Saturday, 11 August 2018

Responses to Demise of TR 4

Thanks go to the reader for forwarding the following:- 

Napo Briefing Paper 1 Strengthening Probation, Building Confidence 

INTRODUCTION

As soon as it was possible to get out of Parliament without having to answer questions about it, the Government published their long awaiting Probation System’s Review, in the form of an 8 week consultation when Minister’s will be on holiday!

It is difficult not to be sceptical about how genuine a consultation this is, especially given the reputation of Governments around “consultations” generally and their ignoring all the warnings about the risks in TR. With some of the disastrous Transforming Rehabilitation Revolution’s Chief Engineers still in key position (e.g. Michael Spurr as Supreme Head of HMPPS; Contracts and Costing Chief Iain Poree; Grayling’s Chief Communicator Amy Rees back in Wales) this scepticism is re-enforced.

REUNIFICATION & ADDITIONAL INVESTMENT?

However, it is also difficult not to see the critical importance of this next stage in the transformation probation and community rehabilitation services in England in Wales. Napo, along with most experts and probation stakeholders, predicted long before any TR contracts were exchanged, that Grayling’s model was unsustainable. In particular:

1. Artificially splitting service delivery at local level between the nationalised NPS and the outsourced CRCs is irrational and dangerous. It creates unnecessary bureaucratic, trust and information barriers between local professionals. It means offender managers in the NPS are overloaded and prone to burn out with only high-risk cases, whilst former colleagues in CRCs have fewer opportunities to learn and develop when working on only low and medium risk cases. It creates an artificial market for staff, especially in areas where recruitment and retention are already difficult, such as London and the South-East.

Can you imagine any other service being treated like this? What politician would suggest dividing the local fire service into two with the nationalised service only responding to serious fires and where there is an immediate risk to life and a privatised fire service only responding to low risk call outs? Why is such insanity allowed in probation? Addressing this insanity must be everyone’s first priority in this review.

The consultation talks about new models being explored and almost piloted, particularly in Wales, where core probation services are being brought back together. It states, “We will then consider whether the learning from these new arrangements is applicable to the system in England” (pg7). Confirming how serious the Government are about learning will be a big test of the consultation.

2. The TR revolution has been undermined by shocking financial planning and incompetent contract management from the start. This needs to be recognised and addressed in any plans to move forward.

Much has been made and said about the constant need to adjust, top-up or bail-out the existing CRC contracts. The excuses offered by Minister’s recently are enlightening in that they shed some light on the continuing weakness of the contracts – e.g. Gauke recently telling Parliament that some contractors are still being paid less than the cost of providing the service as if this was a good thing. In reality, giving this critical work to companies to run against ridiculous margins is dangerous.

Napo believe that the current contracts are founded upon fiction, guesswork and hope – Grayling’s team desperately trying to stimulate a non-existent and sceptical market with false and over-optimistic promises. It is inevitable that some owners want to walk away early. Others will want to sue the Government for mis-selling. Simply terminating the contracts and starting again would inevitably cost.

We believe the “early termination of the contracts” is a cover for a final bail-out – those who want to walk being allowed to cut their losses and those who want to stay being squared up to the end of the original contracts so their shareholders are at least not out of pocket and wanting to sue the MoJ. A key signpost to if we are right will be the length of the new contracts – something the consultation is silent about.

However, very little public debate has focussed upon the relative costs of the NPS – also being met by the taxpayer and managed incompetently by the MoJ. Prior to TR, Napo asked what the anticipated budget for the NPS was and were met by an indignant and angry response that it was, “None of our business”. We doubt there ever was an original NPS budget – none has ever been published to our knowledge.

We do know that as the number and type of case being passed to CRC’s were less than expected there was a corresponding increase in the anticipated number of cases arriving in the NPS. By 2020, there will be several thousand more offender managers in the NPS than was planned in 2014.

The financial strain on all parts of the service has had a constant impact operationally – including upon staff morale. In the NPS this has been amplified by constant payroll and pension issues, as a consequence of forcing it into inappropriate HR systems to meet the TR timetable. Workloads have risen - in CRCs because of staff cuts due to budget problems and in the NPS because they can’t recruit enough staff quickly enough. Sickness absence is still high across probation.

Whatever happens next, Parliament’s first question should be, “How much is all of this actually going to cost us?” Napo members, probation’s clients, victims and the public can only hope this time probation gets a financial settlement more worthy of its true value.

3. The consultation also talks about wanting to “Develop a workforce strategy which ensures providers can recruit and develop staff they need to deliver quality probation services and support staff to build careers” (page 7).

Even recognising this as an aspiration is welcomed given the experience of Napo members across the NPS and CRCs since TR. The artificial split has been one factor that has prevented any significant progress in terms of developing a clear professional career path from entry level (as a PSO or working in an AP) into senior leadership training and development for probation managers. Napo have long argued for a license to practice for all Offender Managers and, whilst encouraged by this being potentially in the scope of the consultation, we note the limited progress as the NPS had been unwilling to “impose on” private contractors.

Developing a more coherent professional strategy should start by removing the split between providers of core probation services in communities.

The next step is then strategically addressing probation pay reform across the whole service.


Pay reform was identified as a priority before TR. A sensible and sustainable pay system will be fair and measurably equitable, consistent, stable and transparent. Probation’s is utterly opaque, rooted in unfairness and increasingly inconsistent even locally. Whatever operating model the Government settles for it will not be stable or sustainable whilst experienced offender managers doing exactly the same work in the same offices for the same employers earn several thousand more or less than their each other just because of different start dates. At an ET case in 2016, NPS officials admitted to recognising age discrimination risks. Since then no formal negotiations have been allowed to address these even in the NPS.

This additional cost and financial instability generated by TR has prevented the Treasury releasing funds for probation pay reform. For the last two years, Napo have been told addressing this is Spurr’s “top strategic priority”. In the meantime, the MoJ has been a dysfunctional parent, failing to get its accounts signed off and is now effectively being run by its Treasury auditors – like a near bankrupt business. Since 2016, Probation have seen the HMPPS favourite child, aka the Prison service, get two pay rises whilst probation staff have received literally nothing. In CRC’s, some of the more stable have offered at least something to staff but all are struggling and fear pay reform in the NPS leading to an exodus of experienced staff to their local competitor.

If Ministers are genuine about valuing staff then finding the resources for pay reform must be built into the costs of the next phase with employers and unions given the space to seriously negotiate a sustainable pay model for the future.

CONCLUSION

Napo members have been waiting for the Probation Services Review for a long time and will inevitably be reading between the lines. Our first impressions is that this consultation doesn’t give many clear answers or even a clear direction. Right down to how and when it was released, it reflects a Government that’s confused and chaotic - reacting tactically on a day by day basis rather than thinking strategically.

