Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Probation Must be Devolved by Default!


For those who are really keen, you can read the full monty speech here, but I've picked out what I think are the key bits. 1) Andy Burnham is keen on devolution 2) Civil servants haven't a bloody clue how to run a successful probation service 3) There is zero chance of "pride and trust" being restored under HMPPS control 4) Before Dame Antonia got to it, the Probation Service was already a gold winning "genuinely world class organisation". We demand probation is devolved now and out of the bloody civil service!  

"The Prime Minister has set an ambitious objective for his Government, to deliver good growth in every part of the UK – including through devolution by default. The Civil Service’s job is to deliver the Government’s agenda. That puts devolution by default at the heart of our work.

It will require a fundamental rewiring of the way the state works, and a major shift in powers and resources from Westminster to communities and regions. And a more collaborative approach, ensuring policy made in Westminster helps the communities that most need it.

This new approach to give power to communities will be a central part of the Prime Minister’s 10 year plan. It represents a radical change to central government - genuinely devolving power, not just delegating it.

---//---
The Future Civil Service programme has three central principles:
  • Delivery,
  • Innovation and Productivity, and
  • Pride and Trust.
---//---
The Review into the Organisation, Performance and Transformation of the Permanent Civil Service - which began in July and will report to the Prime Minister before next summer - will set out a vision for the future of the Civil Service for the decades ahead, as a genuinely world class organisation serving the duly elected government of the day, with relentless focus and determination.

It will follow the Prime Minister’s 10 year plan to rewire the state by putting devolution by default and power to communities at the heart of our future operating model.

The Review will confront the tough questions:
  • Whether current departmental structures remain optimal in an era of cross-cutting delivery?
  • What AI and devolution by default mean for Civil Service boundaries, and accountability?
  • And how to build the capabilities needed for the future, at national, regional and local level? What will this require of us?
 A change programme of this size demands imagination, determination, and visible leadership.

It is being led by the Permanent Secretaries, and we are asking all leaders across the Civil Service to demonstrate energetic and positive leadership, showing passion for high performance, grounded in the highest standards to motivate and support their teams as we transform the Service.

---//---
Thank you very much."
Dame Antonia Romeo

--oo00oo--

Note - "Devolution is the transfer of power, responsibility, and decision-making from a central government to regional, national, or local authorities."

78 comments:

  1. Seen on Twitter from Ian Acheson:-

    "It was good of Antonia Romeo to find the time to lecture #OurAndy on the importance and urgency of civil service reform. Here's an example of how disastrous the blob is at managing change that I suspect didn't make the cut in her speech.

    I've absolutely avoided the tittle tattle around Romeo's previous conduct mainly because of my own experience of being a pushy outsider in CS. I've focused on aspects of her performance which have been effectively memory holed. 'Transforming Rehabilitation' is exhibit A Romeo while DG at the MoJ was Senior Responsible Officer for this part privatisation of the probation service which was a total disaster from start to finish. Government ideological vandalism certainly but implemented by her. She assured parliament the doomed transformation programme “is going to work and isn’t taking on any unnecessary risk” It was a total fuck up from start to finish when Probation was returned to public sector after wastage of £467 million underestimated costs and bail outs. The probation union said the process was a “shambles” with “zero communication”, increased paperwork, fragmented risk management, deskilling and demoralisation of staff, and poorer outcomes for offenders being supervised. In other words it put the community at greater risk. £9 million alone was spent on consultancy trying to gild this turd while probation officers had their pay frozen. The National Audit Office demolished the programme finding 'systemic failings' in design and implementation, aspects she was fully responsible for as SRO. So it's for this reason and this alone I have serious reservations about the spin that says she's equal to the task of 'rewiring government.' It doesn't matter that she's a women and ambitious (oh no!) or all the fluff around her media profile. What matters is *delivery*. But airbrushing serious failures won't cut it either. The systemic rot in the senior lanyard class in public service is a 'mediocracy' - people promoted up to and well beyond their level of competence. Not sure she's the best exemplar of how to tackle that. We shall see."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Peter Principle seems to be at its strongest in the Probation service !

      Delete
    2. The Peter principle is a concept in management developed by Laurence J. Peter which observes that people in a hierarchy tend to rise to "a level of respective incompetence": employees are promoted based on their success in previous jobs until they reach a level at which they are no longer competent, as skills in one job do not necessarily translate to another.

      The concept was explained in the 1969 book The Peter Principle (William Morrow and Company) by Laurence Peter and Raymond Hull. Hull wrote the text, which was based on Peter's research. Peter and Hull intended the book to be satire, but it became popular as it was seen to make a serious point about the shortcomings of how people are promoted within hierarchical organizations. The Peter principle has since been the subject of much commentary and research.

      Delete
  2. Devolved to what though? As councils, mayors and social service are rotten, and privatisation is a no go.

    ReplyDelete
  3. On the "devolved to what?" question, I think the post runs together two separate things: who employs and governs probation (currently HMPPS inside the civil service), and who sets local priorities and buys local services. Romeo's speech is generic "devolution by default" language, not a probation commitment, so that leap is more wishful thinking, not her thinking.
    On the first, I don't see trusts returning in their old local form, but the idea hasn't gone. Napo's non-departmental body and the Howard League's Community Justice Agency are essentially a national trust: independent employer, own standards, own professional identity, out of HMPPS. That fixes the "civil servants don't know probation" problem without putting risk decisions in front of local politicians. The MoJ consultation on independent regulation of practitioners closed in October, so the professional-standards machinery may arrive whatever happens to the employer question.

    PCCs go in 2028, but their functions pass to mayors, or to council-leader boards where there's no mayor, so there is a vehicle. The Greater Manchester MoU shows the scope: co-commissioning of housing, drug treatment, family and peer support. It doesn't cover supervision or risk. Councils being hard pressed is an argument for ring-fenced money, not for skipping the local layer.
    The Reform-mayor worry is fair, but at commissioning level the exposure is limited. A mayor can influence which services get bought, not who gets recalled. National standards, ring-fenced budgets, minimum service floors and HMIP inspection are the guardrails. The government is already accepting party-political mayors over police governance, which is higher stakes.
    Timpson going and Burnham arriving change the odds. Burnham built the GM model, so I'd expect co-commissioning MoUs to spread as PCC functions move to mayors, with the Welsh one due by December. Taking probation out of the civil service is a different fight, and I've seen nothing to suggest the new government will concede it. I've also found not been able to find any outcome evaluation showing GM's model has reduced reoffending.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Now milburn turns his hand to rewiring the state.

    "After leaving university, he returned to Newcastle where, with Martin Spence, he operated a small radical bookshop in the Westgate Road, called Days of Hope (the shop was given the Spoonerised nickname Haze of Dope). He studied for a PhD at Newcastle University, but did not complete his thesis... In 1997 he was appointed Minister of State at the Department of Health, an important post in which he had responsibility for driving through Private Finance Initiative deals on hospitals..."

    "We will always ensure there is a safety net for the most vulnerable and those who are unable to work... BUT... under-25s will no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit or personal independence payment"

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwn70l1628l0o

    "Some young people could see reductions to the benefits they are entitled to under a radical overhaul of the welfare system to be recommended by a government-commissioned review.

    Alan Milburn's year-long report, which will be published on Tuesday, will recommend moving under-25s off the main sickness and disability benefits, the Times reported, external.

    Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, has been tasked by the government with helping reduce the one in eight 18- to 24-year-olds in the UK who are not in education, employment or training - otherwise known as "Neet".

    He said on Wednesday night that his plans would not be "pain-free" and would affect both existing and new claimants.

    His report is expected to recommend that under-25s are no longer able to claim the health element of universal credit or personal independence payment (Pip).

    Instead, they would receive an allowance on the same basic rate as universal credit.

    Some could be eligible for a new "additional cost allowance" to cover day-to-day costs related to their conditions.

    But many claimants would receive less under the plans, which the government is set to take forward into legislation in the new year.

    Milburn, a Labour MP from 1992 to 2010, is also expected to recommend an investment of billions into more employment support for young people, including work placements, job subsidies and one-to-one personal advisers.

