creating a fit-for-purpose prison estate, improving prison safety, and developing the workforce.

1 Smarter Sentencing

Sentencing policies affect key outcomes of the justice system, such as levels of crime, and also have an impact on the size of the prison population. The courts must not only protect the public by imprisoning people who have committed serious offences, but it should use sentences and sanctions that make them less likely to reoffend in the community. However this is not currently the case, as three quarters of all crime is reoffending. It has a huge cost to society, estimated at about £18.1 billion a year, five times what the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) spend annually on prisons. To address high levels of reoffending and unsustainable levels of overcrowding the Government should ensure that prison sentences are used proportionately. 

1.1 Towards effective sentencing

Some types of sentences are used heavily even though they result in consistently high levels of reoffending. Nearly half of all prison sentences are ‘short’ custodial sentences of six months or less. The majority of these, some 11,500, are for theft offences. These carry a very high reoffending rate of 65 per cent – for theft offences specifically, it is 82 per cent – and this has remained around this level for over ten years. Convicted offenders who are not sent to prison may instead receive a community sentence. If they are personalised and properly enforced, these flexible punishments may entail unpaid work, restrictions on activities or a curfew, and rehabilitative measures, such as treatment requirements for addictions or mental health problems. While reoffending rates are not directly comparable, the reoffending rate for suspended sentence orders and community sentences is only 33 per cent, illustrating how high the rate is for those on short custodial sentences.

Reoffending following short sentences costs an estimated £4.4 billion a year, which could be avoided in part if other types of sentences where used. Short sentences can break a prisoner’s ties with housing, employment families and leave little time to focus on prisoner’s needs, making them more likely to reoffend. While short-sentences prisoners make up only a small proportion of the prison population at any one time, the high churn that they create puts disproportionate and sustained pressure on the criminal justice system. Community sentences could be used instead for many offence types.

The MoJ has shown in repeated studies that these are on average more effective at reducing reoffending. Evaluating levels of reoffending between two groups with comparable offender characteristics – created from 150 variables including offending history and other data like employment history – the MoJ has shown that those on community sentences reoffend 4 per cent less than those on short sentences, and those who do reoffend commit fewer crimes. 

Therefore, to reduce reoffending and deliver the best value-for-money, the use of short prison sentences should be reduced in favour of non-custodial sentences. At just under £4,500 annually, a community sentence costs just over a tenth of the cost of imprisonment.  Given the evidence that community sentences are often more effective, if these are used instead of short custodial ones, reoffending should decrease and the costs associated with repeat crime should fall. The MoJ estimate that if all those who currently receive a short prison sentence instead received a community sentence, there would be 32,000 fewer crimes every year. This would create savings for the police, the prison service, and the public. It has been estimated that the Government would accrue savings of at least £83 million a year if community sentences were used instead of short prison sentences for theft and non-violent drug offences.

1.2 The decline in community sentences

In the last ten years the numbers of custodial sentences and community sentences passed have decreased, as shown in Figure 2. However, despite the evidence in their favour, community sentences have declined at a much faster rate, with their use more than halving in the last decade. 

This decline in the use of community sentences is likely to have been driven by poor confidence in their effectiveness, against a background of continued poor performance by probation services. Despite the evidence that they result in less reoffending on average, in a 2017 survey of 582 magistrates, 37 per cent said that they were not confident that a community sentence is an effective alternative to custody. In addition, 65 per cent felt they did not reduce or deter crime, and three quarters felt that they did not effectively protect the public. 

Magistrates will often lack a full understanding of community sentences due to poor training or available information. In the same survey, 28 per cent of respondents said they did not feel their training had adequately prepared them for dealing with community sentences. The use of pre-sentence reports by the National Probation Service to sentencers, which recommend what a community sentence should include, declined by 22 per cent between 2012-13 and 2016-17. The Centre for Justice Innovation has suggested a link between this and the decline in community sentences. Similarly, as probation services for low-risk offenders are currently provided by private Community Rehabilitation Companies, who are not permitted to access courts and advise magistrates, sentencers will often not be fully informed. 

Sentencers may lack confidence in probation services to enforce a sentence properly. The “implementation and delivery” of probation services by all Community Rehabilitation Companies inspected by HM Inspectorate of Probation in the 12 months to March 2019 was rated at best as “requires improvement”, with the majority rated as “inadequate”. Investing in a larger, better trained workforce could result in higher-quality supervision and enforcement, and therefore begin to offset the costs of reoffending. The Government plans to spend at most an average of £329 million a year on Community Rehabilitation Companies’ services between 2014 and December 2020, which is less than one fiftieth of the annual cost of reoffending. 

In 2021 under a new proposed model for probation, the management of offenders will return to the National Probation Service and some elements of community sentences, such as unpaid work, will continue to be outsourced. Whilst it cannot yet be said whether this will result in more personalised, well-delivered community sentences, it is likely that investing in this part of the system could create better outcomes. 

To move towards a more effective sentencing policy for those who currently receive short sentences, the Government could consider doing two things. First, it should invest in better training for sentencers. Spending on training for magistrates fell from £72 per person to £30 per person between 2009-10 and 2013-14, and it is reported that this trend has continued. If magistrates were better informed about community alternatives, they could be more willing to use them. Second, the Government should consult on how to decrease the use of short prison sentences. This should consider how to affect this change, such as with a ban or a presumption in favour of community sentences.

Recommendation 1: The Ministry of Justice should launch a consultation on the use of custodial sentences and consider the impact of implementing a ban on, or presumption against, short custodial sentences. It should also consider how to make magistrates more willing to use and improve their understanding of a community sentence, as they are less expensive than prison sentences and, on average, more effective at reducing reoffending.  

