Tuesday, 21 August 2018

Prisons : Policy v Management

Thanks go to the reader for pointing us once more in the direction of comment from a former MoJ insider on the growing confusion between policy and management at his old department. (I've taken the liberty of removing references for clarity.)  

What ministers need to take responsibility for is failed policies 

Rory Stewart's promise to resign if he doesn't cut assault rates in 10 violent prisons by at least 10% in the next 12 months – very precise figures, those! – looks at first sight entirely admirable. Brave, certainly, even foolhardy, given the relentless upward surge of violence ever since his predecessors cut prison staffing levels by 25% in 2013 (assaults up another 15% last year alone). And a welcome change from the usual evasiveness of politicians. And no one can doubt Stewart's passionate belief that prisons must do better – or that he is the one to make them do it. It's rare that we hear such belief in public services from a Tory politician, in this age of austerity, and Brexit.

And yet, it's an odd and, I think, inappropriate thing to say.

Those with long memories may recall Martin Narey's threat, made in 2001, to resign if he couldn't turn failing prisons around. But there's a big difference: Narey was chief executive. It was his job to run prisons. Stewart is minister, not chief executive; though, as I have previously noted, he continually blurs the two roles. (And it's noticeable that since he arrived, the actual chief executive, Michael Spurr, is never heard from or seen). But the execution of a complex programme of intervention in 10 prisons, to see what can be done to reduce violence – that, surely, is an executive job, for which the chief executive should be answerable? (Odd to think how hard Michael Howard fought to avoid resigning, on the grounds that 'operations' was not the responsibility of ministers!).

The other difference is that Narey was battling decades of weak, poor management: his threat was a message aimed at the old guard of the prison service, who did not see a need to change. Stewart doesn't have that problem. Actually, what he is battling is the consequence of policy decisions by his immediate predecessors - gross under-staffing: not the fault of officials, but of ministers. Narey's threat had a point: Stewart's does not.

Is it, anyway, a resigning matter - for chief executive or ministers? After all – isn't it a bit odd for a minister to promise resignation over not cutting assaults by 10%, when no minister has offered to resigned over the doubling of assaults so far? And if the reduction is say only 5%, or 10% in some prisons, but less in others - or if it is decided there's a better way, maybe by restoring staffing levels - how does it then make sense to resign? There seems a histrionic air about this, rather than sound political judgement.

Stewart seems to have fallen in love with the strange but compelling world of prisons – as some outsiders do. Prisons are fascinating - because they are a world of their own, because there are so complex, because so much is at stake. It is rumoured that Stewart wants to swap the ministerial role for that of chief executive. Maybe Stewart would make a good chief exec, in due course. (Though it's a bit hard to see him as a civil servant, bowing to ministerial wishes and sensitivities – especially under a Labour Government).

But at present he's the minister, and it's a bad idea to have a minster trying to directly manage a public service, as Stewart seems intent on doing. The separation between policy making and executive management was at the heart of the Agency concept launched by the Margaret Thatcher in the '80s – with strong, visible professional leadership, empowered to run the service directly, freed from ministerial micro-management, but held publicly to account for performance within a policy framework set by ministers.

That idea enabled the prison service to turn round from being the basket case of the public sector in the early 90s, survive the fastest ever rise in numbers and innumerable scandals in that decade and become a far safer, more controlled, more decent system in the 2000s. It's a concept now empty of meaning in the case of HM Prison and Probation Service, with the motor powers of any service – its finance, HR, IT and estate services - now taken back to the centre of the MoJ, whose record in those matters is not to be envied, and the chief executive has been made invisible, while the minister assumes the management role.

The political and the managerial are rightly separate spheres, different jobs, both need doing, the one complementing the other, but requiring different skills, expertise and behaviours, though to be sure, they need to understand and respect each other. Stewart has shown remarkable grasp of the realities of prison work - but he hasn't worked in a prison, as has every head of the service since Richard Tilt in 1995, a change which in my view has made all the difference. And he shows a tendency to believe prisons can be run like a military command – by no means the first to make that mistake). In my long experience as an observer of prison management, good and bad, the command and control model has its limitations: eventually, you must let Governors and their teams do the job they are paid for and trained for. It's also more than a little worrying how Stewart is always so sure that he is right. In excess, that can be a dangerous quality.

And here's the nub of the matter: as Peter Dawson, who heads the Prison Reform Trust (himself a former Governor) points out, ministers need to focus on doing the things which only ministers can do: policy, and politics. And this is where Stewart, and Gauke, fall down. Only minsters can tackle our over use of custody, which has caused gross overcrowding and a repeated need for massive building programmes - which are in turn overtaken by further rises in numbers. That means not just legislation, but educating the Neanderthals on his own benches, and in the Tory press (and maybe outing Labour on the issue, too). But Stewart, while agreeing that we use prison far too much, seems already to have thrown in the towel on penal policy). Again, only Ministers can secure adequate funding for prisons: but Stewart shows no sign of repenting of Grayling's savage and irresponsible staffing cuts, which are at the heart of the current crisis*. Even so, MoJ is racking up an enormous deficit which, after the retrenchment of the Grayling years, looks set to make MoJ the Black Hole of public finance, just as we move towards another recession. Nor are ministers willing to accept responsibility for the chaotic mess which Grayling's privatisation policy made of the probation service, itself a factor in the burgeoning prison crisis, as courts lose confidence in community sentences.

In many ways, the ministerial job is the less attractive of the two. But it is Stewart's job, and he should get on with it. And let Spurr get on with his.


Julian Le Vay

* In fact, under pressure on BBC 4's 'Today' this morning, he came close to conceding that the Grayling cuts were too deep: 

A Conservative prisons minister has admitted officer numbers should not have been cut to the extent they were as he refused to add HMP Birmingham to a list of facilities he would resign over if conditions failed to improve. The remarks from Rory Stewart came as the government took the extraordinary step of taking immediate control of the category B facility in Birmingham from the private contractors G4S.

Ministers were warned of a raft of failures at the 1,200 capacity prison in a report from inspectors which described soaring violence, drug use, and appalling living conditions including “ever present” cockroaches and blood and vomit in corridors. But when pressed on the Conservatives' previous action to drastically reduce prison officer numbers by 7,000 and to then reappoint some, he replied:


“You’re absolutely right that one of the challenges along with the drugs was staff numbers which is why we’ve brought in 2,500 extra officers. So you’re absolutely right – I’m conceding to you that we needed more officers.”

Monday, 20 August 2018

MoJ in Cloud Cuckoo Land

From wikipedia:- 'Cloud cuckoo land is a state of absurdly, over-optimistic fantasy or an unrealistically idealistic state where everything is perfect. Someone who is said to "live in cloud cuckoo land" is a person who thinks that things that are completely impossible might happen, rather than understanding how things really are. It also hints that the person referred to is naive, unaware of realities or deranged in holding such an optimistic belief.'

Because prisons are naturally fairly secretive places, the MoJ's standard policy is to try and ignore problems for as long as possible in the vain hope they go away. In a world of post truth and fake news it's also become standard practice to deny the obvious, even when it becomes crystal clear to everyone else and the saga at HMP Birmingham fits the mould perfectly. 

We all know about Chris Graylings disastrous policy decisions when he was in control at the MoJ and in particular his keeness to sign up to austerity cost savings that included massive staff cuts. 'Fair and Sustainable' has proved to have been preparing perfect foundations for the current prison crisis and the decision to force privatisation of HMP Birmingham led quickly to the riot in 2016. 