This presents us with a huge opportunity. Like many consultation papers the best starting point is not the questions they ask but identifying the questions they don’t ask, exploring these and asking what the gap means. The big questions that the paper doesn’t ask but needs an answer to are: 


  • Will the Government have the sense and courage to reunite core probation services locally and if so, how and when can this be done? 
  • Will the Government recognise the true value of a professional, trained, locally accountable probation service and how much is it willing to invest to meet this aspiration? 
  • Will this really extend to staff this time, with their response to Napo’s demands for pay reform being a critical early signpost?
Dean Rogers
Assistant General Secretary 

Friday, 10 August 2018

Run It Up the Flagpole and See Who Salutes

It's Friday and I sense another lull in respect of the probation world, which is just as well because I've been encouraged to wander 'off piste' with this that appeared over night:- 
Off topic. I imagine it is not just me who has noticed the divisive and hateful bigotry that is being freely traded on social media these days. Boris Johnson's, the [former] Foreign Secretary, words have noticeably increased that content. It's distressing. What is equally evident is that there is no significant repudiation from those who would once have considered his comments incendiary. Have we become immune to this, a new narrative becoming normalised? If you find a gap I would appreciate one of your 'off piste' focus blogs. Having said that, once upon a time, Probation values would not have had this as 'off piste.'
It's been bothering me as well, hence my making this observation yesterday:-
I suspect that in the current age of post truth and fake news, well argued cases, evidence, truth even counts for nowt - what matters nowadays is winning the emotional argument. Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage learnt this lesson ages ago.
If truth be known I've been waiting to use this from the Irish Times since I came across it in June. Politicians, especially former journalists like Boris Johnson, don't make 'mistakes' with their political posturing and I can't help feeling there are some very uncomfortable parallels here:-   

Trial runs for fascism are in full flow

Babies in cages were no ‘mistake’ by Trump but test-marketing for barbarism

To grasp what is going on in the world right now, we need to reflect on two things. One is that we are in a phase of trial runs. The other is that what is being trialled is fascism – a word that should be used carefully but not shirked when it is so clearly on the horizon. Forget “post-fascist” – what we are living with is pre-fascism.

It is easy to dismiss Donald Trump as an ignoramus, not least because he is. But he has an acute understanding of one thing: test marketing. He created himself in the gossip pages of the New York tabloids, where celebrity is manufactured by planting outrageous stories that you can later confirm or deny depending on how they go down. And he recreated himself in reality TV where the storylines can be adjusted according to the ratings. Put something out there, pull it back, adjust, go again.

Fascism doesn’t arise suddenly in an existing democracy. It is not easy to get people to give up their ideas of freedom and civility. You have to do trial runs that, if they are done well, serve two purposes. They get people used to something they may initially recoil from; and they allow you to refine and calibrate. This is what is happening now and we would be fools not to see it.

One of the basic tools of fascism is the rigging of elections – we’ve seen that trialled in the election of Trump, in the Brexit referendum and (less successfully) in the French presidential elections. Another is the generation of tribal identities, the division of society into mutually exclusive polarities. Fascism does not need a majority – it typically comes to power with about 40 per cent support and then uses control and intimidation to consolidate that power. So it doesn’t matter if most people hate you, as long as your 40 per cent is fanatically committed. That’s been tested out too. And fascism of course needs a propaganda machine so effective that it creates for its followers a universe of “alternative facts” impervious to unwanted realities. Again, the testing for this is very far advanced.

Moral boundaries

But when you’ve done all this, there is a crucial next step, usually the trickiest of all. You have to undermine moral boundaries, inure people to the acceptance of acts of extreme cruelty. Like hounds, people have to be blooded. They have to be given the taste for savagery. Fascism does this by building up the sense of threat from a despised out-group. This allows the members of that group to be dehumanised. Once that has been achieved, you can gradually up the ante, working through the stages from breaking windows to extermination.

It is this next step that is being test-marketed now. It is being done in Italy by the far-right leader and minister for the interior Matteo Salvini. How would it go down if we turn away boatloads of refugees? Let’s do a screening of the rough-cut of registering all the Roma and see what buttons the audience will press. And it has been trialled by Trump: let’s see how my fans feel about crying babies in cages. I wonder how it will go down with Rupert Murdoch.

To see, as most commentary has done, the deliberate traumatisation of migrant children as a “mistake” by Trump is culpable naivety. It is a trial run – and the trial has been a huge success. Trump’s claim last week that immigrants “infest” the US is a test-marketing of whether his fans are ready for the next step-up in language, which is of course “vermin”. And the generation of images of toddlers being dragged from their parents is a test of whether those words can be turned into sounds and pictures. It was always an experiment – it ended (but only in part) because the results were in.


‘Devious’ infants

And the results are quite satisfactory. There is good news on two fronts. First, Rupert Murdoch is happy with it – his Fox News mouthpieces outdid themselves in barbaric crassness: making animal noises at the mention of a Down syndrome child, describing crying children as actors. They went the whole swinish hog: even the brown babies are liars. Those sobs of anguish are typical of the manipulative behaviour of the strangers coming to infest us – should we not fear a race whose very infants can be so devious? Second, the hardcore fans loved it: 58 per cent of Republicans are in favour of this brutality. Trump’s overall approval ratings are up to 42.5 per cent.

This is greatly encouraging for the pre-fascist agenda. The blooding process has begun within the democratic world. The muscles that the propaganda machines need for defending the indefensible are being toned up. Millions and millions of Europeans and Americans are learning to think the unthinkable. So what if those black people drown in the sea? So what if those brown toddlers are scarred for life? They have already, in their minds, crossed the boundaries of morality. They are, like Macbeth, “yet but young in deed”. But the tests will be refined, the results analysed, the methods perfected, the messages sharpened. And then the deeds can follow.


Fintan O’Toole

Thursday, 9 August 2018

Of Public Services and Private Profit

I was a late and somewhat reluctant convert to Twitter, but to be honest this blog would not now be possible without recourse to it. Although I find it pretty useless for meaningful discussion, in voyeuristic fashion it provides valuable insight and information and is a brilliant recruiting sergeant for the blog. I saw this yesterday:-  
"The problem is now that probation is provided for profit, CRCs will effectively be making a sales pitch. They want – and probably need – more customers from the courts. And to the extent that they get them, so their shareholders will benefit." Frances Crook quoting Rob Allen
With the MoJ intent on forcing through another round of private sector contracting for probation services, despite a mountain of evidence that it will be an abject failure, this tweet resulted in us being pointed in the direction of an extract from Kittens are Evil : Little Heresies in Public Policy:-

Foreword 

Saying that ‘payment by results’ is fundamentally flawed is like saying kittens are evil. It’s heresy. 

The official consensus around payment by results is that it’s a no-brainer, and if there are problems with it in practice, it’s your fault: you’re not doing it right. Coercive and simplistic thinking informs a whole range of practices aimed at improving public services, so good people try hard to make bad initiatives, based on bad theory, work. Teething troubles, poor governance, bad apples and unintended consequences are cited as reasons for high-profile failures, such as disability assessments, Universal Credit and the Troubled Families initiative. 

This book argues that best efforts and poor excuses aren’t good enough. The authors describe how a bad system beats well-meaning individuals every time. They argue that no amount of tinkering, re-branding or good governance can compensate for the serious and widespread harm inflicted by a fundamentally flawed set of beliefs. George Monbiot succinctly described these beliefs and their consequences in The Guardian (April 2016): 
We respond to these crises as if they emerge in isolation, apparently unaware that they have all been either catalysed or exacerbated by the same coherent philosophy; a philosophy that has – or had – a name. What greater power can there be than to operate namelessly? 
So pervasive has neoliberalism become that we seldom even recognise it as an ideology. We appear to accept the proposition that this utopian, millenarian faith describes a neutral force; a kind of biological law, like Darwin’s theory of evolution. 

The authors of this book challenge manifestations of neoliberal assumptions in public services – through family intervention, personalisation, numerical targets, marketisation, league tables, economies of scale, inspection and payment by results. 

At the heart of neoliberalism is a belief about people. Individuals are perfectible: anyone can (and should) be successful, to ‘make something of themselves’, if they only try hard enough. If they are unsuccessful, they should be forced to compete harder. (Try watching Ken Loach’s I, Daniel Blake.) If only we ate less, exercised more, stopped getting older, were more enterprising, ticked the right boxes, remembered our unique customer reference number, were digital by default and frankly were more service-shaped. Wouldn’t that make the government’s job easier? 

