Thursday, 20 June 2019

In Search of the Probation Narrative

I've been away for a few days and been somewhat distracted and inattentive. Despite lots going on and the whole future of probation up in the air once more, it seems mightily quiet, so I thought I'd go in search of the narrative:-  

We have a new minister, refusing to use 'probation' in his title, telling Bob Neill and the Justice Committee they are misguided in thinking TR was a disaster:-

"To condemn TR out of hand and say that it was a failure is unfair to many aspects of it: for example, the increase in the overall number of people supervised; some of the really good projects that we saw in the south-east relating to stalking; and the work done on unpaid work requirements. I do not think it would be fair to write off the past four or five years as a blind alley, because it certainly was not. A lot of what we have learned from that will be taken forward in the new model, but the end of the division between serious offences and less serious offences will help us, most notably not just with overall accountability but with the workload of probation officers. Perhaps we can explore that as we go into questions."

--oo00oo--

We have those cunning MoJ spin doctors attempting to push some good news stories to deflect attention:-

'Lifeline' community treatment pilots to steer offenders away from crime

Vulnerable offenders in the criminal justice system will be offered targeted treatment under new plans designed to boost rehabilitation and reduce re-offending announced by the government today (20 June 2019). Where appropriate, through the new pilots more offenders will be diverted towards community sentences in where they will receive treatment for mental health, drug or alcohol issues, often deemed to be the root cause of offending behaviour.

Pilots have already seen an almost 250% increase in those referred for mental health treatment within 18 months and a higher rate of compliance with the terms of an order, just 8% failed to comply with their requirements. The approach will now be rolled out to new sites in London and Greater Manchester.

This focus on ensuring people get the right care, at the right time, in the right setting will be integral to the forthcoming Health and Justice Plan, announced by Health Secretary Matt Hancock and Justice Secretary David Gauke today. This comes 10 years on from the landmark Bradley Report, which set out a comprehensive plan to reduce reoffending and improve public health for vulnerable offenders.

Justice Secretary David Gauke said:

"Providing targeted, tailored and timely mental health and addiction treatment for vulnerable offenders across the country will help cut reoffending - saving taxpayers’ money and making our communities safer. We will support agencies across health and justice to work more closely together to ensure offenders have the right support and to build greater confidence in community sentences. This is just the start of our shared vision to reshape offender health and strengthen community sentences, ultimately improving rehabilitation and breaking the cycle of offending."

Health Secretary Matt Hancock:

"Addressing prisoners’ physical and mental health needs early on can help tackle the root cause of their criminality and steer them away from the path of reoffending. It is crucial the health and justice systems work together to provide the best possible care for prisoners. Today’s announcements demonstrate our commitment to giving people the support and treatment they need to live healthy lives in prison and reintegrate into society when the time comes."

--oo00oo--

And make no mistake, the MoJ has to come up with something positive to try and counter their tendency to lie, cheat and bully - hardly a comforting prospect for a 'reunified' probation service under civil service control. This from the Guardian:-

Bullied bisexual prison officer unlikely to work again, tribunal finds

A bisexual prison officer is unlikely to ever work again because the harassment and discrimination he suffered at work has permanently damaged his health, an employment tribunal has found.

In two judgments, it was revealed that Ben Plaistow, 41, is likely to receive an exceptionally high compensation payout when his case is finally settled later this year, not only because of the campaign of bullying and harassment his colleagues at HMP Woodhill in Milton Keynes conducted against him during his two years of employment there, but also because of a litany of failings by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ), including the forging of documents submitted to the tribunal.

“Perhaps most seriously, given the identity of the respondent [the MoJ], is the forgery by late production and backdating of documents designed to ‘plug gaps’,” the tribunal ruling states. It also refers to “corruption of documents by conflation, amendment or post-dated creation” and said the MoJ’s failings go “beyond error”. The colleagues were found to have engaged in a “campaign of victimisation” against Plaistow, with their conduct found to be “vexatious, disruptive and unreasonable”.

Government lawyers involved in the case were also criticised for failing to demonstrate appropriate diligence and were accused of having “blindly” followed instructions from their MoJ colleagues.

The judge, Michael Ord, sitting with two lay members in an employment tribunal in Cambridge, previously found that Plaistow experienced a campaign of direct discrimination and harassment because of his sexuality, and was victimised and unfairly dismissed because he complained about what took place. 
He was subjected to a catalogue of abuse including being called “poof”, “gay” and “vermin”, was pushed and slapped, and had a bottle of water squirted in his face.

Plaistow was hired as a prison officer at HMP Woodhill in 2014 and was fired two years later after he was accused of gross misconduct. In December 2015, he was alleged to have used unnecessary force on a prisoner while breaking up a fight. The incident led to his suspension and subsequent dismissal. However, the tribunal heard he did not use unnecessary force. This was backed up by CCTV footage and witness testimony from the prisoner, who acknowledged he was at fault.

Expert medical reports found that Plaistow, who was well-regarded by both the prison service and prisoners, was highly unlikely to ever work again. He has been diagnosed with PTSD, moderate psychological damage and paranoia as a result of “lengthy failings” by the prison service. One doctor who assessed him found his condition to be “chronic and permanent”.

The payout he eventually receives will be based on a career-long loss of earnings; Plaistow had hoped to work until the age of 68, so is likely to have lost 27 years of his working life. Final calculations are still being worked out and will include the loss of his £31,660 a year net salary since his dismissal and into the future, as well as the loss of his pension.

As well as awarding him £41,000 for injury to feelings, the top end of the top band in this category, the tribunal has also awarded him £15,000 aggravated damages and £8,000 exemplary damages. These damages are only awarded in rare cases. Aggravated damages are given when the employer’s conduct towards the victim has been humiliating and malicious and exemplary damages are a sign of great disapproval of the employer’s conduct.

The tribunal found that the MoJ’s “conduct as an arm of the state in relation to this case has been unacceptable”. The tribunal raised further concerns about the training the MoJ promised to provide following the case, which it found to be “wholly unconnected” to the substance of the judgment, relating to discrimination and harassment based on sexual orientation.

“No steps have been taken at management level as to identification and eradication of such conduct amongst staff,” the tribunal heard. Until the MoJ was approached about the investigation by Plaistow’s lawyers, it had “taken no steps whatsoever to investigate the serious findings and matters of concern”, the tribunal found.

The government department was criticised by the tribunal for not being able to say if anyone had been suspended pending an investigation or whether any steps had been taken to prevent officials from colluding during the investigation.

An MoJ spokesperson said: “We do not tolerate any kind of discrimination in our prisons and take action to make sure all staff are treated appropriately and fairly. A new staff network, ‘pride in prison and probation’, was set up in 2016 to support workplace equality and now has 5,000 members. We have noted the judge’s decision and are considering next steps, and a separate internal review is ongoing.”

--oo00oo--

Of course there is the on-going Employment Tribunal that tends to confirm the MoJ's love of secrecy in trying to bully and silence:-

An Academic Says She Was Bullied At The Ministry Of Justice After Revealing It Was Running A Programme That Made Sex Offenders More Likely To Reoffend

An academic whose research revealed that the Ministry of Justice’s treatment of sex offenders in prison might actually increase their chance of reoffending is suing the department. She says she was bullied out of her job after whistleblowing about the results. Dr Kathryn Hopkins worked as a researcher in the MoJ’s analytical services department. Her study of the controversial Sex Offender Treatment Programme (SOTP) suggested that five years on from release, prisoners who had been on the programme were more likely to commit a sexual offence again.


--oo00oo--

Then we have the saga of HM Probation Inspectorate continuing to find 'excellent' leadership everywhere in the CRCs, but sadly hand-in-hand with poor performance:-

"Although inspectors praised Kent, Surrey and Sussex CRC’s commitment to innovation and strong leadership, they did have concerns about the quality of some case supervision and its ‘Through the Gate’ work with offenders leaving prison. There is a widespread shortage of qualified probation officers and the CRC has found it particularly difficult to recruit and retain staff because of its proximity to London. The CRC has decided to tackle the problem by leading the development of a new apprenticeship scheme to offer people a different route into the sector. If the scheme is successful, it could be rolled out nationally."

When is HMI going to admit their inspection methodology must be seriously flawed, or are the cynics correct in assuming there must be some other policy aim at work here? 