Monday, 20 January 2020

A Kafkaesque World

We've discussed at some length how unsuitable it is to have probation officers functioning as civil servants as part of the forced marriage to HM Prison Service. The two organisations have extremely different identities and cultures and it's quite obvious that NPS as part of HMPPS is dysfunctional and simply not fit for purpose by any measure, which sort of flies in the face of this surprising news that was announced to very limited fanfare on 8th January:-

The National Probation Service (NPS), a statutory criminal justice service that supervises high-risk offenders released into the community, has successfully achieved a 5-star EFQM Recognised for Excellence (R4E) following a rigorous assessment in December 2019. NPS previously achieved a 2-star EFQM Committed to Excellence (C2E) in 2016 and a 4-star EFQM Recognised for Excellence (R4E) in 2017.

EFQM Recognised for Excellence is Europe’s leading recognition programme for organisational performance, and forms part of the EFQM Levels of Excellence.

Amy Rees, Director General for Probation and Wales said:
I am thrilled by this tremendous achievement for the National Probation Service which is evidence of the excellent work undertaken and the dedication our staff demonstrate in their roles to protect the public and change lives.
Sonia Crozier, Chief Probation Officer and Director for Women said:
I am absolutely delighted that the British Quality Foundation has awarded NPS a five star excellence rating. It is a testament to the hard work, commitment and professionalism that our staff show every day in changing lives. Everyone should be exceptionally proud of this considerable achievement especially during a period of enormous change. And it’s was a great way to end 2019.
Of course we now know why there was little publicity for this amazing award because only a week later HM Inspectorate of Probation published its damning verdict on this 'excellent' organisation. In stark contrast they found:-
  • NPS operational staff often felt disconnected from the ‘centre’. They view HMPPS as remote and distanced from operational delivery. 
  • Probation officer vacancies remain high, particularly in London and areas close to London. Over 600 probation officer vacancies were reported in June 2019; however, there were also 614 probation officers in training in June 2019, which in time should ease the shortage. 
  • Workloads for probation officers are unreasonably high. In July 2019, over 60 per cent of probation officers were working in excess of the 100 per cent standard on the NPS workload measurement tool. Nearly 30 per cent had workloads of more than 120 per cent. 
  • The span of control for SPOs is too broad. Half supervise between 11 and 20 staff. This prevents them from supervising staff effectively to ensure they deliver a quality service. Half of the SPOs who responded to our survey said they spend less than 20 per cent of their time monitoring casework. 
  • Continuing professional development of qualified staff is not sufficiently comprehensive or responsive. A culture of learning and continuous development has not been sufficiently embedded. 
  • The use of accredited offending behaviour programmes has substantially reduced. HMPPS is not supporting divisions to properly understand the profile of their service users or to improve their use of services. 
  • HMPPS does not adequately oversee the commissioning process to ensure that quality services are available and accessible to service users. 
  • Gaps in local provision are apparent. The NPS is commissioning services from CRCs but then purchasing very few of them. 
  • Underinvestment in NPS buildings has meant that many probation staff work from buildings that are in disrepair. We found a catalogue of problems on our inspections, including faulty plumbing, broken lifts, vermin infestations and some older premises that are unfit for purpose in a modern probation service. In the last year, only 43 per cent of facilities management jobs were completed within the 10-day target. Business-critical jobs, for example in approved premises, remain unresolved for an unacceptably long time.
Staff 

Despite ongoing recruitment, staff vacancies are high throughout the NPS. Divisions rely on the HMPPS national recruitment process. There has been some progress in meeting staff targets, but there remain many vacancies for probation officers, especially in those areas closest to London. The profile of staff does not match the profile of the offender population; 70 per cent of probation staff are female, whereas 97 per cent of the NPS offender population are male. The NPS is not attracting sufficient numbers of men into the profession.

Workload, especially for probation officers, is unreasonably high. In July 2019, over 60 per cent of probation officers were working in excess of 100 per cent on the workload measurement tool. Nearly 30 per cent of probation officers have a workload of more than 120 per cent. The NPS workload measurement tool does not sufficiently capture the complexity of the NPS caseload, many of whom present a high risk of harm to others, aggravated by multiple offending-related factors. 

The span of control for SPOs is too broad. Half of the SPOs who responded to our survey supervise between 11 and 20 staff. Managing too many staff and holding multiple responsibilities prevents staff from being sufficiently supported to deliver a quality service. We note that the role of the SPO is being reviewed, and we welcome this. The centre does not monitor the workload of other grades of staff, such as administration staff and VLOs. In our divisional inspections, we found that many VLOs are holding a very high number of cases, on average 215 each. 

The Learning and Development Unit sits within the new Performance Directorate in HMPPS and is responsible for learning and development across prison and probation services. The NPS national training team is part of the HMPPS Learning and Development Unit. This team is responsible for identifying the training needs of different grades of NPS staff, commissioning training packages and delivering professional skills training across the NPS. Access to training for PSOs and PQiPs is sufficient for them to gain the required qualification. 

The needs of qualified probation officers, however, are not well met. Newly qualified staff need more support to gain the confidence and skills to supervise the complex and high risk of harm offenders who form the NPS cohort. The quality of training is not always pitched at the right level for probation practitioners and the method of delivering training is not always appropriate. Probation staff find that the e-learning is too basic, the locations of some venues are too far for some staff to travel and some staff are not released to complete training due to high workloads. 

Learning and development is supplemented by divisions creating their own practice guidance. The Effective Probation Practice (EPP) division – originally part of the NPS structure, but now a team in the Performance directorate in HMPPS – has links with the divisions via the divisional Performance and Quality teams. The EPP division issues practice guidance, 7-minute briefings and videos to highlight areas of practice where training or guidance need to be developed. While training events and workshops have been evaluated following delivery, there is no mechanism to evaluate the impact of the EPP division on practice.