The damning report of the local Independent Monitoring Board was ignored and the MoJ 'controller' was either asleep at the wheel or their pressing the alarm bell at MoJ HQ was simply ignored. In the end it took an unannounced visit by staff from HM Prison Inspectorate some 10 days ago, when their cars were trashed in the official car park, the subsequent 'worst report ever seen' and an urgent warning notice from Chief Inspector Peter Clarke, before ministers reluctantly agreed that 'something' had to be done.

But even then the policy is to try and defend the indefensible, namely that it's nothing to do with privatisation or G4S, the company involved, and pretend it can all be fixed with a new governor, 30 extra staff and 300 less prisoners. Lets pretend the emperor is fully clothed, things can be sorted in 6 months, G4S can still have a stab at running some probation contracts and Rory Stewart won't have to resign in 12 months. It's all cloud cuckoo land. Here's the story in the Guardian:-   

MoJ seizes control of Birmingham prison from G4S

The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) has been forced to take immediate control of HMP Birmingham from its contractor G4S, after a damning inspection found that prisoners used drink, drugs and violence with impunity and corridors were littered with cockroaches, blood and vomit. The government is having to take the unprecedented step of seizing control of the failing prison, removing its governor and sweeping out hundreds of prisoners on Monday, just hours before an extraordinarily critical report is released by the prisons inspectorate.

The state of the category B prison is likely to raise significant questions in the coming days about private sector involvement in the prison system. G4S was awarded a 15-year contract to run the prison in 2011. The chief inspector of prisons, Peter Clarke, said there had been “dramatic deterioration” since the last inspection in early 2017 and the government should launch an urgent inquiry into the appalling state of the prison, the most violent in England and Wales and the site of riots in 2016.

Prison gangs perpetrating the violence “could do so with near impunity”, he said. Inspectors saw prisoners who were evidently under the influence of drink or drugs, which went unchallenged, including widespread use of the psychoactive drug spice.Staff were fearful and experienced widespread bullying, the report said, and inspectors witnessed an arson attack on a supposedly secure staff car park during their inspection.

Prison officers often had little grasp of where prisoners were, the report found. Communal areas were filthy, with cockroaches, vermin, blood and vomit left uncleaned, and wings that had virtually every window damaged or missing. Clarke said the report contained “some of the most disturbing evidence that inspectors ... have seen in any prison.”

In his letter to the justice secretary, David Gauke, Clarke said there was an “urgent and pressing need to address the squalor, violence, prevalence of drugs and looming lack of control”. Clarke said he was “astounded that HMP Birmingham had been allowed to deteriorate so dramatically”.

He said he had no confidence in the ability of the prison to make improvements. “There has clearly been an abject failure of contract management and delivery … the inertia that seems to have gripped both those monitoring the contract and delivering it on the ground has led to one of Britain’s leading jails slipping into a state of crisis.” Clarke has invoked an “urgent notification protocol”, a device that puts the justice secretary on notice that urgent action is needed to address significant concerns at a jail.

The MoJ said it had instigated an intensive period of improvement measures with little success, forcing it to take the prison back under government control. HM Prison and Probation Service will run the prison for an initial six months, before assessing whether control can be returned to G4S. The “step in” process is not technically nationalisation, but a process allowed when a provider is deemed to have breached its contract to run the prison safely, meaning there is no liability to the taxpayer.

No staff redundancies will take place, though the MoJ said it would send in an additional 30 members of experienced prison staff as well as a new governor, Paul Newton, formally of HMP Swaleside. More than 300 prisoners will be moved from the prison while the jail is overhauled.

The prisons minister, Rory Stewart, said the conditions in the prison were clearly unacceptable. “It has become clear that drastic action is required to bring about the improvements we require,” he said. “This ‘step in’ means that we can provide additional resources to the prison while insulating the taxpayer from the inevitable cost this entails.

“We have good, privately run prisons across the country and while Birmingham faces its own particular set of challenges, I am absolutely clear that it must start to live up to the standards seen elsewhere.”

However, MoJ sources have been keen to stress the government does not believe privatisation was at the root of the prison’s troubles, pointing out that other G4S prisons including HMP Oakwood had recently received good inspection reports. Stewart has staked his own reputation on dramatic improvements to the prison system, telling the BBC he would resign in a year if he has not managed to reduce the level of drugs and violence in 10 target jails, although Birmingham was not among them.

The MoJ said it was clear that the prison was still suffering significant effects following the 2016 riots involving more than 600 prisoners, the worst since the infamous Strangeways riots in 1990. The government was forced to send in specially trained Tornado Squad officers, who battled prisoners for more than 12 hours.

A report by the independent monitoring board ahead of the riots had warned of the dangers posed by prisoners under the influence of psychoactive drugs including spice and black mamba. Assaults on staff at HMP Birmingham rose 84% to a record high of 164 incidents last year, according to MoJ figures.

The “step in” to take control in Birmingham is the first time such drastic measures have been used mid-contract. In 2016, the government stepped in at the end of its contract with G4S to run Medway Secure Training Centre, after undercover reporters filmed staff apparently mistreating children.

Sunday, 19 August 2018

Responses to Demise of TR 5

Napo Briefing Paper 2 Strengthening Probation, Building Confidence

INTRODUCTION 


It is easy to be sceptical about how serious the Government are taking their 8 week holiday homework project, aka the “Strengthening Probation, Building Confidence” consultation. However, Napo will not abdicate our responsibilities as the voice of the probation profession and will respond fully and comprehensively during the consultation period – and we’ll continue to influence the debates and discussions beyond 21st September. 

As part of this, we are producing a series of in depth briefings and question papers looking at the other big questions prompted by the paper, even if they’re not specifically mentioned in the consultation…the questions the Government are less keen to see asked. Briefing #2 looks at the money and the financial questions around the proposed new CRC contracts. 

WHERE’S THE PROFIT THIS TIME? 

It’s probably not surprising, given the ideological commitment to outsourcing now embedded in the Tory Party’s DNA, that Gauke’s consultation would insist on sustaining a “mixed-economy” of some sort. This instinctive preference would be re-enforced by the mounting evidence of organisational weakness across the nationalised NPS. The NPS is massively “over-budget” (if it ever had an actual budget) but it can’t pay people or collect pension contributions properly. It’s even getting charged at premium rates to call its own HR helpline!

Yet the Justice Select Committee’s report into TR has officially defined the contracts as “a mess”. In doing so, the JSC join the HMI Probation in officially questioning if the current model could ever work. It must be a huge worry going forward that whoever contracts are let to and on whatever terms, the MoJ will still have responsibility for shaping and monitoring any contracts – with an overwhelming track record of failure.
  • When questions about how much the TR model has actually cost produce confused, contradictory and opaque political answers can anyone be confident these same people have any more idea or chance of getting this right next time? 
For people seemingly wedded to the merits of outsourcing, Gauke and his team seem to be pretty hostile to anyone making a profit. For example, they keep insisting the extra costs to the contracts published in the OJEC updates last summer (and presumably the further imminent update due for this year’s contract adjustments) are not actually extra costs but merely a “restructuring” of the contracts. It’s even been suggested these extra costs are really a saving and that providers are operating at below actual cost – i.e. operating at a loss. The MoJ tell us further planned spending isn’t additional investment but merely not collecting contract fines. In other words, the Payment By Results formula’s being replaced by Rewarding Failure Payments to keep these Contractors in the game. 

