Sunday 9 June 2024

A New Journey

Since this blog journey began a long time ago it's changed, adapted, responded and developed in a number of ways and certainly kept me engaged, amused, enlightened and massively informed. It was never intended to be about me, but to the astute or regular reader it will have inevitably revealed much of my character, interests and core beliefs. Along the way the audience has changed as has the way it's physically viewed and inter-acted with. My initial scepticism of Twitter was quickly dispelled and is now vital both for information-gathering and two-way debate and discussion. 

Regular readers will recall the blog was unmoderated for many years, but the character, quantity and quality of contributions has changed dramatically, as a consequence and reflection of the probation workforce and indeed it's disastrous enforced takeover by HM Prison Service and the dead hand of civil service control. Moderation now sadly has to routinely discard much that is deliberately inflammatory, conspiratorial, libellous, boring or seriously off subject, which is a shame because I'm pretty liberal as far as topic areas are concerned.

Many times packing it in has been actively considered, but every time something significant happens and probation gets in the media and the thing takes off again. And lets be honest, I've got a lot invested emotionally to happily rise regularly at silly o'clock to knock something out. But, at the beginning of the year it began to dawn that it would be sensible to be at least considering how it might gently coast to conclusion, and that would be a shame without adding something of my probation journey, not least because it has shaped me as a person enormously. 

Some may be aware that earlier in the year I was very kindly invited to effectively 'come out' and speak to my old Napo branch at an open meeting. Thankfully it was 'hybrid' with some colleagues in the room and many more online. Many in the audience were fairly new to the profession and some not in Napo, but the enthusiasm and energy that soon became apparent was truly inspiring as many began to realise things used to be very different and they could be again if people started doing something about it. I came away feeling much more confident in knowing how to proceed and in particular how I might start talking more of my own probation journey and before it is too late. 

That first public outing and very kind positive feedback subsequently led to being invited to address a London Napo branch meeting and although of necessity online only, nevertheless led to a lively and stimulating discussion. I've enjoyed both experiences enormously and as I say, gives me renewed hope that the probation ethos still resonates, has a future and we must continue to keep that flame burning, particularly in light of significant impending changes in the domestic political landscape. I'm very much looking forward to attending the forthcoming Bill McWilliams lecture in Cambridge on 27th June and the Napo AGM and conference when it returns to that great city of Newcastle in October.

But this isn't the only new journey on the cards. I wanted to share that quite unexpectedly I find myself in the wonderful care and treatment of our fantastic NHS as I start a course of chemo. I'm hugely lucky in having had no obvious side effects so far, beyond increased need for rest and naps, but it serves to remind me that normal service may be interrupted on occasion.

I'll end this by mentioning a book I'm currently reading 'Life On Air - A History of Radio Four' by David Hendy. 'Revelatory' says a review, and indeed it is. I suspect like many people, and as confirmed within the book, people grow into Radio Four and only in later life begin to realise what a very special life-enhancing institution it is - but boy I had no idea of the behind-the-scenes battle for it's survival. A battle that continues right to the present day of course under sustained political pressure and cuts from successive governments and parties. 

I'm on the final stretch of the book, but this struck a particular chord with me, discussing as it was the constant internal BBC battle to ensure that Radio Four retained its rich mix of content:-

"But the one all-encompassing idea that drew these various arguments together was that the 'rich mix' was somehow the quintessence of the Reithian ideal - and that to dismantle it would be a betrayal of the founding mission of the BBC."  

"....'broadcasting', he told colleagues, 'meant scattering widely' - and an assumption 'that some of the seed would take root and grow'. In broadcasting, just as in gardening, quality emerged not from rapid change and zealous assaults, but from a steady, organic growth nurtured with patient care. 'It was extraordinary, the Editor of 'Woman's Hour' once pointed out, 'how good gardeners were always good broadcasters.'  

What a wonderful probation metaphor I thought.                