    Those with more severe disabilities and unable to work would get a new benefit paid at a higher rate.

    Milburn told the Times about his report: "Candidly, it could mean that some people will get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system.

    "But actually, for young people, there's a different debate that we've got to resolve, which is whether the priority is their longer-term life chances or just their immediate shorter-term finances.

    "I think what the current system does [is] it prioritises the latter over the former. I believe that's the wrong choice and it needs to be the other way around."

    He added that currently "you've got hundreds of thousands of young people stuck in a benefit system that is trapping them in poverty, giving them no prospect of prosperity or a job".

    His new proposed system would involve an element of carrot and stick, wherein young people could lose some of their benefits if they did not engage with the extra work support options.

    "A deal isn't a deal unless there are potential consequences," Milburn said. "Entitlements and responsibilities are two sides of the same coin."

    A government spokesperson said: "We will always ensure there is a safety net for the most vulnerable and those who are unable to work.

    "But the prime minister has been clear that we need a wholesale change in the way we support young people to grow up in this country, where we invest in their success rather than paying for failure." "

    https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/young-people-and-work-interim-report/young-people-and-work-interim-report

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "The independent review into young people and work (the Milburn report) was commissioned by Pat McFadden, the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions."

      Seems the full-fat report isn't released until next Tues, but milburn's clearly had a cosy lunch with his chums in the media & pre-released his "independent" findings.

      Seeing as public funds filled his independent pockets, maybe there should be some kind of penalty for briefing the media before parliament?

      But, same as it ever was, standards & behaviours vary according to one's position in the chumocracy.

      Delete
  5. I'm not sure if devolution actually means a more localised service. More localised control perhaps, but not necessarily more localised delivery.
    The current probation model hamstrings the service. Theres no deviation permitted from process. Whatever devolution may mean, I see little change for the service without a change of model and ethos.

    'Getafix

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello and greetings Getafix. My view: The devolution by default thing sounds hopeful for Probation but should be approached with caution. There will be - and is- warm talk of localism in courts, services, even commission of services, some of which will bring improvements, but until Probation is unshackled from Prison Service, it is now fast beconming nothing but an extension of it. While the ownership of enforcement and management of licences and community orders remains within HMPPS nothing like enough will be achieved to reverse the hideous situation where more people are recalled to custody than were released, this years figures. The review of Probation Governance is long overdue.
      Pearly Gates

      Delete
  6. https://inquest.org.uk/news-and-comment/press-releases/inquest-responds-to-new-ombudsman-evidence-of-prison-staff-cruel-treatment-of-prisoners/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. From the Inquest page as pasted above:

      "The report details horrific instances of prison staff’s callous behaviour to young people in particular. In one scenario, a prison officer said to a 19-year-old teen in a use of force incident that happened during a strip-search, ‘How f***ing difficult was that mate. You stupid, stupid boy.’ Following this incident, the teen’s teeth were significantly damaged and he alleged a racial slur was used against him, yet the prison’s own investigation found no need for a formal investigation."

      And from the ppo pages:

      https://ppo.gov.uk/corporate_document/greater-consequences-are-needed-in-response-to-staff-behaviour-issues-says-prisons-and-probation-ombudsman/

      "I am concerned about the failures in staff behaviour and conduct found in our investigations. I know (and have seen) that Governors, Directors and prison staff have a very difficult job and many of them do excellent work every day, but professionalism among all staff is crucial to ensuring safe prisons and building better staff-prisoner relationships.

      The aim of this bulletin is to help prison staff improve standards of professionalism and create a stronger culture of safety. It is clear that greater independent oversight of staff conduct is needed, and it is my hope that this learning prompts Governors and prison staff to reflect on conduct in their prisons.” - Adrian Usher, Prisons and Probation Ombudsman

      Delete
  7. From the Probation Institute website.

    https://kellygrehaninjusticeblog.substack.com/p/the-great-tagging-expansion-more

    'Getafix

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. its a long piece but here's the concluding paragraph:

      "As the number of people subject to electronic monitoring grows, so too does the burden on police and probation services, yet there is little evidence that breaches are consistently acted upon or that tagging is delivering meaningful improvements in rehabilitation or public safety. For some individuals, electronic monitoring may be proportionate and necessary, but for others it clearly isn’t. At a time when resources are stretched across the justice system, electronic monitoring risks becoming a technological solution in search of a problem. We need to ask whether the money and effort devoted to tagging might be better invested in what we know supports desistance: stable housing, treatment, employment, and relationships. After all, a tag can monitor where someone is, but it cannot address why they offend in the first place."

      Delete
    2. “We need to ask whether the money and effort devoted to tagging might be better invested in …. “

      We don’t need to ask. We already know the answer!!

      Delete
  8. Simply sharing my very best wishes, care, thoughts and prayers with all those who work across Probation on what feels like a hugely significant/landmark day. I hope that you have been able to find a collective ‘Voice’ that clearly sends an unequivocal message to HMPPS and this Government and Ministers concerned. IanGould5

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The only real message is about renewing probation: reshaping probation’s professional identity, increasing its autonomy and improving access to resources. But who is really behind that agenda, and whose interests does it ultimately serve?

      Delete
    2. Significant? Landmark?

      https://www.ukauthority.com/articles/edmi-trial-cuts-manual-tasks-for-probation-managers

      "A new tool giving probation staff faster access to GPS tagging data is being piloted across three English regions, with the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) reporting early time savings and quicker responses to non-compliance

      The Electronic Monitoring Data Insights (EMDI) tool brings together information from across electronic monitoring services into a single platform, reducing the need for time-consuming manual processes. It is designed to help practitioners understand offender movement patterns, assess compliance with licence conditions and take proportionate action where necessary.

      The tool is being piloted in the London, West Midlands and East of England probation regions, where thousands of users have already carried out over 30,000 searches. Testing indicates it saves an average of 21 minutes per week for every person on probation whose trail monitoring data is reviewed, allowing practitioners to spend more time managing risk, supporting victims and engaging with people on probation.

      Practitioner feedback quoted on the Ministry of Justice's Justice Digital blog highlighted the tool's impact on professional decision-making. One said: "We can make professional judgment decisions in a significantly more informed way."

      Another said it provides an ability to identify potentially concerning behaviour earlier: "Very quickly using this, we can see if he is actively putting himself into situations to offend… this will be a really powerful tool to use."

      A third described using the data in enforcement action: "Thanks to the data, I was able to recall him (the person on probation) due to non-compliance."

      MoJ said the tool is one of a growing suite of innovations aimed at stabilising and transforming electronic monitoring services. It plans to roll out EMDI across all probation regions by the end of 2026, enabling practitioners to respond more effectively to emerging risks while spending more time supporting people on probation to achieve positive outcomes. Usage and feedback will continue to be monitored to develop the service in line with staff needs.

      HM Courts & Tribunals Service (HMCTS) is upgrading audio-visual equipment in courts and tribunals across England and Wales through its Digital Audio-Visual Evolution programme (DAVE), aiming to replace ageing systems, support remote hearings and improve how evidence is presented."

      Delete
    3. Alison Griffiths MP: "Residents across Bognor Regis, Littlehampton, and our villages have raised serious concerns with me about dangerous offenders being at large in our communities. We’ve seen prisoners abscond from HMP Ford, and there are wider questions about how offenders are being monitored, rehabilitated, and supported when they leave prison.
      🏛️ During Justice Questions in Parliament this week, I challenged the Government on its early release scheme and why 11 probation hostels have closed under Labour’s watch. These are precisely the places intended to supervise offenders and help prevent them from reoffending. With prisoners also leaving custody homeless, we need proper safeguards to protect the public.
      ❗ Disappointingly, rather than explain why these hostels had closed, the Minister chose to open with a party-political attack. Labour has been in government for over two years now. Blaming previous governments cannot continue to be the answer to legitimate questions about public safety. Residents deserve reassurance, proper accountability, and straight answers. I’ll keep pressing until we get them."

