Friday, 14 June 2019

Latest From Napo 189

According to Napo, the centralised civil service-controlled HR and payroll arrangements are still not working properly, which doesn't bode well for further changes coming down the line:-  

Another SSCL screw up

Napo members have been contacting HQ worried after receiving demands from NPS payroll for historic overpayments to be returned. These overpayments range from a few hundred to several thousand pounds and date as far back as the creation of the NPS in 2014.

Napo is of course challenging this latest systematic failure of the computerised HR and payroll system. Given recent announcements about the future of probation, Napo are in the process of preparing a comprehensive case to present to ministers arguing zero confidence in SSCL and the NPS being able to cope with any of the many complexities that arise from the proposed transfer of CRC staff into the NPS at the ending of CRC contracts.

Given the scale of this issue, Napo have issued guidance on what to do if you receive an overpayment demand.

If you are not yet a member of Napo but encounter this problem we are willing, as part of the collective nature of the dispute, to be flexible around our usual rules about not representing someone who joins with an existing problem.

If someone fills in the questionnaire and joins Napo then we will progress their case alongside others in the same position. However, you must join Napo immediately for us to progress a questionnaire and we will review the level of legal support we can afford to support for members who had not taken out our “employment insurance” by joining Napo prior to the overpayment demand arriving.

--oo00oo--

Advice to members regarding overpayments made by the NPS

Over the last weeks many members have informed us that they have received demands from the National Probation Service, via their SSCL HR service provider, for monies relating to alleged historical overpayments. These overpayments range from a few hundred to several thousand pounds and arise from a period stretching back to the creation of the NPS in 2014.

Napo is challenging this latest systematic failure of the computerised HR and payroll system. Being able to pay your staff properly is the most basic requirement for any employer and it is both incredibly frustrating and worrying that the National Probation Service still cannot provide a stable, safe payroll service. Given recent announcements, Napo are in the process of preparing a comprehensive case to present to Ministers arguing that no-one can have any confidence in SSCL and the NPS being able to cope with any of the many complexities that arise from the proposed transfer of CRC staff into the NPS at the ending of CRC contracts.

The scale of the problem is still emerging but is clearly significant. Accordingly, we will be asking Ministers for an amnesty on overpayments. The NPS have resisted such suggestions citing arguments about public money needing to be recovered – taking no account of the public money being wasted managing the fallout from this failing system.

However, whilst we argue for this and for a safe and stable future service we are acutely aware that members need Napo’s advice and support in responding to the failures in the existing provision. The following advice aims to do so.

As well as following the advice below, any member with an overpayment demand are also asked to fill in the attached short questionnaire to help Napo make sure the NPS have your case and are progressing it.

WHAT TO DO IF YOU RECEIVE AN OVERPAYMENT DEMAND

 A. Ask SSCL to prove the money is owed

The overpayments seemingly arise from past payroll errors. However, no-one can be confident that SSCL’s calculations and records are now correct. We have seen examples where they have been unable to present a consistent account of what someone was paid; why it was wrong; and how they have calculated the overpayment. You are entitled to an explanation before you can agree to any monies being taken. This is a legal right.

Therefore, we advise that you:
  • Acknowledge receipt of the request but ask for a full breakdown of how the overpayments were accrued with an explanation for each variation to your normal wages;
  • Ask for copies of your actual wage slips from these periods (to cross reference against the ones available at the time if you still have them) to double check that what they say they paid you was correct;
  • Challenge any discrepancies; payroll errors or changes they do not explain clearly;
  • Keep doing so until there is a clear record that looks safe and factually correct.
Notify your line manager of the problem and ask if they will support you if you need assistance. Keep a copy of both this request and their reply.

B. Ask about any errors or correction that maybe needed before any safe and final amount for any overpayment can be confirmed

In some cases it is clear that SSCL have not recorded important information. For example, if a line manager had exercised their discretion to waive sick-pay reductions these may not have always been recognised by SSCL and could account for the alleged overpayment. They may have wrongly calculated your sick pay, as we know the SSCL computer has struggled with NPS staff having a different sick leave calculation period than other HMPPS staff. Any questions you may have relating to such possibilities should be raised and answered before any alleged overpayments are recovered.

Further, all members impacted should ask for written confirmation that all deductions taken from pay at the time are also correct and/or identified before any overpayment plan is finalised. This will include potential adjustments to PAYE tax and NI contributions. You should ask if your employer will, as part of their contractual obligations under PAYE resolve any necessary adjustments with HMRC prior to any alleged overpayment recovery, so that you can know your full financial position prior to reaching any agreement with the SSCL.You should also specifically ask them to confirm that both your employer and employee pension contributions are correct and if not that any rectification has been made – again before any overpayments are recovered. In most cases, your pension should not be impacted as the employer is under a legal obligation to make up full contributions whenever someone is on reduced salary due to illness, maternity leave, etc. However, if you opted for part-time work and continued to be paid at full pay this could be an issue. Asking will force the employer to check – and we are aware of errors that have taken place in recent months.

Anyone who by being overpaid thinks that SSCL will have recovered more Student loan repayments than was necessary can also appeal to the Student Loans company – and can inform the SSCL of the need to do this before beginning any repayments so that you know your full financial position before agreeing to a repayment plan.

C. Consider the reasonableness of the proposed repayment and challenge this if needed.

The SSCL will propose how much they want to recover from you over what period to make up for any alleged overpayment. Once you have gone through A and B and can be sure the alleged overpayment was made you can still challenge the fairness of any recovery and/or the reasonableness of their proposed recovery schedule.

They cannot take any monies off you until you have specifically agreed for them to do so. If they do so this would be a potential illegal deduction of wages and you should immediately contact Napo so we can help members challenge this in the courts if necessary.

There are several examples we have already identified where we have challenged the reasonableness of any recovery. This is especially relevant where someone has retired since the alleged overpayment and have no income other than their pension to make a repayment.

Likewise, if the case relates to an alleged overpayment that is now more than three years old we would argue it is not reasonable to ask for a recovery now.

Equally, if you were aware of a potential overpayment at the time and can evidence that you raised a concern with the SSCL / your line manager / HR and they offered reassurance or said that payments were correct you should use this now as evidence of a lack of confidence in the current claims; as well as evidence of your employer frustrating your contract by not paying you properly and fairly. Napo can advise in these specific cases directly.

In cases where a member was on maternity leave when the alleged overpayment took place and/or has reduced hours the legitimacy and reasonableness of the alleged overpayment can also be challenged.

In all of these cases, Napo cannot guarantee that a challenge would be successful in removing the alleged overpayment but by presenting such challenges members can delay the repayment process and increase the potential of the NPS changing their collective position whilst the challenges take place.


D. Challenge to make sure the alleged overpayment recovery plan is fair and affordable

Napo believes that no repayment, even if fully explained and legally justifiable, should be more than 5% of disposable income. Nor do we believe that it is reasonable to seek to recover money for an excessive period of time as members should not have the consequences of their employers errors impacting upon them for a prolonged period.

These two benchmarks may not however be compatible. For example, in one recent case the overpayment for someone who had significantly reduced their hours was several thousand pounds and using the 5% rule could have taken almost a decade to pay back. The threat was that any amount unpaid if and when they left would have to be recovered in full – meaning they could be tied to the NPS which of course is itself potentially illegal. In that case the alleged overpayment was greatly reduced, after Napo’s input, to accommodate some fair and reasonable recovery.

You are entitled to negotiate a reasonable recovery plan and one must be agreed before any monies are taken. The evidence you are asked to provide to support your case in negotiations should also not be intrusive or compromise your own data protection rights.