37 comments:

  1. Jim I feel part of your story mate. Before that how saddened to read of your treatment and obviously wish you speedy full wellness.
    Your experience in speaking to branches is what usually inspire members to full activism participation demonstration rebellion. Some of the experienced will tell you there are two camps in the union . Those that preserve the revenues to self interest and those believers who still think there is a fight to be had. Terms conditions and costly areas of representing members properly. The ones that lose are them members as Napo direction has seen a decline to funding members protection seeking only to save their salaries and with the memberships enthusiasm to develop fight and solidarity went as well . Just my view but good luck with your infiltration you should have run for the general secretary role previous experience would not be essential actually as the job really doesn't need that it only needs a Mann with a passion and heart for probation. Something you have in excess.

    ReplyDelete
  2. From Twitter:-

    "All ‘offence focused’ work has now been scrapped. There will be only one offending behaviour programme going forward, this will cover all offenders."

    ReplyDelete
  3. From Twitter:-

    "The country needs more secure mental health facilities not prisons. Use the prison building money to build mental health hospitals."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-politics-69103457

      Delete
  4. BBCNews: "Labour pledges 20,000 more prison places while Tories promise £730m for mental health services"

    Sung to a familiar tune: "They're beginning to sound a lot like tories"

    ReplyDelete
  5. I wish you well on your road to health.

    ReplyDelete
  6. From Twitter:-

    "I'm getting tired of all the posts blaming prisons for not doing enough. We are very much against ECSL and do everything we can to prevent early release. We do all we can to prepare the people we work with but what good does it do if the support isn't there on the outside?

    People are being released homeless, with no drug/mental health support. Is this the fault of the prison? People are also being given such short sentences that we do not physically have enough time to help everyone. Is this also our fault?

    We see the same reasons for recall over and over. Men being sent to reside in areas which are not close to home, not living where they have been directed. Is this the prisons fault?

    We have all been trained to manage risk. We have additional training to manage risk in a prison and many of us have years of experience working in the community, in APs and courts. To suggest we don't know what we are doing is hugely offensive.

    How about we stop blaming each other, acknowledge that we are all trying our best and dealing with a broken system that has failed everyone?"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Many prisons are not “doing enough”. OMUs in prisons by their very design pit themselves against probation offices. Probation officers in prison OMUs and probation officers in community probation offices are not the same.

      Delete
    2. From Twitter:-

      "It’s absolutely not the fault of the POM or the prison - by any means! It’s the ministers. We’re all fighting a losing battle - sorry you feel that you’re being blamed. Anyone on the front line knows it’s not the fault of prisons (from a COM!)"

      Delete
    3. Seen a lot of prison time myself working roles by the way but on basic observation prison staff do very little than while the day away much like the inmates. How hard is it to lock em in all day and wander around with a few legal visits. Real recording and rehabilitation are just politic speak. Labour are talking tough justice as punishment I heard so no use hoping for them then.

      Delete
    4. The short sentences are even shorter because of ECSL. But even when they're not, no work is being carried out around addressing the offending or utilising the resettlement departments of prisons. It involves a scurry of emails around CAS-3, Duty to Refer and the AP in short order by the COM. I see little empathy in these imposed notices for ECSL and that is something within a prison POM's gift. The divisions are created becauswe ECSL favours prisons- fewer prisoners, less work, easier to run the ship. Two weeks is not enough in many cases and we were told no high risk to be released and it was 35 now it's 70 days.Jump when we tell you to jump and there's another comms from the prison and your soul leaves your body as it drains from the anticipation of even more work. I don't want to create division either, but then prisons don't help themselves. Clause 26 of ECSL (this isn't true, but for illustrative purposes): If COM starts complaining continue to mention Annex M. Don't respond if COM has asked if work been carried out regarding addressing offending or resettlement- that's for the COMs to deal with. Reduce time for licence conditions submission has been enacted- we as a prison can't have that processed in short order but we will have it backed up in policy on Delius. But we can make the COM do lots of resettlement work in a very short space of time. Do you know how overworked CAS-3 , APs and council housing divisions are because of ECSL or referral drug or counselling agencies, mental health or OPD Pathway? I'm not saying prisons have it easy, but the community is fighting fire with water pistols. and prisons have not grasped this.

