I gave a talk last week to U3A. I've given loads of talks about probation over the years, never scripted, but rather shaped by my current mood, the prevailing situation and an assessment of how and why it's all gone wrong. I obviously have a pop at all the main political party's for their respective part in the demise of a once well-respected public service and profession, along with the part played by Tory rags like the Daily Mail. They were a particularly sparky bunch last Wednesday with two 'biting back'. "Why are you being so negative?" and "We can't afford to spend on all that old stuff". There's absolutely nothing positive to say about the situation and there's loadsamoney to spend downstream on yet more bloody places to lock everyone up.
--oo00oo--
If you listened to Charlie Taylor giving the Longford lecture you will notice his utterly damning verdict on HMPPS and MoJ ability to organise the proverbial piss-up in a brewey, so is it any surprise what's happened to probation under their command and control? Examples of how probation is now part of the problem abound on here regularly:-
Ten years ago, frontline, I had a youngish man due for release. I went to see him in advance, he was very nervous, he had all the "right" motivations, get a job, stay clean, stay out of trouble. But he had nowhere to go to, no accommodation on release. I chatted, we got to know each other. Time marched on. I referred to housing, I asked around, nada. I lost sleep over this one. For weeks. It seemed so horrible and frightening for him, and it was my duty to advise and assist. In the end a colleague - time served PSO - put me on to a local landlord he knew and we got it sorted. The accommodation was so dodgy I persuaded the housing authority to regard him as homeless. I persuaded my lad to stick with it. Two things from this. A. It was a relationship. I cared about him, deeply. B. The solution was local, boots on the ground. Nothing nothing about the way Probation is now enables any of this..“an all-White, all-female panel” … as are most of our management and senior management teams!
*****
• Trainees (PQiP): The incoming pipeline is heavily skewed, with 79% being female.
• Frontline Staff (Non-Managerial): Women represent 75.8% of the workforce.
• Middle Management: Women represent 74.3% of the workforce.
• Senior Leadership: Women represent 67.8% of the workforce.
• The Baseline Ethnicity: Roughly 80.8% of the entire service identifies as white.
So the upshot of this is that probation is probably the least diverse it has ever been while parroting on about diversity till the cows come home……….practice what you preach senior leaders……
"Dame Antonia Romeo, Cabinet Secretary and Head of the Civil Service - the most powerful unelected official in Britain - has been given her targets for the year. Not a single one of them has a number in them, let alone one that goes up; but they do nonetheless make for interesting reading. The targets were published at 5:23pm on Bonfire Night, with the public looking up at the sky, and with the mainstream press practising the same studious indifference to Britain's real centre of governing power as they always have.
Key Details on Progress for Britain
Independent Registration: According to the Electoral Commission, Progress (registration ID PP18166) was authorised as an independent political party in Great Britain on 28 October 2025. Its registered officers are Maxi Gorynski (Leader and Nominating Officer) and Sebastian Steele (Treasurer).
Stance on Reform UK: Progress for Britain markets itself as a movement "beyond left and right" aimed at the "politically homeless". When publicly introducing the party on X (formerly Twitter) on 15 April 2026, Treasurer Sebastian Steele explicitly dismissed Reform UK as a viable option, stating: "We can all see the Greens and Reform aren't serious choices. Progress is the answer."
Media Overlap: Party founder Maxi Gorynski has appeared on GB News and contributed articles to publications such as Spiked and The Reformer Scotland—a Scottish publication that also features contributors from Reform UK. However, this reflects overlapping media commentary rather than a political or organisational affiliation.
(Note: Progress for Britain is also completely separate from Progress, the long-running centre-left pressure group and think tank affiliated with the Labour Party.)
What was the gender balance when we were Trusts and a gold service? Just wondering if too many females have led to the demise of the service.
ReplyDelete"Just wondering if too many females have led to the demise of the service."
DeleteWhat a ludicrous thing to wonder... political imperative, punitive ideology & financial incentives killed the probation service we once knew... these are the most culpable perpetrators in approx chronological order, of which 1/20 is female.. and mostly for her inaction as opposed to anything proactive:
k baker
m howard
bliar
straw
blunkett
narey
c clarke
edwards
reid
falconer
straw (again)
wheatley
cameron
mcnally
hughes
clarke
spurr
grayling
gauke
buckland
And all white, of course.
