We seem to be on a roll in exploring all aspects of why the probation service has gone from gold standard to utterly broken with news of the upcoming free webinar by the Social Work Network next February:-
“Probation work is not a branch of social work”: Post-1995 probation, social work and the making of separate professionsProfessor Mark Drakeford | Professor Anne Worrall | Professor Gwen Robinson | Professor Aidan Worsley | Russell Webster | Dr Caroline J. Bald (Chair)
Baroness Blatch’s wording in the House of Lords on 5 December 1995, when she defended the removal of the social work qualification requirement and described probation as “a discipline in its own right”.
What happened when probation and social work ceased to share a professional route – and what does that history mean now?
In 1995, the Home Office removed the requirement for probation officers in England and Wales to hold a social work qualification and began the process of separating probation education from social work education. The change marked an important point in the development of two increasingly distinct professions. It was also strongly contested: of 493 responses to the consultation on the proposed changes, only 11 supported the proposals in full.
Thirty years on, this Social Work History Network webinar brings together people whose professional and academic lives span that period of change. Some trained at a time when movement between social work and probation was still relatively commonplace; others have researched what happened to probation and social work - their workforce and professional identity afterwards.
Using personal experience, historical research and contemporary perspectives, the panel will consider what was gained and what may have been lost when the professions moved apart. In particular, we will explore education and professional formation; workforce identity, mobility and resilience; the changing place of qualified and paraprofessional staff; and what professional boundaries mean for the people who encounter both social work and criminal justice systems.
The discussion will also look forward. At a time of renewed interest in probation professionalisation and regulation, what can this history tell us about professional identity, education and the relationship between social work and probation today?
There will be time for discussion and questions from the audience.
Why was the social work requirement removed from probation? Thank you AI:-
In 1995, the UK Home Office removed the requirement for probation officers in England and Wales to hold a social work qualification (such as the Diploma in Social Work).
Official Reasons for the Change
- Widening Recruitment: A 1994 Civil Service review and subsequent Home Office arguments suggested that ending the social work mandate would help broaden and diversify the field of recruitment to bring in people with different backgrounds.
- Redefining Probation as a Justice Discipline: The government and then-Home Secretary argued that "probation work is not a branch of social work" and viewed probation as a distinct discipline in its own right—moving away from a welfare-focused model to a more enforcement- and compliance-oriented judicial function.
- Service-Led Training: The policy shifted qualifying education away from independent universities/social work programs and put training directly under the control of the probation service itself (leading to the introduction of the Diploma in Probation Studies in 1997).
The decision was heavily contested at the time—out of nearly 500 responses to the government consultation, only a small fraction supported it. Critics, practitioners, and academics argued that severing the link would narrow the training's focus and produce a more rigid system rather than fostering critical-thinking, anti-oppressive practice.
The Full Quote
"Prison works. It ensures that we are protected from murderers, muggers and rapists – and it makes many who are tempted to commit crime think twice ... This may mean that more people will go to prison. I do not flinch from that. We shall no longer judge the success of our system of justice by a fall in our prison population."
Oh look, this bollocks is still current in the Tory Party:-
Prison Works: Building a stronger, fairer justice systemIn a major speech, the Shadow Justice Secretary, Nick Timothy MP CBE sets out why prison works and why Britain needs much more of it. Too many violent and repeat offenders avoid custody, and those who are jailed are held in a crumbling Victorian estate. The speech will make the case for a radical expansion of capacity through new, purpose-built prisons, a reset of the relationship between the MoJ and HMPPS, and greater independence for governors, all aimed at a system that keeps the public safe. Westminster 24th November 2026.
--oo00oo--
While we're at it, thanks to AI, lets remind ourselves of other stand-out moments of Howards time at the Home Office:-
In October 1995, then-Home Secretary Michael Howard sacked Derek Lewis, the Director General of HM Prison Service, following a series of high-profile prison escapes. The dismissal sparked a major constitutional row over ministerial responsibility and led to a landmark High Court settlement and one of British television's most famous political interviews.Background and Dismissal
The Escapes: The crisis was triggered by high-security breakouts, most notably the escape of three inmates from Parkhurst Prison on the Isle of Wight in January 1995 and an earlier breakout from Whitemoor Prison.
The Learmont Report: Howard commissioned an independent inquiry led by General Sir John Learmont. Published in October 1995, the report criticised management failures across the Prison Service from top to bottom.
The Sacking: On the day the report was released, Howard demanded Lewis's resignation. When Lewis refused to step down, Howard dismissed him.