It’s certainly true that few shareholders have so far got rich on TR. During negotiations with Napo, some CRC owners have shared confidential financial information with our Reps. These show contracts operating at very difficult margins - consistently less than 5%. Not much has to go wrong when a margin is that tight for a contract to be in trouble. This model sank Carillion. Napo understands that Interserve has been in similar difficulty and doubt remains around if their auditors will allow them to re-tender unless profit margins in new contracts are significantly higher. Working Links’ staff report having visits from the Bailiffs because of unpaid utility bills. 

But higher margins in new contracts will mean higher costs for the taxpayer or a diversion of monies away from the NPS, who manage and support high risk offenders. You simply can’t have it both ways. The consultation paper says nothing about how much the taxpayer should be investing in rehabilitation but unless the spend increases the current problems will surely be replicated. The Government cannot hide from this basic, mathematical fact. 

SO WHAT’S REALLY GOING ON NOW? 

Napo’s intelligence confirms the existing contracts are already being restructured. The CRC owner’s financial risks are being reduced. It is not overly cynical to suggest losses are being rectified now to avoid companies suing the MoJ for miss-selling the original contracts – it is no secret that before contracts were signed Iain Poree and others acknowledged that the work split was going to be more like 50:50 than the CRC:NPS 70:30 ratio originally anticipated in the TR consultations. 
  • If this contract restructuring is happening now, to square off the original contracts which will be finishing early, does this mean the taxpayer will be footing a higher than expected bill for probation by 2020?
  • Will anyone get around to adding up the additional unbudgeted costs of the NPS (who have had at least 50% of the work rather than the expected 30%) whilst the Contractors are compensated for their shortfall? How much will TR have cost? 
HOW SERIOUS IS THIS PLANNED “COMPETITION” FOR “NEW” CRC CONTRACTS? 

Two points immediately jump out about Gauke’s continued confidence in the market for probation services. Firstly, what market? Who is still in and who is dropping out? Who’d be joining the competition? 
  • Will the Working Links’ Bailiffs be off their backs and their contracts magically profitable with core probation provision returning to the NPS at least in Wales? 
  • Are Interserve so battered and bruised by their TR hiding that their auditors tell them Purple has no Future? 
  • Will the likes of SERCO or G4S be allowed to join the competition, after being excluded last time because they were under investigation of defrauding the taxpayer on previous MoJ contracts? 
  • With even bigger contract areas, will the charities and potential Mutuals that dropped out last time because it was impossible to find the deposits to underwrite investment and pension risks, be any better placed now, after 5 more years of austerity?
Secondly, will the existing survivors agree to play-on? Without their risk’s being greatly reduced and some guarantee of a profit in evidence, how could their Shareholders let them? 
  • With so little likely competition, isn’t the current round of negotiations more about contract adjustments up to 2020 – and as such, just the first phase of formal negotiations around longer more profitable contracts for the current holders? 
Unless this is wrong, that’s not competition – that’s a cartel - one where the Contractee is a known incompetent and the Contractors now know what they’re buying. 

LET’S LOOK AT THE MAP 

This impression is re-enforced by a quick analysis of the new proposed contract areas in England. 4 of the 10 currently have 1 provider, potentially bidding against itself: 

Kent Surrey Sussex (SEETEC) 
London (MTC Novo) 
South West (Working Links run BGSW and the Dorset, Devon and Cornwall CRC area) 
Eastern (Sodexo run the 3 CRCs in BENCH, East Anglia and Essex)

In 4 more the competition is between struggling Interserve and 1 other provider. If Interserve withdraw the other provider will also have a huge negotiating advantage: 

South Central (MTC Novo in Thames Valley v Interserve in Hampshire IoW) 
East Midlands (RRP having the existing area and potentially picking up Interserve’s responsibility for Lincolnshire when it moves from being partnered with North Yorkshire and Humberside) 
Yorkshire (where Sodexo have South Yorkshire and Interserve the rest) 
North-West (With Sodexo having Cumbria and Lancashire whilst Interserve the rest) 

In the remaining 2 CRCs the “competition” is also limited, if intriguing: 

West Midlands – where RRP could go up against People First, the provider in West Mercia and Warwickshire who were the 3rd and last bidder for the original contract and the only one left standing after the original winners walked away) 

North East – where Sodexo have ARCC in DTV to “compete” against, unless the MoJ decide to force an arranged marriage to protect the only Mutual winner in the 1st contracts. 

HOW LONG WILL THE NEW CONTRACTS RUN? 

Everyone with an interest in this needs to know who is in the bidding and who is out - asap. This is especially acute for staff in the Working Links areas, who know they’re losing Offender Management in Wales and for staff employed by Interserve.

The next Napo briefing will explore in more detail the staffing implications and questions around a second tier transfer for those returning to the NPS (e.g. in Wales) and potentially transferring to a new CRC owner elsewhere. 

However, the consultation paper has some potentially positive and ideas about a probation wide workforce development strategy, professional development and career pathways linked to professional standards, a national qualification framework from PSO through to senior management levels, etc. These will need to be carefully developed, in partnership with staff via consultation forums not yet established and in place. Doing this well will not be quick, especially with unions and HR leads on all sides concentrating on TUPE and staff transfer issues, as well as pay reform, etc. 

The paper also correctly talks about wanting to test new models – with co-commissioning and co-designing of probation serves with regional Mayors and PCCs. With specific reference to the merger of all core probation services in Wales, the consultation talks about considering ,”whether the learning from these new arrangements is applicable to the system in England”. 

Unless the whole consultation is a cruel hoax and these sections are meaningless filler, it is impossible to see how a sensible and serious contract settlement can be developed to let new long-term contracts in 2020. 

Napo knows that some CRC owners have been pressing for contract stability and contracts of a minimum of 10 years. From their perspective that isn’t unreasonable, giving them greater scope to borrow and invest in infrastructure, ICT, etc. But that can’t seriously be allowed to happen if the parties don’t know what will be required – especially after the MoJ made such a mess of the contracts last time for exactly the same reason.

The length and structure of the contracts will give a huge indication to staff, owners, MPs and the public about how serious Gauke and Co are about stabilising the probation service and how genuine the consultation is. There would seem to be only 3 probable answers:

A.  Long 10-year contracts, which mean all of the talk about testing new models is merely talk. 

B.  Short 2 to 3 year initial contracts to stabilise, with on-going negotiations and a break clause for re-tendering and restructuring around the end of the existing contract period (2022-23). This would easily facilitate merging core probation services by 2022 and some consensus about what should/could be competed locally, facilitating charities to re-enter probation in areas where they operated prior to TR. 

C.  Something half way between these 2, (eg. 5 to 7 year contracts), would suggest the MoJ are still, in fact, making this up as they go along and everything is still to play for.

CONCLUSION 

It is natural for Napo and our members to believe that there is a coherent, carefully designed political plan for the service we care so much about. However, it is more likely, given the chaos across Government that this consultation is more about the Government being seen to have a plan. Our hope is the momentum Napo has helped build across the political spectrum, which recognises the importance of getting this right and the risks of continued failure, will exploit this Government uncertainty and force a real and genuine debate around the consultation. 

Critical to a wider discussion must be questions about the type and shape of the proposed new CRC contracts. This briefing highlights some of the core questions all stakeholders need to recognise and ask, and Government needs to answer NOW, with their answers also informing people’s replies to the consultation. 