Any costs incurred in relation to addressing the alleged overpayments can also be accounted for and set against the claim as it should not cost you anything to help them rectify their error. This will include all mobile phone calls to the SSCL (charged at premium rate so use work phones and time where at all possible) and potentially compensation if you have had to use your own time (e.g. you’ve retired or are on sick or maternity leave).

NON-MEMBERS

If you are not yet a member of Napo but encounter this problem we are willing, as part of the collective nature of the dispute, to be flexible around our usual rules about not representing someone who joins with an existing problem.

If someone fills in the questionnaire and joins Napo then we will progress their case alongside others in the same position. However, you must join Napo immediately for us to progress a questionnaire and we will review the level of legal support we can afford to support for members who had not taken out our “employment insurance” by joining Napo prior to the overpayment demand arriving.

Thursday, 13 June 2019

MoJ and Secrecy

As time goes by it will become increasingly apparent to more people why probation should never be part of the MoJ and disappear behind a wall of secrecy, subject to a stifling civil service command and control philosophy. The following ET case reported by Buzzfeed sheds some light on what the issues are:-   

An Academic Says She Was Bullied At The Ministry Of Justice After Revealing It Was Running A Programme That Made Sex Offenders More Likely To Reoffend

An academic whose research revealed that the Ministry of Justice’s treatment of sex offenders in prison might actually increase their chance of reoffending is suing the department. She says she was bullied out of her job after whistleblowing about the results. Dr Kathryn Hopkins worked as a researcher in the MoJ’s analytical services department. Her study of the controversial Sex Offender Treatment Programme (SOTP) suggested that five years on from release, prisoners who had been on the programme were more likely to commit a sexual offence again.

The SOTP was a six month group therapy course taken by thousands of prisoners serving sentences for rape, child abuse and other sexual offences from 1991 to 2017. The controversial scheme involved bringing offenders together in groups to discuss their crimes. 


Amongst those believed to have undergone the treatment programme are the black cab rapist John Worboys and several notorious paedophiles. Another alumnus of the SOTP course is Clive Sharp, who took the course after being convicted and jailed three times for sexual attacks including rape of an underage girl when he was 17. According to a report in the Mail on Sunday, he told his SOTP facilitator in the 1990s that he fantasised about tying up a woman, then raping and murdering her. When released in October 2012 he went on to do just that, sexually torturing, killing and dismembered a woman. He is now serving life with a minimum 37-year term.

Hopkins says she raised the alarm in early 2012 that it was not working – and indeed that her early findings suggested it increased reoffending and was a risk to public safety. In June 2012, an independent peer review recommended that the report could be published, subject to some changes. Instead of stopping the programme, the research was re-run in different ways over several years and eventually given to a different researcher to complete.

The hearing started at the Central Employment Tribunal in London on Monday and is expected to conclude next week. The MoJ had a solicitor and barrister appearing in court for them. Hopkins is making her case with no lawyer and began giving evidence on Tuesday. She argues that her career suffered after whistleblowing because she was taken off the project, given a critical performance review, overlooked for promotion, bullied by managers and was not named as an author on the final report.

The MoJ disputes her account. It says It had issues with her performance and that she was not listed as an author on the final report because it was a “complete reset and reconstruction and analysis of the data set” undertaken after she had been moved off the project.

It was not until January 2017 – almost five years after Hopkins raised her initial findings – that the MoJ stopped the SOTP. The MoJ argues this was because the research was more robust by this point. Despite multiple freedom of information requests which began in 2012, the final report was not published until June 2017, and that only happened five days after the report findings were published in the Mail on Sunday following a leak. The MoJ published the latest version of the research without naming Hopkins as an author.

In a witness statement to the court, she described the horrified reaction of managers and prison service officials when she called a meeting to break the news of the results in early 2012. “It was met with shock and anger - I was told that the results could not possibly be correct. I assured them that the methodology was robust, the datasets large, the follow-ups long, but this was not accepted. I pointed out that previous research in the area, upon which the claims of efficacy of the SOTP were based, were far inferior to the analysis I had undertaken, but I was not believed. I was told that the results must be wrong - but not given any indication as to why.”

The MoJ disputes her account of the meeting, arguing that she did not disclose her concerns that early and that the results were “insufficiently certain” at that stage for them to act. By the end of 2013, after another year of working on the project, Hopkins says she had run the evaluation again and discovered that increasing the sample size produced results that were stronger “and therefore even more alarming” than previously.

Hopkins says that she was made to re-run the study in different ways multiple times, including increasing the sample size, but the research was still not published. She told the court: “We kept on getting the same results, over and over and over again.” She says she blew the whistle multiple times to people within the MoJ and prison service, arguing that the SOTP should be stopped at least temporarily given the public safety implications of her findings.

In court documents she says: “I expressed my concern again about the public safety implications, and suggested that the SOTP should be stopped, even temporarily, until the research was finished. However, I was ignored.” Hopkins’ manager at the MoJ, whom she has accused of bullying her, argues in her witness statement that Hopkins was too emotionally involved in the research and “would just re-write the same analysis without undertaking full quality assurance”.

In court documents the manager says she considered “the problem was competence on [Hopkins’] part, as she did not appear to understand or be able to act on my and others’ concerns and/or a refusal to consider any other point of view except her own.” The manager said the department delayed publication because of quality concerns. “Publishing something that I still had major concerns about was going to damage the reputation of the department and may have an unwarranted negative impact on operational practice,” she said in a statement.

The MoJ argues that the need for extra scrutiny and to re-run the data was because of the seriousness of the national and international implications of the subject. It says they had concerns about the robustness of the methodology and that the delays were to make sure the report was of the best quality. However, the conclusions of the final study are similar to Hopkins’ initial findings. Hopkins’ initial report found that 7.9% of offenders who had attended the SOTP sexually re-offended, compared with 4.3% of untreated offenders. When the research was finally concluded, officially under a different author using slightly different methodology and a longer time span, the results showed a similar trend.

The final study said that 10% of sex offenders who went on the course committed at least one sexual re-offence (excluding breach) compared with 8.0% of matched comparison offenders who did not. The difference was even more marked for child sex offenders, with 4.4% of those on the course reoffending, compared to 2.9% of the comparison group.

Hopkins was told not to discuss the research findings and in December 2013 was told to respond to an FOI withholding the report, as it was 'about to be published'. She recalled: “I was not happy to do this, as I knew that there were no plans to publish the report, and felt that I had been asked to breach the Civil Service Code”. Hopkins argues that it was “common practice to make false statements in response to FOI requests,” citing revelations by BuzzFeed News last year over the failure to release a full report into unrepresented defendants under FOI. The Ministry of Justice disputes this.

In March 2014 Hopkins emailed a long complaint about the public protection issues associated with the SOTP to managers, alleging a cover-up by the MoJ. She complained about being asked to run and re-run analysis that always came up with the same results and said that her professional expertise was being ignored. She pleaded to have the report sent for independent peer review.

One manager said that they were unable to support the report’s publication in 2014 because “I and others both within and outside the Directorate could not be confident [it] was robust, as it had not addressed all issues raised through quality assurance processes.”

In December 2014 she was told her performance was “must improve”. Hopkins argues this was because of her whistleblowing and the pressure she was putting on the department to publish. However, in court papers her managers argue “there was evidence to support that her quality of work was inconsistent and had a higher volume of errors than was expected, and that she needed to demonstrate better collaborative working.”

Hopkins worked for the MoJ from 2007 until September 2016, when she moved to HMRC. The final paper was published on 30 June 2017.