Political and Legal Fallout
Policy vs. Operations: HM Prison Service had recently been established as an executive agency. Howard maintained that he was responsible for overall policy, while Lewis held sole responsibility for day-to-day operations. Critics and opposition MPs argued Howard was using this distinction as a political shield to avoid resigning himself.
Wrongful Dismissal Settlement: Lewis sued the Home Office for breach of contract and wrongful dismissal, arguing Howard had repeatedly interfered in operational matters. In March 1996, the Home Office reached an out-of-court High Court settlement, agreeing to pay Lewis £125,000 (one year's salary) plus additional pension and bonus compensation.
Newsnight Interview: During the 1997 Conservative leadership contest, BBC presenter Jeremy Paxman repeatedly asked Howard whether he had threatened to overrule Lewis over the removal of Parkhurst's governor, John Marriott. Howard evaded giving a direct yes-or-no answer to the exact same question 12 times, creating a defining moment in British political broadcasting.
Subsequent Revelations: Former Prisons Minister Ann Widdecombe publicly clashed with Howard in 1997 over his handling of the affair, famously remarking that he had "something of the night" about him. In 2005, Home Office documents released under the Freedom of Information Act showed that while Howard had privately inquired about his power to overrule Lewis, he accepted civil service advice against doing so and issued no formal instruction.
Twenty Year Stretch: Michael Howard and the Legacy of Punishment
"Howard’s legacy was longer lasting however. By provoking political adversaries to oppose his reforms, he pushed his shadow Tony Blair and New Labour as a whole into a repressive approach to penal policy. Prison numbers have continued to rise ever since 1993.
More disturbing perhaps was Howard’s shamelessly populist approach to law and order- most notoriously in his attempts to increase the tariff for the juvenile killers of James Bulger, later described by a senior judge as “ institutionalised vengeance ... [by] a politician playing to the gallery”. In respect of his sentencing policy the Lord Chief Justice told the House of Lords that “Never in the history of our criminal law have such far reaching proposals been put forward on the strength of such flimsy and dubious evidence.” Indeed the most recent review of evidence by the Ministry of Justice has found that “to date there has been no clear consensus from criminologists and commentators about whether there is an incapacitation effect at all, and if so, its scale.”
Howard’s treatment of the probation service was equally cavalier, removing the requirement for university based social work training and threatening the very existence of the service. When he left office recruitment had almost dried up and it was left to Jack Straw to introduce a new scheme of professional training as an urgent priority."
Rob Allen
Emotive title, Probation work is not an official branch of social work but social work practices and ideas are embedded within probation. I’ll echo Anon 8 November 2026 at 19:46 about the Social Work Network next February - “Probation work is not a branch of social work”: Interesting topic and some prestigious names on the panel, but how can anyone assess the present or future of probation without current probation officers with suitable experience, knowledge and understanding, or frontline voices? TR, unification and subsequent changes, where were these social workers, professors and academic voices? Academic insight has its place, but summarising what we already know which is what they all seem to do nowadays means little without the lived experience of those working in probation today.
ReplyDeletehttps://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/02645505241241588
DeleteProbation As Social Work by Rob Canton published in Napo Journal April 2024. Most unusually, but in recognition of its importance, I published the whole long article in four parts.
DeleteAbstract
In England and Wales probation was regarded as social work for most of the twentieth century, but some thirty years ago the government rejected this conception. In the context of continuing deliberations about the purpose and character of probation, it is timely to revisit its relationship to social work. It is argued that a principal reason for the politically motivated repudiation of social work was its associations with care, but this rested on confusion about care and a comparable misunderstanding of the concept of control. Appreciation of social context is argued to be fundamental to the work of probation. Social capital is no less important than human capital in achieving desistance. The skills and values of social work continue to inform probation because they match up to the demands of the job. Reaffirming connections between the professions would enhance the policy and practices of both.
ghost in't'machine also reminds us:
ReplyDelete"David Waddington's View: As a Conservative Home Secretary, Waddington published a seminal 1990 White Paper where he famously stated that "prison is an expensive way of making bad people worse." He argued that while custody was necessary to protect the public from dangerous offenders, it did little to rehabilitate minor criminals and often acted as a "university of crime". "
But this was ignored and instead the Home Secretary embarked on the “prison works” agenda with the underlying strategy drawing heavily from US thinkers and policies developed during the 1970s and 1980s used to expand incarceration.
DeleteIt is an obvious fact of life that the Probation Service will not progress unless one is honest about where things have gone wrong. And if you are not able to blame yourself when you are to blame, the chances are you will not be able to correct yourself.