7. Organisational delivery standard – staff findings 

This section considers the extent to which staff in the organisation are empowered to deliver a high-quality, personalised and responsive service for all service users. Inspectors pursued lines of enquiry regarding: recruitment; workload; staff supervision; managing poor performance; staff undertaking the Professional Qualification in Probation, known as ‘PQiPs’; newly qualified officers (NQOs); and quality development officers (QDOs). We also conducted an e-survey of band 5 middle managers. 

In our divisional inspections, every division was rated as ‘Requires improvement’ against our standards for staff. 

National staff shortages – the background 

We found staff shortages in all divisions of the NPS. They were particularly acute for the probation officer grade. The number of staff in post has fallen short of the target since 2015; at the same time, the NPS caseload has increased. At the time of Transforming Rehabilitation, a divisional staffing profile was established as part of the operating model. This has proved to be inaccurate, partly because the number of NPS cases has been higher than expected.

In addition, the problem has been exacerbated by national recruitment difficulties, which are particularly challenging in some areas, especially those close to London. Probation officer training was frozen for a period of time, with a resultant gap in the throughput of newly qualified officers; as a result, probation officer grades are particularly stretched.

Workforce planning 

Nationally, the NPS staffing plan has been reviewed to reflect the changing workload. The plan is based on activity costing, the tiering model and the future target workforce. The workforce planning tool incorporates ‘movers and leavers’ and predicts how long it will take to fill gaps, for example through the recruitment of PQiPs. 

The difficulties with workforce planning from the time of Transforming Rehabilitation have not been fully resolved, and this presents a risk to the future unified model of probation. For example, the reported shortage of CRC probation officers has recently changed from 40+ to 500. Data on divisional staffing requirements is not sufficiently accurate, and HMPPS has acknowledged that this is “a work in progress and not as good as it should be”. 

Recruitment 

HMPPS has made some progress in recruiting the numbers of staff required, but national recruitment processes do not always meet local need. Divisions can run local recruitment campaigns for qualified probation officers, but only within the staffing requirements set by the national workforce planning committee staffing forecast. The position for Probation Service Officers (PSOs) is more positive, with few vacancies across the NPS.

There have been lengthy delays in vetting of new starters, resulting in the loss of some successful applicants who have found work elsewhere while waiting for a start date. The length of time taken to complete vetting processes has recently improved. In April 2018, the NPS had 694 vacancies for probation officers. The highest number of vacancies were in South East and Eastern (102). In June 2019, figures showed that the NPS had 3,319 probation officers in post versus a requirement of 3,934 – a gap of 615 probation officer vacancies. 

To address the shortfall of probation officers in the long term, divisions are recruiting high numbers of trainee probation officers (PQiPs). In June 2019, 614 were in training, which is the expected full year cohort. The Director General of Probation has approved the recruitment of 400 PQiP learners to be seconded to CRCs, to ensure continuous service delivery ahead of implementing the unified model. Further work needs to be completed to ensure the accuracy of the vacancy data used to design the unified model of probation. 

PQiPs are appointed to local offices with vacancies, though vacancies may no longer exist in their selected office by the time they have completed their training. On qualifying, a small number of NQOs may not wish to move to another office – which could be some considerable distance away – and they remain in post as a PSO. This is costly to the NPS, as the financial investment in training does not yield a return in such cases. It also adversely affects the ability to fill vacancies in some of the LDUs where NQOs are most needed. Market forces payments for the South East of England and South West South Central do not attract sufficient numbers of staff to work in these high-vacancy areas. 

In summary, centralised recruitment processes are not sufficiently responsive to local need. While progress has been made in recruiting PQiPs, it will be some time before gaps in skills and experience are adequately filled. 

Diversity of the workforce 

The NPS workforce is not sufficiently diverse. Newly recruited probation officers have been predominantly white females, and the staff profile is currently 70 per cent white female. Staff from black, Asian and minority ethnic backgrounds are not represented enough at senior manager level. The entry criteria to PQiP has been widened, and this has attracted more applications from women with diverse backgrounds. A small team has been recruited in HMPPS to help increase the number of black, Asian and minority ethnic staff at all levels of HMPPS, particularly in senior leadership. HMPPS human resources teams have used Facebook and local recruitment initiatives such as school visits to try and attract more diverse applications. Despite these efforts, not enough men are being attracted into the workforce. As a result, there is a mismatch between the profile of the workforce and that of the people under supervision. 

Workload management 

The national workload measurement tool (WMT) is used across the NPS to measure the workload of those who supervise offenders. This tool measures individual, team and divisional workloads based on a nationally agreed Specification, Benchmarking and Costing Framework. Cases are classified by type, complexity and tier. 

We found that staff have little faith that the WMT accurately reflects how busy they are. Some staff are shown as being significantly ‘over 100 per cent capacity’, despite the WMT not covering the full range of tasks they cover. The BSC directorate reports that up to 120 per cent is an acceptable workload, as the level of demand varies between similarly tiered cases. However, this is interpreted by some responsible officers as “120 per cent is the new 100 per cent”. 

During this inspection, the NPS acknowledged that the WMT does not accurately reflect some situations, such as co-worked cases, and is not sufficiently responsive to the complexity and changing demands of NPS workloads. It is recognised that the WMT does not take sufficient account of the complexity of managing women offenders. There is limited scope to introduce changes to the WMT due to budgetary considerations and the limitations of the Notice of Change process. The move of the WMT to Kainos, a private contractor, has improved functionality. For example, Kainos has created a monthly dashboard that provides performance and quality managers with a real-time picture of workload distribution. 