DeleteHow could we have forgotten boateng so quickly? Never a home sec or justice minister per se:
Delete"In 1998, Boateng became a Minister of State at the Home Office and subsequently became Number 2 Minister there. He was made a Privy Counsellor in 1999. He earned a reputation for being tough on crime, particularly with regard to aggressive begging on the streets... 'We are a law enforcement agency. It's what we are, it's what we do'. "
Romero, Rees, Farar, Flynn, Thornden-Edward’s … should we go on?
Deletehmmm, one might argue that the damage was well & truly done by the time they came along; they simply oversaw the inevitable.
DeleteIf it was, it didn’t change and even worsened…..
DeleteHere we go thanks to AI:-
ReplyDeleteIn 1990, the Probation Service in England and Wales was still slightly male-dominated, nearing a 50/50 split. While exact figures for that specific year vary by grade, 1990 sat right in the middle of a major demographic shift for the profession:
• 1980 Baseline: Men made up roughly two-thirds (67%) of practitioners, while women accounted for one-third (33%).
• The 1990 Transition: Throughout the 1980s, the number of male officers remained relatively steady while female recruitment grew rapidly. By 1990, the gap had narrowed considerably as women approached half of the frontline workforce.
• The 1993 Tipping Point: Women officially outnumbered men at the maingrade probation officer level for the first time in 1993.
• Management Roles: Despite the near-parity among frontline officers in the early 1990s, senior management and chief officer roles remained heavily male-dominated during that decade.
By 2006, the historical 1980 ratio had completely inverted to roughly two-thirds women and one-third men, a trend detailed in research on the feminisation of probation and HM Prison and Probation Service workforce data.
It's difficult not to read that as a 'yes' to the original post.....
DeleteProbation has a diversity paradox: plenty of rhetoric, but very little representation. It has undergone a remarkable transformation from predominantly male to around three-quarters female, both on the frontline and in management. The separation from social work in the mid-1990s and the growing recruitment of criminology graduates from the 2000s onwards contributed to that shift. But it is difficult to ignore the irony of a service dealing predominantly with male clients having become so overwhelmingly female. Where is the gender balance? Surely the experiences and perspectives of the people being supervised should be reflected in the workforce responsible for supervising them.
ReplyDeleteEthnic diversity is an equally uncomfortable story. Around 80% of the workforce remains White, despite decades of equality strategies, diversity initiatives and talk about tackling institutional racism. How difficult must it be for some Black and ethnic minority staff to join, feel they belong, stay and progress? How many feel they have to suppress their cultural identity, moderate their behaviour or assimilate simply to fit in and get on? What sort of inclusion is it if people have to compromise who they are to succeed? And how do the black and ethnic minority service users feel about it?
Senior leaders need to stop congratulating themselves on diversity initiatives and start examining their own organisation. How many disciplinary proceedings involve Black staff? How many grievances are raised by them and not upheld? What does exit feedback tell us about why Black and ethnic minority colleagues leave? And how do those figures compare with the wider workforce? These are basic questions that deserve proper scrutiny.
This is hardly a new problem. In 2000, probation was already being publicly challenged over racism. By 2021, HM Inspectorate of Probation was reporting that race issues had been sidelined, with minority ethnic staff describing racism, inappropriate behaviour and complaints being ignored or dismissed. The shocking case of a Black female probation officer being sexually propositioned by a white male colleague on the basis that he had never slept with a Black woman illustrates just how deep some of these problems have been. In 2023, the Guardian reported the case of a Black probation officer subjected to monkey chants and other racist behaviour, who felt ignored and isolated after making a complaint. How many more incidents go unreported, are dismissed or are effectively tolerated by predominantly White management groups?
More recently, the Guardian reported warnings that sexual harassment, racism and bullying had become “normalised” in prisons and probation offices across England and Wales. These are not isolated concerns that can be dealt with through another round of diversity training.