--oo00oo--

We have the MoJ's proposed new model for probation containing such meaningless crap as this:- 

68. A Regional Co-ordination Function is predicated on the Dynamic Framework and the regional oversight of multiple contracts delivered on a regional and sub-regional footprint. Working in an Intelligent Customer capacity, it will actively co-ordinate supply and demand to ensure the Responsible Officer can have access to the right services at the right time. 

69. The Dynamic Framework will be the means for NPS regions to access services for offenders both on community orders and those supervised on licence in the community, with the ambition that some services will eventually reach into the pre-release phases of sentence in England, offering Through-the-Gate. The Dynamic Framework will also be the anticipated sourcing vehicle for spending the Regional Outcomes Fund if appropriate. 

70. The Dynamic Framework also provides accessibility for a range of different commissioning bodies, HM Prisons, Regional Authorities for Probation, HMPPS Wales, Welsh Government, PCCs, MOPAC and GMCA, Local Authorities, etc. It should be noted that commissioning bodies other than the Authority (HM Prisons, Regional Authorities and HMPPS Wales) can also buy services directly from the Framework or via co-commissioning arrangements with the Authority. The Framework will also be used to award both contracts and grants.

--oo00oo--

With the government stubbornly wedded to still keeping a privatised chunk of probation in the mix, charities and other third sector players need to be mindful they got their fingers seriously burnt under TR and lost a lot of money. The CivilSociety website highlights other worrying effects of the disastrous policy:-    

Government probation reform led to 50 per cent drop in charity grant funding, says report  

The government’s most recent overhaul of the probation system may have led to a 50 per cent drop in grants from independent funders, according to a new report. Charity sector thinktank, NPC's new report, Independent, Effective, Humane, shows that independent grant funding for probation charities dropped from £37.1m to £18.4m from 2013 to 2014, the same time as the government’s Transforming Rehabilitation programme was introduced. 

The report says the figures suggest “funders may respond directly to policy upheaval—by pausing their funding”. It says grant funding levels have since recovered but warns: “With renewed uncertainty about the future of probation services in 2019, charities need commitment and stability from funders.” 

The report says charities that are involved in probation services are heavily reliant on independent grants, with smaller, specialist organisations getting about two-thirds of their funding this way. It says this is because the public “don’t often give to criminal justice charities” and the government is increasingly funding through contracts instead. And the report says probation charities are concerned that independent funders are being put off funding probation services because they are worried “their grants are propping up a harmful prison system”. It says they are also concerned about charities ability to access service users in prison, and the risk of subsidising government contracts or private sector profits. 

An anonymous grant-making trust is quoted in the report as saying: 

“We have moved away from funding work in prison to work in the community with people who are at risk of offending or reoffending. “When we do due diligence, charities say that our grant might subsidise government contracts. We understand how hard it is for charities—they are between a rock and a hard place—but it just isn’t acceptable to our trustees.” 

Following a highly critical report on the government’s £900m Transforming Rehabilitation programme by the chief inspector of probation last year, the Ministry of Justice announced its decision to end current probation contracts early and consider a new model for probation from 2020 onwards.  

--oo00oo--

Finally, in trying to speculate where we might usefully look in terms of what the hell the probation narrative currently is, I'll end with some House of Lords exchanges from the 16th May, the day when the infamous government 'u-turn' was announced:-

Baroness Chakrabarti Shadow Attorney General

My Lords, I am incredibly grateful to the Minister for repeating the Statement. This is a welcome U-turn on a disastrous probation policy—but what a mess, what an absolute mess. I feel the need to probe the underlying thinking a little further to ensure that lessons are truly being learned in the Government. Those of us on these Benches have real constitutional concerns, and concerns about accountability for public safety in relation to privatising the criminal justice system.

Today’s U-turn, a necessary first step to cleaning up the probation mess, comes only after hundreds of millions of pounds have been squandered propping up failing private companies, and public safety has been put directly at risk as a result. So I must probe the Minister on the thinking for the future and the proportion of these funds that are to be preferred towards private companies as opposed to voluntary bodies and social enterprises. This is crucial to understanding whether failing outsourcing giants, such as G4S and Sodexo, are going to be offered a way back into the probation system.

Lord Dholakia Co-Deputy Leader of the Liberal Democrat Peers

My Lords, I thank the Minister for repeating the Statement. All of us think that it has been a long time coming and it is right that we should broadly welcome the thrust of the Government’s intention to reorganise this service.

I take our share of the blame as part of the coalition Government, during which we supported some of the reforms of the National Probation Service in 2014. Some of the principles of these reforms were very sound when they were introduced. It was right that supervision was available for at least the first year when inmates leave prison. It was important to provide through-the-gate services, so that people can have a place to live as well as continuity of training and treatment between prison and the community. To do all this, it was vital that voluntary organisations working in the criminal justice field were fully involved.

Mr Grayling has bungled and underfunded contracts so badly that his reforms failed to achieve these objectives. No wonder it is estimated that these botched reforms have cost the taxpayer more than £500 million, according to the National Audit Office. He is the most unfortunate Minister whose record is dismal, and it is a surprise that he has lasted so long, even at the Department for Transport at this stage.

We need some guarantees to ensure that the probation service is not let down again. Who is examining the existing case load of probation officers? What further resources are available to make them more effective? Is there any way of tying probation resources to the rise in the number of prisoners in our establishments? Is there some way of ensuring that more incarceration of prisoners will effectively mean more work for the probation service? A good many well-trained but disillusioned probation officers have left the service in the last few years. What is being done to bring them back into probation work?

The Minister has just announced a new targeted innovation fund. What share will voluntary organisations have in such funds in order to make the probation service more effective? The new targeted innovation fund ought to make sure that such organisations are not locked out. Of course reforms are necessary, but we should never lose sight of the fact that when the state incarcerates prisoners, it takes full responsibility for each individual. We would do well, in very difficult times, to say to ourselves that if we lose that responsibility we will lose control of our criminal justice system.

Lord Keen of Elie The Advocate-General for Scotland, Lords Spokesperson (Ministry of Justice)

My Lords, I thank the noble Lords for their contributions. I do not accept the characterisation of these matters advanced by the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti. Indeed, as I have often observed in the past, the gross overstatement of an argument simply diminishes it in the ears of hearers.

The position is that we have learned lessons over the past few years from the way in which probation was set up and carried through, as between the National Probation Service and the CRCs. Indeed, one of the difficulties that emerged arose not out of money being used to prop up CRCs, or money being taken from the taxpayer for the benefit of CRCs, but because the Government was actually too successful in negotiating the commercial terms of the CRC contracts, with the result that the CRCs made persistent losses on these contracts of such magnitude that they began to withdraw from the quality of service they should have provided in the first place. That created very real difficulties, and we accept that. We actually had to go to the CRCs and try to renegotiate in order to keep them on a reasonable path of provision.

One consequence of that has been that, for example, CRCs have paid out more than £9 million in respect of what are called service credits—which are, for them, service debits; they are credits to the taxpayer but debits to the shareholders of these companies—because of their failure to reach performance targets. So we responded to the very real difficulties that emerged in that context.

We are now developing a system whereby we will have the probation service on a regional basis. These regions will be coterminous with the PCCs, in the hope that, going forward, there will be greater linkage between the PCCs and the probation service. We will have a director-general of probation, which I think accords with a recommendation that has just been made in the interim report issued today by the noble Lord, Lord Ramsbotham, who was commissioned by the noble Baroness’s honourable friend, who I believe continues to be the shadow Secretary of State for Justice, Richard Burgon MP, who asked the noble Lord to look at this.

On the question of U-turning on nationalisation, I will quote from the interim report of the noble Lord, Lord Ramsbotham. He says:

“There is no doubt that the private sector has brought rigour to the oversight of probation. The best of them explained how they had introduced a forward-looking culture of delivering more with less, which must have relevance for the future, plus a better understanding of the relationship between cost and delivery”.

We are seeking to build on those benefits, appreciating that there were also deficits in the way in which CRCs delivered at the end of the day.

To take up the particular point raised by the noble Lord, Lord Dholakia, we are concerned to ensure that the voluntary sector has access to these contracts going forward. Indeed, one of the difficulties that emerged with CRCs was that, as they fell into greater financial difficulty, they drew back from their engagement with the voluntary sector and we therefore lost the immense benefit of that sector’s involvement in the probation service.