In our view, many probation officers have unacceptably high workloads. In our divisional inspections, only 46 per cent of probation officers said they had manageable workloads, compared with 87 per cent of PSOs and 83 per cent of PQiPs. This correlates with the figures provided by HMPPS for 04 July 2019, when of 2,547 probation officers, 63 per cent (1,600) exceeded 100 per cent on the WMT. A further breakdown shows that 47 per cent (1,189) exceeded 110 per cent, 29 per cent (743) exceeded 120 per cent and 17.43 per cent (444) exceeded 130 per cent. 

The NPS operating model includes ‘case management support’ for probation officers, with a range of specific tasks undertaken by other relevant grades to enhance offender supervision. PSOs were recruited in large volumes to undertake tasks that supported cases held by probation officers, including delivering specific pieces of work identified in the sentence plan and activities such as more complex referrals. 

Case management support was expected to provide an element of workload relief for probation officers. However, the distribution of work between probation officers and PSOs has not sufficiently evened out. WMT data suggests that PSOs are significantly less heavily loaded, with only 10 per cent (75) exceeding 100 per cent, 5 per cent (39) exceeding 110 per cent, 3 per cent (22) exceeding 120 per cent and 1.71 per cent (13) exceeding 130 per cent. 

Divisions can decide whether to use ‘case management support’, and it is not being applied to full effect. Furthermore, PSOs have had some difficulty in accessing the relevant training to manage specific types of case. The impact is that there is insufficient workload relief where it is required. 

Workloads for PQiPs are monitored by divisional training managers and practice tutor assessors (PTAs). NQO workloads are managed by divisions and monitored by the BSC team. NQOs have protected caseloads; however, local pressures often mean that they are required to take on a higher number of cases than planned. This results in NQOs lacking the skills and experience to manage appropriately some of the complex cases allocated to them. 

In summary, probation officer shortages remain a major issue for the NPS, which ultimately cannot be resolved by ‘moving work around’ within limited resources. Until this shortage is addressed, too many probation officers will be managing high caseloads of challenging individuals for which they receive inadequate training and insufficient oversight. This situation undermines the very real commitment and dedication of local staff and managers.

Saturday, 18 January 2020

Clinging to a Dream

Dear Jim,

Thanks for letting me know of Harry Fletcher’s death last week. I am truly sorry that a great champion of the probation service is now no longer with us.

I have just read about the latest news reports of the scathing coroner’s inquest into the Welsh SFO just reported in the national press. After reading the comments about it in your blog, there is something that struck me.

I trained through the DipSW route in the late 1980s sponsored by the Home Office. We probation office trainees were glad to be entering a profession with a proud tradition. Our social work student counterparts were envious of our higher salary and status, self-delusional on our part I know! In turn, as we became main grade officers, we tut-tutted as we read about the endless child care catastrophes like Baby P and Victoria Climbie and consoled ourselves with the thought that at least we were not in a mess like the social work profession. 

Unlike social workers, we had a strong union, not like the supine and ineffectual BASW. We, in the probation service, had practitioners who were leading lights in respected psycho-therapeutic organisations like the Portman Clinic. We were unaffected by political vicissitudes (more or less), unlike local authority social workers who were always at the mercy of venal local politicians.

How times have changed. Since I retired last year there have been 3 probation debacles reported. TR has been disastrous as you have documented in your blog since 2014. I have no faith that joining CRC staff to HMPPS will improve things. Whilst control of the probation service remains under the thumb of central government, much of the creativity and enterprise of probation officers will continue to be strangled. In contrast, if I was to train now on a DipSW I would not hesitate to practice as a social worker, despite the multiple problems they face like most public sector workers.

Just like the prison service, the probation service has been hollowed out of highly experienced staff. It will take 10-20 years to build up that workforce expertise. Just recruiting and having no staff vacancies will not address the long-standing structural problems.

I came into probation via a science degree. Would I have been accepted as an entrant to the service now? Maybe, but concentrating on graduates from one sector, criminology and psychology, is the antithesis of diversity. We are more than just applied criminologists and psychologists. We draw on many disciplines and rely on practitioners who have varied and rich life experiences. This is what makes us, at our best, always hopeful in looking for change in service users no matter how long or problematic their criminal history. 
But always tempered by the realism that we are all but flesh and blood. 

I have always been impressed by the humanity shown by my most respected colleagues in treating everyone with dignity and respect yet being vigilant for signs of a relapse or disguised compliance. This is a difficult balancing act and necessitates extended training (15 months is totally inadequate), excellent supervision (haven’t had that for decades!) and a passion for wanting to turn lives around and help society to have fewer victims in future. This all sounds very quaint and unrealistic like watching the TV show The Waltons but compared with the clusterfuck that has unfolded since November and since 2014 with Graying’s butchery, I will continue to cling onto my vision (dreams?) for a better future in the probation service.

You are free to reproduce any of my meanderings but please bear in mind I aim to work agency and will require a reference from my CRC previous employer.

Best wishes,

Anon

Friday, 17 January 2020

Food For Thought

Only a day after publication of the highly negative HMI report on NPS core functions, I saw this photo on Twitter, posted by Lucy Frazer MP, Minister responsible for Probation:-

Image

"As we transition to a new way of delivering probation - strengthening management of offenders in the community, better protecting the public, I was delighted to hear ideas from the new Probation Divisional Directors for the NPS"

Basically it got me thinking. This is the team that have been responsible for the state NPS currently finds itself in, but more importantly, do they inspire confidence that they've got the wherewithal to tackle the problems identified in the HMI report and successfully integrate case management from the CRCs? 