A systems view has a very different starting point. This book argues that it is the system itself that is troubled, not families or individuals. As in finance, neoliberal ‘quick wins’ all too often turn into long-term disaster, and it is the same in the public sector that has internalised its thinking.

The system is where we need to intervene. Attending to systems and their consequences for people is the only sustainable route to better lives and a better society. 

This book isn’t a conscious attempt to design a new system, although in places it makes a start. It does, however, provide strong evidence for public sector professionals, academics and policy makers to see neoliberalism for what it is – not a neutral or inevitable force, but a set of intentional and man-made political beliefs. By seeing it, we can help politicians who believe in something different, to create a new orthodoxy. 

Charlotte Pell, Visiting Fellow, KITE, University of Newcastle Business School 
Simon Caulkin, Writer and editor

--oo00oo--

Here is Kathy Evans, CEO of Children England, writing in Chapter 2: Public Service Markets Aren't Working for the Public Good... or as markets:-

With business terminology and comparisons now so deeply embedded across public and charitable services, it is perhaps illustrative to look at the most basic rudimentary tenets and ‘rules’ in successful commercial business. If public service market proponents were right in their belief that all types and sectors of organisation are best run according to the disciplines and incentives of commercial business management, it should be the case that the keys to business success would apply equally to public service provision. But they don’t. 


In commercial business demand is always a good thing. Increasing the volume of customers who want to buy your product is the first and most important objective of successful business for any entrepreneur – an objective which also underpins the entire advertising and marketing industry. In public or charitable services, however, demand is not straightforwardly positive. Up to a certain point knowing that people want and appreciate the service you offer is a ‘good thing’. Given the often sensitive personal and social problems that such services are there to meet, however, their need for help is nothing to celebrate or exploit, and an increasing volume of demand may be a cause for real concern, both as a service and as a society. ChildLine, for example, has reported that the numbers of children calling them to seek help for their suicidal feelings has substantially increased, year on year. As a service, the fact that they are available to respond to such distressing demand is a testament to the value of their service and the trust children have in them; the cause and implications of that rising demand, however, are clearly something about which to be deeply alarmed. 

In commercial business repeat custom is brilliant; indeed it has become prevalent to see customer loyalty reward schemes and ‘product obsolescence’ as strategies to promote repeat custom. In charitable and public services, if the same people are returning for your help over and over again then you need to consider the possibility that you are doing something very wrong!

In commercial business demand is your source of income. If demand is higher than you can supply you can still capitalise on it, either by raising the price (and rationing over-demand) or by investing in increased capacity to meet greater demand. The feasibility and repayment of loan finance in order to capitalise on high demand can be calculated by the projected income that will automatically be generated by being able to meet it. In public and charitable services, however, the person demanding your help does not bring with them the additional income that might help you to meet it. Whether your service is funded by taxes, donations or grants the capacity you have is finite unless or until anyone agrees to contribute more funds. A loan to invest in increased service capacity cannot easily be premised on any assumption that higher demand will generate any more income with which to repay it.

In commercial business, price is a reasonable gauge for value. When a customer decides that the price asked or negotiated for a commercial product is both affordable and reflective of its value to them, the sale can take place to the mutual satisfaction of both the customer and the seller. In general, in commercial markets, customer willingness to pay higher prices compared with others can be taken as a reasonable reflection of the relative value they place on that product. In charitable and public services the client rarely if ever pays or negotiates a price to be paid from their own pocket, and they may be inherently and completely oblivious to the costs of meeting their needs (e.g. an infant child needing expensive health care). Those who do fund the service, be they public commissioners or charitable donors, are not the consumers of it. The price of a service may, therefore, be completely unrelated to the value people place on receiving it, making ‘market competition’ on the basis of price comparisons an irrelevance in determining value. This disconnection between price and value can work both ways – a very expensive service could still have low satisfaction among its service users, just as a relatively low-cost, volunteer run service may be viewed as priceless and irreplaceable by the people who rely on it.

When the fundamental tenets of good business are so different from the similarly fundamental features and dynamics of public service delivery, it should be beyond doubt that ‘market forces’ cannot work in the same way in both sectors either. American economist, Professor Edgar Cahn, in an open letter to the non-profit community (2007) powerfully expressed an even more fundamental reason for the incompatibility of market mechanisms with the delivery of social benefits and support. The ‘core economy’ to which he refers in his quote below is a term used to describe the networks of relationships within family, friendship and community, through which people support each other at no monetary charge: 

Markets driven by monetary exchanges cannot put supply and demand together to rebuild the Core Economy because of the way that market value defines value. If quantity is scarce compared to demand, then market value is high. The opposite applies: if supply is abundant, then value goes down. We say something is dirt cheap or worthless if it is abundant.

That definition of value devalues those very universal capacities that enabled our species to survive and evolve: our ability to care for each other, to come to each other’s rescue, to learn from each other, to stand up for what’s right and to oppose what is wrong. In market terms, those capacities, if abundant, are worthless. In terms of rebuilding the core economy, those values are literally price-less.”

--oo00oo--

Whilst the ever-so-smug civil servants now running NPS continue to revel in policies, procedures, acronyms and a command and control environment that takes them ever-further from the true probation ethos, it's fascinating to learn that the Kent, Surrey and Sussex CRC are reverting to pre-privatisation post titles of Chief Probation Officer and Assistant Chief Probation Officer:-

"Manjinder takes up the role of chief probation officer on 1 November 2018 and will report directly to KSS CRC chief executive officer, Suki Binning. In the coming weeks, KSS CRC will also reintroduce the roles of deputy chief probation officer, assistant chief probation officer and assistant chief officer to reflect the service’s probation identity, values and tradition."  

Wednesday, 8 August 2018

Latest From Napo 177

Here we have the latest blog post from Napo General Secretary Ian Lawrence:- 

Inside the 'Marketisation' Event 

The report of how Napo managed to lobby the participants prior to one of last week’s ‘Probation Marketisation’ events, sets out clearly what we think of the whole exercise. Anyone who believes that the announcement of an eight-week consultation period on the ‘Strengthening Probation, Building Confidence’ blueprint is going to be taken notice of by this Government will be disappointed.

If there were any lingering doubts about the Government’s intention to continue with their ideologically driven privatisation programme they would have been easily dispelled by the proceedings.

Fantasy land


I have to give it to the Tories in one respect, and that’s their capacity to carry on day by day in Government without so much as an occasional acknowledgement of the litany of failures they have presided over when it comes to opening services up to the market. Rail Franchises, Carillion, and PFI projects in schools and hospitals that our grandkids and their children will still be paying for by the next century.

That, as well as avoiding a Parliamentary debate into the lack of a structured response to the Justice Select Committee report into the Transforming Rehabilitation programme, means that they could swan off into the summer hoping that nobody would notice the fact that half a billion pounds has been spent on a failed social experiment known as Transforming Rehabilitation.

‘Warming the Market’

The event convinced me that the decision to sell off new probation contracts had already been made and that the consultation on whether this is the right thing to do will be a sham. The full implications of what we are facing soon became very clear as a posse of MoJ and HMPPS officials set out their stall to entice the assembled audience of privateers and Third Sector representatives to seriously consider bids for the proposed new 5-7 year contracts that will be on offer post 2020.

Use of terms such as ‘Warming the Market’ in response to how bidders were to be encouraged to come forward was quite frankly insidious to listen to, and gave the impression that every colour of carpet will be laid out for the private sector to get their noses into the trough. Perhaps someone on the organiser’s side might reflect on the fact that it is people’s jobs and careers that are going to be impacted upon, yet sadly there was little sign that this was fully appreciated by those engaged in this circus.