Taking this forward, we hope to re-establish clear, unambiguous faith in—for example—non-custodial sentences so that the courts can have more confidence in putting those forward and thereby, touching again on a point made by the noble Lord, relieve pressure on the prison system itself by virtue of an improved probation service.

Lord Judd Labour

My Lords, does the Minister not agree that in its earlier chapters the probation service attained an outstanding reputation and public confidence because of the quality, wisdom, experience and insight of its staff? That is crucial to the operation. Does he not also agree that, while there may be an argument about what happened in the last phase, there is very little doubt that, among many people, its reputation seemed to be in jeopardy as short cuts were taken and that there was a perception that the probation service had become an extension of the custodial system and had rather lost the purpose it was there to fulfil? Does he not therefore agree that, whatever happens—and we wish the new system well—commitment, quality of staff and the relationship and friendships that have to be built up between the officers and the people with whom they are dealing will be absolutely crucial?

Lord Keen of Elie The Advocate-General for Scotland, Lords Spokesperson (Ministry of Justice)

My Lords, I without hesitation and qualification commend the professionalism, integrity and ability of the staff within the probation service. That is why we are intent on implementing a statutory professional regulatory framework that will recognise the degree of professionalism that they have exhibited and continue to exhibit in the discharge of their demanding functions. The National Probation Service has extended its staff in recent years by about 500, and is bringing on further training of such staff. Going forward, we have appreciated the need to ensure consistency in the delivery of probation services and are not looking back to the prior form in which probation was delivered. When there were 35 probation trusts operating, with commendable staff, there were 35 ways of doing things. We have found that it is far better to try to identify a single, unified way of doing things for the entire probation service.

Lord Ramsbotham Crossbench

My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for quoting the interim report that I was required to write by the Shadow Minister for Justice. I note that he quoted my paragraph saying that not all had been lost by the community rehabilitation companies and citing the economic rigour that they had to bring to their role. Perhaps I might ask Minister two questions. First, he will have noted that the Justice Select Committee and the Public Accounts Committee—plus the National Audit Office and Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Probation—issued very critical reports of the whole transforming rehabilitation process. They said that the procedure had been rushed and unpiloted. Are the new proposals again to be rushed through unpiloted? Secondly, will the 11 areas correspond to the existing 11 government regions within which the police and crime commissioners operate, or will we have yet another division? By adopting Department for Work and Pensions boundaries, Transforming Rehabilitation completely crossed every single common-sense boundary that had been followed by the probation service for years.

Lord Keen of Elie The Advocate-General for Scotland, Lords Spokesperson (Ministry of Justice)

I am obliged to the noble Lord and welcome the fact that he has given consideration to these issues and is able to contribute to this matter with his interim report. No doubt he may take that further. On his second point, I had mentioned that the 11 proposed areas will be coterminous with PCC regions. There are more than 11 PCCs, of course, but we will ensure that the regions are coterminous so that we can develop the appropriate relationships between the PCCs and the NPS in that context. It is certainly not our intention for this to be rushed. I would mention two points: first, although the existing CRC contracts, as adjusted, run to the end of 2020, we have the ability to extend them to the spring of 2021 to have time to bring in these reforms; and, secondly, there will be a pilot in some sense because the model we are now adopting is the one we had already decided to adopt for Wales, which will be implemented from 2019. We will be able to see how this actually operates in practice before we proceed further with the rollout across the rest of England.


--oo00oo--

I love this bit:-

"When there were 35 probation trusts operating, with commendable staff, there were 35 ways of doing things. We have found that it is far better to try to identify a single, unified way of doing things for the entire probation service."

MoJ Give Evidence 2

Here we have another chunk of the recent dialogue with the Justice Committee and a bit more 'granularity':-

Q406 Victoria Prentis: It occurs to me that as part of this session I should declare that I am a trustee of Nacro and a non-practising barrister. 


You have already talked about the transition strategy. Is that part of a wider transition strategy for ensuring that there is continuous support? 

Amy Rees: The straightforward answer is absolutely. We are conscious that we now need to get to the end of the contractual period, which is likely, as Jim has just said, to be spring 2021, with everything in the best shape possible. We are going to do that in three ways: first, ongoing contract management that will continue throughout the period and is well understood; secondly, the benefit of what happened in Working Links is that we now have tried and tested contingency plans if we cannot make it to the end with any particular provider through unforeseen circumstances; and, thirdly, there will be active dialogue with the current providers about how we can best manage the transition. That is all on the CRC side of the house; there is also quite a lot we will need to do on the NPS side of the house to be ready. We are starting that work and planning now. 

Q407 Victoria Prentis: How are you going to incentivise the CRC companies to keep up the work? 

Amy Rees: First, our contractual terms are very clear about what they are obliged to do. Secondly, as we have just discussed, we have quite a lot of stabilisation measures to try to make a stable business for them going forward. In addition, we are working closely with them on how we can manage transition so that it is beneficial to both sides; and we are in active discussion, as you would expect, with trade unions about how we manage the change for the staff who will be affected. 

Q408 Bambos Charalambous: I have two points, the first of which is about the contracts. The contracts were very badly drafted in the beginning, which led to lots of problems. Has any lesson been learned from the procurement process? I think it was rushed through and that has led to untold problems now. 

Robert Buckland: Mr Charalambous, you reiterate and perhaps develop some of the points we have already discussed. I have already dealt with some of the baseline assumptions made about the type of cases that were going to be coming through the system, and the fact that we ended up with more serious offences that had to be dealt with by the NPS. That meant that fewer less serious cases would have been dealt with by the CRCs. We were also making sure that there was a full and proper understanding of the need for as stable a staff base as possible. My experience of the probation service is that we should encourage as much longevity of service and experience as possible. Nothing is better than experience, bearing in mind that we are dealing with a cohort of individuals who display all sorts of challenges. One learns from experience how to deal with them. 

More fundamentally, there is the role of probation staff and the wider public understanding of the importance of their role. I want to make sure that, in future, probation officers are valued by everybody as much as they are by people in this room and those of us who have worked with them, and that their vital role is enhanced and understood. That aspect of the reforms is going to be really important. 

To take your point, as you have heard from my officials, we are taking great care with any assumptions that are made about the future, but the big advantage of this change is that we will no longer have the division between serious and non-serious; we will have an overall framework with the regional model. Let us take an individual probation officer, for example. The inspectorate said that a caseload of more than 60 is too much. We are already mindful of that and want to help probation officers manage a lower caseload and a wider range of offences, not just all serious offences. A lot of NPS officers have had to deal with quite a serious diet of heavy cases. It is right to level that out so that there is a mixed caseload, to acknowledge the fact that it can take a very heavy toll when you are dealing with complex and challenging individuals. That wider understanding of the context is very much part of how we are going to develop the process. I take on board your comments. I think that this time, with the timescale we are talking about, we can and will do better. 

Amy Rees: TR was certainly an ambitious and innovative reform, and we acknowledge that there were two particular areas of complexity that will not exist in the new model. The first, as the Minister said, is that there will not be split offender management. That was quite difficult to contract for. We will not have to contract for offender management, which was a complicated and tricky thing to do. 

The other area was the inclusion of payment by results, which, as you can appreciate, was also a pretty tricky thing to try to contract for. We will not be doing that in the new model, so we are certainly looking to simplify the new contracts that we will be signing with new providers. 

Q409 Chair: It seems to be accepted in light of experience that payment by results was not the right model for probation. 

Amy Rees: We would certainly acknowledge that PBR added a massive level of complexity and risk that we and providers have been learning about in reality. 

Q410 Chair: You are not going to pursue it anyway; that is understood. Ms Crozier, turning to the relationship with the workforce, they have been through a good deal of upheaval and probably need some stability as well as support, don’t they? 

Sonia Crozier: Absolutely, but I have to say from my direct contact with NPS staff that the announcements have been broadly welcomed. There is a real sense that they want to get behind the changes as we go forward. Let us not forget that, whether you work in the NPS or a CRC, there is a strong culture of vocation in the probation service. People do not give up despite adversity, and that has been seen and assessed by Her Majesty’s inspectorate of probation; they have gone into probation areas where things are not as they should be, but people carry on. Obviously, we cannot rely on that good will forever, so the transitional work Jim will be leading has to put supports in place to make sure that we carry people forward to contract change. 