We all know TR was a crock of shite; that having privateers running CRCs was a very bad idea, but it's taken a lot longer to focus attention on the ever-so-smug NPS where unfortunately there remains a very unhealthy air of unjustified superiority. What a wonderfully encouraging environment for the impending CRC case management reintegration? I'm not imagining this either; this came in over night:-
"Are CRC staff finding resistance from NPS staff regarding the reunification of offender management? No-one wanted the split but there now seems to be a lot of hostility, perhaps those in the NPS have come to believe they are elite."
Of course this issue has been around ever since the disgraceful 'shafting' and split, but there's growing evidence it's become institutionalised and it will inevitably poison the reintegration process, further hindering NPS in being able to sustain anything like satisfactory service delivery. Lucy Frazer would do well to ponder on this if the government wants to avoid further negative publicity for the hugely damaged probation service brought about by her Tory colleague Chris Grayling.

--oo00oo--

Locating material to sustain this blog sometimes takes me to surprising places and in this regard I have to thank Twitter again for pointing me in the direction of a brilliant post-election essay just published by Prof David Graeber in the New York Review of Books. 

Interestingly, although principally concerned with a forensic analysis of the reasons behind the recent domestic Labour defeat, the author contends publication in the UK would have been nigh-on impossible, such is the degree of unpalatable truth contained within it. Anyway, a brilliant read, but it was the following that particularly caught my eye with regard to the demise of our profession and growing realisation that we must break free from HMPPS and the dead hand of civil service control:-  

"Whereas the core value of the caring classes is, precisely, care, the core value of the professional-managerials might best be described as proceduralism. The rules and regulations, flow charts, quality reviews, audits and PowerPoints that form the main substance of their working life inevitably color their view of politics or even morality. These are people who tend to genuinely believe in the rules. They may well be the only significant stratum of the population who do so. If it is possible to generalize about class sensibilities, one might say that members of this class see society less as a web of human relationships, of love, hate, or enthusiasm, than, precisely, as a set of rules and institutional procedures, just as they see democracy, and rule of law, as effectively the same thing. (This, for instance, accounts for Hillary Clinton’s supporters’ otherwise inexplicable inability to understand why other Americans didn’t accept the principle that if one makes bribery legal—by renaming it “campaign contributions” or half-million-dollar fees for private speeches—that makes it okay.)

The peculiar fusion of public and private, market forces and administrative oversight, the world of hallmarks, benchmarks, and stakeholders that characterizes what I’ve been calling centrism is a direct expression of the sensibilities of the professional-managerial classes. To them alone, it makes a certain sort of sense. But they had become the base of the center-left, and centrism is endlessly presented in the media as the only viable political position.

For most care-givers, however, these people are the enemy. If you are a nurse, for example, you are keenly aware that it’s the administrators upstairs who are your real, immediate class antagonist. The professional-managerials are the ones who are not only soaking up all the money for their inflated salaries, but hire useless flunkies who then justify their existence by creating endless reams of administrative paperwork whose primary effect is to make it more difficult to actually provide care."

David Graeber is a Professor of Anthropology at the London School of Economics and the author, most recently, of Bullshit Jobs: A Theory. (December 2019)

--oo00oo--

By coincidence, regular contributor 'Getafix pointed me in the direction of this article from Times Higher Education illustrating pretty much the same issue:-

Box-ticking is the inevitable result of top-down impositions

"Overseeing an Athena SWAN application convinced an anonymous academic that if tasks cannot be properly resourced, they should not be attempted at all.

The current industrial action by members of the University and College Union is about many things, and not everything can be solved by cultural change. Yet the way UK universities currently work – or don’t work – has created a system in which everyone loses. It was inevitable that overloaded colleagues could not give Athena SWAN applications the attention required: they were juggling other tasks and needed to protect their personal time.

The neoliberal university incentivises half-hearted implementation. It delegates tasks to those unable to say no. Whether as a conscious coping strategy or out of sheer necessity, slow walking, box-ticking and perfunctory hoop-jumping are inevitable defence mechanisms that people adopt in the face of such top-down managerialism. All too often, valuable staff time is wasted without universities' having anything to show for it. This is Kafkaesque, yet the solution ought to be a simple one: if tasks cannot be properly resourced, it is much better that they not be done at all.

When my school’s new equality, diversity and inclusion committee met to consider the feedback on our successful Athena SWAN application, only a single member of the senior management team showed up. Half an hour late. But perhaps that is as it should be. Staff are not a resource to be managed. Properly empowered, they will flourish of their own accord."

The author was, from 2017 to 2019, a lead in equality, diversity and inclusion in the humanities school of a UK university.

Food for plenty of thought here I think.

Thursday, 16 January 2020

NPS Recruitment Problems Explained

Following on from the recent HMI report on NPS central functions, the BBC's Home Affairs correspondent Danny Shaw used Twitter to beg a question and I reproduce some of the responses:-

WANTED: Men - to serve as probation officers. The service is dominated by white women, inspectors say, and doesn’t properly reflect the gender & ethnic profile of the offenders they supervise. Why is the service unable to attract enough men? Inspectors also urge probation staff to show more professional curiosity, not to accept what offenders say at face value. A timely intervention perhaps...amid concerns about supervision of serial rapist Joseph McCann & London Bridge killer Usman Khan. All this against background of staff vacancies - 650 unfilled posts, a legacy of recruitment freeze around the time of probation reforms in 2014/15 - and high caseloads. Staff responsible for 39 cases each on average, with some looking after 60 offenders.

I’ve got twenty years in probation and can recommend it as a career to other men. To attract more male applicants they need to increase starting pay and change entry requirements. I wouldn’t be able to “get in” now and I’ve managed to claw myself up to an area manager grade.

And it will get worse as once this latest recruitment is over TPOs will be expected to pay for any criminal justice modules they have outstanding on top of any student debt. Thereby also excluding those with huge amounts of life experience so valuable to a job like this!

