Friday, 25 September 2020

Justice Committee Hears From Justin Russell

On Tuesday, in connection with its inquiry into the future of the Probation Service, the Justice Committee took oral evidence from HMI Justin Russell, together with representatives from several CRCs. I've waited until written publication of the exchanges as I suspect there is much that will be of interest to readers. A long but important first part:-   

Q1 Chair: Our first witness, who is with us in the room, is Justin Russell, Her Majesty’s chief inspector of probation. Welcome, and it is very good to see you again, Mr Russell. 

Justin Russell: Thank you and thanks for having me. 

Chair: Thank you very much for coming to help us. Perhaps we can cut to the chase because we have seen a good deal of written evidence, of course, about the inquiry, and your work is familiar to us in any event. 

What a lot of people might be thinking is this: the probation service now is going through its second major reform in five years. The first was pretty substantial, with the CRCs and so on—a major reform; and now another major reform is going in the opposite direction. I suppose people might ask what confidence we can have that the new model will stick and that we are going to get a lasting solution that we can deliver on. As the person who is charged with inspecting the service, what is your take on that? 

Justin Russell: You are right to say that a lot of people hope that this new model will stick. It is the fourth major restructuring in over 20 years, following previous restructurings, so it is very important for everyone working in the service that they get some stability going forward. 

I do not think structural reform by itself will necessarily bring that stability. It is very important that it is backed up with real resources, strong leadership and the right performance framework. All of those elements have to be in place. Merely shifting boundaries around while changing the structures will not by themselves necessarily bring substantial improvements in quality. 

Q2 Chair: Some of the Committee’s findings and reports were quite critical of the previous structure and the fragmentation. Did that fit with the evidence that the inspectorate found? 

Justin Russell: It did, and I think the findings from the inspectorate over the five years of Transforming Rehabilitation matched what your Committee and the National Audit Office have been saying. From quite early on in our inspections, we were finding, as you say, a fragmented and two-tier service with some quite serious flaws in the way the structure had been set up. 

The most serious flaw of all was the commercial contractual mechanism, and the way that that meant some very serious underfunding of the CRCs. I think the Lord Chancellor came to your Committee and said that potentially there was a £700 million underspend on CRCs compared with what was expected to be spent on them over the seven years of the contract. That gap in funding has had a deleterious effect on the quality of service that they have been able to deliver. 

Q3 Chair: That is something you were able to pick up from your inspections. 

Justin Russell: It certainly is, and we have been picking it up since we started doing inspections after TR. There are some areas of good practice: some services have done well. We have seen some areas of improvement. London CRC, for example, has improved over the years, and South Yorkshire has scored well over the years. 

In our most recent round of inspections, we re-inspected nine CRCs and compared our results with our previous set of standards; three of them we now rate as good, so there have been some signs of improvement. The remainder are still in need of some improvement, particularly around the basics of offender management and managing risk to the community. 

Q4 Chair: That is very helpful. When you said, as you fairly did, that there are other things beyond purely reunification that were required, are there particular areas of the topics you highlighted to us that you think should be given the most focus? 

Justin Russell: In terms of what our inspections have found over the last two or three years, it is the focus on public protection. Actually, the CRCs have not been bad at looking at desistance and at reoffending. That has been very much where their focus has been, and they have introduced some interesting innovations around that; they have introduced new rehabilitation programmes and some quite sophisticated data tools to see what the needs of offenders are. 

We consistently score them down on the management of risk. Over half the cases we inspect in CRCs are not satisfactory in relation to protecting the public—assessing risk, planning for it and then reviewing it. That needs to be a key focus going forward. 

It is not just CRCs. It is the weakest area of performance for the National Probation Service as well. They score a bit better than CRCs, but it is still bringing their scores down. They all need to improve in that really critical area of public protection. 

Q5 Chair: System wide. 

Justin Russell: Yes. 

Q6 Dr Mullan: I want to pick up on a couple of those points. It is a really difficult thing to weigh up the extent to which you might attribute the factors, but would you say that the reorganisation was a small factor or a big factor versus the other things you talked about? 

Justin Russell: A big factor in terms of the poor performance? 

Dr Mullan: Fragmentation in terms of performance. 

Justin Russell: It was a big factor, but it was not necessarily the split, although that was a factor. The under-resourcing was a critical factor because so much of the probation budget goes on staff; that is the biggest element. It had a real impact on case loads and on the manageability of what staff were doing. We were consistently finding staff saying, “I’ve got too big a case load. I can’t manage that.” We were finding probation officers with 70 or 80 cases, and you cannot manage risk effectively or do a good job by the people you are supervising if you are managing that many people. That was a direct result of the lack of resources, and that, in turn, was a reflection of the failure of the funding mechanism. 

Q7 Dr Mullan: I assume that the funding mechanism is the same funding mechanism for the three that you found to be good performers versus the ones that were not. What do you think is the difference within the same framework and budget, the same contracts, for those to be good when others are struggling? 

Justin Russell: The overall shape of the contracts is similar, but they all went in with different bids and different tenders. Some of the providers were more ambitious in their assumptions about what they would get from payment by results in the later years of the contract, and those are the ones that are really suffering now and have the biggest holes in their budgets. What we actually see now is almost a three-tier probation system, where we have the National Probation Service, we have maybe three or four decently performing CRCs and then some that are really struggling because of the holes in their budgets. 

As we have gone back into those CRCs in the last year, they are still having to cut budgets; they are still cutting probation numbers. Particularly, Purple Futures and the RRP services in the east and west midlands are where we see those real issues very much at play. 

Q8 Dr Mullan: Did you notice any difference between whether they were perhaps a private sector provider or a non-profit provider? Did you see any pattern in that regard? 

Justin Russell: Not necessarily. There are good providers, both private and of a more mutual arrangement. Durham and Tees Valley is the best-known example of the more mutual arrangement. MTC is the provider for Thames Valley, and we have rated them good. Sodexo is the provider for South Yorkshire and we have rated them well. 

Private providers can do a decent job, but they are in a very different position financially and there are risks. Once you start to outsource something and you have large providers moving into the market—large parent companies—you are also at risk of what is happening to the owning company as well. If they get into trouble, the justice subsidiaries may struggle as well. We had that issue with Working Links at the beginning of last year when they went into administration. That caused all sorts of problems in the south-west and Wales.

Chair: That is very helpful. We have the new model; it is still in draft form, of course, at the moment. February 2021 is the time when I understand the final model is expected. 

Justin Russell: We are still waiting for the detail in the target operating model, and the detail behind the transition plans. 

Q10 Chair: We are about four months before it goes live at the moment. Do you have initial views as to the progress on that? Are you concerned that we are that close to going live? 

Justin Russell: It is an ambitious timetable. The clock is ticking, and they have eight months to go till June next year. My own experience of leading big transition programmes is that there is an awful lot of detail that you have to get right. If you do not get it right, you have people turning up to work on day one whose IT systems are not working, who maybe cannot even get through the door and who do not have half the cases they are supposed to be bringing with them. 

The critical things are that you need to make sure the people are coming across, that you have everyone in scope, and that you have sorted out terms and conditions, pensions and vetting and all the rest of it. You need to make sure that the IT and the data systems are right, because we are talking about 130,000 cases transferring into the National Probation Service, and you do not want to lose any of them on the way. 

You need to make sure that you have sorted all the buildings and the accommodation. Purely sorting out the leases on tens or hundreds of buildings is a detailed and difficult task. There are some big things that need to happen between now and June. We are going to do our own inspection of transition planning and readiness, starting at the end of November, and we hope to report in the new year on how we think that is going. 

Chair: That is useful, thank you. 

Q11 Rob Butler: I would like to continue talking about transition, if I may. Let us get to the nub of it: do you think there is enough time to transfer successfully by June 2021?

Justin Russell: Potentially. It partly depends on how much you can derisk what you have to do and the mitigations you have if things aren’t right. If you are trying to do everything on one day, there are huge risks attached to that. It is how much you can mitigate. 

Some of the obvious things are being done. They are lifting and shifting people’s case loads, so probation officers will move into the new structure with their existing case load, and will carry on supervising that so that people do not get lost in the process. They will carry on having the same line management. 

Ironically, one of the failures of TR was around encouraging innovation in IT systems, Because that did not really work out, quite a few of the CRCs are still using the NPS case management system, so they will not have to transfer that, although London and Thames Valley have their own case management, so that will be an issue. 

Q12 Rob Butler: That is a very pertinent point. I happened to visit Thames Valley CRC a couple of weeks ago and they are very proud of their IT system, which they would say is rather more sophisticated than that of NPS, particularly, for example, in being able to track their service users, as they call them, in real time, which the NPS system apparently does not. They are not going to be able to use that system, so they expressed concern that there is almost going to be a backwards step in some elements of supervising offenders once they go back to the unified model. Do you have concerns about that? How are you going to inspect it? 

Justin Russell: Yes. I have been to the Bicester office for MTC and looked at that case management system, which is called Omnia. I sat with a probation officer and they were really pleased with it. We have had very positive feedback from probation staff in both Thames Valley and London about that new system; it feels much more intuitive, and it is quicker to do assessments. I hope there are elements that can be transposed. 

That is an issue you need to talk to the Department and HMPPS about, but it is those sorts of innovations that TR was all about in some ways, and you need to make sure that some of the learning is brought along. It is not just IT: there are other things that they have been doing around community hubs and service user engagement as well. 

Q13 Rob Butler: If I quote you correctly, I think you said that you encouraged the NPS to capture what works in CRCs and transfer initiatives or ideas to the new service once it is a unified model. Will an element of your inspections be monitoring that to make sure that the advances that have been made, in an albeit flawed system, are not lost? 

Justin Russell: We will keep inspecting against our core standards around quality and management services and facilities; where we spot good practice, we will continue to flag that. We have been doing that with CRCs, and we will be looking to see whether they have brought that in with them. I have written to the Minister to talk about what I see as some of the positive things that CRCs have been doing. When we do a report, we flag up those initiatives as well. It is important to bring those over where they can, yes. 