ReplyDeletePoliticians and the incumbent holders of political office and HMPPS corporate key leadership have a duty to hold honest and unflinching reflection and interrogate why Probation Service in England and Wales is facing a critical collapse driven by severe staffing shortages, explosive caseloads, and the fallout of past structural overhauls. It appears that there isn’t even a token of navel gazing, never mind serious reflection and assessment as to what went wrong, why did it go wrong and how can the service be brought back to being fit for purpose and prevent the same reoccurring.
If our politicians and HMPPS key leadership are not able to take personal accountability for their mistakes, accountability within themselves, they will not be able to change direction.
The last 14 odd years has taught us much about our political leaders and key corporate leadership . The future of Probation Service now depends on whether they can actually behave rationally, without allowing their emotions and personal career ambitions to overrule them and act in the best interests of the Probation Service to ensure it can fulfill its mandate.
And whether they can, in the immortal phrase, leave their egos at the door.
But what is worse that no Secretary of State nor the whole parliament has reversed the nonsense imposed by the Conservatives under Michael Howard. The Liberal Democrats should have demanded it in 2010 but they backed the Grayling nonsense - my career when backwards from then - but I had already needed to be creative with the way I served court orders after the 1991 legislation - labelling convicts as offenders for ever more - the start was in 1984 with the incrementally increasing centralisation after Leon Brittan' became Home Secretary - the few who feared what was coming either like me failed in our campaigning and/or put our own careers above preventing a national disaster in England and Wales - I failed on both counts.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.gov.uk/government/publications/updated-estimates-of-children-with-a-parent-in-prison/transparency-data-updated-estimates-of-children-with-a-parent-in-prison
Delete"From October 2023 to October 2024, an estimated 219,000 children had a parent in prison in England and Wales, with an estimated 2% of school-aged children experiencing parental imprisonment.
The vulnerability of this population is highlighted by the finding that at least half (53%) of children identified were at risk of harm from the imprisoned parent."
https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/person-sets-fire-newport-probation-34887457
ReplyDeletePolice are investigating reports of a burglary and arson at the Newport Probation Service office in Lower Dock Street on Sunday, November 1.
DeleteOfficers from Gwent Police attended a report that an unknown person or people had broken into the offices and taken a number of items. The report was made at 10.20pm however, it is believed that the burglary happened between 9pm and 10pm.
According to the force, while waiting for the window to be boarded up, security staff have witnessed an unknown person access the building through the window and set fire to the property just before midnight.
The unknown person was described as wearing a balaclava, grey jogging bottoms, black jacket and shoes and carrying a knife. The person then left in the direction of George Street, Newport.
Emergency services included South Wales Fire and Rescue Service, attended and enquiries are ongoing.
Investigating officers are now appealing anyone who was in the area between 9pm on Sunday, November 1 and 12.30am on Monday, November 2 to contact.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c51kdk8z7ym3o
ReplyDeleteDominic Casciani
Home and legal correspondent
Published
6 hours ago
Around 650 more offenders will leave jails in England and Wales on Tuesday in the third phase of the government's plan to end the prison population crisis.
The group will include offenders serving up to three years and two months for their crimes.
Under the new rules, they are leaving jail after serving no more than a third of their sentence behind bars, rather than a half.
At least 1,350 offenders have left jail early since 1 October under the first two waves of the scheme.
By the end of the year officials project that at least 2,500 will have been let out to spend two-thirds of their sentence on a licence in the community.
Tuesday's third stage continues the process of releasing batches of offenders serving increasingly long sentences - culminating next June with those serving more than 12 years.
The cohort will include people convicted of affray, which has a maximum sentence of three years, burglary and fraud.
Some violent offenders convicted of wounding, grievous bodily harm with intent or lower-end firearms charges could also be released.
Offenders convicted of one of more than 70 offences are exempt from the earlier release scheme, including manslaughter, rape, sexual and grooming offences and those on life terms.
Weekly prison population statistics show that the early release programme is having an impact - for now - on the population crisis inside jails.
On Monday the latest release of weekly data showed there were 86,982 people in jail, with enough spare spaces to take in 2,076 additional offenders if needs be.
That is 500 more cells available at any one time than was the case on the eve of the programme beginning in October.
Victims' groups and survivors have also raised concerns. Refuge, which supports survivors of domestic abuse, told the BBC last month that perpetrators of such abuse were among those being released.
Typically, those being released should expect to be electronically tagged and subject to other monitoring conditions for the second third of their sentence.
Once outside, they will be monitored by probation officers, who are responsible for trying to make sure that offenders take part in courses or other programmes to turn around their lives - and also that they keep to their licence conditions, which can include bans on entering certain areas and contacting victims.