These questions include: 

How much is probation really worth to Government? Will they take this opportunity to finally take rehabilitation seriously and invest what’s needed, whatever the operating model(s), and allow greater transparency around funding arrangements? 

Are all of the existing providers indicating they want to stay in, or have some (like Interserve or Working Links) already told the Government they plan to withdraw? If so, what are the exit terms being agreed? 

What assurances are current providers being given about future profits to keep them in the game?

How are the MoJ finding extra monies to stabilise the market and minimise contractor losses? Is this coming from the taxpayer or will the NPS get a smaller slice of probation funding? 

How long does the Government want to let the new contracts for and will there be break clauses to allow for further reform and restructuring? 

If there are no break clauses, how exactly do they intend incorporating lessons from cocommissioning and/or the Welsh “pilot” or is that meaningless, cynical political spin?

Dean Rogers
Assistant General Secretary

Friday, 17 August 2018

Cultural Reflections 2

I notice that in parallel with yesterday's discussion there was some similar introspection over on Facebook:-  

Someone close to me was explaining about a friend who had got into trouble and was sent to prison. How was her Probation Officer I asked? She said ‘the lady at Court was nice’ and then ‘her Probation Officer is about 21 and awful’. So - stereotypes of any type are odious. This is not about age per se, this is not about anyone individually, but I think this reflects a new cultural attitude, a pride (as in lack of humility), a lack of awareness of privilege, a lack of curiosity, a lack of wonder about people. There are too many frankly unkind and slap dash POs coming through. There is a culture that rewards this. Someone said to me once (probably when I was young and they could see a certain arrogance in me) - ‘you have to earn the right to speak into someone’s life’. It’s true, you do. If you don’t bother with this, you become ‘awful’ - which not a good look.

Nicely said. ‘‘Twas ever thus.


Oh you mean that The Probation Service does NOT reflect our communities and is filled with university educated and upwardly mobile, young, white females? Surely not?

Perhaps this is a manifestation of the culture of probation practice. However, I know some young POs who are considerate and caring and go above and beyond in their work with those serving sentences. Maybe she was unlucky as there are always bad apples!

Is this about making younger or inexperienced officers feel bad? There are POs of all ages and experience who are not very good at their jobs. I know a huge raft of younger officers who are doing an incredible job in challenging circumstances. Also some of our clients often take a dislike to their officer because they are actually doing a good job! Sometimes it can take weeks or months of mutual relationship building to reach a good understanding of the purpose of the whole thing, and having to carry out tasks such as enforcement can impact on this, but it doesn't always mean that the person is doing a bad job.

No I was at pains to say it’s not about age it’s about the relationship between professional experience/culture of the organisation. And the relationship between maturity and professionalism. I want to know if something has changed in the organisation as many have observed it - I’m not the only one who sees it. But how to go beyond sense and into evidence I don’t know. User voice is no more in London.

I was a PO for over 10 years. Temping for the last 4 years. I had my temp contract terminated because an offender I had inherited from a female PO put in an official complaint about me for being intimidating and the SPO terminated my contract without an investigation! The offender in question is a sex offender who was annoyed at me because I didn't change his appointment because he wanted to go on a date! I had already changed his appointment due to his employment. He said his previous PO would have allowed him to go on his date and I was being unreasonable. He missed his appointment so I sent him a warning letter. He showed up to his next appointment and then refused to engage in the supervision session, didn't wanna take his sun glasses off, refused to answer any questions. He was on licence and was refusing to engage in the ARMS assessment. I reminded him of his licence conditions and the part about recall. Then he claimed I was intimidating him had upset him so much he was going to go home and get drunk and do drugs. Btw, I was his first male officer! The SPO said that I should have been more understanding. Understanding of what? I reminded her of his licence conditions and the possibility of an SFO because no ARMS had been done before and the previous PO had never enforced any missed appointments or enforced his licence.

I had only been 21 for 2 months when I started in the Probation service in 2014, and I found it tough with some older male service users, as they took one look at me and judged my ability and knowledge as they had children older than me. Now I’m 25 and I still regularly get asked how old I am, which is very frustrating when you are trying to be taken seriously. However, sometimes it is professionals in Probation and other services that seem to judge my ability more than the offenders. This job has taught me not to judge a book by its cover, and I would hope that my colleagues do not judge me by my age, but by my practice.

Absolutely it’s all about the practice and that is what I care about. I really didn’t mean to offend and just want to encourage all new POs who care and are doing a great job. I remember well being a new trainee and it was very stressful and very rewarding, it’s an extraordinary job.

No offence taken, just wanted to highlight how this job can be extra tough on young PO’s! 

Very very true!

I think the process of how we no longer look for the welfare aspects reflects how people are trained. I don’t think age comes into it if you really do care and want to make a difference. I think as individuals our lives shape us and as such some youngsters coming through have some real life experiences. So your right age is not the factor it’s about the care of what happens inside and outside of probation. If this could be on the training agenda then I think we’d have some pretty good officers to keep the service going forward.

Just spoken to a new PQIP recruit who explained the new NPS selection process and he said it’s resulted in a far more diverse intake. Great! But I still don’t see the absolute need for a degree.

I was having a discussion about this very thing this week. Sadly, I think with the split, many amazing experienced officers have gone and have been replaced with new who can then be moulded into the new way of working, hitting targets, paperwork takes priority, 10 minutes per service user, call centres and not understanding the relationship between NPS and CRC or between the service users across the board. You can quite easily have a person on NPS now and never know that their cousin, brother in-law and partner may all be on CRC. I think it's a sad reflection of how the Government have broken this amazing service.

Great discussion. I agree that there are good and bad officers of all ages. I think that the managers are an important part of the Equation.

A manager who does not meet probationers face to face tends to see issues in terms of enforcement and this rubs off on younger officers. Also we have some managers who appear to have put themselves up for the SPO role because they do not want to work with our client group. It worries me that some senior staff lose sight of the fact that a good quality relationship with a probationer is the most effective tool we have!

Thursday, 16 August 2018

Cultural Reflections

Increasingly we seem to be focusing on the cultural distinctiveness of probation being under threat and in that context I was particularly struck by these three contributions from yesterday:-   

No, I don't think it is a storm in a teacup. I was proud to work for a service that was prepared, subject to the obvious limitations, to "put its money where it's mouth was". I benefited from an organisation that was prepared to be open minded and not dismiss my application out of hand because of a criminal conviction. I committed that offence over 30 years ago. I disclosed it, of course. It has never held me back or prevented me from doing my job. I hope well. I have not been civil service or Visor vetted since TR. My Visor vetting needs renewing next year. Theoretically, I should have nothing to worry about as presumably once cleared and assuming no change in circumstances the vetting should be a straightforward decision. I will let you know!

I think this is really interesting debate. I was taught to be a reflective practitioner. Is it any wonder we are met with 'resistance' from those we work with to our conditions and stipulations? They would say obstacles and downright jump, do as I say or else, hoop jumping punitive sanctions. And I would say that is where the art of Probation lies, managing those poles within a range of contesting demands, in a responsible and empathetic way. For me that is why Probation deserves its professional status and high regard. A difficult task but not an impossible one. I empathise with all those Probation staff who are now faced with their pasts being resurrected on the alter of 'past performance as a stable predictor of future performance.' Spare a thought.