Q14 Rob Butler: But do you have confidence that the transition can take place by June 2021, and that that is not overly ambitious? 

Justin Russell: Until we have done our national inspection in December, we will not have the evidence one way or the other, so I am happy to come back to you early in the new year and report on what that shows. 

Q15 Andy Slaughter: On transition, what effect is it going to have in relation to the existing workforce? I think you also have an ambition to recruit 1,000 new officers by January next year. 

Justin Russell: HMPPS have that ambition, yes. We will be holding them to account on whether they meet it as part of our inspection. 

Q16 Andy Slaughter: Yes. Do you think it is realistic? 

Justin Russell: I spoke to the director of the workforce programme last week, and we are very carefully monitoring what is happening with staffing numbers. We see signs on the ground that probation officer numbers, in the NPS at least, are starting to increase. We inspected the north-west NPS at the beginning of this year and were pleased to see that they have had 153 new trainees come into the north-west. I hear similar things from other regional directors. 

The last published figures showed that probation officer numbers had gone up by about 200, by about 6%, and the gap in the number of unfilled probation officer vacancies is coming down. It is still above 400, so they still have some way to go. I think the number of trainees, on the latest published figures for the end of June, was above 500, so there is a gap between that and 1,000. I am told that there were 9,000 applications for the most recent round of PQiP recruitment—the new trainees—so there is a pipeline, and obviously, as the job situation starts to tighten and people are looking for opportunities, that, to some extent, may help them to get bigger application fields as well. 

Q17 Andy Slaughter: It is perhaps not surprising in the current climate that there are a lot of applications for jobs, but this is becoming quite a familiar story. You could say the same thing with prison officers or indeed police officers, where the service has been cut back to the bone and there have been huge reductions over 10 years. Now some compensation is being made for that, but you have the situation where you are trying to recruit people, who perhaps have no background, and train them. In some cases that makes it worse for a period of time, because the existing service has to switch its resources to that sort of induction process. Given that we have very high case loads anyway, are you concerned about that process? What do you think can be done to mitigate the problems with it? 

Justin Russell: You are right to say that in the short term there are certainly pressures that come with recruiting new trainees: they have to have a reduced case load while they are training; you have to have someone mentoring them; and you have to have a trained assessor who is assessing them as well. All of that affects productivity, although in the long run, once they have the hang of the job, it goes back up again. They need to keep the numbers coming in; they need to keep recruiting. 

The other factor is that you have potentially 20,000 extra police officers coming downstream who will be putting more business into the courts and on to the probation service, and they will need to keep recruiting to meet that requirement as well. They will need to go beyond 1,000, I would have thought, to start to meet those extra demands as well. 

Q18 Andy Slaughter: It is a perfect storm in a way. We are transitioning from one system to another because the previous system failed; the service is trying to make up for the lack of numbers and deal with what are perceived to be the current problems of excess case load, which have caused some pretty distressing events to happen. Obviously, you are aware of all that, and it is your job to monitor, criticise and so on, but, going beyond that, do you have any insight into how the service should be operating? Do you have any advice, or do you not see that as your role? 

Justin Russell: I have been talking to quite a few regional directors over the past few weeks. They have to balance both recovery planning from Covid and preparing for this major transition next year. That is a big demand on them. They need support teams around them; they need support from the centre to be able to do that, and they need resources. I was encouraged that an extra £150 million went into the probation service this financial year. It is really important that that gets baked into the baseline going forward, and that they have a decent settlement in the spending review to support all of that work going forward. It will be very challenging for those leaders, particularly those who may be new to the NPS. 

Q19 Andy Slaughter: We all know that the MOJ has received probably the highest cuts of any Government Department, and this is only mitigating that to some extent. Do you see there being a risk to the public in what is happening at the moment, and do you think any steps should be taken on safeguarding in terms of the way that the service operates during the transitional period?

Justin Russell: As I said, our biggest areas of concern in our quality standards are around risk of harm and whether they are getting the risk assessments and the planning and reviewing right. That has consistently been unsatisfactory. We will continue to focus on that in all of our inspections relentlessly and check that lessons are being learned. 

There are some signs for encouragement, in that some of the scores have started to improve a bit. What I hope is that they do not start to go down again as we get nearer to transition. Keeping the service’s eye on the ball of delivery, as they also prepare it, is really important. As the CRCs head towards the exit door, it may become more difficult for them, particularly for their parent companies, to stay focused on delivery. A lot of CRCs are starting to lose their leaders, as senior leaders are now moving into regional director and heads of operation jobs in the NPS and leaving the CRCs, so there are real vulnerabilities around that which the service needs to look out for. 

Q20 Paula Barker: There is just one question from me. In respect of the workforce strategy and the transition, do you know whether the trade unions will be fully engaged, on behalf of their members, in the whole process? 

Justin Russell: I don’t know. I certainly hope they have been, and we will be checking on that in our transition planning inspection when we start it in November. That is certainly one of the questions we will be looking at. 

In the Wales example, where Wales went through the transition a bit earlier, there was, certainly in the offender management function, a lot of negotiation and liaison with the trade unions. I think that is still going on. I am not sure that they have yet settled the terms and conditions around the Welsh probation service, so there are lessons from that exercise for the rest of the country as well. 

Paula Barker: Great. Thanks very much. 

Q21 Dr Mullan: I have a couple of questions. In terms of the 1,000 figure— although this might already have been covered—as the companies are wound down and we move back to a single model and their staff transfer over, I assume it is clear that that 1,000 will be on top of any people who transfer in, because you are not really creating a bigger workforce if you are just bringing in-house existing people. Is that part of how you understand it? 

Justin Russell: The big problem we have is that there are no national figures on the CRC workforce; we do not know how many probation officers or PSOs they recruit, so it is very difficult to know how big the hole is that needs to be filled as they transfer over. We have been collecting that data as we do inspections. The data from the services that we have inspected shows that probation officer numbers have come down by about 10% across those we inspected over the last financial year, as resources have got tighter, so that is increasing the hole that needs to be filled. 

There are very few CRCs, if any at all, that are now starting to train new probation officers—it is not in their interests—so it is very much on the NPS to make good that gap. I am sure they take account of what the potential gaps in the CRCs are, as well as the NPS gaps, when they decide how big the recruitment cohorts should be going forward. 

Q22 Dr Mullan: I guess what I am getting at is how you are going to be able to draw a firm conclusion as to whether the overall workforce of people working on behalf of Government in probation has gone up by 1,000, versus people who have just come in from the companies. How will you know? 

Justin Russell: That is a very good point, and I will be asking the very same question as they continue to pass statistical bulletins, because the statistical bulletin, as you have probably seen, is purely NPS staff. We have never had a bulletin on CRC staff. There will at some point be a number of people who are in scope for the transition to CRCs and we will know that number, but, as you say, we will not necessarily know what the gap in that number is. 

Q23 Dr Mullan: I am interested in the vacancies in the sense that it is all very well to talk about lack of budgets, lack of money to hire people, and so on, but when you cannot hire people within existing budgets, it demonstrates that it is not just a matter of the overall money available to the services. Why do you think they are struggling to recruit? Are there not suitable people? Is it salary, or work environment? What do you think means that they struggle? 

Justin Russell: As you might expect, the biggest struggle with vacancies is in London and the south-east; and in the south-east it is the bits of Kent and the home counties that are closest to London. That has been a real issue. In our Joseph McCann review, we found staff shortages in the Hertfordshire office that had been supervising him. Some of our inspections have shown vacancy rates in the NPS of up to about 20%. They are being plugged with agency staff at the moment. 

What I am often told is that agency staff are quite happy to do long-term placements; they do not particularly want to go for permanent probation officer jobs because they find that reduces their flexibility. There needs to be some combination of thinking about what flexibility or work-life balance they can offer within the service, or if it is the salary. There was some language in the workforce strategy about looking at pay and conditions, which I hope indicated that they are considering what might need to be done on that, in particular in areas of high vacancy. 

Dr Mullan: It is interesting what you say about the number of applications and what they are applying to do, so maybe there is a more positive future. Thank you.

Maria Eagle: Briefly, before I move on to Covid, there is one thing that strikes me about the reason why the CRCs were set up and split away from the NPS. They were going to deal more with minor offenders who could be turned away from repeat offending more readily perhaps, and the NPS was going to stick with dealing with some of the very serious and dangerous offenders. Have you any view about all these challenges coming at once—the high case loads, the organisational change as the two organisations are put together, the lack of staff and the recovery from Covid—and what impact they are going to have, if any, on the ability of the service as a whole to deal with the high end, more serious and dangerous offenders? If they are not supervised properly and if they are not properly dealt with, the consequences of things going wrong can be much greater for those who end up being victims of perhaps further offending. Do you have any handle on that, and whether or not during this transition there is going to be an issue in dealing with the serious and dangerous offenders at the toughest end of the scale? 

Justin Russell: What we are finding is that supervision of the higher risk offenders who are in the case loads of the NPS has been rather better than the lower and medium risk offenders. Because those offenders will stay with their NPS probation officers as they go through transition, there should be continuity of supervision through that process and, hopefully, people’s eye will stay on the ball with them. 

Interestingly, when we did our study of serious further offences, two thirds of homicides committed by people on probation were people who had been assessed as low or medium risk, so it is not people at the high end who are offending. What we find as we look at CRC case loads is that they are pretty chaotic people: they are quite likely to have a drugs problem, and 40% of them are domestic abuse perpetrators. Calling them low risk is not necessarily always the case; they might be homeless and, quite typically, have issues with accommodation. 

We find that that population has huge needs. They are quite chaotic and need particular interventions and support, maybe different from supervising a lifer coming out of prison or someone convicted of a serious sex offence. They need the right sort of supervision and services going forward. It is important to make sure that that happens as they move over to the NPS caseload next summer. 

Q25 Maria Eagle: Can you let us know what your initial findings are on the inspection of probation services during the Covid-19 period? Obviously, that has changed how everybody does things, so do you have any initial findings from your inspections? 

Justin Russell: Yes. We have finished the fieldwork and have been writing up our findings. We looked at six local services, and in detail at 60 cases, in June, and we interviewed some service users about their experience and interviewed probation officers. 