      Delete
  7. Best wishes with the treatment.

    / Probation Officer

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sky news:-

    Labour has pledged to deliver 14,000 new prison places to tackle the overcrowding crisis if it gets into government.

    The party has announced plans to unblock the planning system in order to expand the prison estate and ease capacity.

    Prisoners have been let out of jail early in recent months as part of emergency measures to tackle a chronic shortage of spaces.

    Overcrowding has also resulted in offenders being held in police cells and officers being asked to consider making fewer arrests.

    Labour said the prison estate is "bursting at the seams" due to inaction and mismanagement by the Conservatives.

    The Tories previously promised to deliver 20,000 new prison places by the mid 2020s but only 6,000 have been created so far.

    Labour said it will deliver the remaining 14,000 if it gets into government.

    Shadow justice secretary Shabana Mahmood said: "The crisis in our prisons is a powder keg waiting to explode. Worse still, we never had to get to this point.

    "The dangerous overcrowding of our prisons was foreseeable and avoidable, but this government has not had the will or courage to act."

    She added: "We will build the prison places they promised but never delivered and we will drive down reoffending."

    It is understood the new spaces will be created by a mix of expanding the size of current prisons and building new ones.

    Labour plans to designate prisons as sites of national importance, placing the power to approve a planning decision in ministers' hands, in order to speed up the process.

    In 2019, then prime minister Boris Johnson pledged to create an additional 10,000 prison spaces by 2025. This was on top of the 10,000 places his predecessor Theresa May had promised to build in 2016.

    The commitment was reaffirmed in the 2021 Spending Review, which said the government would spend £3.8m to provide 20,000 prison places by the mid 2020s.

    But the project has been bogged down by planning constraints with reports suggesting the extra spaces will not be delivered until 2030.

    Labour is also proposing to bring together prison governors and local employers to create employment councils to drive down reoffending, link offenders to training and jobs, and reduce the burden on capacity in the long term.

    In a further law and order offering, the party wants to set up 80 new specialist rape courts across and England and Wales to fast-track cases as part of plans to tackle violence against women and girls that will be included in Labour's manifesto this week.

    It will also comprise a pledge to introduce specialist rape units in every police force, where staff trained to deal with domestic abuse will work with victims, Sky News understands.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Increasing the number of prison places will ultimately only serve to increase the prison population further.
      The focus needs to be on how to keep people out of prison and not on how to squeeze more in.

      'Getafix

      Delete
  9. Is Sunak about to resign?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Heard that muted LBC to go over the d day gaff . He should go anyway too rich off the backs of hedge fund trading robbing any shares from mug investors. Let's hope so anyway . His Californian home is sounding attractive for new school term ..

      Delete
  10. JB: you'll beat the C & then together we can beat the middle class wankers across all party lines who think prisons are a panacea.

    Hint: its not an Italian pudding.

    Solidarity is the answer.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Labour has pledged to deliver 14,000 new prison places to tackle the overcrowding crisis if it gets into government. What is the point? Soon those 14000 places will be full too.

    If mass incarceration is what they want then replace every prison bed with a double or triple bunk bed. Another option is do away with beds altogether and then they could fit at least 3 or 4 prisoners to every single cell. That’ll double and triple prison capacity overnight. It wont increase staffing, improve rehabilitation or reduce crime.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/msps-call-urgent-review-scottish-prisons

      Delete
    2. At last it seems to me at the very least any party talking jail places more prison anti release punishments is not talking freedom with condition. No rehabilitation. Not social housing reform not mental health drugs rehab facilities tough on the real causes of crime. Poverty drug dealers piss poor housing councils shite social care run down public service. Following the Tories in workhouse values just blows my mind. No change then. As for posters the old values won't be coming back it's a new era. Inmates are not your old school it's a fair cop guv. Jail is a multi cultural punishment universal depravation and full assault on mental well being no one comes out a jail without further damage these days.