Suffice to say it was not a pleasant experience. Firstly, it was quite surreal to see so many people almost gleefully talk about ‘learning the lessons’ and how they were listening to the criticisms and were moving swiftly to make things right this time. Presumably, the representatives from G4S and SERCO would have lapped this up given that they have used up more lives than my Cat in terms of their scandalous history of running outsourced contracts.

It was a more positive experience to speak with a number of Third Sector representatives, the majority of whom were equally unimpressed with what TR had not delivered for them and who remained sceptical that things would be much different post 2020. They did however have a real inclination to contribute positively to reform, and in that respect I found their company altogether more pleasant than some others I rubbed shoulders with. This link reflects much of the sectors hoped for direction of travel:

Anyway, the upshot to the afternoon went something like this: Probation spending has undershot which is why its’ been possible to waive the penalties on CRC shortcomings, shove more money into failure and throw in another £22m a year to improve ‘Through the Gate’ services, and rebadge all this in a glossy brochure marked ‘Strengthening Probation and Building Confidence.’

It was not one of those occasions where I had an opportunity to make a withering critique of what has gone on and what is being proposed next, but I was able to find out that the next generation outsourced contracts will be of 5-7 years duration and that nobody quite has a clue exactly what a Professional Register will do and who will run it.

Two things struck me most about this event. Firstly the complete denial as to the shambles that has taken place, and secondly the fact that quite a few people there seemed oblivious to the reality that any new contracts will need to take into account the outcome of a an NPS pay reform settlement that we all hope will flow from the negotiations which start in a couple of weeks.

Those contracts will have to be of sufficient size financially to make any prospective bidder bother to complete the application. That remains to be seen, but as far as Napo is concerned I did make it clear to all assembled that a Probation underspend means there is obviously money out there to treat properly with staff who have not only had the indignity of TR to contend with but who have not had a salary rise in seven years.

Tuesday, 7 August 2018

Probation 'Now An Embarrassment'

I see the plight probation finds itself in has once more attracted the attention of the FT no less:- 

Probation ‘mess’ casts shadow over government outsourcing


Bailouts of £500m to private sector, with some offenders only monitored electronically
  • £3.7bn privatisation of probation services seen as ‘mess’ and ‘disaster’ 
  • Private providers complained contracts were lossmaking and ‘unsustainable’ 
  • Questions remain about government plans for new private-sector contracts 
James Alderson joined the National Probation Service a decade ago to help offenders stay out of prison. But when a large part of the service was privatised in 2015, he found that staff cutbacks and piles of paperwork meant he had less contact with the people he wanted to help. 

Privatisation was meant to bring innovation and cost discipline to the service, and cut stubbornly high re-offending rates in England and Wales — where more than half of people with previous convictions go on to commit another crime within a year of being released. But Mr Alderson, whose name has been changed, said “the entire process has been a disaster”. MPs on the Commons justice select committee have reached a similar conclusion, saying in June that privatisation had been a “mess”, with private companies making “little difference” to offenders’ future prospects. 

Last month, justice secretary David Gauke agreed to end the private sector contracts in 2020, two years earlier than originally planned. The government has not disclosed the cost of the experiment, but the Ministry of Justice has been forced to agree bailouts totalling at least £500m to the private sector. The fallout has revived questions about private-sector involvement in delivering key government services, especially after the government contractor Carillion collapsed earlier this year.

“It’s another example of the doctrinaire assumption by politicians that the private sector will always deliver better results,” said Julian Le Vay, a former finance director of HM Prison Service. “Probation wasn’t broken,” he said. “There was room for improvement but we could just have had a more efficient public-sector organisation, without affecting the quality of service.” 

‘It was a big bang’ 

The grounds for privatisation were laid in the 2007 Offender Management Act, which was brought in by a Labour government. But it was Conservative Chris Grayling who, as justice secretary, launched the “rehabilitation revolution” in 2014. He cancelled his predecessor Ken Clarke’s pilot programmes for privatisation, pushing through a more ambitious set of reforms in just over a year.

“It was a big bang that completely reorganised the world, and if it didn’t work there was no easy route back,” said Mr Le Vay. 
Before Mr Grayling’s reforms, public-sector trusts supervised around 200,000 ex-offenders each year. But Mr Grayling broke up the system, giving eight private firms, including Sodexo, MTCnovo, and Ingeus, £3.7bn worth of contracts to run 21 “community rehabilitation companies” providing supervision and support to “low-to-medium-risk” offenders. 

The community rehabilitation companies were also given the job of working with 45,000 prisoners who had been in jail for less than 12 months, who had previously received no support after release but had a high reoffending rate, with nearly two-thirds committing another crime within a year. Cases involving “high-risk” offenders remained within the National Probation Service, which is now part of the civil service. 

Lossmaking contracts were ‘unsustainable’ 

But after the overhaul, private-sector companies were not getting the level of referrals expected, in part because of errors in Ministry of Justice forecasting. The MoJ had projected that private sector providers would handle 70 per cent of the cases. But in reality, the private providers only handled about 40 per cent of cases. The courts who assigned probation cases had little faith in the private providers, none of whom had any previous experience in the field. 

It also proved difficult to classify ex-offenders, because a change in circumstances, such as eviction, an alcohol problem or family conflict, could easily change their risk category from “low” to “high”. Probation staff were also divided arbitrarily between the public and private providers, even though in some cases they continued to share offices. 

By 2016, the private providers were complaining that the contracts were lossmaking and “unsustainable”. As a result, they axed jobs and closed offices, making it more difficult for offenders to attend appointments. Some contractors, such as Sodexo, monitored offenders using unmanned electronic kiosks. Two out of five offenders monitored by the private providers are now supervised by telephone, with calls every six weeks, rather than in person, according to the chief inspector of probation. 

‘Now we are an embarrassment’ 

The government is now consulting for a new round of contracts, with different financial terms and minimum requirements for the number of face-to-face meetings held with ex-offenders among other changes. The new contracts would also align the community rehabilitation companies with the National Probation Service’s regional operations. MTCnovo has said it is committed to the service and would bid for future contracts.

But few believe that privatisation of the probation system can work, even with the changes. 
The Welsh government has already decided to use devolved regional powers to take its own probation service back in-house, giving control to the National Probation Service. 

Robert Neill, the Conservative MP who chairs the Commons justice select committee, has questioned whether a privatised system “will ever deliver the kind of probation service we need”. Mr Alderson said: “Other criminal justice systems used to look at us as a model for offender intervention,” he says. “Now we are an embarrassment.”

--oo00oo--

I notice the article generated a couple of responses on Facebook:-

The FT is still a relatively influential newspaper despite its comparatively small circulation. It has an excellent international reputation for well sourced and evidenced financial journalism that is mainly aimed at looking after business interests rather than having an overtly political axe to grind. Those with power money and influence read it and form their opinions as a result. In other words those who can make a difference read it, including overseas investors in the so called UK 'justice market', and will undoubtedly now be more cautious particularly if they do some research and find a number of articles across the media warning of a mess. This article takes up the best part of page 3 along with a smaller article regarding Grayling failing to take advice regarding Heathrow. The final three paragraphs are particularly telling 'But few believe that privatisation of the probation system can work, even with the changes'.

The Welsh government has already decided to use devolved regional powers to take its own probation service back in-house, giving control to the National Probation Service. Robert Neill, the Conservative MP who chairs the Commons justice select committee, has questioned whether a privatised system “will ever deliver the kind of probation service we need”.' I detect a groundswell of opinion that runs counter to the MoJs proposals that are clearly not brave enough given the scale of the problems faced. Yes to end of CRC contracts. Yes to reunification of core probation services. Yes to both English and Welsh probation services returning to public ownership.