We found that the probation service had done, in some ways, a remarkable job at completely changing their operating model overnight to one of remote supervision, so that 80% to 90% of people were receiving phone supervision rather than face to face. Some critical services had to be stopped altogether. They had to stop doing unpaid work; they stopped doing accredited programme delivery, or at least the new programmes. They necessarily, I think, focused on risk, on doing risk assessment, and on people’s welfare. In general, looking at the cases we inspected, they did a reasonable job of that. We did not have to raise any urgent alerts about people who had gone missing or were not properly being managed. It was by phone, but it was reasonably consistent contact; 75% of them had had a contact every week from their probation officer by phone. 

There were a variety of views from staff about having to work from home. The majority welcomed the flexibility it gave them and the savings in travel costs and all the rest of it. Some of them struggled a bit to find the space to work at home. In the probation service, there are some pretty challenging conversations with some difficult people; in front of your kids in your living room, that is quite a tricky thing to be doing, and people felt a bit stressed by that sometimes. 

We also talked to some service users. Where they were in a stable situation—a stable family life and somewhere to live—some of them preferred being remotely supervised; they preferred phone contact. It meant that they did not have to sort out childcare and worry about going on public transport. They said they felt they could be more open sometimes with their probation officer when they were doing interventions. With service users who were more vulnerable and might have a mental health problem and other welfare needs, some of them really struggled quite a bit and missed personal face-to-face contact with their probation officer, who could be quite an important person in their life sometimes. 

Q26 Maria Eagle: Having done some of that work, what is your sense of how the Covid-19 challenge and this period has changed priorities for the probation service? 

Justin Russell: One of the positives is that it has given the CRCs more experience of particularly focusing on risk, on risk assessment and getting that right. They have done a reasonable job of that, so those staff will be taking that into the new arrangements next year. People have got the hang of doing other forms of remote supervision, and, longer term, there will probably be a move towards some supervision continuing to be online or over the phone, but in a mix with face to face. 

One of the interesting things is improved multi-agency relationships. Probation officers have struck up good relationships with the police in particular and with social services. They are communicating more; they have daily conversations about who may have been arrested or flagged on social service systems, and more people are turning up for multiagency meetings—MAPPA meetings and MARAC meetings. Because it is much easier to dial into a virtual meeting, they are getting quite good attendance, and that is a positive. I would expect that maybe some of those will continue to operate like that going forward. 

Q27 Maria Eagle: Do you think that new priorities for the service will come out of this period that will continue, or will there be a shift back to old ways of doing things? 

Justin Russell: I think the priorities will remain reoffending, desistance and steering people away from crime, and the public protection role. Those are not going to change. The way they deliver those services may change to reflect the use of new technology. Necessarily under Covid, the focus was very much on risk and public protection. There was less delivery being done on offending behaviour programmes or interventions. Those are now being switched back on and people are starting to come in. That is the gap at the moment that will need to be filled; there are far fewer people doing accredited programmes at the moment than there were before Covid, and that number will need to go up. 

Unpaid work is quite interesting as well. The old model of doing unpaid work was that you put a lot of people in a minibus and took them off to do litter-picking or other work. It is quite difficult to keep social distancing, so they are having to find different ways of doing it. People are having to make their own way to work placements. There are fewer people on placements and there is more focus on individual placements. There are some quite big challenges around that as well. 

Q28 Maria Eagle: You recently launched a consultation on the future of adult inspections. Do you have any initial findings in respect of that work? 

Justin Russell: We are just going through our consultation responses at the moment and we will publish our way forward on that. There is broad support, I think, for two or three of the key things that we are going do. 

One is that, as CRCs and the NPS come together, we will no longer need separate inspection teams for the two different sorts of service, so there will be single inspection teams. They will be able to look end to end at every case they look at, right from the point when the initial court report is done through to planning assessment and on to review and through-the-gate release. Then we will aggregate all that data. 

A key thing we are going to do is start looking at a much more local level. Our inspections will look at local delivery units, which might be a single city, a unitary authority or a single county. That will give the probation service itself much more granular detail, so you will know how probation is performing in Newcastle, Leeds or Bristol, and not just the whole of the south-west or the whole of the north-east. That will be important to the public, so there will be more transparency to the public. I will be able to go on the radio and tell Radio Leeds listeners, “Here is how your local probation service is operating.” I find that difficult to do at the moment when I am reporting on the whole of Yorkshire and Humberside. That is important. 

Another key thing is that I have always been keen to look at the outcomes of the probation service. Is it making a real difference to the people being supervised? Are they getting into accommodation? Are they getting off drugs? Are they getting into employment and training? Is their health improving? We will be looking at how we can measure those outcomes, as well as process, in our inspections. We are doing some pilots in Wales this autumn to see how we can measure those sorts of things in practice in a local service. 

Maria Eagle: Thank you very much. 

Q29 Dr Mullan: While we have you here, I want to ask you about the proposals in the new White Paper around probation, particularly the use of more tagging and home detention. I don’t know if you have seen anything about them and I know it is perhaps not strictly under this remit, but have you had any initial thoughts as to whether you think that is going to work and what you think the challenges might be? Do you think the probation services will be in a position to monitor and go after people who breach their tagging, in collaboration with the police? Do you think it is going to make a difference to people’s compliance? What would your thoughts be?

Justin Russell: There was a whole range of proposals in the White Paper around community supervision, many of which I think the probation service will welcome. There is obviously the tagging stuff. There is improving the quality of pre-sentence reports, community sentence treatment requirements and the courts to supervise people— problem-solving courts. There is plenty there. 

On electronic monitoring, I think the GPS technology is potentially a game changer in being able to monitor people’s movements, as well as whether they are just at home or not. We will need to see what difference that makes. There has been a new systematic review of the evidence on electronic monitoring published, and I was reading it last night. It varies according to who is being supervised, so there is good evidence that sex offender reoffending rates reduce under electronic monitoring, and there are certain other groups of offender where it has a positive effect. 

For others, it may not have such a positive effect. It partly depends on how you manage it, but there are signs that it has an impact on reoffending rates, and that is a positive thing, but it needs to be used in the right way. When it is used for people coming out of prison for home detention curfew, you have a very strong stick for people to stick to their curfew because they will be called back to prison if they do not. If it is a condition of a community sentence, the breach proceedings may be a bit longer, so part of the success of it will be how quickly you can act on that, and people realise that there are real consequences from breaking the tag.

The longer you have someone on a tag, the more, potentially, they could breach and, therefore, the implications on the Prison Service downstream start to flow from that, but I am sure they will have done the modelling on that going forward. 

Q30 Dr Mullan: Do you think people being in their homes and confined in that way is going to make it easier for probation supervisors to meet them and engage with them, or does that not tend to be a challenge in their engagement with the people they are supervising? 

Justin Russell: At the moment, the static electronic monitoring tends to be about curfewing people at night-time, which is not when you would be having an appointment anyway. One of the interesting proposals in the White Paper is that you would have variable curfew hours, maybe longer at weekends than during the week, and that probation would have more control, potentially. There is some very interesting language in the White Paper about giving the probation service more discretion, and more flexibility to vary the conditions and requirements relating to supervision. I would certainly welcome that and think it would be a positive development. 

Chair: Mr Russell, thank you very much indeed. It has been very helpful and informative, as always. We look forward to hearing from you again with the updates that you so helpfully give us. Thank you for your time and for your evidence to us today. We are grateful to you.

Wednesday, 23 September 2020

Napo and Sentencing Proposals

Published today and circulated to all Napo members:-

Napo responds to Government White Paper

Last week the Secretary of State for Justice Robert Buckland MP published his White Paper: A smarter approach to sentencing. Napo has scrutinised the document and highlighted a number of concerns we have with the proposals. This briefing has been shared with David Lammy MP and his justice team and Katie Lomas National Chair and Tania Bassett National Official met with him today to discuss them in more detail. Napo will continue to raise these issues across parliament to try to influence the policy further including through our parliamentary networks such as the Justice Unions Parliamentary Group and the Justice Select Committee.

White Paper Briefing: A Smarter Approach to Sentencing
 

The White Paper published 16th September 2020 outlines government proposals to reform sentencing and community orders. Below is Napo’s response to the paper and highlights concerns with the proposals as well as unforeseen consequences of the reforms. 

In 2019 Lord Woolfe said that there needed to be a full review of the terms of reference of the sentencing council as well as a full review of the guidelines as he felt it had lost focus of its original purpose, becoming more and more punitive. It is then disappointing that the Lord Chancellor did not undertake this as part of the paper. Napo believes that this is fundamental to any proposed sentencing reforms. 

Napo is also clear that longer periods in custody does not aid rehabilitation and this briefing is written within that context. 

Courts 

Courts have been struggling with listings for some time now as a result of court closures and staff cuts. Covid-19 has further exacerbated this with an estimated 45,000 cases now awaiting court time. As a result, we are seeing trials for even the most serious offences being adjourned to 2022 and beyond. In order for any effective reforms to sentencing to take place this issue needs to be addressed as a matter of urgency by re-opening courts and not closing Nightingale Courts (one of which has closed after just 2 weeks). 

As raised by David Lammy MP, problem solving courts introduced under the last Labour government, have proven themselves to be very effective and as such Napo agrees that there is no need to pilot these. Instead they should be rolled out nationally as soon as possible and courts given the funding required to do this. The closure of smaller local Courts does not create ideal circumstances for the introduction of problem solving Courts which should be connected to the local community. Their reopening (and the commitment to no further closures) could support the introduction of problem solving Courts while assisting in clearing the backlog of cases. 

Pre-sentence reports 

Napo welcomes the proposal to review the use of pre-sentence reports. As part of the last probation reforms an arbitrary target of 80% of all reports to be completed in a short format has contributed in a drop in quality in reports (as identified by HMIP) and therefore significant drop in courts ordering them (as identified by MOJ figures). Napo has opposed this target from day one as well as other stakeholders such as the Magistrates Association.