      Delete
  9. "Chief Probation Officer" jones (as he's often referred to in the press) & his hmip team made very clear observations/recommendations in their report:

    https://hmiprobation.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/document/national-findings-dynamic-inspection-of-public-protection-in-the-probation-service-2026/

    *** hmpps, of course, think they know best:

    "10 November 2026 - Published the HMPPS action plan in response to the HMI Probation dynamic inspection of Public Protection in the Probation Service."

    https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6af3431eb83b3cae0d0a21af/National_Action_Plan_to_HMI_Probation_s_Dynamic_Inspection_of_Public_Protection.pdf

    1. Reduce vetting delays
    and address workforce
    instability by
    implementing streamlined
    and more regionally
    responsive recruitment
    processes.

    hmpps: "A Recruitment Stabilisation Plan is now in place,
    underpinning a whole-system approach to improving
    probation recruitment."

    2. Develop a national
    strategic approach to
    information sharing with
    police and children’s
    services to support
    regions in achieving
    consistency and
    compliance with
    legislation to obtain and
    use information to protect
    the public.

    hmpps: "HMPPS agrees that stronger national arrangements, frameworks, and expectations are required to support effective and consistent information-sharing with police and children's services and compliance with legislative requirements."

    3. Provide regions with
    increased dedicated
    learning and development
    resource to enable
    greater delivery of
    training and continuous
    professional development
    activities for all staff.

    hmpps: "HMPPS has already established a comprehensive national learning and development model... current evidence indicates that the primary challenge is not a lack of learning provision... delivery of the Our Future Probation Service (OFPS) programme, will reduce workload by 25% by April 2027."

    4. Develop and implement a
    training programme for
    Professional Qualification
    in Probation (PQiP)
    trainees and continuing
    professional development
    programmes that gives
    priority to applying
    practical skills in
    managing complex risk,
    ensuring consistency and
    quality across all regions.

    hmpps: "HMPPS considers that the significant reforms already made to the PQiP programme, together with the existing national CPD offer, provide the appropriate framework to deliver these objectives."

    5.a. Evaluate current national
    performance metrics to
    determine whether they
    drive quality public
    protection practice and
    consider how to embed
    public protection-specific
    metrics in dashboards to
    enable leaders to monitor
    quality and impact
    effectively.

    hmpps: "HMPPS considers that a separate evaluation of current national performance metrics is not necessary at this stage, as significant reform of the Performance Framework is already underway."

    5.b. Embed public protection-
    specific metrics in
    dashboards to enable
    leaders to monitor quality
    and impact effectively.

    hmpps: "Public protection already forms a significant component of the Performance Framework and is supported by a range of quality measures that assess key risk-related practice."

    6. Review national
    arrangements to provide
    regions greater autonomy
    in adapting risk
    management approaches
    to local contexts, while
    maintaining
    accountability and
    assurance.

    hmpps: "HMPPS does not consider that the inspection findings indicate a need for additional regional autonomy beyond existing arrangements."

    7. Review AP capacity and
    placements to support
    the appropriate
    management and
    resettlement of people on
    probation.

    hmpps: "HMPPS agrees that effective Approved Premises (AP) capacity planning, placement decision-making and resettlement arrangements are critical to supporting public protection outcomes and the safe management of people on probation."

    ReplyDelete
  10. Speaking of hostels/APs:

    "A probation hostel manager has won a significant employment tribunal, confirming the hours he spent on standby were working time and should be compensated with rest periods, says UNISON today (Friday).

    A tribunal in London found all the standby hours for Andrew Wisdom, a 56-year-old area manager who oversaw 24 probation hostels, counted as work periods, not just the time he spent responding to incidents.

    It ruled that Mr Wisdom, who lives in Milton Keynes but managed probation premises as far away as London, was not given sufficient compensatory rest after being on-call during unsocial hours, breaching working time regulations.

    As part of his role managing staff and ensuring support for high-risk people transitioning from prison into the community, he was also often on standby outside his usual 9am to 5pm shifts.

    During this time he was frequently called out to attend late-night emergencies, such as when residents went missing or got into trouble with police. But the tribunal found he was not allocated adequate rest periods.

    The level of compensation will be decided at a later remedy hearing.

    UNISON is to discuss the implications of the judgment with the Probation Service so staff in similar roles are given the rest periods to which they are entitled.

    Andrew Wisdom said: “I’m extremely proud of this legal victory, and grateful for the support received from my colleagues and UNISON. Hopefully, probation staff in similar situations can now look forward to a better work-life balance.”

    UNISON general secretary Christina McAnea said: “This important ruling highlights serious flaws in the way regulations have been applied.

    “Probation staff are overworked and feel exhausted by the demands of these essential jobs. Experienced workers are leaving the service because there’s only so much they can give.

    “Workers like Andrew help to rehabilitate former prisoners and keep communities safe. It’s vital the Probation Service implements the tribunal findings and tackles the problems causing a recruitment and retention crisis across the sector.”

    https://www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions/mr-a-wisdom-v-the-secretary-of-state-for-justice-3312322-slash-2023

    ReplyDelete
  11. Rewiring the world? An interesting view of the nvidia thing:

    " It seems odd that a CEO’s stepping down when the only proven allegation is that he had affairs with two age-appropriate women.... Perhaps Jensen should’ve gone to Epstein island and he’d be fine!... Israeli media outlets like Ynet and The Times of Israel are excited about the possibility that an Israeli could take over Nvidia... Jensen Huang has said four of six key chips in a recent Nvidia roadmap came out of Israel. Huang called the country Nvidia’s “second home” ... Michael Kagan is Nvidia’s current CTO., having previously co-founded Mellanox. He’s pushed for Israel to treat AI like critical national infrastructure and said Israeli tech and talent is central to Nvidia... Eyal Waldman co-founded and ran Mellanox for years before the sale to Nvidia. He was a software engineer at Israeli defence contractor Elbit Systems... In June 2026, the Israeli government approved a National AI Program which Netanyahu launched with Brig Gen Erez Askal. He’s the former commander of IDF visual-intelligence Unit 9900 and the country’s first AI chief... Askal recently said: “If it’s not your AI, you have no control over your country.”... "
    Source: Did Israel just coup Nvidia? Council Estate Media and Ricky Hale Nov 13 2026.

    For me, the story isn't about Israelis or Jews; its about the mendacious genocidal regime - which currently has Israel in a headlock - & those who subscribe to its violent & unrelenting expansionist programme.

    ReplyDelete
  12. There are so many of these "action plans" with so many concerns for so many prison establishments; ALL are about BASIC & fundamental failures of running a prison.

    Yet we're told that the architects & 'senior leaders' of these catastrophes in hmpps are, in fact, beyond excellent - so much so that they now head up major organisations such a the *entire* Civil Service, or Homes England, "the government’s housing and regeneration agency".

    What on earth could possibly go wrong?

    But... the political zeitgeist says we must build more prisons & subject ever more souls to a litany of failures, omissions, incompetence & abuse.

    https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6af75040b237843d998742c4/HMP_Highpoint_-_action_plan_-_Nov_2026.pdf

    "This action plan is the HMPPS and MoJ response to the HM Inspectorate of Prisons inspection report for Highpoint Prison - published October 2026."

    Drugs were too readily available
    in the prison and were a
    significant threat to stability.
    Prisoners were often found under
    the influence, and the prison’s
    approach to their management
    was often punitive.

    Levels of violence had risen, and
    the rate of serious assaults had
    increased by 43%

    The partnership oversight of
    health services and social care
    delivery was poor. There were no
    local health delivery board and
    no overarching improvement plan
    to address some known issues.

    Too few prisoners attended work,
    training or education; our roll
    checks found only 42% in
    purposeful activity during the
    working day.

    Leaders did not plan a sufficiently
    broad, ambitious and consistently
    available education, skills and
    work curriculum.

    Prisoners had too few
    opportunities to progress through
    their sentence. Prison offender
    manager contact was mainly
    transactional, with insufficient
    structured one-to-one work to
    help prisoners understand, work
    towards and demonstrate
    progression against their
    sentence objectives.

    The use of PAVA incapacitant
    spray was among the highest of
    category C prisons. Leaders
    were not analysing trends in its
    use, and scrutiny was not always
    sufficiently robust.