Wednesday, 12 June 2019

MoJ Minister Says Very Little

Nobody seems to hang around long at the MoJ and after the breath of fresh air from Rory Stewart, the new incumbent doesn't sound that inspiring judging by his inaugural speech at the recent Modernising Justice conference. He reckons he 'knows what works' which should be sufficient cause for concern and he's obviously happy not returning 'probation' to his title.  

Robert Buckland QC speech: Modernising Criminal Justice Conference 2019

This is my first keynote speech as the Minister of State for Justice. That’s my full and frankly rather formal title. Many of you will be familiar with the more colloquial, the more catchy title: ‘Prisons Minister’.

As I have said to my team, I think the term ‘Justice Minister’ is actually a better fit for what I’m doing. That’s not some sort of rebranding exercise on my part, it’s because I think it’s important to take a ‘whole system approach’ to our criminal justice network, of which prisons are one important constituent part, but by no means the whole story. My other responsibilities include the probation service and they include sentencing policy as a whole.

Of course, in a sense, we’re not really talking about a single system at all – we’re talking about a kind of eco-system – made up of a complex network of separate yet interconnecting and mutually dependent systems, services and organisations. It’s where I’ve spent, as you’ve heard, most of my professional career – over 25 years in fact – first as a criminal barrister in courts like Swansea, Cardiff, Merthyr and Newport and also as a part-time judge in a Crown Court. For nearly 5 years I was the Solicitor General before taking up this post last month.

I have seen the trends. I have seen what works. I’ve also seen what doesn’t work. And I have seen how important it is that different parts of our system – and other sectors and services well beyond it – work properly together. And today’s conference provides an opportunity to share insights, to collaborate and to learn from each other as we continue to build a modern justice system, taking advantage of new technology and new approaches.

My direct experience of working within the criminal justice system has informed and shaped my views on how we improve it. In fact, in my very first speech in the House of Commons as a newly-elected MP some 9 years ago, I was clear about the need for us to be smart on crime and to look at tackling the causes of criminality, with the root of it all being crime prevention and early intervention. That’s what I still believe and will be one of my guiding principles as Justice Minister.

Now we all know that the criminal justice system should be much more effective at rehabilitating offenders so they don’t go on to commit more crime and to create more victims of crime. We all want to see justice delivered for victims of crime and a system that properly supports and protects those victims and vulnerable people too. And we all recognise that those who break the law need to be punished in a way that is proportionate, purposeful, and which protects the public.

Now I believe we are all united in that and, in general, in what needs to be done to deliver it. In a whole-system approach, we also need to make sure that respective structures and systems are united too. That’s why there are new structures in place in Her Majesty’s Prisons and Probation Service that will ensure we will have an equal focus on probation and prisons, and I’ll be working with Jo Farrar and her team to do just that. But as well as structures and systems, there’s another ‘S’ word that I believe is right at the heart of driving and implementing reform – and that’s ‘staff’.

Now having worked over the years with our hard-working and dedicated prison officers and probation officers – I don’t need to be persuaded of their contribution and huge importance to our system. You will know that we have invested significantly to increase staff numbers. We’ve recruited over 4,500 new prison officers – that’s exceeding the original target of 2,500. And that brings the total figure in the system to over 22,500 officers, returning us to around the same staffing levels as in March of 2012. And we’ve also appointed 700 extra probation service officers too.

Now I’d like to warmly welcome everybody who’s recently joined the service and sincerely thank everyone – old and new – who works in our prisons, in probation services – and indeed our wider justice system – for the often challenging and difficult work that they do – day in and day out. And I am clear that there is more we need to do to support our staff and to ensure that the workforce is more representative and I’ve already been listening to those needs and concerns. And I’ve also been struck by the expertise and commitment of the people I’ve met. And I look forward – politics permitting of course – to meeting many more of you very soon and to share in and see the great work you are doing.

What’s also struck me is just how important it is that we get the support right for prisoners so that they are set on a path towards rehabilitation and away from reoffending. And to do that, we need to focus our efforts from the inside out and from the outside in. Let me start from the inside out. We need prisons that are fundamentally safe and secure. That’s about ensuring we prevent drugs, mobile phones and other contraband entering our prison estate. Now a lot of work has been undertaken already to stop the flow of these items and to disrupt and bring to justice the criminal gangs who frankly are targeting our prisons.

This very much includes the 10 Prisons Project, supported by my predecessor. And may I pay tribute to the work of Rory Stewart. He served for 18 months in office and proved himself passionate, dedicated and brought real energy to the role. Rory of course notably said he would resign if violence and drugs didn’t reduce in the 10 prisons within a year. I have said I am going to do things my way, but I remain passionately interested in the outcomes of this project. As I am sure you will be.

We will report the results of the project publicly this coming August, twelve months after his announcement. We’ll be comparing a quarter’s assaults data from August 2018 with a quarter’s assaults data to June 2019. That will be, at the time, the most up to date data available at the conclusion of the project. And alongside this, we will also report mandatory drug testing results for the 10 prisons.

Being able to safely and securely hold those sentenced to custody – and effectively supervise people in the community – has to be the first thing we need to get right, but it can’t be the only thing. It’s also about having the right support in place that will prevent offenders committing more crime. We’ve just marked the first anniversary of the Education and Employment Strategy, that’s a vital strategy to ensure prison is a place where offenders can develop the skills they need to secure employment on release. It’s one of the key factors that will determine whether they reoffend. Let me give you just two examples of that important work:

The New Futures Network is brokering partnerships between prisons and employers to help businesses fill those skills gaps and for prisoners to find employment, initially it’s working in Yorkshire, Tees & Tyne and Wear and Wales and is now recruiting employment brokers to cover all of our jurisdiction. And last month, we announced changes to the release on temporary licence rules – the ROTL rules – which will allow prisoners to be considered for temporary release earlier to provide more opportunities to work and train with employers.

But as well as getting the conditions and support right in our prisons, we also need to look past the prison gates. We also need to tackle this from the outside in. And in February, the Secretary of State, David Gauke, set out a vision that recognises prison as the right place for the most serious offenders, but looks beyond the traditional prison estate to more innovative, effective alternatives in our community.

In particular, it’s clear that short prison sentences simply aren’t working. Over a quarter of all reoffending is committed by those who have served short sentences of 12 months or less. They trap people in a cycle of crime that is very difficult to break out of. The result is more offending, more victims, more crime. That’s why we think there is a case to abolish or further restrict the use of sentences of 6 months or less with some exceptions, and we hope to set out our proposals for consultation by the summer. And alongside this, we need to ensure that there are more robust and effective alternatives to prison in place.

And I want to make sure that sentencers have a real choice when it comes to the options before them. And having sat as a sentencer, I know from the perspective of the judge how important that is. Getting the balance right, getting the sentence right, not just to fit the crime but also to fit the criminal in the dock before the sentencer.

Now a key part of this shift from custody to community will be about harnessing and embracing modern technology. And we’ve seen how technology is already making a difference in the justice system. For example, our investment in new video conference centres is allowing local courts to hold virtual hearings and avoid the need to transport prisoners. In April, Her Majesty’s Prison and Youth Offending Institution Peterborough became the fourth prison to get a new centre.

Now careful and targeted use of technology can really help – it’s not just technology for technology’s sake – but to help deliver the outcomes we all want to see. And the same is true with community sentences. We’ve already announced the roll out of GPS tagging so that offenders in England and Wales can be monitored 24 hours a day. The tags have a very wide range of uses including creating no-go zones for an offender, checking that offenders are attending a rehabilitation programme and monitoring their whereabouts.