I feel we were so much luckier years ago to have 2 years post graduate training, otherwise are people just expected to live by their wits?

Katie Lomas An interesting question and one Napo have been asking for some time. Lots of factors but suppressed wages, lack of recognition of professionalism and entry requirements that, until recently, favoured younger women graduates all have an impact.

I have worked as a PO for several years in Cat. B local remand prisons. Then moved over to my current role as a offender manager for the CJS across Devon & Cornwall for the last 18 months. Would like to work in probation but keep getting told I don’t have the qualifications!!

Because the one male friend I know who was a Probation Officer was so stressed by his job he had a nervous breakdown, one mistake and the sword of Damocles is swung upon their heads as Politicians avoided blame for their lack of investment in the service.

MoJ data show the NPS has not managed to increase the overall number of Probation Officers in the 5 years since TR. Those at Director and SPO grade have increased markedly. Maybe decent wages would make a difference.

Sociology of women and work 101 - the feminisation of a profession or semi-profession results in impoverished working conditions. Not meant to be patronising. Just stating a fact. Look to any of the medical-related professions, primary school teaching and so on.

Low pay, low status, little advancement possibilities, huge workload, few good results - men know better than that.

Traditionally probation only had 4 grades and there was no recruitment problem then when I started in 1970s though comparative pay was already falling hence Butterworth Enquiry, but pay has continued to fall & then crash from about 2008.

Presumably the same Inspectors asked ‘How did this come about?’...Qualifications overtook experience, targets overtook professional judgements....a theme carried across so many public services.....

The question should be why can’t the probation service recruit staff at all?

Because as per usual, where women dominate the workforce, the pay is low and the work is hard.

Because it's shit money, massive work load and a thankless task...

Is the equality/diversity employment pendulum swinging back to a more central position I wonder?

Check the rate of pay. Where women dominate, this can reflect low wages.

It doesn't pay well enough for the amount and type of work that has to be done.

Or the level of responsibility they carry.

I think pay has a lot to answer for. You can earn more in prison or social work. My local social worker counterpart is on 10k+ more than me.

Why would you want to do this job? It’s all so so in need of change!

In what other position would you be expected to supervise high risk people who have committed murder, rape and sexual offences, write parole reports and attend Oral Hearings for a starting salary of under 32k?

--oo00oo--

Meanwhile on Facebook there's been response to the HMI report:-

My heart goes out to former probation colleague's in both the NPS & the CRCs. The staffing crisis is real & does damage to each and every member of staff and offenders being supervised. I am also concerned the current PO training at 15 months is insufficient to equip Probation Officers with the skills & abilities they need to work with offenders.

Same, glad I got out when I did.

I would love a job in probation. Have applied many times, have a first class criminology/law degree with voluntary experience in mentoring young offenders. I’m 47 white and never even got to the interview stage of the process. I tried 5 times and gave up.

Did you try applying to a CRC or only NPS?

What a shame it sounds like you have a lot to offer and are serious about the job to try 5 times not just a passing phase like some of the appointees I’ve met. In my view the recruitment process seriously needs looking at. Good luck.

Only NPS.

What annoyed me the most is you cannot get feedback from the recruitment process. I couldn’t work out what I was doing wrong or what they are after. It’s highly frustrating. I’m currently doing a MA in social work at least this gives me a recognised qualification course. I’m afraid I’ve heard too many similar stories about criminology students.

Since I left it seemed to me that they took people who were already working in Probation because they knew the IT system, which was awful, and how the offices operated.

Apply to volunteer for the CRC. You get crucial experience and work directly with offenders. It’s brilliant and the probation staff I worked with were amazing. You also get opportunities straight away with emails about up and coming jobs. Good luck.

Register for agency work with probation. CRC if you can. As above.

I'm glad I was able to take early retirement and redundancy before it all kicked off! I warned the people that I worked with that if they thought it was bad then it was going to get worse. Unfortunately they did not have the opportunity that I had. Mind you - redundancy of £14,000 for 31 years service was crap!

Me too. I got out at the right time. All this was forecast and I do feel for colleagues still there struggling. I also agree with the redundancy. What a load of rubbish pittance for long service and stress.

I currently work in admin, 11 years service. Can't believe that is all you got. What was your role? x

Started as a Community Service Officer in 1981 - loved that job, then they decided to change everything from a centralised CS office and move it to individual offices - that didn't work, then I had to lose my CS caseload and be a Probation Services Officer. Eventually I had a caseload and was a Court officer managing breach of Court Orders. I think over my time I did most things! I was at the top of my pay scale for a long time!

Worked for probation for nearly 11 year but because I don't have a degree I am not allowed to progress to PO, yet I basically do a PO job.

Are you able to do the 4 knowledge modules? I think it's the sponsored route, that will mean you can then go for the PQiP. xx

Not the point. Some PSO's have experience and skills and do the work already - too few PQiP places in the past - lack of support etc and then training is back to basics - frustrating!

Been a PO for 21 years and not got a degree. But then I came through the DipSW route.

I have just been given a blanket no.

There will be apprenticeships coming soon for PSOs to progress.

When you can qualify in 15 months, without having to write a single report and have insufficient time to experience all areas of the job, coupled with the shambles that was TR, I’m not surprised at all!!

By the time we got as far as Charles Clarke, I could see what was happening. The Govt was determined to deprofessionalise and wreck any system that was seen as helpful. Privatisation was inevitable. I really feel for you all. Being a PO/SW completely broke me.

I was a PSO for 15 years and had the opportunity to qualify via PQF over the 3 years. They really need to bring that method back. I have AP, court YOs and rural working as experience as my time as PSO and still nothing prepared me enough to transition at the time of qualifying to a PO over 5 years ago!

No shit sherlock.