******
Hats off Mr Alderson, whoever you are. I have a feeling that there is all to play for now, and the biggest hurdle and risk in the path of serious positive progress is the devastating effect of TR on probation people. There used to be a fashion in management theory for drawing analogies between organisations and individual psychology/pathology. Any psychology/psychiatry/etc practitioner would have a their hands full with Probation as a client. If you were to diagnose Probation as a group collective, what would it be? PTSD? Stockholm Syndrome?

Monday, 6 August 2018

Napo Elections 2018

Vice Chair Post

NAPO members will be aware that there are currently National Officers elections underway and everyone by now should have received their ballot paper. I wanted to take some time to write to you all about why I am standing as I may not be a name on the paper as familiar to some of you as the incumbent officers or those who have been regulars at AGM for many years. 

I have decided to stand for national election as I believe these elections are probably the most critical that NAPO has faced in a decade. At a time when we need to ensure that our officers are effective at steering the union in the right direction for survival and future longevity, we also have a general membership that is as disengaged and apathetic about those at the top than at any time I can recall. This was no more evident than in the General Secretary election, where no amount of positive spin can put shine on a turnout of 16%.

I make no secret of the fact that I voted for radical change in the GS election, but I am fully prepared to work with the newly re-elected GS in working towards a more open, democratic and accountable union. I believe this to be critical at re-engaging you and then with the top table and the NEC. 

I have sat in NEC meetings and seen critical debate shut down too soon with too few members to challenge the chairs rulings or ask the really difficult questions necessary to hold officers and officials to account. This is not me criticising the NEC either, it is an extremely difficult job with members often conflicted between representing the will of their branch and voting independently for what they feel to be the good of the union. 

My point is the NEC agenda is not led by NEC members but by what the Officers and Officials wish to cover. It’s why at AGM a couple of years ago some of you may recall my emergency motion for NEC reform, following from a year of in-quorate NEC meetings. I fear that we are facing this threat again with numerous NEC posts vacant. Which makes it even more important that we have elected National Officers who work for the members and hold each other and our paid officials to account, where officers do not hide behind the veil of collective responsibility and challenge each other. 

Over the last few years I have been made aware of National officers being ‘frozen out’ of key decisions because they did not see eye to eye with the majority. This cannot be allowed to continue if we are to survive as a democratic union. 

The Assistant General Secretary has an ambitious strategy for growth which will be covered fully at AGM. This will require buy-in from members and elected officers at all levels in order to be a success. It is therefore critical at this stage that we have National Officers who can see this strategy through in whatever form the members decide is appropriate and hold all to account for it’s effective implementation. 

As an aside I implore those who read this, those who are critical and discerning about NAPOs activity, to stand for NEC, we need people who are prepared to scrutinise, to question and yes to be critical and ensure as a union we don’t pass bad decisions on the back of apathy. 

That’s my statement anyway. I have Jim’s agreement to engage with you on here. You will no doubt have read the election statements of all the candidates and so I am here to discuss anything from my statement you may wish to discuss. 

Regards,

Jamie Overland

Saturday, 4 August 2018

CRCs Get Ear of Sentencers

With the profession still coming to terms with last weeks announcement regarding TR2, I think it's probably fair to say not many of us have noticed PI 5/2018, but Rob Allen has and there are grounds to be concerned:- 

Private Communications

New liaison arrangements between courts and probation services came into force last week. Much of Probation Instruction 5/2018- which like previous versions have been agreed with the Senior Presiding Judge- describes national and local procedures for ensuring effective communication and dialogue on issues of joint concern and escalation mechanisms when problems arise. As long as someone knows the difference between the JBG, JDG and JOG, I’m sure it will work well.

Two matters stand out. First compared to earlier protocols it’s pretty Stalinist. The 2016 instruction “was not intended to be prescriptive in the method of exchanging information” at a local level, requiring only a process to provide assurance that the protocol is being followed. The new version even contains a standardised agenda for local liaison meetings in order to maintain consistency although the local judges, magistrates and probation staff will perhaps be relieved that “the degree of granularity or detail required is not prescribed”. My guess is that the arrangements haven’t been working sufficiently well and with ministers wanting fewer short prison sentences and CRCs wanting more community orders something more than a mild refresh was required.

The second point concerns the role of CRCs. I’m probably reading too much into it, but it seems like they now have a seat at the table with sentencers for the first time. In 2014 it was for the National Probation Service (NPS) to liaise between judges, magistrates and providers of probation services, providing information about the services available in their local area. By 2016, NPS was to facilitate provision of information and presentations from local Community Rehabilitation Companies and Electronic Monitoring Services (EMS) about available provision. In the new arrangements, the CRC and EMS are expected to be represented at the Crown Court meetings and must be at the Magistrates Court’s .

About time you might think. How can courts possibly have confidence in community sentences if they can’t meet the providers - or see what they do. The new protocol says both NPS and CRCs should endeavour to meet requests from judicial officers to observe probation (and prison) work in the local area. I’m generally in favour of this sort of activity, helping to fund some of it when I ran the Rethinking Crime and Punishment Programme 15 years ago.

The problem is now that probation is provided for profit, CRC’s will effectively be making a sales pitch. They want – and probably need – more customers from the courts. And to the extent that they get them, so their shareholders will benefit.

Judges and magistrates on the other hand must be mindful that the principle of judicial independence extends well beyond the traditional separation of powers and requires that they are and are seen to be, in the words of the Guide to Judicial Conduct- “independent of all sources of power or influence in society, including the media and commercial interests”. The Guide is quite strict, telling judges they should take care in considering whether their name and title should be associated with a public appeal for funds, even for a charitable organisation. “Such an appeal could amount to an inappropriate use of judicial prestige in support of the organisation”. The Guide even suggests it may be inappropriate for a judicial office holder to deliver a public lecture or participate in a conference or seminar run by a commercial organisation.

Magistrates have been aware of possible conflicts of interest in this area. Former Chair of the Magistrates Association (MA) Malcolm Richardson told the Justice Committee last year that “there has been excessive concern on the part of some about building relationships with organisations that have a profit motive. I think that that is to underestimate the ability of sentencers,particularly magistrates, to manage those relationships”. He may have been referring to those of us who were critical of an ill judged – and quietly abandoned-income generating scheme dreamt up by the MA in 2015 to involve private Community Rehabilitation Companies (CRC’s) investing in the MA Education and Research Network. Or he may have meant his own Association which raised prescient concerns in 2010 about the impact that introducing a profit motive for reducing re-offending might have on meeting the core aims of the criminal justice system.

It may be that we all need to make adjustments to the realities of private sector involvement in criminal justice- and the obvious benefits of replacing short prison sentences with community orders outweigh footling concerns about propriety. But maybe not.

Rob Allen

Friday, 3 August 2018

Responses to Demise of TR 3

An interesting article just out on Napo news detailing how it's not just the CRCs that are deperately short of money - it's all going pear-shaped in NPS as well:-

Why some supplements are definitely not performance enhancing

MFS mess highlights ongoing financial chaos in the NPS

One of the stated ambitions of the government’s current consultation, “Strengthening probation, Building Confidence” is to “Develop a workforce strategy which ensures providers can recruit and develop the staff they need to deliver quality probation services (Page 7)”.

The consultation doesn’t detail the scale of this challenge, but Napo members’ recent experience in the NPS starts to join the dots to outline a pretty challenging and ugly picture. The backdrop is a failing NPS – hamstrung from the start by inadequate financial planning or resources. This has resulted in occasionally dishonest behaviours (see below), irrational short-term panic measures, which corrode staff trust and confidence in their employer and in turn make their stated aspiration harder with every perverse action.