Last month, I visited the Manchester Electronic Monitoring Centre. And there, I saw the teams who are responsible for monitoring information generated from those GPS tags. I also learnt about how staff engage with other stakeholders, including prisons, probation, the police and courts. But new technology on its own is not enough. Collaboration with other parts of the system will be vital for the success of tagging, particularly when it comes to the enforcement of breaches.

Now despite its potential, new technology can only go so far. Confidence in community sentences starts with confidence in the probation services that deliver them. As we announced last month, we will be ending CRC contracts early and streamlining responsibilities for public, private and voluntary sector partners. Now that means a stronger and enhanced role for the National Probation Service in managing all offenders, greater voluntary sector involvement in rehabilitation, and the private sector leading where it has specialist experience and where it can support innovation in rehabilitating offenders and organising Unpaid Work placements.

Each National Probation Service region will have a private or voluntary sector partner – an Innovation Partner – who will be responsible for delivering Unpaid Work and Accredited Programmes in the community. And we will also be developing a commercial framework to allow the NPS to directly commission services on a scale that encourages the participation of those smaller suppliers and truly being responsive to the needs of local areas. And our plan is to ringfence an initial £20 million per year for a Regional Outcome Fund to be spent on innovative, cross-cutting approaches. And that will allow us to test services before expanding them.

These changes I believe will allow each sector to play to its strengths, to deliver more investment in skilled probation staff, and to ensure stronger supervision and support for offenders so that sentencers and indeed the public will have confidence in community alternatives to prison. I want to see prisons and probation systems working collaboratively with partners at a local and national level and work effectively together to deliver our new probation system.

As we make these changes, with care and due attention to the interests of our dedicated staff, we will continue to focus relentlessly on improving operational performance through the way in which we manage contracts and the investments we make in the delivery of services. So this year, for example, we will spend an additional £22 million supporting offenders as they move through the prison gate into the community.

And we also need to make sure that judges and magistrates get the right information on what probation services are available locally to improve the quality of rehabilitation support offered by probation in our communities. So for example, we are working very closely with the Department of Health and Social Care, NHS England and Public Health England to pilot a Treatment Requirement Programme to increase the number of community sentences that have mental health, drug and alcohol treatment requirements. Because frankly for too long, although those options have existed in the statute book, have they really been a reality for sentencers? I think not.

I know there are real challenges for our system. I am not prepared to just wring my hands and say: ‘Rome wasn’t built in a day’. As I have set out, there are things that we can do, and we are doing, and which will make a difference. Whether that difference is made through more joined-up support, better targeted interventions or by introducing and harnessing new technology, when we talk about “modernisation”, we must understand that our work frankly is never going to be fully done. What is “modern” today becomes quickly out of date if we aren’t constantly vigilant.

The prison and probation population is constantly changing. It presents new challenges each year. The idea that our justice system alone should – or could – be responsible for offender management – itself a term that I think is becoming increasingly inadequate to describe what we are trying to do – is just plain wrong. Without other agencies of national and local government, plus the private and third sectors, the justice system would be little more than a set of pious hopes and intentions.

I believe that by working closely together: prisons, probation, police, the courts, national, local, voluntary, private, public sector, these reforms will allow us to seize the opportunity to finally turn the tide on reoffending. We know what works, we know what the evidence says, we know what to do. And we’re getting on with it.

By doing so, by building on the progress made so far and, by harnessing that new technology, we can ensure our criminal justice system punishes those who have broken the law in a purposeful and in a targeted way – increasingly in our communities – and at the same time can better support offenders to turn away from crime for good and to re-join society as law-abiding citizens. Ultimately, that will mean, as I say, less crime, fewer victims and safer communities.


Robert Buckland QC

Tuesday, 11 June 2019

The MoJ Responds 3

Support for Offenders on Probation 

We recommend that the UK Government should introduce a presumption against short custodial sentences. The Government should carry out an assessment of the potential impacts that such a policy might have, including on the prison population, both the male and female estate, and the allocation of cases to different courts (Paragraph 140). 

We welcome the Committee’s support for sentencing reform and the recommendation to restrict the use of short custodial sentences. There is a strong case to abolish sentences of six months or less, with some exceptions. We are currently exploring options, including looking at the approach taken in Scotland and whether we can go further than this. This involves an assessment of potential impacts. 

If short custodial sentences continue to be used, within 12 months the Government should consider repealing Section 2 of the Offender Rehabilitation Act 2014. Before repealing the Section 2 provisions the Ministry should assess what policy or legislative measures should replace those provisions. (Paragraph 145) 

The Government is of the view that Post-Sentence Supervision under Section 2 of the Offender Rehabilitation Act should remain in place. This has led to the supervision of 40,000 additional offenders being released from short custodial sentences, and is a positive change for public safety. However, we are continuing to consider ways of improving post-sentence supervision, in order to clarify expectations for its delivery and ensure a focus on rehabilitation. We will also need to consider how proposals to reduce the use of short custodial sentences would impact on post-release supervision. We recommend that the Ministry of Justice should review the purpose of Through the Gate and the support that it provides offenders. 

As part of this review the Ministry should consider introducing a prisoner discharge pack, based on need, and minimum expectations on resettlement services offered and how offenders’ knowledge of accessing Government services through digital portals can be improved. Real consideration should be given to whether it is appropriate to release prisoners with few family ties, from custody on a Friday, when access to Government services can be difficult. (Paragraph 152). 

As part of our future arrangements set out above we are reviewing the purpose and focus of resettlement activity and looking at enhancing the role and pre-release planning time of the community responsible officer as well as providing greater clarity on service delivery in prison and from the community. We recognise that effective probation is dependent on offenders’ access to wider services, such as housing, universal credit and substance misuse treatment. We are working with other government departments on these issues, including through the cross-Whitehall Reducing Reoffending Board to facilitate this.

With regard to release on a Friday, automatic release points for custodial sentences are set in legislation. Where the release date falls on a weekend or Bank Holiday, the Criminal Justice Act 1961 requires the release date to be brought forward to the first preceding working day, i.e. Friday. Delaying when the prisoner is released to the next working day, i.e. Monday, would mean holding the person unlawfully. To amend the release arrangements, we would need to change primary legislation and we have no evidence to suggest that those released on Fridays are more likely to reoffend than those released on any other working day. 

We are currently considering responses to a recent consultation on the policy which highlighted the potential for Release on Temporary Licence (ROTL) to be used on a case by case basis to allow offenders with Friday release dates to access services and support before the weekend, where this has been identified as key by their community offender manager. 

We have, however, recognised the need for immediate action to improve Through the Gate services to prisoners. Contract changes agreed with CRCs in 2018 included an enhanced Through the Gate service to increase the current level of service from April 2019, and this includes minimum expectations for resettlement services for prisoners. This is supported by £22m per annum of additional investment (for the remaining lifetime of the existing CRC contracts), and applies to all prisoners being released from resettlement prisons. Almost 500 new staff have now been employed in the 86 resettlement prisons to provide this enhanced service. Provision of the new specification will also be available to those being discharged from non-resettlement prisons through NPS commissioning via the CRC Rate Cards which have been updated to include the enhanced TTG service and improvements have been made to the pay mechanism for this. We recommend that offenders should begin receiving pre-release resettlement activity no later than 12 weeks prior to release. 

When an offender requires pre-release support before the 12-week pre-release point that should be provided and CRCs should be appropriately remunerated. (Paragraph 156) 

We recognise that resettlement needs to be fully integrated into the offender management system, with prisons and probation working together to help offenders transition successfully to life in the community. As we develop our future approach to resettlement, we are looking to extend pre-release support beyond 12 weeks for offenders being released from prison. 