    Processes to identify and help
    the most vulnerable prisoners at
    risk of exploitation and neglect
    were weak,

    The quality of key work was still
    not good enough and did not link
    to offender management.

    The food served to prisoners in
    the south site of the prison was
    not good enough

    The applications system was
    ineffective.

    The waiting list for psychology
    interventions was too long and
    there were too few suitable
    confidential rooms in which to
    deliver talking therapies.

    Too few prisoners benefited from
    timely identification of their
    support needs, to enable them to
    overcome barriers to participation
    in education, skills and work

    Too many prisoners did not
    complete and achieve their
    intended learning aims in
    education, skills and work.

    The inter-departmental risk
    management team did not
    provide sufficient oversight of
    high-risk releases to ensure
    comprehensive risk management
    planning.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. to wit, The Independent: "The gruelling life Russell Brand faces inside Wandsworth prison"

      Delete
  13. The grinning -womannequin at the head of this blog inspired me to ask the ghost in't'machine about the job:

    "The UK Cabinet Secretary—the head of the Civil Service—receives a salary bracketed between £210,000 and £215,000 per year (based on a full-year equivalent of approximately £225,000 to £230,000).

    Opinions differ on whether the role is adequately compensated. On the r/ukpolitics discussion thread, some contributors and former officials argue that the roughly £200,050–£225,000 salary is underpaid"

    https://www.civilserviceworld.com/news/article/dave-penman-high-drama-spirit-and-sound-ideas-from-antonia-romeo

    "The cabinet secretary’s LSE speech set out not only the need for change in the civil service but also an understanding of the buy-in from staff that will be required"

    Elsewhere: https://www.civilserviceworld.com/in-depth/article/romeos-radical-change-agenda-welcomed-but-sector-calls-for-action-now

    "‘Compelling’ but short on ‘detailed plans’: Reaction to Antonia Romeo's speech on civil service reform"

    Doncha just lurv this one: "“She identified all the right issues: using AI to make public services more human"

    What the fuck is in that kool-aid?

    ReplyDelete
  14. Napo overwhelmingly voted for action short of strike and strike action. It’s on NAPO site under latest news ( hard to find) and in press see guardian

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In probably the most historic ballot result in Napo’s 114 year history, our Probation members have voted in huge numbers to support a campaign of industrial action over Pay and Workloads.

      In the electronic ballot, among the first to be held under new legislation, members responded to the questions on their willingness to support action as follows:
      Pay :
      85.84% in favour of action short of strike action
      74.82% in favour of strike action
      Workloads:
      87.40% in favour of action short of strike action
      75.84% in favour of strike action

      Napo Probation Negotiation Committee (PNC) decide to launch industrial action on 23rd November.

      The ballot result was considered at a meeting of Napo’s PNC this afternoon who agreed that in view of this conclusive result, we should immediately serve notice on HMPPS and Government that we will be calling on our members in Probation England and Wales to commence a campaign of Industrial Action on Monday 23rd November. As we have previously announced, the first stage of this be to ask you to work only your contracted hours. To confirm, this is action short of strike action.

      Appreciation to all members who voted in the pay and workloads ballot

      It’s likely that the result will attract substantial media interest in the lead up to the start of industrial action (see Today’s Media Release here). Napo will of course make it clear that we remain open to reaching meaningful solutions, but that the employer needs to respond to this result.

      Meanwhile, we wanted to express our huge appreciation for the work that has gone in by Napo Branches and our members for taking part in the ballot and providing us with a powerful mandate to maintain our campaigns on your behalf.

      Please look out for important information next week on the next steps in the campaign as well as holding an All-Members meeting on Thursday 19th November at 12noon,

      Delete
  15. Oh.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckz74jzpy18do

    Trump, Putin and Xi plan historic joint meeting as Trump attends the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec) summit in the southern city of Shenzhen.

    "President Trump will conclude his visit to China with a trilateral meeting between the president of the United States, the president of the People's Republic of China, and the president of the Russian Federation"

    ReplyDelete
  16. Well, perhaps this finally puts to bed the suggestion that concerns about probation workloads are simply a minority of disillusioned staff moaning.

    Over 70% turnout in both Napo ballots, with 87.4% of valid votes cast on the workload question supporting action short of a strike. That’s a considerable expression of concern from a workforce that has spent years being told about transformation, efficiency, resilience and the importance of public protection.

    And now, from 23 November, PPs are being asked to do something that really shouldn’t be considered extraordinary. Work their contracted hours.

    I imagine HMPPS has been busy preparing its Gold Command contingency arrangements for industrial action. Entirely understandable, of course. Public protection responsibilities don’t disappear during an industrial dispute. But I do wonder how much attention and resource is being devoted to managing the consequences of staff working their contracted hours, compared with addressing why the service has become so dependent upon people working beyond them in the first place. Because if working to contracted hours creates an operational crisis, surely the crisis existed long before the industrial action began?

    HMPPS has already acknowledged that the Probation Service is unsustainable. Yet individual PPs remain responsible for managing complex risks, meeting statutory deadlines, responding to emergencies and making defensible decisions within workloads that frequently exceed the time realistically available.

    So what happens when that additional goodwill is no longer there?
    Who determines which work takes priority? Who takes responsibility for the tasks that cannot reasonably be completed? And how will individual PPs be protected from being held accountable for failures arising from organisational capacity rather than their own professional decisions?

    These are not simply questions for Napo members. They are questions for those responsible for directing, resourcing and overseeing the Probation Service.

    For years, professional commitment has helped bridge the gap between what the organisation demands and what its staffing capacity can realistically deliver. But commitment should never be mistaken for an unlimited resource. And perhaps that’s what makes this ballot result so significant. Thousands of staff have now formally expressed their unwillingness to continue accepting the conditions under which they’re expected to deliver probation. We talk endlessly about resilience, but resilience cannot mean expecting individuals to absorb organisational failure indefinitely.

    HMPPS may well have contingency plans for the industrial action beginning on 23 November. But where is the contingency plan for a Probation Service that can no longer rely on the unpaid labour and goodwill of its workforce to keep it functioning? Because you can prepare for industrial action. You can't contingency plan your way out of the underlying reasons people voted for it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for these thoughts/comments are you happy for me to share them on X and do you have any thoughts about ‘Unison’ who have voted to accept the pay award and the divide this creates. iangould5

      Delete
    2. Regarding UNISON, I do find the different positions taken by the unions concerning, particularly at a time when probation desperately needs a collective voice.

      I can understand why some colleagues might regard 5% as an offer worth accepting, especially given the financial pressures many are experiencing. Equally, I understand Napo’s concerns about the longer term implications for pay progression and the failure to adequately address the erosion of probation pay.

      But what troubles me is the division this risks creating within an already fragmented workforce. We’ve seen enough of that throughout probation’s recent history, particularly during TR. Colleagues who were once part of the same profession found themselves divided by organisational structures and decisions they had little control over. We should be extremely cautious about allowing another divide to develop between staff represented by different unions.

      Ultimately, Napo and UNISON members are working within the same service, facing many of the same excessive workloads, staffing shortages, professional responsibilities and pressures.

      Those difficulties don’t disappear because one union recommends accepting a pay offer while another rejects it. And perhaps that is the bigger issue. Pay cannot be considered entirely separately from workloads, retention and the increasing demands placed upon PPs. What does a 5% increase actually achieve in the longer term if the working conditions driving experienced colleagues out of the profession remain largely unchanged?

      I respect the democratic decisions made by members of both unions, but I would hope their leaderships can continue working together on the issues that unite their members rather than allowing their different negotiating positions to become another source of division. Because the employer remains the same, the pressures remain the same, and the need for a properly resourced, professionally valued Probation Service remains exactly the same.

      The last thing probation needs is another situation where those doing the work become divided while the underlying problems remain unresolved.

      Delete
    3. Huge thank you for permission and for your wise thoughts. Im acutely aware that it probably will make no difference but remind myself that any step we take is far better than none at all . Wishing alll those staff working tonight AP’s and tomorrow AP’s and CP a kind difference making day . Iangould5

      Delete
  17. 25% of staff appear to lack the understanding that you can vote FOR strike action in solidarity, but not actually go on strike.