Q411 Ms Marie Rimmer: The National Audit Office said that the possibility of multiple provider failures is a live risk. How are you managing that? 

Robert Buckland: I think you are referring to the issue of what happens between now and the end of the CRC contractual period. We have already talked to the Committee about the experiences we have had, for example with Working Links, where we had to take action to make sure that another provider came in. That was done via Seetec. I am happy with regard to the transfer of undertakings, for example; it is not TUPE, but it is analogous to it. That happened in as smooth a way as possible so that staff were not unduly inconvenienced.

We took a lot of learning from that, which I think makes us very resilient if we are to face another challenge of that nature between now and the end of 2020. Wales is leading the way, because by the end of 2019 we will have a unified service up and running. That has been a very important source of information to equip officials with the wherewithal to deal with any failure. 

We have to be mindful of the fact that it would not be right, according to competition rules, to slot another private provider into a region because of the 25% rule, so there would have to be another solution, which will be a GovCo solution. We have thought ahead on this. We have had the experience already and we will put it to good use if needed. It is my belief that the provisions and contingencies we have made in order to support the CRCs will be enough to carry them through to the end of 2020, but we are ready if there is an issue. 

Q412 Ms Marie Rimmer: How are you going to monitor it as it goes along, without waiting until it collapses? 

Amy Rees: As you would expect, we monitor these contracts really carefully. Since the lifetime of the contract, we have been in active dialogue, hence the changes we made to the contracts over the last couple of years. We will be in even more active dialogue now about how we manage transition. We have an existing experienced contract management team that will continue to monitor the health of those contracts going forward. 

Q413 Ms Marie Rimmer: Our report was deeply concerned that the voluntary sector was less involved in probation than before the TR reforms were implemented, which was an unintended consequence. What is the MOJ doing about that? 

Robert Buckland: Perhaps I could preface the remarks and then Jim can come in. On the basis of what I said before, we think the new model, with its direct link between the NPS and providers, means there will be room for smaller localised organisations, whether it is the third sector or other types of organisation, to provide localised tailored support. I talked earlier to the Committee about co-commissioning with police and crime commissioners. You make an absolutely fair point. That was lost in the mix when it came to previous provision. We do not want to do that. In short, we are going to design a system to make sure that we can and will involve the smaller organisations. Jim might want to come in on that. 

Jim Barton: I have a couple of minor additional points. As the Minister pointed to, we are consciously designing the shape of the new market in a way that reduces barriers to entry for the voluntary sector. For the innovation partners, we intend to put in place larger contracts aligned with the future NPS regions. The first thing we are doing is fundamentally changing the payment mechanism. As we have already referenced, there will be no payment by results. Therefore, the financial sums that organisations need to put at risk, or have in their reserves earmarked to cover risk, will be significantly lower. That should make it possible for larger voluntary sector organisations or consortia to consider themselves credible bidders for those contracts. 

The second thing we will make sure that we do, which again is learning from transforming rehabilitation, is to provide much earlier clarity on what financial guarantees organisations need to put up, because I think that came as a slightly unpleasant shock to some organisations towards the tail-end of a procurement process, having invested a fair amount of time and effort to get there. We will make sure that people have sight up front of all the information that is relevant to them when making a decision with their trustees as to whether they can bid for contracts. 

As the Minister referenced, the second part of our market strategy is a framework or dynamic purchasing system that has consciously been chosen and will be created with the aim of reaching out to more specialist and, therefore, predominantly smaller not-for-profit organisations that can support individual offender need and specific cohorts of offenders. We have learned the lessons and we aim to apply them. 

Q414 Ms Marie Rimmer: Is the voluntary sector still strong enough to carry out the role you envisage for it? As I am sure you are aware, we have lost some incredibly good smaller providers, particularly BAME providers. Is the strength still there in the voluntary sector to provide services? 

Jim Barton: As you will know, we fund Clinks, the umbrella organisation for the sector, for a number of reasons. One is to do precisely that—to monitor the health of the sector. Their last report, “TrackTR”, was published last year, and gave some evidence that we are on a declining trajectory. It is getting worse and harder for the sector as a whole, and we acknowledge that. We will continue to work closely with Clinks and, through them, the rest of the sector during transition, because it is not in our interests for the voluntary sector to be hollowed out. 

Q415 Ms Marie Rimmer: It is going to be incredibly difficult, isn’t it? 

Amy Rees: Anecdotally, in Wales, where I am based, we have been discussing this with the VCS for longer, since last July. It is true that the market and the VCS have found the landscape more difficult, but we are reassured that there are still providers out there; they absolutely want to work with us and are in active dialogue with us about how we can strengthen them and shape the contract so that it is better for them. They need a bit more certainty for a bit longer than we have perhaps given them in the past. I am reassured that there is still a market and a vibrant sector that we can work with, but it definitely has been difficult for them over the last couple of years. 

Q416 Ms Marie Rimmer: In October, the MOJ accepted our recommendation that it should publish a workforce strategy. Indeed, we were told that the Department was working on one. By May, the MOJ said instead that it had rejected the recommendation. Why did you change position? 

Robert Buckland: Being frank, with regard to strategies, one can spend a lot of time drawing up a plan. It is far better to get on with it, and the figures are yielding some positive results. In the last year, 2018-19, we have appointed an extra 624 probation service officers, which is already a substantial increase for the NPS. My plan is to recruit more officers. We have an active recruitment campaign now; I want to see it very much focused not just on the NPS but on where there are issues with provision at the CRCs, so that we crack on with recruiting more officers there as well. 

In short, we want more probation officers doing a caseload, as I was saying, in accordance with the recommendations of the inspectorate, and handling a more mixed caseload, to acknowledge the fact that it can be a very stressful and difficult job; plus the enhancement of the role of probation officers in terms of their professional status. That is a strategy. I have set it out to the Committee, and I am happy to write to the Committee to explain it. That is our strategy. We have it, and we are going to crack on with it. 

Q417 Ms Marie Rimmer: You are using the inspector’s report and other reports, so you must have some idea of the numbers you need, and where. How do we know that it is actually happening, and when is it planned to happen? Is it keeping up to date, Ms Crozier? 

Sonia Crozier: One of the key lessons we learned from transforming rehabilitation is the cost of breaking the probation pipeline in terms of qualified officers coming through. We had a break, and it has taken us some time to recover from that, but we now have a well-rehearsed process for recruiting new officers to the National Probation Service and a commitment, as the Minister has just outlined, that, through transition, we will not break that pipeline again in preparing for the future. We have a good system now to project forward and reach out to the market, to attract graduates into the organisation. 

Q418 Ms Marie Rimmer: The Committee is still concerned about the critical shortage of probation officers. It seems to me that what you are saying is that you can give us some information and we might not need to be as concerned as we are. Would you let us have that information, please? 

Robert Buckland: Indeed. As I said, the very significant increase in appointments last year is a good sign that we are moving in a positive direction to achieve the ambition I have for the service. 

Q419 Ms Marie Rimmer: Could you let us have something that we can see and test ourselves? 

Robert Buckland: By all means. 

Ms Marie Rimmer: Thank you. 

Amy Rees: I just want to add a little bit on workforce. There is obviously recruitment, but the other important announcement we made as part of the announcement the Minister alluded to earlier is that we will be creating a statutory professional framework. That is really important, because people qualifying on day one is one issue, but going forward we have to ensure that professional learning, training and development is maintained. This is a guarantee that that will happen for everyone existing in the system and for new people coming into the system. We also think that it is a really important statement to the criminal justice system more widely about acknowledging the professionalism and the critical importance of the work that probation staff do.

Q420 Ms Marie Rimmer: We welcome the intention of implementing the independent statutory register for probation. Would you like to tell us a little more about that? Which body will own it, how will it work and when will it come into force? 

Robert Buckland: The statutory basis is the big departure. We will develop the detail of the plans as we come to the legislative stage, because it will require legislation. As Amy said, it will be a new framework of standards and excellence, which will support probation officers not just in enhancing their role but in setting a standard to which they will work, which allows the sharing of best practice. We have many examples among local probation officers of individuals doing great and innovative work. Let’s share and understand that better and spread it through the service. What better way than via a framework? To coin a phrase, it is a royal college approach, which has worked so well in other professions that I want to see it in the probation profession. 