What feels like a million years ago (how the time flies when your country and its moral backbone is being dismantled) a rather clever advisor to Probation Management said something along the lines of... this may not be verbatim but it made a huge impression on me at the time... 


"You are a terrific organisation. You have enormous assets, in the main your staff and reputation, and deliver great value. You punch way above your weight. Your one weakness is that your corporate strategy appears to be to jump through every hoop that is presented to you. Without a strong and clearly articulated statement of your identity, purpose and values, you will have nothing to fall back on, to defend your organisation, and will be diminished by every hoop through which you jump. With a clearly articulated statement of your purpose and identity, good leadership would be able to embrace some demands, and refuse others, and every time this happened, the purpose and identity of your organisation would be strengthened."

My Trust paid a lot for that advice, and it was spot on, but not heeded. But still good advice.

--oo00oo--

Continuing this theme, twitter threw up the following piece published on the Medium platform and which rather neatly summarises my thoughts about being a probation officer and my growing irritation with managerialism :-

Ambition, humility, confidence and change

I have made no secret of the fact that this has been one of the most difficult years I have had in a work context. I have always struggled a bit, both professionally and personally with confidence — people meeting me may not realise it, but it’s the constant inner critical voice telling me I’m faking it and can make people think I’m competent and it’s all a facade which is going to be pulled away at any moment.

The year was difficult because it came off the back of having a deeply dysfunctional relationship with a previous line manager. I have now settled down to having a new manager who couldn’t be more different and with whom I not only get on well with but I genuinely like as a person, it has given me more time to reflect on management skills, styles and professional development.

But aside from that, it has made me think a lot about the importance of self-confidence in professional growth. I am not, I don’t think, an ambitious character. I don’t crave advancement. I have been in my current job for nearly six years and it has offered me incredible opportunities to learn and develop vast swathes of knowledge in the field of mental health particularly, when I came from having worked in a particular narrow field and for that I am very grateful. However, my lack of ambition has been interpreted as a lack of desire to advance or grow professionally. I have been told this repeatedly.

I have constantly remarked, to anyone who will pause to listen to me for a couple of minutes, that lack of interest in hierarchy and particularly a lack of professional ambition, shouldn’t be interpreted as a lack of interest in development but increasingly I see it to be the case. I look at the language around fast-track social work training which pushes the idea of leadership early on even when training and seems to imply the lack of desire to lead is somehow something to look down on. Leadership is all. Leadership is where the dynamism goes. You need to be a Leader — here, have some training so you can call yourself a Leader. Lead, Inspire, Put up a Wallchart telling people who come into your office what a good Leader you are. Nowhere does there seem to be space to learn about the importance of humility and yet, it is through humility that we both grow and learn — not just to listen but to change on the basis of what we have heard.

While I have never had much interest in management, I have constantly had a strong interest in professional growth. I don’t want career advancement based on a hierarchical model of climbing a structure and reaching a career ‘peak’ with a stream of underlings and a raft of powers. I have though, always sought and been ambitious to grow professionally within the role I have. I want to learn. I want to be the best I can possibly be in the current role I have because by being more knowledgeable, more understanding and more effective, I can make more of a difference — it might not be able influencing strategic directions of large organisations, but on a micro level it might make a difference to one or two people who might, in turn, go on to make a difference to others.

But this is not recognised as growth too often within organisations which are built on traditional power structures. We push people into feeling that they have little value if they do not constantly seek advancement through the structures that are in place professionally. We create leadership development courses and talent management programmes which define people by their ambition within organisations. And yet (while this isn’t the case for me), rely on those having the confidence to apply and put themselves forward for these courses or opportunities which filters out the potential talent that may not have the supportive line manager or self-confidence to challenge or push themselves into these roles. This means that those who have the necessary personal skills including humility, may not have the same opportunities to develop or grow.

Fundamentally the substantial changes which will come and are needed in this sector come by engaging with people who use the services which are provided or which are potentially provided and listening with humility in order to make changes. As staff, we are conditioned within the organisations and systems which train us. People who have gone from university into graduate training programmes can’t bring the changes if they don’t know what needs to change. Change projects which are internally focused at staff who are involved in them risk losing the purpose of why we are making these changes if they are not, from the start, co-produced with those who have experienced services which do not work, which exclude with too much vigour, which come from a position of arrogance of ‘me empowering you to give me feedback’.

So moving on from thinking about the way organisations value staff, to looking at the way the service-user/patient and carer voice is used in all changes which happen particularly around the development of strategic changes, we come back to the value of humility in leadership. I don’t want any manager of mine to flaut inspirational quotes or posters. I don’t want an inspirational leader. I want a manager who listens. I want a leader who has the humility to listen — not on the basis of hierarchical structures to those around them, but to those who are most affected by the direction of the organisation they lead. And I mostly want them to have the humility to push a change in direction based on this feedback.


Ermintrude

Wednesday, 15 August 2018

ViSOR Special

It's quite clear that all is far from well in NPS and the vexed issue of vetting and ViSOR is rapidly becoming the catalyst that highlights why probation should never be part of HMPPS and the civil service command and control ethos. We've covered it several times before and the subject formed a large part of yesterday's blog by Ian Lawrence, no doubt because Napo is getting quite a lot of grief from the membership. 

The latest Napo briefing document published two weeks ago can be found here and there's been much discussion on Facebook:-

Does anyone have a view, advice re latest visor business ie let the police investigate your life before you get permission to access visor!!!!! Form includes asking for details re your lifestyle, personal details, financial circumstances (do you have debt and susceptibility to bribes), details of your partner, family members and children umm don’t think I’ve forgotten anything oh yes all information will be treated confidentially now sign and you have 14 days to complete it!

It sounds like you might need government Secure Clearance level to access it now - I’m secure cleared and that sounds like the sort of thing I was asked. Have you been turned down for credit in the past 7 years was one of the questions on my form and I was like “I can’t remember what I was doing last week let alone 7 years ago...”

The form is very similar to the one I filled in for a job with them, but my form was for a CTC level check. It's interesting that they put microscopes in places you never know you possessed!

From the submission by Napo Cymru to the Wales Justice Commission: (the whole thing is online here.

"With developing work, particularly in MAPPA and Prolific Offenders (IOM: Integrated Offender Management) there is increasing risk of Probation’s identity and role being subsumed and diluted. There is high concern amongst Probation practitioners regarding the vetting processes required for Probation Staff to be given access to the Police Visor database. This process is opaque - the criteria, who makes the judgement regarding acceptability, whether the information disclosed is stored, the existence of an appeals process are unknowns. It is likely to further exclude those with “lived experience” of crime and the CJS from probation practice, whose contribution can be significant – and lead towards an homogeneity of the workforce"

Yes I questioned it and was basically told we have no choice. I’ve done it but not happy about it. The Napo advice was useful.

Scream it. Probation has its own identity and values, and its leaders need to have the confidence and commitment to champion that. The Visor vetting is deeply dubious, and questionable both ethically and legally, in my view. Our top brass need to put the foot down, say it is not in the interests or ethic of our organisation to oblige its staff to submit to this, and at a bottom line, agree to a very limited number of VOLUNTEER staff to jump through these dodgy hoops.

I know. We have had the stuffing knocked out of us, TR was properly traumatic, financially and emotionally. Good people have gone. We were advised to "get over it" but injustice is a thing that burns. And finding the energy (even the troopers) for more is a big ask. I am searching my soul.