    We really are seeing the dumbing down of the service!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Today's Guardian:-

    The government’s plans to release thousands of prisoners early were dealt a blow on Friday after probation officers across England and Wales voted to strike over pay and excessive workloads.

    Members of the union, Napo, backed overtime restrictions and other forms of action short of a strike, which is likely to start on 23 November. Plans are being made for strike action to follow at a later stage.

    The union, whose members work across probation offices and in family courts, said it launched its ballot because of an “inadequate” 5% pay offer from ministers and a failure to cut workloads.

    Probation officers have come under increasing pressure since the launch of the latest early release scheme in October, which is meant to ease overcrowding in prisons.

    They are responsible for monitoring offenders’ behaviour, overseeing their rehabilitation, monitoring their electronic tags and recalling them to prison for any offences or licence breaches, such as entering an exclusion or restriction zone protecting victims.

    By the end of the year, about 2,500 offenders, including sex offenders, domestic abusers and stalkers, will be released under the scheme.

    The union had sought a 12% increase. Napo general secretary Ian Lawrence said: “The high turnout by our members and the result vindicates the campaign to achieve a pay rise to make up lost ground in comparative pay with other staff employed within HMPPS [HM Prison and Probation Service].

    “The vote also reflects serious anger at the state of probation workloads, which were already in crisis before the latest version of the prisoner early release scheme.”

    Napo said probation wages have “stagnated” since 2010, with reception staff on a salary just above the minimum wage – the lowest in the civil service.

    On pay, Napo members voted by 85% in favour of action short of strike action and 74% in favour of strike action. In a ballot on workloads, the vote was 87% in favour of action short of strike action and 75% in favour of strikes.

    The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) is recruiting an additional 1,300 trainee probation officers for the 2026-27 financial year as part of a £700m investment package extending through 2028-29.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Institute for Government, a thinktank, said slow progress on recruitment means probation practitioners were still overstretched and ill-equipped to absorb additional demand.

      It said there had been a serious staff shortage in probation for several years, with the number of probation officers consistently 25-30% below target staffing. As of March 2026, nine probation delivery units (8% of the total) had a vacancy rate of 40% or more.

      An MoJ spokesperson said: “Probation staff do a vital job protecting the public, which is why we have put a strong offer on the table, giving every worker a further 5% pay rise, which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade alongside record investment.

      “We’re also recruiting an additional 1,300 officers to significantly cut workloads.

      “While we are disappointed that some have voted against this competitive deal, it will not change our first responsibility of protecting the public and we have robust contingency plans in place to ensure offenders are still subject to the same rigorous supervision.”

      Delete
    2. This MOJ spokesperson seems to completely misunderstand the issues at hand and this is what makes my blood boil...if the service has been 25/30 % below target staffing for many years and 9 PDUs at 40% since March you may have expected a functioning leadership to put in place the contingencies to deal with this way before a vote on industrial action...and then to say "we have robust contingencies to deal with industrial action because public protection is our priority"....clearly public protection was NOT a priority before this, or rather, as other's have said, the service has been relying on the goodwill or exploitation of staff in the various affected offices to "manage public protection" before the service bothers to take any meaningful action to help the affected staff! The hypocrisy and lack of duty of care is beyond shocking...the MOJ response beyond disrespectful

      Delete
  19. Well done, Napo. Now let’s secure unity with both UNISON and GMB Scoop.

    As has been said before, the message should be about renewing probation – not reimagining or reinventing it, but restoring it to a fresh, healthy and vigorous state. Not through rose-tinted nostalgia, but by reshaping its professional identity, strengthening its autonomy as a standalone agency and improving access to resources through legislation.

    There’s talk of localism and devolution, but devolving what, exactly, and to whom? The alternatives are not adequately funded, and privatisation is a non-starter.

    Whether it’s prison capacity, professional registration for probation officers or the future direction of the service, probation officers and their unions must have a meaningful voice in the decisions being made.

    At every turn, we need to follow the evidence, understand who is really behind the agenda and ask whose interests it ultimately serves.

    In the meantime, turn the WMT back on, stop hammering staff with performance targets and dashboards, and pay people properly.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It’s happening https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6pv92pl02kpo

      Delete
    2. That phrase carries real weight. “Renewing probation” captures a central debate in criminal justice right now, moving away from an overly managerial approach and rebuilding probation as a distinct profession. Bodies like Napo and the Probation Institute should be embracing it before shifting political narratives, ministers or think tanks appropriate it and redefine it around their own agendas. I’ve seen it a few times- this one unfortunately is behind probation journals paywall.

      https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/02645505261478012?af=R&

      Personally I’d take it further and I think Napo needs to get back to the basics of “advise, assist and befriend”. There’s a lot in those three words that remains relevant today. That doesn’t mean turning back the clock. Technology has its place, but, as this recent probation institute article highlights, it isn’t – and shouldn’t be – at the forefront of what probation is about. The profession, its people and its relationships with those under supervision should be.

      https://www.probation-institute.org/news/the-great-tagging-expansion-more-surveillance-same-problems

      Delete
  20. Working to contract and no overtime may seem like a solution and I support that manner of thinking. However, this is where the real bullying and intimidation starts. Union members will identify and highlight to others those that are not playing the game, the cold silence, ostracised because they are non-union members. The main question is why aren’t they union members? Unions are not mandatory and as for the managers of these unions they will not be financially burdened by any collective action. The next group that you have to be wary of is the SPOs, some are union members and they will intimidate and bully people to be part of the action, some actively ‘out’ non-members. Finally the SPOs and senior management who ‘suck up’ to each other are the keyboard warriors of probation, will also put the squeeze on, competency will rear its ugly head once again. So it is not straightforward, there will be some people who will feel the squeeze from several areas, so look after your colleagues the division we saw with CRCs should never be seen again, individuals have freedom of speech and the right not to be in a union. We all know why NAPO were ineffective in the TR action as the money was needed elsewhere!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In my experience the divisions around the time of the split were all of the managers makings !

      Delete
    2. And it’ll be the same this time too. But either way, with all unions on board. That’s why they need to force GMB into standing with probation unions. If it doesn’t then how can it be considered a probation union.

      Delete
  21. What makes you think that NAPO members will behave like that towards non union members?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Napo and union members can seek solidarity with non union members. It’s a choice to be in a union and nobody should be treated unfairly for not being unionised. Support your colleagues and share information, whether in a union or not.

      Delete
  22. When I worked in industry many years ago, (when we had industry) we had a closed shop. (Look it up.) We also had a complement of those who didn’t want to pay union subscriptions but of course wanted the wages, terms and conditions negotiated through collective strength.
    Our response to the Naysayers would always be, ‘ if you want to ride on the bus, you have to pay your fare.’

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I understand the analogy, but I think there is another side to this. In probation, some colleagues have chosen not to be union members not because they want to benefit from others’ efforts without contributing, but because they have become disillusioned with unions, their effectiveness or their ability to represent and support them when it mattered.

      We should absolutely encourage union membership and recognise the importance of collective strength. But that means rebuilding confidence, demonstrating value, being visible, sharing information and supporting colleagues.

      We should be careful not to create a divide between union members and non-members. That only weakens the solidarity we are trying to build.

      The answer isn’t to ostracise those who aren’t on the bus; it’s to make the bus somewhere people actually want to be.

      Working together, rather than creating an us-and-them culture, is what strengthens our collective voice.

      Delete
  23. I think there’s something in both comments (13.26 and 13.36) Collective strength relies on people contributing, and rebuilding confidence means understanding why some colleagues have become disillusioned.

    The point about making the bus somewhere people want to be is a good one. How have we reached a position where some no longer feel it is? Poor experiences of representation, communication or feeling unheard all deserve an honest discussion.

    At the same time, the joining and rejoining around the last two ballots feels encouraging. People clearly still see value in standing together. More widely, the constant negativity towards unions can’t help persuade others to join.

    We need room to acknowledge what has gone wrong while explaining why unions matter: they give us a collective voice over pay, workloads and how we are treated. Rebuilding confidence is something union leadership and members both have a part in.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I wonder whether there is also a generational element here, not in the sense that younger colleagues care less, but in how familiar people are with unions and collective bargaining.