      Delete
  12. Best wishes Jim - I do hope the chemo does the job. I have followed your blog from the beginning and now, as a fairly recently retired PO (some 39 years service, one of the vanishing CQSW brigade), I continue to take an interest in the old Service. I guess Probation is now in my DNA.

    ReplyDelete
  13. BBC News website:-

    Donald Trump will sit for a virtual interview with a probation officer from his home in Florida on Monday, part of the sentencing process for his felony conviction in the New York hush-money case.

    The first former US president criminally convicted, Trump will appear from Mar-a-Lago and will be seated alongside his lawyer Todd Blanche, a source with knowledge of the matter told CBS News, the BBC's US partner.

    A New York City probation officer will use the interview in a pre-sentencing report for Justice Juan Merchan, who is currently deciding what punishment Trump must face.

    Trump was convicted last month of 34 counts of falsifying business records and is expected to be sentenced on 11 July.

    A former commissioner for the New York City Department of Correction and Probation told NBC News, external that it is not normal for a probation interview to take place virtually.

    "It is highly unusual for a pre-sentence investigation interview to be done over Zoom," said Martin Horn.

    But he added that any visit by Trump to the courthouse in downtown Manhattan would be "very disruptive" to other court business, especially given the presence of the Secret Service and media, and could be unfair to other defendants who might not want to be identified.

    “So in the end, this might be better for the probation officer,” he said.

    Convicts in the New York Court system do not usually have their lawyers present for probation interviews, according to the Associated Press.

    However, Judge Merchan has allowed Mr Blanche to appear alongside his client on Monday.

    Pre-sentencing reports include information about a convict's personal life, criminal history, financial means, health condition and overall living arrangement.

    They are used by the judge to inform what punishment should be given.

    The interview is often an opportunity for a convict to argue for leniency in the sentence.

    Jurors found Trump guilty of falsifying business records to conceal hush money payments made to former porn star Stormy Daniels during the 2016 presidential election campaign.

    Most legal commentators believe that Trump is unlikely to face any jail time, given his lack of criminal history and age.

    Trump is the presumptive Republican presidential nominee. He has repeatedly claimed without evidence that the prosecution in New York is politically motivated and an attempt to prevent him from retaking the White House in November's election.

    He has also said he will appeal the conviction.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ugh! High profile cases - always a fucking nightmare & often a source of conflict for the professional, discerning probation officer.

      Have done a handful over the years. One offered to fly me to their remote location, another sent a fancy car expecting me to accept a lift. No thanks. Uncompromising alternatives were found in all cases & interviews were done 2-up.

      Go well on your new journey Jim.

      Delete
    2. If a poor person had reason to request a report by home visit or other means we’d do it. No need to play holier than thou because the offender is rich. They’re smart to interview Trump virtually, otherwise it’d be a media frenzy and nobody needs that.

      Delete
    3. “the professional, discerning probation officer.”

      More like overworked, underpaid and exhausted wreck of what used to be a probation officer!

      Many would take the remote island just to escape ECSL and Probation Reset.

      Delete
  14. Does anyone know of any research about the impact of sentence guidelines on rates of incarceration? Having worked in courts before during and after implementation I am more and more of the opinion that the SG is making quite a significant contribution to rates of imprisonment.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hope the treatment goes well. You are truly a hero and I know the strength you have to maintain this blog means you have the heart of a lion and the ability to beat this illness.

    ReplyDelete
  16. From CNN:-

    Former President Donald Trump completed his pre-sentencing interview with the New York City Department of Probation on Monday after his hush money trial conviction last month, a source familiar with the proceedings told CNN.

    “Earlier today, President Trump completed a routine interview with [the] New York Probation Office. The interview was uneventful and lasted less than thirty minutes,” the source said, adding, “The President and his team will continue to fight the lawless Manhattan DA Witch Hunt.”

    The interview took place around 3:30 p.m. Monday, a second source told CNN.