The Ministry of Justice should set out its minimum expectations to providers on the balance between remote and face-to-face supervision, and on the location of meetings between an offender and their Probation Officer (Paragraph 161) 

We accept this recommendation. We recognise the concerns that remote supervision should not be used as the only means by which an offender is supervised, and that the physical environment in which offenders are seen must be conducive to fostering open and honest engagement and maintaining confidentiality. 

We have already taken steps to change existing CRC contracts to introduce a minimum requirement for providers to offer monthly face-to-face contact with the responsible officer for the first 12 months of an offender’s order or licence. This will ensure that offenders are more closely supervised and provide a stronger basis to identify and enforce any breach of sentence. 

In future arrangements, we intend to specify through national standards the minimum frequency and form of offender contact. This will include a requirement for a minimum of monthly face to face contact for all offenders, with those posing a higher risk requiring a greater level of contact. Face to face contact will be required to take place where there is an appropriate level of privacy. Telephone contact will be permitted to support, but not replace, face to face contact. 

The Ministry of Justice should introduce national guidance on best practice relating to changes to an individual’s Probation Officer and case manager (Paragraph 164) 

We agree that to enable positive relationships to develop, wherever possible the same responsible officer should supervise an offender throughout their sentence. Evidence identifies the relationship between the responsible officer and the offender as key to desistence. As set out in the probation consultation response, we believe that bringing together offender management under one organisation will promote continuity of the responsible officer and enable effective monitoring of changes of responsible officer through the collection of management information. 

The National Standards for the Management of Offenders will be revised for future delivery of probation services and will be supported by practice guidance to drive up quality of delivery. This will include the importance of continuity and effective management of case transfer. 

When the Ministry of Justice responds to our Report it should have undertaken a review of output 3 of service element 6 of its guidance on unpaid work orders. It should set out in response to this Report any changes it will implement. (Paragraph 169) 

We are seeking to reduce stand downs on Unpaid Work through a number of measures. This includes changing the performance metric to a completion date of 12 months, to drive prompt delivery of unpaid work hours and holding providers to account through management information regarding rate of stand downs. We intend to specify in future contracts an appropriate number of placements to avoid the need to stand down offenders. 

Where it is necessary to stand down offenders, we have reviewed output 3 service element 6 and will change the specification to credit hours which reflect the individual circumstances of the offender, taking into account travel time and employment impact, with an hour being the minimum credit. 

We recommend that, where possible, unpaid work should contribute to the local community and be linked to education and training (Paragraph 172). 

Unpaid Work provides the opportunity to engage offenders in learning in a practical setting and 20% of the hours can be used to undertake employment related training, which is currently being underutilised. 

We are taking action to improve current delivery of unpaid work and will shortly issue guidance to providers to promote the appropriate use of the 20% education and training allowance which has been incorporated into revised Community Payback Practice Guidance. 

Future contracts will ensure that providers of Unpaid Work source sufficient group and individual placements to allow offenders to complete their requirement within their local community, where appropriate. The contract will require active engagement with local stakeholders and liaison with communities to source local placements. Providers will be required to source placements which can develop personal and practical employment related skills for service users with education, training and employment related needs. 

It is intended that in future contracts all offenders will be assessed for employment, education and training needs and the 20% allowance will be maximised to address these needs. The allowance for education and training activity has been extended to employed services users with an identified employment need and includes preparatory and motivational work. There will be additional flexibility at the start of Intensive Unpaid Work orders, based on need, so that an offender can build up to the minimum of 28 hours per week. 

We recommend that the Government should amend the Homelessness Code of Guidance for Local Authorities, to make it explicit that an individual who is homeless because of having served a custodial sentence should be deemed vulnerable for the purposes of the Homelessness Reduction Act 2017. We further recommend that the UK Government should work with the Welsh Government to ensure that their homelessness legislation takes due account of the risks of reoffending. (Paragraph 182) 

Homelessness legislation already provides that a person who is vulnerable as a result of having served a custodial sentence has priority need for accommodation, and the statutory Homelessness Code of Guidance reflects the legislation as amended by the Homelessness Reduction Act (HRA) 2018. The HRA significantly amended homelessness legislation to strengthen duties to all eligible applicants, irrespective of priority need or intentional homelessness, and in this context we have no plans to amend the priority need categories at this time. 

The guidance issued in 2018 now includes a dedicated chapter focussing on supporting those with a history of offending into suitable accommodation. Contained within that new chapter is: ‘A person who is vulnerable as a result of having served a custodial sentence, been committed for contempt of court or remanded in custody, has a priority need for accommodation’. As part of the planned review of the HRA, the effectiveness of the guidance in supporting those with priority, including those with a history of offending, will be assessed. 

Local authorities now have a duty to take reasonable steps to prevent or relieve homelessness, including to people with a history of offending. From 1 October 2018, prison and probation services have a duty to refer any user of their service who they consider to be homeless or threatened with homelessness within 56 days to a local authority of the person’s choice. The duty to refer will encourage local housing authorities and other public authorities to build stronger partnerships focussed on early help and intervention and to build more integrated pathways and services. The duty will help ensure that people who face the threat of homelessness are identified earlier and provided with help to prevent them from becoming homeless. 

As part of the implementation of the Government’s Rough Sleeping Strategy, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government is working with colleagues in the Ministry of Justice to pilot a scheme to support individuals released from three prisons, who are at risk of becoming homeless or sleeping rough. The contracts for these three pilots will be awarded at the end of April and will operate over a three year period. The pilots will test a new partnership approach with prisons, Probation Providers and Local Authorities working together, to plan, secure and sustain accommodation for offenders on their release. 

The Government has committed to review the implementation of the HRA within two years which will provide a forum to consider a range of issues such as these.

Although the Housing (Wales) Act removed the priority status of prison leavers in Wales, it also introduced an Accommodation Pathway for people leaving the custodial estate to respond to concerns that this change might cause. HMPPS was, and continues to be, fully involved in the development of the pathway to ensure it meets the needs of offenders leaving custody and provides for a successful transfer to the community. 

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice should work with the Department for Work and Pensions to enable offenders serving custodial sentences to apply for Universal Credit (UC) prior to their release from custody so that they receive UC on the day of release. As an interim measure, and until offenders can receive UC upon release, the Government should set up a transitional credit fund for those offenders who have insufficient funds to provide for the basics, such as travel, a roof over their heads and food, in recognition that £46 is wholly inadequate to cover these. (Paragraph 187). 

We agree that offenders should have prompt access to the benefits to which they are entitled on the day of release. We are working with the Department for Work and Pensions to improve the process to access Universal Credit, help offenders pre-populate their claim in custody and to ensure that they have the relevant identification documents. Offenders are able to access a DWP Work Coach prior to release who can make an appointment as early as the day of release to complete their claim, and can receive an advance of a full month’s benefit, including the housing element where appropriate, within hours. 

The purpose of the Discharge Grant is not to provide for all the prisoner’s needs after release. It is intended solely to assist them in the first few days after release and before they might reasonably be able to get a job or an appointment at a jobcentre and/or begin to access state benefits. We have recently concluded our review of the current use of the Discharge Grant and Discretionary Accommodation Payment. We are currently analysing our findings. 

In addition, existing policy provides for an amount of up to £50 (in addition to the discharge grant) to be provided directly to an accommodation provider to enable an offender to secure accommodation, at the Governor’s discretion. Every discharged offender, regardless of whether they receive a discharge grant, is also issued with a travel warrant, or payment of fares where a warrant is inappropriate, to their destination. Offenders are also discharged with any prison earnings/private cash. 