As I was saying to you, Ms Rimmer, you do not need to convince me about their value. I have seen it for myself. What I want to do is to convince the public about their value and to understand them. I do not want them to be a forgotten corner of public service; they are a vital part of public service and, without them, we would soon notice the difference. 

Q421 Ms Marie Rimmer: Yes, we have noticed the difference. 

Sonia Crozier: I am absolutely delighted about the announcement on formal registration. That will give confidence to staff that, in future delivery of probation, there will be a commitment from us on the quality of the training they should be offered post qualification, which will give greater consistency and enhance quality. It will restore some of the sense of confidence, in the way the Minister just described, and the sense that we are not a forgotten corner of the criminal justice system but have something of value to add, in our ability both to effect change in individuals and to protect the public. 

It also gives assurance to victims of crime. Some of the most difficult conversations I have with victims, particularly of serious crime, are about their concerns whether the professionals overseeing individuals are actually properly qualified and trained to do their job. Once we have registration, it will give confidence to victims of serious crime as well—the confidence piece that the Minister so well articulated.

(To be continued)

Wednesday, 19 June 2019

Napo at Work in the South West 25

As always, thanks go to the reader for forwarding the following:-

Branch Report 31 

June 2019

Dear members,

A short update on the meetings over pay and how far Seetec claim things are developing. Keep in mind many of their initial plans were not based on the contracts ending as early nor the reduced and uncertain TR2. The fantastic news of the case management separation is just the start of the Napo campaign to see 100% return to public service.

Seetec is the contract holder for the remaining period to 31 3 21 which is just about the next 20 months. The Seetec promises of more pay to certain grades is now retracted and evaporated as an outdated wooing of the staff illusion. Their so called repair plan of 90 days is nowhere near target from their 14 of February boasting. No discernible action plan has been shared or mentioned to the Unions which actually deal effectively with the calamities raised within the HMIP report on workloads and the dysfunctional workload indicator process.

There has been a bit of talking up from Seetec and what they have been doing in relation to third party contracts to providers debts, office renewed space and recruiting hopes projections. These are less helpful to staff who should ordinarily expect to have the basics in place and at the least appropriate office base. Understanding facilities are essential tools of the job. In managing the disaster Seetec should have set out to ensure the repair of Working Links gross mis-management were handled sympathetically towards staff with a more gentle approach. Instead we read of the back slapping celebrations that work continued while they seamlessly took the reins. This is no consolation to the absented and overworked staff and still no recognition of a need to have a moratorium in light of the issues raised in the HMIP report. That issue will continue until the safe return of case management to public services.

The meeting in Reading was a lengthy listen to Seetec promoting a new model but still nothing in writing and an agenda that came out the day before the meeting. Most of what we heard was jam tomorrow. The reality of the case management for Wales having to be in place by December 2019 is a good thing and focused attention on the priorities that will have to be in place to ensure a smooth transition and the necessary protection for those staff and for the longer term. Anyone having suffered the Working Links way for this number of years will need full support and a decent period of adjusting built into the arrangements. It is clear to all involved in this issue, the transfer arrangements will have to be tighter than before given what we have learned. The predicted collapse of Working Links may have had some bearing on the Wales’ return to public ownership. What I wonder is where did the money go and will there be an appropriate if not criminal inquiry as to how they spent\ lost so much public monies.

The ongoing meeting provided limited scrutiny of the Seetec future planning especially now they have their news, the whole case management game is up in March 2021. They were very clear that they believed that splitting case management away from interventions is not a good thing to do. On that point we would easily agree however when pushed they would not accept that putting case management back into public ownership was the correct thing to do either. Well they cannot have their cake and eat it.

They still refused to share their planning documents. The General Secretary remarked carefully that the current talks went nowhere near appropriate meaningful consultations. The senior management avoided engagement on the issue. They also want to engage in terms rewriting. How long they have left in in charge makes this a questionable activity.

The Pay talks themselves.

If ever there was a story of how to play important issues into the long grass Seetec have all the same disingenuous approaches, that Working Links excelled. With only three meetings involving the Pan Trades Union Sides and Seetec representatives, none of them appearing to have authority to formally agree any changes or settlement offer. The so-called talks amounted to just a few hours on the claim and that only happening at the end of the meeting. It was worse than poor in that the General Secretary pointed out a range of failures to consult properly and meaningfully with the lack of information and absence of new evidence to support their rejection of the joint unions pay claim. The miserly and below par offer is just 1% but they claim is 2% because they ignore that contractual rights includes 1%. A clear signal that staff just come last every time. It was made clear the South West is well noted as a difficult area to recruit staff, despite the evidence for pay incentive endorsements for the region. Seetec ignored it. We doubt they will find the numbers of staff they will need in the short term. This in turn led them to continue to ignore the real issues of overwork and stress for staff. They continue to bluff by directly ignoring staff terms and conditions. Workloads weightings will not go away and as more staff are feeling the pressure the area remains as it was and the next HMIP report will most likely say much of the same. I take no pleasure in reporting this view. We have all the information we need to help the area and yet we have the private profits motive paying staff less but expecting even more.

Wages in the South West

Workers in some sectors are gaining pay rises but real wages overall in the South West are still £21.78 a week lower than a decade ago. The Government has been keen to herald a return to above inflation pay rises but any rises have not been spread equally or fairly.

Average real pay in the financial sector has increased by 9.3% (£119 per week) since 2009 reaching a record average of £1,405 per week – driven by big pay rises for London’s bankers. Other sectors that have seen real wage growth include, retail and hospitality - boosted by increases to the minimum wage. The story is very different for public sector workers.

People employed in health and social work and education are still £36 a week worse off than in 2009. Real pay for workers in manufacturing of food and drink, a key sector for the West Country, is still down by £52 per week.
Source TUC.

Nonetheless and despite the meeting closing with a promise of a letter to the NAPO General Secretary which rejected flatly the Pay claim, the response had been swift from Ian Lawrence and the combined Unions. Members will have seen the issued bulletins on talks and the subsequent letter notifying of the additional dispute on pay. We wait for continued talks but I doubt they will pass on any appropriate pay increase to staff no matter how much the MOJ floated them.

As a branch in the SSW we have our AGM on the 27th of June please attend have your say and question your branch officials on strategy and direction for the protection of your role terms and conditions through this next year. It will be challenging and as we stick together easier to ensure your protections and the future transfer arrangements are managed fairly and properly no matter what the intentions of Seetec, the NPS in terms of the staffing ratio, and the possible although not yet certain split of interventions .

If you’re not in Napo and reading this then please join now. Whatever the future shapes up for probation together we are stronger. Whatever it takes.

Dino Peros 

Napo SSW Branch Chair.

Tuesday, 18 June 2019

MoJ Give Evidence

Last Wednesday the House of Commons Justice Committee had the opportunity of grilling the new man at the MoJ, along with Jim Barton, Sonia Crozier and Amy Rees. As on previous occasions, although somewhat lengthy, it's important that what was said is examined in some detail, but in several chunks:-   

Q375 Chair:
Minister, thank you very much for coming and bringing your officials. You are well known to us. All of us have met your officials in the past, but perhaps they could introduce themselves for the record. 

Jim Barton: I am Jim Barton, the director responsible for delivering the probation reform programme. 

Sonia Crozier: I am Sonia Crozier. I am chief probation officer of the National Probation Service. I also have responsibility within HMPPS for women.

Amy Rees: I am Amy Rees. I am the interim director general for probation and Wales. 

Q376 Chair: Let me kick off. There have been some important announcements about the future of probation, welcome ones as far as this Committee is concerned. What changed the Government’s mind from last October? 

Robert Buckland: First, can I pay tribute to the work of the Committee, which has taken a long and informed interest in this? I am grateful to all members for having considered the matter and helped inform the process. 

I am fairly new in post, but, as you know, Mr Neill, I have had a long involvement with the system and have worked with probation officers for the better part of 30 years, so I know their worth and value. I think we acknowledge that, although there has been important change brought about by transforming rehabilitation, we needed to make further changes. There had been a process during the TR regime from 2014 onward where we had made adjustments. Most notably, the decision to end the CRC contracts earlier than planned was a major adjustment, but we based our decisions on the evidence and the information, and as a Department we are not frightened to acknowledge when change is necessary. 