    TUC research published this year found that almost a third of workers aged 18–24 either hadn’t heard of unions or didn’t know what they did! That suggests we can’t assume everyone starts with the same understanding of why membership matters.

    Perhaps those of us who have been around longer need to talk more about what collective organisation means in practice, while listening to what newer colleagues want from it. Explaining, involving and encouraging people seems more likely to build solidarity than assuming they already know the history.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember when I first started out in work, on a paid YTS, if anyone remembers those! Someone from one of the major unions came along and explained why paying £1.50 a week in subscriptions was worthwhile. By the end of the talk, we realised he wasn’t just some union representative; he was the General Secretary. We all signed up, got involved and participated. We felt part of something. Even through my student year I maintained union membership of one form or another.

      Fast forward to probation. I changed my union affiliation to one of the main probation unions, but apart from the very early days, I never really felt involved. There was little opportunity to participate. I regularly challenged the status quo and the employer, applied to become a union rep, but as far as the local branch was concerned, my face didn’t fit, and they made it crystal clear.

      At the same time, probation was going downhill, union communication was abysmal and local representation wasn’t particularly great either. Anyone remember the Napo forum? We had some brilliant conversations and debates on there until it was shut down. That’s around the time I found this blog. When I needed representation, getting the union on board was a chore. Phone calls were passed around, emails went unanswered, delays for representation were endless and, in the end, I did most of the work myself. When I challenged them about this, I was treated as the enemy. The irony is that when I eventually spoke directly to the General Secretary, the very person others seemed so keen to criticise, he was the one who actually listened and helped.

      Despite all this, I lived through two periods of industrial action I can remember. The first time, I didn’t join the strike. How could I stand alongside the same union clique of members and branch reps who I knew had been actively stabbing me in the back? The second time, during TR, I had moved to a better location. I joined the protests, stood around a burning oil drum (until the fire brigade came and outed the fire) and marched through the streets with placards.

      Following TR, probation unions failed, disappeared or fundamentally changed. I left that union and joined another, partly to ensure I had access to representation should I need it in the future. When I eventually needed representation, I specifically requested an external rep. They were excellent. I still did a lot of the work myself, but one thing they did exceptionally well was to listen and to represent me. No delays in responding, no avoiding calls, no telling me how busy they were, and no fudging, dishonesty or side deals with management. There is a trade-off. I don’t feel as up to date with probation-specific communications, I no longer get to attend specialist AGMs and I probably won’t be involved in future strike action. But I’m still active in my own way. I still encourage people to join a union, even the union I previously had to leave for my own sanity and safety, hoping it’s changed for the better.

      So please, don’t shut people out and withhold information because they’re not attending your union meetings or standing on your picket line. Don’t make assumptions based on whether we’re Gen X, Gen Y, millennials, Black, White, gay, straight, or anything else. There’s already too much of that coming from the ivory tower. Unions should be demonstrating a better way, not reproducing the same divisions. You don’t know everyone’s journey, what they’ve experienced or why they’ve made the choices they have. Instead of asking why someone isn’t standing alongside you, perhaps ask what needs to change to make them want to. Collective strength is built by bringing people together, not pushing people away.

      / Probation Officer

      Delete
    2. Reading Anonymous14 November 2026 at 14:59 and other comments, yes, we absolutely need to include non-members and those in other unions by sharing information and seeking solidarity. Napo needs to demonstrate why it should be the principal union, and those who have left should consider rejoining. I’ve left in the past too, for similar reasons involving reprehensible union reps and branch practices. I’m also aware of the small-county politics and behaviours within Napo, which it needs to address. The bigger branches can have problems too.

      In this instance:

      * Napo: Rejects the HMPPS pay offer and seeks industrial action.
      * UNISON: Accepts the offer.
      * GMB/SCOOP: Accepts the offer.

      There is a reasonable argument for Napo being the principal professional and industrial voice. UNISON historically sought members from administration, while GMB/SCOOP has built its membership from managers and senior managers. Both are much larger, broader public-sector unions, with wider memberships and priorities extending across multiple sectors. Their negotiating considerations can therefore differ.

      The biggest challenge for Napo is maintaining workforce solidarity when two other ‘sister unions’ have accepted the offer, when arguably they should have been advising their members to reject it. If Napo has the largest membership, it needs to take on the principal union role. That’s more realistic than expecting UNISON and GMB to support Napo on every occasion or their members to transfer. Otherwise, everyone loses out by not having a single, coherent industrial and professional voice.

      Napo has spent years trying to establish a distinct professional identity, yet every news article seems to present probation alongside an image of a prison or an electronic tag. Having three unions pursuing different industrial strategies doesn’t help. Napo needs to bring the profession together, be more inclusive and provide that stronger voice. Bring back ‘advise, assist and befriend’. I also like the phrase ‘renewing probation’, as someone mentioned earlier. Get the Probation Institute on board too. There is an opportunity here, but it needs to be fought for, and that starts with having a united voice.

      Delete
  25. Wonder if Unison will now change their tune.

    ReplyDelete
  26. The hmpps misinformation campaign is now being actively aided & abetted by the bbc news reports:

    "The Probation Service uses electronic monitoring to track curfews and conditions of a court or prison order, with most of those eligible for early release now requiring tagging.

    But a September report by His Majesty's Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP) found that almost half of electronic tags used to track offenders' movements were not fitted on time."

    The Probation Service does not 'use electronic monitoring to track curfews and conditions of a court or prison order' - that's what hmpps do; the probation service are just the enforcers when they've been notified of a breach by the tagging contractor.

    Nor does the Probation Service fit tags - which is very clearly implied by the phrasing of the second paragraph.

    Responsibility for fitting & monitoring of tags is held by the rarely named contractors, e.g. serco & g4s.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Maybe in the same spirit as Plaid Cymru are making one simple request of Westminster (give us what Scotland have), Probation Unions should be replicating such in their negotiations (amalgamate probation pay and conditions with our Prison colleagues in HMPpS), which would automatically result in significant increases across the board and timely annual progression moving forward!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Napo, alongside UNISON and GMB/SCOOP, submitted a joint pay claim for a 12% increase across all pay points and cash allowances (such as London Weighting and the Prison Supplement), a £15/hour minimum wage, and a one-year deal.

    unison - we'll take the pay offer but can you please look again at the cbf

    gmb - we'll take the cash at the earliest opportunity thank you, & do what you like with the other stuff

    napo - 74% turnout, so 5792 members voted...
    Yes to strike action = 4,269 or 74.82%
    No to strike action = 1,437 or 25.18%

    NB: I can't quite work out if there were 66 or 86 spoilt/invalid voting papers. Its a small detail, perhaps, but there's always something that ruins a good story with napo. The carelessness grates.

    ReplyDelete
  29. How the chumocracy works, part 437:

    "The boss of Wales' largest and most troubled health board is leaving her post... Carol Shillabeer became the chief executive of Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board in May 2023 ... the board has spent nine years in special measures under the highest level of oversight due to concerns about care quality, patient safety and leadership. Shillabeer apologised "unreservedly" "

    So? Makes sense that she's going, doesn't it?

    "Shillabeer will join Lancashire and South Cumbria NHS Foundation Trust in north west England as their chief executive in the new year... Lancashire and South Cumbria NHS Foundation Trust say Carol Shillabeer was appointed as the Chief Executive with a salary package around £225,000 per year."

    Ah, I see. And what does she think of her time at Betsi?

    "Shillabeer said it had been "an enormous privilege" and she was "very proud of what colleagues across the organisation have achieved during an extremely demanding period". "

    What did others think?

    "Dyfed Edwards, chair of the health board, congratulated Shillabeer and said she joined "at an exceptionally challenging point" and "provided committed and determined leadership over the past three and a half years". "

    But what about "the board has spent nine years in special measures under the highest level of oversight due to concerns about care quality, patient safety and leadership" ?