Napo believes that our members are best placed to determine what format a report should be written on based on the individual they are assessing, their needs and the risk they pose. Therefore, we see no reason to pilot “targeted” reports, simply allow practitioners to use their professional judgement. This would both improve the quality of reports (by allowing sufficient time for pre-sentence reports to be completed) and increase sentencers confidence in the assessments they are provided with. 

GPS, Tagging and Curfews 

Tagging has never really been fully utilised. In part because there is a lack of confidence in how they are monitored by the private sector. G4S and Serco have both been investigated by the serious fraud office for falsely claiming money for tags that have been fitted inappropriately or not at all. Whilst Napo welcomes the powers for probation to alter curfews as and when it is appropriate they have little control over the tagging process itself. For tagging to be both value for money and an effective supplement to other interventions this should be brought in house. Its effectiveness is currently undermined when providers fail to notify of breaches, are difficult to share information with and have little or no accountability. 

Custodial Sentences 

Napo is concerned that at a time when we need to be looking at developing a more progressive justice system the proposals to remove the automatic release at the half way point is a backwards move instead. Automatic release half way through a custodial sentence of 4 – 7 years was introduced by the last Labour government. With the exception of a few, very critical and horrendous cases, this has proven to be an effective way of using the licence period for more rehabilitation and public protection measures. Changing this back to two thirds reduces the amount of time probation have to work with an individual to reduce their risk and help to turn their life around during the resettlement portion of the sentence which can only happen in the community. 

Preventing automatic release for certain prisoners of concern and relying on the parole board to deem them safe before they can be released, appears to similar to the now abolished IPP sentences which proved to have been disproportionate and have left prisoners wallowing in prison way beyond their original tariff. Napo is deeply worried that this measure, which can be imposed even if no further offence has been committed and concerns about risk do not have to be connected to the index offence may be open to abuse. Much more detail is required to reassure both practitioners and prisoners on what exactly these concerns relate to, what evidence is required to support refusal of automatic release and what needs to be achieved for a prisoner to be considered for release by the parole board. There are currently prisoners serving an IPP that have no prospect of release as they are unable to achieve the targets set by the parole board (for example offending behaviour programmes that must be completed for release but are not being offered in the establishment they are held or are not accessible to them because of mental health issues). 

Rehabilitation and resettlement are not the same although they are both important. Rehabilitation can begin while in custody and will continue in the community. It is the process by which people make changes to their lives to enable them to desist from offending. It may include education and training, addressing substance use, changing thinking and behaviour patterns, getting support with emotional wellbeing and mental health issues. Resettlement only happens in the community, although it should be planned while in custody. It is the process by which someone moves from custody to community and reintegrates positively into society. When people are released at the end of their sentence they may have begun their rehabilitation journey in custody but their resettlement will be done in the community with no support or monitoring by Probation as they will have no licence period. This also means that there will be no risk management on release. 

It will also generate a considerable amount of additional work so reassurances are needed that the Parole Board will be adequately funded and resourced to prevent further back logs in the system. 

Wider Reforms 

Extending the victim service in probation is welcomed. However, the role of victim liaison officer (VLO) was downgraded by the Ministry of Justice during transforming rehabilitation. This has left our members feeling undervalued and sends a message to the public that this role is not really seen as critical. The changes will also increase workloads considerably for VLOs, many already working with hundreds of cases, so Napo would like assurances that there will be a targeted recruitment drive to increase the staff resource in this area. Napo welcomes the move to bring all interventions back in house under the NPS and the intention to integrate unpaid work into the wider community. Unpaid work is the most visible role that probation plays in communities. However, under Transforming rehabilitation many CRCs began to charge community groups for this service reducing access by small community groups to utilise it. Napo would like assurances that these charges will stop and that unpaid work can be accessed by all community groups. 

Tania Bassett, Napo National Official 
21 September 2020

Monday, 21 September 2020

Our Prison Disgrace

I resisted for as long as possible, but it seems there is now no option but to use the new Blogger dashboard despite it being much worse than the original. It all takes much longer to navigate, is not user-friendly and will inevitably drive me to distraction. I hate change for it's own sake and especially when not an improvement!

--oo00oo--

We didn't cover it last week, but there was a scathing report from the Public Accounts Committee on the state of our prisons which yet again underlines why probation should not be part of the dreadful HMPPS:-   

Summary
 

The Ministry of Justice and HM Prison and Probation Service have failed in their attempts to improve the condition and suitability of the prison estate. Despite promises to create 10,000 new-for-old prison places by 2020, just 206 new places have been delivered so far, and prisoners continue to be held in unsafe, crowded conditions that do not meet their needs. Budget cuts imposed at a time of much promised reform across the department have exacerbated the challenges to these ambitious programmes which have been on the cards for over a decade. As we saw with the Ministry’s inability to successfully contract out services during probation reforms, the Ministry has once again exposed taxpayers to higher than expected costs as a result of inadequate planning, unrealistic assumptions and poor performance whilst managing facilities within prisons. HMPPS has allowed a staggering backlog of maintenance work to build up that will cost more than £900 million to address. This means that 500 prison places are taken permanently out of action each year due to their poor condition. Prisons play a crucial role in supporting prisoners to stay away from crime on their release and reduce the £18.1 billion cost to the economy of reoffending each year. The poor condition of many prisons, coupled with high levels of overcrowding, are contributing to dangerously high levels of violence and self-harm in prisons. Despite our recommendations in May 2019, there is still no sign of a cross-government strategy for reducing reoffending. 

Although COVID-19 has eased pressure on demand for prison places in the short-term, we are concerned about the Ministry’s ability to both improve the condition of the estate, and meet rising demand through building new prison places in the medium to long-term. The Ministry’s track record does not inspire confidence, and there is limited headroom in the prison estate to allow the space for vital maintenance work. The Ministry is now optimistic about both its capacity and capability to improve the prison estate and its future financial position. But it will need to demonstrate it has learnt lessons from its past failures and that it has a coherent long-term and fully funded plan in order to make genuine progress.

--oo00oo--

This from the Guardian on Friday:-

England and Wales' disgraceful prisons expose ministers' refusal to learn from mistakes

The slow-motion collapse of England and Wales’ prison system is a textbook example of the government’s repeated public service failures in the age of austerity.

The mismanagement of the prison estate, exposed in a scathing report from the Commons public accounts committee, is a carbon copy of ministers’ numerous other foul-ups over the past decade. There are starring roles for inadequate funding and disastrous use of private contractors, with supporting parts for squandering money by aiming for unachievable savings, raiding capital budgets to prop up running costs, making big promises with no credible delivery plan, and failing to join up policy. Inevitably, it is all followed by yet more delusional promises of future delivery and the piecemeal populism of ever-longer sentences.

Prisons are the responsibility of HM Prison & Probation Service, an executive agency of the Ministry of Justice (MoJ). Its declared aim is to ensure they are decent, safe and productive places to live and work.

But the last annual report from HM Chief Inspector of Prisons for England and Wales said living conditions for most prisoners were inadequate and some were squalid, including cramped, bloodstained, flooded and filthy cells, rat, flea and cockroach infestations, and broken windows.

Among the 117 prisons in England and Wales, two-thirds are crowded. The 10 most crowded hold at least 47% more prisoners than intended. Today, more than 79,000 people are incarcerated in prisons and young offender institutions. A year ago – before the pandemic caused a backlog of more than 500,000 trials – it was 83,000.

Low-risk prisoners are forced into high-security regimes. High-risk prisoners are inadequately secured. Assaults on staff have doubled since 2015 and around 1,000 attacks a year are classified as serious. There were more than 50,000 incidents of self-harm in the year to September 2018.

Inevitably, incompetent contracting plays its part. In 2015, the MoJ handed management of the facilities to two companies – one of which, Carillion, collapsed within three years – without fully understanding what it was contracting out. The MPs say this failure will affect prisons for many years.

In yet another example of grandiose promises being followed by failure, the government has delivered just 206 of the 10,000 new-for-old prison places promised by 2020.

Five days after the MPs’ report, the government unveiled plans to ram in ever-more prisoners. Its white paper A Smarter Approach to Sentencing is anything but – simply a rehash of the default position of longer sentences, including the ability to sentence people in their teens to life without parole. Other measures such as deferring sentences to give offenders a chance to turn themselves around will do little to ameliorate the increase in the prison population, which could run into thousands.

The long-running disgrace of our prison system betrays a refusal among ministers to learn from mistakes. Every single one of these failures has been seen elsewhere.

Mismanagement of probation and defence equipment exemplifies a strategy of dumping complex problems on private contractors for vast amounts of money without fully understanding the causes of the difficulties or what was required to put them right.

The £1.2bn programme to modernise courts over-promised, failed to get to grips with delivery, and didn’t listen to the people the changes would affect. The quality of NHS hospitals and equipment, meanwhile, has been undermined by repeated raids on its capital budget.

And yet the government’s planning reforms – facing growing opposition from Tory backbenchers – continue to show an inability to join up policy across government, handing massive power to developers while failing to address priorities such as investing in England’s northern towns and cities, providing more social housing and tackling climate change.

This shambolic way of running the country has now reached its nadir in the utterly inadequate test and trace system – incompetent contracting, an inability to understand the problems, overpromising, failing to focus on the detail of delivery, and an pathological refusal to listen to experts. There must be a better way.

Richard Vize is a public policy commentator and analyst

Saturday, 19 September 2020

Unfit For Office

It will be apparent to regular readers that I've refrained from too much political discourse of late but I can resist no longer given the increasingly serious situation we find ourselves in with a Prime Minister so clearly unfit for office that even the right are turning against him. This from the Guardian:-

Sinking without trace: rightwing press turns on Boris Johnson

Where’s Boris?” asked this week’s Spectator, the weekly magazine the prime minister once edited and from which Johnson might once have expected a better press had it not been for the coronavirus crisis.

With a front cover image featuring a distant blond dot on a tiny boat bobbing rudderless and oarless on a stormy sea, the message of chaos and drift from the title was emphatic – a criticism of the prime minister’s leadership in the battle against the pandemic that is being replicated across an increasingly sceptical rightwing media.