One of the clearest examples is the NPS handling of Market Forces Pay Supplements (MFS) across some parts of the South East and Eastern region over the last three years. MFS payments are a standard HR tool across the public sector. When it becomes difficult to recruit or retain staff with particular skills a higher starting salary can be applied to incentivise people to work in a usually disproportionately expensive area. In this case, one aim was to neutralise the impact of London Weighting (LW), which could see people living in Kent, Surrey, Berkshire, etc take jobs in London because LW is more than their commuting costs. MFS payments could level the competition between areas for new starters. No doubt it also helped neutralise the impact on staff of transferring from CRCs where they’d otherwise have to re-start on their Band minima.

When the Coach is paid less

So in theory MFS payments are logical and rational, although they are not a strategic alternative to a more sustainable, transparent and sensible pay system than probation currently has. The rub is that anyone in those areas doing the same work in the same areas but earning less than the uplifted MFS salary would also expect to benefit – otherwise they’d be leapfrogged. No serious HR professional would consider using a recruitment payment that would risk annoying existing staff and generating a retention problem. This is amplified where the MFS payment are being paid to less experienced and/or newly qualified staff and the expectation is that experienced colleagues will support, mentor or coach the newer colleagues. Who could seriously expect someone to do that if the new colleague is knowingly being paid more than the coach? When probation pay reform is the publicly stated number one strategic priority for the whole organisation, surely no-one would risk insulting the intelligence of experienced staff by not at least matching the salaries of new starters?

Welcome to the NPS…the youngest offspring of the dysfunctional parent department, the MoJ. Before 2017, NPS HR asked HMPPS/MoJ for the permission and monies to implement MFS payments in some cases. Permission was given for both new starters and existing staff to get uplifts – except that the NPS HR systems prevented some existing staff from getting the uplift. After Napo intervened, these members were eventually identified and paid but some of the “performance dividend” was lost.

Farce and high dudgeon

Meanwhile, in 2016 the MoJ failed to get its accounts signed off because it spent more than it had coming in and didn’t know how to stop. Since then it’s got worse. In 2017, the favourite MoJ department (that's the Prison Service if anyone had not noticed) got all of the pay rise, apart from the Chief Engineer of the shambles who still got his annual 5 figure bonus. When it was probation’s turn there was nothing left. This financial chaos, also reflected in PAYE and Pension problems previously highlighted by Napo, led to the Treasury taking over the financial management of the MoJ.

In essence, the MoJ is being managed like a potentially bankrupt business, the Treasury playing the part of the auditors, needing to sign off every possible request for monies with a default position being “No”.

Accordingly, in 2017, NPS HR asked the HMPPS / MoJ HR to implement further MFS payments. This was agreed. The HMPPS / MoJ HR leads then asked the Treasury to release the monies for what had already been agreed. Such was their incompetence, instead of asking one question as part of a strategic business case and explaining that this required paying both the new starters and those being uplifted (possibly because their shambolic HR systems made it difficult to quantify who’d need an uplift and the cost implications) they asked two questions:


  • can we pay the new starters?; and
  • can we uplift the salaries of existing staff?
The Treasury said ‘yes’ to the first question but an emphatic ‘no’ to the second.

Long-serving Napo members naturally felt aggrieved and submitted grievances. The local NPS managers in most cases expressed huge sympathy but were then instructed by their bosses either to reject the grievances or to refuse to hear them at all. Unfortunately, the law offers no remedy as such payments are indiscriminate even if unfair. Instead, the central instruction from MoJ HQ is that these issues can be addressed via the forthcoming pay reform negotiations.

The Pay reform negotiations* which start later this month will be challenging and difficult enough already without this added complication. Over half the NPS staff in the most populated grades are still below the mid-point of their salary range, earning several thousand pounds less than those even longer serving staff who are at the established rate for the job. Staff at the top of the scales have had literally no pay rises for almost a decade. Tension between these groups is evident and no reform will be possible without winning the agreement of the majority of staff. Unless the Treasury are persuaded to throw unprecedented sums at pay reform these negotiations – delayed for 15 months – will be very difficult. To suggest throwing into this mix additional outstanding pay grievances is beyond naïve.

To pronounce at the same time an intention to “Develop a workforce strategy which ensures providers can recruit and develop the staff they need to deliver quality probation services” will be seen as an incredibly ambitious aim, coming as it does after the shambolic mishandling of the MFS issue.

Napo and the other trade unions will do everything we reasonably can to protect members’ best interests and remain positively engaged in any negotiations that could lead to better outcomes for members. But as our members know, when dealing with unpredictable situations huge caution is required. Whatever supplements the MoJ leadership are taking or planning to use in future, there must be serious doubt about the accompanying claims on the packet that they will somehow enhance performance.

*Napo’s pay team for the forthcoming pay negotiations will comprise Ian Lawrence, Dean Rogers and Yvonne Pattison.

Thursday, 2 August 2018

Time to Re-boot Napo?

Now that the dust has settled since last Friday's TR2 announcement, somewhat surprisingly yesterday's news from Napo in the South West has generated quite a lively debate regarding Napo in general and highlighted some particularly uncomfortable issues in particular:- 

"What have we (i.e. Napo members) done?

1. We've been generally weak with no profession-wide membership base, partly due to own goals by the union
2. For example, we did nothing about the Benny Hill (Ledger) debacle, which gave Officers the green light to hide/manipulate facts
3. We voted for Lawrence, an experienced Trade Unionist but not probation savvy - who brought a different agenda (I would suggest 'his own') which created friction in HQ
4. We never voted strongly for any meaningful action when we had the chance
5. When we did take industrial action it was meaningless in that others happily covered & there was no impact beyond losing a day's pay
6. We generally focus so much on our demanding caseloads that we were/are blinkered to the political machinations which are wrecking our work... something Trusts & NOMS took great advantage of.
7. And we have relied on the union to take up the role of early-warning system & decoder of political messages but they have failed us by being variously incompetent, complicit, silent, beleaguered by in-house politics, naive.

So while our heads have been buried in caseloads + switching IT off & on every 5 mins to make it work, we've been taken for one hell of a ride by everyone - MoJ, Noms, Trusts & Napo. And I don't really have an answer, beyond switching Napo off & on again - a system re-boot from scratch maximising what now seems to be probation-wide acknowledgement that probation is fucked. But the recent re-election of the GS suggests there ain't no such appetite."


--oo00oo--

The facts are alarming:-

Some figures from the Certification Officer's website and National Archives for the past 15 years showing the decline in membership from a high point in 2010:-

2003: 7729
2004: 8432
2005: 8677
2006: 9053
2007: 9004
2008: 8830
2009: 8869
2010: 9255
2011: 9100
2012: 8360
2013: 8008
2014: 7354
2015: 6749
2016: 5261
2017: 4996

Normally a trajectory like this in any organisation would trigger some serious action and almost certainly emergency measures, but things just seem to be jogging along. The newly-elected General Secretary very successfully closed down all options for a debate between the two candidates and there hasn't been a peep out of the two Co-Chairs who I gather don't like going to London very often. 


But Napo is in the middle of elections for Chair, Vice Chair and the NEC - so as the union and profession face existential threats, where is the debate and discussion going on? When I saw this a few weeks ago, I genuinely thought lessons had been learnt and things could only get better:- 

Publishing today…

I have been writing about all things Napo for some time, some articles have been published and some haven’t! Here I intend to bring together things I’ve published along with thoughts and discussion about my life as a Napo Officer. I want to make it easier to have discussions with more people so comments will be open on most of my articles and posts. Please use comments wisely, I will not be moderating them constantly but will remove any that are a personal attack on anyone or that I believe are against Napo’s objects.