The training of new probation officers is going to further contribute to the issues raised in this piece, it is appallingly poor! Newly qualified POs can take up a post with absolutely zero court experience and hence no PSR writing and risk assessment skills. This is where you earn your stripes, questioning, enquiring, challenging the offence account. New staff are scared to ask questions as they not equipped to engage in appropriate interviewing skills. Disasters will increase over the next five years without doubt.

What a holy mess. I too am glad I retired before all this, however, I'm also angry at the complete bollocks made of what was a very good professional service, with ethics and really good training/mentoring. Of course, there are still good people with high values and great skills trying to work in horrendous circumstances. It beggars belief what this Tory privatisation ideology has done.

There does'nt seem to be much or any reference made to the totally shambolic CRC sector the so called "Privatised" half of Probation in this article. I worked in both National and Private sectors, and was, before Grayling and his band of lunatics ripped apart a dedicated, effective and internationally recognised organisation for the sake of putting public money into greedy private pockets, extremely proud of the work we did! As if it's not galling enough to blame the overworked staff whom are still trying to do the job as it used to be done, no blame has been apportioned to the CRCs and their "Managers" whom, in my experience, made it impossible to work effectively by pulling resources, equipment and experience, and replacing same with a "System" that prioritised data entries over effective supervision of offenders, and untrained, inexperienced staff, most of whom tried desperately hard to work out what they were supposed to do! I eventually, after almost 25+ years in the service, walked out in disgust at the CRCs totally abhorrent practice of putting profit before public safety, but still, with my retirement looming ominously on the horizon, remain extremely proud of the work I and my colleagues achieved before the "Government" decimated the profession. It's about time the blame for all the problems was placed at the feet of those whom engineered the problems and NOT at the feet of the staff!

Wednesday, 15 January 2020

NPS Is Not Fit For Purpose

Yesterday's HMI report on NPS core functions pretty much explodes the myth that this command and control civil service bureaucracy has been performing well since the TR omnishambles and is fit and ready to absorb case management from the CRCs. Not only is it patently not ready, there must be urgent reconsideration of the NPS being part of HMPPS before reintegration happens. 

The smug top management is basically out of touch with what's happening at the service delivery level and this fundamental disconnect will only get worse under a malign and corrosive civil service command and control mindset. This from the Guardian:-

Staff shortages leave probation service in crisis, report finds

Public safety is at risk as huge workloads and staff shortages continue to place the probation sector under pressure, inspectors have said, while officers lack the “professional curiosity” needed to spot potentially dangerous behaviour among offenders managed in the community. Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Probation has painted a picture of a service in crisis with hundreds of vacancies, overstretched officers and managers, and crumbling, overcrowded buildings, including hostels for recently released offenders.

An inspection of the central functions supporting the National Probation Service (NPS), the publicly run arm of the probation sector, which supervises about 105,000 high-risk offenders, found that some officers were not properly reviewing their cases. The report follows a number of high-profile cases with links to probation, including those of the London Bridge terrorist Usman Khan and the serial rapist Joseph McCann. As part of their work, probation officers are tasked with rooting out offenders who claim their behaviour has improved but have not actually reformed – known as “false compliance”.

Khan, a convicted terrorist who killed two people on London Bridge in November while out of prison on licence, appeared to have convinced professionals around him that he was no longer a risk by taking part in rehabilitation courses. Inspectors said false compliance was a real challenge for probation officers who needed highly tuned skills and expertise to interview and challenge offenders effectively. Justin Russell, the chief inspector of probation, said the lack of skills could be down to inexperience in the job.

Amid questions over the failings in the case of McCann, a convicted burglar who carried out a string of sex attacks after being freed in a probation error, Russell said probation officers were still not carrying out basic domestic violence and child safeguarding checks for some offenders. The inspectorate said having a workload that offered “enough space and time to do that reflective thinking” was important.

The NPS has a workforce including 6,500 probation officers and a budget of more than £500m a year. Inspectors rated all of its divisions as requiring improvement on staffing, and none of the areas are fully staffed. High rates of staff sickness average 11 days per person, 50% of which relate to mental health difficulties, and there are 650 job vacancies nationwide.

Russell said the vacancies were in part related to a pause in recruitment from 2014, when disastrous privatisation reforms introduced by the then justice secretary Chris Grayling were being pushed through. Those reforms are in the process of being unravelled after the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) decided to renationalise the sector. Those probation officers in place had an average of 39 cases on their books but could have up to 60 at any one time, while victim liaison officers had an average of 215.

Russell said staff shortages were especially acute in London and the south-east. He said putting probation officers under such pressure could compromise effective work with offenders and their ability to manage cases properly. Staff were being “driven spare” by offices in disrepair, he added. Inspectors found broken CCTV, plumbing and heating problems and one case of a rat infestation. Russell said it was unacceptable that outstanding repairs also meant premises approved for housing high-risk offenders when they were initially released from prison were out of action.

The inspectors also found significant areas of positive performance, including better services for victims and women under supervision. Leadership was good but middle managers were too stretched, the report found. Among 24 recommendations made to HM Prison and Probation Service – the part of the MoJ that runs the NPS – department bosses missed opportunities to make improvements, inspectors said. Russell said immediate steps should be taken to tackle workloads and more investment in training was needed.

The justice minister, Lucy Frazer, said: 


“We know that probation is not getting enough of the basics right – that’s why we are bringing all offender management back under the National Probation Service, which the independent inspectorate says is good at protecting the public. It is also clear that the workload is simply too high for many probation officers and the 800 new officers currently training to join the NPS will make a real difference. I am reassured that the chief inspector shares my confidence in the vision and leadership of the National Probation Service – which will be essential to delivering these reforms.”