“The question now is whether he can become a proper leader with a sense of direction and purpose,” said the magazine’s editor, Fraser Nelson, effectively arguing that Johnson’s premiership was at a crossroads, that a narrative was close to being set.

After a week in which Britain’s test-and-trace system – once intended by the prime minister to be “world-beating” – was at the point of collapse, Nelson asked “whether the pattern we have seen in recent months – of disorder, debacle, rebellion, U-turn and confusion – is what we should henceforth expect”.

Others writing in the same magazine put it more idiosyncratically. “What on earth happened to the freedom-loving, twinkly-eyed, Rabelaisian character I voted for? Oliver Hardy has left the stage, replaced by Oliver Cromwell,” said columnist Toby Young, complaining of a “lack of engagement with the detail”.

Earlier on Thursday, the same day the Spectator cover emerged, the Daily Mail had reached a similar conclusion. “Boris: We’ve Failed” the front-page headline blared, with the paper claiming it had warned of a “looming test crisis five months ago”.

The rightwing tabloid highlighted Johnson’s subdued performance the day before in front of parliament’s liaison committee, where he had been forced to admit that “the short answer” was that there were nowhere near enough Covid tests available.

Only a week earlier, the prime minister talked optimistically about a “moonshot” plan to test millions of people a day as way to return to pre-coronavirus normality. Now he had humiliatingly been forced to admit there were nowhere near enough tests for worried parents at a level closer to 230,000 a day.

“Too often the government has over-promised and under-delivered,” concluded a leader in the Times on Friday morning. “Policies have had to be swiftly abandoned after the exposure of entirely predictable problems,” the centre-right broadsheet continued, adding the A-level fiasco and the problems with the contact-tracing app for good measure.

The paper – perhaps with one eye on a promotion for the former Times journalist Michael Gove – argued that Johnson needed to appoint “competent deputies” before “the public come to a settled and unflattering view about his ability to do the job”.

--oo00oo--

Toby Young writing in the Spectator:-

I admit it : I was wrong to back Boris

A friend emailed me earlier this week in despair about the Prime Minister. ‘Boris reminds me of a hereditary king — Edward II or Henry VI — who is so staggeringly incompetent that he must be removed before doing too much damage,’ he wrote. ‘I felt the same way about May but Boris is worse.’

He is not the only person feeling like this. It pains me to say it, but I too have given up on Boris. The final straw was hearing him talk about his plans to create an army of ‘Covid marshals’ last week — Britain’s very own, curtain-twitching version of the Stasi.

What on earth happened to the freedom-loving, twinkly-eyed, Rabelaisian character I voted for? Oliver Hardy has left the stage, replaced by Oliver Cromwell. His government has even said it wants to lower the speed limit on motorways to 60 mph. Didn’t Boris once say that voting Tory will cause your wife to have bigger breasts and increase your chances of owning a BMW M3? Where did that guy go?

Some people think it’s all to do with his bout of coronavirus. As one person put it to me, surviving a near-death experience can affect people in one of two ways. Either you become more devil-may-care, thinking it could all end at any moment so why not live life to the full; or you become super-cautious, having been left feeling vulnerable by your brush with mortality. According to that armchair psychologist, Boris has gone through door number two. A less generous theory is that the disease actually damaged his brain in some way — and there is some evidence that cognitive decline can lower your appetite for risk. Whether the damage was psychological or physiological, the implication is clear: he’s no longer fit to be prime minister and should step down as soon as he’s got Brexit done.

This explanation is attractive to  former Boris enthusiasts like me because it lets us off the hook. It’s not that we overestimated him; rather that he’s changed in a way we couldn’t have anticipated. But the difficulty with those theories is that his mishandling of the crisis predates his battle with Covid-19.

Few would dispute that he failed to give the pandemic the attention he should have done in January and February, time he could have spent devising an effective containment strategy. Come March, he was just buffeted by events, one minute saying we should ‘take it on the chin’, the next imposing a full lockdown. His lack of engagement with the detail, both before and after his spell in intensive care, means the government’s response has been led by others around the cabinet table, like Matt Hancock, who seem to be wholly captured by a small coterie of scientific advisors who decided early on that Sars-CoV-2 was ‘the big one’ and have been unwilling to abandon that hypothesis in the light of all the evidence to the contrary.

Boris’s supporters cannot claim they were unaware of this risk. His inability to focus on anything for very long was constantly flagged up by those who’d worked closely with him, most recently at the Foreign Office. My response when this was put to me by his detractors was that he had been preparing for the role of prime minister all his life, had a heroic conception of himself as a world-historical individual and wanted to be installed in the pantheon of immortals as one of Britain’s greats. So even if it was only for vainglorious reasons, he would apply himself in No. 10 in a way he never had before. Hal would become Henry V, not Henry VI. 

Unfortunately, Boris’s critics have been proved correct. Funnily enough, one of the most prominent, Michael Gove, is now de facto deputy prime minister. Four years ago, when justifying his decision to knife Boris in the Tory leadership contest, Gove said it was because, having seen him operate up close, he’d concluded he lacked the character for the top job. Not lazy exactly, but not serious enough. At the time I took this with a pinch of salt, thinking Gove was exaggerating to make it sound as if he was motivated by public-spiritedness rather than personal ambition. Now I think he was right.

Hope followed by disappointment is a familiar story in politics, a cycle as old as history itself. I should have been better prepared. In future, I will not be so naive.

Toby Young is associate editor of The Spectator.


--oo00oo--

Finally Ian Dunt writing for inews:-

Boris Johnson’s campaign to undermine objective truth stops him from being held accountable

Without it, the Government can keep on lying – and keep on operating with impunity

On 19 October 2019, Boris Johnson told the House of Commons that the deal he had agreed with the EU was “about as perfect as you could get”. It was “excellent”, “great” and “very good for this country”. There would be no border in the Irish Sea. Anyone who opposed the deal was standing with the EU over British interests and trying to undermine Brexit.

In the Commons this week, that message was inverted. The deal was now portrayed as a disaster which had to be dismantled through mechanisms contained in the Internal Market Bill. The Prime Minister’s spokesperson said it “contains ambiguities, and in key areas there is a lack of clarity”. There will in fact be a border in the Irish Sea. Anyone who defends the deal is standing with the EU over British interests and trying to undermine Brexit.

In speech after speech, Tory MPs rose to attack the deal, seemingly without recognising that their contribution was fundamentally incompatible with the speeches they had been making over the course of the previous year. When Labour opposed the Government, the official Conservative Twitter account put out a message saying the party had “just voted to side with the EU”.

What we’re seeing here is not standard-issue political cynicism. It is something qualitatively different: a conscious effort to eradicate the notion of objective truth as an operating principle in British political life.

It involves a three-stage process: the willingness of the Government to produce disinformation, the undermining of independent fact-checkers who might assess it, and an audience so blinded by tribalism that they will willingly receive it.

The first aspect has been present in the Johnson administration from the beginning. After all, the recent mutation over the EU deal is just the latest reversal he has engineered on the topic. Back when he was foreign secretary under Theresa May, he insisted that “no British Conservative government could or should sign up to” a deal which put a border in the Irish Sea. He then reversed his position before now reversing it again. His public utterances on other policy issues, including the response to Covid-19, follow the same pattern.

The main threat to this approach comes from independent journalists, who might call out the rewriting of history. This is why reporters and media outlets which ask tough questions of ministers are sporadically blacklisted, including Channel 4 News, senior figures from the BBC and Sky, Radio 4’s Today, ITV’s Good Morning Britain and a variety of smaller outlets.

None of these tactics work if you have an electorate which still retains the capacity to assess government messaging on the basis of its objective validity. That’s why a concerted effort is made to frame information instead on the basis of tribal identity.

This is an old phenomenon. The philosopher John Stuart Mill recognised people’s tendency to prioritise their tribal identity over objective reasoning in the 19th Century. A hundred years later, the journalist George Orwell wrote about how people were prone to evaluating new information on the basis of their allegiances.

The only thing which has changed is the advent of social media, where behavioural algorithms allow the Government to deliver a bespoke message, tailored to people’s emotional instincts, in an attempt to create closed-off information ecosystems. Technology has tapped into a human vulnerability and the Government is exploiting it.

That’s why the Conservative party sent that tweet after the debate. It’s why Tory MPs this week claimed the EU wants “to see our country fail” and was trying to turn the UK into an “enslaved economic satellite”. As Conservative MP Lee Anderson said on Monday night: “Members of this House need to decide where their loyalties lie. Is it with the EU or with the United Kingdom?” Once the tribal viewpoint is secured, people stop looking for the truth and instead seek out that which supports their world view.

This approach is not happening by chance. It is followed by nationalist governments around the world, including the US, Brazil, Hungary, Poland and India. It is a very old story: the purposeful expansion of executive control. If nationalists can lie without consequence, then there are no limits on their power. They cannot be scrutinised on the basis of their record.

This story will continue until people recognise it for what it is. The first stage in that recognition is to think rationally on the basis of verifiable information. To even retain the capacity for memory and objectivity, is, in this period, a radical act.

We need to remember that Johnson once insisted he would never sign a deal like the one he accepted, and that he is now attacking the very document which he once celebrated. It’s only by retaining that capacity for objective truth that this Government can be held to account. Without it, they can keep on lying – and keep on operating with impunity.

Ian Dunt is the author of How to be a Liberal: The Story of Liberalism and the Fight for its Life, published by Canbury Press hardback, £25 (also available as ebook and in audio).

Thursday, 17 September 2020

World Class Probation Service?

Having done the rounds of media outlets yesterday morning spreading misinformation about the number of Covid-19 tests being carried out daily - but not on Good Morning Britain and Piers Morgan - the Justice Secretary Robert Buckland gave a speech about the latest sentencing plans and here are some highlights:- 

Protecting the public from serious offenders

The White Paper focusses firstly on the most serious offenders. Because we believe it is crucial that sexual and violent offenders spend as much of their sentence behind bars as possible. This is what the public wants, and victims should be able to expect.


Automatic release and parole board oversight

Offenders who have committed serious crimes and who are assessed to be dangerous at the point of being sentenced can receive either a life sentence or an Extended Determinate term. This means there is no automatic release and these cases go to the Parole Board to assess whether it would be safe to release offenders.