The government has not yet published any figures for the rate of recall of prisoners to jails for breaching their licence conditions.
The most up to date statistics show that just 12,338 offenders were sent back to jail for breaching their terms between April and June. That was 12% higher than the year before but a decrease on the first three months of the year.
Rehabilitation experts say that the recalls are often more likely to be linked to the offender failing to keep to appointments or living at a specific address. Around a fifth of recalls are for a new offence.
Napo, the probation service union, has previously said the releases have put enormous strain on its members who are charged with monitoring the offenders in the community.
DeleteIts members have been balloted over recent weeks on potential strike action over pay and conditions - and the result of that poll is expected on Friday.
The government has offered probation officers a 5% pay rise by the Ministry of Justice, while it had demanded 12% as part of a plan to make up for loss of earnings caused by cuts from 2010.
The Ministry of Justice says the offer is fair and has been accepted by two other unions and is twinned with a £700m investment in probation to recruit 1,300 extra officers and the roll-out of AI tools to cut the workload of monitoring offenders.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has previously criticised the scheme, saying she was "worried about dangerous people being let out on the street when they haven't served their sentence, haven't been rehabilitated".
An early release programme introduced by the Conservatives saw more than 10,000 prisoners freed early between October 2023 and September 2024.
1300 new officers and £700m investment in Probation. Best joke of the year!
DeleteAccepted by 2 other unions? ballot has not yet closed
DeleteMeanwhile:-
ReplyDeleteRewiring the state and the future civil service
The Cabinet Secretary’s Annual Lecture
Tuesday 10 November 2026 6.30pm - 8pm
This is a defining moment for the UK Civil Service, tasked with rewiring the state and increasing resilience to deliver for the ministers and the country. Transformation is no longer optional - it is urgent and imperative.
With a major institutional reform programme underway, please join the Cabinet Secretary and Head of the Civil Service, Dame Antonia Romeo, as she reflects on how the organisation can become a global leader in modern, AI-enabled public service delivery: more productive, more agile, and more relentless in its pursuit of technological advancement and devolution of power.
Meet our speaker and chair
LSE alumna Dame Antonia Romeo (MSc Econ) is Cabinet Secretary and Head of the Civil Service, leading half a million civil servants to implement the Government’s agenda, deliver essential public services, and reform the Civil Service. She also acts as the Prime Minister's principal policy adviser and Secretary to the Cabinet. This follows nine years as Permanent Secretary of three Government departments: the Home Office, the Ministry of Justice and Department for International Trade. Dame Antonia has held a number of senior roles in the civil service including Her Majesty’s Consul General in New York, Special Envoy to the US technology companies, and Director General of Economic and Domestic Affairs in the Cabinet Office. She joined the Civil Service in 2000 as a professional economist following an early career in the private sector at strategic consultancy firm Oliver Wyman.
The head of the civil service is expected to say Whitehall must become more productive under plans for a “fundamental” overhaul.
DeleteCabinet secretary Dame Antonia Romeo will warn departments must improve efficiency in a “tight fiscal context” and argue changes are needed to address low public trust and the emergence of AI.
Chancellor John Healey earlier told departments to make 1 per cent cuts to their capital budgets to fund defence amid Andy Burnham’s wider drive to streamline central government in Whitehall, and push power into the regions.
Dame Antonia will say Whitehall must be reimagined in “the most fundamental way”, according to The Telegraph, and “the civil service of tomorrow must look very different from the civil service of today”.
In a speech at the London School of Economics on Tuesday, she is expected to argue: “Improving our productivity and efficiency is therefore essential in a tight fiscal context. It’s the only way we will be able to meet increased demand for services.”
She will praise the “remarkable institution” she leads but argue that officials must adapt to the age of AI, which “represents the most profound paradigm shift in modern governance”.
“For the first time in history, the efficacy of public service no longer has to be artificially constrained by the limits of human bandwidth,” the cabinet secretary is expected to say. “We must remain capable of explaining how and why decisions are made to retain public trust. Ethical and transparent deployment of AI with appropriate guardrails must be our overriding principle.”
She will also call for more to be done to improve public trust, arguing that “trust in public institutions generally has reduced and needs to be re-earned”.
“For the first time in history, the efficacy of public service no longer has to be artificially constrained by the limits of human bandwidth”
DeleteWhat utter claptrap; a series of meaningless grunts & noises from a pointless, callous, self-obsessed individual who has left nothing but chaos & despair in her wake.
Ghost in't'machine says:
"A self-obsessed person is someone with an extreme, single-minded preoccupation with their own needs, desires, image, and thoughts, often showing little to no genuine regard for the perspectives or feelings of others.