I am publishing my blog now as I submit my nomination for Napo National Chair. There are many challenges ahead for Napo members, whichever employer they work for and there are many challenges for us as a Union. I have invested four years in my role as Vice Chair of Napo and have learned so much in that time. My second and final term of office is almost over but I have work yet to do. Our Trade Union is a precious and valuable thing but in recent years it has seen attack after attack. We have weathered many storms and there will be more to come. My vision for Napo in the future is as a vibrant and independent Trade Union and Professional Association, one that can adapt quickly to changing demands, both external and internal. I want to see a Union that communicates with members, collectively and individually. I want to hear a strong voice representing the professions of our members in Probation and Family Courts.

I am not unaware of the difficulties that we face. Napo reps are seeing workloads increase in both their work and trade union roles. Changes in both Probation and Cafcass have resulted in us losing many of our most experienced reps and activists (although some stay on as retired members). We need to revitalise our branches, making sure that reps and branch officers can work efficiently, using all of the central support available to them. We need to make sure that our NEC and it’s committees work well, allowing members to directly participate in setting the agenda and priorities for the Union. The most common question I hear from members is “what is happening about xxxx”. We need to make sure that members have access to information in a variety of media.

For lots of reasons it feels as though we are at an important point in time. In Probation we have the Justice Select Committee confirming all we in Napo have said about the devastating effects of TR. In Cafcass there is acknowledgement that workloads need urgent attention and that the service is being held up largely by goodwill and dedication of staff. PBNI (Probation Board of Northern Ireland) avoided the worst of the disastrous attempts at reform of Probation but struggles around workloads and protections for staff continue. With so much happening Napo needs to capitalise on every opportunity. We must make the most of the position we are in.

I look forward to discussing these issues with you further – feel free to share your thoughts in comments…

--oo00oo--

So, what happened? July 12th saw the last from Katie Lomas as she blogged about the importance of Napo branches - zilch since then, indeed as far as I know, nothing has been heard from any of the candidates for any of the positions being contested. It's true that informal approaches have been made to me regarding possible Guest Blogs along the lines of those very successfully published from GS contender Mike Rolfe, but strangely none have materialised. 

Readers will recall this from a couple of days ago:-
"Email from managers this morning warning against use of social media to criticise NOMS, talking to journalists etc. Disciplinary etc etc."
I think it's reasonable to assume that management in both NPS and the CRCs are extremely concerned about staff using this blog as a way of communicating their thoughts, concerns and information. Sadly, I feel the very same policy continues to operate in Napo.

Wednesday, 1 August 2018

Napo At Work in the South West 16

Time to take a short break from worries over TR2 and return to news and views from Napo in the South West:-

Napo SSW Branch report 25 


Dear Napo members,

Those of you who have been waiting for the Government announcement today will in some part be celebrating the news of the contracts to be ended two years early. Be in no doubt for the DDC area Working Links had already failed to manage anything properly and without this bailout would certainly have been ditched, sued and foreclosed on by Aurelius, their parent company who had already started proceedings to ensure they had grip on anything left.

It’s a pity this news provides a stay of execution for Working Links as they no doubt breathe a sigh of relief as they survive. Another huge waste of public money to keep them going. The reason for the failing Government policy and continued patching up of the TR disaster is because there is no plan B. I met with Chris Grayling during his duplicitous tour of the West Country areas and despite all efforts to insist on piloting change he set a course to sea without any life boats. He bluffed his way on about the usual post release rubbish and we are where we are, despite knowing it will all be a failure.

As your branch chair and being responsible for protection of your terms the recruitment drive to engage post 2014 contracted staff must be begin as we shall want to ensure all staff are carried through into re engagement post the contract ending with Working Links. If you are reading this in the DDC area and not a member of Napo join now or make contact with the chair of the branch to ask in detail why you need to. I say this confidently as we have spent some considerable time looking at the future potentials. In this regard bringing contracts in early is because they have not delivered nor are they ever likely to able to. We should ignore all the rubbish about spin, about any success and celebrate the fact that not one of the contractors or private sector muscle is going to cry foul and start arguing over lost profits and the so-called clauses of protection. Why not? Because the private sector, in their clamour to manage big, ended up by simply demonstrating they cannot manage at all! In defiance of what is obvious this broken policy continues to peddle ideology of private sector in the running of the probation services but read between the lines it will not be anything like it is now.

1. Firstly new contracts

2. Return to face to face offender management. (Vindicating our SSW branch\region dispute over the Working Links incompetent service design model). Also noted in the recent Justice committee report.

3. Approximately 8 newly co terminus contracted areas. TBA

4. Wales to be independent and free of the mantra of the Working Links Way. (Wales can cheer as they are no longer to be phrased as Working Links “Our People”)

Members will know this was foreseen by NAPO in our reporting and a while back when we stated in a branch report update

sadly the collusion to keep the CRCs limping home to end of the unlikely to be renewed contract period might be the only way to save their remaining reputation for what is increasingly becoming another government public services negligent farce. By the way has anyone ever seen a real contract manager who knows what that actually means?

The indication from Working Links themselves this year is worth noting again and their desire to quit before contract time ends is welcome news, and we have reported on this, the only difficulty is that WL are not able to quit their toxic contract . Foolish arrangement to be in really and they have to fund the costs to get out should they try. All said I cannot see the government bailing them out this early even though the remainder of the contract is now on a declining curve. NAPO looks forward to assisting in the acceleration of the contract ending should this become a real potential.


Napo SSW is pleased to report that we have made efforts and continue to do so to see the contracts ended early. We have led on many campaign fronts

⦁ The regional dispute
⦁ The Parliamentary evidence
⦁ Plymouth Council motion
⦁ Campaign of role protections.
⦁ Non variations on our contracts roles and terms.
⦁ Collation of the catalogue of secrets public risk issues failures and collusion's of the Working Links way.
⦁ Non-compliance with lawful requirements in relation to health and safety vehicles and a range continued failings.

and we will continue to do so. The future question is not whether we face another contracted period but with who. Working links have not been able. We intend to test and ensure new or winning contractors are fit or suitable to be considered should they want to contract into a further bidding round. Whatever happens next few years our Napo members will need to have our terms continue to be protected and a reboot on the National staff transfer issues will yet again be on the agenda. This time round I will want to ensure with National Napo the grief and lessons learnt from the past abuses from the Working Links way and nationally that contracted out arrangements actually ensure no changes to staffing or their terms. Again, non-members join Napo now.

In relation to Wales, we celebrate their great fortune to formally have an end date to rid themselves of the drain of the Working Links cash grabbing way. Well in so far as case management at least!!! It is a start however. We know from recent talks that the risk to divide interventions away from casework relationships is another nail in the box for the end of probation as we know it. We will all appreciate the alarm this will cause to interventions staff in programmes and unpaid work. Disappointingly and incredibly, National Napo briefings fail to acknowledge properly this further sub division and obvious small sweetener to keep Working Links onside for the moment.

Sadly we may lose the oversight of the recently appointed Probation justice leader Dawn Blower. Napo regionally was hopeful that Dawn’s more reasoned style and approach might have helped in further dialogue as we all work more effectively to protect staff from the continued excesses of the Working Links failing way. I am sure the demands of the Wales reintegration will dominate attention and see the full PO compliment of staff return to their professional duties within a collegiate group and re-bond within the public sector proper. Then Wales can finally jettison the case management aspects of the private contract mess.

Well done to them.