The Government should consider how offenders who are being released to an unknown or non-fixed address can be supported in having access to a bank account, so that an absence of such an account does not prohibit the offenders from getting a job, claiming benefits or securing a place to live. (Paragraph 190) 

Action is already underway to improve offenders’ access to bank accounts on release from custody. The Offender Banking Programme enables prisons which release significant numbers of offenders to develop a relationship with a commercial bank. This allows offenders to open a basic bank account in the last six months of their sentence. In 2017, 6,500 accounts were opened under this scheme – a record number. In April this year a new CRC specification has come into force to make clear the expectation that the CRC is responsible for arranging for prisoners to get a Bank Account. 

HMPPS also continues to work with UK Finance to look at other potential forms of identification which can be used by offenders who are released without accounts and we are working with HMT to encourage the challenger banks to join the programme to provide more capacity including in the Youth Estate.

The Long-Term Delivery of Probation Services 

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice should initiate a review into the long-term future and sustainability of delivering probation services under the models introduced by the TR reforms, including how performance under the TR system might compare to an alternative system for delivering probation. The Government should publish its review, in full, by 1 February 2019. Given the issues which have arisen due to the speedy implementation of the TR reforms and lack of piloting, any new model must be thoroughly planned and tested. (Paragraph 200) 

We have taken the time to think about what worked well, as well as what didn’t, under the Transforming Rehabilitation reforms. Further, the public consultation on the future of probation generated feedback on every aspect of the current system. We have reflected carefully on this feedback to ensure that future arrangements benefit from the expertise and experience of providers, service users, voluntary organisations, sentencers, probation staff and other partners. 

We want to build on the positive changes introduced by Transforming Rehabilitation, while accepting there have been challenges resulting from the complexities of contractualising offender management and splitting functions between the NPS and CRCs. In our future approach, we intend that the NPS will have responsibility for all offender management services - for low, medium and high-risk offenders. Private and not-for-profit organisations have demonstrated their strength in delivering interventions and driving innovation. We will retain and build on this success by sourcing key services, such as Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes, and other resettlement and rehabilitative interventions from the private and not-for-profit markets. We intend to do this through competitions for suppliers for Unpaid Work and Accredited Programmes, and through creation of a dynamic framework for resettlement and rehabilitative interventions. 

We will now run a period of market and stakeholder engagement to finalise our proposals, including on how services will be packaged within competitions, and to set out further detail on the service design for future services. We will then seek to launch the competition processes later in the year for Unpaid Work and Accredited Programmes and the dynamic framework. 

We aim to complete the reintegration of offender management under the NPS in Wales before the end of 2019, and in England around spring 2021. We will seek to apply any lessons learnt from transition in Wales, where probation services are already co-terminous, when transitioning services in England.

(Concluded)

The rehabilitation system has suffered hugely as a result of the failed reforms

Commenting on the Government’s full response to its report on Transforming Rehabilitation, Chair of the Justice Committee, Bob Neill MP, said:

“The MoJ has finally responded to the recommendations in our Transforming Rehabilitation report, eleven months after it was published. We welcome the MoJ’s announcement that all offenders will be brought under the supervision of the National Probation Service. But it has been a very long time coming, and the system has suffered hugely as a result of the failed reforms. Indeed, some people have told us that they welcomed the new proposals as ‘probation could hardly get worse’. We will question Robert Buckland, the responsible Minister, next week on what went wrong and details of the proposed new probation system.”

(We will cover what Mr Buckland had to say as soon as the transcript is published. MoJ staff including Jim Barton get a grilling tomorrow.)  

Monday, 10 June 2019

The MoJ Responds 2

Providers and Working Relationships 

We recommend that from 1 February 2019 the Ministry of Justice should publish information on probation supply chains for each CRC area and NPS region on a quarterly basis. This should include information on all sub-contractors (not just those in the voluntary sector) and the monetary value of the sub-contracts. (Paragraph 100) 

We do not accept this recommendation. Under Schedule 4 of the Amended and Restated Services Agreement we cannot publish information which has supplier information included, without their permission, as it is commercially sensitive. 

However, we are working with providers to seek agreement to publish sub-contractor lists on a quarterly basis and improve transparency in this respect. The Ministry will require agreement from both the Parent Organisations and Sub-Contractors themselves for this information to be published. 

We will monitor the health of CRC supply chains by requiring confirmation that payments due to supply chain partners are made in line with contractual obligations. 

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice should consider, in response to this Report, what benefits might be gained from reintroducing targets for each Community Rehabilitation Company on the proportion of its budget which should be spent on voluntary sector provision, and whether involving some of the smaller, more specialised voluntary sector organisations could be incentivised. (Paragraph 102) 

Given their shortened lifespan we do not intend to introduce new requirements or targets for Community Rehabilitation Companies. 

In future arrangements we want to see a much clearer role for a wide range of voluntary sector providers in probation delivery, including local and specialist services. Throughout the consultation we were told that we needed to consider how to create the right environment to enable these organisations to deliver resettlement and rehabilitation services. To make the most of the range of providers available, we believe that these interventions should be commissioned and delivered locally where possible. 

We have developed an approach to support the direct participation of smaller voluntary sector providers in the delivery of resettlement and rehabilitation activities. This will be through the procurement of a dynamic framework across England and Wales. The dynamic framework will operate as an open panel of suppliers, who can be admitted to the panel at any point during its lifetime subject to a qualification process (based on experience and capabilities). 

By 1 February 2019, the Ministry of Justice should review the ISPA, with a view to reducing its length and complexity. The Ministry should write to the Committee after that review to set out the changes that it has made. (Paragraph 106) 

We received significant feedback on the ISPA in the responses to the consultation and continue to review how we best ensure the contract meets the needs of the supply chain. The MoJ is committed to ensuring voluntary sector participation in procurement. 

We recommend that the National Probation Service and Community Rehabilitation Companies should be required to provide the Ministry of Justice with workforce data on a quarterly basis. This should include information on the recruitment and retention rates for Probation Officers and other case managers by grade, and total workforce numbers by NPS area and CRC. This data should be published by the Ministry as part of its quarterly statistics. (Paragraph 116) 

As of October 2018, workforce data – including information on recruitment and retention – is collected from CRCs as well as the NPS. The CRC providers are the owners of this information, and given it is commercially sensitive, publication is not possible. 

However, the Ministry is utilising this information to support whole-system probation workforce planning and the design of future contracts. In addition, we are investigating whether this information can be shared publicly. 

We recommend that from 2019 all providers, both CRCs and the NPS, should be required to use the same, or a similar, staff survey each year. Results of those staff surveys should be published for the seven NPS areas and the 21 CRCs. (Paragraph 119). 

In future, all offender management will be delivered by NPS staff, who are civil servants. They will therefore be subject to the wider Government staff survey.

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice should publish a probation workforce strategy, which covers both staff working in the NPS and CRCs, in the next 12 months. As a minimum, the strategy should set out the Ministry’s expectations with regard to professional standards, training, maximum caseloads/workloads for probation staff. This strategy should be developed in consultation with the trade unions and HM Inspectorate of Probation. (Paragraph 126). 

We do not accept this recommendation. Rather, HMPPS is developing a wide-ranging HR programme as part of its professional recognition programme. We recognise that resource requirements to manage cases will vary. As a result, HMPPS is seeking to deploy a common tiering framework for offender management to enable comparisons of workload. Current workforce planning assumptions for offender management are for average caseloads to be below 60. This is in line with HM Inspectorate of Probation guidance, which states: “Aggregate caseloads of more than 60 cases would normally be considered difficult to supervise effectively.” 