More than two decades on from the original accusations, and five years after the 2021 watchdog findings, race equality is still described as a “work in progress”. At what point does a work in progress simply become an excuse for a lack of progress?
Plenty of rhetoric, glossy initiatives and self-congratulation. Perhaps it’s time probation leaders looked in the mirror and practice what they preach.
https://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/801451.stm
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/mar/16/race-issues-sidelined-since-probation-service-shake-up-says-watchdog
https://metro.co.uk/2021/03/16/probation-officer-propositioned-colleague-as-he-hadnt-slept-with-anyone-black-14254777/amp/
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/aug/24/prison-service-pays-undisclosed-sum-to-ex-contractor-lloyd-odain-over-racial-harassment
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2025/may/06/prisons-minister-vows-to-end-toxic-cover-up-culture-in-england-and-wales
https://hmiprobation.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/news/race-equality-in-probation-remains-a-work-in-progress/
Being Black, Asian or from another ethnic minority doesn’t mean we all have the same experiences. I won’t say if I’m a current or former employee, but being black you feel constantly watched, waiting to get something wrong, while things you get right go unnoticed. You learn to put up with the subtle comments, little digs, passive-aggressive behaviour and the lack of promotion you brush off and pretend it doesn’t bother you.
DeleteThis isn’t against white colleagues because plenty won’t tolerate discrimination, but they're in every team and the rot spreads. From what I’ve seen, move into middle management and it gets worse. Everyone watching, few willing to speak or work with you, everything under scrutiny and you just know what is coming. Senior management can be even lonelier. Either become the person they want you to be or stand your ground and deal with the consequences.
I’m sure some have had very different experiences, but the headlines didnt write themselves and all the talk about safe spaces and bringing your whole self to work doesn’t match reality. You learn what you can say, who you can say it to and when to keep quiet. What’s the point of diversity strategies when the statistics show an increasing white organisation, where the oppressed are expected to explain and fix the problems, while the oppressors hide behind the same policies, and everyone else looks the other way?
Being Black in the probation service has never been easy. Sometimes it feels like people would rather we kept quiet or left. I was lucky to have a Black manager once, someone who wasn’t afraid to stand up for colleagues and challenge discrimination. It made a difference but in the end we all find it’s better to move on.
Blaming the wrecking of the Probation Service on the workforce (regardless of gender, ethnicity etc) an outrageous suggestion. More interestingly ,the culture of the service pre TR, was caring and emotionally intelligent, ie , I suggest timidly, sterotypically female, while its workforce was predominantly male. Now we have a predominantly female workforce, with a culture of bullying, top-down dominance, control and enforcement...
ReplyDeleteSo probation’s ‘advise, assist and befriend’ ethos thrived under a predominantly male workforce, continued under a more balanced one, but became less caring and more dominating and controlling as the workforce became predominantly female. There’s a whole research project here on the shifting values and culture of probation. The question is, was that shift unintended or by design?
DeleteThe question isn’t why the workforce became less caring, but how changing workforce and management demographics coincided with a decline in professional status, identity, pay and working conditions, alongside a shift towards a less relational, more managerial, and enforcement-oriented culture. To understand where it went wrong, examine how changing gender and ethnic demographics, particularly in management, contributed to, reflected or were shaped by that transformation. Is it because of changes in the workforce, or a fundamental transformation of the profession itself?
DeleteThe dagger through the heart that destroyed probation was the removal of the social work requirement.
DeleteIt was that ethos that formed the corner stone that probation was founded on, operated on, and was successful on. Its removal destroyed its unique identity, leaving it open to whatever direction the politicians decided to shove it down. Probation would not (nor could mot) be in the dire state it finds itself in today if the social work requirement had not been removed.
'Getafix
Off topic - anyone heard of Sarah’s Helm. What all the fuss about? Sarah?
ReplyDelete“Probation work is not a branch of social work”: Post-1995 probation, social work and the making of separate professions
ReplyDeleteRegister for this webinar
All welcome at this free event on Wednesday, 24 February 2027 from 1pm-3pm (UK)
Thirty years on, this Social Work History Network webinar brings together people whose professional and academic lives span that period of change. Some trained at a time when movement between social work and probation was still relatively commonplace; others have researched what happened to probation and social work - their workforce and professional identity afterwards.