What that means for our region is that we will see the Working Links contract waning initially and whether Working Links Aurelius want to stay in the game, re invest and actually try and convince this government that they could manage a bigger area in a new arrangement, yes of course wanting more money! Oh no, Napo will work collectively to ensure this is not a likely potential. The SSW branch remains committed to ensuring the reinstatement of public service ownership whatever it takes. This includes the retention of intervention workers.

The plans whatever they become, may all just be aspirational if we get a change of government.

Michael Spurr has also written today to all staff. This is a carefully scripted letter of MOJ spin. A classic example of how the seniority want us to perceive things whilst we can all see the plain truth. The Justice committee report in June has spelled it out yet Mr Spurr neglects to mention it at all. The common thread here is that leaderships are better able to lead when they understand they need their followers to want to be led. At no point does Mr Spurr appear to appreciate that spin over substance just won’t wash any longer. The current situation remains in crisis and the future plan with continued contracts will be just as toxic. If you do not learn from being burnt once what chance have we? I hope then at least we won’t have the same people at that authority level. Whatever, Mr Spurr could easily have understood to mention a closer and much needed new approach to work carefully with the unions, in regard to all matters and in particular the growing and obvious need to restore national collective bargaining on pay if the so called intermix of staff is to work in any way.

In the meantime, members, the slippery slope for the end of the Working Links way for probation work has just received a push in the right direction. The end of their regime, the sooner the better, may well yet see continued deprivations and attacks on staffing positions increase in search of more money for Aurelius and shareholders, seeing the end of the publicly funded gravy train. They are in a declining contract period and may well want all that remains. That said we would like to see our staff reinstated into decent offices, placed back in our NPS facilities to re-engage our professional standards across all aspects of work. Also within the next year of 2019 work through an agenda that minimises any further damage that their management and model has reaped on the wellbeing and job securities of our highly skilled staff. There is more to come as I will be reviewing the Justice committee report shortly.

Napo National elections

The names have been published of our potential new National officers group for the next two years of NAPO. Obviously, we have different employers with the ridiculous failings of the inept and incompetent situation of the CRCs and the slightly better but woeful examples of practice from the NPS in their approaches to staff and Trade Unions. Please consider this should not be a factor as you vote for the best candidate that we need urgently to start the regeneration of Napo’s fortunes. 


We must have a change in direction away from the recent moves to reduce branch member led engagements. The bureaucratic technocratic heralding that feeds the mis-direction of our once strong and solid member led Union. 

The General Secretary election is now over and this branch supported Ian Lawrence for many reasons. He has been a loyal active participant in the dispute against the worst experiences of the Working Links way. He has worked collaboratively with me in our branch executive and kept onside sister territories BGSW and Wales. This unified defence against the ongoing failings of the Working Links way. Ian has attended many local branch meetings and our AGM and professional debates for the past 3 years and is on first name terms with most of our branch. Not only for the support we have received but the genuine attempts that Ian has demonstrated in the dispute to work to our betterment despite the appalling situations our members continue to face. Enough of the detail now, I will shortly be writing up the issues from the Parliamentary TR investigation recommendations and in a future branch report details on the continued falling short by miles of the Working Links way.

For now let me publicly congratulate Ian on the overwhelming vote to his victory. His re-election saves Napo funds a considerable settlement figure despite what other misinformed people may have said. Which is irrelevant as Ian stood to win and he tells us to “complete his mission” on the restoration for probation back to public ownership. This involves the resolve pay deprivation, a fair deal on workloads, professional status and the ongoing matters that continually unfold this current TR mess. 

To assist Ian in that process we have to look carefully at the skills of his support team. It is NAPO members’ responsibility to ensure we collectively vote for the best able candidates and their experience. I have been around Napo circles for a long while in many roles. I was a Vice Chair for 4 years and had many challenging duties in the difficulties Napo faced internally. The job of Chair is demanding, travel has its burdens but we need a mature able candidate who has appropriate skills and background of demonstrating representing members first hand. Dealing with controversy able to withstand pressure and maintain the agenda for member’s needs. Being appropriately trained and hold some recognised qualification like the Diploma in Employment Law really helps. The two candidates for Chair in this election illustrates to my knowledge there is only one who could deliver what our Union requires in this difficult time. The strength to change Napo’s direction and restore member recruitment retention and activism is led in major part, by the Chair. We have seen 4 years of the incumbents deliver little that we can see as what is required in fact it has been detrimental to many. The Union’s strength is obvious when we are properly led and listened to. The SSW branch support Denise Mason’s election campaign and I would urge you strongly to look carefully when it is time to vote. I will be reporting on election matters throughout the summer. 

The Vice Chair’s role also requires engagement to help stem leaving members while recruiting and they have to manage the Union business. It is not a role for the lucky and the workshy. Part time often requires sacrifices and long travel for Vice chairs. Our very own branch JNCC representative Denice James is standing for this important role. This branch has nominated Denice and she has experienced first-hand the decline in professional standards caused by Working Links CRC. The Working Links way has seen a valueless organisation. Their games during failed ACAS talks where they will not return to is part of their smoke and mirrors approach to anything they have a contractual responsibility. No attempts to engage meaningfully the management of professional staff and our terms and conditions. Denice has seen the decimation of standards and quality while we all look on at the failing targets. 

The lack of staff, lack of resources whilst the money to fund the CRCs has been funnelled out the back door to Aurelius. This parent company of the Working links failings way, will not declare the truth on the 4 million plus bail out they pocketed last summer. Denice James is angry that the CRCs approach has been unfair without principle and focuses solely on their cash for targets agenda. Their poorly managed government contract which is useless, as we see the Working Links way has failed to reduce any offending rates and in fact have increased, clinging on to the hope of yet more bail out money, while implementing the flawed and criticised by the select committee telephone contact reporting model. Another example of gross errors of this government policy. Denice James has a good record in the branch, she is principled with integrity, is not afraid to direct and lead and would be a great asset to the NAPO top table ensuring our General Secretary and officials do the job members actually require. Denice has good hands on experience in negotiations and supporting members against the weighted indifference of the current regime. This will be understood by many voting members in the CRCs and NPS and voting for Denice James is a vote for change. Do not miss this opportunity. 

The other best candidate for the two National Vice Chairs and for the change agenda is Robbie Bourget from Thames Valley NPS. Also a probation officer but with a long pedigree of Union involvement. Robbie has experience in representation JNCC negotiations NEC and sub committees over many years. Robbie has a natural style of engagement and is able to focus members concerns to directly benefit them through NAPO policies and representation. Napo has been well supported by Robbie’s upfront style and direct approach. A seasoned Napo activist and a member of Napo who will be a solid supportive advocate of genuine Napo values. Robbie has always maintained a Napo role during her service and is well able to meet the challenges for future of likely turmoil as the select committee report starts to make an impact on this governments inward thinking. Voting for Robbie as another of the two Vice Chair roles will be a vote for change and member led union values.

Napo has lost too much ground on terms and conditions across many activities. Reducing our a Union to a position without collective bargaining and no dispute with the employer? A critical failure to maintain central collective bargaining. Walking away from staff transfer protections collective agreement without a legal challenge is just not delivering any fight at all. Job evaluations in the NPS that has seen the decline in pay awards and reducing any chance of winning re-gradings. Again, no dispute? 

The Judicial review situation has never been made formally clear to members. It is a growing list and we will all have our own views but this election is a real chance to be involved in that change agenda and for the betterment of your futures, your pay, your terms and your member led branch activists. To hold the roles you need should the worst happen and to ensure we stave off the move to a technocratic styled Union that will issue your representational needs through a computer type approach with a formula of ticking the box and Napo will send you an electronic pre-formatted advice sheet. Good luck with that, do it yourself approach, unless you vote for change.

Dino Peros

Napo SSW Branch Chair.