    Trump answered all questions in the virtual interview and was described as polite, respectful and accommodating to the probation officers, according to a New York City official familiar with the interview.

    Juanita Holmes, commissioner for the New York City Department of Probation, was present, along with the general counsel for the department and the officer assigned to Trump’s case, the source said. Trump attorney Todd Blanche was also present for the meeting. It is not standard for anyone other than the assigned officer and the defendant to be present at pre-sentencing interviews.

    Trump, according to the source, told the officers to be safe at the end of the interview.

    The probation department did not rule out the possibility of a follow-up meeting, the source added.

    The meeting forms part of the report the probation department will submit to Judge Juan Merchan to help decide Trump’s punishment ahead of his sentencing, set for 10 a.m. on July 11. Merchan could sentence the presumptive GOP presidential nominee to probation or up to four years in state prison on each count, with a maximum of 20 years.

    In a pre-sentencing interview, a defendant is typically asked about their conviction and other basic background information such as their employment and criminal history. Defendants do not have to cooperate with the routine pre-sentencing investigation, but a judge can take a negative inference from a defendant’s lack of cooperation.

    As part of the process, Trump’s legal team can submit letters of support from his friends and family to Merchan. The former president’s team is scheduled to submit its sentencing recommendation Thursday, according to a source familiar with the plan.

    The Manhattan District Attorney’s Office will also submit a memo telling the judge what sentence it sees fit for Trump.

    A Manhattan jury last month found Trump guilty of all 34 charges in his hush money trial, making him the first former president to be convicted of a felony. He was accused of falsifying business records related to a hush money payment to an adult film star in 2016.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cannot imagine anyone wanting to manage him

      Delete
    2. I would!!

      Donald Trump on my caseload. That’d be great.

      Cycle of change for his MAGA plans.

      Diversity toolkit for his views and opinions.

      Thinking skills and Victim empathy work.

      General chit chat about his part, present and future plans. They already said he “was described as polite, respectful and accommodating to the probation officers”.

      I think he’s going to jail though.

      Delete
    3. I’m sure many would want to

      Delete
    4. Oh well good luck although anyone should appreciate he would only tell you what do . He would not likely listen let alone hear you. He would dominate and all the weak nonsense probation fishes up these days in cognitive packages would be laughed at. Back basics trump has no idea of he is seen as. As neither does anyone who think they could get through to him.

      Delete
  17. Prisoners sentenced to 4 years or more to be eligible for HDC from 17/6/2024 in plans to reduce prison population. Some exemptions apply. All this on top of ECSL

    ReplyDelete
  18. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4nnq8q5depo

    who could this be?

    A 46-year-old man has been arrested as part of the National Crime Agency (NCA) investigation into PPE Medpro, the company led by Doug Barrowman, husband of Baroness Michelle Mone.

    The NCA opened an investigation into the company in May 2021 into suspected criminal offences committed in the procurement of PPE (personal protective equipment).

    The company was awarded government contracts worth more than £200m after Baroness Mone recommended the firm to ministers during the Covid pandemic.

    Baroness Mone, 52 and Mr Barrowman, 59 have denied wrongdoing.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Desperate cash-strapped tories strike again

    https://www.aol.co.uk/news/rishi-sunak-closest-aide-placed-170744228.html

    Rishi Sunak’s closest parliamentary aide placed a £100 bet on a July election just three days before the prime minister named the date, the Guardian can reveal.

    Williams, 39, is the Tory candidate for Montgomeryshire and Glyndwr in mid-Wales. He had a majority of 12,000 before the boundary change.

    The £100 bet could have led to a £500 payout on odds of 5/1

    If he was so certain & so desperate to win, why not go all in with a bet of £several-000's?

    ReplyDelete
  20. https://insidetime.org/newsround/more-men-moved-out-of-high-security-jails/

    ReplyDelete
  21. All the very best on your new journey and I hope everything goes to plan, wishing you well.
    sox

    ReplyDelete