Common Signs
• Conversation dominance: They frequently steer every discussion back to their own lives, achievements, or problems.
• Lack of empathy: They struggle to see things from someone else's point of view or offer meaningful emotional support.
• Constant need for validation: They look for continuous praise, attention, and a supportive "audience" to feed their ego.
• Difficulty compromising: They expect things to be done strictly on their terms and may blame others when things go wrong.
Potential Causes
• Upbringing: Being raised in an environment where they were never taught to consider others.
• Early rejection or neglect: Feeling unseen or unprioritized in childhood, leading to an intense adult drive to command the spotlight.
How to Deal with Self-Obsessed Behavior
• Set firm boundaries: Keep interactions brief, neutral, and direct (e.g., politely excusing yourself) without getting drawn into power struggles.
• Lower your expectations: Accept that reciprocity may be low or non-existent in the relationship.
• Seek balanced connections: Invest your emotional energy in people who offer mutual care and active listening
In an attempt to work out what Antonio was on about I found this article regarding human bandwidth. In The Atomic Human (2025), Neil D. Lawrence introduces the concept of bandwidth as a core framework for understanding the fundamental differences between human and artificial intelligence. An AI system might analyse all of Shakespeare’s works statistically in moments but cannot appreciate the human experiences that gave them birth or the emotional impact they create in readers. The machine’s bandwidth is wide but shallow; the human’s is narrow but deep.
DeleteWide but shallow. So whilst they process masses of information in a short time they lack emotional depth. Pretty good fit for the MOJ.
Niiice!!
Deletethat speech in full
Deletehttps://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/rewiring-the-state-and-the-future-civil-service
And here are the cabsec's "objectives" as referred to by reflux (or whatever they're called)
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6aeca8103e39e22b60743579/Cabinet_Secretary_Objectives_2026_2027__updated_.pdf
"Details - The Cabinet Secretary and Head of the Civil Service’s objectives for 2026-27, as agreed by the Prime Minister (updated November 2026)."
Women and the Criminal Justice System 2025
ReplyDeleteThese statistics will be released on 26 November 2026 9:30am
Casciani/BBC in attempt at kindly spin on prison numbers:
ReplyDelete"On Monday the latest release of weekly data showed there were 86,982 people in jail, with enough spare spaces to take in 2,076 additional offenders if needs be.
That is 500 more cells available at any one time than was the case on the eve of the programme beginning in October."
Population for week to 9 Nov'26: 86,982 + 99
Population for week to 2 Nov'26 86,883 + 49
Population for week to 26 Oct'26 86,834 +277
Population for week to 19 Oct'26 86,557 -476
Population for week to 12 Oct'26 87,033 +254
Population for week to 5 Oct'26 86,779 -720
THE BIG RELEASE of 700 people
Population for week to 28 Sept'26 87,499 +254
Population for week to 21 Sept'26 87,245
I make that 922 in & 1176 out over those eight weeks, a net gain of 254 places in the system... or a net loss of 446 places if we allow for the extraordinary 700 on 1 Oct which was supposed to 'free up' space.
Meanwhile, time to change the means of collecting the data (again):
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6af1bd492bbfd6e00e470e41/changes-format-population-bulletin-monthly.pdf
"Continuity / Comparison to historic data
To maintain continuity and enable comparisons with historical data, the previously published aggregated figures can be recreated by combining the relevant individual establishment totals. For example, adding together the figures for Usk and Prescoed will produce a total directly comparable with the previously published combined figure for Usk/Prescoed."
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cr86z6zpdqg4o
ReplyDelete* Cyber criminal orchestrated £2m crypto theft bid from jail cell - "This was an attempted crime that married 21st Century computer sophistication with old fashioned housebreaking in an audacious attempt to steal cryptocurrency of up to £2m... It was apparently devised and directed from a prison cell"
https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/median-and-mean-salary-of-civil-servants-by-department-and-working-pattern-2016-to-2026
ReplyDeleteMinistry of Justice (Overall - civil servants)
median salary 2026 - 35,530
mean salary 2026 - 38,020
median salary 2016 - 25,430
mean salary 2016 - 27,510
The Secret Barrister
ReplyDeleteHow can Russell Brand’s barrister suggest that a victim of sexual assault is “not particularly vulnerable”?
By thesecretbarrister on November 11, 2026
JB you disappoint me 😉. Thought you would have a brilliant article up by now re the ballot results re NAPO, Unison et al. Come on mate! Get your fingers on the keyboard. Waiting while frothing at the mouth in anticipation 😊 Always makes my day to see a new post from you.
ReplyDelete