    Clearly the facts & statistics matter not as yet another failing 'senior leader' rises to the top of the earnings chart - see also: romeo, rees, farrar, copple (self-proclaimed Prison & Probation Operations Expert, no less), etc ad nauseaum.

    note: "chief executive of Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board total remuneration (including pension calculation): Between £440,000 and £445,000"

    Looks like the 'determined leader' might have to tighten her dior medallion clover belt.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Corruption, abuse & the chumopcracy in action. Again.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6jd7k7g57x5o

    "A former Metropolitan Police detective, investigated for sexually exploiting vulnerable crime victims it was his job to protect, later lied about the death of his wife in a Barbados hotel room, BBC Panorama has learned... Warren Arter first met his wife Rebekah in 2006 after she reported domestic abuse to the Met. He then abused her for more than a decade... in 2009 he was placed in charge of a unit in south-east London investigating rape cases... and was later suspended by the Met and investigated over his conduct towards eight alleged victims by its watchdog, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) - but was never convicted.... Over the seven years he was suspended, Arter continued to receive his full detective inspector salary, before being dismissed in 2023 for drug offences."

    ReplyDelete
  31. Incredible! BBC News website today -

    The head of the government's main ethics watchdog has stepped back after it emerged he was investigated in a previous job over alleged sexual misconduct involving female colleagues, and had, in one case, been sanctioned.

    Stuart Sterling was appointed as the first chief executive of the newly formed Ethics and Integrity Commission in October 2025.

    The existence of the allegations against Sterling, and the investigations into them, were first reported by the Sunday Times.

    Following the report, a government spokesperson said: "These are serious allegations. Stuart Sterling has stepped back from his role while we swiftly establish the facts."

    The Labour Party promised in its 2024 manifesto to create the commission to "ensure probity in government" in response to scandals during the Covid pandemic.

    As its head, Sterling's role included advising the prime minister on tackling misconduct in public life.

    The Sunday Times reported that, in 2003, Sterling had been subject to a "full misconduct hearing" when he was a junior officer with Northamptonshire Police in what was treated as a case "of sexual harassment".

    The paper said he had been accused of inappropriately touching the breasts of a female colleague in a police station, and a male colleague who allegedly witnessed the event had reported him to his superiors. It reported that he had been suspended on full pay.

    A representative for Mr Sterling said: "Stuart states that a full disciplinary process was held regarding the complaint in 2002. He complied with this fully. It resulted in a sanction."

    The Sunday Times reported that he was given a financial penalty of two weeks' pay. It said that, at the time, that was the maximum sanction possible short of forced resignation. He then received two police commendations and was promoted to be a detective sergeant.

    The Sunday Times said that by 2008 Mr Sterling had been reported to the force again after another allegation of sexual misconduct against a female colleague, this time at a social gathering outside work.

    Mr Sterling's representative said: "He denies that the alleged incident in 2008 ever took place. He was never subject to any criminal investigation, but the allegation was examined by professional standards".

    The representative added: "He was not required to resign from the force. He left voluntarily".

    Northamptonshire Police has confirmed that it holds a digital record of a misconduct process from 2002.

    It did not comment on the later allegation.

    In 2009, Sterling joined the Cabinet Office. It is not clear what vetting process he underwent. He has since served in a variety of senior roles and in 2019 was seconded to the National Police Chiefs' Council. In 2023 he received an OBE for helping to plan the funeral of Queen Elizabeth.

    It is understood the Cabinet Office will now examine whether appropriate and correct disclosures of information were made.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Corruption, abuse & the chumopcracy in action. Again. And again. And again. And again.

      "[arter was] suspended by the Met and investigated over his conduct towards eight alleged victims by its watchdog, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) - but was never convicted.... Over the SEVEN years he was suspended, Arter continued to receive his full detective inspector salary"

      "[sterling] states that a full disciplinary process was held regarding the complaint in 2002. He complied with this fully. It resulted in a sanction... He then received two police commendations and was promoted to be a detective sergeant... by 2008 Mr Sterling had been reported to the force again after another allegation of sexual misconduct against a female colleague... "He was not required to resign from the force. He left voluntarily"... In 2009, Sterling joined the Cabinet Office... Sterling was appointed as the first chief executive of the newly formed Ethics and Integrity Commission in October 2025."

      Poor old Lizzie didn't get much of a respectable send-off though; firstly her death was announced by a paedophile on the news, a serial perpetrator of abuse against women received an OBE for helping to plan her funeral and her favourite boy was a sexual predator.

      Delete
  32. Trades Unions are past their sell by date. Look at the last fifty years, British car brands sold or gone bust, major manufacturing giants closed down, coal mining, ship building and now look at what they are doing everywhere. They make demands for higher salaries, but productivity does not improve, to pay for the salaries they have to cut the staff and cause increased unemployment. The only people that unions benefit are the union leaders on their inflation busting salaries. They are out of new ideas, the government and employers know how to treat trade unions, let them demand a lot, offer a reduced amount and divide the membership, simple but effective. I have no time for trades unions, if I have an issue I will use an employment lawyer through my life insurance which costs a lot less in the long run, because so far I have never had an issue to deal with that could not first be discussed and an amicable agreement reached. Stand up to the bullies there are many ways of gaining the upper hand, keep the dictats in a separate folder, when told to something that is disagreeable request it is put in writing, when told that the senior manager says it has to be done ask the senior manager if that is the case, a lot of the time managers will tell you their line manager told them to do it, on many occasions they did not. Work your contracted hours, if you need overtime pay, get a better paid job. Let’s see how the quality of reports and risk assessments will drop when the managers and the non-operational staff hiding as QDOs and PTAs become involved. Enjoy your Sunday, another fun filled week on the probation roller coaster awaits.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Unions have a place, the doctors and lawyers haven proven that. I agree with Anonymous15 November 2026 at 13:24

      Delete
    2. Not everyone can afford to get employment lawyers or life insurance

      Delete
    3. Agree with 13:27
      We got a better offer last year due to us rejecting HMPPs first offer

      Delete
    4. I can see where 1259 is coming from and acknowledge what others are saying in reply. There was a time and place for unions chimney sweeps etc and yes doctors got a pay rise, but probation is not in the same bracket and NAPO has lost significant membership over the years because they have failed to deliver. Too many people will do overtime, bow down to churlish and bullying managers. There is plenty of cash available to pay NSD officers and managers at higher pay grades with lower caseloads, but nobody has picked up on that, how come the money is available for them but not the rest of us? You don’t see NAPO, GMB or UNISON pick up on it, because they signed it off!! Get the QDO’s back doing a job that they are good at talking about but not doing it, the good ideas club again with limited operational experience. The service has been divided into them and us and main grade probation officers lose out every time.

      Delete
    5. I find the comments about QDOs and PTAs rather disappointing, particularly given the wider discussion we’ve been having about professional development, the loss of experience and the need to support newly qualified POs.

      We cannot spend one day lamenting the erosion of professional expertise and the lack of meaningful development, then spend the next suggesting that those working in roles intended to support quality and learning should simply be returned to frontline caseloads.

      That’s not to say every role is effective, every appointment is appropriate or that the balance between operational and non-operational staffing shouldn’t be scrutinised. Of course it should.

      But surely the question is whether those roles are delivering meaningful support, strengthening professional judgement and improving the quality of probation practice?

      A well-supported PO is not a luxury. Neither is good quality training, reflective practice or professional development.

      And let’s not forget that the people occupying these roles did not design the staffing model, determine the pay offer or create the workload crisis.

      We’ve spent considerable time discussing how divided probation has become. Yet here we are, dividing ourselves again into those supposedly doing the ‘real work’ and those who apparently aren’t.

      Perhaps we should direct more of our scrutiny towards the decisions that have left the service so overstretched, rather than assuming colleagues in different roles are somehow responsible for the conditions we’re all working under.

      Because if we’re serious about renewing probation, we need to value the people delivering supervision and the people helping them develop the knowledge and skills to deliver it well.

      Those should be complementary responsibilities, not competing ones.

      Delete
    6. I don't blame QDOs or PTAs but I do blame the tools and structures that consume their time...RCAT, QDTs, case audits...these aren't professional development or supporting good practice...they are doing damage by focusing on adherence to processes and guidance dictats and very much focused on OASYS as the be all and end all of the work.