Totally agree! One of my colleagues was asked by her manager “what have you got to hide?” leaving my colleague feeling embarrassed, intimidated and angry! I feel there will be little to no support from management and that saddens me though doesn’t shock me..which is even more sad!

"If you have done nothing wrong you have nothing to fear" is the standard trope of the totalitarian. Very very creepy.

It’s the intrusiveness, the insinuation that if you’re in debt you are susceptible to bribes, the nosing into your family...who may have done something wrong...that you don’t know about, the putting of staff against staff again, the suspicion!!! It stinks!!!

God I am so glad I am out. This sounds like the Stasi. 1984 here we come.


Do people not need to give consent to their details being disclosed? If I'm being forced to disclose other people's information without their consent as I don't actually know what or where else the info is going or to be used for, could I be breaching some sort of privacy regulations?

If you or your close ones refuse to give consent from what I have read they will do it anyway!! So I guess they are asking for consent out of.....courtesy??? 

I'm a PO that will 100% fail vetting due to having a past conviction 40 years ago. I know others that have failed because of past convictions of self and family, previous dismissal from employment, bad credit and CCJ’s. I also know one person who failed and was not told why. Rightly Napo are finally addressing this. PO’s do not need to use Visor, it’s a system we’ve never needed. How are the police getting away with forcing us to use their system and then dictating who is eligible!

Imagine if Probation demanded all PC’s and DiCk’s must use NDelius and any that had ever had a disciplinary, a student loan or were ever on benefits can no longer work on the frontline! To use this useless system means submitting my life history via an admin (who will tell everyone) to be vetted and failed by local police. No thanks!

On failing vetting I’ll be sent to work in Courts, and EVERYONE will know why. There’ll never be a chance of promotion or role change. Very unfair! If I refuse to fill in the form that’ll ruin my career I’m threatened with disciplinary. It’s not a “reasonable instruction”, it’s extremely unfair!

Don't fill in the form make them direct you but I doubt they will. The problem is they will oust you from role anyway claiming you did not fill it in. There is a post in Napo by the said perspective VC come national chair that was largely in agreement with the Vetting. All right for some then eh? The change in our work now determined by a further police check when we all know what they are about is just a deeper mire. Most staff know it will only ruin a few colleagues lives and they wont hold any solidarity for that. Nor will Napo.

I have 10k credit card debt. Am I likely to fail?

Maybe not if your credit rating is okay. Most people with have some debt. I think CCJ’s are a definite failure, and bad credit rating and associated debt a possible failure.

Yes it was Katie Lomas that told us that forcing Vetting on staff against their will, and shifting Vetting failures into alternative positions against their will, is acceptable. There are many staff really worried about Vetting and imagine how it must be for those that expect to fail it - the condemned waiting for an execution date. You’re right, there’ll be no solidarity as the majority of staff are of the “what have you got to hide” mentality. When it came up in our team meeting the manager told us how clean her background was and how she passed Vetting with flying colours. Not a care for others in the room that were very quiet, or the brave one that announced they expected to fail.

It’s not a “reasonable instruction” if there are no reasonable procedures in place to deal with vetting failure, including how the NPS will apply Vetting Plus exemptions or alternative adjustments to keep staff in post. I suspect there’s been more failures than expected already and NPS are struggling to keep staff at the mo. Napo could easily fight this and kick Vetting into the long grass.Reply

Probation has its own identity and values, and its leaders need to have the confidence and commitment to champion that. The Visor vetting is deeply dubious, and questionable both ethically and legally, in my view. Our top brass need to put the foot down, say it is not in the interests or ethic of our organisation to oblige its staff to submit to this, and at a bottom line, agree to a very limited number of VOLUNTEER staff to jump through these dodgy hoops.

I have commented on this previously, if VISOR is such a precious inner sanctum it seems daft to open it to thousands of supposedly clean slates. Create a passageway with guards and access protocols. If there is a reason that this is not a sensible option then please explain why.

Visor is an excuse. The real reason is Vetting brings us in line with prison staff who are Vetted. Then probation staff can easily be moved between probation and prisons.

Man down t’ pub says probation management should be completing a Vetting Plus form at point of Vetting application of every staff member expecting to fail. Vetting Plus allows those that’d normally fail get clearance, and is renewed on an annual basis. How else do you think ex-offenders go into prisons as mentors.

Probation managers can also override vetting failure with Director approval and allow them to remain in post.

I'd like to know how many have failed Vetting already, how many have been moved in to new roles and how many were dismissed or left after failing.

And how many cases did Napo take on, win and return staff to original posts?

The answer is zero because Katie Lomas & Co think moving staff to other roles is an acceptable solution. It is not.

I think there would grounds for Constructive Dismissal if an individual failed and was subsequently told they could not continue in the role. Would NAPO support them at an Employment Tribunal? I think not, given they have been complicit in the implementation of this new diktat. About [time] NAPO was replaced by a union that has it's members rights as it's priority. Where is our pay progression due in April? What will they take away this time as part of a pay deal that they probably won't honour next year, as in the case of the last pay reform?

I've said it before and I'll say it again. Malicious gossip around vetting has led to shameful and serious levels of bullying (staff on staff) by individuals seeking to protect their own position and damage the reputations of others. Some very experienced staff have behaved appallingly.

"Divide & Rule" - one of the favourite bullying strategies of Spurr's Noms/HMPPS. Introduce divisive, discriminatory, so-called 'elitist' practices which enables management to scapegoat staff, and which encourages staff to develop cliques & alienate those who are deemed 'less than' in order to secure their own positions.

This should have been a blog post. There’s ongoing discussion on fb around this. The more it’s exposed the better. It’s not right that any probation colleague with years of experience should be moved to the court team or forced out of employment because of bad credit, a past conviction or dismissal, or the conviction of a partner or family member. Will Napo tell us the figures of how many have failed Vetting, how many moved to other posts against their will, how many NPS overrides have been applied, how many have Napo fought to keep in post? - Answers on a postcard to Katie Lomas and Ian Lawrence.

Do CRC staff get vetted ?

No. They just use the DBS system.

I think it was definitely Napo who wanted vetting in the NPS - I mean 100% must have been, because NPS imposed it so Napo must have wanted it. I'd also heard the moon is made of cheese. Wonder if Napo did that too.

Some of us were moved to CRC's nothing to do with vetting. Some NPS staff think they are better than CRC staff. If they can move a huge number of staff into the private sector they are not going to worry about moving staff who fail the vetting. The MoJ has walked all over us and continue to do so. We've been given poor advice from the start of this shambles. Here we go again with more shit and more money wasted.


How and why the police are now involved in deciding who is eligible for frontline probation work is beyond me. The NPS / HMPPS is using Visor vetting to bully and control. This is their little stick or power at the moment at last Napo is working to smack it’s hand and take it away.

“the only concession they are willing to make is to ensure that their communications to Divisional Leadership teams include the requirement to support staff who are suffering the intense distress and indignity of this process.”

This shows how bad the NPS really is, and that it doesn’t care about staff issues at all. No different from the hangman agreeing to use a clean rope.