This was one of the key moments when both the Secretary of State and I felt very strongly that we needed to streamline responsibility for provision in the area to make it clearer and more straightforward, in particular to understand the important role of the National Probation Service. These reforms will give the NPS a stronger and clearer role in managing all offenders. We believe that the system we are going to develop will enhance and encourage voluntary sector involvement in rehabilitation to a greater level than we have seen previously. 

I have described the scenario as a mixed economy. I believe that very fundamentally. It is important that we retain the voluntary sector, and indeed the private sector, in helping us to make that provision, but the overarching framework within the NPS and the creation of 11 regions will underline the importance of allowing each part of the sector to play to its strengths and deliver more investment in further enhancing the role of our probation staff. That aspect of our proposed reforms has perhaps been somewhat overlooked. 

For me, it is absolutely vital not only that we increase the number of probation staff, which is happening, but that they feel valued and understood by wider society as a vital part of the system, whose judgments are to be relied upon by sentencers and whose assessments within the community are an important part of offender management and rehabilitation. As part of that process, your Committee played its role, but the observations of the former chief inspector of probation, Dame Glenys Stacey, also played a very important part in influencing the thinking that has brought us to this position. 

Q377 Chair: It is Keynesian; the facts or evidence have changed, and you have changed your view. 

Robert Buckland: To condemn TR out of hand and say that it was a failure is unfair to many aspects of it: for example, the increase in the overall number of people supervised; some of the really good projects that we saw in the south-east relating to stalking; and the work done on unpaid work requirements. I do not think it would be fair to write off the past four or five years as a blind alley, because it certainly was not. A lot of what we have learned from that will be taken forward in the new model, but the end of the division between serious offences and less serious offences will help us, most notably not just with overall accountability but with the workload of probation officers. Perhaps we can explore that as we go into questions. 

Q378 Chair: You have come into post recently. Have you had the chance to meet many frontline probation staff since you have been there? Perhaps you would tell us what you have found in terms of their response. 

Robert Buckland: In the few weeks that I have been in office I have already visited a probation centre in Greater Manchester, together with senior probation staff, but, most importantly, to meet probation officers working with offenders on the ground in an innovative way. In the particular probation office I visited they were managing quite hard-to-reach offenders with a particularly innovative programme that involved therapeutic and support services to understand the underlying reasons for offending. For me, it is reacquaintance with a profession I have worked with and been impressed by over nearly 30 years. 

Q379 Chair: I understand and agree with what you are saying. I think we would all endorse what you say about probation staff. 

One of the things that troubled us was what seemed to be a diminution of confidence on the part of the judiciary and sentencers in the way they could rely on the follow-up to sentences. Can you talk to us specifically about how that is going to be addressed in the new system? The decision was that the people who wrote the reports were NPS staff, but in the past the follow-up was done by CRCs. How is the confidence of magistrates and judges going to be addressed? Bring in your officials by all means. 

Robert Buckland: Absolutely, but can I lead off on that basis? I come to this job in the sense that I will take the position of the sentencer. Having done it myself and sat in the judge’s chair and looked at the options when sentencing, I understand that the confidence sentencers need in their options is absolutely vital. We are already seeing some important examples of work being done to improve the options that have existed for a very long time in statute but which, in reality, have proved somewhat different. 

Let’s take mental health treatment requirements as part of a community order. A number of pilots are now being undertaken in Milton Keynes, Northampton and a few other centres—I think London is piloting two. We have not yet seen the outcome evaluation or the process evaluation, although we will, by the way, have some idea shortly from the Department of Health as to the process evaluation, but we are already seeing a tailored approach to individual need. I accept that that can be a challenge and there is always a resource issue with these options, but it is my aim to try to make sure that sentencers have a proper choice, that the words on the page in the 2003 Act become more and more of a reality, and that by improving that choice prison is not the only staple in the diet of sentencing, if I can use that phrase. That is well understood. I am happy for officials to come in to develop those points. 

Q380 Chair: I understand that and agree with it, but I am interested in the nuts and bolts of how we give the sentencer reassurance that there will be a better follow-through than appears to have been the case in the past. Who would like to deal with that? 

Amy Rees: To add to what the Minister said, in July we launched our probation consultation document called “Building Confidence”. As part of that, we trialled the new model in Wales, which looks very similar to the model we are now going for in England and Wales, so we were able to gather quite a lot of detailed feedback about what people thought about that model, including the judiciary, and they were very supportive of what we were planning to do in Wales. 

It comes down to some quite simple things. There will be one person responsible for probation in a region. If you have issues that you want to follow through, you will be able to go directly to one person. The system will have an owner in a region that gives a point of interface with the judiciary that we think has been missing over the last four or five years. 

Q381 Chair: A resident judge at Chelmsford, Maidstone or somewhere has a specific person they can go to. Is that what it comes down to? 

Amy Rees: And who manages the whole system. 

Q382 Chair: That can be followed through, and the recorder, Mr Buckland or I, is in the same position to do that. 

Robert Buckland: Indeed. I think the relationship between the judiciary and the probation service is absolutely vital. The judiciary need to have confidence that the authors of pre-sentence reports are people who have the experience, authority and understanding to reach judgments that can be relied on. I am not a nostalgist, Mr Neill, but we are looking at building those relationships in a stronger way. With technology, there are many other ways in which it can now be done just as effectively. The relationship—the liaison—is strengthened so that resident judges, circuit judges and recorders can have confidence. 

Q383 Chair: I understand that. Does anyone want to add anything to the details and specifics of that? 

Jim Barton: I acknowledge that the model we are now proposing to implement removes the disconnects you have referred to, Mr Neill, in terms of the person offering advice to sentencers not necessarily working for the organisation that is then responsible for those cases. Under the new model, that disconnect is simply removed. 

Q384 Chair: There will be a direct link between the author of the report and those who do the administration. Similarly, if for any reason there is a breach and people are brought back, do you think you can give better assurance under the new system that it will be joined up? 

Robert Buckland: Yes. 

Q385 Chair: That is helpful. How does it differ from the old probation trusts? The Secretary of State says it does not, and I can understand why to some extent. Eleven regions are a bit different. What would you say are the key differences? 

Amy Rees: There is obviously a size difference, which we have acknowledged, and that is important. Beyond that, there are some more important differences. As I just referred to, there will be a single director responsible for probation services in a region. That means both the directly delivered part and the commissioned part, but that responsibility is through a civil service relationship so the Minister will still be able to have a line of sight, not just on the direct delivery but on the commissioned services. 

Jim Barton: Perhaps another point of difference with probation trusts is the size of the market involvement. I know that the Committee has followed the history of probation very closely over many years since the creation of probation trusts in 2010. You will remember that there was always an intent that probation trusts should commission out potentially up to 20% of their services. From my anecdotal memory of that time, having worked for one of those trusts, I think only one or two got anywhere close to that level, despite a considerable push from Ministers through successive Governments to try to achieve it. What we are committing to under this model is that there will be an absolute requirement that the National Probation Service commissions the provision of interventions from market providers, whether they be private or voluntary sector organisations. 

Sonia Crozier: The other obvious difference is that we have become a national probation service in areas where it is important to have a greater degree of consistency. We have pursued that very hard and have taken out some of the differences that we inherited from 35 trusts—for example, in the use of our approved premises and the targeting of that. The benefits of being a national service will be taken forward into the new regions but will be combined with the kind of flexibility at local level around commissioning and engagement with the voluntary sector that Jim Barton has just described. It is about taking the best of what works nationally but combining that with new opportunities to have a greater focus on local engagement. 

Q386 Chair: One of the criticisms of the previous regime was that, whatever the intention, in practice some voluntary groups were involved, maybe not as many as had been hoped, but that one thing the old trusts had was a fairly direct link into the local community through representation and membership of the trusts. That seems to have been very much lost. 

Given that a lot of the folk who will be dealt with by probation will have housing and social services issues, potentially education issues and health issues, how will you get a meaningful say at local level as well as national level rather than everything being referred up the line to the Minister, as I found when I was in a health authority, and becoming very centralised? How are you going to avoid that? 