      Delete
    7. The majority of QDOs and PTAs have limited risk assessment and practice knowledge, the majority jumped ship as soon as they qualified to escape the front line and yet they try to tell experienced practitioners with exemplary records of risk management and resettlement of VH and HR offenders and prisoners. In the past you needed at least five years post qualifying experience before you could become an SPO, Senior Practitioner or a PTA, now we have numbers of limited experienced staff in those roles so that is one of the reasons the service is failing and the number of recalls is so high as they have people tied to the desks and not out in the community and visiting prisons to engage with their caseloads. The rot has set in for good.

      Delete
  33. Without historical unions children would still be going up chimneys and prisons would still have treadmills…….

    ReplyDelete
  34. I’m not convinced by the suggestion that trade unions have had their day.
    Have unions always got things right? Absolutely not. Have members been let down by poor representation, ineffective local branches or decisions that ultimately achieved very little? Undoubtedly. And having lived through the strikes against TR, I certainly don’t need reminding that collective action doesn’t always deliver the outcome we hope for.

    But none of that demonstrates that we’d be better off without unions. The suggestion that an individual can simply rely on an employment lawyer through household insurance rather overlooks how legal expenses insurance actually works. It isn’t a guaranteed route to legal representation. Most policies require a case to have reasonable prospects of success, generally assessed at 51% or better, before agreeing to fund proceedings. There are also exclusions, funding limits and conditions to consider.

    You can have a perfectly legitimate workplace grievance, experience appalling management or feel you’ve been treated extremely unfairly, yet still find that your circumstances don’t give rise to a sufficiently strong legal claim for an insurer to fund.

    And that’s a crucial distinction. Not everything that is wrong in the workplace is necessarily unlawful. Effective union representation should help challenge unfair practices, support colleagues through grievances and disciplinary proceedings, and resolve problems before they escalate into legal disputes. More importantly, an individual employment lawyer isn’t going to negotiate national pay awards, challenge changes to contractual conditions or secure manageable workloads for an entire workforce.

    I also find the argument about productivity rather ironic in probation. We’re repeatedly expected to become more efficient, absorb additional responsibilities and manage increasingly complex demands, while the time available to deliver meaningful supervision continues to be squeezed. And when POs challenge those conditions, they’re told to work harder, adapt or find another job.

    The recent ballot demonstrates that these concerns are not confined to a handful of disillusioned colleagues. Thousands of members have formally expressed their dissatisfaction with pay and workloads.

    That doesn’t mean everyone must agree with industrial action, nor should anybody be judged for their union membership or the decisions they make. We’ve already experienced enough division within probation.

    But let’s not confuse dissatisfaction with particular unions or their leadership with the principle of collective representation itself. NAPO, UNISON and GMB should absolutely be challenged to demonstrate their value, represent members effectively and explain how they intend to achieve meaningful improvements. They should be accountable to the people paying their subscriptions.

    Yet there is something rather contradictory about describing an organisation where individuals feel powerless to challenge management, where experienced staff are undervalued and workloads are acknowledged to be unsustainable, while simultaneously arguing that collective representation is no longer necessary.

    An employment lawyer may help defend an individual’s legal rights. A union, when functioning as it should, can challenge the conditions affecting an entire workforce.

    Those are not interchangeable.

    The fact that unions haven’t always succeeded doesn’t mean we no longer need them. It means we should be demanding better from them. Because whatever our individual experiences of union representation, I struggle to see how thousands of POs negotiating separately with HMPPS would leave any of us in a stronger position.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just to add, apologies for referring specifically to POs in my previous comment. The ballot and the issues surrounding pay, workloads and working conditions affect staff across the Probation Service, including PSOs, administrative colleagues and others. Every role matters, and all eligible members have an equal voice in this dispute. My intention certainly wasn’t to overlook the wider workforce or the contribution they make.

      Delete
  35. Does anyone seriously think the current workforce comprised of poorly educated robots will strike no chance ther le is no solidarity watch

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Complaining about a lack of solidarity while dismissing your colleagues as ‘poorly educated robots’. The irony is clearly lost on you. Perhaps the problem isn’t the intelligence of the workforce, but the contempt some seem to have for it.

      Delete
  36. https://nation.cymru/news/ministers-defend-pay-offer-for-probation-workers-amid-strike-threat/

    Alan Jones, Press Association Industrial Correspondent

    The UK Government has defended a pay offer to probation workers which has been rejected and sparked a threat of strikes.

    Members of Napo have voted in favour of industrial action over pay as well as their workloads. In a statement, the union confirmed: “We will be calling on our members in Probation England and Wales to commence a campaign of Industrial Action on Monday 23 November.”

    Initially, staff will still work their contracted hours but will not undertake any overtime. Members have also voted in favour of strikes, but no walkout dates have been confirmed yet."

    - Here's the mendacious moj's less than original take on events:

    "The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal.

    A spokesman said: “Probation staff do a vital job protecting the public, which is why we have put a strong offer on the table giving every worker a further 5% pay rise, which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade alongside record investment ... We’re also recruiting an additional 1,300 officers to significantly cut workloads."

    “While we are disappointed that some have voted against this competitive deal, it will not change our first responsibility of protecting the public and we have robust contingency plans in place to ensure offenders are still subject to the same rigorous supervision."
    ___________________________________________________
    Hansard, Feb 2025: "Probation is currently in a multi-year pay deal covering the period 1 April 2022 to 31 March 2025. This pay deal has provided certainty in pay increases throughout the period while securing necessary reforms to the pay structure helping to resolve some longstanding pay issues."

    ghost in't' machine says:

    Cumulative Pay vs. Cost of Living: According to probation trade unions (Napo, UNISON, and GMB/SCOOP), the cumulative nominal rise in probation staff pay points between 2010 and 2024 was roughly 11%, while RPI/cost-of-living metrics rose by over 81.2% over the same period, leaving real-terms pay significantly behind

    Austerity and Pay Freezes (2010s): Following the 2010 general election, public sector pay freezes and 1% public sector pay caps severely suppressed annual increments across the Probation Service for much of the decade.

    The 2022–2024 Multi-Year Deal: A previous multi-year framework yielded low annual increases (such as 3.2% in 2023 and 4.5% in 2024) that lagged behind high inflation peaks

    The 2025 Settlement (6% Award): Following union campaigns, rejections of initial government offers (such as an earlier 4% proposal), and ballot threats for industrial action, HMPPS and the government finalized a 6% increase across all pay points and cash allowances, backdated to April 1, 2025

    Current Pay Framework (Post-2025)

    • PQiP: £28,064 nationally
    • PSO, Band 3: £28,064 – £33,549.
    • Band 4: £37,238 – £44,520
    • Band 5: £46,746 – £48,760

    Let's have a look at those moj words again:

    "The Ministry of Justice said most probation trade unions had accepted its “competitive” pay deal." - aye, 2/3 = most; so well done unison & gmb for shafting your colleagues. However pisspoor napo have been over the last two decades, at least their members have managed to make a stand this time.

    "giving every worker a further 5% pay rise" - annual pay deals are just that; they will always be "a further" whatever, its not special treatment or a generous donation.

    "which follows the biggest probation pay increase in over a decade" - yep, because there's been fuck all for over a decade

    MP pay rise history since 2010
    April 2010 – March 2011: £65,73
    May 2015 – March 2016: £74,000 (+10.3%)
    April 2022 – March 2023: £84,144 (+2.7%)
    April 2023 – March 2024: £86,584 (+2.9%)
    April 2024 – March 2025: £91,346 (+5.5%)
    April 2025 – March 2026: £93,904 (+2.8%)
    April 2026 onward: £98,599 (+5.0%)

    MPs: Overall ~42% increase since 2010
    vs
    Probation Band 4 (max): ~24% increase since 2010

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And 42% of £65,ooo (£27,300) is worth three times more than 24% of £36,ooo (£8,640).

      Delete
  37. Pay for PO well behind social worker teacher and police con stable

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And why do you think that might be 13:29?

      Delete
  38. Job de professionalised despite workload

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We haven't done anything professional in decades. Let identify what today.

      Delete