Using personal experience, historical research and contemporary perspectives, the panel will consider what was gained and what may have been lost when the professions moved apart. In particular, we will explore education and professional formation; workforce identity, mobility and resilience; the changing place of qualified and paraprofessional staff; and what professional boundaries mean for the people who encounter both social work and criminal justice systems.
The discussion will also look forward. At a time of renewed interest in probation professionalisation and regulation, what can this history tell us about professional identity, education and the relationship between social work and probation today?
https://www.kcl.ac.uk/events/probation-work-is-not-a-branch-of-social-work
Interesting topic and some prestigious names on the panel, but how can anyone assess the present or future of probation without a current probation officer or frontline voice? TR, unification and subsequent changes, where were these academic voices? Academic insight has its place, but summarising what we already know means little without the lived experience of those delivering probation or whatever we’re calling it these days.
DeleteThank you AI
ReplyDeletewhy was the social work requirements removed from probation?
In 1995, the UK Home Office removed the requirement for probation officers in England and Wales to hold a social work qualification (such as the Diploma in Social Work).
Official Reasons for the Change
• Widening Recruitment: A 1994 Civil Service review and subsequent Home Office arguments suggested that ending the social work mandate would help broaden and diversify the field of recruitment to bring in people with different backgrounds.
• Redefining Probation as a Justice Discipline: The government and then-Home Secretary argued that "probation work is not a branch of social work" and viewed probation as a distinct discipline in its own right—moving away from a welfare-focused model to a more enforcement- and compliance-oriented judicial function.
• Service-Led Training: The policy shifted qualifying education away from independent universities/social work programs and put training directly under the control of the probation service itself (leading to the introduction of the Diploma in Probation Studies in 1997).
Opposition and Controversy
The decision was heavily contested at the time—out of nearly 500 responses to the government consultation, only a small fraction supported it. Critics, practitioners, and academics argued that severing the link would narrow the training's focus and produce a more rigid system rather than fostering critical-thinking, anti-oppressive practice.
The critics were right.
DeleteProbation in danger
ReplyDeletePublished on March 3, 1995
Last updated May 27, 2015
Home Office plans to remove the professional training of probation officers from universities could close university social work departments, destroy the professional credibility of the probation service and seriously damage the link between research and practice, according to the joint university council of social work education.
David Ward, chair of the council's work with offenders subcommittee, said: "Departments that had responded to Government requests to give more attention to probation students will be most affected."
The Committee of Vice Chancellors and Principals has written to the Home Secretary Michael Howard arguing that the "most valuable benefits" of placing training within universities will be lost under the new proposals. "The knowledge base of probation owes a great deal to university-led research.This has made a significant contribution to the development of probation practice and has done much to shape the present probation service."
The Central Council for Education and Training in Social Work has also described the plans as "unnecessary, damaging and wasteful".
Launching the Review of Probation Office Recruitment and Qualifying Training last week, Mr Howard said: "I propose to sweep away the barriers to the recruitment of people who have relevant skills and experience to offer but who lack the social work diploma qualification which is at present required by the law."
But the National Association of Probation Officers argues that the university-based qualification is crucial if probation officers are to gain the necessary legal, criminal and social policy training. A spokesman said: "These new recruits are being set up to fail. This is a potentially disastrous move that will increase the likelihood of offenders reoffending."
There are about 30 departments of social work in universities and colleges that offer probation training at qualifying level.
William Forsythe, head of the department of social work and probation studies at Exeter University, said: "All these departments will be badly affected by the move. These courses are all run in partnership with the probation service."
'Getafix
I would say to those considering training as a PO, taking on the responsibilities and stress - don’t bother. You can walk into a band 4 job with hardly any qualifications/training , little experience and put up with less shit as a PO (Napo magazine ) ‘’ DASO Rebanding Victory: Recognition Through Collective Action
ReplyDeleteAfter years of campaigning, evidence gathering and collective action, Napo has secured a hard-fought victory for Domestic Abuse Safety Officers (DASOs), with the role successfully regraded from Band 3 to Band 4.