Robert Buckland: We are already having active dialogue with police and crime commissioners. There was dialogue prior to the announcement, as you would expect and hope, and that has carried on. I met a representative sample of PCCs only last week to discuss ways we can jointly commission local services. 

It seems to me that the “and crime” element of the PCC model is one that comes into play when we are dealing with prevention and rehabilitation. Therefore, it is an entirely logical step to use that network as an important framework, below regional level, to identify some excellent examples of local provision so that we can, as you say, have a direct link with the small charity that might be working with veterans in Wiltshire, for example, or an organisation that might be working with a particular cohort of vulnerable offenders in another part of the country. There will be a direct link in terms of how the relationship with the NPS is maintained. As Sonia says, the local being blended with the national is where the balance needs to be struck. 

Q387 Chair: It is local knowledge, isn’t it? Some of the key decision makers being involved is critical. What are the practical means by which you can achieve that, Ms Crozier? 

Sonia Crozier: As we take forward future design, we want enough well-informed local managers who are working to a common set of principles engaging with local partners. That is different from the position we have been in previously where you might have managers from the NPS and the CRC combining two voices locally, which can be confusing, or perhaps there are no voices because one thinks the other is doing something. We will have a unified approach, with leadership flowing down and sufficient local managers on the frontline doing all the things you have just described, building relationships with local charities at a very local level in small towns across the country. 

Q388 Chair: You signed MOUs with both the Mayor of London and the Mayor of Greater Manchester in relation to elements of justice devolution. Many of us would say that some elements of probation work are pretty obvious examples of areas where you could devolve a lot of the delivery of these matters. How will that fit together under the new set-up? 

Amy Rees: We are in active dialogue with both of those Mayors and both regions. We already work quite closely with them. For example, in Greater Manchester we have had an intensive alternative to custody pilot running for some time, so it is building on a dialogue that already exists. We think the new model will be much better placed to allow us to work much more closely with those kinds of partners and others. Why? Because we are directly commissioning from a framework that will both allow much smaller organisations to be part of that framework and enable us to commission together with all sorts of organisations—PCCs, metro mayors or local authorities. 

Q389 David Hanson: I will take you back to the National Audit Office, if I may. In its report in March this year, it said that the part-privatisation of probation services had been extremely costly to the taxpayer. What is your current estimate of the cost? 

Robert Buckland: Where we are with the overall cost is that the net figure, in fact, is somewhat more encouraging when one takes into account the fact that we will have ended the contracts early. 

Q390 David Hanson: What is it? 

Robert Buckland: The projected spend? The overall non-spend on the contracts is £1.4 billion. The net figure is £800 million in terms of money actually not spent, so there is still an overall excess, if you like, rather than a deficit. 

Q391 David Hanson: There is a figure of £171 million in the National Audit Office report as the cost to the taxpayer. How do you account for that? What is that for? 

Robert Buckland: That figure is included very much in the net figure. I can break that down. That £171 million consists of £113 million that the Department agreed with 20 of the 21 CRCs with regard to changing the baseline. You will remember that there was a frequency of reoffending baseline assessed as at 2011. What happened was that that was not reflected by the reality of the number of cases being dealt with by CRCs, and it was remodelled to a figure based on the 2015-16 year. 

Q392 David Hanson: There was £467 million put in 18 months to two years ago. Where has that gone? 

Robert Buckland: I am just trying to explain, if you will bear with me. A figure of £1.8 million was allocated to the Merseyside CRC. There was a particular issue there because they had overseen quite a significant improvement in the frequency of reoffending in their area and were making some progress. There was a request made by the parent company for the original baseline to be maintained because they were performing. 

A figure of £30.2 million was agreed by the Ministry with regard to some technical variations with providers, which related to the source of the data used to calculate the volume of casework by CRCs, and £43 million was agreed with CRCs to deliver an enhanced through-the-gate specification right through to the end of 2020. There was £213 million that was a marginal adjustment factor change; in other words, that was the change to the contracts made back in 2017. That payment was made to rectify the original assumptions that we know have been looked at carefully by the PAC and which I know you understand. 

There was an £82.2 million additional fee for service payments made to CRCs in the financial years 2016-17 and 2017-18, but, as I have said, because of the underspend of £1.4 billion, you take that into account and, although that money has been significant, the overall net sum that we are not spending—it is a bit inelegant—or the net money we have avoided spending because we ended the contracts earlier is £800 million. 

Q393 David Hanson: But by ending the contracts early you are still going to spend that money in some form or other in the next couple of years, but not with the current CRCs. 

Robert Buckland: Yes, but it is an important point— 

Q394 David Hanson: As a taxpayer, Minister, what I am interested in is that the National Audit Office has said that the cost to the taxpayer is £171 million. I want to hear from you whether you agree with the National Audit Office or whether you can publish figures that show a different form of defence. I would appreciate that.

Robert Buckland: With respect, I have gone through the figures with you because you deserve particularity. I know you would insist on nothing less as a former Minister for Prisons yourself. 

What I am saying is that the projected overall spend on the contracts was going to be £3.7 billion. By ending them, we spend only £2.3 billion. You then add on the £470 million I have talked about. I am not giving you a conservative estimate. There are other rounding figures that mean an overall £800 million underspend. 

Q395 David Hanson: Has it been a good deal for the taxpayer, Minister? 

Robert Buckland: I have acknowledged that there have been problems with TR. That is why we are making these reforms. I am sitting here telling you frankly that we think we can do better, of course; but it would be wrong to say that overall, looking back on this period, we will have ended up spending more than the projected £3.7 billion. In fact, we will be spending £800 million less than that, which I think is an important overall framework in understanding where we are financially. 

Q396 David Hanson: How much additional money have you put into the current CRCs for 2018-19? 

Robert Buckland: I do not know whether Jim has any more granularity on that. 

Jim Barton: You will appreciate that this is a reasonably confused figure, because, within the £467 million total, some payments, essentially, are backward looking because they correct assumptions in the original payment mechanism; some of them reflect adjustments to the ongoing monthly payments that we make—the changes to the fee for service mechanism that we made in 2017—and some of them are straightforward top-up payments to buy new services. 

On the specific question about 2018-19, the changes we have made previously that will impact this year are the £22 million additional spend on a significantly enhanced through-the-gate service. That service is now live in all bar four resettlement prisons, with 500 additional staff in post delivering improved support for offenders pre-release. The changes that we made to the frequency baseline that the Minister referenced previously mean that as a result most CRCs would, if we had not made those changes, have been paying us because of underperformance on the frequency measure. Most CRCs are now in a position where their frequency payments hover around a zero figure. 

As the Minister pointed out, we believe that the change in the frequency baseline was, with the benefit of hindsight, absolutely the right thing to do, because the deterioration in performance between 2011 and 2015 happened before the CRCs existed or were under private ownership. If we had our time again, we probably would not have signed a contract that linked frequency payments to a baseline in 2011 that we and providers did. Last year, we made the choice that to enforce that element of the contract would have meant that contracts would have been underfunded. The consequence of that is a poorer probation service. That is not in our interest. 

Q397 David Hanson: What is the plan for payments for 2019-20 until the contracts expire? 

Jim Barton: We will apply current contractual terms, so it will depend on the volume of work that CRCs do and their performance under the PBR mechanism. 

Q398 David Hanson: What is your rough estimate of the net cost to the Department of that contract for 2019-20? 

Jim Barton: That is included in the figures you cite. When the NAO rightly says that the cost of those contract changes is £467 million, that extends from the date we made the changes to the end of the contract. For example, through-the-gate is £22 million a year, and £43 million in total between the point when we made that change and the end of the contracts. 

Q399 David Hanson: In a previous session with Richard Heaton, we asked for a breakdown of the costs for each CRC, and the net plus or minus figure for each CRC. I have a letter from Richard Heaton dated 8 April in which he says: “You also asked for a breakdown of costs for the financial year… We are still finalising our year end position, so are not yet in a position to provide this data. We will provide you with an update as soon as we are able.” Do you know when that will be? 

Robert Buckland: I will take that away and make sure that the Committee is furnished with that information as soon as possible. 

Q400 David Hanson: This is the final question from me on financing. In May this year, the permanent secretary, Richard Heaton, required a ministerial direction to process payments to CRC subcontractors because he could not reconcile those payments with his duty as accounting officer. Why could he not reconcile those payments? Why did the Minister overrule the decision of the accounting officer? 