Tuesday, 14 January 2020

TR2 In Trouble

Yesterday we heard through a number of tweets that reintegration of case management from CRCs to NPS has been delayed, and today we find out why, because there are significant problems with NPS under HMPPS control. Today's report by HM Chief Inspector of Probation only serves to highlight what the risks are should TR2 proceed without a major rethink and some urgent action. Here is the press release:- 

Chief Inspector urges action on National Probation Service staffing, workloads and facilities

The organisation that supervises high-risk offenders in the community is hampered by staff shortages, stretched middle managers and poor facilities, according to inspectors.

HM Inspectorate of Probation inspected all seven divisions of the National Probation Service (NPS) between July 2018 and June 2019, and found recurring problems with staffing and facilities. The Chief Inspector of Probation decided to conduct an extra inspection into HM Prison and Probation Service’s provision of central functions to NPS divisions.

HM Chief Inspector of Probation Justin Russell said: “Staff across the NPS are committed and hard-working and leadership is good at every level, but high workloads and a poor facilities management service means the NPS is not performing to its full capability. At the time of this inspection, there were 615 probation officer vacancies across the NPS. The service is especially short of this crucial grade of staff, who play a vital role in rehabilitating offenders and protecting the public. The problem is especially acute in London and the South East. HM Prison and Probation Service has overall responsibility for NPS recruitment across England and Wales. Since probation reforms were introduced in 2014, not one of the NPS divisions has been fully staffed. A steady state has never been achieved.”

The NPS is responsible for supervising nearly 106,000 high-risk offenders, and violent and sexual offenders subject to Multi-Agency Public Protection Arrangements (MAPPA). Inspectors found staff who are in post are often overloaded. Sixty per cent of NPS staff have workloads that exceed their expected capacity. Nearly three in ten have been allocated workloads of more than 120 per cent of expected capacity. Victim liaison officers, who work with victims of serious and sexual crimes, have an average of 215 cases on their books.

Mr Russell said: “Many probation officers have unacceptably high workloads. Staff are under pressure and this could compromise their ability to build effective working relationships with people under supervision and to manage all cases to a consistently high standard. NPS probation officers are working with people who have committed serious offences and who require intensive supervision and rehabilitation. We found staff shortages mean some newly-qualified probation officers are allocated complex cases that they do not have the skills and experience to handle competently.”

Inspectors did find “significant areas of positive performance”, including improved services for victims and women under supervision. Leadership is good at every level of the NPS, but middle managers are too stretched. More than two-thirds (68 per cent) of Senior Probation Officer managers said they ‘seldom’ or ‘never’ complete their management tasks each week. Nearly half (47 per cent) put in more than five extra hours per week.

Mr Russell said: “Senior probation officers should be supervising up to 10 staff. In practice, we found half of middle managers are supervising 11 to 20 members of staff, and often have extra corporate responsibilities. They told us they are frequently overwhelmed and do not have enough time to supervise their staff effectively.”

In May 2019, the government announced that the NPS will take over the supervision of all offenders from 2021, taking on nearly 150,000 low and medium-risk cases from Community Rehabilitation Companies. 

Mr Russell added: “HMPPS has made some progress on staffing issues, but they must pursue this work with a greater sense of urgency. Immediate steps must be taken to improve workloads. Senior probation officers should be freed up to provide oversight and guidance to junior colleagues; probation officers need enough time to manage their caseloads properly and to develop their professional skills. Greater investment is needed in ongoing training and development. I urge HMPPS to fill vacancies quickly and work to ensure that the probation workforce better reflects the population as a whole. This will help them to get the right workforce in place to ensure a smooth transfer of cases next year.”

The Inspectorate found HMPPS headquarters missed several opportunities to improve the quality of the NPS’s work. HMPPS has a role in ensuring probation staff learn from serious further offence reviews and complaints. The organisation also collects data about offenders and offences to inform the commissioning of offending behaviour programmes. 

Mr Russell said: “These centralised functions are not performing as they should, and this is preventing NPS divisions from doing their best work. HMPPS does not have a written strategy that sets out how lessons from serious further offence reviews and complaints will be shared. HMPPS should be stepping up to fulfil this role. There should be a comprehensive plan to ensure lessons from serious further offence reviews are captured and shared as quickly as possible. This will help probation professionals to improve their practice and avoid repeating past mistakes."

“Local NPS divisions are not making use of the services that have been commissioned from CRCs. HMPPS should do more to help NPS divisions understand the types of offenders and offences in their region, so they can commission the most appropriate services to meet local needs.”

Over the past year, inspectors have found a multitude of problems with NPS offices. These include: broken locks, faulty CCTV, vermin infestations, and poor plumbing and heating. Some facilities are in such a state of disrepair that they cannot be used. The Inspectorate rated the quality of NPS facilities as ‘Requires improvement’ in six out of the seven NPS divisions.

Mr Russell said: “NPS staff have told us repeatedly that facilities are not managed properly. Repairs are not fixed quickly and there are difficulties with escalating jobs. We looked more closely at the issue in this inspection. The management of NPS facilities is contracted out to four private sector firms, with a fifth company acting as the managing agent. The target is for jobs to be fixed within 10 working days. For the first six months of 2019, less than half (43 per cent) of jobs were completed in this timescale. Although this is an improvement on the previous year, it is still not good enough."

“Probation staff need appropriate facilities to do their job. In particular, it is unacceptable that outstanding repairs at approved premises mean staff have to find alternative accommodation for high-risk offenders because beds cannot be used. The Ministry of Justice needs to hold these companies to account to ensure they deliver the contract as intended. Probation staff deserve to work in safe and secure environments.”

The Inspectorate has made 24 recommendations to HM Prison and Probation Service and the Ministry of Justice to improve central functions to the NPS.