But there are small number who, for particular reasons, are assessed as posing a serious threat to the public, for example through terrorism, when that is not the crime for which they are serving a sentence. At present, these offenders will be eligible for automatic release from prison and will not fall under Parole Board oversight.

By introducing a new power for the Justice Secretary to prevent their automatic release and instead refer their cases to the Parole Board, we will now ensure that these offenders are properly assessed before being released – to determine whether or not they do pose a threat to the public, or if it would be safer for them to serve the remainder of their term in prison. This represents a major change and will reassure the public that dangerous criminals will be properly assessed before release.

Around 2,000 more serious and violent offenders who receive a standard determinate sentence of 7 years or more will now spend at least two thirds of their sentence behind bars, thanks to legislation already brought in by this government. We are going to widen that approach, so that offenders serving a fixed sentence of 4 to 7 years will also spend longer in prison.

Sentence lengths for serious offences

The public rightly expects child killers to feel the fullest and the harshest extent of the law. We will therefore ensure a Whole Life Order is not just available to sentencers in these cases, but that it will be their starting point. In exceptional circumstances we will also give judges the discretion to impose a Whole Life Order on those aged 18 to 20, where currently only those aged 21 or over may receive this severest of punishments.

Adult offenders who are given life sentences in other circumstances often do not serve enough of that sentence before they come before the Parole Board to consider their release – certainly not as much as the public rightly expect.

We will now ensure that these offenders spend longer behind bars before they can be assessed for release. By changing the way in which discretionary life sentences are calculated, we will see to it that judges base the minimum tariff to be served on what two thirds of an equivalent determinate sentence would be, rather than half, as they do at present. We will also increase the time that must be served in prison for those who commit sexual offences against children and receive a “Sentence for Offenders of Particular Concern”. At the moment such offenders may be considered for release by the Parole Board after serving half their custodial term, but we will up that to two-thirds before the Board may look at the case. There exists in law a minimum custodial sentence for those who commit key offences, including a “second strike” for possession of a knife or offensive weapon and a “third strike” burglary of someone’s home. These are serious crimes that put the public at risk of both physical harm and deprivation of their hard-earned possessions, and of their wellbeing when it comes to safety at home.

But too often these types of offenders receive sentences below the statutory minimum, failing to properly punish or act as any kind of meaningful deterrent and protect the public. We are proposing therefore to modify the criteria for passing sentences below the statutory minimum, making it less likely that a court would depart from the minimum term.

The public want to know that custodial sentences for these sorts of crimes do what they say on the tin. They want to know that when serious and violent offenders go to prison, that’s where they’ll stay for as long as possible. These reforms will restore their faith that the system will keep dangerous criminals off our streets for longer.

Supervising offenders in the community

It is imperative that judges and magistrates have the power to impose short custodial sentences, where they are appropriate. I have seen first-hand on many occasions cases where this is the right and frankly the only sentencing option that is realistic for the court to hand down.

But protecting the public is also about making sure that we make smart interventions to prevent low-level and repeat offenders from going back and forth to prison, for short custodial sentences that hold little rehabilitative value for them.

Offenders in this category often live chaotic lifestyles, sometimes driven by drug and alcohol misuse, or poor mental health. Their backgrounds are often characterised by entrenched poverty, absent role models, and a lack of any decent education. This makes for bleak prospects and many offenders believe that they have few options but to get involved in criminality.

There is no doubt that they deserve punishment but, if we are to have any chance of turning their lives around – and in the process preventing crime – then we need to divert them towards lives that hold the promise of the things we all want from life – a place to call home, meaningful work, a future that’s better than the past.

If we’re going to offer offenders opportunities to work hard towards those things, then we must identify their individual needs and ensure that the sentencing toolkit is able to meet them.


High-Quality Pre-Sentence Reports

Pre-sentence reports should give crucial insights into the individual needs of offenders. These are often complex but with an accurate picture of the offender’s history, a court has the best opportunity to pass a sentence likely to drive better outcomes. More information being available also reduces the space for assumptions to creep in, which, too often, can be the entry point for stereotyping.

Evidence suggests that some offenders are sent for short custodial sentences without a PSR ever being produced. I know from my own experience as a practitioner that PSRs can be an invaluable tool, but two questions would always cross my mind in court: will a PSR even be available; and, perhaps more importantly, will it be of any use?

We will now pilot new ways of delivering high-quality PSRs, identifying the offenders who would benefit most.

Other alternatives to custody

At the same time, we will encourage courts to look at other alternatives to custody, such as. deferred sentencing. These can make use of services such as NHS Liaison and Diversion, to divert offenders away from criminal justice, into services that can support them to address mental health problems or substance misuse, with any breach of conditions imposed by the court potentially putting them into custody.

We will also simplify the out of court disposals framework so that low-level offenders can be dealt with quickly and effectively, by avoiding court and saving the taxpayer valuable money but still preventing ongoing crime. This will require a mixed framework of legislation, with community resolutions and conditional cautions used to modify behaviour.

In one of the most innovative ideas in this White Paper, we will also pilot 5 “problem-solving” courts, which will take a completely new approach to dealing with low-level offending. Utilising the most up to date evidence, these new courts will use elements such as judicial monitoring and graduated sanction incentives for those who have high needs or prolific offending histories, to look at innovative solutions to their offending without taking them into custody.


Empowering Probation

Something that will be vital to these reforms is a world-class probation service.

At a minimum, probation ‘manages’ offenders through their sentence, putting in place requirements from the courts as part of licence conditions and checking compliance. But when probation is at its very best, it goes much further. It is in the proactive ‘supervision’ of offenders, by dedicated probation staff, that lasting change can happen. By influencing the way sentencing works throughout the process, adjusting to the unique journey made by each offender under supervision, and having the professional discretion to tighten up restrictions, we can better protect the public and address underlying offender behaviour.

In order to do that, probation practitioners must be able to build meaningful relationships with offenders – to understand the risks they pose and their individual needs, so that they can put in place not just what is required by a court or licence, but what is most likely to drive successful rehabilitation in each case. Ultimately, that is the best way to reduce the number of victims.

In recent years, the probation service in England and Wales has come under significant scrutiny and last year we announced large-scale changes to improve the way the service operates, bringing the system under a unified National Probation Service, to be responsible for the delivery of community sentences, licences and other forms of post-sentence supervision.

Improving the way probation interacts with sentencing starts with how it informs the way sentences are handed down. Under the new system we propose, we will unify sentence management under the National Probation Service – growing confidence with sentencers, with whom they have a much closer relationship than they did under the previous Community Rehabilitation Company model, for example, to compile the crucial high-quality Pre-Sentence Reports that I talked about earlier.

The 12 new probation regions will create a unified approach, as well as working more closely with local justice partners, meaning they can commission and deliver solutions based truly on local needs. A new Dynamic Framework for rehabilitation will enable these services to be more easily delivered by voluntary and specialist organisations that can really get results – particularly for vulnerable offenders and those with complex needs. More than 160 organisations have already signed up to bid for contacts, of which 60% are from the voluntary sector – an excellent start.

At the true heart of a successful probation system is its practitioners. Something I saw time and again in my career was that a really good probation officer can make all the difference. Through the Workforce Programme we launched in January this year, we’ve set ourselves an ambitious target to recruit 1,000 new probation officers and to train probation staff to be better equipped for the modern demands of the criminal justice system.

Building relationships with offenders is critical to influencing rehabilitation, but we also want probation staff to have the powers necessary to do their jobs where other methods fail. We will now legislate to give probation officers greater flexibility to take action where an offenders’ rehabilitative needs are not being met or where they pose a risk to the public, meaning that they will be able to act swiftly, using their professional judgement to warn offenders about their behaviour and to advise courts to take enforcement action.

Taken together, these changes will empower probation services to be more dynamic in the way they operate and more useful at every point at which they interact with other criminal justice agencies – informing better sentencing and carrying them out to much better effect.


Reducing reoffending

Too often it is sadly the case that offenders find themselves back within the criminal justice system over and over again, with rates of reoffending remaining stubbornly and disappointingly high.

More than three-quarters of people convicted or cautioned in England and Wales already have at least one other criminal conviction or caution to their name. What this demonstrates is that the criminal justice system is too often unable to rehabilitate offenders the first time around. If we are to bring down crime rates and stop individuals from posing a menacing and continued threat to our communities, there are a number of options we must now consider.

As I have mentioned, technology already plays a role in sentencing but, for offenders who blight our neighbourhoods and burgle homes for example, it’s time we looked at how electronic monitoring and GPS tagging could better protect the public and drive offender behaviour change.

For some offenders who are stuck in cycles of crime, not being able to get a job can be both a major driver in their offending, but also a major barrier to their rehabilitation. Evidence suggests that offenders who find P45 employment in the twelve months after release from prison have one-year reoffending rates that are 6-9 percentage points lower than similar offenders who did not find employment. It doesn’t sound much but literally we are talking about thousands of crimes, thousands of lives, thousands of victims we can safeguard.

We want to now reduce the time period after which some sentences can be considered spent for the purposes of criminal records check. This will enable offenders who do not pose a risk to the public to finally get a job that could be a significant milestone on their route away from offending once and for all.

Prisons and probation must provide the opportunity for individuals to rehabilitate, so we will also deliver a Prison Education Service, focussing on getting them the skills and training to re-join society as contributing, law-abiding members – that helps to bring down crime too.


Robert Buckland QC MP

--oo00oo--

This from  Frances Crook, Howard League, via Twitter yesterday:-
"Good to hear the Justice Secretary promising a 'world class' probation service after the years of Grayling's failed restructuring. But, haven't we heard promises of world class services recently that have not delivered!" 
"We had a world beating probation service, so much so that people from across the world would come to copy and learn. Then it was dismantled and destroyed by Grayling. Now it is being rebuilt, but will not be properly independent, local or resourced. So not really world beating."
"Justice secretary announced problem solving courts, seven years after closing the problem solving court."