Sounds like Probation has succumbed to the same fate as many once-effective public services (NHS, DSS/DWP, etc) i.e. they are self-soothing narcissists who are ignoring/failing their raison d'etre. This is the inevitability of the obsessive target-driven culture which has overshadowed, overwhelmed & stifled any indigenous culture of professional practice. Visor, E3, OMiC - none are necessary for effective probation practice but, hiding behind the kevlar shield of Risk Management, they allow hierarchical managerialist bullies to flex their departmental muscle, demonstrate power & control, show who's in charge. Yet in a bid to be regarded as 'ok' those same organisational opportunists try to claim ownership of the very culture & values they are erasing. I recall seeing a senior NPS person on social media saying she is "passionate about Probation values". The dissonance is writ large, but no-one is calling it out.

More importantly, none of this bullshit assists those who are made subject to supervision by Probation staff.

They could have given us more staffing, increased resources, better quality training, and housing, jobs and support for those on probation, but instead we get Visor and Vetting that helps who exactly???

I have Visor clearance but it is due for renewal next year. The process is opaque so; whilst I have been cleared with my and my extended family's "lived experience", as it is termed, fully disclosed, am I assured clearance on the re-check? A rhetorical question but as there have been no changes in my circumstances, the answer should be "yes". We will see.

NAPO should have started fighting this last year. Too little too late really. I have been under pressure with this since last year. Failed Visor and given the opportunity to appeal. Police provided details of my fail due to life experiences and they dug up all sorts of info about me. All very stressful and so intrusive as much of this happened 25 - 30 odd years ago and I have been in probation now for 15 years. The Police are now requesting more info and a response from me in relation to my past for an appeal. I have not taken this route yet. If I could get out of the service now I would. There is very little respect/support for staff in relation to this and a lot of pressure from senior management to comply with vetting. Why has there been so little opposition to this up to now? Allowing the police to play such a major part in who can work in probation? I am ashamed of the service I work for.

"Whilst it is essential to have enough staff to meet with the mandatory ViSOR requirements, it is important that you only train, and therefore obtain security clearance for, those staff who have agreed to the vetting process and are identified as having a need and a purpose in accessing the ViSOR database."

Why are they being allowed to deviate from this??

I penned a guest blog 'Whitewashing the Probation Service' on this in October 2017 and the situation has only worsened. C’mon Napo - pull your finger out!

Probation Instruction PI03/14 can be found here.

June 2015 - Mike McClelland briefing GLNapo

"6. Security Vetting

This is currently covered by Probation Instruction 3/14. At the Probation Consultative Forum (PCF) in April, Napo expressed its concerns about this PI. In places it is felt that it is difficult to follow and that it has not been satisfactorily transposed from the Prison Service policy upon which it was based. It was not the subject of full consultation with the unions prior to publication. At the PCF, it was agreed that (retrospective) consultation would be sought with a view to improving the quality of the PI. We await an invitation to consult."

May 2016 - E3 Implementation Agreement

1. This document sets out the terms of a proposal for an agreement between the NPS and its recognised Trade Unions as to how the operational changes resulting from the E3 Programme will be implemented.

2. The Agreement is based on four principles that underpin our approach to implementation:


a. Openness and Transparency. NPS will share with staff the information they need to make informed choices.
b. Fairness. NPS will ensure that all staff are treated fairly.
c. Equality. NPS is committed to ensuring that the implementation of E3 complies with the highest standards in relation to equality considerations.
d. Minimise disruption – NPS will balance the need to minimise the disruption to staff with the need to minimise disruption to the provision of probation services. NPS will make every effort to minimise the impact on staff and where reasonable take into account personal circumstances, in line with our policies and the provisions set out below.

2017 - HMPPS/NPS response to NAPO can be found here.


2017 - Ian Lawrence's blog  'VISOR vetting - some clarification about what is going on'

2017 - Napo Briefing

"The employers have accepted that the additional vetting required for ViSOR use is likely to create additional stress for some staff. The NPS has repeated the reassurance that no one will lose their employment simply because of a vetting issue, unless the information uncovered is so serious that the code of conduct is breached."

Jan 2018 - Ian Lawrence

"During the consultation on the extending of ViSOR use, Napo raised a number of concerns about the impact of vetting as well as practice and workload issues. We received some assurances from the employers"

Aug 2018 - Katie Lomas

"The introduction of this wider use of ViSOR was part of the E3 phase 2 programme. At the time of the consultation on phase 2 Napo made representations about the mechanism for vetting"

So it seems there's been 4 years of Spurr saying "This is what will happen" & Napo saying "Ah, but, erm, well, erm...". It's the same inaction & passive complicity that allowed TR to proceed, that allowed the CRC clearances & that has allowed HMPPS to ride roughshod over NPS staff.

“The NPS has repeated the reassurance that no one will lose their employment simply because of a vetting issue”. This is simply not true if ‘vetting failures’ are being shoe-horned into alternative roles against their will. And what happens when there’s no positions in Courts, will ACO, SPO, PO, PSO ‘vetting failures’ be forced into Admin roles? For PO’s and PSO’s more likely forced out of the service!
🙁




Tuesday, 14 August 2018

ViSOR and Probation Culture

At last there are signs of a fight starting for the values, ethics and culture of probation and with the likelihood of Wales shortly seeing reunification under civil service control, it looks as if ViSOR vetting is rapidly becoming a major issue there. Thanks go to the reader for forwarding this:-

Ian Barrow 
Director, National Probation Service Wales

Dear Ian,

(cc: Members of Napo Cymru)

Re: VISOR Vetting

I am writing on behalf of the executive to raise the matter of VISOR vetting.

For some time now the practice has been that a small number of Probation Officers and other staff, administrators and managers for example, have submitted information and been vetted for VISOR. We understand that until now the established practice is for one or two officers in a site to be approved for VISOR access.

This has its problems, which Napo nationally has been involved in, and we recognise the immediate logistical attraction of blanket vetting for all staff to be vetted and for VISOR access to be an expectation of the role of staff.

However, we now have an instruction from you that all Probation Officers and some other staff, should submit their information in order to be vetted for VISOR access, to a short and apparently urgent deadline. We have been inundated with calls from members concerned about the implications. These are:

  • Those staff who “fail” the vetting process will be disadvantaged. You have undertaken that staff who “fail” the process will be redeployed. We expect higher numbers than can be easily accommodated within alternative deployment to “fail”. 
  • Those staff who “fail” will have their careers limited and compromised by exclusion from VISOR access and the work that will then align with it 
  • Members are required to submit information regarding their nearest and dearest. Some members report that they have been advised that their nearest and dearest do not wish their information to be given, which places them in a stressful and compromised situation. 
Napo Cymru is concerned that there is an increasing risk of Probation’s identity and role being subsumed and diluted. This process is opaque: the criteria; who makes the judgement regarding acceptability; whether the information disclosed is stored; the existence of an appeals process; are all unknown. It is likely to further exclude those with “lived experience” of crime and the CJS from probation practice, whose contribution can be significant – and lead towards an homogeneity of the workforce.

At the bottom line, this is a significant change to the values and culture of probation. It requires the leaders of Probation to make decisions taking regard of their role as leaders of an organisation and culture. It could be argued that acquiescence to a dictate from another organisation calls into question the leadership within our organisation.