We are working hard to recruit more probation officers. In 2018, 707 Probation Service Officers were appointed, some of whom will be training to become qualified probation officers. 

We also want to ensure that our staff’s professional service is supported by ongoing continuous professional development and recognition through an independent statutory register for probation professionals and intend to bring forward legislation when Parliamentary time allows to establish this. This will help ensure there is a shared identify and culture amongst all staff who will be in the NPS in the future. 

By 1 February 2019, the Ministry of Justice should ensure that security constraints and IT barriers which prevent data from being shared between organisations involved in managing an offender from the point of arrest, in prison and through to support in the community are proportionate. This should include identifying how the number of IT systems could be rationalised and/or linked so that the same data is not repeatedly inputted into different systems. (Paragraph 131) 

As outlined in the consultation, we recognise the importance of simplifying data access and improving data sharing. Action is already underway to facilitate better access to essential data for probation providers. 

Data sharing arrangements with other departments already exist, including with the Police, DWP, HMRC as well as between prison and probation services. Since January 2018, HMPPS has taken in-house the management of the prison case management system, Prison NOMIS, and the risk and needs assessment tool, OASys. This enables us to make changes and develop Application Programme Interfaces (APIs), which facilitate greater, faster and better data sharing internally and externally. This includes an interface to the MoJ analytics platform and performance platform. Work is also underway to migrate the probation case management system, National Delius, to a new cloud environment that is expected to reduce a number of the current access and related security constraints. This is due to be completed by the summer. 

As part of the development of the next generation of probation services, we plan to simplify data access and exchange across HMPPS digital services and deliver improvements to IT systems. We are working towards greater centralisation of data systems, in particular those relating to risk and needs assessments, and improved data sharing within HMPPS and with external partners. The HMPPS Digital and Technology Strategy is looking to address the current need for users to have access to multiple HMPPS systems and work towards establishing data services that provide the relevant information the user needs via a single interface.

(To be continued)

Sunday, 9 June 2019

The MoJ Responds

I notice that the MoJ have responded to the issues raised by the Justice Committee and although somewhat lengthy, it's probably necessary to try and digest it by means of several chunks, this being the first:-   

Transforming Rehabilitation: Government Response to the Committee’s Ninth Report of Session 2017–19


Introduction 

The Government welcomes the report of the Justice Committee on Transforming Rehabilitation. The following document provides a response to each of the Committee’s recommendations which takes account of developments since the publication of the report in June 2018. In particular, responses to individual recommendations should be seen in the context of the planned reforms set out in the Government’s response to the public consultation Strengthening Probation, Building Confidence. 

The importance of the Justice Committee’s report is reflected in the Government’s decision to end contracts for Community Rehabilitation Companies early, in the publication of the public consultation on the future of probation, and in the nature of the strategic changes being brought forward. These changes are intended to directly address the structural challenges identified by the Justice Committee and reiterated in feedback from the public consultation, subsequent reports from other key stakeholders such as HM Inspectorate of Probation, and by our own internal analysis of lessons learned from Transforming Rehabilitation. 

Structural Issues 

We recommend that any significant changes made by the Ministry of Justice to CRC contracts, including those currently underway, should be publicly disclosed. This disclosure should include information on any significant changes to the payment model and funding for CRCs, as well as information on what the Ministry expects to receive in return for the changes. (Paragraph 42). 

Notice of significant changes made by the Ministry of Justice to CRC contracts have been published in the Official Journal of the European Union (OJEU). Regarding recently agreed changes, notice of confirmation that contract changes have been agreed was published on 8th February 2019. In the event that the Department makes any future substantial changes to the CRC contracts it will comply with any applicable transparency requirements in accordance with the Public Contracts Regulations 2015 including, for example, publication of Modification Notices in the Official Journal of the European Union. 

The Ministry of Justice should move away from a “sticking-plaster” approach of rolling contract negotiations following the current round of renegotiations. If contracts are to be terminated the Ministry of Justice needs to ensure that transition plans are put in place which make sure that: offenders receive the support they require to be rehabilitated and their risk of reoffending does not increase.

The Ministry should undertake a public consultation on any further changes to ensure a wider range of views on contractual arrangements. This public consultation should consider the number of CRCs and the bodies eligible to bid for CRC contracts (Paragraph 46). 

We have taken action to terminate existing contracts early and put in place new arrangements for delivery of probation services. We also made changes to secure operational stability over the remaining, shortened, period of existing CRC contracts, including investing an additional £22 million a year in Through the Gate support for offenders when they leave prison. 

Between 27 July and 21 September 2018, we conducted a public consultation, Strengthening probation, building confidence. This sought the views of stakeholders and the wider public on a range of proposals for the future of probation. We have taken consultation responses into account as we have developed our new plans and set out the action we intend to take and our strategic approach to the future arrangements for delivery of probation services in our response on 16 May. 

We are developing a transition strategy to ensure a smooth handover from incumbent providers to new providers, and effectively manage the integration of offender management responsibilities into the National Probation Service. This will include a variety of measures to protect operational continuity of services and minimise uncertainty for staff and offenders, informed by our ongoing engagement with Trade Unions and other partners. We will also ensure we learn lessons from the integration of offender management delivery in Wales, which we plan to deliver by the end of 2019. 

The Ministry of Justice should continue to closely monitor the financial position of all CRCs to ensure that no CRC is suddenly unable to deliver probation services. It should ensure its contingency plans reflect the Principles set by the National Audit Office in its paper on “Managing Provider Failure”. (Paragraph 49). 

We accept this recommendation. As part of our full review of probation services, we have built a comprehensive picture of CRC finances. While the Department expects all CRCs to continue delivering services throughout the remaining life of the contracts, we have extensive contingency plans in place should any provider be unable to deliver their contractual requirements. We have a contingency steering group which regularly reviews the likelihood of provider failure, based on commercial, financial and operational intelligence. We have detailed contingency plans in place for all contracts, which align with the National Audit Office principles. The plans have been developed, reviewed and tested with input from relevant functions within the Ministry of Justice and HMPPS, relevant specialists across government, key officials involved in the implementation of contingency responses in other government areas and external advisors. The plans are subject to regular review. 

The Department’s response to the Administration in February 2019 of CRCs operated by Working Links demonstrates the strength of our contingency planning. The Department arranged for and oversaw a successful transfer of affected services in the South West and Wales to Kent, Surrey and Sussex CRC (operated by SeeTec). Probation services remained fully operational throughout this period.

The Ministry should conduct a review after HMI Probation’s new inspection regime has been in place for a year to assess: the number of providers who are rated ‘good’ or ‘outstanding’; the additional burden being placed on providers because of the increased frequency of inspection; and whether there were any elements of the inspection and audit regimes which could be consolidated. (Paragraph 55) 

We do not accept this recommendation. A Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on inspections has been agreed between the Ministry of Justice, HM Prison and Probation Service and HMIP. The MoU is regularly reviewed and will be fully updated in due course to reflect the implications of future probation arrangements for the oversight of probation. 

The MoU sets out how HMIP will target its recommendations following inspections and how the Ministry will respond to HMIP’s recommendations (and the implications for differing perspectives between contractual standards/SLAs and HMIP inspection standards). 

It also sets out an agreed approach to oversight of the probation system following the introduction of the inspectorate’s new inspection methodology from April 2018. HMIP is in the process of consulting on lessons learned from the first year’s application of its new inspection methodology. 