Wednesday, 16 September 2020

Cliche Irony

Remaining on the theme of sentencing and politics, I guess we need to note the irony of the Centre for Justice Innovation publishing its Smarter Community Sentences report last week calling for an end to cliches, just before Boris Johnson indulged in classic cliche gesture politics of tougher sentencing. Politicians have learnt that it's a popular card well worth playing especially if you're not very popular. This from the Law Society Gazette:-

Thinktank backs smarter community sentences to cut reoffending

The government has been urged to move away from the old clichés of tough and soft justice and focus more on making community sentences ahead of a sentencing white paper due to be published shortly.

The Centre for Justice Innovation says in its latest report that evidence clearly shows community sentences reduce re-offending more than short custodial sentences. However, there has been a 46% decline in their use over the past 10 years in England and Wales. Those advocating for short custodial sentences as opposed to community ones ‘are, in short, recommending that communities and victims suffer more from crime, not less’.

The centre believes the forthcoming white paper and ongoing work to reform the probation system provide the government with real opportunities to reform community sentencing, and highlights successul initiatives in other jurisdictions.

Describing unpaid work as the ‘backbone’ of community sentences, the report cites 2016 inspectorate findings that 35% of probationers had not started their unpaid work within two weeks of being sentenced. The centre says reforms in Scotland to unpaid work within their Community Payback Orders have focused on improving the speed with which placements are commenced and completed. The report recommends ‘short, swift’ unpaid work orders and empowering courts to set time limits.

The ministry and probation service should shorten the overall length of community sentences given to low-risk offenders. This would free up time for probation staff to concentrate on supervising higher-risk groups. The report says the ministry could learn lessons from Northern Ireland’s Enhanced Combination Order, which includes psychological assessments in respect of mental health issues and family support work. The offending rate of ECO participants in the six months following sentence was 17.3% compared to a 57.7% re-offending rate in the six months prior to sentencing.

Probation officers should be given powers over electronic tag monitoring, including the ability to vary hours. The report says in the Netherlands, the private sector provides monitoring equipment but public sector agencies are responsible for installation, maintenance and decision-making.

A smarter approach to tagging would enable victims to have a say on restrictions. In the US, GPS tagging technology has been used to give domestic violence victims more control over their own safety.

The centre, which has supported the expansion of family drug and alcohol courts, also suggests the government implement a problem-solving suspended sentence for those with substance misuse issues as an alternative to longer prison sentences. It says Scotland, Northern Ireland, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the US actively involve the courts in efforts to strengthen the accountability of community sentences.

Under the new suspended sentence, probationers would be required to comply with a 'demanding' order of treatment, supervision, monitoring and reparation. The same judge would regularly review progress. Non-compliance would result in prison.

The report concludes: 'We believe it is time to reform community sentences. In doing so, we need to move away from the clichés of the past about tough or soft justice.'

--oo00oo--

We believe it is time to reform community sentences. In doing so, we need to move away from the clichés of the past about tough or soft justice. Instead, the unification of the management of offenders within the National Probation Service and the forthcoming Sentencing White Paper are real opportunities for this Government to make community sentencing smarter.

Smarter community sentences mean giving probation practitioners the powers, the freedom and the flexibility to do their jobs. Smarter community sentences mean ensuring victims and communities who suffer from crime have more of a voice to see reparation done. Smarter community sentences mean leveraging the full resources of the Government, from the police, the courts, through to drug treatment and employment services and others to work with probation to deliver punishment and to give offenders the chance to turn around their lives.

Summary
 

Effective community sentences are a vital part of a justice system in which crime is proportionately punished, the harms it has caused repaired and the underlying factors that lead to offending addressed. Moreover, the evidence is clear that community sentences reduce re-offending more than short custodial sentences. Those who advocate for offenders to receive short custodial sentences as opposed to community sentences are, in short, recommending that communities and victims suffer from more crime, not less. 

Yet, there has been an 46% decline in the use of community sentences over the past ten years in England and Wales. At the same time, the quality of supervision delivered by our probation services has deteriorated. We believe it is time to reform community sentences. In doing so, we need to move away from the clichés of the past about tough or soft justice. Instead, the unification of the management of offenders within the National Probation Service and the forthcoming Sentencing White Paper are real opportunities for this Government to make community sentencing smarter. 

Smarter community sentences mean giving probation practitioners the powers, the freedom and the flexibility to do their jobs. Smarter community sentences mean ensuring victims and communities who suffer from crime have more of a voice to see reparation done. Smarter community sentences mean leveraging the full resources of the Government, from the police, the courts, through to drug treatment and employment services and others to work with probation to deliver punishment and to give offenders the chance to turn around their lives. 

Specifically, we urge the Government to create smarter community sentences by: 

• Improving the delivery of unpaid work by giving victims and communities a stronger voice in choosing what work is completed so they can see that justice is done, and by delivering standalone unpaid work orders swiftly, so probationers get the punishment done and can move on with their lives, and so judges can see their rulings carried out. 

• Improving the delivery of supervision by working briskly with low-risk probationers, thereby freeing up probation to both deliver high-quality community sentences and to work with police in the management of probationers who pose a higher risk of re-offending, through a reinvigorated Integrated Offender Management (IOM) strategy. 

• Improving rehabilitation so that people have the best shot at turning their lives around, by increasing the overall level of funding available for drug and mental health treatment for probationers in the community in the next Spending Review. 

• Improving information to victims about community sentences via the court reform programme so victims are informed about what is being done in their case. 

• Improving tagging of probationers by giving probation officers powers to flexibly vary the monitoring of tags without having to go back to court and by giving victims of domestic abuse a voice in setting the restrictions on perpetrators to better guarantee their safety and the safety of their children. 

• Improving collaboration between the court and probation to divert vulnerable offenders away from court where necessary, to use judges to monitor repeat offenders and be more responsive to their behaviour, and to change the enforcement system so it responds more swiftly to failure and better rewards compliance.

The value of community sentences 

Criminal justice systems around the world use community sentences to deliver punishment, reparation and rehabilitation. Punishment - inflicting some form of pain or loss (‘harsh treatment’) and the communication of disapproval (‘censure’), because doing so gives voice to the standards we honour as a community. Reparation to ensure that victims and communities that suffer see and experience offenders’ atonement for their wrongs. Rehabilitation because it embodies our belief in the possibility of redemption for rule-breakers and our commitment to keep communities safer by reducing reoffending. 

Community sentences play a vital role in keeping the public safe. There is considerable evidence that community sentences are an effective means of reducing re-offending. Previous studies by the Ministry of Justice in England and Wales, which control for the differences in the offender characteristics of those on community sentences and those receiving short prison sentences (those that are less than 12 months), show that the proven reoffending rate of offenders on community sentences is consistently lower than for those who had served short-term prison sentences. A 2019 study found that “sentencing offenders to short term custody with supervision on release was associated with higher proven reoffending than if they had instead received community orders and/or suspended sentence orders.” It also found that “the average number of re-offences per sentencing occasion was also higher following short term custodial sentences of less than 12 months than if a court order had instead been given (by around 65 re-offences more per 100 sentencing occasions).” Those who advocate for offenders to receive short custodial sentences as opposed to community sentences are, in short, recommending that communities and victims suffer from more crime, not less. 

The deterioration of community sentences 

However, in England and Wales, the quality of the supervision of community sentences has deteriorated over the past decade. In 2018, the Chief Inspector of Probation found that, due to the Coalition Government’s Transforming Rehabilitation reforms, which split probation provision into a public-sector National Probation Service (NPS) and privately-owned Community Rehabilitation Companies (CRCs), probation services “are failing to meet some of their performance targets… In too many cases, there is not enough purposeful activity… the probation profession has been diminished… There is a national shortage of qualified probation professionals, and too much reliance on unqualified or agency staff…. in the day-to-day work of probation professionals, there has been a drift away from practice informed by evidence.” 

Moreover, there are fewer community sentences being given out by courts. There has been a 46% decrease in the number of community sentences in England and Wales over the past ten years. Our research into why this has found that it is, in part, because the relationship between courts and probation has been buffeted by a number of reforms in the past six years, most notably the split of probation, the underinvestment in probation by the CRCs, and the disruptions caused by court closures and court service efficiency reforms. 

The reality of community sentences Community sentences provide proportionate punishment for lower level offending through restrictions of liberty like curfews and electronic monitoring. They can provide reparation through things like unpaid work and restorative justice. They can also address the underlying issues behind offending, like drug addiction, through supervised community drug treatment. Yet these purposes of punishment, reparation and rehabilitation are not clean and separable: in practice, community sentences are a mixture of all three. Probationers can often feel that parts of community sentences that are intended to be rehabilitative are intrusive, even painful, while others experience ‘punitive’ sanctions such as unpaid work as motivating and even enjoyable. It is also worth remembering, for example, that individuals serving a community sentence can experience additional pains, such as restrictions on their ability to travel abroad, or the impact on their lives of a criminal record on their employment. These punishments, which often get forgotten in discussions about “the toughness” of community sentences, can often be experienced as far greater hardships than the terms of the court order itself. 

This means that the reality of community sentences as experienced by probationers is often different from what is intended by judges and lawmakers, and what is expected and imagined by the public. Moreover, probationers are not a homogenous group: community sentences are given to a wide spectrum of individuals, from affluent motorists who repeatedly speed to homeless people with complex substance abuse and mental health needs. Strengthening community sentences, therefore, requires us to grapple with the complex realities of how probation functions in practice.

Monday, 14 September 2020

Tough On Crime Again

Politicians, especially those in trouble, just can't avoid the temptation of using the populist 'tough on crime' card and Boris Johnson is in a great deal of trouble. Here's Rob Allen's take on this particular No 10 distraction tactic:-   

The Impulse to Punish

Depressing if predictable trailing of the forthcoming Sentencing White Paper today, with Justice Secretary Robert Buckland telling Sun readers “it’s time for a tougher criminal justice system” and the Prime Minister writing in the Express that “some individuals are so dangerous or their crimes so abhorrent that they should never be released”.