This matter is to be raised at the next JCC and we ask you to:
  • Negotiate for a small minimum of staff to be required to undergo vetting and the arrangements for working with our MAPPA cases that this will require 
  • Engage further with staff and explain the proposed requirements for VISOR vetting and the details around appeal, data collection, and protection 
  • Justify these in relation to Probation Values Ethics and Culture 
  • Allow time for this to be properly negotiated and considered 
  • Meet with staff to elucidate your understanding of what Probation is, (especially in light of the recent announcement) it’s Values, Mission and Purpose 
I look forward to hearing from you,

Lisa Robinson
Joint Chair Napo Cymru


--oo00oo--

This from Napo News last Friday:-

Update for Members – ViSOR Vetting

Members will be aware that Napo have been in discussion with the employers about the extension of ViSOR use (and therefore Police vetting) in the NPS since the E3 consultation. Our latest update gives the history and context as well as outlining the many concerns that members have about the vetting. An emergency meeting was held with the employers yesterday (9th August) to try to get some clarification in some issues and to seek some resolution which would mitigate the potentially significant impact of failure of this level of vetting. We are as frustrated as members about the lack of progress in this and the collective view was made clear yesterday. What was also made clear was the employers view that what they are doing is entirely reasonable and while they accept that this is causing high levels of stress the only concession they are willing to make is to ensure that their communications to Divisional Leadership teams include the requirement to support staff who are suffering the intense distress and indignity of this process.

Napo’s leadership group are due to meet next week and will discuss this and give consideration to all possible courses of action that are available to us at this point, including an industrial strategy and campaign. We are also consulting with Unison Leaders on a joint strategy.

Monday, 13 August 2018

The Government and Homelessness

With regard to today's much-trumpeted announcement that the government intends to eradicate street homelessness by 2027, those of us with long memories will recall how things were very different when the government once had in place quite a spohisticated network of services for this group. They were the DHSS 'spikes', direct descendents of the dreaded Victorian Workhouse, but swept away by political correctness in the 1980's. This reprint from the Sunday Times September 15th 1985:-   

Last days of the spike


By the time George Orwell was writing about homelessness in London, “the spike” had become the common name for a shelter of last resort. The original, and by far the biggest, was the great Victorian Institution in Camberwell, which this week closes after more than a century of service. Brian Deer looks back over its history.

When in 1850 the first steam engines came chugging through south London on the new Chatham and Dover Railway, the noise, the grime and the curiosity were all too much for the nuns of Nazareth House. Confronted with the disturbance of the industrial revolution, they packed their bibles, sold their land, and on the site of their convent up sprang perhaps Britain’s greatest single landmark of Christian charity.

The site was first refurbished as the Camberwell workhouse, taking whole families from the newly-emerging urban underclass of homeless, jobless poor. The demand was overwhelming and soon the Guardians of Camberwell erected two vast grey-brick buildings either side of the nuns’ simple chapel. And so was born the place where a million men have slept, and which to its users has ever since been simply known as The Spike.

Nobody is certain about the origins of the nickname. One view is that the spike in question was the means by which those too drunk to stand were held in an upright posture. Another is that it was the implement with which residents broke rocks for their keep. But whatever the origin of the label, it became known throughout Britain and Ireland as the place where you could always get a bed for the night and not have too much bother.

On a winter night in its heyday, some 15 years ago, the Spike, now the Department of Health and Social Security’s Camberwell Resettlement Unit, packed in 1,100 bedraggled men. Each had a narrow bunkspace, a thin mattress and a blanket. Most were chronically alcoholic, many had fleas or lice, and considerably more than a handful would wet their bed at night.

They slept in eight noisy, dirty and often dangerous dormitories, each over 30 yards long, in two hospital-like wings. One wing housed the long-stay guests, or “residents”, who were allowed to remain all day on the premises if they performed some useful chore. The other was for “casuals”, who each afternoon lined up outside the gates to register, shower and eat.

Even 10 years ago, Dr John Hewetson, Camberwell’s medical officer, recorded an alarming level of sickness among the unit’s users. Nearly half had a history of mental illness. 34% were handicapped, 14% suffered from epilepsy and 13% had tuberculosis. “Schizophrenics, demented old men, the brain-damaged, rigid abrasive characters are all accepted at Camberwell,” Hewetson noted.

In the past decade, the numbers admitted to the unit have been run down, and this week the few who remain will be bussed away to psychiatric hospitals and the Spike will finally close. Smaller hostels are to take the strain of the homeless, and only the acrid smell of a century of filth recalls Camberwell’s easily-forgettable past.

The closure is part of a national plan to shut 24 resettlement units in major cities and hand over their functions to local government and voluntary bodies. “This provision, which is largely a relic of the poor law workhouses, has come to seem increasingly anomalous,” Tony Newton, the minister for social security, told parliament earlier this year.

From Newton’s standpoint, the closures of the units will be happy events – lifting the dead hand of the DHSS bureaucrats from the department’s only direct services for the homeless. There is no rationale for government-run centres that have no links with the local community.

But there has been a sadness at the Spike in recent weeks that may seem at first hard to comprehend. “This is the best place of them all. I don’t want to leave here,” explains Albert Mills, aged 70, who has stalked the unit’s corridors since 1972. “Nobody worries you here. You can do more or less what you want to.”

Like nearly all the Spike’s residents, Mills has given smaller hostels a try, attempted life in lodgings and spent years living rough. Today, he sits aimlessly watching daytime television and remembering his youthful years. “I was never any good on my own,” he concludes. “I’d just be pissed all the time.”

The paradox of the Spike is that, for all its poor conditions, people like Mills much prefer the life in a big institution and will find it hard to struggle-on elsewhere. Before its run-down, 90% of those resettled by Camberwell were back within six months and, for them, pools of urine in the dormitories are of less importance than the right to be left alone.

“In the smaller hostels they are seen more and probably kept on their toes a bit more than they are at Camberwell; and some of them don’t like that,” says Frank Woodhead, who as the Spike’s current manager is supervising its closure. “It’s just their way of living, you see. If they’ve been wandering round the country for years, it doesn’t go down very well.”

The impeccable Victorian structure stands all but silent now, the gates finally closed on the destitute men who have walked from all over England to the shelter of Camberwell. This weekend, a few late stragglers will appear – to be sent on somewhere else. And even those who are found new homes find it hard to stay away. They come wandering back along the railway track for a last goodbye to the Spike.

--oo00oo--

Hansard 29th October 1979

Mr. Kilroy-Silk

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services if he will give the name, location and capacity of the reception and resettlement centres administered by the Supplementary Benefits Commission for homeless single (a) men and (b) women; if he considers the number of places to be sufficient; and what steps he is taking to increase the number.


Provincial

Alvaston Derby 104
Brighton Sussex 38
Crown Quay Lodge Sittingbourne, Kent 76
Fazakerley Liverpool 61
Glasgow Bishopbriggs, Glasgow 63
Leeds Leeds 96
Leicester Wigston, Leicester 100
Newbury Berkshire 68
Plawsworth Chester-le-Street, Co. Durham 112
Southampton Southampton 80
South Wales Bridgend, Mid-Glamorgan 64
Walkden Worsley, Manchester 84
West Midlands Stourbridge, Worcestershire 123
Winterbourne Bristol 112
Woodhouse Sheffield 96

London 

Camberwell Peckham, SE15 550
Camden Birkenhead Street, WC1 35*
Cedars Lodge Cedars Road, SW4 30* 70
Bridge House Kingsdown Close, W10 120
Hither Green Ennersdale Road, SE13 150
Pound Lodge Pound Lane, NW10 80
Lancelot Andrewes House Great Guildford Street, Southwark, SE1 60
West End House Dean Street, Soho, W1 80

Total 2,452  
*women