Given the different roles and remits of inspection and audit there are limits on the extent to which these functions can be consolidated. To avoid placing an excessive burden on individual providers, the MoU confirms that HMIP and the Operational Assurance team in HMPPS will share timetables of inspection and audit visits and liaise on any issues arising from the timetabling. 

The role of HMIP in providing an independent oversight of the quality of probation services will continue under future arrangements and HMI Probation will continue to independently set and review their inspection standards. MoJ and HMPPS will work closely with the inspectorate so that HMIP can consider the best approach to its future inspection regime taking account of the proposed changes to structures. 

The Ministry of Justice should review contract performance measures so that they focus on outcomes, especially on housing, employment and drug rehabilitation, rather than inputs or outputs. This review should be completed by 1 February 2019 (four years after probation services were fully divided between the NPS and CRCs). (Paragraph 62) 

Given their shortened duration the Government does not intend to review or make significant changes to existing CRC contract performance measures. As part of the programme of work underway to implement the changes set out in the Government’s response to the consultation Strengthening Probation, Building Confidence, we are developing key performance outcomes and measures to hold the National Probation Service and future contracted providers to account on their respective responsibilities. It remains our intention, as set out in the consultation response, that the future performance framework will take an outcome-focused approach to measuring quality of service delivery. It will be the responsibility of the NPS to ensure offenders receive the right interventions to improve outcomes such as accommodation, employment and health, and ultimately reduce re-offending. We will ensure the contract performance measures drive providers to focus on the quality of the services they deliver, in order to support changed lives and reduced reoffending. We will set out more detail in due course. 

In response to this Report the Ministry should set out whether the 2011 baseline for reoffending is the correct measure against which CRC performance should be assessed. If the Ministry believes that the 2011 baseline remains the correct measure it should set out its reasons why. (Paragraph 66) 

We set out in the consultation that, to provide a better reflection of CRC performance on frequency of reoffending, and to support providers in maintaining effective probation services, we would offer to amend contracts to measure CRCs against a 2015/16 baseline, rather than a baseline set in 2011. We have agreed to vary contracts with 20 of 21 CRCs. Merseyside CRC, which is owned by Purple Futures, chose to retain the 2011 baseline. 

By January 2019, when the next annual cohort data is released on final binary and frequency reoffending performance, the Ministry should ensure that CRCs receive full data relating to which of their offenders reoffended. (Paragraph 71) 

The Ministry of Justice does not have control access to the Police National Computer data, on which reoffending performance is based, and is unable to give access to the data to CRCs. This was explained during the bidding phase for CRC contracts, and some CRCs have made arrangements to access the data themselves at cost. To enable CRCs to assess progress against their targets, the Ministry of Justice published interim figures during the period in which full ‘one year’ reoffending results were not available. We continue to provide these interim figures to all CRCs. 

In response to this Report the Government should set out what other steps it is taking to address underperformance of CRCs, including in cases where service credits are not applied. (Paragraph 74) 

We have acknowledged that CRCs need to do more to improve performance in some areas. As part of negotiations on current contracts, we have introduced changes to improve performance over the now shortened remaining term of the contracts, including implementation of a new requirement to offer a minimum of monthly face-to-face contact with offenders and an enhanced specification for Through the Gate services. 

Our contract management teams continue to robustly monitor CRC contracts. Assurance includes a combination of tracking compliance against contractual obligations and assessment of the quality of service delivery. Contract Management teams have identified a series of ‘risk based’ areas – key areas of service delivery where the greatest attention is required. There are strict monthly reporting processes, including the provision of detailed management information, to facilitate robust oversight of these areas. 

Where CRC service level performance is below a prescribed level, Contract Management teams implement improvement plans to address service delivery against a specific performance metric. As of February 2019, there were 26 specific improvement plans in place across 12 of the CRCs and covering 7 service metrics.

CRCs are also required to implement action plans to address HM Inspectorate of Probation and Operational and System Assurance Group findings and recommendations. Contract Management teams agree these plans with CRCs before implementation and hold CRCs to account against the recommendations using monthly governance arrangements. 

Our starting presumption is that service credits are applied if accrued by CRCs for underperformance. On those occasions where it has been considered appropriate not to apply the service credits we have instead sought to agree a reinvestment of the value of the service credit back into the delivery of services. 

Should the Government decide that probation services should continue to be delivered as per the Transforming Rehabilitation reforms, we recommend that the Government should ask HM Inspectorate of Probation to conduct a review of how best offenders should be distributed between the NPS and CRCs, and to investigate the impact of changing offender risk and how the NPS and CRCs manage this matter. (Paragraph 76). 

As set out in the Government’s response to the probation consultation, the split in responsibility for offender management on the basis of risk will not be retained under future probation arrangements. In future the National Probation Service will have responsibility for managing all offenders on a community order or on licence following release from prison. This clearer set of responsibilities will reduce duplication of roles and improve clarity and accountability whilst ensuring that we make the best use of wider private and voluntary sector provision. 

There are clear benefits for risk escalation procedures to having a single organisation responsible for managing offenders. This will allow us to better respond to changes in caseloads – for example, increases or decreases to the proportion of high or medium-low risk offenders – as well as improving continuity of supervision and removing inefficiencies as cases will no longer be required to be passed between the NPS and CRC as assessment of risk changes. 

The Ministry of Justice should assess whether it remains appropriate to encourage the NPS to use CRC Rate Card services, or whether the NPS should be liberalised to develop its own supply chain as a matter of course (Paragraph 87). 

Transforming Rehabilitation showed that real partnership working between public and private sectors can drive innovation. We recognise however that some CRCs have struggled to invest in the development of their supply chains and have often relied on developing and delivering Rate Card services themselves. This has affected the range of services they have been able to make available through the Rate Card and there has been much lower than expected use of rate card services by the NPS. 

Under plans for future probation arrangements, we are committed to harnessing the expertise and innovation of the voluntary and private sectors through the delivery of interventions – such as Unpaid Work, Accredited Programmes and wider resettlement and rehabilitative interventions, with the clear expectation that the NPS will source these services from the market. Each NPS region will have a private or voluntary sector partner responsible for direct provision of Unpaid Work and Accredited Programmes, and supporting the NPS to identify and deliver wider innovation.

We intend to create a separate dynamic commercial framework across England and Wales for the NPS to directly procure rehabilitation and resettlement services under future probation arrangements. This is central to our plans to streamline the system and develop a greater role for smaller providers, including voluntary sector providers in future probation arrangements. Our market analysis has shown this approach, which will allow for more direct and flexible local and regional approaches to commissioning services, would be welcomed by the voluntary sector. 

The dynamic framework will operate as an open panel of suppliers, who can be admitted to the panel at any point during its lifetime subject to a qualification process (based on experience and capabilities). Eligible panel members will be invited to participate in mini-competitions for the services required. Contracts will be designed flexibly, so that innovative approaches that show results can be quickly identified and spread across the wider system. 

We recommend that in response to this Report the Ministry of Justice should set out its vision for future local accountability of probation and the role that Police and Crime Commissioners might play. (Paragraph 90) 

We have engaged PCCs on how they could more effectively support probation services in the future and how probation can better work with them to engage with the local criminal justice system. We want NPS Regional Directors to be working with PCCs to identify shared strategic priorities, with an expectation that they would seek opportunities to co-commission services that reduce reoffending. To enable this, we are considering how probation performance and needs data can be meaningfully shared at a local level. Where appropriate, PCCs will also be represented during the recruitment process for the Regional Director posts. We will continue to engage with PCCs to ensure probation can take advantage of their developing role in local criminal justice systems.

(To be continued)