Some comfort I suppose that after explaining his plans to lower from 21 to 18 the age at which people convicted of murder will be able to be sentenced to spend their whole life in prison, Johnson clarified that he wasn’t “talking about permanently locking up young people who make teenage mistakes or commit youthful indiscretions”. Thanks for that. And maybe some promise in his view that “we need more and better rehabilitation behind bars, improved monitoring of and support for ex-prisoners and more effective non-custodial sentences for low-risk offenders”. But all in all while the numbers directly affected by his draconian measures may be relatively small, there’s a real risk of an inflationary knock on effect on sentencing levels for less grave crimes.

It’s possible that courts may re calibrate their sentences downwards in the wider range of cases where two thirds rather than half will be spent inside. But for some reason I’ve never understood, they are not supposed to take too much account of what a sentence means in practice. More likely that some will take their lead from Johnson’s idea that public protection should be the single most important principle of sentencing and impose yet longer terms. Of course, public protection is important but the experience of the IPP sentence – widely acknowledged to be basically unjust -should serve as a warning against ignoring other purposes of sentencing.

Johnson may be surprised to know that he has some support in international law. The Nelson Mandela Rules say that the purposes of a sentence of imprisonment are primarily to protect society against crime and to reduce recidivism. They go on to say that those purposes can be achieved only if the period of imprisonment is used to ensure, so far as possible, the reintegration of such persons into society upon release so that they can lead a law-abiding and self-supporting life. And that's a problem.

Last week’s Public Accounts Committee Report showed the government’s abject failure to make progress on David Cameron’s 2016 vision of “a modern, more effective, truly twenty-first century prison system." Given the financial constraints facing the government in coming years its hard to see much in the future. We have heard about better rehabilitation in prisons for a decade but it seems much less capable of being delivered than are longer sentences.

Maybe the White Paper will have something more positive to say but I am not holding my breath. As Nietzsche said, “ Mistrust all in whom the impulse to punish is powerful".

Rob Allen

Sunday, 13 September 2020

Carrying On

Unless something extraordinary happens later today, at some point a visitor to this corner of the world wide web will lift us over the line representing the seven millionth 'hit'. Quite a milestone for any publishing endeavour I think, it just takes longer nowadays for all sorts of reasons that will be very well-understood by those connected to the probation world. 

Readership and contributors have been declining over recent years, but here's a funny thing - if I don't publish anything, we tick over with about a thousand to fifteen hundred 'hits' daily, but it rockets to between three and five thousand if anything kicks off. It still seems to fill a need and is possibly some kind of comfort blanket, especially during troubled times. 

Certainly this appeared to be the case during the early days of lockdown and sadly is proving to be the case as we inevitably head into a new period of 'shafting' brought about by TR2:-
"The NPS will not match all CRC job roles, as some jobs do not exist in the NPS and some CRC qualification criteria are insufficient."
"My reading is that "Employment protections" apply for those transferring to NPS only. HMPPS cannot possibly offer a guarantee for those poor souls cast adrift who are deemed unsuitable, unworthy, not in the clique, unable to pass vetting, etc. Back to 2015/6 & throwing staff under the privateer bus."
"Stories of staff being marched out of offices. Others unable to apply for other jobs like OM, AP and OMiC. All unions will do is ask for transfer into a non-frontline role. Usually it’s due to past convictions (both major and minor) already on DBS, links to family members with criminal records (or under investigation) and bad credit. Can’t believe unions didn’t oppose vetting."
This was always likely to happen as a result of vetting and civil service command and control and was certainly flagged-up and discussed on here ages ago. We all know CRCs made use of volunteers, many of whom were former or even current clients and a significant number were put on the payroll. HMPPS and NPS don't believe in volunteers and vetting makes it almost impossible for any employee with 'lived experience' to transfer over. In essence a disgrace going against as it does the very essence of probation's ethos. 

People who know me are aware I often say 'it's all been said'. Nobody likes repetition and surely there's nothing new to cover? Especially when contributions dry up, I've considered packing it in many times, but I've come to appreciate it's actually quite hard to do when something has become such a significant part of your life for so long. Each time I tend to think I'll just see us through this crisis and then stop. 

Thing is, we seem to have those fairly regularly and deep down I still want to see probation regain its identity and independence. I guess whist ever I'm speaking to like-minded refuseniks, dissidents, contrarians and remaining 'old-timers', we carry on.    

In the very early days I offered a bottle of a favourite tipple to any person providing screenshot evidence of significant milestones and I have fond memories of hand-delivering a litre of gin to a very keen reader in Newcastle several times! They may still be reading, but the offer remains open to all, Covid-19 and appropriate social-distancing permitting. 

Thanks for being part of the journey and making the blog what it is. Take care, stay safe look out for each other and cheers! 

Saturday, 12 September 2020

Ballot Background

Yesterday's Napo mailout gave news of a ballot being held for CRC staff on the Collective Agreement to support the transfer of staff to the NPS or a provider of Dynamic Services. This is the supporting material referred to in that communication:-

A ballot for Napo CRC members
10th - 30th September 2020


Probation Reform -the story so far

Napo members have been at the forefront of their unions long running campaign to restore all Probation services to public ownership and control. The historic U-turn in Government policy announced by the Secretary of State for Justice on 11TH June followed the previous decision last year that 80% of probation work would transfer to the National Probation Service.

While the 2019 announcement of partial unification was welcomed at the time, Napo have maintained pressure in and outside of Parliament to press for the total reunification of Probation to bring certainty over the future of the service. Ministers have taken a courageous decision to fully reverse the disastrous Transforming Rehabilitation reforms that were implemented in 2014 and which we opposed from the start. These have also been widely and continuously criticised by politicians, the Justice Select Committee and HM Inspector of Probation. Reunification of the service also signals the early termination date for the existing Community Rehabilitation Company (CRC) contracts in June 2021. These contracts were expected to last for at least a decade and despite the best efforts of staff working within the system they have failed to deliver the promised service improvements and innovations.

This has been an immensely difficult time for all Probation staff, and especially those who have been working tirelessly against the odds to maintain services in the private sector. Our members have had to contend with unrealistic workloads, a fragmentation of services and, in some cases, seriously dangerous operational models which contributed to the demise of the former Working Links CRC in February 2019.

The new plans will see the National Probation Service take full responsibility for Sentence Management, Unpaid Work and Programme delivery with Dynamic Framework (DF) Providers being commissioned to offer additional support services. This is similar to the arrangements that existed under many of the former Probation Trusts prior to the Transforming Rehabilitation reforms.

Why this ballot is taking place - an overview of the Probation Reform negotiations

Napo negotiators were quick to move to the next stage in our campaign and engage with senior HMPPS and NPS leaders on the immediate challenges before us. These included the transfer of staff in June next year, the need to start to repair the massive damage suffered by the service and the need to achieve some short term stability. Just as important has been the re-opening of the debate about the long term future of probation where over the recent years we have mapped out our vision for the future of Probation:

  • Fully unified service provision delivered within the public sector and never for profit
  • Removal of Probation from the civil service and release from the prison dominated culture which means that Probation is the forgotten ‘P’ in HMPPS
  • A service built on evidence based practice
  • A service rooted in the local community and partnering with local specialist providers
Negotiations on the Probation Reform programme have actually been taking place for just over a year. The talks have covered the earlier decision to transfer Sentence Management work and staff from the Wales CRC to the NPS (which took place last December), the announcement in May 2019 that all Sentence Management would transfer to the NPS, and the subsequent decision in 2020 that Unpaid Work and Programmes would also be brought back into public control and ownership in June 2021.

Our most recent work has included finalising a new Staff Transfer and Protections Agreement to support the transition, a new Voluntary Redundancy /Voluntary Severance scheme, and the terms and conditions for staff transferring into the NPS. Napo’s ideal outcome would have been to see all directly employed CRC staff transferred into the NPS especially in light of the continuing staff shortages but this is not possible because in legal terms the principle is that the workers transfer with the work they do. We have been consulted on the assignment process that is being used to ensure this principle is adhered to.

Assignment

The CRCs have until the end of September to complete the assignment process which includes an appeal stage. All directly employed CRC staff will transfer to either NPS or a Dynamic Framework (DF) provider. They can object to the transfer but this will have the effect of ending their employment. Numbers are not yet certain but early estimates suggest that there are likely to be a very small number of staff transferring to DF providers. This will apply to those staff where their current role entails 50% or more of their time providing services such as Education, Training and Employment (ETE), accommodation and wellbeing support.

It is the role and not the person which is assigned, if a member of CRC staff moves to a new role before the date of transfer, that can change their assignment. For example, if they are currently in a role assigned to DF and they move to a role assigned to NPS they will transfer to NPS. Each CRC will (on HMPPS instruction) set a date after which no more recruitment (or level moves) is allowable. This is usually around 6 months prior to the transfer.

Napo Officials are encouraging CRC owners to do all that they can to enable their staff to move to their preferred future employer. This is especially important if their current CRC employer is successful in bidding for DF services and need staff who are sufficiently motivated to work for them. Napo are also maintaining pressure on CRC employers to ensure that their staff are paid the equivalent of existing NPS pay bands by the time of transfer to the NPS or DF provider.

The Framework for Transfer to the NPS or a DF provider

There is an important distinction between the transfer processes to the NPS or a DF provider. The CRC to NPS transfer is a Staff Transfer Scheme under COSOP (the code of practice governing transfers of staff into the public sector). The staff transfer scheme will include the Staff Transfer and Protections Agreement (STAP) and if CRC members agree to it then transferees to the NPS will be harmonised to new terms and conditions and the NPS pay scales that exist at date of their transfer. If the agreement is rejected, then staff transferring into the NPS (and those staff in NPS Wales who transferred prior to the end of the STAP negotiations) will do so with their existing CRC terms.

In the case of a CRC staff transfer to a DF provider, this will take place under the TUPE regulations because it is a transfer of a private sector employee to a third sector or private sector employer. There is case law to support this position. This means that those transferring to a DF provider will have their existing CRC terms and conditions protected.
Employment protections

Napo and our sister unions have secured a commitment from HMPPS to no compulsory redundancies for two years from the date of transfer and enhanced voluntary redundancy/severance terms if these should be necessary for the same period of time.