Robert Buckland: I do not have the information before me with regard to that particular decision. I accept that the procedure is not one that is commonly used. 

Q401 David Hanson: It has not been used generally in the last 10 years. 

Robert Buckland: I accept that, Mr Hanson. It is a matter on which I will want to furnish the Committee with full information. I do not have it to hand. 

David Hanson: I am grateful for that, Minister. Could we have an explanation as to the reasons why the accounting officer’s decision to rule out payments to subcontractors was made by the Minister, unless anybody at official level can help?

Q402 Chair: It will be helpful to have that. 

Mr Barton, you talked about proceeding on current contractual arrangements until they terminate. Is there a risk of any further payments being necessary? You are working on the current volumes and assumptions until the end of the contract. Those assumptions of workload proved erroneous and unreliable in the past. Is there still a risk that we may need further bail-outs for some of those firms? 

Amy Rees: As Jim outlined quite clearly, the contracts will operate in the way we have now set out. The package to which we have been referring in terms of the £467 million was one that we designed in order to take us to the end of the revised contract period. We believe, from the best knowledge we have, that that will be enough to stabilise as we go forward. Having said that, in the way we have just described, the contracts are built on changing metrics. Did they reduce reoffending? Is that binary or is it among the reoffending group? What happens to fee for use? What happens to the rate card? Lots of elements can change over the next two years, so it is impossible to say it will be exactly as this, but in good faith we negotiated those contract changes in the belief that they would take us to the end of the contract period, and that would be sufficient to stabilise the system. 

Q403 Chair: I think the Committee is rather in favour of the change you made. There remains a risk, but your view is that it is a manageable one. 

Amy Rees: There are lots of changing numbers, and multiple parts and frequencies, which mean that it is difficult to say, when you take all of that, that there is no risk at all, but we believe we have taken steps to eliminate the risk as far as we can. 

Q404 David Hanson: Can I get a commitment from the Minister, helpfully, for the Committee? When the period with the current CRCs has been finalised and completed, will you agree to publish a cost analysis of the final package for the costs of CRCs and the changes from 2011 to 2020? 

Robert Buckland: What we can do is provide as much information, with as much granularity as possible, for the Committee, so that we understand the whole period. What that will look like precisely I cannot tell you now, as Amy has said, but in terms of learning we have had to deal with a number of issues—for example, Working Links and what has happened in Wales as well. We have the learning and experience of the model now to deal with any contingency issues that might arise between now and the end of 2020. 

Let’s not forget that the issue was the profile of offences and the unforeseen outcome that was the increase in serious offences that had to be dealt with by the NPS. The workload of the NPS increased in a way that perhaps had not been foreseen, which meant that there were fewer of the less serious offences that would have been dealt with by the CRCs. 

Understanding that fundamental reality can perhaps inform as fully as possible not just members of the Committee but the wider public about the scale of the challenge that CRCs faced.

Jim Barton: On the question about further contractual changes, you will have noticed in previous evidence that we had planned to end current contracts on 4 December 2020, but in our announcements on the future direction of travel we are referencing transition happening in spring 2021. We think we need to take the time to manage transition well. That is a hard lesson learned from transforming rehabilitation. To provide us with the small number of additional months needed to do that, we have an option to extend CRC contracts into the first half of 2021. We have recently published, through the Official Journal of the European Union, notice that we have that option and that we intend to make that contract change. That would be on amended contractual terms. 

Q405 Chair: I understand that. Perhaps hard-wiring anything by an absolute fixed date is never wise. 

Robert Buckland: That’s right, Mr Neill. As Jim said, the pace of change is different from the period prior to the introduction of TR in 2014. We will be developing our business case by late summer and looking to move on to the next stage, the competition stage, in the autumn. You are looking at a clear set of milestones within which there will be a lot of work that I will be keeping a very close eye on, because I get the point that we have to get the commissioning right. You will be bearing down upon me very hard if we do not, so it is very well understood. 

Chair: That is fair enough.

(To be continued)

Saturday, 15 June 2019

Napo at Work in the South West 24

Thanks go to the reader for sharing the following:-  

10th June 2019

Some progress on improving the dialogue but Unions reject shabby Pay Offer

This bulletin sets out the key outcomes from last weeks’ meeting between KSS CRC and SEETEC senior leadership and the Trade Unions in Reading over 6/7th June.

This engagement followed the recent correspondence from Napo, UNISON and GMB in which we explained our serious disappointment at the lack of tangible progress by KSS CRC and SEETEC senior management following agreed actions from the earlier meetings’ with the unions. Even allowing for the chaos that SEETEC have inherited from Working Links, the employer has so far failed to show that they are that much different when it comes to recognising the role of the unions and entering into negotiations.

It has taken some time, but at least a number of joint objectives on future engagement were agreed. We expect these to help facilitate urgent and long overdue dialogue on a range of very important issues. Many of these are the result of the legacy failures of the incompetent former CRC provider Working Links. Some are existing priorities (such as the transfer of Offender Management work to NPS Wales by December this year and the overall operational plan up until April 2021).

New structures for improved engagement

The unions have agreed to a regional engagement structure. One will cover the former Kent Surrey and Sussex area of the enlarged CRC, and one for the South West, West and Wales. There will be a standardised agenda to ensure consistency and an overarching JNCC comprising of union reps and senior management as has been the case in the meetings at Chippenham, Cardiff and Reading. We need to see a serious improvement from what has happened so far.

There will also be a restoration of localised and more informal ‘short sides’ discussions to try and deal with day-to-day issues that may arise in between the above.

Specific working groups are be established covering:
  • The transition of OM work from Wales
  • Unpaid Work
  • Workloads as a result of the intended Operational Model
More details of dates for these and the names of the respective union reps will follow.

Pay dispute on the cards

Sadly, it did not prove possible to make any progress whatsoever in terms of securing an acceptable position on pay. We were strongly critical of the employer who has not only failed to understand the dreadful position that they have inherited, but have not provided us with information that we are legally entitled to and who also apparently lack the authority to actually negotiate an acceptable outcome.

Moreover, we said that the Probation U-turn has markedly changed the longer-term approach to pay reform that the employer envisaged. The unions are demanding that urgent remedial action be taken NOW to establish pay parity across the whole of the extended CRC, and redress inadequate pay rates following the imposition of a pay award to staff in the original KSS area last year.

The employer has undertaken to reply to the Unions by the middle of the week and we will issue further news as soon as it becomes available. Meanwhile, we have put the employer on notice that in the absence of a positive response we reserve the right to move to a dispute.

Future of Probation

As you would expect, a debate took place at Reading following the news of the Governments policy U-turn which will see an estimated 80% of offender management work move to 11 new NPS regions by the time that the current CRC providers are shown the door by April 2021 (latest) or sooner if there is a Labour Government in power. This means that the National negotiations on the selection and transfer process for Wales will be vital in terms of these being the benchmark for England. The unions have also said that we expect the employer to carry out the instructions it receives from the centre, and that we are not prepared to see this, or any other CRC provider, determine the future placement of staff to the NPS.

We reiterated that while the U-turn is a victory for the probation unions it does not give us all that our members are demanding. We have made it clear to senior KSS and SEETEC as well as Ministers, that we do not see any justification for retaining Intervention and Programme work in a so- called ‘mixed-market’ and we will continue to demand:

  • The total reunification of all probation work to public control
  • The harmonisation of all staff on to NPS Pay rates before the ending of CRC contracts
Join a union now!

In light of the foregoing, we must again emphasize the importance of belonging to a trade union. Please share this bulletin with colleagues who may not be in a trade union.

The unions are campaigning for:

  • Fair pay for all
  • The reunification of all probation work
  • An end to all privatisation
  • A moratorium on formal action against staff caused by inept management and the operational failures identified in previous HMI Probation reports (e.g. Gloucester and Devon, Dorset Cornwall)
  • Restoration of effective collective bargaining across the extended KSS CRC
  • Immediate action to reduce workload pressures
  • Staff to be treated with dignity and respect.
Can you afford to leave the struggle to everyone else?

Ian Lawrence 
General Secretary Napo
Siobhan Brown/Simon Dunn/Debbie Monkfield Regional Organisers UNISON
Helen Coley Regional Officer GMB/SCOOP